News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by pjmlp on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @03:18AM (#4228192)
While I appreciate getting my vacations paid like that, the article shows a bit how Americans vs other continents see the vacations.

Here in Europe the only people I know that dare to have any contact with their company during vacations are usually labeled as workaholic.

We appreciate our 22-30 days vacations, without any contact with the employer while enjoying friends and family.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by ekianjo on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:21AM (#4228639)
In Japan you guys wouldnt survive :) You get 10 days vacation a year, and you will be damn lucky if you can take them all since it depends on the willingness of your employer to allow them when you want them. People usually work late and night and often on saturdays depending on the work pressure.

I am not saying whats wrong or right, but I know my friends back in Europe think its crazy to work such a long time.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by kalleboo on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:39AM (#4228803)
Yeah, it can be nigh-impossible to get vacation time in Japan. Add to that the loyalty to their employer (I call it stockholm syndrome) and many won't even ask. My girlfriend is lucky if she gets 2-3 weekend days free a month, let alone any vacation days. On top of that it's not unusual to have to leave home before 5 AM only to not get home again until after 8 PM. For 2-3 days in a row. And she's not especially well-paid either. My and her mother keep prodding her to quit, but of course her position in the company is essential and she'd never want to "betray" her employer. No matter what explanation I try, she doesn't understand how it's her employer who's exploiting her...
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by marekmroz on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @10:28AM (#4229321)
I think Stockholm syndrome is an apt description of this condition. Maybe it happens because breaking the vicious cycle requires a person stuck in such predicament to acknowledge that their time, and to an extent their person, is a resource in the sad, neo-liberal sense.

Usually people have more heroic visions of their person and possibly this is where the honor and pride narratives stem from, such as "I pulled a 10th all-niter in a row ant helped the company make 0.1% more in profits" or "I can't betray my employer".

Another factor is that with a work schedule like that there is simply no time for a person to look for and apply for other positions, so suddenly quitting is a much harder decision to make without a fallback plan.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by hkmurakami on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @01:48PM (#4230316)
It's just generically incredibly difficult to switch jobs mid-career in Japan. The vast majority of hiring is done w.r.t new grads, who are then groomed (read: brainwashed) into drinking the company coolaid.

There are four options I can think of:

1. You are a bonafide superstar and manage to switch into a solid company (my boss when I was in Japan managed to do this).

2. You become a contract worker.

3. You go to a smaller (less prestigious, usually lower pay, less stable) company.

4. You go to a "foreign national" company (European/American companies' Tokyo office)

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by kalleboo on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:04PM (#4231156)
Exactly, switching jobs is generally not an option.

Sadly for many japanese, they see suicide as an easier out than trying to find a new job. Long hours and no vacation also clearly lead to depression. I'd rather see my gf drop down to a part-time job (baito) than give up completely.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by hkmurakami on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:24PM (#4231790)
I can never forget my friend/coworker telling me over dinner back in 2010, "I now know what those guys who jump into trains must have felt like."
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by justinhj on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:28PM (#4231295)
Does this loyalty work both ways in Japan? Are you more likely to work your whole life at one company, or are layoffs as rife as they are in the US?
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by hkmurakami on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:38PM (#4231839)
This is Japan's "Cool Aid".

The truth is that there are no laws or contracts preventing companies from laying off its workers en masse, yet the individual deludes himself into thinking that there is some concrete social contract exists. The thing is, when the economy was growing at 5% a year, companies could uphold this (ephemeral) social contract by employing people for a lifetime and guaranteeing a great pension.

I personally know CEOs of smaller companies in Japan who vowed to not lay off a single person during the tough times of 2008-2010. The C-suite guys took zero salary for at least 2008, and all other employees took a temporary 30% pay cut. However, this is not the norm. While outright firings may be more rare, things go on underneath the surface. Fulltime employment slots replaced with contract workers in factories, significant amounts of employment moving overseas to SE Asia, etc.

Layoffs aren't as common as the US, but that's actually not necessarily a good thing. Hiring of new grads has gone down significantly (the last graduating class with decent job prospects was the class of 2008), while the older workers (even those who underperform) are kept on board. Like kalleboo says, Japan is about "family". They are kind towards members of their family, and strikingly cold to those who are not. Those who are part of the company are "family", and are protected. New grads who cannot find work are not part of the family, and don't receive the same empathy. Even those who can find work, even at the best and brightest companies, are faced with a situation where their lifetime earnings will be significantly lower than those of the boomers. (on the order of $2.5MM vs $3~4MM lifetime)

There are no good figures about the employment rate of college graduates, but if you discount students who have gone onto become 'part time / contract' workers, the employment rate may be around 60%. (The problem is that all the stats are wildly skewed - for instance, employment rates that include 'underemployed' new grads, or only counting graduates from mid-tier colleges and above) No one really knows how bad the true youth unemployment situation is in Japan.

College students are very risk averse, particularly in the turmoil following the financial crisis. I recall that a poll among college students back in 2011 declared that they wanted to become public workers above all other options (public workers cannot be fired, afaik).

Japan's leaders are very talented at keeping a sinking ship afloat. But they can't avoid the inevitable. Like the country's debt problem, there will come a moment when things catastrophically implode.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by ekianjo on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:37PM (#4232047)
Totally agree about the debt problem. Its a ticking bomb and theres a lot of pain ahead in store for Japan's economy.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by kalleboo on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:30PM (#4231603)
For many many years it has been. People'd get picked up fresh from college and they'd be part of the companies "family". Nowadays, especially after the financial crisis... not so much. Companies now only hire part-timers so they can fire them at will. Youth unemployment is skyrocketing as in many other countries.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by pyre on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @10:37AM (#4229361)
The other problem is the this seems endemic in Japanese culture. I would expect that her next employer might look unfavorably on her 'betraying' her previous employer (though I don't have experience to know for sure).
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by pmiller2 on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @12:20PM (#4229870)
What next employer? How does one even go about finding a new job while working hours like that? Unless she gets fired, I don't expect she'd even have the time to conduct a job search if she wanted to.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by hkmurakami on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @01:50PM (#4230332)
You basically have no choice but to use your "paid vacation" days to conduct a job search.

If you're based in Tokyo, switching jobs is much easier because (a) there are a lot of companies in general there, (b) the culture of the companies are a little more westernized than the rest of the country, and (c) you have the option of going to a foreign national company.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by kalleboo on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:08PM (#4231180)
I've also Tokyo seems more westernized in both culture and business, I guess due to offices having a lot of competition from foreign headquarters?

