News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by 1970-01-01 on Friday March 14, 2025 @10:14AM (#43362838)
Still unclear what happened. Did they not anticipate a big moon hole or did navigation fail when the rangefinder failed?
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by martin_drapeau on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:46AM (#43363765)
Scott Manley has a great video explaining what he thinks happened. https://youtu.be/ISZTTEtHcTg?si=0LZFyiCysBiFZrMz
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by 1970-01-01 on Friday March 14, 2025 @12:13PM (#43364055)
Scott Manley and I agree that altitude signal shouldn't matter if navigation is correct. Athena simply risked touchdown, and it didn't find a flat spot, it found a hole.

https://youtu.be/ISZTTEtHcTg&t=1158

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by ceejayoz on Friday March 14, 2025 @12:15PM (#43364073)
Can you quote the bit you think is relevant here?

He's saying modern spacecraft can null out the horizontal velocity to land, but without an altimeter, you don't necessarily know when to do so, nor when to give the thrusters a little boost to avoid an obstacle you're about to hit, like a plateau.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by numpad0 on Saturday March 15, 2025 @12:21AM (#43369953)
tldw: speculation: landed with too much lateral velocity and one of legs broke
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by someothherguyy on Saturday March 15, 2025 @12:47AM (#43370060)
Does anyone know an extension that strips this tracking information and normalizes YouTube URLs?
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by wruza on Saturday March 15, 2025 @02:58AM (#43370589)
Just in case, I’m using my own violentmonkey scripts rather than hoping for extensions, and everyone can do that too (now only on firefox, I guess, and maybe brave).

For example, I remove &t=<n> from urls that youtube added recently in addition to regular watch position restoration. This broke it for me and they don’t seem to plan a revert.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by Tyr42 on Saturday March 15, 2025 @08:37AM (#43372147)
That is also used if you want to share a video at a particular timestamp with someone. E.g. check this out it happens 40s in. YouTube.com....&t=40s
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by wruza on Saturday March 15, 2025 @12:47PM (#43373635)
A little downside, yeah, but these scripts can be easily toggled. What can't be easily done is finding my last timestamp in a 5h long vod when &t-in-history screws it up.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by tennox on Saturday March 15, 2025 @02:26AM (#43370459)
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by ceejayoz on Friday March 14, 2025 @10:20AM (#43362889)
I'm not sure what you find unclear. Navigation was fine - "Athena knew where it was relative to the surface of the Moon" - but without a working altimeter it was kinda fucked for actually touching down.

Hard landing, skid, tip.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by JshWright on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:45AM (#43363753)
The top-heavy design didn't help things either. I'll be shocked if they don't go three-for-three on landing sideways given IM3 has the same tall design.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by ceejayoz on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:49AM (#43363800)
The company claims it's not as top-heavy as you'd think from pics:

https://www.theregister.com/2025/03/07/intuitive_machines_la...

> At his press conference earlier today, Altemus defended the design, saying the spacecraft doesn’t have a high center of gravity because most of its cargo attaches to the base of the vehicle. He said there were no plans for a radical rethink of his company's design.

(We see this in returning F9 first stages, as well.)

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by sandworm101 on Friday March 14, 2025 @03:38PM (#43366404)
>> The top-heavy design didn't help things either

Just wait for SpaceX to start trying to land starships on the moon. Also vertically. Also doomed to tip over whenever the surface is slightly out of spec.

https://www.spacex.com/humanspaceflight/moon/

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by JumpCrisscross on Friday March 14, 2025 @03:46PM (#43366477)
> Just wait for SpaceX to start trying to land starships on the moon. Also vertically

SpaceX has done it. To date, other nation-states have tried and failed to replicate their achievements in this domain.

IM’s design is wrongly optimised and probably requires a rethink. That the CEO won’t contemplate this isn’t a great sign for the company.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by CamperBob2 on Friday March 14, 2025 @03:56PM (#43366580)
SpaceX has done it.

SpaceX has landed Starship on the moon?!

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by JumpCrisscross on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:04PM (#43366663)
SpaceX has repeatedly and reliably landed vertical stacks. On any body. Out of the engineering problems inherent to HLS, sticking the landing isn’t material. The fact that it is to IM suggests a design fuck-up unless there is a great reason the problem was—and remains—unavoidable.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by MegaButts on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:46PM (#43367117)
Has SpaceX ever landed their rocket on a surface that isn't purposefully engineered to be flat?
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by Seanambers on Friday March 14, 2025 @05:23PM (#43367454)
Multiple sea landings, but I guess you'd argue those don't count since the vehicles tip over in water and explode.

