There's no rationale behind that.
The root issue here is that La Liga is able to get a court to shut down a web host. It's shouldn't be anyone's problem but La Liga's that people pirate their stream, but a court let them make it everyone's problem. And there are any number of dumb things the court could have let them do, and turning CF into a utility company that can get shut down by the court doesn't solve the issue.
Finally, the main/original reason CF is useful is because the internet was created naively with no protections against bad actors. Weakening CF just empowers bad actors like LaLiga that much more at the expense of the rest of us. Being able to cloak my origin behind CF so that LaLiga or any other overpowered government or private entity doesn't know who I am is a feature. LaLiga having no option but to throw a tantrum that takes down half the internet is also a feature, and not one we should quickly hand away just because, idk, we can imagine some utopian vision where CF is unnecessary.
You're missing the part where it's a single company, not just "the entire anti-DDoS infrastructure", that's being talked about here.
It would be perfectly possible (no idea how practical offhand) to have an entire ecosystem of competing CDNs all doing the same thing that Cloudflare does, rather than just Cloudflare making those decisions all by itself.
If the ecosystem were truly more competitive, it would be much more likely that, for instance, if you went to block the CDN serving one particular football piracy group, it would not block half your government websites at the same time.
I don't know how this doesn't count as a net neutrality violation.
What's hilarious is that you know who else was obsessed with invading russian hordes?
Hitler and the Nazis. The hordes of bolschevism was the biggest threat to the world and hitler was going to save the world from them. (actual 2nd world war) Nazis were the ones obsessed with saving the world from the Russians.
(I'm just trying to point out, your language really doesn't suggest you are a rational, well thought out person on this issue)
> Additionally, there are historical reasons for what is going on between Russia and Ukraine
And there are historical reasons why Europe cares about what is going on between Russia and Ukraine.
Sorry but not only Russia gets to have "historical reasons" and "interests". We all do. Europe does too. Sorry if that upsets you and think Russia is the main character.
And sadly Russia's attacks on Europe are not limited to Ukraine. For example they have been doing chemical attacks in the UK before the full scale invasion of Ukraine.
> It is not like Russia is going to attempt to conquer Europe, is it?
It doesn't have to in order to be a threat to Europe. That's the thing about power.
> We might though
Who's "we"?
What's sad is how cucked the Hungarians are. Is there a more tragic country? Backed the wrong horse 1914-18, then again 39-45, then again in the cold war, and now again during the Russian invasion of Ukraine. What a tragic place. Literally always on the wrong side of history. I guess if there was ever any doubt that the Russian invasion of Ukraine is wrong, it's that Hungary supports said invasion. Hey, but it also means it will fail, because everything Hungary seems to touch turns to shit :)
This statement is an unnecessary, and offensive generalization. Many Hungarians do not agree with Orbán at all. Read more about "Magyar Péter".
> it's that Hungary supports said invasion.
It does not.
> Hey, but it also means it will fail, because everything Hungary seems to touch turns to shit :)
So you have nothing to worry about, then. Why even bother crying about Hungary if you genuinely believe this? I highly doubt you genuinely believe it, otherwise you would not have been crying about it. :) And if you do not believe it, then it is just yet another insult coming from you. Not surprised though, based on your comments. You seem to have made this account only to argue politics and shill your own master. We are on a tech forum, but God speed.
Also: It's not a tech forum, there's lots of non-tech content here.
Just because I disagree with some things that you say, that does not make me a troll. Not everyone who disagrees with you is a troll.
What even is the point of this discussion?
> Also: It's not a tech forum, there's lots of non-tech content here.
It is though, despite non-tech content.
Non-interventionism is probably the be the way to go about it. What should we do? Nuke Russia? Send Ukraine weapons? They are known for grabbing men off the streets and put them at the frontline. Sounds... amazing. There is a reason for why Telegram rooms exist that tell you which areas to avoid inb4 you get inscribed / enlisted / whatever you want to call it.
And DDoS protection.
