News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by FiloSottile on Friday March 07, 2025 @08:52PM (#43296795)
1Password truly doesn’t get enough credit for the choice to encrypt every vault with a high entropy secret key passed device to device. It surely costs them in UX and support load, but it would have made a breach like this essentially inconsequential.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by 3np on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:19PM (#43297477)
That's table stakes today. LastPass was not up to standards.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by aryonoco on Friday March 07, 2025 @09:08PM (#43296896)
Bitwarden truly doesn’t get enough credit for being completely open source and having independent implementations of the server code (Vaultwarden) with which the official clients are fully compatible, which I can run on a vm on a server under my desk.

In 50 years time, who knows if any of these companies will be around. But I’m pretty sure that my grandchildren, should they want to, will be able to open a gpg encrypted gzipped file (with the passphrase I’ll leave them) containing my passwords in a csv file.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by serf on Friday March 07, 2025 @09:10PM (#43296910)
>But I’m pretty sure that my grandchildren, should they want to, will be able to open a gpg encrypted gzipped file (with the passphrase I’ll leave them) containing my passwords in a csv file.

technical possibilities aside, do you presume your grandchildren will be technically apt?

I am pretty sure 99% of people would halt at 'gpg' , and that's now -- not 60 years from now.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by tbrownaw on Saturday March 08, 2025 @12:12AM (#43297660)
> I am pretty sure 99% of people would halt at 'gpg' , and that's now -- not 60 years from now.

I know reading the docs is considered uncool for some reason, but it really does work.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by OJFord on Saturday March 08, 2025 @01:08AM (#43297898)
To how many non-SWE members of your family could you say 'here is the Netflix password, you can decrypt it with gpg', and have them be like 'ah yes, let me just `man gpg` this will be no problem'?
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by tex0 on Saturday March 08, 2025 @01:49AM (#43298084)
Probably zero. And strike the non-SWE part. gpg isn't really easy to use.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by trueismywork on Saturday March 08, 2025 @02:33AM (#43298305)
Hence need to invest in better opennsource pgp tooling. It won't take more than 10 million USD and will benefit every single person on earth.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by timeflex on Saturday March 08, 2025 @02:34AM (#43298309)
Google, "How do I decrypt a GPG file."

First result with simple command. I went from KeePassXC to `pass` & back to KeePassXC. But I question the integrity and/or motive of people like you.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by shaky-carrousel on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:25AM (#43298779)
If secretaries can learn Emacs, surely people can learn GPG. Underestimating others does no one any favors.

https://www.gnu.org/gnu/rms-lisp.en.html

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by stockboss on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:31AM (#43298805)
i would imagine if a lot of money, like millions, was on the line, people get really resourceful all of a sudden. of course, we're not talking Netflix passwords but usernames and passwords to brokerages, bank accounts, etc.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by TeMPOraL on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:16AM (#43299294)
Often curiosity is motivation enough. Some people go to great lengths just to learn something about their distant ancestors.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by OJFord on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:25AM (#43299334)
Sure, but surely we're intending to leave them access, not a problem to solve.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by darkwater on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:36AM (#43298823)
They can just ask the super AGI that will exist to tell them how to do. Heck, even current LLMs can tell you how to do it step by step.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by fc417fc802 on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:44AM (#43299793)
Cynically, it's far more likely they will upload the gpg blob to said agent, provide it with the password via the conversation box, and ask it to directly provide the specific information that they're after.

The AI model will be of certified provenance and run on attested hardware [0] so this won't be as much of a security issue as you might expect. Naturally the various three letter agencies will have full hardware access including query history.

Periodically, hardware zero days will drop and all hell will break loose.

Alright that's enough speculative dystopian fiction for me for today.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42454139

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by TeMPOraL on Saturday March 08, 2025 @05:17AM (#43299001)
Until ChatGPT? Zero.

Since ChatGPT? ~all of them except maybe my grandparents.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by harikb on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:15PM (#43297461)
They will just ask their AI agent to decrypt it (with the password of course). No need of ability to run gpg.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by soraminazuki on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:39AM (#43298839)
No, you can't tell your non-SWE friends and family to "just ask an AI" when the potential consequences are them losing access to their vault or having it stolen. They need to know exactly what they're doing.

