News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Reason077 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @01:32PM (#43222119)
Amazing how the idea of being able to file tax returns online, without paying for a commercial service to do it, is considered far-left extremism in the US.

You’d think that simplifying tax returns and reducing costs in the taxation system would be something the right could get behind?

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:29PM (#43222736)
They claim that if the government could calculate taxes for you, then it would be too easy for the left to add new taxes that you wouldn't notice.

The real kicker of course is that if you don't file your taxes, they actually do calculate your taxes for you, and send you a bill. It just includes the non-payment penalty and doesn't include donations.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by peter422 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:51PM (#43223560)
I don’t remember the exact amount but after I filed my taxes last year I got a refund from the IRS for under 1 dollar because I had mistakenly put a small typo while entering a 1099 and they automatically corrected my return and sent me a few cents of a refund.

The fact that they are capable of doing that implies how much time we all have to waste doing our taxes.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by thelastgallon on Saturday March 01, 2025 @04:01PM (#43223636)
Then the right thing to do would be to remove tax deduction at source from payroll. People will notice how much they are paying in taxes when they have to write a check every month to the government and start asking questions.

For most people, taxes are more than the next 3 biggest expenses.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by nxobject on Saturday March 01, 2025 @04:46PM (#43224026)
Are you sure the question wouldn’t be “why don’t they just take it out at payroll like they did before $RIGHT_WINGER did this, that would be more efficient and save everyone time like every other country in the world?”
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by xethos on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:34PM (#43226592)
If you want efficiency, then sure, remove them automatically and save everyone the time. But Americans, by and large, aren't into efficiency.

If you want people to visually see where their money goes and when taxes are increased, you do a better job breaking down where it goes when described on a paycheque. Think "$0.82 for military spending; $0.05 for road maintenance" instead of "Federal tax: $317.02"

If you want the people to misunderstand and hate the government, then you make the people do math every month with numbers that change throughout the year and have financial penalties for getting wrong.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:52PM (#43234328)
Most people would just set up auto pay and then it would be functionally the same. Out of sight out of mind. I'm pretty sure separating it wouldn't do anything except cause a lot of enforcement issues when people failed to pay.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by johnnyanmac on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @03:02PM (#43259276)
A shame because it's on your paystub. You can see exactly how many taxes are deducted on every W-2 paycheck.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by WorkerBee28474 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:05PM (#43223104)
> They claim that if the government could calculate taxes for you, then it would be too easy... to add new taxes that you wouldn't notice.

As a non-American whose country break out the VAT into a separate line item, with the explicit intent to inform consumers how much tax they are paying, and who has shopped in countries where they roll it all into one, I can say that this 'claim' is absolutely what happens in practice.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:31PM (#43223353)
Are you saying the only way that citizens are informed of the current tax rates is through price tags?
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by WorkerBee28474 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:40PM (#43223456)
Why on earth would I say that?
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:43PM (#43223479)
That's what your comment implies. That taxes are being hidden because they aren't on the price tag.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Aloisius on Saturday March 01, 2025 @04:06PM (#43223677)
Or not on the receipt.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by johnnyanmac on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @03:09PM (#43259336)
They are "hidden" the same way manufacturing costs, labor, theft correction, psychological penny deduction, etc are hidden on your receipt, sure. You need to research to look all that up.

Meanwhile, you can simply check "VAT rate 20xx" and find that. It saves time doing the math for your state sales tax and then doing mental math to figure out what you leave the store with.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by cameronh90 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:26PM (#43225748)
In the UK, VAT is incorporated into the price. This does lead to some sort of an awareness issue.

Pretty much everyone does, of course, know that the VAT rate is 20%, but still you always get people complaining that we’re being ripped off when something which costs $1000 ends up being sold here at £950.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Reason077 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:39PM (#43226609)
Even in countries where price tags must include VAT/GST, the exact tax content is usually broken down as a line item on invoices and receipts. Best of both worlds.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by superb_dev on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:46PM (#43222913)
Is non-payment cheaper than donations?
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by lesuorac on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:50PM (#43222952)
No.

Taxes are in hindsight so you've already made whatever donations you did by the time you paid taxes.

Donations either lower your tax bill or have no effect on it. So, by not filling taxes (_and getting caught_) you're just increasing your tax bill.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by abeyer on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:21PM (#43223261)
Unless of course you're owed a refund, in which case they'll hold your money and pay you interest on it (at least for a few years.)

...but then tax you on the interest they paid you if you claim it.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by froindt on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:46PM (#43223523)
My understanding was they don't pay interest on tax refunds, but you pay interest on unpaid tax liabilities.

Do you have a source handy? My Google-fu is failing and only bringing up interest on unpaid taxes.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by tarlinian on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:04PM (#43226389)
If the refund is paid in less than 45 days after the tax filing deadline or the day you file your taxes, they will pay you interest. See here: https://www.irs.gov/payments/interest#pay
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Rebelgecko on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:43AM (#43227774)
Within the last few years I got a couple hundred bonus bucks back from the IRS as interest. Might've been a year where they were overhelmed and took significantly longer to cut the check that usual
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by nkrisc on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:50PM (#43226686)
You’re saying I can pay the IRS to figure out my taxes for me?
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:53PM (#43234333)
Technically yes, but you'll pay them a lot more than you'd pay H&R Block or any of the other tax prep people.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by twoodfin on Sunday March 02, 2025 @01:14PM (#43233248)
There’s no way the IRS can track and calculate many large, important features of the tax code.

EITC eligibility, for example, depends on the aggregate employment and spending patterns of your household. The IRS does not (and shouldn’t) track when you moved in with your boyfriend.

The home mortgage interest deduction depends on your primary residence; if you have more than one, that means tracking how much time you spend at each.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:40PM (#43234175)
This is true. They would have to send you a simple form to ask you for those things. Or change the way those things are reported. But fun fact, ~80% of tax returns could be calculated by the IRS with no input from the taxpayer, based on the actual returns that they get now. In other words, 80% of returns don't have any information they don't already know. That's mainly because most taxpayers have a single W2 income and just take the standard deduction.

Although you're wrong about the mortgage interest deduction, that is reported by the bank per address, and you have the list your primary address with your state tax authority, which the IRS gets a copy of.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by twoodfin on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:45PM (#43237052)
“A simple form to ask you for those things” is what we have today. Or is the IRS failing to simplify these forms to the utmost degree?