Sports broadcast piracy has a history of serious organized crime involvement, and then some, such as https://www.theregister.com/2002/03/13/murdoch_company_crack... where the allegation was NDS did the hacking and leaked the keys of the rival tech to various mob groups for exploitation.
The shops themselves were not in the software business. One of them was specialised in turntable needles, and it was pretty popular. You had to go to the counter and specifically ask for "the menu" in order to access the "other side" of the business. It was an open secret though, as there was a lot of traffic in the shop for "the menu". You'd choose what you wanted, paid for your copy and leave with a bunch of floppy disks with it. They charged extra for the actual disks but you could also bring your own and only pay for the service.
If you mean electronic music bootlegs, then I don't see why the media or the format is that relevant. It's still just regular bootleg, and it's been popular since whenever copying and selling music was made possible.
But for fun, go pay for a legit ticket to watch a movie like "The Godfather" or "The Irishman." Count the dead bodies.
1. IP holder representative sends notice to Cloudflare 2. Cloudflare sends automated notice to account manager 3. Cloudflare informs person from step 1 of who actually hosts the site 4. Person from #1 emails web host who is probably a shady company who in turn ignores email 5. Nothing happens
Then lobby the government to change the laws or other requirements so that any IP holder can have a more effective process.
The solution is not to hack some workaround.
The huge majority of europeans have nothing against the american people. Please, do not propagate these claims.
Source?
America the political entity represented on the world stage by our government, oh yeah people are pissed.
When they call the other person's claim propaganda and are trying to state their own as fact, they should be able to back it up with something.
I'm not going to blindly take something like that as fact, especially considering recent (but also historical) events.
(Might also not be relevant but I will clarify anyway: I am not American)
Note that even running a survey with "negative" question would bias the results in that direction (eg. difference between "how do you rate this?" and "what is bad about this?")
I don't know, is there? I'm fine with a source for either one.
The poster you asked for proof was countering anecdotal claim with their own — why did you not join them in asking for the proof first?
Anyway, this is all rhetorical — as I said, just pointing out that you are not being fair to the poster you replied to, because if you were, you would have asked exactly what you asked here: "is there any source for any of these claims either way?"
And yes, both claims are unsupported, I definitely agree.
I know that people here would love to live in an alternate reality where everybody in the EU is fuming at the US having a right-wing government but that's not here at least yet. The US has done so many terrible things throughout history; they will survive this too.
They may never recover from decades of top secret intelligence being compromised.
Right, because extrapolation is famously applicable to human history.
In my circles of high level Spanish/European motorcycle racing, we continue to have a very positive reception as Americans in the paddock. The (Spanish) TV announcers have been positive towards our riders, the teams and crew are positive and helpful. We have more people wanting to talk about Route 66 than trade policy. Most Spaniards I know tend to roll their eyes at their own government more than anything happening in the U.S. The only exceptions are hysterical US expats on Facebook groups acting like the sky is falling. But they do that reliably every time a Republican gets elected.
Anecdotes aren’t data of course, but vocal people online don’t represent broader thought.
Yeah, you're in a bubble and you're likely misreading their politeness. I don't know any Spainards who would want to get into pointless political arguments with Americans who they guessed to be right of center in the off chance they were supporters of the current US government. Unless of course they were Vox affiliated, but even then I'm not sure they would bother engaging. They'd probably prefer to stick to talking about common interest stuff (like motoracing). "Anti-American sentiment" in the European context usually means being Anti-American government, not being dicks to individual Americans. The few cases where it actually crosses into Anti-Americanism the way you describe it seems to happen when the US militarily attacks a country they consider to be "brothers" or very close to. One example would be Greeks during the NATO bombing of now Serbia. Definitely one of the worst times to visit the Acropolis for an American.
I think your error is that you are gauging "Anti-American sentiment" by measuring how much you witness them bitching about Americans or Israelis. Whereas you should measure it by their actions. Tesla sales dropped signifcantly in Spain as it did in the rest of Europe. BYD sales are up 644%. See what they think about taking family vacations to the US.
