News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by ChrisMarshallNY on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:14AM (#41658028)
I used to love eating octopus, but since I've learned so much about their intelligence, I have not been able to bring myself to do so, anymore.

I have the luxury of choice. There are many, in this world, that do not.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by nerdponx on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:28AM (#41658811)
Consider the intelligence of pigs as well. Even if cows, sheep, deer, rabbits, chickens, turkeys, et al. all sit below the "I don't want to eat you" cutoff point, pigs should probably be above it.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by jdhzzz on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:57AM (#41659154)
Not doing that is why future generations will loathe me and my generation.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by squigz on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:41PM (#41661101)
If you're referring to not choosing to eat meat, I sort of doubt future generations will 'loathe' you - just as I don't 'loathe' members of previous generations who did things we've since learned better about.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by crooked-v on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:11PM (#41662041)
Yeah, generally when you see historical figures talked about like that it's people who were standout bad and criticized even in their own times, like Christopher Columbus.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by dhosek on Thursday September 26, 2024 @11:05AM (#41659233)
I’ve been able to give up eating cephalopods, but pigs are too delicious to give up.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by ep103 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:03PM (#41662635)
I try to eat meat to minimize the formula of:

cruelty_cow = IntModifier * Animal_Intelligence /(AmountOfProvidedMeat/Deaths) * FrequencyOfEatingThisAnimal

Solve for:

Min (cruelty_cow + cruelty_pig + cruelty_octopus + ...)

Where AmountOfProvidedMeat > NeededMeatForHealthyDiet

And Cost * AmountOfProvidedMeat < Food_Budget

I've generally found that maximizing on Fish, Chicken, and Cow (in that order) seems to be the best bet. I tend not to touch veal, lamb, or octopus.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by baggy_trough on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:04PM (#41662648)
A single walrus eats 4500 clams a day so let's hope they are low on pain awareness.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by nerdponx on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:35PM (#41663045)
One thing to consider about veal is that it's an unavoidable byproduct of the dairy industry. Veal calves do not need to be mistreated to become veal, but the plain fact is that they are also not going to be kept alive either. A male cattle that is not a breeding bull has no economic value until its corpse is processed, barring entertainment uses like rodeo.

If you refuse to eat even humane veal (free to roam and milk-fed), then IMO you should refuse dairy entirely.

It might also be worth considering that the entire concept of humane dairy is questionable. It depends on separating mothers from calves, and either eating the latter or weaning them at far too young an age, or both. Cows are dumb, but they're not that dumb, and more importantly they are prey mammals with strong "familial" instincts. The process is fundamentally at least somewhat cruel.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by Tijdreiziger on Thursday September 26, 2024 @05:42PM (#41663771)
Modulo some planning and adjusting of recipes, meat is unnecessary for a healthy diet, and a vegan diet tends towards 0 cruelty.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by rickydroll on Thursday September 26, 2024 @06:15PM (#41664096)
It all depends on the definition of a healthy diet. I have type II diabetes, and I eat low-carb as much as reasonably possible. A friend with A-fib and gets the best results from the low-fat vegan diet. I have a friend whose partner accumulates iron in her blood, so she does best with a vegetarian diet. If you have kidney disease, you need a diet with specific types of protein and a bioavailability level that you can't entirely get from plants.

The human body is an amazing thing that is simultaneously a fucking pain in the ass. There is no "one truth" for food.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by rickydroll on Thursday September 26, 2024 @06:20PM (#41664140)
I decided on pigs as the smart threshold because they were as smart as my dogs, and I would never eat my dog. Mutton, lamb, or chicken is no problem whatsoever. You grab them by the neck, stare deep into their eyes, and you will see the back of their skull.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by golergka on Thursday September 26, 2024 @08:16PM (#41664986)
You have to consider that eating meat or not is not matter of life and death for an animal. It's a matter of either living and then being killed, or not being born at all. When people don't eat meat, farmers don't breed the animals.

Now, you still might think that not being born at all is a better alternative, of course. I'm only pointing out it's a different dilemma.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by makeitdouble on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:48PM (#41665486)
Your point is correct, but it's also a view on life/death that is typically not accepted.

We don't look at human life in that lens, it's a whole can of worm, but we can agree that ending someone's life is viewed separately from whether that person could have not existed in the first place.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by steveoscaro on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:59PM (#41664882)
reminds me of Werner Herzog's classic rant on the stupidity of chickens..

"Look into the eyes of a chicken and you will see real stupidity. It is a kind of bottomless stupidity, a fiendish stupidity. They are the most horrifying, cannibalistic and nightmarish creatures in the world."