Sadly, my girlfriend lives in Kagoshima, at the ass-end of backwardness. Convincing her parents that I'm not going to murder their daughter is going to be hard enough! (Japanese news media's treatment of foreigners is rivaled only by Fox News I think). As a white, european male, it's been enlightening being at this end of racism.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by hkmurakami on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:45PM (#4231865)
I do think that's a factor. Also, in general Tokyo has a lot of cultural influence from the west, (having a decent number of foreign professionals there probably helps) and its inhabitants exhibit more western tendencies as a result. I think it's primarily at the individual level, rather than the corporate level though.

Kagoshima is so close to Okinawa, that I imagine there is some cultural undertones that have permeated from the controversies regarding the US Army's isolated (but still brutal) incidences of poor behavior. (iirc they were the subject of the relocation of the Futenma base as well?)

Kyuushuu people are pretty oldschool from what I understand. At least you're caucasian though, you would be truly doomed if you were non-Japanese & non-White. At least they treat you as if you're going to murder their daughter, rather than treating you as an untouchable :(

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by jmcqk6 on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @10:57AM (#4229489)
You only have one life. Why would anyone want to spend the vast majority of it doing work for someone else? The rare case is that they are passionate and care about the work. Anything else, and I just don't understand it.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by timjahn on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:13PM (#4231524)
There are plenty of family and/or medical related reasons to spend a large amount of time doing work for somebody else.

Because you don't doesn't mean it's wrong, stupid, or pointless.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by kalleboo on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:35PM (#4231637)
I have a hard time imagining a world where nobody worked for anyone else. Who would drive the garbage truck?
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by jmitcheson on Thursday July 12, 2012 @02:00AM (#4233260)
A robot.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by ekianjo on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:41PM (#4232063)
Even when you have your own business you are always working for someone else, customers or shareholders are your bosses. Dont fool yourself.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by jmcqk6 on Thursday July 12, 2012 @10:25AM (#4234628)
Yeah, I realized I didn't write what I really wanted to say, which was, why would you stay at a job you hate? Or even a job that you barely tolerate? Or a job that you are apathetic about? One life, and most of your time is going to be spent at that job. It should be something you like at the very least.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by lifeisstillgood on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @10:39AM (#4229373)
but is there a genuine tournament-style approach to promotion and rewards.

For example - if she does work like a demon for 10 years, gets the promotions, will she be in tenure, exceptionally well paid etc. If so it may be a rational decision.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by Qworg on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @12:18PM (#4229860)
Time in and out of the office tiers as well.

When I lived in Japan, I stayed with the head of Korean Air for Japan and with a mid-level engineer at Mazda.

The Mazda engineer left the house at 6 AM and got back at 7 PM or so.

The executive left the house at 10 AM and got back at 5 PM.

When I asked the executive about it, he told me that he had to come late and leave early so his entire staff could leave at a reasonable hour. It cascades - it never looks good if your superior is at work when you're not, so you make sure you get in before him and leave after him. The lower you are, the longer you're at work.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by vonmoltke on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:52PM (#4231405)
Out of curiosity, do Japanese companies not use multi-shift schedules? A former employer of mine ran three shifts, particularly for hardware testing, and I don't see how such a schedule could work with that sentiment.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by Qworg on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @10:53PM (#4232704)
Not for white collar jobs AFAIK. The salaryman is expected to come before his boss and go home after - work may extend to drinking after work to build team identity/loyalty.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by kalleboo on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:06PM (#4231166)
This company kind of sucks. They dangle the typical japanese seniority pyramid in front of hires, but my girlfriend has been at this for 10 years now and it's not leading anywhere nice.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by mitsche on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @11:27AM (#4229638)
I'm European and I am certain that this is wrong, unethical, and bad for society as a whole. I'm not surprised that "death from overwork" is an isolated cause of death and has its own term in Japan (Karōshi).

As an employee in Japan I wouldn't want to survive.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by edandersen on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @08:51AM (#4228985)
>> since it depends on the willingness of your employer to allow them when you want them.

In Japan employers cannot refuse requested holidays unless it would damage the business (for low ranked people with no authority, this is not a problem). It is the peer pressure and subtle bullying in traditional organizations that keeps people from taking holidays.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by ekianjo on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:45PM (#4232079)
In theory, yes. But in reality, they can pressure you not to take too long of a vacation, limiting your opportunities to go abroad on vacation, for example.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by DannoHung on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @08:30AM (#4228918)
Yeah, probably not. But why would I want to survive given that case?

I mean... that sounds just about as bad as actual slavery, but with the disadvantage that you still have to make ends meet.

And the other thing I keep hearing about that situation is that it has nothing to do with actually getting the work done, it's just to show that you're committed. And I think committed is the right word because that concept is CRAZY.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by krschultz on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @09:02AM (#4229025)
Any comparison between a high paid salary employee with a few weeks vacation a year and slavery gets a downvote from me.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by pyre on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @10:43AM (#4229402)

  > high paid salary employee with a few weeks vacation
  > a year
I'm not sure that we're reading the same thread. We're talking about how hard it is to get any vacation time in Japan, for any job, from low- to high-paid.

10 days of vacation equates to 2 weeks of vacation time, but from what I understand, working long hours and on the weekends is an implicit requirement of many (most?) jobs in Japan. So even getting the weekend off during that '10 days of vacation' could be problematic.

Sure, it's definitely not slavery, but it sure seems highly exploitative.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by krschultz on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @11:15AM (#4229576)
The salaryman can quit. A slave couldn't. We often focus on the fact that slaves were unpaid, but that is really the smallest injustice they faced.

Materially, in the US slaves often had higher material 'quality of life' than northern (free) factory workers. They had a better diet, lower pollution, better housing, and more time off. The plantation owners effectively viewed them as an investment. Really, if you want to talk about underpaid and overworked, a more apt comparison would be factory and mine workers in the 18th century.

The horror of slavery was that you had no choice in life. Who cares if you are fed well if someone else can decide to split your family up. Someone can kidnap you, drag you across an ocean (where you have a high chance of dieing) and put you in a country where you can't speak the language. Someone else can decide to move you to a new home. Someone else can decide whether or not you are allowed to read. Someone else can legally beat you.

