Unfortunately, most consumers, recruiters and sometimes hiring managers are in a position of information assymetry vis a vis the people selling them something. That is, consumers rely on the self-reporting of vendors which purport to be experts.
It would be different if it’s someone e.g. very high up at a F500 selling something, even with a huge information asymmetry, because it’s still possible to bank on their credibility. (Assuming they offer sufficiently many guarantees signed by sufficiently many people.)
I could think of reasons both in favor and against, but I'm curious about your rationale.
When there’s little to no credibility to offer, such as when a newly hired intern is selling it, then of course it’s no different.
In contrast, product information invites people crafting lies for an advantage.
Starving for talent my ass. His portfolio companies have infinite appetite for talent at zero cost, the minute one person wants one point of the upside they’re right back to starving for free talent.
Silicon Valley is the ultimate thought experiment in how wealth inequality plays out when resources are effectively inexhaustible. You don’t have to speculate about a post-scarcity world, this is a post-scarcity world. Ballers in SV ship a billion in revenue on a Tuesday. And yet somehow it’s Andreessen who ends up with all the chips at the end of the night.
These talking heads don’t have a plan, they don’t know what their next big payday will be, they don’t code, they don’t design, they don’t sell anything other than their own personal brand, they don’t add value.
They’re just patient and connected like zen spiders sitting on a web: they’ll learn first about a new big thing, they’ll be there immediately, their friends will wire up the deal in their favor, and they’ll do a TED talk a few years later about how making themselves absurdly wealthy with no real effort is somehow the future of humanity.
They openly advertise their glee at the (ridiculous) idea that soon some autoregressive language model will do all the work and the owners of NIDIA cards can just pocket it all.
In the 90s there was this meme of a yuppy couple doing a business from their couch via “The Information Superhighway”: outsource everything, all you need is a laptop, a glass of Chardonnay, and a lot of cheek.
pmarca should spend less time yakking about AI on Lex stream and more time learning AI on geohotz stream.
Consumers rely on advertised claims being truthful.
It is not a matter of people badly predicting their own needs in most cases,though there are some that do have problems with this. It is a matter of people being misled by false information and trying to course correct after that information comes to light.
In a world where lies of omission and ambiguity towards borderline malice isn't considered an outright lie, but the sales reps do make those outright lies, and fake reviewers are not punished; there are real problems especially when the presumption is they aren't doing this (when in many markets this is exactly the standard behavior, and even academic studies show these things happen regularly).
Presumptions are just assumptions. Someone will take advantage of the grey unenforced area to push a product that may not be as professionally tested as they claim (or even finished). I've certainly run into a lot of these bait and switch types in my long professional career. The general term to describe this is snake-oil, and with the concentration of the market over time (increasing marketshare less participants), this only gets worse.
I wish morep people understood the "Kardashian effect" as I like to call it -- the most popular thing is only most popular because it was already popular. I think in almost everything in my life and in every domain, #2 or #3 is better-suited (for my preferences and needs).
A year or two ago on HN I read a short blog post about omitting the word "best" from internet searches and being more specific in your criteria (e.g. "car with best resale value" instead of "best car"), and it has made my life and way of thinking a lot better
I like to explore alternatives to the most popular choice, but more often than not I end up back at the #1 consensus choice.
I have some friends who simply must pick the #2 or #3 choice in every domain. They always have an elaborate justification for why it’s better. From my point of view it seems driven by contrarianism.
Some times they pick some interesting alternatives that I explore. Most of the time they end up with also-ran purchases that die off. I joke that my one friend is the best predictor of impending product line cancellation that I know. He used a Zune when everyone went iPod. He went Windows Phone when iPhone and Android were front runners. He event eschewed Instagram for some other platform that he was sure was going to win the social media wars, but was actually so unnoteworthy that I can’t even remember the name right now.
Since that can often mean extra effort/support, I won't recommend such things to others. I'll try to pick something that will be the least trouble for them.
https://news.mit.edu/2015/harbinger-failure-consumers-unpopu...
Not to say that every #1 popular item is always the best, but definitely a lot more than never.
Popularity is only a decent proxy for consensus if people actually look at the other options. I've been burned by trusting this metric more times than I can count.