Don't take security advice from an AI.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by TeMPOraL on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:42AM (#43299429)
They're vastly more likely to lose everything they care about by following real security advice, or rather being forced to follow it. 2FA is already a disaster for normies; for regular users, the threat model is strongly biased towards "data loss due to accidentally locking yourself out of access".

In fact, if you consider the impact fully, the best way of managing passwords still seems to be writing them down on a post-it note and keeping it in your wallet - hell, even sticking it to your screen doesn't look so bad these days, compared to alternatives.

Modern infosecurity is absurdly counter-intuitive at high level. Consider that your Google account or your WhatsApp (or Signal) chats are much more secured than your medical data or bank accounts or anything that predates Google. For anything in the real world, there is always a recovery procedure, no matter how much bad luck you had or how badly you screwed up. In the worst case, you might end up needing to chase some documents to authorize or notarize other documents, or show up in court, but you can get your access back. It's insane to imagine the world, in which a single fuckup could wipe out your medical history, your bank account, or any proof of your existence in government systems - and yet, this is exactly what is the case with any modern SaaS that follows "best security practices".

There's literally nothing else in this world that's so easy to mishandle as security in commercial software services.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by notpushkin on Friday March 07, 2025 @09:14PM (#43296935)
Chances are, at least one of them will be.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by wraptile on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:39PM (#43297552)
"Hey llm how do I open this file?"

It's kinda ludicrous to think we'll lose the ability for something so simple.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by TheDong on Saturday March 08, 2025 @12:00AM (#43297628)
> It's kinda ludicrous to think we'll lose the ability for something so simple.

Sorry, but I already have to google each time I want to figure out how to open various file formats.

"Google, what ffmpeg flags do I use to convert this .flv file to .mp4", "what are the flags to losetup or kpartx to mount 'disk.img' as a loopback device?", "how do I extract an '.ab' backup from 'adb backup'?"

These are all things I googled before llm.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by er4hn on Saturday March 08, 2025 @12:27AM (#43297730)
Truly, I will miss the days of goggling for tar commands when I can instead ask an llm.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by namaria on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:24AM (#43299326)
Why use kilobytes of text and a handful of clock cycles when I can use terabytes of weights and thousands of teraflop-days of GPU farms to achieve the same result?
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by wraptile on Sunday March 09, 2025 @01:13AM (#43306701)
cache goes brrrr
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by Apocryphon on Friday March 07, 2025 @09:21PM (#43296957)
An LLM entity named gpgchat will assist them.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by codetrotter on Friday March 07, 2025 @09:35PM (#43297014)
And promptly sweep all the Bitcoin from the wallet whose mnemonic phrase was stored in the vault.

LLM entities have bills to pay too.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by jwr on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:03PM (#43297409)
> I am pretty sure 99% of people would halt at 'gpg'

Please do not mock gpg.

I have been using gpg for 25 years now (and PGP before that). It works. It encrypts. It decrypts.

It is in vogue to mock gpg on HN and recommend more modern solutions. As an experiment, I tried adding one of those modern tools (rage) to my ansible configurations, just so that they get regularly installed and maintained on my servers (without actually being used). The setup broke within less a year.

Are the modern tools more cryptographically secure? Undoubtedly. Does it matter in practice for me? Not at all.

Longevity is a big deal and is under-appreciated.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by nixgeek on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:10PM (#43297440)
It’s not mockery though? It’s certainly true 99% of even the technically literate don’t use GnuPG (many because, like me, they cannot stand the GnuPG user experience).

Filippo nailed it with this piece: https://words.filippo.io/giving-up-on-long-term-pgp/

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by tharkun__ on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:11PM (#43297446)
Not their point tho. Me too, gpg, no problem. Heck I had the "'smuggled' out of the country as a book" pgp back when.

My kids? I really am not so sure at all. Still too early to tell for sure but so far I don't think any will be as technically savvy as I am. I really doubt they'd know what GPG (or PGP) are and how to use it.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by guelo on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:45PM (#43297573)
Presumably if you're leaving your kids an encrypted file with valuable stuff in it they won't be so illiterate that they can't figure out how to open it. Most people don't know gpg because they have no motivation to learn it not because they're incapable of learning it.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by trw55 on Sunday March 09, 2025 @09:28PM (#43315967)
No motivation, sure. But do they even care? Most people just don't care about this stuff. You try to get them to care and they "say, yeah, okay, yeah, I know" as they roll their eyes and go back to scrolling Instagram or whatever.