I think you’re seriously underestimating the amount of data the IRS would have to proactively collect. “We get your tax obligation right 80% of the time!” isn’t an acceptable SLA. Kids are born, houses (and electric cars!) are bought and sold, community college classes are enrolled in, …

Re: Primary residence: Uhh, OK, so I report to my state tax authority who reports to the Feds. I thought the point of this thread was that somebody else would do all this for me, but for the evils of Grover Norquist and Intuit?

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:50PM (#43237087)
That is not what we have today. For starters, that form starts with "tell us what is on your W2". They already know that. They don't need it.

There is a reason TurboTax is popular -- because it's a better interface for asking those questions.

But look at other countries. They don't ask you to fill out a form. They send you a bill and ask if they missed anything. For 80% of taxpayers, they would send the bill and the taxpayer would say, "yep, that's right". And your taxes would be done.

The rest could keep doing it the old way.

> Kids are born, houses (and electric cars!) are bought and sold, community college classes are enrolled in

All things they already know about! Because when you claim those things on your taxes, they cross check that to try and catch you in a lie.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by twoodfin on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:13PM (#43237240)
The IRS is not keeping a database of real estate transactions and birth records. Let alone modest charitable contributions or fluid household composition.

When the IRS audits you, they don’t come with their own evidence beyond the basic income reporting that yes, they could pre-fill into forms. It’s up to you to produce documentation that justifies your filing.

Our tax code is complicated. It relies on voluntary (but potentially audited) reporting and compliance. If you want to argue for a simpler tax code, great, but at the end of the day, either the IRS needs to collect a lot more data or we’re stuck with self-reporting.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Monday March 03, 2025 @12:05AM (#43238476)
Again, for 80% of filers, none of this matters. They have their one W2 and take the standard deduction. The only thing the IRS needs to know is what's on the W2 and their marriage status, which they absolutely do have because if you get the marriage status wrong they send you a letter (and it's a matter of public record anyway).

So for 80% of people, they would never have to fill out a tax form at all. They could just get the tax bill and have it auto-pay (or more likely auto-refund).

And for the next 10% of people, who only take a small set of deductions that you can take on top of the standard deduction, you don't need even a two page form, you just need a wizard that asks a few questions like TurboTax.

And then for the rest they can opt to fill out the regular forms if they don't agree with how the IRS calculated their bill. This is how it works in pretty much every other civilized country (and a lot of uncivilized ones too).

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by cragfar on Monday March 03, 2025 @09:22AM (#43242002)
You're missing that those 80% are not the same people every year. The IRS definitely doesn't keep a database of who is married or not, nor are they scouring every counties database for changes. I'm not sure where you're getting the "they will just send you a letter" part.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by johnnyanmac on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @03:05PM (#43259308)
Sounds fine to me. Sometimes you have a simple W-2. Sometimes you need to report life changes. "Efficiency" means those 20% figure it out when they have to.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Animats on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:47PM (#43222937)
Heavy lobbying by Intuit/TurboTax for years.[1]

[1] https://www.opensecrets.org/search?q=TurboTax&type=site#gsc....

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by astrange on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:35PM (#43223412)
It's not TurboTax, it's Grover Norquist. Republicans are already ideologically against easy tax filing because they're against taxes, they don't need corporate backing for that.

Using OpenSecrets in particular is misleading because it shows you donations fron "employees of corporations" to political campaigns and then people pretend it's donations from "corporations", which is obviously not the same thing. (and not allowed either)

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by adastra22 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:45PM (#43223503)
I mean, it's both. Intuit gives money to representatives that ideologically dislike taxes, and therefore WANT it to be a horrible experience so that you'll go along with getting rid of it (which Intuit knows will never actually happen).
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by astrange on Monday March 03, 2025 @07:15PM (#43248513)
> Intuit gives money to representatives

No they don't. Corporations can't give money to representatives. That's exactly why I just said OpenSecrets is misleading.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by j_san on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:15PM (#43223203)
I don't think that far-left was primarily only written because of the tax returns. I followed some links in the article and came to this twitter thread which might explain where that notion comes from: https://x.com/lukerosiak/status/1885523747425399247

(Disclaimer: I don't live in the US and don't want to take any political stance with this)

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by janeerie on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:19PM (#43223249)
This is exactly right. Direct File got thrown into the discussion, but it was not the reason that 18F was getting labelled as far-left.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by djur on Saturday March 01, 2025 @06:47PM (#43225402)
I don't see any evidence that 18F was any more "far-left" than tech workers on average.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by skissane on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:11PM (#43225617)
The tweet the GP linked – https://x.com/lukerosiak/status/1885523747425399247 – mentioned they wrote a Slack bot to lecture people about using inclusive language.

I don't think that is average for US tech workers. I don't believe the vast majority of US tech firms have such a thing.

I wouldn't call that "far left" myself – although "far left" as used by American conservatives is a pejorative colloquialism whose meaning has shifted from its traditional definition (Trotskyists, Stalinists, Maoists, etc). Not slang I'd use myself but I can understand it.

P.S. If you don't trust a tweet from a right-leaning journalist, here's a page from their own GitHub repo about their bot: https://github.com/18F/charlie/blob/main/InclusionBot.md

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by djur on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:26PM (#43225752)
I have worked at a place with a bot like that. It's one of over a dozen bots in that repository and seems to have been created and maintained by 3 people over the years. I believe 18F peaked at 250 employees.

Some of the terms are genuinely offensive or unprofessional. I'm not sure about some of them, but I'd expect a government agency to show a higher level of sensitivity and professionalism about their language than a private start-up.

I also note that the bot "lectures" people as a private message.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by thuridas on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:31PM (#43225783)
So now trying to avoid offensive language in the government is the reason to fire a whole department?

What is going to happen in four years? Is every administration forms to fire each others federal workers?

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by skissane on Saturday March 01, 2025 @08:03PM (#43225971)
If a government agency has a culture which appears to lean strongly in one political direction, it is unsurprising that when the opposite political persuasion gets into power, the agency becomes a target.

