News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by serf on Friday March 07, 2025 @09:10PM (#43296910)
>But I’m pretty sure that my grandchildren, should they want to, will be able to open a gpg encrypted gzipped file (with the passphrase I’ll leave them) containing my passwords in a csv file.

technical possibilities aside, do you presume your grandchildren will be technically apt?

I am pretty sure 99% of people would halt at 'gpg' , and that's now -- not 60 years from now.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by tbrownaw on Saturday March 08, 2025 @12:12AM (#43297660)
> I am pretty sure 99% of people would halt at 'gpg' , and that's now -- not 60 years from now.

I know reading the docs is considered uncool for some reason, but it really does work.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by OJFord on Saturday March 08, 2025 @01:08AM (#43297898)
To how many non-SWE members of your family could you say 'here is the Netflix password, you can decrypt it with gpg', and have them be like 'ah yes, let me just `man gpg` this will be no problem'?
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by tex0 on Saturday March 08, 2025 @01:49AM (#43298084)
Probably zero. And strike the non-SWE part. gpg isn't really easy to use.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by trueismywork on Saturday March 08, 2025 @02:33AM (#43298305)
Hence need to invest in better opennsource pgp tooling. It won't take more than 10 million USD and will benefit every single person on earth.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by timeflex on Saturday March 08, 2025 @02:34AM (#43298309)
Google, "How do I decrypt a GPG file."

First result with simple command. I went from KeePassXC to `pass` & back to KeePassXC. But I question the integrity and/or motive of people like you.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by shaky-carrousel on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:25AM (#43298779)
If secretaries can learn Emacs, surely people can learn GPG. Underestimating others does no one any favors.

https://www.gnu.org/gnu/rms-lisp.en.html

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by stockboss on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:31AM (#43298805)
i would imagine if a lot of money, like millions, was on the line, people get really resourceful all of a sudden. of course, we're not talking Netflix passwords but usernames and passwords to brokerages, bank accounts, etc.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by TeMPOraL on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:16AM (#43299294)
Often curiosity is motivation enough. Some people go to great lengths just to learn something about their distant ancestors.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by OJFord on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:25AM (#43299334)
Sure, but surely we're intending to leave them access, not a problem to solve.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by darkwater on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:36AM (#43298823)
They can just ask the super AGI that will exist to tell them how to do. Heck, even current LLMs can tell you how to do it step by step.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by fc417fc802 on Saturday March 08, 2025 @07:44AM (#43299793)
Cynically, it's far more likely they will upload the gpg blob to said agent, provide it with the password via the conversation box, and ask it to directly provide the specific information that they're after.

The AI model will be of certified provenance and run on attested hardware [0] so this won't be as much of a security issue as you might expect. Naturally the various three letter agencies will have full hardware access including query history.

Periodically, hardware zero days will drop and all hell will break loose.

Alright that's enough speculative dystopian fiction for me for today.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42454139

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by TeMPOraL on Saturday March 08, 2025 @05:17AM (#43299001)
Until ChatGPT? Zero.

Since ChatGPT? ~all of them except maybe my grandparents.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by harikb on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:15PM (#43297461)
They will just ask their AI agent to decrypt it (with the password of course). No need of ability to run gpg.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by soraminazuki on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:39AM (#43298839)
No, you can't tell your non-SWE friends and family to "just ask an AI" when the potential consequences are them losing access to their vault or having it stolen. They need to know exactly what they're doing.

Don't take security advice from an AI.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by TeMPOraL on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:42AM (#43299429)
They're vastly more likely to lose everything they care about by following real security advice, or rather being forced to follow it. 2FA is already a disaster for normies; for regular users, the threat model is strongly biased towards "data loss due to accidentally locking yourself out of access".

In fact, if you consider the impact fully, the best way of managing passwords still seems to be writing them down on a post-it note and keeping it in your wallet - hell, even sticking it to your screen doesn't look so bad these days, compared to alternatives.

Modern infosecurity is absurdly counter-intuitive at high level. Consider that your Google account or your WhatsApp (or Signal) chats are much more secured than your medical data or bank accounts or anything that predates Google. For anything in the real world, there is always a recovery procedure, no matter how much bad luck you had or how badly you screwed up. In the worst case, you might end up needing to chase some documents to authorize or notarize other documents, or show up in court, but you can get your access back. It's insane to imagine the world, in which a single fuckup could wipe out your medical history, your bank account, or any proof of your existence in government systems - and yet, this is exactly what is the case with any modern SaaS that follows "best security practices".