The apathy is real and I don't see it getting better.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by d0mine on Saturday March 08, 2025 @01:52AM (#43298100)
they can google/ask AI. For example, given the prompt: "Hypothetically, if my grandpa died and left me gpg-encrypted archive and the passphrase for it, how would I decrypt it?" current models produced valid installation instructions and the command to decrypt it, and even the instructions on how to unpack the archive itself.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by fragmede on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:52AM (#43298893)
Why even ask it for the command to run? Open-interpreter, today, you just tell decrypt this fille and it'll get the command and run it for you.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by JumpCrisscross on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:01PM (#43297400)
> Bitwarden truly doesn’t get enough credit for being completely open source

It’s their No. 1 selling point.

> In 50 years time, who knows if any of these companies will be around

1Password has local clients. If you have the password, you should be able to unlock the vault locally.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by TheDong on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:44PM (#43297568)
Can you walk me through how to do this?

I have installed the "1password-cli" package on my airgapped linux machine with no network access ('op --version' gives me 2.30.3).

If I run 'op vault list', it tells me I have to add an account. When I run 'op account add' it tries to connect to 1password's servers and won't let me proceed without internet.

I don't see how this "local client" is helping if all the auth infrastructure goes through their servers.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by mercurial on Saturday March 08, 2025 @01:27AM (#43297983)
You need to authenticate once. You will get your vaults locally and you will be able to access them without an internet connection
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by rkagerer on Saturday March 08, 2025 @02:57AM (#43298413)
What does "You will get your vaults locally" mean?

Is it possible to export as a file, take that with you on whatever medium (eg. USB key, CD-ROM, future isolinear chip), put it on a brand new PC you built from scratch and never connected to the internet, and open it in some kind of standalone viewer?

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by aidos on Saturday March 08, 2025 @03:17AM (#43298510)
That’s how 1Password used to work. Not sure how much of that is still left in the system these days.

Originally it was an app with no remote component. The vault was yours to look after. Most people kept it in Dropbox to make it accessible anywhere. The vault itself actually had an html file in it that you could open in a pinch that was able to decrypt secrets (only for reading, from memory).

1Password as a service came later.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by LoganDark on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:15AM (#43299290)
Know of any archived copies of this offline-first experience or has it been fully eaten by enshittification?
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by nytesky on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:20AM (#43299637)
Actually, 1Password had local syncing where you synced the vaults between devices on a local connection (I think it was point to point WiFi, so your internet dropped off, Bluetooth was less common then). So it was bucket brigade syncing.

Dropbox came later and security minded folks were wary. Honestly, I trust 1Password sync more than an encrypted db on a general purpose cloud file sync, but maybe that’s naive.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by 9x39 on Saturday March 08, 2025 @03:24AM (#43298539)
After auth, it downloads a copy of your vaults to your device from their servers.

Super contrived, but you could probably just copy the sqlite dbs of your vault it creates locally to another PC along with the 1Password installer and it might let you sign in with just your master key.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by fiskfiskfisk on Saturday March 08, 2025 @03:45AM (#43298630)
There might be alternatives that are better designed for that use case these days; pass and KeePassXC are popular ones, depending on the interface you want (pass is made for the cli as the primary interface).
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by tmpfs on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:20AM (#43299305)
Please try our solution[1]

It's truly local first and will work fine in an airgapped situation.

It's also designed to be self-hostable[2], is open source [3] and the API is well documented[4].

[1] https://saveoursecrets.com/ [2] https://saveoursecrets.com/docs/cli/self-hosting/ [3] https://github.com/saveoursecrets/sdk [4] https://docs.rs/sos-sdk/latest/sos_sdk/

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by aryonoco on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:52AM (#43299476)
The likelihood that someone would be able to do this in 50 years time, without your company still around? Close to zero.

Passwords, even ssh keys and passkeys, are little pieces of plain text. If you think needing a specialised sdk or cli to retrieve plain text is a good software architecture, I think we see the world quite differently.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by tmpfs on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:23PM (#43304908)
That's the exact reason it's open source, so it would still be possible to access your data in such an event.

We clearly see things differently but I think using computers to make our lives easier is worthwhile and storing/managing our secrets securely, effectively and conveniently is better managed by software than some ad-hoc setup.