I got the vectrex too, an Atari STM I think, it wasn't quite the same as an Atari STFM. When I wanted to learn piano/keyboard, he bought me a frickin keytar, a Yamaha SHS-10, instead of lessons or a simple full size like I asked for.
Instead of a gift certificate to get some clothes, he got me a gimmicky Canon SLR that ate batteries and that I couldn't afford to develop the film.
He was a very strange person. Sometimes incredibly funny and generous, other times hateful and selfish.
Edited to add: sorry for the trauma dump. I have no idea what point, if any, that I was originally trying to make.
I would have liked to have eaten something other than boiled potatoes and peas in my birthday. I would have liked to go to the ice rink with my friends. Instead I got a camera I couldn't afford to use.
I may be one of these types, but at least in many of my cases, I don't really know that it mattered in the end?
Maybe after a review I pick something that didn't win in the long term or even eventually exited the market because it wasn't popular enough. But, my requirements are almost never strictly that it's popular. What I end up with does typically do the job very well for the time I have it, and after few years the requirements may change or the need may go away completely. If one of my requirements is that a device is built with metal instead of plastic, maybe I never have to replace it.
Another example: Your friend had a Zune, but then I'm guessing they moved on to a phone, [because phones eventually] became better music players. If the Zune did all the things they wanted while they had it, especially if they had a unique need, maybe were happy with it. (Although, that isn't necessarily always the case.)
This doesn't seem quite as applicable for selecting software, though. Popularity often is part of what I look at there, because I want to know dependencies won't need replacing and support will be available. Additionally, you can potentially work with the developers so the selection iterates and grows into your requirements.
the same group of consumers has an outsized tendency to purchase all kinds of failed products, time after time, flop after flop
You really don't want these people as customers: In a key part of the study, the researchers studied consumers whose purchases flop at least 50 percent of the time, and saw pronounced effects when these harbingers of failure buy products. When the percentage of total sales of a product accounted for by these consumers increases from 25 to 50 percent, the probability of success for that product decreases by 31 percent. And when the harbingers buy a product at least three times, it’s really bad news: The probability of success for that product drops 56 percent
https://news.mit.edu/2015/harbinger-failure-consumers-unpopu...Always a great cue to instantly stop considering a product.
Perhaps I should set up a Patreon where people can give me money to not watch things.
(Admittedly, this may be a mathematical artifact. Cancelled shows have less opportunity to decline in quality. At one point, The Dragon Prince was my all-time favorite show. I haven't even bothered to watch the last several seasons. It is even possible that the people cancelling the show are able to accurately predict that something is going to go downhill in the future, though I doubt it.)
Depending on the domain, there's a good chance #1 may also be a sponsored result.
Alternatively, the Mickey Mouse effect.
- ZFS. There are other filesystems that provide checksumming, CoW, etc. but ZFS is a proven solution in this space. I am happy work on BRTFS and bcache continues but they are not yet there.
- Debian. There are distros that do things better and differently but nobody has quite as smooth an experience, hardware support, security, and software availability all in one package. Alternatives are really good so it really says something about Debian that it is as popular as it is.
- ssh. There are some alternatives but when was the last time you heard an argument made in their favor?
I could go on but hopefully I’ve made my point. Sometimes the standard choice is the right now. And yes I know me picking Debian as a good distro can start a flame war :)
I often wondered how to strike the balance right on these things, since apparently all options can lead to success.
It would have been quicker and cheaper if the company just hired more actual developers to integrate properly with existing systems (and resulted in more featureful, less buggy applications), but the prospect of paying lower salaries for less qualified people to do the same end result (as promised by the slopware vendors) seems to be a siren song of sorts to management.
The problem is that this disposition is not the norm for a technician, which is why I tend to prefer hiring and training engineers that are artistic, creative, and obsessive.
We incinerate the book every few years, but the fundamentals remain the same.
Winners are mostly chosen by effort put into marketing, not product quality.
The goal of the business it to make money, not make a great product.
They will make the product better if and only if it will lead to greater profits.
If you can make more money hiring more sales and marketing people to sell a broken product than hiring more engineers to fix the product, you're going to hire more sales and marketing people.
More broadly: products are the way to make profits, but they aren't the purpose of the venture.