Spanish people often end up buying local alternatives when available anyway but don't mind buying whatever when there are no alternatives (iphones, sneakers etc)
You ask the Spaniards if you want to send ammunitions to a country convicted of war crimes, the majority will most likely say no. And if your government is actually acting in accordance with that position and pushing the rest of Europe on that front, there's even less reason to bitch about Israelis to random foreigners.
> Most Spaniards I know tend to roll their eyes at their own government more than anything happening in the U.S.
This we can agree on. As it should be. Why bother with things out of your control?
Live sports piracy has the unusual property that you have to be able to get the block in place within the ~90 minutes of a football match, even at weekends and across time zones. Otherwise there’s no point.
If the courts let Cloudflare slow roll this, at the legal system’s normal snail-like pace, the law would be effectively useless.
Then the streams are on sites with names like fins38gy2m.ws a new URL for every game.
The hosts of the streams can set up an URL days in advance, and post it to the aggregators at the start of the game.
Anecdotally: oh yes. I don’t know anybody who pays, although that may say more about the populations I work with and hang out with.
I hear there’s plenty of headroom for the direct economics to work, if you’re reselling for less than the ~EUR100/month range the commercial providers charge [1]. Gross median income in Spain is on the order of EUR27000 annually, for reference [2]—so I’m not sure how many of the pirate viewers would be able to afford the legit product if the pirate channels dried up.
I also hear [0] there’s a robust side trade in exploiting pirate viewers’ machines though malware-style techniques while they’re there and feeling enticed to click yes to things…
[0] https://www.webroot.com/blog/2021/05/12/we-explored-the-dang...
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/LaLiga/comments/1fksf3i/how_much_do...
[2] https://www.ine.es/dyngs/INEbase/en/operacion.htm?c=Estadist...
Sorry, you mean WhatsApp detects and prevents the sharing of piracy links? I wasn’t aware of this, good to know. Is there a source of the various checks they have like this?
Note that the ads were for things like VPN providers and pirate IPTV feed services, which people are willing to pay for.
[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domain_generation_algorithm
one of the claims were that this is somewhat a procedural fraud since the plaintiff (Telefonica Audiovisual) and the defendant (Telefonica Spain) is technically the same thing. the order was granted after the defendants admitted, and therefore there wasn't any hearing with CF.
Now, there is also a conflict of interest, because Telefonica (the main telecom provider here, think Deutsche Telekom in germany or any formerly-public ISP) is also a rights holder to some football, meaning their interest is to block everything instead of their internet users, who suddently can't work on Github, visit Twitter or many other large sites; or even can't buy in many places online because Redsys (the largest payment processor here) also uses Cloudflare to protect their infra, and Cloudflare IPs were being blocked indiscriminately. All of this while being able to force other ISPs to block those IP ranges too, and without any possible recourse by either Cloudflare or the sites themselves, which according to Tebas "are only used by 4 nerds who like to complain".
1. La Liga (Spanish Football) finds pirates streaming their games objectionable
2. They notice that many of these streamers use Cloudflare for something, presumably CDN and load balancing.
3. They appear in court in Spain and get an ex-parte TRO blocking all Cloudflare IPs. (Ex parte TRO: restraining order granted without Cloudflare being summoned to court)
4. Based on this, they tell ISPs to block pretty much all of Cloudflare in Spain.
5. Cloudflare goes public in frustration, noting that they could just send take down requests for infringing content like every other rights holder in the world, and that many Spanish utilities and civil resources use Cloudflare.
Interesting. My gut is that it’s hard to beat La Liga on their home turf, as evidenced by not even being invited to the court hearings which shut you down across all of Spain.
Long term, I’d guess CF wins this one? Probably they will have to escalate in some way to Eurozone courts, although I have no idea how this might work. No cloud business could meet the standard put forward by La Liga; but also there are only so many CDN companies. Meantime I guess illegal streamers can move to Google and see which legal group wins that battle.