Nitpick, passkeys are not text, they are binary blobs.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by harikb on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:12PM (#43297451)
“1Password anywhere” (single html file password manager) stopped working a while ago. May be 6 years back. Sure you can install a new client and use a stored folder - but compatibility lasting to your grandchildren’s time / 50 year etc - highly unlikely
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by aryonoco on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:01AM (#43299513)
Since I’m talking about reliable long term archival of critical encrypted data here, let me again ask: in your opinion, what is the likelihood that in 50 years time, with 1Password long gone, my grand children would be able to run that local 1Password client and successfully decrypt the data?

Because I feel pretty confident that gpg will still be around (though hopefully long deprecated), that gzipped files would still be able to be opened, and everyone would still be able to open a csv file. Without any specialised software, sdk or whatnot.

If this scenario doesn’t concern you, that’s fine, 20 years ago it wouldn’t have been my concern either. But the older I’ve become, the more I think about this stuff.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by Spooky23 on Saturday March 08, 2025 @08:55AM (#43300270)
Close to zero. Archive is a different discipline. You need to have formats that are long lived and accessible over time. Paper is best, and it goes from there. Some electronic media archivists are fans of TIFF. It’s a field with controversy.

Pick the formats your storing and handle security at the container. This might be an encrypted system that is copied and updated over decades or a physical storage safe or box.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by bigfatkitten on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @09:15PM (#43349443)
I'd be extremely surprised if any of those creds are still valid in 50 years, assuming you don't use 1Password to store other assorted information.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by noduerme on Friday March 07, 2025 @10:25PM (#43297221)
I still rely on a gpg encrypted text file for storing my passwords, too. 25 years of that and it's second nature. No other solution has ever appealed to me.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by ptk on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:14PM (#43297456)
I’m autofilling usernames and passwords from 1Password’s browser extension probably 100+ times per workday. Are you manually copying and pasting anywhere near that amount? I think I would be miserable with that setup for anything beyond very light use.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by nicolas_t on Friday March 07, 2025 @09:12PM (#43296928)
It's such a pity that bitwarden's client doesn't work offline for modifying vaults (need to be online to be able to access the server implementation). I would switch from my old local vault 1password in an instant.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by XorNot on Friday March 07, 2025 @09:14PM (#43296937)
I just have KeePass in a syncthing folder with a trigger to sync on open.

Technically I think I could drop the trigger if the desktop app would open by making a temporary file copy and syncing back (ironically Keepass2Android is very good at this).

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by dp-hackernews on Saturday March 08, 2025 @05:28AM (#43299055)
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by nonninz on Saturday March 08, 2025 @11:07AM (#43301227)
Can you expand why the trigger is necessary?
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by XorNot on Saturday March 08, 2025 @10:37PM (#43305953)
I have the folder which is synced, and then the device local copy which is what I open.

This is because AFAIK desktop syncthing doesn't like it if the file gets replaced out underneath it. This might've changed.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by infinitezest on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:28AM (#43299683)
This is literally the only thing that's holding me back from switching as well.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by notesinthefield on Friday March 07, 2025 @10:27PM (#43297231)
Is bitwarden’s only differentiator being open source and self hostable? Im looking at other services and thus far see no reason to leave 1Password.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by MyOutfitIsVague on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:01PM (#43297394)
That, and it's better in most functional and polish regards than LastPass. I haven't used 1Password, so I can't compare those two directly, but I'd strongly recommend BitWarden over LastPass as far as those two are considered.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by rafram on Saturday March 08, 2025 @12:36AM (#43297765)
1Password is also significantly more polished and easy to use than LastPass.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by selykg on Saturday March 08, 2025 @11:05AM (#43301206)
I have my own beef with 1Password, but having used both Bitwarden and 1Password, I still find 1Password to be the better UX and more secure solution. Bitwarden is also worse at filling with their browser extension, rather significantly. That said, 1Password's Safari support with multiple profiles is... frustrating... at best.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by behringer on Friday March 07, 2025 @10:45PM (#43297315)
is that not enough? It's also inexpensive and works very well on all platforms.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by haswell on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:00PM (#43297386)
Not OP, but UX also matters a lot.

I’d strongly prefer an open source and selfhostable option, but each time I’ve evaluated Bitwarden in the past, it was a big enough downgrade from 1Password that I didn’t think switching was a good option.

If the experience ever becomes as seamless, I’ll be switching.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by eknkc on Saturday March 08, 2025 @12:57AM (#43297855)
This. 1p is polished and easy to use. Bitwarden is as functional as 1P but janky.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by matwood on Saturday March 08, 2025 @01:57AM (#43298116)
1P family sharing and 1P cli also work well.