The Japanese salaryman/women can quit her job if they want to. If they don't, that is their choice, but it is a choice. That is a massive difference. Any comparison between the two really papers over the horror of slavery. Much like any Nazi comparison, it drags the quality of the discussion down.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by pyre on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @12:03PM (#4229800)
You missed this part at the end of my post:

  Sure, it's definitely not slavery, but it sure seems
  highly exploitative
Also:

  The salaryman can quit. A slave couldn't.
If the problem is endemic to the culture, then quitting one job just to take another offers no real change in situation.

To run with the slave analogy, it would be like a slave being able to choose their master, but all masters beat/rape their slaves.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by saturn on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @12:28PM (#4229912)
> The horror of slavery was that you had no choice in life

Your argument is all just semantics. Fine, slaves had no choice, and a large segment of Japanese (and other) society have no meaningful choice. Happy?

Slavery is a concept, anyway. You don't have to pedantically compare every single use of the word to some pet historical incident. I think it's entirely reasonable to compare sections of the working class's lives to slavery, and your attempts to "ban" the whole topic are really misguided and inappropriate, IMO.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by rmc on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @11:56AM (#4229763)
I am not saying whats wrong or right, but I know my friends back in Europe think its crazy to work such a long time.

I'm willing to say it. That's wrong.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by moheeb on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @01:58PM (#4230381)
It is not wrong, it is just what they have come to expect. (Entitlement perhaps?) Do you think the settlers of the new world, for example, were pissed they didn't get their 28 days off a year?

"ahh...that vacation really rested the milk cows. Oh!...my crops are dead :( "

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by rmc on Thursday July 12, 2012 @11:37AM (#4235067)
Ethics and morality changes with time. Just because people were happy with something 300 years ago doesn't mean that it's OK to do it now. People used to be happy with lots of things that we now think of as wrong (e.g. slavery, aristocracy ruling the country, women as second class citizens, burning witches, racism, etc.)
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by ekianjo on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:47PM (#4231872)
Haha. Well said. There are certainly certain circumstances where you cannot be "entitled" to vacation when your life depends on it :)
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by daliusd on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:31AM (#4228659)
I think there is nothing wrong about 10 days or 40 days. It is more important how something matches your expectations. If you expect 28 days and get less then that's bad.

As European I really enjoy long vacations and use them for personal development. I guess I could still do that in Japan without long vacations but I guess I would need to do that on time of company.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by monkeyfacebag on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @11:10AM (#4229547)
"I guess I could still do that in Japan without long vacations but I guess I would need to do that on time of company."

So in other words, you'd need more than 10 days of vacation.

I don't think expectations are important at all here. When vacation time is established at national, cultural levels, the expectations of the population will reflect that.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by daliusd on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @02:26PM (#4230577)
I think in IT you are creative person and you can't create more than you want to. You can be extremely productive but there is upper limit. If you get 10 days and don't get 28 days like European you get that 18 days in some other way.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by nandemo on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:23PM (#4231987)
There are about 15 national holidays in Japan. Also, if you stay at the same company (which most people tend to do if they can) you're entitled to an additional vacation day every year up to 20 days. So a person with a 5-year tenure will have 15 + 15 = 30 days a year.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @11:58AM (#4229773)
And yet for all the supposed strength of the Japanese work-ethic, they've been in their two Lost Decades for basically as long as I've been alive.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by hkmurakami on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:06PM (#4231167)
Japan doesn't need better employees (the majority of my cowokers were very capable, and some of the hackers I have come to know in the past year are rather incredible), it needs better leaders.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @09:18PM (#4232422)
My best guess is that additional work-ethic has diminishing or even negative returns past a certain point. That's certainly what hours-versus-productivity studies show.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by ThomPete on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @10:20AM (#4229284)
The question of course is. Did anyone try to just leave at "normal" time?
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by rmc on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:30AM (#4228656)
Not to mention that "15 days paid holidays" would be illegal in EU. 20 is the legal minimum, even for lowly jobs like people who sweep floors.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by eekfuh on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @01:22PM (#4230184)
I don't want to sound like "that guy", but isn't this why there really aren't very many startups/innovations coming out of EU?

That sense of entitlement and cushy job seems to prevent people from taking risks. They'd rather just coast.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by angersock on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @03:11PM (#4230873)
As far as startups go, I'd imagine that it's more a function of available capital--and even then I've heard good things about startups out of places like Berlin or London.

As far as innovations go, you should go look at the demoscene and a lot of the goofy but useful JS libraries to come out (say, three.js which I believe is Spanish in origin). So, again, I'm not sure where you get that from.

  That sense of entitlement and cushy job seems to prevent 
  people from taking risks. They'd rather just coast.
As opposed to all the hardworking American office drones that only take ~2 weeks a year? Also, what's this business about a "cushy job"? Wouldn't you want workers to be happier and thus more productive?

Why do you seem to be implying that there is a moral highground to more strenuous and miserable work?

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by OstiaAntica on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:08PM (#4231943)
High marginal tax rates in Europe take away the incentive to create a startup, and the governments there confiscate much more of the winnings from successful companies. That, in turn, ensures that there is little venture capital to invest in the next generation of startups.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by VBprogrammer on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:32PM (#4232034)
I strongly disagree. I suspect you are looking at this from the 'American Dream' capitalist point of view. Our tax rates might be higher, but this is more than balanced out by our strong social security and healthcare systems which allow us to take risks a silicon valley startup couldn't dream of.

I can only speak for the UK (and lumping all of Europe together is pretty foolish given that it has a range of countries from borderline 3rd world to international superpowers) but in London the tech scene is very much alive and well. I myself work for a middle aged startup (going through some horrible growing pains just now), I love to get involved in the London tech scene and I've talked with plenty of people doing well from startups.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by davidandgoliath on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @09:10PM (#4232394)
Strong social security like in Greece? At some point the system isn't going to assist you much when it doesn't exist. Nor will capitalism either, as we'll all be flying kites made of dollar bills inevitably :)
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by cluda01 on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @10:07PM (#4232575)
Well Greece's case is a strong social safety net coupled with rampant tax evasion. A better and to pick in my opinion would be Germany. They have a high tax rate and are an export machine as I understand.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by Retric on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @11:09PM (#4232765)
Much of Europe has similar effective tax rates as the US. The difference is the US tax rate is taken out in a lot of separate taxes at the SS, Medicare, Income tax (federal) + State income tax, sales tax, property taxes + local sales taxes, property taxes. Plus Debt and a wide range of fines and fees. Where Europe has no EU wide taxes and it's all taken out at the 'state' and local level.

