News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:29PM (#43222736)
They claim that if the government could calculate taxes for you, then it would be too easy for the left to add new taxes that you wouldn't notice.

The real kicker of course is that if you don't file your taxes, they actually do calculate your taxes for you, and send you a bill. It just includes the non-payment penalty and doesn't include donations.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by peter422 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:51PM (#43223560)
I don’t remember the exact amount but after I filed my taxes last year I got a refund from the IRS for under 1 dollar because I had mistakenly put a small typo while entering a 1099 and they automatically corrected my return and sent me a few cents of a refund.

The fact that they are capable of doing that implies how much time we all have to waste doing our taxes.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by thelastgallon on Saturday March 01, 2025 @04:01PM (#43223636)
Then the right thing to do would be to remove tax deduction at source from payroll. People will notice how much they are paying in taxes when they have to write a check every month to the government and start asking questions.

For most people, taxes are more than the next 3 biggest expenses.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by nxobject on Saturday March 01, 2025 @04:46PM (#43224026)
Are you sure the question wouldn’t be “why don’t they just take it out at payroll like they did before $RIGHT_WINGER did this, that would be more efficient and save everyone time like every other country in the world?”
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by xethos on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:34PM (#43226592)
If you want efficiency, then sure, remove them automatically and save everyone the time. But Americans, by and large, aren't into efficiency.

If you want people to visually see where their money goes and when taxes are increased, you do a better job breaking down where it goes when described on a paycheque. Think "$0.82 for military spending; $0.05 for road maintenance" instead of "Federal tax: $317.02"

If you want the people to misunderstand and hate the government, then you make the people do math every month with numbers that change throughout the year and have financial penalties for getting wrong.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:52PM (#43234328)
Most people would just set up auto pay and then it would be functionally the same. Out of sight out of mind. I'm pretty sure separating it wouldn't do anything except cause a lot of enforcement issues when people failed to pay.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by johnnyanmac on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @03:02PM (#43259276)
A shame because it's on your paystub. You can see exactly how many taxes are deducted on every W-2 paycheck.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by WorkerBee28474 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:05PM (#43223104)
> They claim that if the government could calculate taxes for you, then it would be too easy... to add new taxes that you wouldn't notice.

As a non-American whose country break out the VAT into a separate line item, with the explicit intent to inform consumers how much tax they are paying, and who has shopped in countries where they roll it all into one, I can say that this 'claim' is absolutely what happens in practice.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:31PM (#43223353)
Are you saying the only way that citizens are informed of the current tax rates is through price tags?
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by WorkerBee28474 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:40PM (#43223456)
Why on earth would I say that?
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:43PM (#43223479)
That's what your comment implies. That taxes are being hidden because they aren't on the price tag.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Aloisius on Saturday March 01, 2025 @04:06PM (#43223677)
Or not on the receipt.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by johnnyanmac on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @03:09PM (#43259336)
They are "hidden" the same way manufacturing costs, labor, theft correction, psychological penny deduction, etc are hidden on your receipt, sure. You need to research to look all that up.

Meanwhile, you can simply check "VAT rate 20xx" and find that. It saves time doing the math for your state sales tax and then doing mental math to figure out what you leave the store with.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by cameronh90 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @07:26PM (#43225748)
In the UK, VAT is incorporated into the price. This does lead to some sort of an awareness issue.

Pretty much everyone does, of course, know that the VAT rate is 20%, but still you always get people complaining that we’re being ripped off when something which costs $1000 ends up being sold here at £950.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Reason077 on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:39PM (#43226609)
Even in countries where price tags must include VAT/GST, the exact tax content is usually broken down as a line item on invoices and receipts. Best of both worlds.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by superb_dev on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:46PM (#43222913)
Is non-payment cheaper than donations?
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by lesuorac on Saturday March 01, 2025 @02:50PM (#43222952)
No.

Taxes are in hindsight so you've already made whatever donations you did by the time you paid taxes.

Donations either lower your tax bill or have no effect on it. So, by not filling taxes (_and getting caught_) you're just increasing your tax bill.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by abeyer on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:21PM (#43223261)
Unless of course you're owed a refund, in which case they'll hold your money and pay you interest on it (at least for a few years.)

...but then tax you on the interest they paid you if you claim it.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by froindt on Saturday March 01, 2025 @03:46PM (#43223523)
My understanding was they don't pay interest on tax refunds, but you pay interest on unpaid tax liabilities.

