There is a very ugly mix of German and English we call Denglish in German.
And there are many "English sounding" things that are not English or also a horrible mix up for marketing purposes.
E.g. Handy for smartphone.
And then there is a similar concept as the Idiotenapostroph which is the Deppenleerzeichen which is a space between combined words that are usually and famously not separated by space in correct German.
All those things are usually used in amateurish marketing and look just like that to the average German grammar enthusiast.
On the other hand especially in many professional fields English conquers the professional slang with gusto of the participants. A very hilarious take on such Denglish for software developers: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=c2V4bOL1jgM
We feel you over here in Sweden. Särskrivning (roughly “word splitting”) is a “problem” far greater than the apostrophes for us. Americentric Swedish Android keyboards are terrible offenders that happily splits words in two.
This is how language evolves nowadays. :/
If they train the predictive text function on swedish text, I don't know why it would do English-y things, and if they didn't train it on Swedish how does it work at all?
It's very surprising, and interesting, to me that this category of problem, in this particular context, is even possible
In German it also knows Computer and Tastatur, but I can’t use autocomplete to type Computertastatur.
Actually I just learned I can. Apparently this word is in the dictionary. But there are just so many compound nouns, it’s impossible for them all to be in the dictionary.
To make it work in such a language it has to understand about constructing compound nouns.
Personally I think our "language culture" is overrated and I wouldn't care if Dutch just disappeared completely in favour of English.
Also In Swedish splitting the words is many cases not incorrect, but just changes the meaning.
For example is Swedish an "English teacher" (Engelsk lärare) would be a teacher that is from England, while an "Englishteacher" is a teacher the teaches the subject English.
So "He is an English teacher" and "He is an Englishteacher" would both be valid sentences in Swedish, but the predictive text model seems to assume you wanted the first one.
For clarity, we already called them Handy when they were phones but not smart.
I guess it's different when you grew up with those words and internalized them.
The worst I ever saw was an advertisement on a bar telling prospective patrons about the availability of "snacks´s". This is so wrong I can't even figure out how many distinct errors were made. (And yes, that's an acute accent, not an apostrophe.)
In English I’m actually ok with it for single letters or abbreviations- “your writing uses a lot of x’s and y’s”, “Can you pack away the CD’s and DVD’s”, but this is a personal quirk and definitely non-standard usage.
It might have looked 'modern' (or rather progressive) seventy years ago (or thirty years ago in the east); these days using proper German seems rather backward, dated or borderline fascist.
It got pretty absurd over the last decades though. My parents were complaining about the bill they got from Telekom -- why in the world were 'Ferngespräche' listed there as 'long distance calls' in a text otherwise (near) German?
Now, I would love to see more English being used in Germany, particularly in official communication as there are plenty of people here who's first language isn't German. But why not both? It's not that much more work. Denglish however belongs strictly banned into the realm of comedy (recently I've seen a gas station advertizing its "Power Sauger" :))
A lot of it is just (1) use of French loanwords to refer to EU-specific concepts (acquis is arguably the most famous), (2) use of genuine but rare English words – for example "subsidiarity", a word few English-speakers know, but the EU loves – but it isn't exclusive to the EU, Catholic theologians love it too (there is a whole section devoted to it in the Catholic Catechism), (3) the kind of common linguistic errors (false cognates, etc) which French speakers (and to a lesser degree, speakers of other EU languages) make when speaking English.
There are also some cases where it is hard to say if what is happening is (1) or (3), for example the use of the word "cabinet" (pronounced the French way) to refer to the office staff of a senior official
For whatever reason, it drives me crazy when I hear people refer to Pizzeria Uno as "Uno's". I've had conversations about it multiple times with different people in my family. There's no one named "Uno", it's a number! I try not to be a prescriptivist but for whatever reason this bothers me to an irrational degree, and I can't understand why nobody else notices.
For example, you you'd say "JCPenney stock is up by 32 cents this week," but you'd also say, "I bought this shirt at Penney's."
[1] https://classics.osu.edu/Undergraduate-Studies/Latin-Program...