PS: Per person the US government spends as much on healthcare as many countries with 'national' healthcare so we are paying for it even if we don't have universal healthcare.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by zeroonetwothree on Thursday July 12, 2012 @02:45AM (#4233378)
I don't know what you consider "similar", but the US does have significantly lower effective tax rates (by 10-15%) than most of Europe: http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2011/09/effective-...
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by Retric on Thursday July 12, 2012 @07:39AM (#4234048)
That's simply ignoring state and local government spending. Ed: And possibly Medicare. It's also ignoring the 50% of company matching medicare which is paid by the self employed.

http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/numbers?units=p

PS: As a sanity check. Federal (24.33 GDP -3.72%GDP given to the sates) State spending is 8.97% of GDP, local 10.69%, which adds up to 40.27% GDP. Note: Actual revenue is only 32.61% GDP because we are just borrowing that much money but debt does get paid back one way or another. http://www.usgovernmentrevenue.com/year_revenue_2012USpn_13p...

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by rmc on Thursday July 12, 2012 @11:22AM (#4234940)
the governments there confiscate much more of the winnings from successful companies

What? Citation needed? In some countries they give money to startups, not the other way around.

And how you you explain "high tax rates" when Barack Obama refers to some countries in the EU as a tax haven?

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by amit_m on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @02:28PM (#4230584)
You cannot base a good argument on two data points. I suggest a 3rd point which I believe is a counterexample to your hypothesis:

Israel has more startups per capita than any country in the world, but has socialized working laws. The legal minimum is 10 (I think), the exact amount for engineers varies from company to company, but it's usually at least 15-18 days of paid vacation per year with some of the bigger employers offering 20-30. We also get 3 months maternity leave, several months of unemployment, etc. Not as good as France or Holland, but much better than the US.

I'd say the approach of the US with regards to anything social can work against risk taking. e.g. Healthcare.

It's much easier to take risks when you have a social safety net.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by davidandgoliath on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @03:57PM (#4231123)
But as a nation you also receive massive amounts of foreign aid, thus have an even larger safety net: someone else is funding a good % of your bills.

At some point that also has to be accounted for when taking into account a country's economic conditions.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by amit_m on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:33PM (#4231625)
So you think only highly prosperous countries can afford vacation days? I believe that among western countries it's more about priorities and who is pulling the strings - if it's the regular folks who have power through their vote or the company owners, who use lobbying firms, campaign donations and control of the media to abort any legislation mandating vacation days, etc.

Western europe has used its economic prosperity to get more vacation days over the years, maternity leave, free education and other social goods. While in the US it seems to work in the exact opposite direction.

The extreme case is France, where they seem to be on constant vacation (>60 days!), get free university education, excellent free healthcare and all the good wine to the great dismay of the Chicago school economists that keep predicting its imminent collapse year after year.

Israel's history is also a counterexample, as it was very poor in its early years (1948 - 1980s) and much more socialistic than it is today. Surely Israel can afford MORE vacation days and other social benefits today than it could 40 years ago. But the trend is exactly the opposite. Unfortunately we have a US educated prime minister.

---

About the magnitude of US foreign aid to Israel and its role in the economy, here are some numbers:

Total US foreign aid to Israel: about 3$ billion / year. [1] Total israeli budget: about 100$ billion / year. [2]

Even though this is serious money, canceling the US foreign aid would not make a huge dent in Israel's budget. e.g. 3$ billion can be taxed by increasing the VAT from 16% to 18.8%. [3]

In addition to that, as someone who watched how this foreign aid budget is spent in the military, one dollar of foreign aid is worth MUCH LESS than one real dollar. Since goods must be bought from a specific purchasing catalogue, and this catalogue is both limited and has highly inflated prices. e.g. more than 2500$ for a standard IBM desktop PC.

I think this follows partly from the requirement that at least 50% of the manufactured goods must be made in the US. So many products are made in China, then shipped to the US for repackaging (where their price is doubled) and then shipped back to Israel.

Note also that a large part of US foreign aid goes to purchasing very expensive fighter jets (F-15, F-16) and spare parts. A hugely important goal of the Israeli air force is to have more F-16 planes than the egyptians have. But the Egyptians also get their aircraft from US foreign aid. My interpretation of this state of affairs is that main reason congress is backing both sides of this arms race is in order to take taxpayer money and give it to the military-industrial complex.

Sources: [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel%E2%80%93United_States_re... [2] (sorry, hebrew only) http://budget.msh.gov.il/#00,2012,0,1,1,1,0,0,0,0,0,0 [3] http://www.ynet.co.il/articles/0,7340,L-4234752,00.html

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by dennisgorelik on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:08PM (#4231942)
3% GDP economy boost is a lot.

Update: Sorry, 3% of budget. It's less than 3% of GDP, but still a lot.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by amit_m on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:18PM (#4231972)
3% of the budget, not the GDP! I am not sure it makes too much sense to divide it by the GDP.

Israel's GDP is around 250$ billion. So US foreign aid is around 1.2% of GDP.

However, as I mentioned in the previous post, this aid does not come in the form of actual dollars but in the ability to purchase goods with highly inflated prices and some strings attached. I'm pretty sure Israel would happily trade 3$ billion of US foreign aid with 1$ billion of actual money.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by davidandgoliath on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @09:09PM (#4232390)
All valid points. Israel is definitely becoming a force of it's own in the tech. sector, and I'm extremely glad to hear of it's flourishing VC ecosystem as well.

re: vacation days & prosperous countries -- no, I don't believe the two go hand in hand (poor folk get all kinds of vacation days in the form of funemployment), nor would I consider the U.S. on average a 'prosperous' nation, I'm merely stating that had the U.S. suddenly had outside funding for it's military for the past ~$x years there'd be far more liquidity to spend on other things like one month vacations for everyone.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by rmc on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:33PM (#4231328)
0.5% of the US federal budget goes to Israel as aid money. That might skew the figures a bit.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by skurry on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:04PM (#4231475)
I found that number hard to believe, so I looked it up. In 2007 (the most recent figure I could find) the US sent $2.5 billion to Israel. The total budget was $2800 billion. So it was more like 0.09%.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by rmc on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:16PM (#4231541)
Huh. My source was the New York Times ( http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/08/opinion/sunday/the-coffin-... ) who stated " all foreign aid accounts for about 1 percent of federal spending — and that includes military assistance and a huge, politically driven check made out to Israel, a wealthy country that is the largest recipient of American aid. True humanitarian aid constitutes roughly half of 1 percent of the federal budget" so I thought it was ½% of US budget went to Israel.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by bgilroy26 on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:29PM (#4231599)
"Federal budget" is a multivalent term. It's more likely that 2.5 billion was .5% of discretionary spending for that year.