Do you have a source handy? My Google-fu is failing and only bringing up interest on unpaid taxes.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by tarlinian on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:04PM (#43226389)
If the refund is paid in less than 45 days after the tax filing deadline or the day you file your taxes, they will pay you interest. See here: https://www.irs.gov/payments/interest#pay
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by Rebelgecko on Sunday March 02, 2025 @12:43AM (#43227774)
Within the last few years I got a couple hundred bonus bucks back from the IRS as interest. Might've been a year where they were overhelmed and took significantly longer to cut the check that usual
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by nkrisc on Saturday March 01, 2025 @09:50PM (#43226686)
You’re saying I can pay the IRS to figure out my taxes for me?
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:53PM (#43234333)
Technically yes, but you'll pay them a lot more than you'd pay H&R Block or any of the other tax prep people.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by twoodfin on Sunday March 02, 2025 @01:14PM (#43233248)
There’s no way the IRS can track and calculate many large, important features of the tax code.

EITC eligibility, for example, depends on the aggregate employment and spending patterns of your household. The IRS does not (and shouldn’t) track when you moved in with your boyfriend.

The home mortgage interest deduction depends on your primary residence; if you have more than one, that means tracking how much time you spend at each.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Sunday March 02, 2025 @02:40PM (#43234175)
This is true. They would have to send you a simple form to ask you for those things. Or change the way those things are reported. But fun fact, ~80% of tax returns could be calculated by the IRS with no input from the taxpayer, based on the actual returns that they get now. In other words, 80% of returns don't have any information they don't already know. That's mainly because most taxpayers have a single W2 income and just take the standard deduction.

Although you're wrong about the mortgage interest deduction, that is reported by the bank per address, and you have the list your primary address with your state tax authority, which the IRS gets a copy of.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by twoodfin on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:45PM (#43237052)
“A simple form to ask you for those things” is what we have today. Or is the IRS failing to simplify these forms to the utmost degree?

I think you’re seriously underestimating the amount of data the IRS would have to proactively collect. “We get your tax obligation right 80% of the time!” isn’t an acceptable SLA. Kids are born, houses (and electric cars!) are bought and sold, community college classes are enrolled in, …

Re: Primary residence: Uhh, OK, so I report to my state tax authority who reports to the Feds. I thought the point of this thread was that somebody else would do all this for me, but for the evils of Grover Norquist and Intuit?

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Sunday March 02, 2025 @07:50PM (#43237087)
That is not what we have today. For starters, that form starts with "tell us what is on your W2". They already know that. They don't need it.

There is a reason TurboTax is popular -- because it's a better interface for asking those questions.

But look at other countries. They don't ask you to fill out a form. They send you a bill and ask if they missed anything. For 80% of taxpayers, they would send the bill and the taxpayer would say, "yep, that's right". And your taxes would be done.

The rest could keep doing it the old way.

> Kids are born, houses (and electric cars!) are bought and sold, community college classes are enrolled in

All things they already know about! Because when you claim those things on your taxes, they cross check that to try and catch you in a lie.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by twoodfin on Sunday March 02, 2025 @08:13PM (#43237240)
The IRS is not keeping a database of real estate transactions and birth records. Let alone modest charitable contributions or fluid household composition.

When the IRS audits you, they don’t come with their own evidence beyond the basic income reporting that yes, they could pre-fill into forms. It’s up to you to produce documentation that justifies your filing.

Our tax code is complicated. It relies on voluntary (but potentially audited) reporting and compliance. If you want to argue for a simpler tax code, great, but at the end of the day, either the IRS needs to collect a lot more data or we’re stuck with self-reporting.

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by jedberg on Monday March 03, 2025 @12:05AM (#43238476)
Again, for 80% of filers, none of this matters. They have their one W2 and take the standard deduction. The only thing the IRS needs to know is what's on the W2 and their marriage status, which they absolutely do have because if you get the marriage status wrong they send you a letter (and it's a matter of public record anyway).

So for 80% of people, they would never have to fill out a tax form at all. They could just get the tax bill and have it auto-pay (or more likely auto-refund).

And for the next 10% of people, who only take a small set of deductions that you can take on top of the standard deduction, you don't need even a two page form, you just need a wizard that asks a few questions like TurboTax.

And then for the rest they can opt to fill out the regular forms if they don't agree with how the IRS calculated their bill. This is how it works in pretty much every other civilized country (and a lot of uncivilized ones too).

Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by cragfar on Monday March 03, 2025 @09:22AM (#43242002)
You're missing that those 80% are not the same people every year. The IRS definitely doesn't keep a database of who is married or not, nor are they scouring every counties database for changes. I'm not sure where you're getting the "they will just send you a letter" part.
Re:GSA Eliminates 18F by johnnyanmac on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @03:05PM (#43259308)
Sounds fine to me. Sometimes you have a simple W-2. Sometimes you need to report life changes. "Efficiency" means those 20% figure it out when they have to.