I do not understand that at all, but maybe my reality is just substantially less mediated by "the conversation" that I don't get it. (Drizzle is fine BTW)
1. Many if not most "customers" (JS devs) don't understand how to evaluate quality deeply (thus, quality signals aren't trustworthy, making evaluation more difficult and resulting in further acceptance of using unevaluated products)
2. There's an overwhelming number of choices, with deprecation, replacement, and eclipsing all being fairly common - potentially even year-to-year
You kinda just have to try stuff out and work with what you've got.
If the project appears to have several active contributors that would be good too.
So hopefully I didn't bookmark a project someone else is trying to judge the quality of based on stars. Who knows how much technical debt or damage I've caused because GitHub doesn't have a bookmark feature that isn't gamified.
Off the top of my head, the best software I use seems to fall into two categories:
- Closed source software that requires buying a license to use
- Open source software that is specifically made for developers and promises to do one job well
Whatever falls in the middle of those two categories tends to suffer, in my experience.
If you think about it, web based software tend not to fit neatly into either category. Most of them are the following:
- Closed source but are either too cheap or are free
- Open source but promises to do way too many things, and also too cheap or free (describes a lot of frameworks and design tools)
Web technology and JavaScript became the dumpster slut of software ecosystems. The end users are not given a big enough reason to pay for them adequately or at all, product owners care little about quality and reliability because it's way too easy to get a zillion low quality users to look at ads, and the barrier of entry for new JavaScript programmers is so low that it's full of people who never think philosophically about how code should be written.
I think an additional problem with the JavaScript ecosystem specifically is external resources are extremely easy to access and their cost is usually borne by end user resources. Therefore they're too tempting for many developers to avoid. Unfortunately the runtime environment of the end user rarely matches that of the developers and seemingly "cheap" resource access at development/test time isn't cheap for the end user.
JavaScript is happy to pull in some library hosted on some third party service at runtime. For the developer/tester this ends up cached by the browser and/or at the edge of the CDN. A developer may also have topologically close CDN endpoints. This inspires them to pull willy nilly from third party libraries because to them they're cheap to access and they save time writing some utility function.
The same goes for CSS, APIs, or media resources. With JavaScript the delivery is a client issue and costs can be pushed entirely onto the client. If pulling in an external resource(s) costs a developer non-trivial money to store and serve they'll put more effort into tree shaking or other delivery optimizations. They may omit it entirely.
I think this massively contributes to the LEGO piece construction of a lot of web apps. It also contributes to performance robbing things like tag managers that insert a bunch of incongruent plug-ins only at runtime from an unbounded number of sources.
Don't agree that JS community is bad, it is the largest community of any language by far, and it has the most money invested into it by a huge margin. There is a lot of trash but there is some seriously good stuff, and you can find 10+ packages trying to do pretty much anything you can think of.
And yes, you can find 10+ packages to do pretty much anything... of which 8 are abandoned and no longer work on up-to-date Node versions or depend on other packages with known vulnerabilities.
Then people started stacking more and more things on top of those libraries, creating a giant dependency morass of microdependencies that larger frameworks are now build on top of. And because all these frameworks do things just different enough from each other, every larger library that a dev would want to integrate with those frameworks now needs a specialized version to work with those frameworks.
In most languages, if you want to know how something works, you can usually dig into your dependency tree and by the time you hit the stdlib's optimization spaghetti/language internals, you'll probably have figured out what's causing your snag/what the library is expecting out of you. In JavaScript, you hit the dependency morass and have to give up. Most competent devs then decide to pick another language.
You can write very legible JavaScript these days, even without a framework, but it looks nothing like JavaScript used in a framework.
The other language I know of with this issue is, ironically, Rust.
The one thing salvaging Rust for now is a lack of similar frameworks, but who knows how long that will last.
For example, in the 2000s and 2010s, javascript had the lowest barrier to entry by far thanks to browser dev tools, so a lot of what you saw was people with no prior experience teaching people with no prior experience. These people are still around, and while plenty have improved, they still form the basis of modern javascript practice.
Nobody else can understand how it's built, but for some reason that's not their problem? It's not like they're taking the time to understand how React is built, either. But as soon as you do something on your own, whoooa buddy. Cowboy programmer alert. It's not good engineering if it's a single, coherent, vertically integrated system. It's only good engineering if it's a mishmash of half-solutions teetering on top of each other.