Moving barges in the sea should qualify though.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by hildolfr on Friday March 14, 2025 @05:41PM (#43367604)
A moving barge with a known flat surface of a known hardness and stability is a whole different category of difficult than doing the same thing on naturally occurring terrain with unknown voids, hardness, roughness and consistency.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by PhasmaFelis on Friday March 14, 2025 @08:04PM (#43368617)
Is a landing barge not "purposefully engineered to be flat"?
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by TylerE on Friday March 14, 2025 @08:36PM (#43368826)
They also have the atmosphere, with drag that will make all velocities trend towards zero. Don’t have that on the moon, gotta do it all with fuel. More than half of the energy she’s by the returning falcon is aerobraking.

Yes, the moon has substantially less gravity but it’s also exponentially harder to get the fuel there.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by chrisweekly on Saturday March 15, 2025 @08:20AM (#43372059)
"the atmosphere, with drag that will make all velocities trend towards zero"

Did you forget about gravity? Terminal velocity in free-fall is not zero!

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by TylerE on Saturday March 15, 2025 @12:13PM (#43373436)
Trend towards. The rocket is descending far faster than low altitude terminal velocity.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by ohgr on Friday March 14, 2025 @08:39PM (#43368848)
So what you're saying is we need to blast some barges into space and land them on the moon so we have a flat surface for starship to land on?
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by sandworm101 on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:30PM (#43366966)
Lol. SpaceX has landed on prepared surfaces, concrete pads on land or on large barges. They literally have a big X to mark the target. Let's see them land on some random beach, an uneven surface that may or may not subside. But that is still peanuts comparted to the moon's surface.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by nomel on Friday March 14, 2025 @07:27PM (#43368404)
For any of these landings, it's a problem of 3d positional/velocity precision. SpaceX has prove that they can reliably land on a target, usually within meters, with negligibly delta velocity on contact.

In other words, they've proven they have the control systems in place for placing a craft at a precise location, with a precise velocity. What requirement do you see outside of this that are far outside of placement and velocity? Autonomous mapping and adjustments for approach maybe?

Let's not assume they're going to try to use their current earthly landing legs.

> land on some random beach,

They did this I believe two starships ago, when they landed in the ocean. Came to zero xyz velocity some target distance above the water, and hovered for a bit. Unfortunately, the surface tension of the sea couldn't support the weight once they lowered for touchdown.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by literalAardvark on Saturday March 15, 2025 @12:31PM (#43373524)
> 3d positional/velocity precision. SpaceX has prove that they can reliably land on a target, usually within meters

On Earth, which has GPS. On a very highly engineered landing surface.

Landing on inertial guidance on soft regolith is a whole different ballgame.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by nomel on Saturday March 15, 2025 @04:57PM (#43375107)
> Landing on inertial guidance

Which is not the future. Optical/lidar/positioning radio is the future, to make it closed loop (NASA’s Laser Retroreflector Array for high, lidar/optical for low altitudes).

> On a very highly engineered landing surface.

As I mentioned, we shouldn't assume the earthy landing legs are used. That would be a very silly assumption.

From what I can extract from your comment, you believe that the positioning system and landing legs are the issue, rather than the control systems. I suspect both are somewhat related: positioning system to place it over predictable regolith with some, yet-undeveloped, landing legs that need to work at 1/6th gravity.

I'm of the opinion that it's possible/solvable, as is NASA. It would be helpful if you would answer why you think it's not possible: what requirement do you see that make positioning and landing on regolith unachievable for SpaceX?

[1] https://www.nasa.gov/centers-and-facilities/langley/nasas-la...

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by literalAardvark on Sunday March 16, 2025 @09:07AM (#43378750)
It may be possible. It may also be that the regolith is too fluffy in that area to support such a large structure without a pad. I don't believe we know.

Athena had multiple laser altimeters on board: they failed to get a fix, perhaps because of the weird surface.

It's my opinion that this isn't something that's easy to do, even for a company that has landed on Earth.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by JumpCrisscross on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:37PM (#43367029)
> that is still peanuts comparted to the moon's surface

Sure. I'm not trivialising the problem in an absolute sense. Just going from floating barge or chopsticks to Moon is a simpler set of problems than reïnventing the sort of translational velocity and attitude control needed to get to first base.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by ted_dunning on Friday March 14, 2025 @06:26PM (#43367956)
You say this based on your history of landing rockets on the moon?

And on your history of dealing with the lunar regolith near the poles?

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by JumpCrisscross on Saturday March 15, 2025 @03:17PM (#43374584)
> You say this based on your history of landing rockets on the moon?