When you take the prior obligations of Social Security, etc. the budget gets much smaller.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by cbr on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:30PM (#4231604)
I think you're misreading the quote. It says foreign aid is 1% of federal spending, only half of that is true humanitarian aid, and the country that receives the most aid, humanitarian and not combined, is Israel.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by rmc on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:28PM (#4231299)
I'm an EU citizen and have worked (and am working) in several EU based startups. I know I can take a job in one or any of them and not lose my holidays and health care. Big companies don't really offer perks like this here (lots of holidays or health care), so why would I want to work in a cubicle? There's an employee shortage, and mandatory holidays means that a start up is as hard work as a megacorp.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by beedogs on Thursday July 12, 2012 @02:07AM (#4233282)
I am so sick of hearing Americans tell the rest of the planet that "not wanting to work yourself to death" equals a "sense of entitlement".

Can we please take this tired, idiotic old meme out back and put a few rounds in it?

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by abalashov on Thursday July 12, 2012 @02:46AM (#4233384)
I'll get the silencer, lest Middle America hear. :-)
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by nl on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:07PM (#4231939)
Well there is Spotify. And MySQL. Skype. One can keep going...

The difference between the US & Europe appears to be Silicon Valley, not a sense of entitlement and cushy job.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by kalleboo on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:32PM (#4231621)
On the other hand if you join a startup in the EU vs. the US, you're nor forfeiting a health plan, and even if the startup goes bust you have the social welfare system to ensure it doesn't put you on the streets.

So I imagine it hinders people from creating startups, but at the same time it helps hire people into them.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by ckrailo on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @02:34PM (#4230633)
Perhaps. Tell me what you think of this article: http://www.inc.com/magazine/20110201/in-norway-start-ups-say...
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by pimeys on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @02:23PM (#4230554)
I prefer good life over innovations. But that's just me...
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by derleth on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @02:37PM (#4230647)
It would be great if you could defend your position without using the logical fallacy of the false dilemma.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by teamonkey on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @03:56PM (#4231116)
I think his comment has more insight than you give him credit for. I would say that culturally, Europeans just care a lot less about startups (and business and money making) than Americans. I think that's the biggest reason why they're less common in Europe.

[Qualifier: I am a European now living in North America]

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by cjy on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @09:43PM (#4232488)
Also, it might explain why youth unemployment is so high in Europe.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by kahawe on Thursday July 12, 2012 @10:23AM (#4234618)
Hello from Europe! I think you are vastly under-estimating the startup scene over here... but granted, being quite far from the Valley surely doesn't benefit them; the whole Internet and IT are very much focused on the Valley and NewYork due to historic reasons, if you ask me.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by DrStalker on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:00PM (#4231710)
How many public holidays are there in America vs. Europe? Australia is 20 days paid leave + ~10 public holidays off per year. In general people will try to avoid contacting you when you're on holiday; obviously the better you do handing over the less likely anyone is to get in touch with you.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by vellum on Thursday July 12, 2012 @12:02AM (#4232939)
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-17654781: Research published last year by Mercer HR suggested there was a statutory minimum of 14 in Spain, 13 in Portugal, 12 in Greece, 11 in France, and nine in Germany and Ireland.

It found US and Australian workers get 10 public holidays, Canadians nine, Chinese 11 and Japanese 15. However, there are regional variations in many of these countries and employment laws differ as to whether workers should be paid for these holidays.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by davedx on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:08AM (#4228328)
Here in the Netherlands, we actually get extra 'holiday pay' by law too. It makes salary calculations more complicated but it also makes me get a big grin on my face in May :)
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by mitsche on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:30AM (#4228499)
In Austria we get 14 Salaries per year. We pay less tax on the 13th and 14th one. I got my 13th just now for July and will get my 14th in December.

We have 25 days of paid vacation. You can work while at home or on vacation, but your co-workers might not appreciate it. Taking leave for doctor visits, weddings, relocations, funerals, etc. does not count towards that.

Also, our stores are closed on Sundays, which encourages spending time with friends and family.

I don't love Austria, but a few things here I find allright.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by seclorum on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:48AM (#4228692)
I'm in Austria too, and as someone who suffered through 15 years of professional working life in California with no more than 4 consecutive days off the whole time (seriously), I can seriously say: thanks, Austria, for the time off. ;)

Lots of other things not to love about Austria (mobthink, Austro-fascism, the horrid city of Vienna, &etc), but the vacation policies are a dream.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by fierarul on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @08:46AM (#4228966)
Austria is actually on my list of countries to move to. And Vienna was the best place to live for many years in the Mercer survey.

Where do I read more about these things that are wrong with Austria?

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by davidw on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @09:22AM (#4229089)
I lived on the other side of Austria, in Innsbruck, and only visited Vienna a few times, but I thought it was quite pleasant. Not the most 'happening' place, but it seemed nice.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by andrewcooke on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @02:06PM (#4230439)
vienna is a great place - one of my favourite cities in europe (i have never lived there, but have a client there so visit regularly). suspect it's just some weirdness on the part of the original poster.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by seclorum on Thursday July 12, 2012 @04:26AM (#4233614)
I live in Vienna, so there's a difference between tourist-view of the place and denizen-view. I don't know if you spent any time anywhere other than the 1st and inner districts, but I respect the fact that everyone has their own opinion. I think its weird to love a city built as a fortress and then as a mass collective to industrial aesthetics, but then again I love big blue sky and buildings with space between them.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by mitsche on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @11:14AM (#4229570)
Agree with mobthink and Austro-fascism. I would add lack of enthusiasm and closed-mindedness. Don't know what your problem with the city is, though. Even after having lived in Vienna for more than a year I'm still stunned how beautiful it is and how easy it is to meet interesting people.

If you're in a circle of cool people, Vienna is probably one of the nicer capitols to live in. And as a country-bumpkin I find it a lot less mentally taxing than let's say London or Berlin.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by seclorum on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @11:27AM (#4229642)
Beauty is obviously in the eye of the beholder - I grew up in the wide-open desert of Western Australia, and spent my young adult life in Southern California, so I'm used to having more sky above me than the pitiful strip that most Viennese residents have to put up with in their daily lives.

I'm a huge non-fan of all these buildings glommed together, 5 or 6 stories high, and I find it oppressive, personally.

