News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by qwertox on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:24PM (#42976439)
> At the heart of this case was the enforcement of a new legal provision under the DSA: the right to access research data (Article 40(12) DSA). This provision requires large online platforms to provide researchers with immediate access to publicly available data on their platforms in order to assess systemic risks. The lawsuit has also helped clarify open legal questions regarding the judicial enforceability of this right in Germany. [0]

Why would anyone living in a democracy be against this?

Also, maybe this linked article would be a better one that the one from Reuters.

[0] https://democracy-reporting.org/en/office/EU/news/court-orde...

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by topspin on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:49PM (#42977326)
> Why would anyone living in a democracy be against this?

Because the language I'm reading here doesn't mean anything.

"Researcher" can mean anything. In the US we see DOGE people rifling through government finance records, pipelining the data to the executive, for targeting of specific political interests. "Research" means whatever the present democratically elected regime wants it to mean.

"Systemic risk" can mean anything. Last month in the US, millions of "undocumented" people were walking around relatively unconcerned. This month they're all a "systemic risk" and being actively hunted down for deportation or worse.

Maybe tomorrow you become a "systemic risk," and whomever is in elected office at that time designates and funds some academics to "research" all your X/Facebook/Mastodon/whatever activity. There is a non-zero possibility in Germany that AfD will one day get to designate what "research" means and what the "systemic risks" are. How does that sound?

So it's not the least bit difficult to understand why members of a supposed democracy might think this isn't a power "researchers" should have. It's only a problem for the naïve, who suppose the future is governed by only the right people.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by Hasu on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:06PM (#42977474)
The data is publicly available. Researchers could get it by scraping, this law says that companies must provide more convenient ways to access that public data.

This has fuck all to do with government overreach or access to private data.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by 8338550bff96 on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:40PM (#42977785)
How convenient does the law say that it has to be?
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by cmdli on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:04PM (#42978024)
I don't know. Perhaps you could research it to found out?
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by SuperNinKenDo on Saturday February 08, 2025 @12:35AM (#42980677)
I dunno. There's an argument to be made that information which one could obtain piecemeal being made easily accessible at mass scale can create a qualitatively different situation to one in which significant labor is required to acquire it.

It's not a perfect analogy, but we can consider the case of recording in public being legal and the majority of people feeling this is reasonable, versus people's gradient of unease with uniquitous CCTV surveillance, versus how people would feel if the government made sure a law that all CCTV cameras are made remotely accessible at all times.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by refurb on Saturday February 08, 2025 @04:22AM (#42981683)
> The data is publicly available. Researchers could get it by scraping, this law says that companies must provide more convenient ways to access that public data.

So if I run a large online shop I need to provide an API so anyone can download all of my product descriptions and prices?

If I publish an online magazine, I need to provide an API so anyone can download all the content I produce?

At first pass this sounds like a law a "well intentioned" bureaucrat came up with that is just one more law to throw on top of the pile of laws that add costs to running a business. Not to mention the potential threat it might pose to some business models that are susceptible to scraping and copying.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by llamaimperative on Saturday February 08, 2025 @07:06AM (#42982386)
At first pass this comment sounds like a critique a “cynical and lazy” internet commentator wrote under willful ignorance of facts like the underlying law only applying to platforms with 45 million monthly active users in the EU.

When you come across something that makes it seem like everyone else has lost their mind, a 30 second Google search might help.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by olivierduval on Saturday February 08, 2025 @11:18AM (#42983973)
The OP mentioned: "This provision requires large online platforms to provide researchers with immediate access to publicly available data on their platforms in order to assess systemic risks"

> So if I run a large online shop I need to provide an API so anyone can download all of my product descriptions and prices?

> If I publish an online magazine, I need to provide an API so anyone can download all the content I produce?

How is your online shop a "systemic risk" ? Moreover "large online platforms" is a clearly defined term... not your usual website

So please: keep cool... We, Europeans, are not always stupid bureaucracy lovers. Sometimes we also have good ideas to try to preserve our shared freedom and rights and democracy :-)

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by yodsanklai on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:06PM (#42977478)
We're talking about publicly available data. If Elon has access to this data, I'd argue that giving it access to German research, and even AfD which Musk supports, won't make it any worse.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by vkou on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:54PM (#42979943)
> There is a non-zero possibility in Germany that AfD will one day get to designate what "research" means and what the "systemic risks" are. How does that sound?