Actually, mini propulsive landers in lunar regolith stimulant. Yes. In atmosphere and with Earth gravity, both of which make it more annoying and more difficult.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by sandworm101 on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:42PM (#43367078)
For selecting and touching down on an unprepared surface, rockets are not the stepping stone. Start with helicopters. It is the same problem: can I land there and what will happen when I put weight on the surface. Try programing a large helicopter to identify and land on a random chunk of rocky terrain. It is not easy. And the bigger/taller the craft, the more difficult it becomes. Then add a 10-second time limit.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by Kye on Friday March 14, 2025 @05:37PM (#43367567)
Are the sky cranes of Mars viable without an atmosphere?
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by Frederation on Friday March 14, 2025 @07:15PM (#43368324)
Keep that Musk copium going, man!
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by oceanplexian on Friday March 14, 2025 @09:38PM (#43369147)
Why does this even have to be a problem?

We can send small probes to image the moon in incredibly high resolution. It's a big place I'm sure there is a perfectly flat rock somewhere they can use.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by sandworm101 on Saturday March 15, 2025 @11:29AM (#43373134)
Have you ever seen a perfectly flat rock anywhere on earth? Once capable of supporting a large rocket? Also, the moon doesn't have the various navigation systems (GPS/radar) that is used when bringing rocket stages back the pad.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by tekla on Friday March 14, 2025 @03:41PM (#43366431)
Why do people keep thinking this thing is top heavy just because its taller than wide?

The heavy bits are at the bottom.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by timmg on Friday March 14, 2025 @03:55PM (#43366573)
> Why do people keep thinking this thing is top heavy just because its taller than wide?

Because it keeps falling over?

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by tekla on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:07PM (#43366697)
The landing leg broke. How does that show you its top heavy?
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by timmg on Friday March 14, 2025 @05:42PM (#43367611)
I didn't say it was top-heavy. I answered the question, "Why does everyone think it is top heavy?"
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by tekla on Friday March 14, 2025 @05:44PM (#43367629)
Ah complete total ignorance. Figures
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by dingaling on Sunday March 16, 2025 @12:31PM (#43380243)
Because itbit wasn't top-heavy, a broken landing leg would just leave it slumped at an angle. Not fallen-over.

Consider the difference between removing the leg of a chair versus a stool.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by _bin_ on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:34PM (#43366999)
i think this becomes somewhat less of an issue once SpaceX gets Starship fulfilling contracts at scale. they're limited in width by the max payload faring width for Falcon 9, which is like half that of starship. add to that an exec claimed it's tall but not necessarily top-heavy as mass isn't evenly distributed throughout.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by strangattractor on Friday March 14, 2025 @06:37PM (#43368045)
Or use New Glenn which works now and has a larger faring.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by 1970-01-01 on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:24AM (#43363538)
If navigation was fine, why was touchdown on a plateau?
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by ceejayoz on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:35AM (#43363643)
Because "where am I" and "how high am I over that position" are very different things.

Visual demonstration of being at the wrong altitude in the right spot: https://www.f-16.net/f-16-news-article968.html

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by echoangle on Friday March 14, 2025 @09:21PM (#43369061)
If you don’t know your altitude, navigation isn’t fine though. Navigation should give you a position in all axes.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by walrus01 on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:28AM (#43363568)
Was there no functioning laser or radar altimeter for the final descent phase?
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by ceejayoz on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:35AM (#43363640)
"However, the lander's altimeter had failed."
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by 1970-01-01 on Friday March 14, 2025 @11:53AM (#43363841)
Looking at this closely, it was working, however it was noisy. I speculate that they didn't correctly anticipate the moon dust problem. Laser rangefinders may not be a workable solution for future landings.

     So engineers at Intuitive Machines had checked, and re-checked, the laser-based altimeters on Athena. When the lander got down within about 30 km of the lunar surface, they tested the rangefinders again. Worryingly, there was some noise in the readings as the laser bounced off the Moon. However, the engineers had reason to believe that, maybe, the readings would improve as the spacecraft got nearer to the surface.
https://arstechnica.com/space/2025/03/intuitive-machines-sec...

https://www.space.com/nasa-moon-landing-dust-concerns.html

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_horizon_glow

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by ceejayoz on Friday March 14, 2025 @12:07PM (#43363995)
Noise at 30km altitude probably points more towards a sensor issue than dust.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by Aspos on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:38PM (#43367036)
May it be that laser bounced off exhaust plume?
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by echoangle on Friday March 14, 2025 @09:24PM (#43369087)
Unless their processing is very weird, that shouldn’t be the issue.