Traditionally how civil servants handle this, is to be aware of the political sensitivities of both sides, and try to avoid language which overly triggers either. But people seem to be forgetting that tradition, or even intentionally discarding it

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by djur on Saturday March 01, 2025 @08:31PM (#43226148)
Which government agencies have been targeted by Democrats for being too conservative?
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by skissane on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:16AM (#43227621)
Not strictly speaking a government agency, but what about the Judicial Procedures Reform Bill of 1937?

I think there was another possible reason for getting rid of 18F, separate from any concerns about its political culture – there was a lot of overlap in the mission statements of 18F and USDS, and it wasn't clear why both existed. Yes, I do understand that they differed somewhat in their working methods and area of focus, but I don't think anyone can deny that they were both ultimately trying to do the same thing. In fact, at one point 18F was even going to be called USDS, until GSA was forced to pick a different name when they discovered OMB was already using it. Abolishing 18F can be seen as a way of rationalizing federal technology modernization efforts.

18F hasn't been without its share of controversies, including an OIG finding that GSA leadership retaliated against a whistleblower who reported doubts about 18F's legality: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GOVPUB-GS-PURL-gpo134276...

And 18F wasn't formally speaking a government agency – it was just a team within GSA. It hadn't been established by law, just by an internal executive branch policy decision. Hence, abolishing it is just an internal restructure within GSA, it isn't a genuine case of "abolishing a government agency".

I believe laid-off 18F workers are still allowed to apply for open positions in the US government, including DOGE positions. So if they are still keen on contributing to 18F's mission, they may have the opportunity.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by djur on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:51AM (#43227804)
I don't think a failed attempt at court reform (ideologically motivated or no) from almost a century ago is very convincing evidence that this is typical practice on both sides of the aisle.

> there was a lot of overlap in the mission statements of 18F and USDS, and it wasn't clear why both existed

And now neither of them exist (the vast majority of what once was USDS is gone, and what remains has been converted into "DOGE").

I don't know what the quotes around "abolishing a government agency" indicate -- those words weren't used previously in this thread.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by skissane on Sunday March 02, 2025 @01:02AM (#43227843)
> And now neither of them exist (the vast majority of what once was USDS is gone, and what remains has been converted into "DOGE").

Do any of the old USDS staff survive? I don't know. USDS acting administrator, Amy Gleason, used to work for USDS under the Trump and Biden admins, so it sounds like there is still room for "old USDS" staff in "new USDS" – if they are happy to be there, and if the new administration is happy to have them.

And I don't think DOGE's remit is completely distinct from that of USDS. Of course, DOGE is a lot broader in scope than USDS, but according to Executive Order 14158 which established it, a big part of its mission is software modernization–same as old USDS was–and DOGE staff appear to include a number of software engineers, which also aligns with that mission.

> I don't know what the quotes around "abolishing a government agency" indicate -- those words weren't used previously in this thread.

You asked the question "Which government agencies have been targeted by Democrats for being too conservative?" – which seems to put 18F in the category of "government agencies" - if it isn't one in some sense, then the question isn't asking for a relevant comparator. And the title of this thread is "GSA Eliminates 18F", and "eliminates" is a synonym of "abolition". So, the premise of your question implies "abolishing a government agency". Which in a sense abolishing 18F is, since it was sort-of-kind-of a government agency – but strictly speaking it isn't, since strictly it wasn't – hence the quotes.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by djur on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:59AM (#43228359)
> Do any of the old USDS staff survive?

40 were laid off and 21 resigned (and Musk claimed that they would have been fired for being Democrats, regardless). That's approximately 60% of the total.

https://apnews.com/article/doge-elon-musk-federal-government...

As for "government agency", I was using your language:

> If a government agency has a culture [etc]... the agency becomes a target

Again, your claim here is that it's typical and predictable that new administrations conduct ideological purges on the civil service. So far, you haven't actually been able to name a single example of a Democratic administration doing that, and instead you're saying that maybe 18F was bad anyway, etc. Would you consider just admitting that your claim is false rather than resorting to this "by definition, strictly speaking, the premise of your question implies" ink cloud?

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by skissane on Sunday March 02, 2025 @05:35AM (#43229123)
> Again, your claim here is that it's typical and predictable that new administrations conduct ideological purges on the civil service.

No, I'm not denying this is reaching a level which hasn't been seen before.

But, perceptions of political impartiality of civil servants have been greatly eroded.

Imagine if the situation were reversed, if Democrats had a widespread perception that the federal bureaucracy had a pro-GOP/anti-Democrat bias – can you be so sure they wouldn't do similar things?

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by djur on Sunday March 02, 2025 @11:55AM (#43232347)
I don't have to imagine.

The ICE union endorsed Trump in 2016, 2020, and 2024 -- the only presidential endorsements it has ever made.

https://www.politico.com/story/2016/09/immigration-customs-e...

The FBI has traditionally leaned Republican (it has never had a Democratic director), as has the US military (especially the Air Force).

Biden did not purge ICE, nor did he replace Trump's FBI director, etc.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by remarkEon on Sunday March 02, 2025 @03:29AM (#43228513)
>So now trying to avoid offensive language

Building a bot to harangue people about pronoun usage seems like a giant waste of time and resources to me. Those sorts of cultural preferences are a feature of only a very very small portion of the US political culture. Maybe nuking the whole department was a bit strong, I don't know, but if I worked at a place that had tools like that I'd quit, and I think a lot of other people would too. Which suggests that the overall culture of 18F was far from the mainstream of America. It should reflect the middle, no?

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by arp242 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:13PM (#43226453)
This is like tiny stuff. What fundamentally matters is the main projects they're working on and if they're doing a good job with that or not.

Maybe a new administration want to to change the culture at GSA/18F. Fine, they can do that.

Nuking an entire department and chucking out a significant chunk of work they've done because of a Slack chatbot and a few minor documents/policies is just mental. It's vindictive score-setting and an ideological purge.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by skissane on Sunday March 02, 2025 @01:13AM (#43227883)
> and chucking out a significant chunk of work they've done

It is unclear how much of the actual work they've done is being "chucked out".

18F did work for various federal agencies, and whatever code 18F wrote for its client agencies would still be in possession of those agencies.

