News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by Liquix on Saturday January 18, 2025 @12:06AM (#42746012)
~90% of the plastic debris in the ocean comes from ten rivers [0]. eight are in china/SEA. millions and billions of single-use items are sitting in warehouses and on store shelves wrapped in plastic. even before the plastic is discarded, the factories these items are produced in dump metric tons of waste into the oceans/soil with little repercussion.

point is, none of our "personal lifestyle decisions" - not eating meat, not mining bitcoin, not using chatgpt, not driving cars - are a drop in the bucket compared to standard practice overseas manufacturing.

us privileged folks could "just boycott", "buy renewable", "vote with your wallet", etc, but sales will move to a less developed area and the pollution will continue. this is not to say that the environment isn't important - it's critically important. it's just to say that until corporations are forced to do things the right way, it's ludicrous to point fingers at each other and worry that what we do day-to-day is destroying the planet.

[0] https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs.est.7b02368

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Saturday January 18, 2025 @12:18AM (#42746066)
That's definitely not true. Let's take Americans, for example, driving their cars to work. Americans are about 15% of the world's emissions, of which 25% or so is transportation, of which well over half is cars. So you not driving to work is making direct impact on 2-3% of the world's overall emissions. Likewise, your decisions on all the other things, if taken in aggregate, will have a significant impact on overall emissions.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by idle_zealot on Saturday January 18, 2025 @12:47AM (#42746171)
"Driving to work" is hardly a "vote with your wallet" style consumer choice. Our housing, building, and transportation policies have been geared towards encouraging car-dependence for nearly a century. In places with better public transit and bike lanes, people spontaneously choose to use those modes of transport. Just like with companies dumping as much plastic waste/CO2 as they can get away with, this is a policy problem, plain and simple. No amount of pro-environment metal straw campaigns will solve it. At best environmentally-conscious messaging could encourage changes in voting behavior which influence policy. At worst people could be convinced that they're "doing their part" and fail to consider systemic changes.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by hmottestad on Saturday January 18, 2025 @12:59AM (#42746225)
Regular voting is usually what affects things such as the transportation infrastructure in your country or city. It’s a slow proceed though.

Here in Oslo there has been a lot of investment in bike lanes, but just because one part of the local government builds more bike lanes doesn’t mean that other parts of the government will follow suit. Police still doesn’t care about cars illegally blocking the bike lanes. The people ploughing snow see bike lanes as the last thing that should need ploughing, preferably no earlier than 2 weeks after it snowed. A dedicated bike path I use to work is supposed to be ploughed within 2 hours of snow, but it took a week before anything was done and now three weeks later it’s still not to the standard that the government has set.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by sshine on Saturday January 18, 2025 @05:51AM (#42747447)
Speaking of Oslo and bicycles, I just want to add an amazing statistic that surfaced a couple of years ago here on Hacker News:

Oslo has a zero pedestrian and bicycle mortality rate!

https://thecityfix.com/blog/how-oslo-achieved-zero-pedestria...

> In 2015, the political climate and public will in the City of Oslo changed the tone on accepting continued surface transportation fatalities. The mayor, city council and transport division staff all supported a shift in roadway decision-making from car-centric to people-centric. [...]

Neighboring capitals with similar progressive bicycle cultures (Denmark, Sweden) have somewhat low but non-zero mortality rate as Oslo had 6 years ago. So the policies definitely make a change, but it's the consequence of a culture. You won't see American politicians suggesting a ban on cars in big cities.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by hmottestad on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:39PM (#42750808)
We’ve had at least one cyclist killed since that article came out.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by dijit on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:35AM (#42746368)
I would agree with you, but Americans intentionally reinforce car dependence whenever it's discussed.

It's bad enough that even non-US people regurgitate those talking points despite them being significantly less true for them; because they see it so much online.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by TulliusCicero on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:18AM (#42746547)
> I would agree with you, but Americans intentionally reinforce car dependence whenever it's discussed.

They do, because their experience is that transit and biking really do suck and are useless. Which is accurate, for where they've lived.

The problem is that you have to convince people that things could be better, when their lived experience is that it's always terrible.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by Fricken on Saturday January 18, 2025 @03:32AM (#42746814)
I ride a bike, and doing so has saved me about $450k in transportation costs over 3 decades. The effort it takes to earn $450k is something to include amongst the unpleasantries and pathologies associated with driving.

Now, of course, I've had my whole life to set up my whole life the way I want it, and with a little foresight it really wasn't that difficult to set it up in a way that facilitates getting around on a bicycle. It involved making choices. Choices about where to work and live. If more people made such choices, there would be more options available to facilitate them.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by ben_w on Saturday January 18, 2025 @03:48AM (#42746867)
450k tax-free, too, because it's a cost saving and those aren't taxable*.

Myself I've not driven at least since late 2017, thanks to excellent and cheap public transport; even before the Germany-wide €58/month ticket, the more expensive Berlin-AB ticket that I used to get was much much less than your $15k/year.

Do most people plan like that?

* usually, though IIRC buying a house in Switzerland gets you a tax equal to the money you saved from not renting it?

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by agentultra on Saturday January 18, 2025 @09:51AM (#42748770)
We also have a carbon tax where I’m from. Since I don’t own a car I don’t pay much into it. However I get a nice big rebate on my tax return. I basically get paid a small amount to not own a car.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by TulliusCicero on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:31PM (#42750747)
I've ridden bikes for transportation in a handful of regions in the US. It is essentially always bad, it's just a matter of some people being able to look past or tolerate the awfulness.

Yes, some people are okay sharing a lane with cars, or using a strip of paint for protection, but accepting a poor status quo doesn't stop the status quo from being poor.

Occasionally there's a route that's legitimately good, almost always due to having an off street trail you can use for the bulk of the commute. Those can be great.

