I am friends with a couple of ER doctors, who are probably the worst offenders (self-acknowledged) in this space. It's based on a real phenomenon, though, of drug-seeking behavior.
As people with chronic pain communicate with each other (through things like Reddit) on the best way to communicate to doctors that their pain is legitimate, those techniques are also inadvertently taught to other people who are seeking pain medication for recreational purposes.
I think the cause of widespread drug legalization has been weakened by a couple of real world efforts in that direction, but I still stubbornly cling to the belief that if people are allowed to make their own choices, then you can partition the recreational users from the chronic pain sufferers and maybe let medical science have a slightly better change of addressing the latter case. That said, given factors like cost and insurance coverage, it may just be a realigning of incentives rather than fixing the problem itself.
I can empathize with this thought (having had an episode of pain disbelief in a hospital myself) but the idea of partitioning recreational users from chronic pain sufferers isn’t reflective of the reality.
They aren’t two mutually exclusive groups. In fact, many recreational users get their start from over-prescribed opioids. Some people experiencing pain and all of the associated emotional difficulties will see the sudden access to opioids as an opportunity or even an excuse to indulge in opioid excess.
Self-medication with opioids also produces a very quick on-ramp to dependence in average users. If you’re anything like me, you prefer to use the minimum dose of any medication and get off as quickly as possible. I’d rather have mild lingering headache pain than take an extra Ibuprofen.
Not so with the much of the general public. I have friends in medicine who believe even Tylenol should be prescription only because of how frequently they see people destroying their livers by taking excessive amounts. Look at simple drugs like Afrin nasal spray and people who become severely dependent for months or years because they can’t even read the directions on the bottle. Open this same door to something euphorically reinforcing like opioids and the number of people walking themselves straight into addictions because they wanted something stronger for the occasional headache would be massive.
Except that you can't. There is no bright line between those two groups. Many recreational users/abusers started their journey when prescribed drugs for legitimate pain. Steady use becomes dependency, then you look for other sources, and quickly you are crawling dark web for a dealer in your neighborhood.
It did actually feel like a 7/10, it really hurt, but somehow it didn't bother me. And it was like that for weeks after the surgery, I didn't really end up taking any pain meds when I got home.
And I wouldn't say my pain tolerance is generally particularly high, pain does usually bother me as much as anyone. Not sure what that was about.
Fear of the pain can make things much-much worse. If that fear is removed, you won half the battle.
Of course, there are levels of pain where all of the above goes out the window and it is absolutely debilitating, but maybe that's the 13/10 pain level that hopefully most of us never have to experience.
If a level ten is passing out, that one would win via Price Is Right rules.
I said “No, I don’t think so. I feel like crying, though.”
“Well, that’s probably because you’re in pain.” At that point what I considered as pain hadn’t really manifest yet.
I have a friend who has had the aspiration to become a regular exerciser for years, but he says everything he tries just hurts too much. I exercise regularly myself, but we haven't found a way to talk about it, because it's so hard to share subjective sensations of pain. In some sense, everything I do hurts, too, and everyone who works out or plays a sport acknowledges a lot of pain. People differentiate routine pain from pain that requires effort to endure and distinguishes both of those from pain that indicates an injury happening or being aggravated, and people value and hone their ability to distinguish the second two from each other, because they don't want to get injured but also don't want to let pain hold them back from doing something that makes their body healthier and stronger.
I've known people who have endured through pain and suffered terrible consequences from it. Five years ago, my wife's aunt loved to say "I'm a tough old bird," and she has since lost a leg unnecessarily, because she thought that having high pain tolerance was a viable alternative to going to a doctor. Now she's in a wheelchair and does everything the doctors say.
Other people have had opposite experiences, where learning to disregard pain led to breakthroughs for them. One woman I know set a big triathlon PR a year after having a kid, and when people asked her how she was able to do that, she said, "After having a kid, the pain just wasn't a big deal to me anymore." She's big into the science, so I expected to hear something about hormones, but for her, her expanded pain tolerance was the entire explanation for her better performance.
Personally, just doing normal exercise presents me with an incredibly rich variety of "painful" sensations and a lot of difficult decisions. Right now I have a nagging shoulder injury, and every time an exercise generates a "painful" sensation in my shoulder, I have to decide, is this reflective of something making this injury worse? better? neutral impact? Should I stop right away so I don't aggravate the injury, or should I do this exercise more often because it's stimulating the tissue in just the right way? There's so much said and written about it, but it often seems frustratingly tautological. You have to know what the sensations mean before you can figure out which words refer to which sensations.
Do a martial art and you'll learn to ignore pain from hits to non sensitive areas too.
But if you have a brain you'll still care about joint pain and pain from hits to areas where it could cause serious damage.
I'd let that shoulder heal a bit :)
Yeah DOMS sucks, but the average derivative over time is zero. It doesn't get worse with more sport. If your shoulder is the same it's probably fine to keep sporting, if it gets worse over time you should definitely give it rest and probably get it looked at.
I am going to add the spiritual aspect to this. I read a post on Reddit asking if Jesus truly suffered more than anyone else on earth, given that more people suffer for longer than his 24 hours ish on the cross.