I think if they'll ever be in a position to do that, they won't give two figs about prior norms and reticence and all this pearl clutching.

Observe the means through which a 49.8% mandate is doing just that in the US.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by implmntatio on Friday February 07, 2025 @11:41PM (#42980431)
As much as I would like to and as easy as it is to agree with you, it's about the public data, not the researcher or research.

And systemic risk doesn't mean anything. It means what you continue to describe: context.

> a power "researchers" should have.

Again. It's about public data. Nobody can or would prohibit counting cars or pedestrians and nobody would try to make it harder than it already is. This applies to platforms like Twitter as well.

> It's only a problem for the the naïve, who suppose the future is governed by only the right people.

The naïve suppose that exactly those people will govern who want the job, which, judging from their experience, are neither engineers, nor hackers, coders, scientists or scientifically literate people and definitely nobody who was ever concerned with their own education.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by s1mplicissimus on Saturday February 08, 2025 @10:29AM (#42983561)
> are neither engineers, nor hackers, coders, scientists or scientifically literate people and definitely nobody who was ever concerned with their own education

I agree chucklingly that the statistical overrepresentation of lawyers in parliaments fits this assessment pretty well

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by tmaly on Saturday February 08, 2025 @10:10AM (#42983428)
Could they use this to get at X data to train LLMs?
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by niemandhier on Saturday February 08, 2025 @06:15PM (#42987041)
All the words you deemed imprecise are explicitly defined at length in the relevant act.

Including a multistep application precess to be recognized as a vetted researcher.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by ethbr1 on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:46PM (#42977290)
> systemic risks

Is the key phrase here.

Good to see the EU recognizing there are innocuous things that when scaled to X- or Facebook- size produce systemic risks.

And if you want to be a platform that large, well, you owe additional societal responsibilities that your smaller competitors don't have to worry about (yet).

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by shawnz on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:32PM (#42976532)
One possible counterargument is that bad actors could use the data to improve their spamming or astroturfing methods.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by Hasu on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:07PM (#42977487)
It's public data already.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by shawnz on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:42PM (#42977810)
But it's behind certain controls such as rate limits and other anti-abuse techniques, hence the researchers' difficulty, right?
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by pyrale on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:04PM (#42977458)
They bought the place already.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by layer8 on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:06PM (#42976859)
Security by obscurity?
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by shawnz on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:52PM (#42977353)
Not exactly: in the security space, we have better tools available than obscurity. But in the spam/abuse prevention space, obscurity is the best you can do.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by philjohn on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:23PM (#42977050)
I mean ... have you been on X recently? The bad actors don't need any help.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by chihuahua on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:30PM (#42977125)
I think Elon is still working hard to get rid of the bots, just like OJ spent years looking for the real killer.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:44PM (#42977268)
He said he'd fix the bot problem. The bots were Elon shills and the problem was that Twitter kept removing them.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by jajko on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:13PM (#42976935)
Counterargument it is, but its pretty weak considering benefits to free society
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by shawnz on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:25PM (#42977646)
I agree that this seems like a net positive to me overall.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by oneplane on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:23PM (#42977035)
If that is the case, having researchers perform analysis makes it possible to identify that risk and that is yet another reason to make sure that public data is not obscured.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by BrenBarn on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:36PM (#42977197)
> Why would anyone living in a democracy be against this?

It seems a sizable number of people living in democracies would rather be living in non-democracies.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by easytiger on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:26PM (#42976468)
Why would anyone in a democracy accept the government has any right to data owned by a private company without court order and limited scope?
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by cmdli on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:58PM (#42976787)
Researchers have exactly the same right to this data as X has to accessing the German market. If they want to make money, they play by the rules chosen by the people of that country. They are free to not sell their services if they don't like the deal offered.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by easytiger on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:50AM (#42988982)
Which researchers, and why do they have such a "right"?
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by oneplane on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:23PM (#42977044)
Because that is what is democratically voted for? If the people (or the representatives they voted for) say that society having access to that data is what society wants, then the company can either provide that data, or have it taken from them.

There should not be a scenario where a company "beats" society.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by jisnsm on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:05PM (#42977470)
Let’s not pretend anybody voted directly for this or was even aware of this law when they cast their vote.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by wkat4242 on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:15PM (#42977570)
No but we vote for people to do that on our behalf.