I check BW every so often but it always feels less polished UI wise. For all the complaints people had about 1P moving to electron, it’s UX is still the best out there.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by TeMPOraL on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:26AM (#43299338)
> family sharing

Why would someone make a feature like this?

I'm confused why some companies (including Amazon and Steam) insist on family features. The mental model behind this is more prescriptive than descriptive - it doesn't match to how users and their families function; rather, it insists on some activities to a) exist in family, and b) be not allowed outside of family.

Or simply: how many people have actual family listed in their Steam / Amazon "family sharing"?

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by aryonoco on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:34AM (#43299730)
I don’t have amazon or steam so don’t know how any of that works. But for a password manager, family sharing is extremely useful.

Bitwarden doesn’t have families per se, it’s got “organisations”. You can setup unlimited number of organisations and users can get invited and join them. Which is very handy for example my wife and I can login and order our groceries from the supermarket using the same account. Or that we can both login and use our electricity company’s web portal which only allows one account per household. All without needing to send each other passwords and updated passwords back and forth.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by TeMPOraL on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:03PM (#43303497)
I have nothing against sharing per se. My issue is with the family nomenclature. In your case it might align perfectly, but for myself and most people I know, it's not the case. That is, the set of people to share a Netflix subscription with, share Steam library with, share Kindle library with, share passwords to various web services, including utility companies, are only partially overlapping, and do not align perfectly with the idea of "family" or "household".
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by aryonoco on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:19PM (#43304510)
Ah ok gotcha. Your issue is with the ‘family’ nomenclature not the functionality, and I fully agree with you.

For what it’s worth Bitwarden doesn’t use that term, they call it Organisation. Personally I feel like ‘Group’ is actually the better term.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by trw55 on Sunday March 09, 2025 @09:33PM (#43316014)
This seems pedantic. I am trying to wrap my head around why "family sharing" is an issue here. You want to share with someone, use family sharing I don't see what the issue is.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by quesera on Saturday March 08, 2025 @10:03AM (#43300781)
I think "family" is just the humane, user-friendly, non-corporate word for "group" in this context.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by TeMPOraL on Saturday March 08, 2025 @10:22AM (#43300907)
Yeah, but "group" is also a humane, user-friendly, non-corporate word for "group" and happens to not carry any confusing connotations.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by quesera on Saturday March 08, 2025 @11:12AM (#43301256)
On the scale of humaneness, "family" will always score higher than "group".

But yeah, it's a content and positioning call for the product and marketing teams to make.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by dahart on Saturday March 08, 2025 @10:06AM (#43300798)
What do you mean about prescribing and insisting? I’m not sure I understand your questions about family sharing and the mental model.

I use family sharing with actual family for my Steam account and all video streaming services. Am I weird? The reason is because streaming services allow sharing under a single paid account, and my wife & kids don’t want to pay for separate accounts, and don’t want to have to authenticate separately on shared devices (TVs, game consoles, iPads, etc). Steam family sharing works across different Steam accounts, and sharing a single account doesn’t work, so Steam isn’t particularly relevant to the discussion of family sharing of passwords. Steaming accounts, on the other hand, all assume they’re being used by a whole family, and the main reason is because of shared devices; the family TV itself logged in. So, they all offer profiles under a single account. Netflix clarifies that family sharing means the people in a single household, maybe others are similar.

We use password family sharing as well. My wife and I share bank and credit card accounts. My wife needs my accounts sometimes to do certain things — you might be surprised how many banks do not offer joint accounts and still treat wives as second class citizens. We share the Netflix & Amazon accounts with the kids so they can use them. I pay for a 1Password family account and share it with my aging father who’s been losing passwords. These things are all pretty useful for me.

I guess you’re making me wonder why someone wouldn’t make a family sharing feature, when it solves real problems and users are asking for it?

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by bostik on Saturday March 08, 2025 @02:10AM (#43298191)
> Not OP, but UX also matters a lot.

That is particularly true for anything dealing with security. I evaluated both BitWarden and 1Password when we wanted to migrate away from LastPass. My recommendation was to eventually go with BW. Its open-source nature was a factor, but for a corporate use the UX factors were even more prominent.