But once you hit bike lanes in an urban area, it's virtually always terrible. A lot of Americans are just used to the terribleness and don't notice it anymore, the same way they don't notice how almost every neighborhood is designed to be unwalkable (and how most are designed to be economically segregated besides).

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by lugu on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:47AM (#42746641)
I live in place known for its rainy weather, 15 km from work (because of the housing crisis). Being overweight, biking to work never crossed my mind for two years. Once I tried to commute during weekend, as a challenge. I realized a few things: - same duration as the train - it give me the exercise I needed - it relaxes me - it is free since I already have a bike

Yes, it still take me 50 min to commute, but now I enjoy it and even volunteerly go to the office more often. It have been 6 months.

My point is: those who complain about biking being terrible or impractical should give it a real try. It may fit you.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by AstralStorm on Saturday January 18, 2025 @04:25AM (#42747026)
And if you need help and can afford it, ebikes exist. Some of them really cheap. Hopefully not skimping on safeties though.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by TulliusCicero on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:38PM (#42750794)
Ebikes are really great and I often ride one to work. They do help with speed, range, motivation, and of course, hills.

They don't do anything about unsafe infrastructure though, which is by far the US' biggest problem for biking. To say that American bike infrastructure is garbage tier is an insult to garbage, that's how bad it typically is. It's extremely unsafe, and people can feel it, they can tell, hence why hardly anyone actually bikes to work.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by TulliusCicero on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:26PM (#42750722)
I've biked around in a bunch places in the US, and the reality is that it really is terrible. Bike infrastructure is F-tier almost everywhere, rising to D-Tier in supposedly bike friendly cities like Portland.

Bike infrastructure generally

* Is designed to be unsafe. Door zones are common, actual physical protection or segregation is rare, ESPECIALLY for intersections.

* Stops and starts randomly. Just look at Google maps for a city, you'll be able to see that the bike network is completely fragmented, with many bike lane suddenly disappearing on a road for no apparent reason.

* Randomly changes style/design principles even within the same city, so both you and drivers are constantly confused unless you're already used to a route.

* Is poorly enforced, with drivers routinely driving or parking in bike lanes with punishment being a rarity.

Now, some spots have good bike trails that work for their commute, and that's a great option when it's available. But I'm a bit tired of the "biking is actually okay in the US!" gaslighting.

Some people still manage, I do sometimes, but after getting hit by cars a couple times I tired of making excuses for it. There's a reason hardly anyone bikes for their commute in the states: overall, biking in the US is simply awful, and that's the truth.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by ben_w on Saturday January 18, 2025 @03:37AM (#42746834)
> The problem is that you have to convince people that things could be better, when their lived experience is that it's always terrible.

Ironically, international air travel to places where it works great may help with this.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by TulliusCicero on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:28PM (#42750736)
For some people yes.

But a lot of people are mentally stubborn, and seem to have inbuilt excuses of, "it wouldn't work here!" despite not spending even ten seconds thinking about it.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:37AM (#42746370)
See, my point is that everyone first goes “it’s not me”, then they understand it is them and go “but it’s not my policies” and then they vote in the policies which are the problem. It’s totally fine to go “we need collective action to fix this”. But you have to actually join the collective action. You think billionaires are getting rich by committing environmental arbitrage? Then don’t oppose attempts to make the costs appropriate, even if you must now pay your fair share too.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by idle_zealot on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:42AM (#42746392)
Sure, recognizing that the problem is political is step one. Step two is... political activism, I guess? Lack of local political engagement and organizing is part of what allows problems like these to form.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:59AM (#42746466)
Not just lack but outright apathy and villainizing of these attempts. If you try to tax gas some oil CEO will run a campaign explaining to the working class that their commute will now cost 10% more, which obviously makes people upset. Part of it is that we, unfortunately, can’t actually subsidize car commuters anymore. But part of it is that CEO is going to incur a cost of 50%, as he should, which is why he’s bothering to spend money riling people up.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by derangedHorse on Saturday January 18, 2025 @07:27AM (#42747860)
It is not feasible to take a bike or public transportation to work in many parts of the world so a policy change like that would just incur an additional cost to those who have no alternative.

A better idea is to encourage other types of transportation in private companies rather than penalize existing companies with taxes. If taxing the companies will raise prices on consumers, you might as well consider it an additional tax on the people.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by Forbo on Saturday January 18, 2025 @09:10AM (#42748434)
Redistribute the tax back to the people. That way you're eliminating the price externality but offsetting the cost to individuals. The fossil fuel industry can't continue to plug their ears and ignore the costs associated with putting more and more carbon in the atmosphere. We need to hold them to account.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Thursday January 23, 2025 @08:53AM (#42804014)
The point is that you make the other alternatives affordable with such a fee. You can take the tax and put it directly into improving that infrastructure.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by irishloop on Saturday January 18, 2025 @12:28AM (#42746102)
Meat and dairy specifically accounts for around 14.5% of global greenhouse gas emissions, according to the UN’s Food and Agricultural Organization (FAO).

If people collectively just ate a bit less meat and dairy, it would go a long way. Don't even have to be perfect. Just show a little bit of restraint.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by throwaway314155 on Saturday January 18, 2025 @12:41AM (#42746151)
Right just a little bit of restraint. On an unprecedented scale of coordination by hundreds of millions to billions of people - a scale of cooperation that has probably never occurred in human history (and there's no reason to believe it will any time soon).