I don't understand why people get so up in arms over npm modules, as if you could stand up code that does the same things in another language without having to manage dependencies.
I still do a lot of programming. And I expect my developers to be competent enough to read other people's code and figure out how it works, what it does, how to use it, based on the tests and plenty of extant examples.
I don't want developers who can only be productive in libraries that everyone else's is using/posting YouTube tutorials on/feeding LLM training corpus'.
The problem with adopting other people's software is that you have to make it work for your purposes, all while accepting it was only ever originally designed for their purposes. And if that's open source and you contribute to it, then you have to make sure all your changes don't break other people's work.
But with my own libraries, I can break anything I want. I have, like, 5 projects using them. It's not a big deal to discover an architectural problem and completely refactor it away to a newer, better design, propagating the change to all the others that use it in fairly short order.
And I don't have to argue with anyone about it. I can just do it and get the work done and prove it was the right thing to do long before any Github PR would ever get out of review.
I also use almost no software that has been written by others. I use two or three external dependencies, in my work. Two PHP ones, and one Swift one. All are ones that I could write, myself, if they got hit by a bus, but they do a great job on it, and, as long as they remain bus-free, I'm happy to use their stuff.
The one exception is an app that I just released, using SwiftUI. I needed an admin tool that displays simple bar charts of app usage data. I was going to write my own UIKit bar chart widget, but SwiftUI has a fairly effective library, so I figured I'd use it, and see how SwiftUI is doing, irt shipping apps.
I think that I'll avoid using SwiftUI for a while longer. It's still not ready, but it has come a long way, since my first abortive attempts at using it. The app works, but I did some customization, like pinch-to-zoom, and that's where SwiftUI kicks you in the 'nads. As long as you stay in your lane, things are sick easy, but start driving on the shoulder, and you are in for some misery.
And that's the biggest problem with relying on someone else's code. They usually punish you for any "off-label" use. Apple has always been like that, but they usually let you get away with it. I go "off-label" all the time, because I don't want my apps to look like Apple Settings App panels. SwiftUI doesn't suffer deviance at all. Just adding pinch-to-zoom was a bit of a misery (but I got it going, after several days of banging my head, and it now works fine). Some frameworks and libraries won't let you deviate at all. You can't have any pudding, if you don't eat yer meat.
From there, I find two problems rather often. One, it doesn't actually do what it claims. Googling is fruitless because I must have been the first one to actually try it. Gotta love Googling an error and finding exactly one result - the source code. I sometimes open a bug report depending on how the project seems, and that gets anything from deaf ears to "oh thanks, we'll fix it in the April release" which is of little use to me now.
The other is something you touched on briefly, that the API or contract changes in unexpected ways over time. You can stave this off for a little while by pinning, but then you're missing out on bug fixes and new features. Which, especially for a middleware type thing, is usually a death sentence by bitrot.
> I keep bumping into the fact that using mentally cheap signals of quality (such as stars or DL counts) almost never indicates the quality of the thing itself.
I find that docs are typically a really good proxy for quality. Solid docs with clear expression of intent (design, usage, features) is usually a good sign.Astro.js, VueUse, Quasar (it's ugly, but amazing).
It seems like a pretty niche project with am enthusiastic following. Like Elm, but even more niche.
I think even he is a little averse to straight up saying it out loud (we’ve discussed it many times): software and product outcomes have gone to shit because we don’t enforce anti-trust law already on the books, let alone update it in light of 50 Moore doublings.
You want a smart phone? Here are two vendors with the same App Store vig at payday loan shark rates. You want to rent cloud compute? Here are several vendors where the 4th place vendor charges the same as the first place vendor. You build disruptive encrypted messaging app? You better live on a boat and watch your six like Jason Bourne Mr. Marlinspike.
Is it even a little surprising that everything from Google search to Netflix is a shittier version of itself ten years ago? There’s no incentive to make it compelling!
We’re not in the “very large” regime?
The better analogy is Tony Soprano with a migraine.
On human welfare? Every other day a new study comes out on the destructive force that heavily marketed smart phones represent: Phillip Morris and Enron put together couldn’t collapse the birth rate in a nation.
This debate is about economic activity as a good a priori. A lot of people assume that.