Over a course of a month, I ran into several subtle footguns with 1P. Search included only some of the fields. Password reset/rotation flow was easy to mess up (thanks to the confusing + inconsistent "copy field" functionality) and get into a situation where the generated password that was stored in the vault was different from the one that was set: in my tests there was 50/50 chance of accidentally regenerating the password before the vault storage step after submitting the new one for a remote service.

There were a whole load of "features" that didn't make any sense. The UI for 1P was a real mess. The feeling I got from it was that their product had been captured by Product Managers[tm] desperate to justify their own existence by shipping ever more Features[tm] without considering the impact on the core functionality.

BW's UI is by no means perfect, and their entry editing flow is far from ideal. But at least most of the actual usability snags in their browser extension have a common workaround: pop the BW overlay out from the browser, into a separate window. Their open-source nature and availability of independent implementations mean that there will be alternatives, should BW go down the same features-features-and-more-antifeatures hellhole in their race to eventually appease their VC backers.

Less is more.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by haswell on Saturday March 08, 2025 @09:22AM (#43300454)
When did you do this 1Password evaluation?

Sounds like our experience with it could not be more different.

> The UI for 1P was a real mess.

In what way? You described how you feel about the UI, but I’m curious about actual specifics.

It’s entirely possible that I’m just too accustomed to it because I’ve been using it for many years, but what you’re describing is how I felt about Bitwarden.

I can completely see choosing BW in a corporate setting for a host of other reasons. But for me personally, the priority is a tool that gets out of my way and just works.

The tool that has done that is 1P.

> Less is more.

That really depends. If less means that the password manager doesn’t get used, then less is less.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by n8m8 on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:00PM (#43297392)
Their comment made me laugh, agreed, open source is really is that big of a perk. IMO especially for something security-related (though 0day is always possible)
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by notesinthefield on Friday March 14, 2025 @10:13PM (#43369326)
I think the assumption something is open source being a perk is naïve - in the end I still have to trust so many elements that actually bring me the platform that BW’s openness doesnt matter.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by notesinthefield on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:07AM (#43299252)
Why would I have asked if it were enough?
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by notpushkin on Friday March 07, 2025 @09:11PM (#43296915)
One of the reasons I’m using Passwoed Store: https://www.passwordstore.org/

Though the tooling isn’t great – I’ll probably switch to Vaultwarden sometime this year.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by MartijnHols on Saturday March 08, 2025 @03:53AM (#43298648)
Proton Pass truly doesn’t get enough credit for being completely open source, more user friendly, and hosted outside the US (wouldn’t want to lose access to your vault [1]).

[1]: https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/you-can-no-longer-base-you...

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by shaky-carrousel on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:20AM (#43298753)
How can I self host proton pass? I'm searching for the server source code and I can't find it. Should be available if it's completely open source.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by MartijnHols on Saturday March 08, 2025 @05:08AM (#43298960)
Don't think you can self-host it, but that would also pretty much defeat the user-friendly aspect. You don't need the server source if the vault is client-side encrypted, besides you would get zero guarantees that what they show and what they're actually running are the same thing.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by juped on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:49AM (#43299464)
Well, Bitwarden is actually completely open source. So I can use the server code. It's pretty great!
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by aryonoco on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:20AM (#43299640)
Proton pass is a poor man’s attempt at a password manager, with horrible user experience (oh we thought just a browser extension was enough!) and random limitations to fit in with Proton’s tortured business model.

I was a Protonmail founding member. I used and evangelised them for years until I realised that they are more interested in chasing the next shiny thing (hey we have a crypto wallet now!) instead of fixing longstanding bugs and performance issues in their mail client.

As for hosted outside the US, I’m pretty sure the vaultvarden instance running under my desk is also hosted outside the US (unless I’ve somehow been magically transported to the US). Plus, I get to physically lock the door when I leave the house and my cat usually sleeps on top of the sever which adds a level of furry protection which proton pass could never achieve

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by MartijnHols on Saturday March 08, 2025 @09:05AM (#43300340)
Oh, impressive how browser extensions can live outside of browsers now. And on mobile too!

After having used Bitwarden for more than 4 years, I only switched last week, so I'm still in the honeymoon phase. But it has everything I used in Bitwarden and more, most notably all the usability features that I was missing in Bitwarden.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by ehnto on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:47AM (#43298876)
I am fascinated by the idea of being 50 years from now, and doing digital archaeology more or less. So much of our actual output is now digital and stored digitally.