What happens to that code going forward – whether it continues to be maintained by other resources, or whether it just gets archived – is going to be an agency-level decision. Probably some will be kept, others will be thrown out – keeping or abolishing 18F is a separate decision from keeping or abolishing the agency-level projects/initiatives 18F was working on. (And even if 18F had survived, probably some of that code would eventually have been thrown out anyway, since government IT projects frequently end up failing and being cancelled, and 18F involvement is no guarantee against that outcome.)

Obviously, if those projects are going to be kept, removing 18F resources is going to cause a delay to the project – but maybe other resources will be found. It also depends on what percentage of the project resources were from 18F. If a project was 18F-heavy, it may take a big hit, if 18F's contribution was smaller, the negative impact might be smaller.

18F was funded out of the Acquisition Services Fund (ASF), managed by the Federal Acquisition Service (FAS) within GSA. FAS is legally obligated to spend ASF funds on federal technology modernization projects. Without 18F, FAS will have to find some other mechanism to spend those ASF funds on technology modernization. So, while of course there will be a delay, agencies which were relying on 18F may still end up getting help from GSA TTS for their modernization projects. I wouldn't be surprised if ASF funds were redirected towards DOGE, and DOGE was then tasked with working on those projects.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by dashundchen on Saturday March 01, 2025 @05:54PM (#43224776)
Far-left is having some affinity groups at work, hiring people who happen to be queer, and being inclusive to people with disabilities?

The right is deranged with intolerance. All the talk about "free speech" and they can't stand that someone might not think or act like them.

The "anti-woke" crusaders are honestly more unbearable than any social justice warrior type I've met because they will not shut up about it and it colors their whole life.

It's just another flavor of identity politics with in and out groups.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by YZF on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:09PM (#43225604)
As far as I can tell all these groups never shut up and it colors their entire life. Far left and far right is just a circle, the join at the same extreme.

What we need is a center. Just stuff that makes sense. The problem is our "sense" has been under attack we've basically collectively lost it.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by GenerWork on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:30PM (#43225779)
>The "anti-woke" crusaders are honestly more unbearable than any social justice warrior type I've met because they will not shut up about it and it colors their whole life.

I'm the complete opposite. Swap "anti-woke" with "social justice warrior" and you have my experience across multiple years, both inside and outside of companies.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by stouset on Saturday March 01, 2025 @01:55PM (#43222374)
The right wants everything related to taxes to be as difficult and painful as possible, in the hopes it will encourage the government to lower them.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by doawoo on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:34PM (#43222803)
They want everything to be privatized so they can rake in that sweet, sweet lobbyist money.

There's zero reason why taxes, for the majority of citizens, isn't just a postcard you get in the mail and confirm against your own earnings records. It should not cost me hours of my own life and/or dollars of my own money to file my taxes. I don't mind paying them (if they're used for something actually constructive like public infrastructure) but gosh they sure make it hard.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by pstuart on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:41PM (#43223460)
Both parts are true. The goal as a whole:

  * Eliminate all taxes
  * Eliminate all regulations
  * Use the government for financial gain (by the "right people")
  * Use the government to oppress all "others" (those who are not white christian men)
  * Crown a king and ensure that crown stays within their select group
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by fzeroracer on Saturday March 01, 2025 @06:54PM (#43225477)
The first two goals aren't even true, mind you. One of the first things the GOP was looking to do was institute a new tax on workers to pay for a tax cut on businesses and the rich. And they want to cut all regulations for businesses, but keep it illegal for workers to unionize and exert power. The last three points are correct however.

Everything they say is double speak, you have to look at what they say and what they do.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by kccqzy on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:02PM (#43222458)
I have heard of this argument many times but it doesn't make sense to me. Most often, the ways to lower taxes come from things like finding new deductions and credits that you didn't know apply to you. This is what the difficult part is. Otherwise, taxes are simple if you just have some W-2 and 1099-INT or 1099-DIV, and claim the standard deduction.

Indeed if taxes are too difficult or painful, a reasonable person would demand that the government simplify taxes, and that's not the same as reducing taxes. But then again maybe they are banking on the masses conflating simplifying taxes and reducing taxes.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by acdha on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:43PM (#43222888)
Taxes aren’t hard but people have been encouraged to talk about it like it’s a colonoscopy by Roto-rooter. Someone can have all W-2 income and only take the standard deduction, but thanks to that messaging they’ll act like filing your own taxes is incredibly dangerous with a high chance of ruining you for life (I know someone whose parent worked for the IRS as an auditor and they noted that many people ended up neutral or even getting a refund because an audit for someone who wasn’t trying to cheat would usually find deductions that they hadn’t claimed).

That’s not accidental: the rich have been funding anti-tax messaging since the introduction of the income tax, and it’s heavily promoted by the media voices they fund. The tax preparation industry is similarly biased since it’s with so profitable for the median voter to think that they need to pay hundreds of dollars every year to fill out a couple of forms.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by recursive on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:59PM (#43223623)
The reason I think taxes are hard isn't because of messaging. I might be an idiot, but it's because of an experience I had years ago where I was trying to follow the rules and pay taxes on some contracting income. I screwed something up. I ended up corresponding with the IRS dozens of times. Somehow I had recorded some income that never happened. I think I spent more time writing letters than I spent on the contract project. To this day I'm scared of contacting.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by EvanAnderson on Saturday March 01, 2025 @04:49PM (#43224062)
> ...where I was trying to follow the rules and pay taxes on some contracting income...

You're an exception and, yeah, it sucks. For somebody who has W-2 income, maybe a 1099-INT, and takes the standard deduction filing taxes is painless and simple.

I've just accepted the $800 - $1,000 cost per year for preparation of my LLC K-1 and personal taxes as part of the cost of being an exception. It sucks, but I just roll it into my rates.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by acdha on Saturday March 01, 2025 @04:57PM (#43224134)
Yeah, I’m not saying that every situation is trivial but the figures I’ve seen have something like 80% of filers using W-2 income so it’s weird when people who don’t have complex property ownership or business arrangements talk like it’s incredibly complicated. Most of us could use Direct File to be just like most other countries in the world, but there’s a now-dominant lobby which tried to block that.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by araes on Saturday March 01, 2025 @05:06PM (#43224211)
Generally agree for most people. Only caveat is for those with mild amounts of savings (not enough to qualify as wealthy).