But sure, if people "just" did a "little", it would go a long way. Just a _little_ restraint from the entire population all at once in perpetuity. No big deal.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by RHSeeger on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:24AM (#42746320)
- Ozone

- Efficient Lighting (LEDs now, but others before)

- Santa Claus

There are certainly examples of a large portion of the population of the planet working together towards common goals. A lot of people putting in a little bit of effort _does_ happen, and it _does_ produce results.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by somenameforme on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:09AM (#42746508)
There was a profit motive in all of those except Santa. For instance until the main players in CFCs (which were the main cause of ozone depletion) were able to invent, patent, and market an alternative to CFCs they successfully lobbied against any change. Then they got a new patent, turned 180 degrees, claiming CFCs were the worst thing to ever exist - and made a ton of money after they were banned. Same thing with stuff like asthma inhalers.

When people want to do something, we're unstoppable. But unfortunately that means the good and the bad, and right now polluting actions are incredibly beneficial, and the alternatives are mediocre and not only unprofitable, but generally incur a substantial cost. There's a reason places like the US/Canada/Australia talk a mean game about climate change, yet remain some of the biggest polluters per capita, by far.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:13AM (#42746531)
Uh, Santa is the biggest advertising campaign for consumerism the world has ever known
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by aziaziazi on Saturday January 18, 2025 @06:46AM (#42747686)
I agree with you and that’s why I’m believe soy will conquer the humans nutrition sooner or later. It already is the undisputed king of world-scale animal nutrition because it’s cheap and super nutritious. The drawbacks in Brasil happens because of its success, replace by another crop and the problems will be even worse.

Replace animals proteins for humans by soy for human and you can divide world soy production by ~5.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by ido on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:33AM (#42746361)
Smoking, drinking - both on the decline for the last decades.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by extra88 on Saturday January 18, 2025 @10:24AM (#42749014)
Improvement of the ozone hole wasn't from millions of consumers making different choices, it was from government regulation and choices of the few leading corporations in particular industries.

Efficient lighting is a mix of regulation against worse lighting and individual consumer economic self-interest, lowering their electrical bill (and sometimes longer-lasting bulbs).

Neither of these are examples of large numbers of people choosing to sacrifice something for a common goal.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by jhanschoo on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:04AM (#42746247)
There are mechanisms for such coordination. Diets have shifted around the world to more McD's, more western cuisine. Wild catch changes all the time as we overfish stocks to endangerment.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by sadeshmukh on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:09AM (#42746270)
Always driven by money. McD's is cheaper and easier to mass produce. Wild catch changes when it is no longer economical to fish one kind of fish. There's never an "enlightenment" of people.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by jhanschoo on Saturday January 18, 2025 @11:58AM (#42749641)
Internationally in markets undistorted by meat subsidies, plant-based food is cheaper and easier to mass produce...
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by sofixa on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:59AM (#42746673)
Yes, a big multi government marketing campaign "Just don't eat meat 1 or 2 days a week" can definitely work. E.g. friday is "Fish day" in a lot of places (education/public) due to Catholic church influences.

Just need a catchy word and campaign for "Veggie Wednesday".

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by Forbo on Saturday January 18, 2025 @08:49AM (#42748286)
Meatless Mondays are a thing.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by bitwize on Saturday January 18, 2025 @12:44AM (#42746163)
You do this through the government. Implement meat rations. Everybody is only allowed so much meat per week. So you have to make it count.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:39AM (#42746381)
Vegetarian here. People who eat meat tend to reduce their consumption if you 1. charge them appropriately for it and 2. give them good alternatives. Telling them to not do something usually makes them angry unfortunately.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by smcin on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:56AM (#42746453)
How effective IYO was Morgan Spurlock (RIP) the activist filmmaker ("Supersize Me", [0]) at trying to educate the general (meat-eating) US public on US meat production, the restaurant industry, nutrition, marketing?

(PS:it's not a dichotomy between strict vegetarianism vs meat 4+ days/wk. Can encourage people to eat healthier and more sustainable.)

[0]: https://www.imdb.com/name/nm1041597/

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:20AM (#42746557)
I mean I’m not an expert but I think the general sentiment among Americans about meat is “yeah I hear meat production is gross/polluting/inhumane but I like meat and don’t want to think about that”. Charitably I think we have a lot of things we can care about and most people want to ignore this, plus there’s a lot of cultural baggage tied to diet people don’t want to leave. I think actual solutions will mostly involve the idea that reduction is good instead of throwing up your hands because you’re unable to commit to being vegan, and adding options to people’s diet that they actually enjoy. I think we have a very hard time solving “I can’t completely solve this and also it requires changes I don’t like so doing nothing at all is fine”.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by ibejoeb on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:43AM (#42746634)
He didn't try to educate. He sensationalized for profit. Supersize Me was a grift. He drank himself fat and fabricated his numbers.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by smcin on Sunday January 19, 2025 @04:50AM (#42755582)
Can't just dismiss his 17 films as a grift. Even accepting all the valid criticisms where he misled audiences, his shockumentaries did try to educate, somewhat, but also stretched facts and went for a personalized narrative, Michael-Moore-style. He did leave a legacy of nearly single-handedly reviving documentary as a film genre relevant to nutrition, one that mainstream audiences would watch.

His sequel "Super Size Me 2: Holy Chicken!" (2017) had fewer distortions and was pretty watchable and educational. Here's a review from https://www.agdaily.com/livestock/poultry/super-size-me-2-mo... which among other things covered in depth: "Many food labels, such as organic, natural, non-GMO, gluten-free, no added hormones, free range, green, artisan, antibiotic-free, are indeed quite misleading" and how those branding terms are misused in marketing to restaurant customers. I haven't seen any industry criticism of the segment with the two branding consultants.

As to the legacy of "Super Size Me", here's a review by an ag evangelist: https://www.eater.com/24173039/morgan-spurlock-legacy-super-...