Fred Meyer is also not "Fred Meyer's" but at least I can see why that would happen.
Then you have Vons, which used to be "Von's Grocery Company." I guess you go in there now and there's just more than one guy named Von in the store.
Ralphs also dropped the apostrophe.
Albertson's is now "Albertsons."
Kinda funny it seems like Americans are dropping the apostrophes. The exact opposite of what the article is talking about.
At least nobody is saying "Let's go to Costco's."
Also in the PNW, everybody called it "Penny's" for as long as I can remember.
Pedant Alert! The chain's name is "Uno Pizzeria & Grill".
You're not wrong, but the actual ordering of the name makes it less clear to a casual observer that there is no person named "Uno".
And the domain the company uses is "unos.com", so at the corporate entity has accepted the name.
Yeah, I've heard servers there say "welcome to Uno's", so I know I've already lost the battle. Like I said, it's not a rational annoyance though, so that doesn't make me feel any better when I hear it.
So calling it Uno's isn't inconsistent with how we talk about Walmart's stores or Google's website, for example.
No, calling it "Uno Corp's pizzeria" would be the equivalent. Nobody says they're "Going down to Walmart's" or "doing some research on Google's."
My family always used "Penny's" to refer to JC Penny. They also continued to refer to Macy's as Dayton's for years after they had changed their name because the locations were all the same, just the name had changed.
Its funny because I too always felt saying "Penny's" was a regional thing, but more of Midwestern thing.
I.e. Maccas vs McDonald's
Of course, the official website https://mcdonalds.com.au/about-maccas/maccas-story uses an apostrophe which is now making me have the same reaction as the Germans :( and makes me think it was run through some international filter :p outrageous!
some examples:
80s: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Downtown_Seattle_Pen...
70s: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:FW_Woolworth,_Penney...
60s: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Penneys,_Eastland_Ma...
50s: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:StateLibQld_1_46896_...
40s: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Seattle_-_Second_Ave...
Fun tangent: I learned pretty recently that the southern California grocery chain is named after a man with the last name "Ralphs," so it never had an apostrophe and indeed shouldn't have one (in any language).
I don't think there's a particular rule that a number can't act as a name like 007's movies. Or that the thing possessing has to be a person, eg. England's weather.
Note though that in German, "-s" is also a genitive suffix, it's just the spelling that's different here.
If you take away the words brought in by immigrants and invaders there is very little recognizable left.
>I'm not exactly worrying about "Haus" creeping into English to replace "House"
It's literally already the same word, we just spell it "wrong", likely out of French/Norman influence.
Could it be that we spell it differently because the word was adopted before spelling was standardised in either language?
This is not true at all. Most of the core vocabulary is derived from Old English. We’ve borrowed a ton of vocabulary to expand new concepts, but the core has remained relatively stable.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_English_words_of_Old...
It's not a big mystery or even particularly complicated, all regular rules of pluralization and the possessive case. I think people get tripped up in school because they see a specific affectation of dropping the S from possessive forms of the names of some historical personages, e.g. "in Jesus' name."
Edit: As a partially related aside, I have a friend who's right about the same age as me that's incredulous that I was taught to use "they" as a gender neutral pronoun when the subject's gender was unknown (or you desired not convey a gender) back in the late 80s and early 90s. Maybe it's just a regional difference in teaching or something. He's from the UP of Michigan, I'm from Florida. So maybe the same thing is true with possessive nouns
E.g. this
> The Deppenapostroph is not to be confused with the English greengrocer’s apostrophe, when an apostrophe before an ‘s’ is mistakenly used to form the plural of a noun (“a kilo of potato’s”)
This also happens in German these days even though in this context it makes almost no sense. And nobody is trying to copy McDonald's here.
I'm mostly curious whether "Rosi's" and "Kati's" in the article are seen by Germans as intentionally trying to look "foreign", rather than the apostrophe "invading" German.
Like, if I go to a Sausage Haus, I'm not exactly worrying about "Haus" creeping into English to replace "House". Nor would I ever call it the "idiot's house" because that would be crazy insulting and perjorative.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bob%27s