Without believing the story of Christ at all, I was still able to do the mental exercise to see that the nature of the pain had nothing to do with the duration. For example, watching your mother watch you get crucified is heart stopping (or to watch another mother have to go through that).
So, what is the purpose of a human feeling that pain as an experiencer or as an observer? Why would our body elicit that psychic pain, why wouldn’t we just focus on the physical and ignore these other things? In that moment, your only concern should be the physical, but it’s not just physical.
The psychic pain almost has no use in a state of physical torture other than to inform the conscious of its duty to morality. Unfortunately, I do not believe science can ever conclude this is the answer (in no possible way, I’m open to being wrong).
I have a relatively common autoimmune disease. I have had much better experiences with NPs than doctors in explaining that certain medications are contraindicated for people with my disease.
Ego has always been a massive issue in medicine. I wonder if this is exclusive to the US, or if we see it everywhere.
But this doesn’t mean we aren’t making incredible advancements. Discoveries are constantly being made in the background and are continuing to build up over time.
For example, a non-addictive pain medication was just approved by the FDA [0]. This will undoubtedly improve millions of lives and prevent uncountable numbers of people from misusing opiates in the future.
[0] https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/fda-appr...
How do we know what is in someone else's head?
it's all part of the same biological soup!
In the meantime, we should take much more advantage of the gap between the sensory and the affective components!
There are many other science-based pain management methods than just drugs. These other methods don't change the sensory part, the pain is there, but they can dramatically change the quality of your life with how you feel the pain.
CBT is very effective for pain management. Even something as simple as distracting yourself from a painful stimulus like a medical procedure can make a huge difference.
For example, your doctor doesn't routinely tell you to show your kids a fun video while they get a shot. But it makes a massive quality of life difference. Without Elmo, my daughter will cry for 5-10 minutes and just be miserable for half an hour. With Elmo, the shot comes, she's annoyed, there are tears for a 5-10 seconds, and then she's fine. There's no reason to not make this routine, except that we think of pain as something entirely objective instead of something that is largely subjective.
I think this research falls into that trap of "This is an important problem, this solution is obviously bad, but we have no good ones, so let's do it." This is likely to cause far more pain than to help anyone.
My experience was/is annoyingly the opposite where I developed chronic neck pain on a relatively fast timeframe and I can't find a physician across all different disciplines that's actually interested in finding out the source. They almost immediately throw up their hands and want to send me to a pain management doctor.
I guess if the goal is to tell whether the person needs pain meds that complication may not matter as much since they don't help (afaik) with those symptoms. But I do sometimes feel like my health problems get taken less seriously if I report on my pain levels rather than my discomfort and/or how it impacts me. Eventually I found a migraine pain scale that focuses on how it affects your life rather than directly how physically painful it is and that helped me have a normalized system for reporting.
I’m not sure about the depression, but it sounds plausible, depending on the experience. That’s out of my expertise, though.
For a concrete example, phantom limb pain can be a form of affective emotional pain, with a huge asterisk in that, it’s more complicated that than only resulting from #2. Too complex to get into in this forum. Here’s reading if you’re interested:
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6051014/#:~:text=.n...
The strongest such look I've ever gotten was a nurse in the ER when I went in with a splinter under my nail. I already felt kinda silly to go to the ER for something so obviously harmless, but it was late I just couldn't handle the pain. She'd offered me ibuprofen, but I had already taken the largest recommend dose of that, so I asked if maybe I could be given a local anaesthetic. She looked like she was considering whether to call the cops, since I was obviously a... Well what, actually? Local anaesthetic addict?Is that even a thing? Why would that be a thing?
I've come to the conclusion that healthcare in my country is better at judging you than they are at caring for you, which is really fucked up
In humans, pain has two primary components [0]:
1. The sensory-discriminative component: where on my body, what type (hot? cold? chemical?), and how intense is the noxious stimulus?
2. The affective-emotional component: how much does the pain hurt, and how does it affect emotional state?
Very importantly, both #1 and #2 are considered “pain”, and they can be experienced both simultaneously and independently. Pain is entirely subjective, as TFA highlights.
It does sound valuable to search for biomarkers of the sensory-discriminative component. But I’m doubtful that biomarkers for #2 are readily observable, beyond fMRI. The “Nociometer” may capture this, but what if it doesn’t in a reliable way, since it’s designed to test #1? TFA discussed how this could save money for health-care system money; this gives me an awful feeling.
Relying on “biomarker-based pain measurements” worries me that patients who are primarily experiencing affective-emotional components of pain will only further be doubted or not trusted by physicians.
There are already far, far too many examples of physicians not trust patients about pain. Re: women at Yale undergoing IVF treatments without fentanyl injections due to a drug misusing nurse stealing the fentanyl. Physicians responded to the unanesthetized women in excruciating pain by saying, “maybe you are immune to fentanyl!” [1*].
I think we should tread lightly.
—
[0] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6676053/
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2024/09/09/health/yale-ivf-egg-retri...
*There is a heart breaking podcast on this scandal, which is how I originally learned about it [2]. Of course when I was in horror telling my wife about the story, the news came as no surprise to her, as she’s experienced pain disbelief from physicians her entire life.
[2] https://www.thisamericanlife.org/804/the-retrievals