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by maeil on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:46AM (#42746407)
> Telling them to not do something usually makes them angry unfortunately

Then it's up to you to get even angrier.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:52AM (#42746435)
Angry people are spiteful. I generally find it a lot more productive to get them to understand why their choices have consequences, how the can (progressively!) fix the problems, and watch things improve from there.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by maeil on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:57AM (#42746457)
Environmentalists and those championing similar causes politically have taken this approach for decades. The result has been a perpetual shift to the right-wing who has no qualms about playing dirty, using fear, anger and other tribal emotions to gain support. Everywhere in the West, authoritarians are seizing power.

Good luck with continuing the virtuous approach while the world goes up in flames. It hasn't worked and has gotten us to where we are right now.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:03AM (#42746479)
I think people should be angry about that, yes. I’m not particularly interested in tying eating meat to racism or whatever it takes to make people fearful enough to support you.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by maeil on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:07AM (#42746496)
And this is why everything will keep going up in flames - you're not interested in doing what it has been shown to take to get people to support your cause.

Unfortunately it doesn't matter what we think people should be angry about. FWIW I obviously completely agree with you! People should be angry about those things! Turns out they aren't. What matters is the reality we live in.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by johnthewise on Saturday January 18, 2025 @03:59AM (#42746895)
I'd say accusing people of random stuff(racism,sexism and other isms) have been so overplayed in recent years, not only it doesn't work anymore, it works against you.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by maeil on Sunday January 19, 2025 @10:28PM (#42764688)
In the US, what Trump is doing is working. In the EU, what the authoritarian far-right parties are doing is working. Their tactics have been working incredibly well for them, use them, the inane pacifist take of "being above that" by environmentalists and progressives in general is what has caused them to be completely irrelevant and the rise of authoritarianism across the West.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Thursday January 23, 2025 @08:55AM (#42804027)
I mean Hitler clearly did something right in getting elected. I'm not sure we want to emulate his policies, though.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by anonzzzies on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:51AM (#42746433)
People, especially men, get irrationally angry by even the slightest thought of their precious meat being touched (including here on HN; there are more than a few crackpots over here who promote a meat only or even red meat only diet). If there would be a reason to violently overthrow the gov, this would probably be it; not for the things that actually matter to better or save humanity, but to save their daily meat platter.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by jchw on Saturday January 18, 2025 @12:46AM (#42746169)
I think this might be the first idea I've ever heard that I truly feel will backfire far worse than alcohol prohibition. I almost want to see it happen.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by VSerge on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:33AM (#42746359)
All families can't afford meat daily, let alone any type of meat they want. So, some families might favor chicken and certain processed meats here and there, but most cuts of beef and lamb for example might be out of the question, and so will daily meat consumption. The same applies for dairy, they might afford big blocks of tasteless cheese, but won't touch often cheese with taste, French or otherwise. There is no enforced rationing, but choice is reduced if not removed for a good fraction of the population, purely for economic reasons.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by numpad0 on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:04AM (#42746487)
What's missing from this type of discussions is performance quantification and scientific attitude. It assumes solid food is indulgence and ultraprocessed vegan shakes paired with appropriate willpower is all it takes to do anything.

Things just don't work that way. Been there, done that. Willpower does nothing. Extra calories around your berry is extra calories around your berry. It's much more worthwhile to think about reducing GHG emission from farming than deceiving yourself into self-harming and projecting your own doing onto greater society.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by smcin on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:03AM (#42746483)
The USDA budget totals ~$200bn, of which 70% goes to SNAP (Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program).

Table FNS-1, p58 https://www.usda.gov/sites/default/files/documents/2023-usda...

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by ido on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:30AM (#42746348)
There's less extreme government action possible: tax meat & dairy higher.

There are already precedents for that, for example here in Germany cigarettes are taxed to about 70% and hard-liquor (altho it's more complicated to calculate as it depends on exact alcohol content) to about 40%.

Meat is only taxed at 7% via VAT (similar to sales tax in the US).

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by smcin on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:47AM (#42746415)
Not by rationing, if you meant the US government: US per-capita consumption of meat is 328 lbs/year [UN FAO]. You'd try to reduce the subsidies and incentives for meat/ corn/ soybean production which are baked into the USDA budget ($200bn in 2024), since the 1930s (Great Depression), and more since the 1950s (and related stuff like the marketing tool of the "Food Pyramid"). These will be as politically hard to cancel as defense production or military bases or prisons.

Here's even a 2023 editorial from the Kansas City Star pointing the blame at Big Ag "Corn drives US food policy. But big business, not Midwestern farmers, reaps the reward" [0]:

> No, corn is not an evil crop, nor are farmers in the Corn Belt shady criminals. However, the devastating effect of corn owes to the industrialization of the plant by a small group of global agribusiness and food conglomerates, which acts as a kind of de facto corn cabal. These massive corporations — seed companies, crop and meat processors, commodity traders and household food and beverage brands — all survive on cheap commodity corn, which currently costs about 10 cents a pound. Corn’s versatility makes it the perfect crop to “scale” (commoditize, industrialize and financialize).

A libertarian take is the Cato Institute "Farm Bill Sows Dysfunction for American Agriculture" [1]:

> The Sprawling Farm Bill:... has its roots in the century-old New Deal and is revised by Congress every five years... "Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), was added to the Farm Bill in 1973 to ensure support from rural and urban lawmakers, accounts for about three-quarters of the omnibus package. Some lawmakers and pundits have proposed splitting SNAP from the Farm Bill to stop the logrolling and facilitate a clearer debate on farm subsidy programs, which make up the rest of the bill." ...aslo criticizes crop insurance subsidies (which mainly go on the four big crops), Agriculture Risk Coverage (ARC) and Price Loss Coverage (PLC) ("Welfare for Wealthier Farmers"), Crop insurance subsidies (" originally envisioned as a more stable and cost-efficient alternative to ad hoc disaster payments, but they have acted more as a supplement than a replacement—and may have actually increased risks along the way.")