By my reckoning, Vienna is an Imperial Fortress with working-class box-traps being used as buttresses around the center. I wouldn't call it beautiful by any stretch of the word - oppressively architected inventory of the masses does not a beautiful city make.

But hey, to each their own. If you find it beautiful, more power to you. I can't stand Vienna, personally, and am glad I live outside the city border near Bisamberg ..

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by mitsche on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @01:17PM (#4230157)
I agree with everything you wrote. I recently moved back to Mattersburg because my dad passed away and I took over the house. And I really enjoy living in the open again.

But the things you describe are something that many big cities have in common. It makes me wonder if you've ever been to a city with a somewhat dense population that you enjoyed being in.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by seclorum on Thursday July 12, 2012 @04:28AM (#4233620)
I lived in Tokyo for a year. That has similarly oppressive issues too, but there are aspects of Tokyo that are tremendous for the soul. Haven't found much of that in Vienna, yet, after 7 years.

And, 15 years in Los Angeles - well, I love LA. To each his own. ;)

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by mitsche on Saturday July 14, 2012 @10:22AM (#4244220)
I think our tastes are very much alike. I feel what you're saying about the oppressiveness, and I wouldn't want to live in Vienna for the rest of my life either. I just think it's a bit much to call the city of Vienna horrid, especially when so many people say so many nice things about it in general.

You've actually made me want to check out LA sometime soon.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by seclorum on Monday July 16, 2012 @04:27AM (#4249836)
Really, the only people I've heard say nice things about Vienna have been American tourists who seem to be most impressed of all by the imperial, oppressive, architecture .. but everyone has their taste. Thanks for listing to my rant about my tastes .. ;)
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by GFischer on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @08:24AM (#4228901)
I like Vienna very much - okay, I was there in the 90's and I come from South America, but I've since visited Toronto and many other European and Latin American cities, and Vienna is among the nicest cities I've visited.

Maybe the problem is a cultural fit, or high expectations from California, but not the city hopefully?

Edit: here in Uruguay we have almost 14 salaries as well: 1/2 a salary in June, 1/2 a salary in December, and 20 days paid vacation (almost a full salary)

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by seclorum on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @11:31AM (#4229662)
In my case its the pure physical nature of the city that disturbs me. I find no love for the narrow strip of sky that most denizens have to suffer for their daily sunshine needs, and that strip of sky is a consequence of the composition of the citys' buildings, glommed together at a uniform height, each building providing a bare-minimum amount of shelter to the occupants. These 5 or 6 storey buildings are, in my opinion, an intentionally oppressive act designed to keep the working, industrial classes, introverted and perturbed - and in that sense, they function very well.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by krzyk on Thursday July 12, 2012 @02:41AM (#4233365)
Yeah, each their own :) I love narrow streets and high buildings (the older the better, bet skyscrapers are also nice). But yeah it mostly boils down to where one grows up (although I grew up in a small town so I shouldn't lake this ;) )

And I loved Vienna, when I stayed there for few days year ago.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by AYBABTME on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @09:58AM (#4229196)
Toronto is a latin city? Do you mean Montreal?
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by GFischer on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @10:56AM (#4229479)
Sorry, I expressed myself wrong. I meant to say I visited Toronto in North America, and other cities in Europe and Latin America (but I haven't been to the U.S. yet as it's the hardest country to visit in terms of visa requirements. Now that I can get one, I don't have time :) ).
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by smsm42 on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @03:32PM (#4230997)
I wonder how much innovation or any technology or other development is happening in Austria.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @12:03PM (#4229801)
Taking leave for doctor visits, weddings, relocations, funerals, etc. does not count towards that.

So what do those days come out of? Here in the US, that comes out of my vacation time.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by sukuriant on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @01:25PM (#4230207)
Also in the US. Doctor visits for me come out of sick leave, a yearly-recycling collection of days that I'm allowed to take out for reasons of sickness. I have a separate set of days for vacation time.

As for funerals in particular, I haven't run in to this situation, so I don't know what I would be doing.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by mseidl on Thursday July 12, 2012 @07:24AM (#4234013)
In Germany we have no sick days. If we are sick, we stay home. If we are sick for 3+ days we need a note from the doctor. But this does not affect our vacation time at all.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by moheeb on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @02:16PM (#4230504)
OK I'll provide a few tips as you're obviously doing it wrong ;)

The vacation days are what you should be using for stuff like doctor's visits and sickness. The sick days are to be kept forever...or an actual vacation. Normally on termination you get reimbursed for sick days. The vacation days are gone however.

In the case of a funeral...that is a vacation!

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by sadga on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:18PM (#4231771)
That's completely reversed from most of the US.

Vacation is usually paid out, sick time expires. Also, many employers require vacation be scheduled in advance, while sick can be on-demand.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by kscaldef on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:56PM (#4231422)
Hmm... I suppose policies may vary, but in my experience exactly the opposite tends to be true. Sick days and personal days vanish at the end of the year while vacation days generally accumulate (sometimes with a cap, though). It's fairly common for people with separate pools to use "sick" days to just take a day off to recharge or run errands. (Although, technically, employers often have the right to demand a doctor's note, but seldom actually do so.)
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by sukuriant on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @10:12PM (#4232588)
At my work, sick days expire at the end of the year and vacation days are kept for a some amount of time, before they meet a functional cap.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by kscaldef on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:59PM (#4231443)
Many companies have a policy for bereavement leave. The amount may depend on your relationship to the deceased. For example, it might be a week for a parent, spouse, or child; 3 days for a grandparent; etc.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by rhplus on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @11:13AM (#4229568)
I'm sure it's fantastic to get a 'bonus' every 6 months, but these government mandated '13th/14th paycheck' schemes are really just employer-managed savings plans. Personally, I'd prefer to get my salary as I earn it and decide for myself how and when I spend or save it.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by raldi on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:55AM (#4228835)
Kinda sounds like the Spinal Tap amps that go up to 11. Why not just get paid a little bit more every month?
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by henrikschroder on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @08:19AM (#4228887)
I guess it's a result of a hundred years of slowly gained privileges getting added on top of each other, and bureaucratic rules muddling everything up every decade or so.

In Sweden, you accrue vacation pay as you work, and when you take your vacation, it's paid out and because of some law or other, it's larger than your regular monthly paycheck. So in essence you get a little bonus for having your paid vacation, same as a bunch of other countries that people have brought up in this thread.

However, if you're paid by the hour, it works exactly like you suggest. You don't accrue vacation pay or vacation days, and x% of your hourly pay is the included extra vacation pay which you just get straight up.