Some are ill-informed: they haven’t read the designer of GDP talk about the perils of GDP as a metric.
A small few know how mathematically comical the fucking Laffer Curve is and who thought it up and where and prey on the good intentions of the former group.
They’re going to catch a guillotine no matter how much caution I or anyone else advocates for.
Collapsing the birthrate?
Human welfare?
We're talking about the App Store my friend. You need to take it easy on the ideology.
It’s not done in a day but I’m on track to finish in 2025.
The problem with X is… the other people who use X.
Their hardware sales shouldn't entitle them to a cut of the software used on it, and the hosting is not worth particularly much.
The value of their platform is in both hardware and software by the way.
If that's what you think matters above all else, would you support a literal mafia group taking a cut if they had started the market in that particular city?
> public property
It's a market, not property.
But Apple owns none of the iPhones, so why do they get a say?
> The value of their platform is in both hardware and software by the way.
They shouldn't be artificially tied together by DRM.
> But Apple owns none of the iPhones, so why do they get a say?
This is an interesting point. But the key thing is people buy iPhones in part because of the walled garden, and Apple bakes it into the price. Without that App Store revenue, those $999 iPhones would simply see a price increase.
And if they baked the price into the phones, at least that would be honest. But they likely wouldn't increase the phone price by that much.
If you didn't mean that, I'm not sure why you gave me that advice. I'll keep it in mind but I'd prefer we keep the discussion focused on what Apple is doing and whether it should be accepted by the general public, both in terms of popularity and legality. And Google too, because this discussion started about both app stores.
Why would that happen instead of Apple taking less profit overall?
I suspect that Apple's pricing for phones is based on primarily on what the customer is willing to pay rather than on the amount needed to be profitable.
Today that’s so captured that Mickey Mouse is still in copyright and insulin for diabetics costs more than the saline it’s in.
It defies both the law as written and the human sense that wrote it to advocate for unproductive rent seeking: sixteen years? With a few point patches along the way? Thirty percent.
The Europeans find it ridiculous, the FTC finds it ridiculous, anyone who likes innovation finds it ridiculous.
But it’s mostly ridiculous because history is unambiguous on this point: you tell the peasants to eat cake long enough and you’ll swing from a dockyard crane.
Let’s seek to avoid that kind of thing?
This is called being a "landlord" and it's actually completely legal.
You buy some land, you build a mall, you invite shopkeepers to set up shops and sell to customers visiting the mall, and the shopkeepers give you $$$$ every month, forever. If they ever stop paying, they lose their shops.
Even though it's shopkeepers that draw customers to the mall in the first place, and even though the shopkeepers are covering all the maintenance costs of the mall, you get paid anyway. Because you own the mall.
So if a mafia group created a market, took a cut from every shop, and threw out anyone who wouldn't pay them their cut? That's actually a legitimate business.
That analogy still doesn't quite hold as you legally agree to pay HOA dues when buying the property and agree the property can seized eventually if you don't pay. No such agreement is made between phone owners and Apple, Apple just sells you the thing and puts some of it's functionality behind ongoing fees.
I have heard the rent argument made for property tax and it holds better there. Own your house outright but fall behind on property taxes and the government can take your house and land - now that feels a lot more like rent.
There is no useful analogy from an idyllic high street with people shopping at leisure to what happens when you give sociopaths unbounded compute and legal carte blanche.
I struggle with this as a meme and I have a more and less charitable theory. My more charitable theory is that people never learned finance seriously. My less charitable theory is that people stand to benefit personally and are indifferent what it costs, as long as someone else pays the cost.
None of these concepts are in the bedrock law of the land: shopping mall, home owner’s association? Which amendment protects HOAs?
It is completely possible to change all of this, and while we should deliberate thoughtfully before making sweeping change, I mistrust anyone who just asserts dubious shit as bedrock laws of nature.
Maybe we’ve got a pretty sickening system composed of dubiously legal and strictly unethical status quos and it’s time to make some changes at arbitrary effort and cost.
Profit margins and low-friction competition go hand in hand, if one endorses the one without demanding the other?
I’ll show you a pretty small-minded person with distressingly little empathy.
Some internet platform thing stops being socially useful from competitive innovation and starts being an extractive rent?
