News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by petre on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @03:17AM (#42113708)
He did the right thing. He's alive and well, fired from his command instead of deceased like the other servicemen in the OV-22 and FA-18D.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by GaryNumanVevo on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @03:50AM (#42113846)
The jet was fine, it kept flying for 64 miles. He probably ejected because there had been a recent osprey crash with causalities and he was scared.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by fragmede on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:07AM (#42113929)
64 miles sounds quite far, and I've gone quite fast on my motorcycle, but they tell us the F-35B can do 1,200 mph. At that speed though, that's just over 3 minutes.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by jyounker on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:45AM (#42114138)
But it didn't land itself, unlike the cornfield bomber: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornfield_Bomber
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by ExoticPearTree on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:47AM (#42114148)
According to the report, the jet flew for at least 11 more minutes. No one flies fighter jets at max speed unless absolutely necessary.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by fragmede on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @07:11AM (#42114913)
That's still a decent ground speed of 350 mph! Never gotten my bike to go quite that fast
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by HPsquared on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @08:26AM (#42115289)
I assume you also don't go max speed on your bike 99.9% of the time. (EDIT: this depends what kind of bike we're talking about I suppose)
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by fragmede on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @12:54PM (#42117861)
Why else go to the track‽
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by ayewo on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:55AM (#42114185)
From the article:

> The jet had flown for 11 minutes and 21 seconds after Del Pizzo’s ejection, slowly climbing as high as 9,300 feet.

After about 11 minutes, the report said, the jet banked down and started descending to its right, clipping the treetops of a forest along the way before crashing. The report said no one was injured by the crash, but it did damage several trees and crops. The $100 million jet was shredded into pieces and a total loss.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by xeonmc on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @08:57AM (#42115479)
To shreds you say? Well how were the trees? To shreds you say?
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by tgsovlerkhgsel on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @05:23AM (#42114317)
3 minutes is an eternity for something like a jet.

If a car drove at highway speed for 3 minutes without crashing after the driver jumped out, you'd be impressed too.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by stavros on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:22AM (#42114011)
"The jet kept flying for 64 miles" and "the jet was fine" are WILDLY different things.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by close04 on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @05:18AM (#42114291)
"The jet was not 100% fine" and "the jet was 100% unflyable" are WILDLY different things.

The question to ask in this case is "would the pilot's presence in the cockpit have made a difference to the possible outcome?".

In my reading of the article the jet could be controlled, and the pilot had access to the backup displays and communication systems. The plane flying such a long distance means the pilot reacted poorly under pressure and did the bare minimum as per the unclear procedures, before catering to his own safety. While not wrong according to the unclear procedure, you want more from someone commanding a squadron.

The pilot could have stayed put at the very least to attempt to mitigate the impact (pun intended) of the eventual crash, if not to actually land the plane using the backup instruments before ejecting to safety. That plane crash could have easily been a tragedy.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by ARandomerDude on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @10:54AM (#42116537)
Yes, for a Cessna or a 737. Not for a modern fighter.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by rightbyte on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @04:29AM (#42114055)
When an user reports buggy or glitchy behaviour I usually don't write it off as cowardice.

I had the same problem in the auto industry. Some times the test drivers were accused of imagining things or sabotaging when the problem could not be recreated.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by close04 on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @05:07AM (#42114237)
When your software crashes in a house it hopefully doesn't kill the whole family. Comparing the expectations from a pilot and squadron commander to a random user of a random software doesn't do any favors to the pilot and suggests you misunderstand the magnitude of the difference.

Even in the follow-up anecdote from the auto industry, a car test driver has vastly different profile than this pilot. They inherently work with untested vehicles and software, where the manual was not yet written. This pilot just followed the broadest interpretation of an existing manual.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by cwillu on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @05:25AM (#42114331)
He compared it to test drivers reporting faults in automotive software, not random software running on a pc.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by Vecr on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @06:09AM (#42114569)
The map is not the territory. Unless you can convincingly explain how your map would have been better in the situation, and together with his apparent dislike of dying would still have had you stick with the aircraft, he shouldn't be blamed.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by cwillu on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @05:24AM (#42114320)
“Better to die than to look bad” is one of the more toxic sayings associated with military aviation.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by close04 on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @05:52AM (#42114452)
Nothing in the incident report suggests the pilot's life was at any point in imminent danger, with the backup instruments functioning, and the plane being flyable.

He "technically" did well to eject only because the manual was too vague. But at the very least "I could have done more but technically didn't have to" is not what you're looking for in a squadron commander. Which is why he's still allowed to fly (he follows the manual) but not trusted with more than that (because those extras are not in the manual).

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by gambiting on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @07:00AM (#42114846)
Maybe I'm going out on a limb here, but I imagine the most straightforward explanation is the correct one - he ejected because he didn't feel safe flying this aircaft anymore. I cannot possibly imagine that any pilot would eject from an aircraft they felt comfortable flying, given that actually ejection is horrifically dangerous and is very likely to maim or kill you, with most pilots unable to return to active duty after ejecting. He wasn't sitting there going "well the plane is flying fine, but the manual says to eject so off I go I guess".
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by bluGill on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @10:05AM (#42115985)
Ejecting from a plane is dangerous. If you have control of the plane then you should be looking to do an emergency landing - there are typically acceptable landing places all over that can get you safely to the ground. I don't know how much control he really had, but it sounds like he had enough to land.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by conradfr on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @06:51AM (#42114791)
Maybe this pilot did not have the upmost faith in this aircraft.
Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by bumby on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @09:30AM (#42115734)
>with the backup instruments functioning

Tbf, the article describes them as "basically functioning". As someone with avionics experience, there's a lot of wiggle room in the word "basically" and I'd want to know the details about the remaining functionality before drawing any hard conclusions.

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by petre on Tuesday November 12, 2024 @02:26PM (#42118742)
I'm pretty damn sure he was thiking about the manual when his controls were glitching and decided to eject. Which also carries risk: his helmet and mask were ripped off and he had to drop the seat pan and raft in order not to get tangled in the power lines.

The Navy's contractors should sort out the glitches in their expensive space junk or build UAVs instead. What if this was a real combat scenario instead of an exercise, where the pilot didn't get to call 911 and risked getting captured by ISIS or some other maniacs?

Re:Marine pilot loses command after ejecting from F-35B that... by Ragnarork on Wednesday November 13, 2024 @06:09AM (#42124989)
There's a big difference between seeing the report in hindsight and being in that aircraft at that given time, having lost your HUD and electronics a couple times already, not ejected and carrying on for a while before deciding its probably too risky to continue operating the aicraft.

How would that pilot know for certain the aircraft was still flyable? That it technically was at that moment is absolutely not the point, and is only known retrospectively after analysis.

I unfortunately don't have anything to confirm that, but I wouldn't be surprised that the fact that it was an F35 didn't help that man's case, as in losing a cheaper piece of equipment would have been less impactful.