Given how I have experienced technology up until this point, my assumption is that everything I will create for work or for pleasure, is more or less ephemeral. It has certainly proven true for work.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by klabb3 on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:34AM (#43299725)
I suspect you won’t be allowed to do archeology, because the company that bought the rights to it won’t let you. If we continue the path we’re on basically nothing will be owned by us or kept safe by us. Just look at the difference from the PC era to the smartphone era. It’s all cloud based now.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by fauigerzigerk on Saturday March 08, 2025 @05:26AM (#43299047)
I think we (or our descendants) will be surprised by the longevity of some of the file formats in use today. I would wager that it will be possible and not too unusual for regular users to open files in formats like PDF, zip or jpeg 100 years after their inception.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by whstl on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:46AM (#43299444)
I've recently had to open some installer files from the mid-90s that were in a proprietary format (I forgot the name... Inno? InstallShield?) and was surprised to see that the current go-to solution is open source.

As long as an open source (or at least open specification) exist, these files will remain being openable. ...or at least until curious minds are able to crack them!

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by eru on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:11AM (#43299572)
I'm not sure whether these file formats will still be in common use, but I'm fairly sure it will be trivial to find software that can read them.

Just like it's fairly easy for us to even run software from 50 years ago thanks to emulation. As long as your software run on a platform popular enough to have a good emulator. But for PDF and zip and jpeg reading software that will definitely be the case.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by 317070 on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:13AM (#43299279)
You think we will still have files? I wager in the long term we're going more towards a people focused than paper focused system.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by fauigerzigerk on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:03AM (#43299529)
Yes I do think we will still have files (whatever they will be called) at some level for some purposes.

I.e, we will still be able to store and transfer sequences of bytes conforming to some specification (file format), and we will be able to attach names to those blobs in some namespace. The concept is too general to ever lose its usefulness.

There are a few key things I have learned in the third of a century that I've been working with data: Data lives longer than apps and longer than people. We will always need units of data that have their own life cycle and are reasonably self describing and self contained (i.e meaningful without resolving external references).

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by criddell on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:33AM (#43299375)
100 years after their inception isn’t very far from now. There are plenty of people here who will be alive in the 2080s.

Everybody has a different idea of what long term means, but I think of it as millennia from now. The kind of time frame that the Long Now Foundation talks about.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by johnmaguire on Saturday March 08, 2025 @09:38AM (#43300584)
PDF - 1993, JPEG - 1992, ZIP - 1989.

We're already 1/3 of the way there.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by nytesky on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:22AM (#43299656)
I backup some what similarly.

Curious, how is Excel encryption? That may be a more approachable format than CSV GPG, and though technically the CSV GPG is more simpler, it may be less familiar to users in 100 years. Excel will still be around ;)

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by loufe on Saturday March 08, 2025 @08:23AM (#43300059)
https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/msoffice/forum/all/what-...

They apparently use AES-128. Not quite the level of Bitwarden, which uses hashing (argon2 or PBKDF2) and AES-CBC-256 simultaneously.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by alwayslikethis on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:21AM (#43299310)
Wouldn't it also make you lose everything in a recovery scenario? If all your computers are lost in a fire or flood, you would lose the recovery key, and having your password would not be enough to recover your database. I use keepassxc with a somewhat long password with a high PBKDF iterations count, which would not require having any devices in the event of a loss.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by al_borland on Saturday March 08, 2025 @08:11AM (#43299980)
There is an option to print out recovery info. A sheet with a QR code and a space for you to write your password (or not, if you don't trust keeping those 2 things in one place). That paper can go in a safe deposit box, with a trusted family member / friend, or in some cloud service you'd still have access to. The QR code + your password allow for recovery.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by aborsy on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:21AM (#43299647)
Loosing everything if you don’t have a key is part of the appeal.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by choo-t on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:53AM (#43299855)
Having one of your backups out of site will prevent its loss during a fire/flood scenario.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by iav on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:47AM (#43299452)
Except for crypto, losing your passwords is annoying but not irreversible
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by Sayrus on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:09AM (#43299559)
Depending on your usage, loosing your password can be irreversible. That'd lock you out of your encrypted email and storage and will take you months to recover your account on some platforms.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by ksenzee on Saturday March 08, 2025 @10:42AM (#43301038)
Your phone also has the recovery key. Having a copy on your person does lessen the chance of losing all your copies at once.