When you negotiate a monthly salary, the number is without the extra vacation pay, but when you negotiate an hourly salary it's with the extra vacation pay. Because, it's just the way it is. :-)

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by rickmb on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @09:39AM (#4229141)
Well, that's more or less how it works. The vacation bonus of 8% percent of your salary is reserved each month, it's just common to pay out at the start of the summer.

But paying out once a year is the legal minimum, you can agree otherwise. At my previous job, we switched to twice a year at the request of the snowboarders that needed the money for the winter vacation...

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by vidarh on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:56AM (#4228432)
Is it "extra", as in on top of the agreed yearly salary?

Norway has a similar thing, in that 10%+ of your salary gets paid out in a lump sum before the summer holidays, and the tax deducted in December is half what it is in the other months. But it's all just an adjustment in how salaries are paid out and when the tax is paid, so you end up with exactly the same total amount.

Of course either way, employers factor it in.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by tallanvor on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:47AM (#4228549)
I guess it sort of depends on your employer here in Norway? I get paid 1/12 of my base salary every month except for when vacation pay is paid out, and then we get an extra amount. So in reality I end up getting paid 2.6% above my base pay every year. --That doesn't include additional pay for on-call hours, bonuses, and such.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by mjwalshe on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:01AM (#4228712)
Its quite common in europe (but not the UK or IE) to get an extra months pay or two as a bonus. 13th Salary and 14th Salary.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by masklinn on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:35AM (#4228391)
Belgium has something like that, I'm not sure it's by law (it might just be working agreements), basically you get a "holiday bonus" once or twice a year, which amounts to about 70% of your (net) salary each time.

France has a slightly different concept (which is not universal by a long shot, but it's almost universal in some work domains) of 13th and (rarely) 14th months. Which are exactly what it says on the tin: you get 1 or 2 extra months of salary per year.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by molmalo on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:43AM (#4228533)
In several countries in Latin America (Brazil, Argentina, Uruguay, Venezuela, Colombia, Costa Rica, idk about others) you receive an extra monthly salary (a 13th month) by law. In some countries, you receive it all in one payment, in others (Argentina and Colombia I think ) you receive one half in July and the other in December.

You can learn more of this here: http://translate.google.com/translate?source=mog?sl=es&t...

Also, in Argentina, the norm is that you have 15 days of vacation when you start working for a company. After 5 years, you have 21 days, then after 10 years, 28. Finally, after 20 years in the same company, you get 35 days. Most probably, the ones getting 35 days work in banks, state owned companies or public service.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by ricardobeat on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:11AM (#4228460)
In Brazil you get a 13th month salary and 1/3 extra for vacation (they don't necessarily overlap in time).
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by Feeble on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:00AM (#4228580)
Welcome to Sweden, 30 days of paid vacation days and 12% extra salary during your vacation because vacation is always more expensive. As above, no-one would dare to contact someone on vacation here unless it is a complete emergency.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by GFischer on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @09:31AM (#4229119)
And I really believe everybody thinks he's more important/irrepleacable than he really is.

Right now, my boss and the 3 "senior" analysts are all on vacation... they aren't really missed. Reminds me of the cannibals joke ( http://www.guy-sports.com/months/jokes_silly_puns.htm ).

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by elorant on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:55AM (#4228568)
In Greece after three years of austerity measures we work at least 12 hours every day and if we manage go 10 days for vacations during summer we'd be happy. I guess that is a preview of what's gonna happen at the rest of Europe and US in the years to come.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by daliusd on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:24AM (#4228645)
In Lithuania after 4 years of austerity we work the same 8 hours and have 28 days for vacations. The only thing that was taken from us is holidays that matches with weekends (e.g. Mother day is on Sunday so we don't get free Monday anymore). We were in quite similar situation like you (in Greece) but our politicians did better job in the face of crisis.

Of course you are still richer than us (so maybe you should stop complaining?). BTW how do you feel about Estonia helping you? Overall looking from our side it looks like that a lot of wrong decisions have been made in Greece but you have made good choices recently. I think you will get better in the future. I doubt that something like that will happen in other EU countries.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by rmc on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @11:59AM (#4229778)
In Ireland after several years of austerity there are still the same legal holiday entitlements. There were a few months where the minimum wage was cut, but it was restored again. Taxes have increased slightly.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by lifeisstillgood on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @10:48AM (#4229431)
I would be really interested in what you think Lithuania's politicians did right and Greece's did wrong?

It would be very useful to see the diff

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by daliusd on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @02:55PM (#4230779)
At first let's list what's similar:

* Corruption level here and in Greece is quite similar in my opinion. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_Perceptions_Index . I think in recent years we got better but still far from perfect.

* We don't have Euro but we are pegged to Euro (de facto fluctuation 0%). IMHO in this regard we are similar to Greece - while we have freedom to change rate we have not used it.

* Both countries were not prepared for crisis if we compare them to Estonia as example.

In some aspects we were in very similar situation. Now what's different in my opinion: Austerity measures in Lithuania were very strict. We had so called "Reforms night" there our newly elected parliament made a lot of unpopular decisions (e.g. salaries decreased in public sector) and actually some of them of questionable long-term value while good in short-term (e.g. they cut payments for private pension funds what saved money in short-term but I have no idea what will happen in the future). Meanwhile in Greece it was really hard to do anything like that because everything they did was met with big opposition from society. As well little details like very early pension in Greece is not helping either. We had big buffer to go in debt without facing serious problem when borrowing money. Lastly we are still quite poor country and it is barely could be worse than it is sometimes :-) Greece is quite rich country.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by elorant on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:10PM (#4231737)
Austerity measures in Greece were also very strict. Greece is the only country in the developed world in the last fifty years that managed to lower the deficit by 5% in a single year. Salaries at the public sector have been reduced by 40%.

As for your last statement, we’re a rich country because we didn’t embrace communism as you guys did.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by daliusd on Thursday July 12, 2012 @01:02AM (#4233094)
Yes, they were quite strict in Greece as well but they were met with constant labor union strikes. I guess the main reason why we did better we had less to lose.