And X is not just any company, it has high influence potential on society

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by computerthings on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:28PM (#42977679)
It's Americans having an issue with this, not Germans.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by oneplane on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:02PM (#42978010)
DSA and DMA is widely known, but perhaps not by their acronyms or every individual rule.

I don't know in what country you live, but this was not exactly some hidden issue, in almost all member states this was a local issue and had local news coverage as well.

The only way someone would not have been aware is if they spent none of their time on any local or global reports. But in those cases, everything is going to be something they are unaware of and we'd be talking about people who are essentially disconnecting themselves from society. Everyone else would have heard about it multiple times since even local elections made a point of mentioning it, and election turnout is high, even if you don't participate yourself for some reason, it would be really hard to not have talked to anyone who did.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by izacus on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:23PM (#42978201)
DMA is very popular among EU voters.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by easytiger on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:14PM (#42977550)
Why does a society, and let's face it, we know for whom this data access is intended and it is not "society", have access to data I do not wish them to have?

Should the government be entitled to a copy of every message you ever send or receive? Why?

This attitude explains a lot about the total death of liberty in Europe.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by oneplane on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:48PM (#42977888)
You're mixing a whole lot of things in a big ball of mud here, with a lot of half-truths and assumptions. Are you doing that on purpose?

This is not about data that is private, it's not a 'copy of your private data against your wishes', it's research access to public data that has impact on civil society due to the outsized impact on daily life some multinationals have.

As for 'liberty': corporations are not people, if anything, society should be free to not have commercial meddling involved in their life. As with everything else there is a gradient here, it's not some extreme choice there either everything is allowed or nothing is allowed. But messing with society is something that is worth preventing, intentional or not. It takes data and research to do that. In most cases, public data, and that is what this is about.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by easytiger on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:56AM (#42989011)
Which half truths?

Define public data.

Which researchers will have access? Who decides upon them and what is their specific objective? Can I have access to it for my research?

> commercial meddling

What do you mean by this? Who is meddling and with what?

The user of social media has a personal engagement with that company. I don't think a government should be involved in that relationship. Why do you think it should?

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by ensignavenger on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:37PM (#42977750)
Almost all of the countries we label as "democracies" have constitutions, and many of those constitutions limit what can be "democratically voted for". In the United States, the constitution has strict limits on ceaseing private property. That does not mean the US is not "democratic" by common usage of the term. Those living in democracies that thus protect private property rights may find laws that encroach on those private property rights odd, and be against them. Even in a country that has no such protections, one may be against such laws.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by oneplane on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:55PM (#42977945)
We are aware of the problems the US has. But the question "Why would anyone in a democracy accept" is easily answered, and as such I did.

As for the statements on encroachment or protections: this is about public data, not about private data or secrets.

The argument made in court is about research facilities due to the outsized impact X can make. You want to play in someone else's country, you'll have to follow their rules. This works the other way around as well, if a German company were to host their data in the US, they would have to accept that the government can snoop on that data whenever they want since the US does not protect German citizens. (and as such, privacy laws in Germany and in the EU since around 1995 do not allow private data to be transferred by default)

Something more countries might want to do is protect citizens from large corporations. They are not your friends.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by ensignavenger on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:37PM (#42979531)
Okay, I can see your point. I thought this was under the question "Why would anyone living in a democracy be against this?" but I see now it was a response to the other question that was response to that question.

It seems like that phrase "democracy" means different things to different people, depending on where they are from.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by mmooss on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:29PM (#42976506)
> government has any right to data owned by a private company