Enough 401k, mild investments over time with disposable income, or transfers from friends / family / inheritance, that the process becomes quite challenging. You make a couple thousand on a decent year in capital gains or dividend distributions, yet end up with rather confusing paperwork piles to deal with at tax time. Finding out it was necessary to note each buy / sell and the holding time individually for the entire year just seemed crazy in the detail necessary.

Mild awareness of why the actual wealthy hire accountants and firms with specialized teams and software to deal with those issues.

The part that's also not dealt with, at least in terms of those deductions, is that usually they're related to businesses and expenses. The deductions are available, yet often you have to be treating almost your entire life like a business expense every moment. Business cell phone. Business internet. Business supplies. Business ads, website, and marketing. Business travel. Business property depreciation / amortization. Business legal and accounting. Business mileage. Business loan interest. Business meals.

A (personal opinion) funny one is "Hire your own children as workers." You can write-off the payment you make to them which reduces your taxes and the income they earn can be tax-free if you pay them less than the standard deduction.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jandrewrogers on Saturday March 01, 2025 @06:54PM (#43225474)
The minute you save a little money and have a few investments it can start to become complicated quickly. Yet you don't have/make enough money to justify the expense of hiring a professional to properly sort it out. This actually can become a giant headache because it is difficult to be certain that you've done it correctly and not overpaid.

Sure, if you only have a W-2 then it is pretty simple. The issue is that over time people have a tendency to accrue other tax reportable activities as a function of age. It actively discourages people from making some types of potentially productive investments because of the additional tax complexity.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:27PM (#43222722)
You know how everyone complains "oh I can't do anything this weekend I have to do my taxes"? They want that pain, so that you bitch and moan about the heavy burden of taxation, and then support the party that claims they want to reduce the heavy burden of taxation.

But also, Intuit spends a lot money lobbying.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Spooky23 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:25PM (#43226536)
My friend owned a tax preparation place for awhile. Half her clients could file with the short form. Most of the rest had either dependent care deductions or EIC, that's it. <5% used deductions beyond SALT and mortgage interest. It's a gross business. They charge people for being ignorant and dumb with money (via refund loans)

Hell, I have a fairly complex return. It takes me <90 minutes with a $40 software package.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by QIYGT on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:56PM (#43223603)
The complexity is also what allows loopholes to exist for rich people.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by kadoban on Saturday March 01, 2025 @01:54PM (#43222359)
The right in America does not believe in a federal government. Anything that helps a federal government exist is to be destroyed.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by vkou on Saturday March 01, 2025 @01:56PM (#43222390)
It absolutely believes in a federal government.

It just does not believe in a federal government that it is not in control of.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by dingnuts on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:12PM (#43222571)
who, exactly, is in control of independent agencies if Congress never corrects their power and the Executive isn't in charge?

For example: the perennial fight over "net neutrality" was because Congress absconded their duty to write regulation and handed it off to the Executive to figure out in a vague way that allowed for flip flopping policies with the force of law every time the administration changed.

You know what would stop the Executive power grab currently happening? If Congress would do their damn jobs. The Republicans in Congress are more to blame for this mess than the White House. This is supposed to be their power that they are just sitting and watching get taken away.

But the Democrats aren't guiltless either. People who care about this sort of thing have been complaining for decades, right through Democrat majorities and administrations. They had plenty of chances. The whole beltway fucking sucks and we are so cooked.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by hackyhacky on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:21PM (#43222661)
> The Republicans in Congress are more to blame for this mess than the White House.

The fact that Congress is ineffective in no way absolves the executive branch of irresponsible or illegal behavior. The president took an oath.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Sabinus on Saturday March 01, 2025 @05:42PM (#43224611)
Everyone is responsible for their own behaviour but if the legislature doesn't function nothing else will either. And we know the legislature has progressively become less functional, less bipartisan, less legislation passed every decade.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by khazhoux on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:03PM (#43225540)
Genuine question: what here is illegal?
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by vkou on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:46PM (#43225882)
The executive cannot just unilaterally shut down departments created by acts of congress.

That's what makes it illegal.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by khazhoux on Saturday March 01, 2025 @08:40PM (#43226192)
18F was not created via act of Congress, as far as I have been able to tell. Do you see a source that shows otherwise?
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Spooky23 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:38PM (#43226605)
18F was a business unit of the General Services Administration, which was created via 41 U.S.C. 251, the Federal Property and Administrative Services Act of 1949. The act transferred the function of the Federal Works Agency and the Treasury Bureau of Federal Supply to the GSA. The agency is directed and authorized to perform a variety of tasks, from real estate, to acquisition, to information technology and telecommunications.

31 USC 1535, The Economy Act, authorizes Federal agencies to purchase from each other in the interests of economy. Obvious application is that rather than have the Social Security Administration lease an office or build a building, they sublease or lease a facility owned by the GSA so Federal demand can be aggregated. 1 big lease is cheaper than 12 little ones.

In the case of 18F, having a consultive entity within the GSA maximizes the value of procurements made by GSA and other agencies. When congress appropriates money to say, the Department of Labor to perform a function, DOL may choose to engage 18F to deliver or assist, avoiding additional procurement and taking advantage of investments and capability already built.

Congress in 1949 recognized that basic concepts like shared services, aggregation and mission focus deliver value and promote efficient operations. The current regime's corrupt interest is obvious to anyone with a brain.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by beej71 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:14PM (#43226456)
I don't know about 18F, but the shutdowns are far more widespread than that.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by vkou on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:12AM (#43228122)
18F is not the only department that is being shut down.

The current iteration of USAID was created by an act of Congress. Unless the President's office has been given the power to create and pass legislature at some point in the past five weeks, only Congress can unmake it.

So was the CFPB, which is also being shut down.

So was the Department of Education.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Arainach on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:55PM (#43223590)
With the exception of a few days (which don't really count because of a sick Senator Kennedy and spineless moderate conservativeJoe Lieberman), the Democrats haven't had a filibuster-proof majority in the Senate in many, many decades.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by vkou on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:47PM (#43222931)
The purple fringes of the congressional GOP would be crucified by their constituents if they were doing this shit, which is why it is sitting back and letting the executive do everything that the party always wanted, but couldn't, while they keep their hands free.