[0]: https://www.kansascity.com/opinion/readers-opinion/guest-com...

[1]: https://www.cato.org/policy-investigation/farm-bill-sows-dys...

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by hgomersall on Saturday January 18, 2025 @03:41AM (#42746844)
That's an incredible amount of meat. That's 400g a day per person. I can't even eat that much meat in one go without feeling the meal is seriously unbalanced. Half that is a meat heavy meal for me. So that must mean a significant number people are eating huge amounts of meat for every meal. That or the waste is huge.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by smcin on Saturday January 18, 2025 @04:58AM (#42747189)
Yes that stat does make me wonder. Even if 21% of meat is wasted [0]. (Possibly they count "reaches a supermarket shelf" as = "not wasted", even if it isn't ultimately cooked or eaten?). But even then.

([1], the 2023 study by Tulane University supposedly finding "12% Of Americans 1/2 Of The Nation's Beef: How a mere 12% of Americans eat half the nation's beef, creating significant health and environmental impacts" is a red herring, all it says is that on any given day, some fraction of meat-eaters exceed portion sizes ("Those 12%—most likely to be men or people between the ages of 50 and 65—eat what researchers called a disproportionate amount of beef on a given day").

[0]: https://ballardbrief.byu.edu/issue-briefs/food-waste-in-the-...

> "Wasted food ranks as the number one material in US landfills, accounting for 24.1% of all municipal solid waste. Americans waste 21% of meat, 46% of fruit and veg, 35% of seafood, and 17% of dairy products. Altogether, Americans waste between 30% and 40% of the total US food supply."... "Poor packaging techniques causes 10% of grain products, 5% of seafood, and 4% of meat to be lost."

[1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/RedditForGrownups/comments/16cpmni/...

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by echelon on Saturday January 18, 2025 @12:47AM (#42746170)
> Implement meat rations.

I don't think we can ever be friends.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by eastbound on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:02AM (#42746478)
The “just a little” argument will immediately be offset by new inhabitants (whether babies or immigration).

In fact, behaviors have convinced me that the goal of ecologists is not a greener Earth, but an Earth with fewer resources used by whites and more resources for the already-90% population that isn’t white. Green is just a racist ideology.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by c0redump on Saturday January 18, 2025 @03:24AM (#42746780)
Yikes. Is this type of schizoposting allowed on HN?
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by Forbo on Saturday January 18, 2025 @08:59AM (#42748357)
Please don't do that. Schizophrenia is a serious mental illness. Don't further stigmatize it by conflating it with the racist drivel posted above.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by sofixa on Saturday January 18, 2025 @03:31AM (#42746812)
Most ecologists are also anti-natalist, so your premise is wrong.

And if you look at CO2 per capita numbers, the average person in a developed country pollutes tons more, regardless of skin colour: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/co-emissions-per-capita . And there are big outliers too, like Americans, and fossil fuel exporting countries.

And what do you know, most polluters have very low birth rates. Where there are high birth rates, the CO2 emissions are derisory (you need 7 Egyptians or 20 Nigerians to match one American).

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:15AM (#42746537)
Most of the world isn’t white so even if you’re not being upset about white people being oppressed or whatever this just makes sense from an equity perspective.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by Imustaskforhelp on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:24PM (#42750707)
Technically most hindus don't eat meat / maybe eats eggs rarely , So its definitely possible but it would probably have to be ingrained in the religion itself.

Another reason is that we had plenty of land and rice and wheat etc. just made more sense than eating meat I suppose.

I have never tasted meat , eggs sometimes but I am stopping that as well , not for hinduism but because I am so close to this ideal , might as well do it 100% lol

I am majorly convinced that there is no god but if I wish there was a god , I wish for Hindu deities (though I am obviously biased and this explains why people have such biases even being half atheists)

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by mossTechnician on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:29AM (#42746341)
The US government could help by ending subsidies towards meat and dairy production, which will prevent those products from being artificially underpriced.

https://www.ewg.org/news-insights/news/2024/10/usda-livestoc...

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by llmthrow102 on Saturday January 18, 2025 @12:47AM (#42746174)
Greenhouse gas emissions are only a fraction of terrible things that humans are inflicting on the environment, and meat/dairy are both nutritious food that provides requirements for sustenance, and if not eaten need to be replaced by something else that will also cause greenhouse gas emissions (aka, a 10% reduction in meat consumption does not equal to a 1.45% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions)

I think it's kind of crazy to place the burden of environmental destruction on individual buying habits, rather than the people in power who actually have the ability to make sweeping changes that might actually move the needle.

Let's start with not incentivizing, then disincentivizing the mass production and importation of plastic garbage waste and e-waste that not only create greenhouse gas emissions but pollute the environment in other, irreversible ways.

And if your government and leaders don't make this a priority, and regardless of who you vote in, big-name corpo donors get their way instead, then maybe it's time for a new government.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by themk on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:21AM (#42746559)
Meat and dairy are bad for GHG, but they are also terrible for most of the other bad things we do to the planet. Eutrophication, species extinction, habitat loss, water use.

And the people in power do what the people want, that's why they are in power. Imagine telling people they couldn't eat as much meat. Would be political suicide.

That's why individual buying habits are important. If many individuals change, we might change as a society. And at some point there might be a tipping point where the people in charge can make a change.

Also, blaming other people for all the problems is not a great way to solve a problem. Take some responsibility.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:42AM (#42746391)
It won’t be 1.45% but it will be 1.3%. Meat is exceptionally inefficient compared to non-meat. It sounds false but it really is like that :(
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by starspangled on Saturday January 18, 2025 @12:57AM (#42746214)
Not encouraging population growth everywhere but particularly in the highest per-capita consuming and polluting countries, but rather allow them to naturally level off and even gradually decline would go a much longer way. It would enable significant emissions reductions and reduction in all other environmental impacts of consumption without impacting quality of life.