Another way to look at it is that the people have a right to the data.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by easytiger on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:14PM (#42977555)
So the people have a right to have access to other individuals personal data?
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by astrange on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:17PM (#42979740)
Sometimes so, tax records are public in some European countries.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by moralestapia on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:12PM (#42976922)
No, each person has a right to their own data. But not "the people", it is the opposite actually.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by lxgr on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:31PM (#42977144)
That entirely depends on local laws. I don't see why it shouldn't be possible for a democracy to pass a law granting such rights.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by moralestapia on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:24PM (#42979790)
Would you be happy if anyone could see all you do on social media?
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by wang_li on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:11PM (#42976920)
To the extent we’re talking about user activity on the site, the people already have access to this data by dint of being the ones who did the things. Sent a tweet, viewed a tweet, clicked a link. They already have it. So what is being asked of X?
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by atlantic on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:35PM (#42976567)
"The people". There's an interesting abstraction. Slogans aside, what does "the people" mean?
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by ok_dad on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:45PM (#42976672)
Don't do that, try and redirect the discussion using some dumb definition/semantics argument. This data is public data on posts that X locks behind a wall in order to force sign-ups and ad views. You and I both know the colloquial definition for "the people", it's literally the electorate of the state in question, in this case all the German citizens who are able to vote for the polticians who passed this public access law. This isn't the government trying to pry private company secrets from poor, downtrodden corporations, it's the government passing a law that public data from social media needs to be easy to access for researchers.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by bloopernova on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:57PM (#42976781)
thank you

The more people that call out derail and divide attempts, the better this site gets.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by ok_dad on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:34PM (#42977177)
> The more people that call out

People, in general, need to stop being such fucking wusses about calling out bad behavior, as proven in DC right now. Thanks for the support.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by standyro on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:20PM (#42977013)
unfortunately this site is just as prone to thought bubbles, media bias, and disinformation campaigns, just like X...
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by easytiger on Friday February 07, 2025 @04:16PM (#42977576)
It's data the user has agreed to share with the company at agreement with their terms. The data is not public if it is not made public. If it was, they wouldn't need to compel them to hand it over.

Who are the researchers and what thesis are they exploring?

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by trinsic2 on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:11PM (#42976912)
Moreover. Companies operate by Charter, via the will of the people (and the people is you or us). And regardless of any agreements companies have with shareholders, first and foremost, you have a responsibility to the people you live and operate with, to act for the peoples interests, otherwise you don't have a right to exist, contrary to the lack of action in law on this.

A Charter is a grant, from the people, for any for-profit organization to exist, it comes with certain restrictions and it can be revoked at any time.

Charter

a written grant by a country's legislative or sovereign power [The People], by which a body such as a company, college, or city is founded and its rights and privileges defined.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by ok_dad on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:35PM (#42977188)
YES! Corporations are FOR THE PEOPLE! Currently, the tail is wagging the dog.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by trinsic2 on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:40PM (#42977242)
As I said, the law is not being respected, but it doesn't invalidate the law.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by caminante on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:08PM (#42976883)
I didn't see it as redirection.

Per @Qwertox who parented this thread with useful context, it doesn't sound like "open to all" access. That's material.

E: Here's the quote:

> This provision requires large online platforms to provide researchers with immediate access to publicly available data

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by ok_dad on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:37PM (#42977200)
> The GFF and Democracy Reporting International had argued that X had a duty under European law to provide easily researchable, collated access to information such as post reach, shares and likes - information theoretically available by laboriously clicking through thousands of posts but in practice impossible to access.

Read the last half of that. The court agrees.

> information theoretically available by laboriously clicking through thousands of posts

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by caminante on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:50PM (#42977329)
Did you intend to provide a different quote?

Subject to confirmation, "researcher" != "all of the people."

That was @atlantic's point.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by ok_dad on Friday February 07, 2025 @05:27PM (#42978238)
Great, so we all agree that according to the German law, researchers have access to this data, so there is no need to argue about it! I would personally go so far as to say "the people" at large should also have access to the data, so that no one can weaponize the definition of "researcher" or "the people" (which is prone to happen, as evidenced here), but luckily that's not the conversation we're having today, in this case the law is very clear and the German courts agreed so. Also, the GP post by that individual had no point, it was ostensibly a question, but in the article they covered that in this case, according to the law and German courts, "the people" means "researchers", so they either didn't read the article or were redirecting for other reasons. I just wasn't going to play around with their "definitionalism" where definitions of simple things are the most important talking point in order to off-track a discussion.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by caminante on Friday February 07, 2025 @06:08PM (#42978562)
> but in the article they covered that in this case, according to the law and German courts, "the people" means "researchers",

From my review [1] [2], it appears that "researchers" is undefined.

Ultimately, can anyone apply for full access for free? I'm sure a lot of people across the political spectrum are curious about this.

If you have a clarification, great. If not, the point stands. X already has a firehose API solution [3]. While it's pay to access, it's unclear what compliance steps these researchers will have to jump through or whether anyone can just override this revenue stream for X and force it to turn over proprietary data that would otherwise be paywalled.