The public has the power to dictate terms to the people running it. It’s a power the public hasn’t exercised a lot recently, but it’s only been about 30 years since LA 92, a little longer to Watts and Detroit.
It would be a grave error to mistake the public’s kindness for weakness.
You have to flip the percentage. The fraction of money that goes to the intended destination after a 30% tax is 70%. The fraction of money that goes to the intended destination with a one year 100% APR loan is 50%.
Though there's no reason to assume a year in particular. If you take a six month loan at 100% APR, you have to pay back 141%. Paying back 141% is equivalent to a 29% tax. And if the best comparison is "six months of compounding payday loans" that's even worse than the initial comment suggested.
> payday loan shark rates
Do you know what the retail markup on things you buy in your local shop?
If a product costs $1 from the producer, the distributer sells it to the retail shop at $2. And the retailer sells it at $4.
If you can hear this, you are the resistance.
That, uh, is kind of what you expect in a competitive commodity market, isn't it? I don't think that's the example you want. (No disagreement about app stores).
When vendors 1-5 are all running 20, 30, sometimes 50 percent margins while their share varies from like 40% to like 5%?
That’s called price fixing.
Sometimes I wonder if the free market has stopped working.
>Sometimes I wonder if the free market has stopped working.
The "free market" means people have the freedom to compete. It doesn't mean they are guaranteed do so. You might as well blame society for getting lazy and complacent.
The "free market" means nothing as nothing like that existed at any point of human history.
But “the effective freedom to compete” is a reasonable TLDR on versions of it that lead to peace and prosperity.
The “money for nothing” kind of capitalism? That kind gets regimes and their apologists killed in my reading of history.
I’ll admonish you to endorse a better plan.
I really admire Google over time, it’s a special place that still has engineers you can’t find many places.
But once they let climber TPMs write their own performance review by just ransacking the dwell? An even worse crop (Altman, Amodei) was inevitable.
Without concrete examples your comment is just vibes.
You don't seem to be arguing that Google is a bad company actually. You're arguing that it was once a good/altruistic company, and now it's more ordinary. This strikes me as an entitled attitude. A company behaves in a good/altruistic way, people get used to it, they don't show appreciation, but they do start cursing if the altruism diminishes even a little. "No good deed goes unpunished"
If you think a company is doing a bad job of serving its customers, compete with it.
If you're right, and you can do a better job of serving those customers, you are likely to become rich.
If you aren't interested in competing, maybe you don't actually believe it is possible to do much better.
I agree that in principle, there can be a role for the government in removing structural barriers to competition. I haven't seen that role particularly well-articulated in this thread, though.
High-paying work in the US right now and software in particular is in a bit of a doldrums where the locally useful needles are like, friction to leave the platform, and the absolute limit of remnant ad load before people throw their phone at a wall, and taking a big cut out of everything, and lying constantly about what foundation models can and can’t do and shit.
I suspect it feels this way because this is a pretty exceptional run where the Valley just doesn’t have shit for the LPs. It was Web3 and then the Apple Watch (or vice versa) and then it was WeWork and then it was the Metaberse and now it’s “AI”.
But it will get better: dumb, lazy, corrupt management eventually gets rotated out. This crop is really hanging on by their fingernails, but the writing is on the wall.
None of the examples of crappy software from the OP are Magnificent 7 companies, are they? Those companies seem to be capable of hiring the best talent.
A critical input into the build vs buy decision is whether your company is actually capable of building. Suppose Dan was advising the company that made the crappy Postgres/Snowflake sync software on whether to build vs buy a supporting component. Given that their main product is already crap, can they really be expected to build a better supporting component in-house? Seems like they might as well buy, and focus their energy on fixing the main product.
Dan advocates vertical integration here, and elsewhere says engineers get better compensation from FAANG than startups. This suggests that big companies made up of lots of talented engineers have natural efficiencies, relative to the alternatives.
A natural interpretation of "antitrust" is: break companies up into their smaller business units. That basically replaces an in-house "build" relationship with an inter-business "buy" relationship. So it seems antithetical to the OP.
Dan, if you're reading this, I encourage you to write a reply here on HN tearing me apart, like you did to all the other HN commenters.