Eating bugs and living in pods sounds great and all, but if the end result is just allowing the ruling class to pack more drones and consumers in like sardines then it's not really solving anything.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by TiredOfLife on Saturday January 18, 2025 @03:07AM (#42746711)
Since my birth the population of earth has almost doubled.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by teaearlgraycold on Saturday January 18, 2025 @12:41AM (#42746152)
I was able to cut out 95% of meat without it being much trouble.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by Brystephor on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:19AM (#42746551)
How much of Americans driving to work is because they choose too though? Amazon's 5 day RTO policy is a good example. How many of the people now going to an office 5 days a week would've done so without the mandate? I see the traffic every day, and saw the same area before the mandate, so I can tell you with confidence that there's many more cars on the road as a result of this commute. this all funnels back to the corporate decision to mandate 5 days in office.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by josephcsible on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:24AM (#42746570)
Exactly. IMO, any politician who's serious about saving the environment or reducing the number of cars should be proposing bills to heavily tax employers for every unnecessary commute they require of their employees (maybe $100-$500 per employee per unnecessary day required in the office).
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Thursday January 23, 2025 @09:00AM (#42804073)
Employers are unfortunately very bad at deciding what is "necessary" work.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by netcan on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:21AM (#42746558)
if taken in aggregate, will have a significant impact

This is a good sentiment. But, in context, it is a fallacy. A harmful one.

Consumer action on transport and whatnot, assuming a massive and persistent global awareness effort... has the potential of adding up to a rounding error.

Housing policy, transport policy, urban planning... these are what affects transport emissions. Not individual choices.

Look at our environmental history. Consumer choice has no wins.

It's propaganda. Role reversal. Something for certain organizations to do. It is not an actual effort to achieve environmental benefit.

We should be demanding governments clean up. Governments and NGOs should not be demanding that we clean up.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by jamilton on Saturday January 18, 2025 @03:48AM (#42746868)
The amount of people who choose to not drive to work is significantly impacted by policy.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by fastball on Saturday January 18, 2025 @12:32AM (#42746117)
This assumes all emissions / externalities are created equal, which they are not.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by eru on Saturday January 18, 2025 @12:42AM (#42746156)
You are right. Though for CO2 that simplification comes pretty close to true.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by smcin on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:07AM (#42746498)
Could you say more?

Are you talking about comparing CO2 to N2O to CH4 to fluorocarbons, for example?

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by fastball on Saturday January 18, 2025 @04:02AM (#42746904)
Yes, that. But also that these different externalities will have different responses to reduction at scale, which also impacts how effective action on a more "personal" level really is.

For example the OP was talking about plastic. A 2% reduction in plastic waste has a clear benefit, because any amount of plastic reduction is a bonus. However it is not clear that a 5% reduction in CO2 emissions due to Americans driving their cars less will have any meaningful difference when it comes to climate change.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by smcin on Sunday January 19, 2025 @12:24AM (#42753952)
Still not understanding you, if you meant "a 2% reduction in plastic waste in country A" is of no global benefit if there's a comparable increase in country B (assuming their disposal is roughly equally bad for the environment globally, since only 9% of plastic globally is recycled). So I assume you meant "a 2% reduction in plastic waste, globally". But then the same criticism applies to country-level reduction in CO2 emissions.

Anyway, maybe the second Trump admin will exit the Paris Accord again, putting strain on China and India participating, so climate summits will be weaker till 2029 (earliest).

Likely the domestic economic impact (on the US) of major climate-related events will have more influence on US policy than international. e.g. whether one of the many causal factors to the huge 2025 LA fires was climate change; or California's water setup where Senior Drawing Rights legally predating the existence of the state of CA allow agribusiness essential unlimited water use to grow pistachios in a semidesert during a drought, or bottle and export artesian water. As well as all the other more proximate causes. Anyway, expect a long and politicized fight between state, federal, city and insurers about the LA fire root-causes, liability and federal compensation. Especially given there's a plan to weaken or abolish the US EPA at the same time.

Ditto, expect nation-level debates (in OECD countries) reappraising whether nuclear (alongside fossil-fuel and renewable) is considered safe, desirable and necessary and how that affects/limits GDP growth, and whether datacenters and AI continue to be seen as a proxy for GDP growth, or whether that assumption breaks down some year soon.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by aio2 on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:09AM (#42746271)
The emissions from vehicles are different from plastics produced by factories.

Also, while important, 2-3% of world emissions is a drop in the bucket compared to the other 97%. Let's consider the other causes and how we can fix them.

Think about this: for many people, not driving to work is a big deal. If people collectively decide to do that, that's a lot of effort and inconvenience just for 2-3%.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by ido on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:39AM (#42746376)
while 3% might sound like a drop in the bucket, there isn't any single specific chunk of the rest of the 97% that will immediately cut, say, 30-40% of emissions (also remember that 2-3% is the super specific "Americans not driving cars", not "everyone in the world not driving cars").
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:47AM (#42746412)
There isn’t really a magic wand we can wave and get 50% back for free and without inconvenience. The other 97% involves things like individually figuring out where our electricity generation goes. Or figuring out which farms to shut down, or what manufacturing we don’t like anymore. All of this must happen. It will be inconvenient. I picked a slice that is immediately relevant to a lot of people here. But there are a lot of axes to look at this.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by citrin_ru on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:22AM (#42746564)
I think many Americans driving to work would be happy to work from home if not RTO mandates (encouraged by the government at least on a local level).
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by photonthug on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:25AM (#42746575)
> That's definitely not true. Let's take Americans, for example, driving their cars to work.