[1] https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/german-civil-activists-...

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42976439

[3] https://mashable.com/article/twitter-elon-musk-paid-enterpri...

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by qwertox on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:39PM (#42976609)
Researches get access, they then publish their studies. The press picks up on these studies and interprets them for "the people", unless "the people" want to read the studies by themselves.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by qwertox on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:28PM (#42976498)
The scope is limited to electoral debates. It's in the interest of the citizens.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by dmix on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:44PM (#42976665)
This is giving random researchers ("including those affiliated with non-profit bodies, organizations, and associations") "unrestricted access to all publicly available data on the platform immediately after elections" as long as they are doing something with some connection to the election? Doesn't sound very limited in scope... just timing. There's tons of nefarious uses for data like that which is why social media APIs usually have limitations on how broad you can go.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by croemer on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:07PM (#42976878)
Twitter gave researches good access. Then came Musk and shut that down. I don't think he did that because he worried about nefarious uses.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by lxgr on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:32PM (#42977155)
> which is why social media APIs usually have limitations on how broad you can go

Without paying, usually.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by layer8 on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:09PM (#42976905)
This law is not about arbitrary companies, but about large social networks affecting millions of people. Requiring a certain transparency from these seems justified.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by mindslight on Friday February 07, 2025 @03:33PM (#42977174)
There are vanishingly few private companies of significant size. For example in the US most businesses with more than a few owners are government chartered corporations, LLCs, and the like. This gets them government granted liability shields, and so it makes sense for them to be more heavily regulated to prevent causing foreseeable harm that they might otherwise escape responsibility for.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by singleshot_ on Friday February 07, 2025 @06:39PM (#42978774)
Every once in a while, someone posts a revealing insight into exactly why Business Organizations should be taught outside law schools.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by singleshot_ on Friday February 07, 2025 @06:36PM (#42978753)
Is such data owned by the platform in EU?
[dead]
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by closewith on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:55PM (#42976762)
> Last, but probably the main thing that triggers me is that it "requires" somebody do some work for free. Why the fuck any company or person must do any work, that it doesn't deem necessary, to satisfy the curiosity of some "researchers"?

In democratic countries, there are many instances where you are required to do work for free to remain in business. You have to maintain accounts, records, licenses, authorisations, inspections, etc, depending on your business. This is a necessary part of engaging with the State in which you operate.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by drysine on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:50PM (#42976714)
>If it's publicly available, you don't need to provide any access to it, it's available.

The data may be publicly available, but there may be anti-scraping measures.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by zimpenfish on Friday February 07, 2025 @02:57PM (#42976774)
> What is a large online platform?

The text actually says "very large online platform" which is defined in 33(1):

> This Section shall apply to online platforms and online search engines which have a number of average monthly active recipients of the service in the Union equal to or higher than 45 million, and which are designated as very large online platforms or very large online search engines pursuant to paragraph 4.

Paragraph 4 just reiterates that. Paragraph 3 gives scope for adjustment:

> In such a case, it shall adjust the number so that it corresponds to 10 % of the Union’s population in the year in which it adopts the delegated act, rounded up or down to allow the number to be expressed in millions.

Basically "very large" -> 10% of the EU population. I'm not a lawyer, though; there may well be specific legal shenanigans going on but at first blush, it doesn't look like it.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by ekianjo on Friday February 07, 2025 @08:58PM (#42979648)
> Why would anyone living in a democracy be against this?

In normal democracies searching through records require a court order.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by viraptor on Friday February 07, 2025 @09:03PM (#42979671)
Through private/personal records. This is not the case here.
Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by like_any_other on Friday February 07, 2025 @10:13PM (#42980039)
> Why would anyone living in a democracy be against this?

The limit to "researchers" and "systemic risk" opens the door to cherry-picking the results - use a microscope to find issues when elections don't go your way, turn a blind eye when they do. The law is good (far better than not having it), but should be expanded, making the data available to everyone.

Re:A German court rules: X must provide researchers access t... by floydnoel on Saturday February 08, 2025 @04:26PM (#42986347)
personally i think it is akin to slavery when compelling people to take certain behaviors.

corporations aren't people, but i could see some people applying that argument in this case.