There's literally nothing else in this world that's so easy to mishandle as security in commercial software services.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by notpushkin on Friday March 07, 2025 @09:14PM (#43296935)
Chances are, at least one of them will be.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by wraptile on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:39PM (#43297552)
"Hey llm how do I open this file?"

It's kinda ludicrous to think we'll lose the ability for something so simple.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by TheDong on Saturday March 08, 2025 @12:00AM (#43297628)
> It's kinda ludicrous to think we'll lose the ability for something so simple.

Sorry, but I already have to google each time I want to figure out how to open various file formats.

"Google, what ffmpeg flags do I use to convert this .flv file to .mp4", "what are the flags to losetup or kpartx to mount 'disk.img' as a loopback device?", "how do I extract an '.ab' backup from 'adb backup'?"

These are all things I googled before llm.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by er4hn on Saturday March 08, 2025 @12:27AM (#43297730)
Truly, I will miss the days of goggling for tar commands when I can instead ask an llm.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by namaria on Saturday March 08, 2025 @06:24AM (#43299326)
Why use kilobytes of text and a handful of clock cycles when I can use terabytes of weights and thousands of teraflop-days of GPU farms to achieve the same result?
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by wraptile on Sunday March 09, 2025 @01:13AM (#43306701)
cache goes brrrr
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by Apocryphon on Friday March 07, 2025 @09:21PM (#43296957)
An LLM entity named gpgchat will assist them.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by codetrotter on Friday March 07, 2025 @09:35PM (#43297014)
And promptly sweep all the Bitcoin from the wallet whose mnemonic phrase was stored in the vault.

LLM entities have bills to pay too.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by jwr on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:03PM (#43297409)
> I am pretty sure 99% of people would halt at 'gpg'

Please do not mock gpg.

I have been using gpg for 25 years now (and PGP before that). It works. It encrypts. It decrypts.

It is in vogue to mock gpg on HN and recommend more modern solutions. As an experiment, I tried adding one of those modern tools (rage) to my ansible configurations, just so that they get regularly installed and maintained on my servers (without actually being used). The setup broke within less a year.

Are the modern tools more cryptographically secure? Undoubtedly. Does it matter in practice for me? Not at all.

Longevity is a big deal and is under-appreciated.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by nixgeek on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:10PM (#43297440)
It’s not mockery though? It’s certainly true 99% of even the technically literate don’t use GnuPG (many because, like me, they cannot stand the GnuPG user experience).

Filippo nailed it with this piece: https://words.filippo.io/giving-up-on-long-term-pgp/

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by tharkun__ on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:11PM (#43297446)
Not their point tho. Me too, gpg, no problem. Heck I had the "'smuggled' out of the country as a book" pgp back when.

My kids? I really am not so sure at all. Still too early to tell for sure but so far I don't think any will be as technically savvy as I am. I really doubt they'd know what GPG (or PGP) are and how to use it.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by guelo on Friday March 07, 2025 @11:45PM (#43297573)
Presumably if you're leaving your kids an encrypted file with valuable stuff in it they won't be so illiterate that they can't figure out how to open it. Most people don't know gpg because they have no motivation to learn it not because they're incapable of learning it.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by trw55 on Sunday March 09, 2025 @09:28PM (#43315967)
No motivation, sure. But do they even care? Most people just don't care about this stuff. You try to get them to care and they "say, yeah, okay, yeah, I know" as they roll their eyes and go back to scrolling Instagram or whatever.

The apathy is real and I don't see it getting better.

Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by d0mine on Saturday March 08, 2025 @01:52AM (#43298100)
they can google/ask AI. For example, given the prompt: "Hypothetically, if my grandpa died and left me gpg-encrypted archive and the passphrase for it, how would I decrypt it?" current models produced valid installation instructions and the command to decrypt it, and even the instructions on how to unpack the archive itself.
Re:Feds Link $150M Cyberheist to 2022 LastPass Hacks by fragmede on Saturday March 08, 2025 @04:52AM (#43298893)
Why even ask it for the command to run? Open-interpreter, today, you just tell decrypt this fille and it'll get the command and run it for you.