The legislature could stop this, yes. But it won't, because he is carrying out the program the GOP always wished it could have done, but couldn't. Once this all goes to shit, they will of course, blame him, while keeping their own hands clean.

And given just how fucking fast a dedicated executive can destroy anything it doesn't like, there's literally nothing the Dems could have done to prevent this. It doesn't matter what laws they passed when they had control of government, when the current executive simply doesn't follow the law.

And the only people who could compel it to follow the law don't want it to.

The only cure to this is never voting red, under any circumstances, for any position, in any race. It's been fully compromised, and is unsalvageable.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by BrenBarn on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:24PM (#43223287)
> And given just how fucking fast a dedicated executive can destroy anything it doesn't like, there's literally nothing the Dems could have done to prevent this. It doesn't matter what laws they passed when they had control of government, when the current executive simply doesn't follow the law.

Oh yes there is. It's just more radical than they were prepared to admit was necessary. It's things like ramming through thousands of new federal judgeships, packing the Supreme Court, passing anti-gerrymandering laws with jail-time penalities for state officials that violate them, and ultimately packing the union (https://harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-133/pack-the-union-a-...). The things that needed to be done were not "make things so no president can do this when he gets elected", it's "fix the system so these kinds of people cannot ever be elected".

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by vkou on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:33PM (#43223382)
Yes, I suppose they can be blamed for not doing something like that when they get a 49.8% mandate.

(We can also blame them for not imprisoning, quicky and fairly trying, and executing Trump for sedition and treason when they could.)

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by BrenBarn on Saturday March 01, 2025 @08:48PM (#43226255)
The thing is that numbers like 49.8% are meaningless because the current system simply does not result in government that is representative of people's interests. There are large numbers of people who don't vote because they feel their vote doesn't matter, and they're right.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Sabinus on Saturday March 01, 2025 @08:57PM (#43226344)
An amazing reform that could be achieved is changing to ranked choice voting from the current first-past-the-post. It'll reduce the incentive for politicians to be radical to stand out, and reassures voters that they won't 'waste their vote' if they put an alternative candidate first.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by marsovo on Saturday March 01, 2025 @10:06PM (#43226789)
I once thought this was the solution too, then NYC's ranked-choice mayoral race gave it Eric Adams. Now I don't know. Maybe open primaries?
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by AnthonyMouse on Saturday March 01, 2025 @11:05PM (#43227164)
Ranked choice was the error. You want one of the cardinal voting systems like STAR.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Sabinus on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:23PM (#43236875)
I don't think ranked choice voting particularly helps preventing corrupt politicians. It mostly diminishes the incentive to be an extremist.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by AnthonyMouse on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:19PM (#43226497)
People suggest things like that as if the underlying problem is that Republicans often get into office with 46% of the vote and if they had to get 51% every time everything would be perfect, under the assumption that then they would never win.

What do think would really happen in that case? They'd change their platform slightly in a way that allows them to get 5% more of the vote and then still get in half the time. They're one of the parties in a two party system and it's a two party system because it uses first past the post instead of e.g. STAR voting. And the reason court packing doesn't work is obviously that as soon as either party actually did that, it would become the norm and happen every time the party in power switched, and nobody wants the courts to become fully partisan and the number federal judges to double every 4-8 years.

If you actually want to stop them from fucking everything up, figure out why they're doing the things they're doing. "They're evil and corrupt and have entirely impure motives" doesn't explain why ~half of voters voted for them.

Instead you have to look at the actual reasons and do something about them. Why do they want to expand oil production? Because people want cheap energy. If you don't want to expand oil production then you need to cause energy prices to go down in some other way, e.g. by not actively opposing the construction of nuclear reactors so their costs don't balloon as a result of lawsuits and a capricious regulatory environment, or provide more tax incentives for renewable energy so the transition happens faster and people stop caring about the price of gas sooner. Use diplomacy to e.g. encourage Germany not to shut down their nuclear reactors and raise global energy prices by switching back to fossil fuels.

Republicans keep getting elected by saying they're going to do something about burdensome regulations. Maybe consider whether there's something there? Look into what it's like to operate a small business. If you're making $9000/year selling stuff on Etsy and you invest in a postage meter, should you now have to know what MACRS is? If you don't, is it because it's somehow illegal to own one? How does property tax work on unsold business inventory stored in an out of state third party warehouse? If you have a question about any of this, why isn't there anyone in the government who can give you an official answer? Does the law create a good way for you to accept digital payments without getting locked into an overpriced payment gateway that can capriciously disrupt your business by dropping your account at any time? If you get an electric vehicle for your business, can you take the tax credit if you have enough income to be eligible for it personally even though the business didn't make a net profit this year? Why is the tax credit aimed at making it easier to afford one limited to people who make enough money that they already can? What can happen if you get some of these things wrong?

People keep voting for Republicans because interacting with the government is slow, frustrating, complicated and dangerous. The best way to take that away from them is to solve those problems yourself instead of insisting that they don't exist.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by BrenBarn on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:47PM (#43226664)
The issues you mention are more or less valid, but I think you overestimate the extent to which those explain why Republicans get elected. Moreover, the problem isn't so much "Republicans get elected" as "bad stuff happens". That stuff happens in large part because Republicans get elected after talking about doing the things that you mention, and then instead passing tax breaks and "deregulation" that largely favors the wealthy. But they also get elected in large part because of the highly unequal and unrepresentative system that they perpetuate, including a media system built on feeding people falsehoods utterly disconnected reality (which is another reason ~half of voters voted for them).

It's true that to some extent both parties participate in propping up that system, but Republicans clearly do so far more. There are a lot of problems with the Democratic party as well, which is precisely why radical change is needed rather than just "pass some garden variety Democrat measures".

I agree that there are important changes to be made that Democrats are lamentably unwilling to engage with, but I'm not talking about a world where Republicans need 51%. For most of the Republicans of national prominence, we should consider ourselves as a failure as a nation if they can even get 5%.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by AnthonyMouse on Saturday March 01, 2025 @10:52PM (#43227094)
> That stuff happens in large part because Republicans get elected after talking about doing the things that you mention

Which in turn works because, even if they don't solve those problems, the problems are real and people experience them. So if you would make the problems actually go away, they would lose the ability to run on them.