Even an example like this that is carefully chosen to make consumers feel/act more responsible falls short. You want people to change their lives/careers to not drive? Ok, but most people already want to work from home, so even the personal “choice” about whether to drive a car is basically stuck like other issues pending government / corporate action, in this case to either improve transit or to divest from expensive commercial real estate. This is really obvious isn’t it?

Grabbing back our feeling of agency should not come at the expense of blaming the public under the ridiculous pretense of “educating” them, because after years of that it just obscures the issues and amounts to misinformation. Fwiw I’m more inclined to agree with admonishing consumers to “use gasoline responsibly!” than say, water usage arguments where cutting my shower in half is supposed to somehow fix decades of irresponsible farming, etc. But after a while, people mistrust the frame itself where consumers are blamed, and so we also need to think carefully about the way we conduct these arguments.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Thursday January 23, 2025 @09:02AM (#42804088)
I didn't really carefully choose this, it was just what I came up. As others have mentioned, meat is another big one. FWIW I have no disagreement with letting people work from home, or pushing for other changes to make them less car-dependent.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by cyberax on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:07AM (#42746493)
> Let's take Americans, for example, driving their cars to work.

This is easily solved by switching to EVs. A small-size EV (perfect for personal transportation) is only slightly less CO2-efficient than rail ( https://ourworldindata.org/travel-carbon-footprint ).

I wish the world would ditch public transit entirely. It's nothing but a misery generator. It's far better to switch to remote work and distributed cities.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:25AM (#42746576)
I unironically like public transport because someone else does the “driving” for me. I’m sure someone is going to explain how Waymo solves this but sitting on a train with my laptop and breakfast while I magically get teleported to my office is much nicer than even being in the back seat of a car.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by cyberax on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:04PM (#42750554)
> I magically get teleported to my office

You work on a train station platform? My condolences.

And indeed, self-driving will solve this. You'll be able to just step into a car, and get teleported to the door of your office. After stopping at your favorite coffee shop midway.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saagarjha on Thursday January 23, 2025 @09:04AM (#42804105)
It doesn't, actually: there is no good place to work in a car. They don't have tables in them, and they accelerate both laterally and in the forward and back directions which makes most people carsick.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by VMG on Saturday January 18, 2025 @03:04AM (#42746698)
Public transit is not miserable everywhere. In Central European countries it can be quite enjoyable.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by petesergeant on Saturday January 18, 2025 @12:44AM (#42746162)
This massively lets the Philippines off the hook. China has a gazillion people, and so does India, and the rest of SE Asia is bad for pollution, but the Philippines — with 1.5% of the world’s population — is an incredible 36% of ocean plastic pollution.

Also a call-out to Malaysia who are an upper-middle income country and contribute far too much per capita given their income situation, but again, they are a drop in the ocean compared to the (much, much poorer) Philippines.

Having spent half my life in South-East Asia, there’s a cultural problem that needs fixing there.

A pretty graph that make it clear just how bad the most egregious polluters are comparatively: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/ocean-plastic-waste-per-c...

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by mnsc on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:16AM (#42746291)
What are they doing in the Philippines? Dumping household waste straight into the rivers?
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by deepsun on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:46AM (#42746410)
I think they are fishing commerially a lot. Most of the ocean trash comes from the fishing industry (e.g. abandoned nets).
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by petesergeant on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:13AM (#42746530)
Pretty much. Buying everything in sachets and then not having any real waste disposal; https://earth.org/philippines-plastic/
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by yodsanklai on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:10AM (#42746280)
> it's just to say that until corporations are forced to do things the right way

But this isn't going to happen by itself. We need to vote for people who believes in regulating these corporations (rather than deregulating them).

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by obeattie on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:24AM (#42746323)
It’s helpful to put this issue into perspective. But dismissing issues as not worth caring about on the grounds that there exist larger problems is fallacious and, to me, quite a dangerous way to live life.

“Why worry about your town’s water quality when some countries don’t have access to clean water?”

“Why go to the dentist for a cavity when some people have no teeth?“

“Why campaign for animal rights when there are some many human rights abuses going on?”

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by eviks on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:24AM (#42746324)
> "vote with your wallet", etc, but sales will move to a less developed area and the pollution will continue.

But voting with your wallet is literally moving sales to a more developed area with less pollution?

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by ternnoburn on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:41AM (#42746388)
Per capita beef consumption is down by 35% in the US since the 70s. From 62kg/person/year to 35.

Beef produces ~100kg CO2 per kg of meat. That's a reduction of 27,000kgs of CO2 reduction, per capita.

That's not nothing. By simply reducing beef consumption by 1 kilogram a month, you can prevent more than a metric ton of CO2. If 5% of Americans cut 1 kilo of beef a month, that'd knock out 15 million tons of CO2.

Small changes can have an impact on aggregate, and just because someone else is not making those changes doesn't excuse us looking at ourselves and saying, "I could choose something else this time".

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by deepsun on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:44AM (#42746403)
And 80% of all the trash in the oceans come from fishing industry (e.g. abandoned nets).
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by maeil on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:48AM (#42746420)
This is nothing but head-in-the-sand, arms-in-the-air, feel-good baloney to convince oneself to sleep well at night.

Guess what happens when you buy a used laptop instead of a new one?

That's right: less "standard practice overseas manufacturing".

Lifestyle change right there.

Buying less, using the same for longer, buying used goods instead of new are lifestyle changes that anyone can make and have an undeniable very clear impact by reducing the amount of stuff that needs to get made. Using my smartphone for 6 years instead of changing every 3 years doesn't mean the one I didn't buy gets sold elsewhere. It means one less sale.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by nameless_me on Saturday January 18, 2025 @01:49AM (#42746424)
I have always felt this way too. Our personal choices do not move the needle on fossil fuel and plastics. One could embrace aversion to these out of a sense of sustainability to signal virtue, but lets not pretend it will save the planet. It won't. Restricting aviation flights, stopping wars and minimizing the dirty fuel used in maritime freight does much more. But the world will not do it.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by kalaksi on Saturday January 18, 2025 @03:21AM (#42746770)
While I agree in general, my opinion is that customer choices do also matter and can move the needle, slowly, with larger cultural change.