I’ll challenge the notion that enriching mediocre people at the expense of society is either reasonable or useful. Enlightenment ideals around the sanctity of personal property fall apart when you extrapolate that to millions of people in passive index funds who don’t vote on governance.
Neither the United States Constitution nor the Universal Declaration of Human Rights nor the Geneva Conventions have any protections for rent seeking assholes as a bloc.
Don’t shoot the messenger: in my reading of history either one group backs down or the other slaughters them.
I’m lobbying for the peaceful resolution.
I’ll also advocate for a punitive wealth tax: not to raise revenue (who cares) but to cripple billionaires who aspire to nation state power. 50 million seems like plenty to live in arbitrary luxury but not enough to buy policy. Seize everything above that.
What happens after that is unclear. War possibly.
If legislature doesn't talk to industry before regulating, expect lots of incompetent, ignorant, economy-crippling regulation.
You don't have to change anything in the US if you want this. Just move to Germany.
>cripple billionaires
You might be able to persuade Trump of this, actually, if you sell it as increasing his power over the other billionaires.
More seriously -- It sounds like you have a strong desire to live in an authoritarian country, where the state possesses unchallenged primacy over its citizens. I support your right to do that. There are many available to choose from.
I'll bet if you do enough research, you can even identify an authoritarian country which also has crippling regulations. That should be perfect.
The United States was mounting a vigorous defense against the Warsaw Pact in 1960, and again in 1970, and straight up through 1979 before Reagan was elected and we took the Laffer Curve straight off the back of a napkin and to the legislature.
There is a way to run a participating democracy without a dystopian upwards wealth transfer, without unlimited political spending, without a catastrophic class segmentation that will lead to war. And we can do it all while opposing unbounded statism.
It sounds like you’re doing well under the current system and trying to frame it like that makes a system good.
Fuck you.
This will be my last reply in this thread (unless you apologize).
>These talking points went mainstream around the time Reagan got elected, around the time stuff like the Laffer curve got taken seriously.
Unfashionable isn't the same as wrong. It's telling that you're responding by saying "this is why you're unfashionable", rather than "this is why you're wrong".
>There is a way to run a participating democracy without a dystopian upwards wealth transfer, without unlimited political spending, without a catastrophic class segmentation that will lead to war. And we can do it all while opposing unbounded statism.
Are you aware that median wages in the US are some of the highest in the world?
https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/daily-median-income?tab=t...
Regarding class divisions and political spending, you might find these links interesting:
https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/america-doesnt-really-have-a-w...
https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/09/18/too-much-dark-money-in...
I actually care more about global inequality than inequality within the USA. I would sooner support effective foreign aid than welfare.
But really -- It's not your specific policy ideas that disturb me, so much as your attitude. Your politics aren't the politics of benevolence or charity. They're the politics of envy, ego, bitterness, and resentment. That never ends well:
https://iea.org.uk/publications/socialism-the-failed-idea-th...
>It sounds like you’re doing well under the current system and trying to frame it like that makes a system good.
Currently surviving off of savings due to a chronic illness. I haven't had a good source of income for multiple years. My Medicaid coverage just renewed. I rent a room in an undesirable area. I don't have a car. I won't get a chance to see my family for Christmas.
But you know what? I am "doing well". That's because "doing well" is more about your mentality than your material resources.
I hope you get the support you need in that area. Merry Christmas.
You have none of these recourses with software. Yes, there are trial periods but that's not the same as buying and returning, and they're usually shorter than return windows.
And there's never any guarantee that it will "just work". We have managed to convince consumers to put up with software that "breaks" in a way that they would never do with hardware.
As Dan notes, a lot of software is just...not very good. It either isn't upfront with flaws (as in the case of the Postgres -> Snowflake tool), has too much scope, or is abstracted poorly. Finding things to buy/use (as in the case of open source) can often eat a lot more time than you anticipate.
I've been dipping my toes into the JS ecosystem, and I keep bumping into the fact that using mentally cheap signals of quality (such as stars or DL counts) almost never indicates the quality of the thing itself. Winners seem to be randomly chosen, almost! The only way to assess is to read the code and try integrating it in.
I'd go farther to argue that the larger an ecosystem/market is, the more untrustworthy it behaves as a whole, simply due to the size, and the types of people attracted to it who want to get influence/money. See also: appliances that everyone needs.