> But they also get elected in large part because of the highly unequal and unrepresentative system that they perpetuate

This is what I mean by 46% vs. 51%. There are way bigger problems than the electoral college or district lines, which would only change how and where both parties campaign rather than making anything obviously better.

> including a media system built on feeding people falsehoods utterly disconnected reality (which is another reason ~half of voters voted for them).

This was never great but the thing that really seemed to turn it into a tornado full of broken glass is the interaction between Trump and the traditional media.

Major media outlets were used to politicians fearing them, and then Trump didn't, so the media got more aggressive and less cautious. Which was only effective for a minute until people started to realize what they were doing and that set the media's credibility on fire and made things dramatically worse.

Meanwhile the right-leaning media outlets, which were traditionally more partisan but only a little, saw this and their conclusion was basically "oh, so we can just do whatever now?"

> There are a lot of problems with the Democratic party as well, which is precisely why radical change is needed rather than just "pass some garden variety Democrat measures".

The most significant thing you could actually do is replace first past the post with one of the cardinal voting systems (STAR, score, approval), because it would allow for more than two parties. Which in turn would upend the the entire partisan apparatus of both sides which has evolved in that environment and would be maladapted to defending itself and therefore vulnerable to positive change. But it's also a subtle enough change and distinct from any of the usual battle lines that all of the villains you'd be disrupting might not recognize the implications until it has already gone through.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by BrenBarn on Sunday March 02, 2025 @01:07AM (#43227859)
> So if you would make the problems actually go away, they would lose the ability to run on them.

But the fact that they run on them without solving them shows that it's possible to run on a vaporware platform and never do what you said you would. So they would just find some new nonsense to run on. Also to a non-negligible extent the "problems" they run on are already illusory or unrealistically exaggerated, like demonizing various groups, or capitalizing on people's lack of understanding of how regulations can amortize risk.

I think we agree that structural reforms are necessary (like changing voting systems), but I think it's more than just that. There is a very real movement that is based in getting a large mass of non-wealthy people to reject reality in order to capture their votes to support the goals of a small number of wealthy people. Switching to STAR voting isn't going to fix it. That entire phenomenon has to be actively purged from society in the way that Nazism was purged in post-WWII Germany.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by AnthonyMouse on Sunday March 02, 2025 @03:28AM (#43228506)
> But the fact that they run on them without solving them shows that it's possible to run on a vaporware platform and never do what you said you would. So they would just find some new nonsense to run on.

People care about the things that are causing trouble for them. You can promise to fix their problem and then not fix it, but if there's nothing they need from you then there's nothing to promise them.

> Also to a non-negligible extent the "problems" they run on are already illusory or unrealistically exaggerated, like demonizing various groups, or capitalizing on people's lack of understanding of how regulations can amortize risk.

Nah, that's just confusing the problem with the rhetoric.

Republicans hype immigration because the Democrats have an immigration problem:

a) "Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free". b) Generous social safety net.

You can't have unlimited immigration of the world's poor and then give them all welfare; you have to pick one. But Democrats can't choose, so we end up with this nonsense where immigration which is formally illegal is still happening at scale and they're neither willing to formally legalize it nor enforce the law against it.

Which means Republicans get to beat them over the head with it because the Democrats have no response to it when they're legitimately caught in an inconsistent position. To stop that from happening they need to pick which one of the two incompatible things they want.

Likewise, the US really does have a lot of regulatory overhead, and many of the rules are needlessly complicated, inconsistent, blunt, poorly considered or obviously corrupt. The people who actually have to interact with them -- mostly small businesses -- are intimately familiar with it and find it infuriating. Now, some of the rules are net positive, but even those are often still needlessly complicated or in conflict with other, stupider rules. To fix it you would need large teams of smart people go through all the rules, throw out the bad ones (even if they're corrupt and someone wants them that way), simplify the needless complexity, do a cost/benefit analysis that includes the administrative cost of implementation and have the ability to actually modify them. Which requires fastidious and diligent people to do something expensive and boring at large scale. But until that happens -- which it hasn't -- there is still a problem.

And in the meantime the Republicans get to say "regulations bad! less regulations!" and have a bunch of people cheer because they know how much the status quo sucks.

> There is a very real movement that is based in getting a large mass of non-wealthy people to reject reality in order to capture their votes to support the goals of a small number of wealthy people.

Eh. That's kind of one of the things a cardinal voting system does fix.

You're defining the problem too narrowly. The general issue is, in a two party system, both of the parties are big tent parties. Which means that if your party wants both X and Y and you need a majority to get either, the people who want X can go drum up support from people who want Y so their party gets in and they get X, because by nature the other major party will support both not-X and not-Y, so more support for Y is more support for the party that wants X.

If you have a voting system that supports arbitrarily many parties and your party supports both X and Y but X is stupid or unpopular, you can't win by getting more people to support Y because then some other party would come in and support Y but not X and then win because you've convinced people to want Y but not X and now that's actually one of the options on the ballot.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by BrenBarn on Sunday March 02, 2025 @04:32AM (#43228818)
> People care about the things that are causing trouble for them. You can promise to fix their problem and then not fix it, but if there's nothing they need from you then there's nothing to promise them.

But that sounds like you're saying the solution is to just fix all problems. That's never going to happen. There will always be problems of some sort, which means there can always be someone claiming to have solutions.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by AnthonyMouse on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:50PM (#43234304)
There are problems and there are problems.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Spooky23 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:43PM (#43226631)
It's way worse than that. The playbook is simple - "it's not us, it's Elon. Trump wants to make america great, Elon went too far. Us innocent legislators didn't see it coming!"

If the democrats grow a pair and shutdown the government by filibustering the budget, Trump will fire (or worse) Elon, scorched earth whatever is left and blame the democrats. They are all about the big lie -- they'll float the idea that Elon was secretly working with the democrats the whole time. If Trump is lucky, there will be an early hurricane or an earthquake in California and the devastation will be Chuck Schumer's fault. Long live the king.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by wat10000 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:05PM (#43225561)
Both major parties have been giving up the power of Congress for decades. They’re constantly handing more power to the executive, seemingly because it lets them dodge responsibility. People get mad at you when you do stuff, but if you just vest some power in an executive agency then people get mad at the President instead when that agency does the stuff.