Personally, trying to make better choices, big or small, isn't about "virtue signalling". It's about acknowledging the issues and living according to ones values.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by renegat0x0 on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:24AM (#42746573)
Do we talk about pollution or emmissions?
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by rolftheperson on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:26AM (#42746579)
This line of thinking is what undermines democracies and ruins the environment. Your choice might just be a drop in the ocean, but guess what the ocean is made out of.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by frankzander on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:30AM (#42746597)
Finally someone who speaks this out. What we do is more or less fly poop ... good four own well being but with almost zero impact. I'll go on doing some things because I think that some of that are the better ways to handle this or that or it's better for my health but with no expectation that I'll change anything.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by bjohnson225 on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:53AM (#42746656)
This reads like an attempt to pass the blame to others. Per capita CO₂ emissions in the US are one of the highest in the world, and significantly higher than those in China or SEA. This is despite the US/Europe moving some of our dirtiest/cheapest manufacturing to that region.

Personal choices matter. See the amount of energy used on air conditioning in the US compared to areas of Europe with comparable weather for a banal example. If we want to significantly reduce emissions it will happen through a combination of personal choices, corporate action and government policy.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by sofixa on Saturday January 18, 2025 @02:55AM (#42746661)
One of the most imminent problems with the environment isn't due to plastic pollution (which is of course terrible, might well have unforseen ramifications via micro plastics, and is impacting negatively biodiversity), but CO2 and other gases impacting climate.

While we should strive to fix both, it's more important in the short term to limit the amount of CO2 pollution before it's too late.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by pointedAt on Saturday January 18, 2025 @03:52AM (#42746880)
well, it's really not about the destruction of the planet but making our habitat more hostile and humans more sick.

sure, STEM will continue to find remedies and cures but at some point we're fucked just because the gene pool was reduced to an unnaturally selected bunch that survived & thrived completely alienated from the actual world.

sure, no biggie, wahaha, that's the name of the game, the old will die, the young repeat the same nonsense and that microbiome and all that other stuff we carry with us as hosts, potentially most likely in a beneficial symbiotic relationship, have no implicit mechanisms to cancel the contract and pivot towards some species or other that won't be d u m b enough to shit all over it's own home & garden, consequently ruining the bio-chemistry with the smell, taste and look of feces everywhere - in the body as well as outside - and all that while it's getting a bit hot in here.

and I doubt that the consequences of controlled demise in a deteriorating environment all while the meds and drugs of leadership and the people fade out quite a few of the brains and the bodies implicit reactions to a lot of sensory perceptions to everything that was vital, crucial to notice for a 'million' years can't be projected to at least some degree. I mean "blindspots" are a thinking tool, after all, but those thinking brains and minds believe in black swans and the better angels of our nature so that doesn't really mean a thing.

the population itself is fine, a habit of psycho-social education and all consecutive upper levels being insanely afraid of competition and insights from below. thing is, whatever financial survival schemes people are running, they all have death cult written all over their faces.

btw, most of this was for fun, I'm really not worried at all. climate change is more a cycle than man-made acceleration. my only point of interest is the deterioration of the species due to all the things that we do and then worry more about the habitat than our and all kinds.

we absolutely can turn the planet into a conservatory. through any climate.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by marhee on Saturday January 18, 2025 @03:55AM (#42746886)
Regarding the immediate effect I am sure your point is valid. But it’s also a bit of a cynical point of view, wouldn’t you say? People make these statements and pursue these personal lifestyle decisions because of their dreams for a better future - not its immediate effect. Just as companies need a vision to succeed, societies need vision as well. If a lot of people are vocal about something and live it, it has a chance of becoming anchored in laws and so force companies to do the “right thing”. Regulation follows collective values.
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by wisty on Saturday January 18, 2025 @04:27AM (#42747037)
I think this is wrong.

Descriptively / "objectively" if you make your demand cleaner, you decrease demand for dirty consumption. You can't say individuals don't matter by comparing them to the world, that's invalid.

Normatively, is it a useful lie? Maybe, to some extent. People are lazy, selfish, and stupid. Peter Singer points out that we might be nice to people nearby, but we don't give money to people starving in other countries even if we think it will make a real difference. And no human can really know how even a pencil is made, so we make poor decisions. A carbon tax would unleash the free market on the problem. But saying individuals can't act is not good leadership, if even the people who say they want to fix the issue won't make personal sacrifices, why should the average voter?

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by jvanderbot on Saturday January 18, 2025 @09:14AM (#42748471)
"Personal impact" is just laundering the responsibility of government and corporations so it looks like it's our fault.

It is true that everyone everywhere all at once could suddenly make the right decision forever and save the planet. But is a statistical anomaly so extreme it's not worth pursuing as a policy. No policy maker worth their salt would look at that and consider it valid long term.

We have a playbook. We refuse to use it. We ban products, and then the companies that refuse to change or cheat get shuttered, and we move on.

Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by saaaaaam on Saturday January 18, 2025 @06:05PM (#42752145)
Isn’t it also the case that a lot of those plastics come from those rivers because the first world ships is plastic water to China to be processed (“recycled”) and that this is what skews the numbers like this?
Re:Using ChatGPT is not bad for the environment by zelphirkalt on Sunday January 19, 2025 @05:03PM (#42762424)
Even assuming everything you state to be true, moving sales to a less developed area also means selling for lower price in most cases. That is an incentive at least to try and comply with regulation. Only that the US is notorious underregulated.