You are right about communism being the reason why you are rich and we are not but there was no choice for us (foreign army in our territory and we erased from map as independent country) so "embrace" is wrong word.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by krzyk on Thursday July 12, 2012 @06:35AM (#4233902)
Officially no, but your social policies (30hr work week, 1 week of paid by country vacations and others that were highlighted in the newspapers when the crisis started) place you even beyond former communist countries :)
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by aninteger on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:50PM (#4231685)
Estonia is helping Greece now? Do you have some news source?
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by daliusd on Thursday July 12, 2012 @01:04AM (#4233102)
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by valisystem on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:25AM (#4228648)
The proportion of public money burnt into corruption is much lower in the rest of europe and US. Whatever happens, it might not be great, but it's not likely to be as harsh as in Greece.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by elorant on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:48AM (#4228824)
Spain doesn’t have corruption as high as in Greece but they’re in deep shit already. Judging a financial crisis with stereotypes isn’t the best approach.

I don’t know if you heard lately about the Barclays scandal. Seems like we don’t have the monopoly of corruption after all. Even the almighty Brits fucked it up big time. Hoorah!

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by rickmb on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @09:58AM (#4229200)
Methinks there's a big difference between private crime and public corruption.

Besides, Britain is not falling apart because of the Barclays scandal, and unlike Greece, it isn't the entire country that is in on the scam.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by gaius on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:19AM (#4228757)
Yet in Germany, workers have 8 weeks vacation and work 8 hours/day.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by riffraff on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:26AM (#4228779)
I seriously doubt germans have 8 weeks of vacation (I think it's four and wikipedia seems to agree[0]) but maybe I am missing something, would you care to share some url about it ?

Because I am moving to germany if I get to not work for two months.

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_statutory_minimum_emplo...

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by maigret on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @09:02AM (#4229023)
Rather it is 6 weeks vacations + public holidays. 8 hours a day is a bit low, in IT you'll most probably do around 9 hours, not including lunch break.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by webjunkie on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:32AM (#4228663)
Maybe you tell other Greeks to pay taxes again.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by _delirium on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @08:08AM (#4228863)
Greeks actually pay more taxes, as a percentage of GDP, than Americans do (31% versus 27%). The main differences lie elsewhere, #1 being that the GDP that is taken out of is much lower, due to Greece having mostly a cottage-industry type economy (lots of small family businesses, few megacorps). That in turn has a lot of causes, some cultural, some historical, some due to excessively complex regulations (which have been streamlined in the past 10 years, but not fast enough).
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by maigret on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @09:03AM (#4229028)
The US is far from the path to debt free either - the difference with Greece is that they can print their own money. The US is trading low taxes against high inflation right now.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by Symmetry on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @10:21AM (#4229287)
Except our inflation isn't particularly high at the moment in the US, we were undershooting our 2% target for a while then the Fed printed a bunch of money (because they can't bring the Fed Rate below the IOR Rate) and now we're on target again.

EDIT: The fact that we could print money to get out of debt if we needed to is a big part of why we don't need to, though.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by tallanvor on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:55AM (#4228571)
I enjoy getting 30 days of vacation a year, and it's one of the reasons I have no plans to move back to the US anytime soon. But I know a lot of people who will still spend 30 minutes or so every other day to help keep their inbox under control so they don't have to stress about it when they get back. --There's nothing worse than coming back to 10000+ emails after 2 weeks and having to spend a couple of days making sure you don't miss anything vital (even after setting up rules to help make sure much of the stuff isn't needed.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by yogsototh on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:37AM (#4228672)
I heard that a technique at "France Telecom" to manage mail after holidays was quite simple.

1. Delete all mail 2. If it was important, they will contact you again.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by pjmlp on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:49AM (#4228825)
I know this technique in many companies I worked for.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by sbov on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:04PM (#4231477)
Sometimes I think this is how my boss handles all email.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by mjwalshe on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @07:05AM (#4228725)
Lol When I worked in international testing for BT I recall when working with my opposite number in FT totally unable to contact them in August.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by fauldsh on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:57AM (#4228574)
28 days is the legal requirement in the UK [1].

I'm getting 35.5 total which is reasonably uncommon but not unheard of.

Although paid paid holiday does sound pretty fantastic.

[1] -http://www.direct.gov.uk/en/employment/employees/timeoffandh...

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by rhplus on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @10:48AM (#4229428)
Note that the 28 days of 'time off' includes employee vacation and whichever public holidays the employer chooses to include. There are 8 public holidays in England and Wales, so the number of 'true' vacation days is usually closer to 20. In addition, the law says that the employer can decide when you take that time-off. For many blue- and white-collar jobs, that often includes about a week over Christmas and New Year where factories and offices literally shutdown, which may or may not gel with some people's personal choices.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by darklajid on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:18AM (#4228349)
Being based in Germany I just gave my wife the gist of the article/idea and she was literally shouting 'Hell, yeah' (okay, I translated this one) when I told her about the requirement to disconnect.

I know I could disconnect/drop off the grid in my free time, but I'm addicted. And what's the incentive to do so?

If, on the other hand, someone pays me good money for the promise of staying offline for 2 weeks: That sounds like a sweet deal to me, Europe or not.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by Tichy on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @05:37AM (#4228519)
Living on Germany, I meet people who can't disconnect all the time. So not sure how advanced we really are. Glad that 30 days of holidays are the rule, though.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by philbarr on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @06:36AM (#4228671)
> We appreciate our 22-30 days vacations, without any contact with the employer while enjoying friends and family.

Not in any company I've worked for. You're expected to answer emails, phone calls, etc. whilst on holiday. I used to follow along with this but now fight back by simply not taking my phone, laptop, or checking any emails but it's always frowned upon. Then again, it's not like they can sack me for it.

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by davidw on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:09AM (#4228331)
That's the traditional model, at least. I think it's falling apart. At least here in Italy, vacations like that are something that only a certain set of people can afford: those with traditional "Permanent Position" sorts of jobs, which, increasingly, is a smaller and older set of the population.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by drivingmenuts on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @09:10AM (#4229049)
In the US, workaholic is said as a bad thing, but a lot of of people within corporations expect it.
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by middus on Thursday July 12, 2012 @06:40AM (#4233921)
Here is another European data point (from Germany):

28 days paid vacation + Christmas Eve + New Years Eve + all national holidays (Christmas, Easter... ca. 10).

AFAIK 24 days are the minimum in Germany (cf. §3 BUrlG).

Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by ajuc on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @04:11AM (#4228337)
Where I live most bigger employers already give people some additional money for vacations (but nothing like 7500$, more like 200$-300$, so the OP idea is still good :) ).
Re:Paid Vacation? That’s Not Cool. You Know What’s Cool? Pai... by chiaro on Wednesday July 11, 2012 @03:36AM (#4228247)
How it should be.