People have been warning for a long time that this concentration of power in the executive is ripe for abuse. And here we are.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by fitsumbelay on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:01PM (#43223051)
https://www.propublica.org/article/inside-turbotax-20-year-f... the business of America is business, you see ...
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Finnucane on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:09PM (#43222543)
no, the right wants you to keep paying Turbotax.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by collinmcnulty on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:20PM (#43222652)
This is commonly repeated but incorrect. The Nyquist pledge is a far more powerful force keeping tax filing complex than Intuit lobbying. This is not a conspiracy theory, this is a stated practice of Americans for Tax Reform, the anti-tax conservative group.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by 1986 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:45PM (#43222907)
*Norquist
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Finnucane on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:26PM (#43222708)
they both have the same goals. that doesn’t make it not true.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by westurner on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:36PM (#43222813)
"Musk ally is moving to close office behind free tax filing program at IRS" (2025) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43222216
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by janeerie on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:08PM (#43223130)
18F is not the group behind Direct File, and it's very annoying that this narrative keeps getting spread. DF was created by a team of people from USDS, 18F and the IRS. It's housed within the IRS.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by djur on Saturday March 01, 2025 @06:49PM (#43225419)
USDS was gutted and turned into DOGE, 18F is shuttered, and IRS is having mass layoffs.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by janeerie on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:36PM (#43225815)
Oh, I know. But the fate of 18F and Direct File are not directly connected.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by khazhoux on Saturday March 01, 2025 @04:29PM (#43223871)
Every time I drive by the huge shiny new Intuit building on 101 near Google, I throw up a little. Regulatory capture in action.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by aeternum on Saturday March 01, 2025 @05:10PM (#43224247)
Simplify the tax code, don't add even more complex bureaucracy in a misguided attempt to make the awful tax code understandable.

Citizens need to understand the tax code themselves, they shouldn't need an entire government division to write software that is the only way to understand it.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by adambatkin on Saturday March 01, 2025 @08:14PM (#43226053)
That's a great idea. Let's do that.

And until that happens, helping people file their taxes for free is a benefit to everyone (except tax prep companies).

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by beej71 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:15PM (#43226466)
And after it happens let's keep filing for free.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by rights_reminder on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:21PM (#43225712)
I know I will be downvoted to hell in this thread for saying this, but the entire income tax scheme is a fraud. The tax code will never be simplified because it was intentionally designed to deceive the average American citizen who has been socialized into thinking that a tax has been imposed on their labor. In reality that has never been the case (power to tax is the power to destroy, pesky human rights).

Ask yourself the following if you have a knee-jerk reaction to disagree with me:

- How many words of income tax law have I read in my entire life? - How many IRS forms have I signed in the past? - Do I know the true legal purpose of the IRS forms I signed?

The truth of the upon whom the income tax has actually been imposed is buried in mountains of legalese that the government knows virtually nobody will bother to read or grok. This paired with labelling anyone who knows the truth a tax protester, tax denier, sovereign citizen, or some similar pejorative, allows IRS to get away with the largest financial crime in history. (To be clear there are many incorrect arguments about income tax law.)

Unfortunately this issue is damn near impossible to convey to anyone in a comment on the internet, but hopefully some brave HNers will realize there is more to be seen here and take a hacker-mindset to it. I recommend reading the book 'Income tax: Shattering the myths' if you care to follow the law and learn more.

“As judges, it is our duty to construe legislation as it is written, not as it might be read by a layman, or as it might be understood by someone who has not even read it.” Meese v. Keene, 481 U.S. 465, 484 (1987)

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Sabinus on Saturday March 01, 2025 @08:51PM (#43226284)
Most developed countries on earth have an income tax. Do you think they're all part of the same elite deception scam?
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by rights_reminder on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:59PM (#43226749)
The point of my comment was that, in the US, the government has to create an elaborate body of law to trick people into thinking the law says something which it does not say. If we did not have limitations on the taxing power of congress, they could just write a simple law that says "There is hereby imposed on all labor of every person working in the 50 states a tax equal to..."

The fact that there is no such sentence in US tax law should be a wake-up call... The reason the income tax parts of the IRC are so complex is to keep them in perfect accordance with the constitutional limits on taxation while deceiving you. Taxes on income are in their nature excises, which are taxes on privileges. Foreign persons do not have the same rights that we Americans do (I don't necessarily agree with this, it is just how the law works).

Eventually this will come to an end. Tens or hundreds of thousands of people have known about what I am saying for a hundred years. Eventually a critical mass of people will be wise to the scam and HR departments will no longer subordinate perjury by pressuring clueless people to improperly sign a Form W-4, declaring themselves to be a foreign person subject to wage withholding (see Treasury Decision 8734)[0].

[0] https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-irbs/irb97-44.pdf

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by verall on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:35AM (#43228234)
This is very interesting. Do you just not pay your income taxes?
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by monetus on Sunday March 02, 2025 @01:40PM (#43233531)
To be clear for others, the sibling comment is incorrect and I think is an idea coming from the sovereign citizen movement. You have to pay income tax generally.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by beej71 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:28PM (#43226553)
I do my taxes myself almost every time. And they're more complicated than average.

I'm all for simplification, but it's already pretty simple to understand for almost all Americans.

The only part that sucks for all Americans is actually filing, especially when you have to pay some asshole intermediary just to make it slightly faster.

In our state, they streamlined filing. I still have to understand the same things, but it's 3x faster than before. So I know it's possible.

Laying off the one programming team whose products were actually improving my interface with the government was braindead stupid.

Again, yes, simplify the tax code. But for the love of Christ, streamline filing with DirectFile no matter what you do!!

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by rights_reminder on Saturday March 01, 2025 @10:07PM (#43226797)
99% of Americans are not supposed to be filing a tax return. Unless you paid US source income to it's foreign owner, you should not be either. What gave you the idea that you needed to?
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by beej71 on Sunday March 02, 2025 @01:33AM (#43227962)
The IRS rules. But tell me more
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by rcpt on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:26PM (#43226542)
Every Republican must swear an oath to uphold Grover Norquist thought
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by sizzle on Sunday March 02, 2025 @03:12PM (#43234524)
Blame the lobbying efforts of Intuit