You send a pulse and record the output of a detector to listen for the reflection. If the laser is reflected at the plume, you should get some pulses very quickly, but also faint and spread out in time, which you would be able to tune out. And the real response from the ground should be more narrow because it’s reflecting at a single distance.

If very short range noise influences the signal when measuring 30km real distance, you’re doing something wrong.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by inamberclad on Saturday March 15, 2025 @12:35PM (#43373553)
Laser is angled outwards at approx 45 degrees, I think it's well away from the exhaust plume.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by lightedman on Saturday March 15, 2025 @08:00PM (#43376010)
I think it would be unlikely that a plume was caused from 30km away on something with no atmosphere.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by numpad0 on Saturday March 15, 2025 @12:50AM (#43370071)
LRFs and radars on the Moon has been fine for a long time, it can also be angled away from gravity axis and multiplied by sine theta if needed.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by nomel on Friday March 14, 2025 @06:23PM (#43367928)
> "Athena knew where it was relative to the surface of the Moon" - but without a working altimeter it was kinda fucked for actually touching down.

Z is an axis that exists in our 3d world, and a required value for any relative position, which means it DID NOT know where it was, relative to the moon.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by PantaloonFlames on Friday March 14, 2025 @07:10PM (#43368291)
Ya the wording was not quite … satisfactory. I think they meant , it could tell X and Y, but not Z.

But all three are important.

Related - I’m not clear how the article can describe that landing as “not crashing”. If that was not a crash, what was it? Will they call it a crash only if there are Hollywood-style explosions?

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by jacobgkau on Friday March 14, 2025 @07:39PM (#43368491)
Bringing "Hollywood-style explosions" into it is a little much. If you slam the breaks on in your car, your tires hit some debris in the road, and you spin around and end up somewhere you didn't intend to be, but the car wasn't meaningfully damaged (i.e. you didn't hit other cars or manmade structures), you made a dangerous uncontrolled maneuver, but you didn't crash. That seems more like how they're describing this "skid."

Relevantly, it sounds like this lunar spacecraft was still functioning after the hard (non-)landing. The only reason it died after that was because of debris settling on the solar panels, which made it run out of power.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by PhasmaFelis on Friday March 14, 2025 @08:16PM (#43368683)
If you do something with your car that ends up with it skidding on its side, that's a crash by any possible definition.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by jacobgkau on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:22PM (#43429713)
Probably, but this is a space probe, not a car. It's lighter than a car, and is operating in an environment with less gravity.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by rdiddly on Friday March 14, 2025 @08:40PM (#43368850)
"The only reason?" One reason for prematurely losing most of the investment is enough. The car analogy is inadequate but let's say my car skids gently into a position from which it won't start and I can't get out and I slowly die of starvation and/or hypothermia. Am I glad that I didn't "crash?"
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by jacobgkau on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:23PM (#43429722)
I didn't say the mission was a success. I was addressing someone's nitpick over the definition of the word "crash."

If the space probe had a wiring failure after landing that caused the loss of "investment," that wouldn't be a crash. It would be a separate problem.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by Retric on Saturday March 15, 2025 @01:10AM (#43370141)
One of the legs broke off which requires significant forces not just a skid.

I mean if my car lands on the side and one of it’s wheels fell off that’s a significant crash.

Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by jacobgkau on Thursday March 20, 2025 @06:24PM (#43429728)
The leg breaking off is probably the best supporting evidence towards calling it a crash, I'll agree with that.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by meindnoch on Saturday March 15, 2025 @11:29AM (#43373139)
But if they knew where it was relative to the surface of the Moon, they could have subtracted that from where it wasn't, or where it wasn't from where it was (whichever is greater), to obtain a difference, or deviation. The guidance subsystem could then use deviations to generate corrective commands to drive the missile from a position where it was to a position where it wasn't.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by russdill on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:45PM (#43367102)
It touched down with a large horizontal velocity component
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by PantaloonFlames on Friday March 14, 2025 @07:16PM (#43368337)
That’s another thing that bothered me about this story. They said they knew where the craft was , relative to the surface of the moon. Wouldn’t that also mean they should know of any substantial horizontal (x/y) component of velocity?
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by gtirloni on Friday March 14, 2025 @09:38PM (#43369148)
Yes, through image analysis.
Re:Athena landed in a dark crater where the temperature was ... by marcosdumay on Saturday March 15, 2025 @01:53AM (#43370312)
I don't know if it's the case, but there's a difference between knowing something and calculating its derivative fast enough for it to be useful.