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by merry_flame on Saturday September 28, 2024 @11:04AM (#41680696)
The eye of the beholder... I've had hens understand how to jump on handles to open doors. Certainly, they lacked the subtlety to shut up once they started gobbling up food, but they knew how to open doors, creep in and stay silent until they reached the kitchen. Nobody trained them to do so, and they certainly had never tried jumping against doors before that happened. Not only did a hen figure out what we were up to with those door handles but suddenly, from one week to the next, each one of our 4 or 5 hens got the memo. I'd venture the guess that most humans find it more convenient to disparage whatever creature they happen to exploit.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by spaceman_2020 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @06:54PM (#41664431)
My wife is grossed out if I eat anything other than chicken or fish. She says that cow, goat, and pig feel too "present" to eat.

I begrudgingly agree.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Thursday September 26, 2024 @08:00PM (#41664887)
I mean they're all mammals, just like us.

Intelligence is just one thing we can consider when deciding what's morally acceptable to kill and consume. Genetic proximity to humans clearly matters to many people as well: lots of people stick to seafood and/or poultry despite the fact that octopuses and some birds can be quite intelligent.

Sociability could be a third factor. Pigs are smarter than dogs, cows are smarter than horses, but we choose not to eat dogs and horses because they more readily comprehend and obey our commands, enabling us to connect with them on a basic social level.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by shiroiushi on Thursday September 26, 2024 @08:53PM (#41665220)
>Intelligence is just one thing we can consider when deciding what's morally acceptable to kill and consume. Genetic proximity to humans clearly matters to many people as well: lots of people stick to seafood and/or poultry despite the fact that octopuses and some birds can be quite intelligent.

Sure, but it's pretty obvious that fish and chicken are very stupid animals, and those mammals are much smarter, so I'm not sure that genetic proximity is as important as you think it is. Octopuses are the only real standout here: they really are quite intelligent, which is even more remarkable because they're invertebrates. And yes, some birds are quite intelligent (like crows), but we don't eat those types of birds (probably because they're just not very good as food).

>cows are smarter than horses, but we choose not to eat dogs and horses because they more readily comprehend and obey our commands

Who's "we"? Horsemeat is very easy to find in restaurants here in Japan. It's not bad if cooked properly, but it's a lot like deer meat. Deer are pretty stupid too (probably about as smart as cows), but they aren't normally eaten either, and it's because most people just don't like the taste that much (it's "gamey"), and it's difficult to cook. Cows taste better than horses because they have a lot more fat.

Also, octopuses have been mentioned here many times, but in the US they aren't a terribly popular food item, whereas here in Japan they're very common (along with squid). So differing cultures and culinary traditions I think have a lot to do with it too, just as with horses above.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by naasking on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:15PM (#41665642)
> Sure, but it's pretty obvious that fish and chicken are very stupid animals, and those mammals are much smarter

Does "smartness" carry inherent moral worth? That would be an interesting principle to hold, given what it might entail for humans.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by shiroiushi on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:32PM (#41665713)
>Does "smartness" carry inherent moral worth?

Well that seems to be the assumption in this discussion thread.

>That would be an interesting principle to hold, given what it might entail for humans.

If you're implying that stupid people should be used as food, that's already been addressed elsewhere in this thread: cannibalism is very rare among other animals that are much stupider than us, and for good reason: there's a big risk of disease (such as prion diseases).

However, if we were visited by aliens that found humans tasty, the morality of offering up our stupidest members of society as food for them might be an interesting argument.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by naasking on Sunday September 29, 2024 @02:15PM (#41689226)
It's more that it justifies treating other human beings like we do animals. Not just for food, but sterilizing them, confining them, abusing them, etc. This is crossing right into the old tragedies of eugenics.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by GrantMoyer on Thursday September 26, 2024 @06:54PM (#41664430)
I feel the same way about some people.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by wut-wut on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:41PM (#41664757)
HA!
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by jjk166 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:47AM (#41659025)
I doubt there are many people in the world whose diets rely on eating octopuses. You'd need either an environment that had octopuses in abundance despite having little of everything else, or a selective method of fishing that primarily caught octopuses.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by diggan on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:44PM (#41661141)
> I doubt there are many people in the world whose diets rely on eating octopuses

Probably right (about the relying part), but eating octopuses is fairly common around the Mediterranean, at least the West side of it. Most restaurants have at least one item on the menu involving octopuses in some form or shape./

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by folmar on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:45PM (#41663162)
Octopuses are usually specifically fished [Cephalopods. Ecology and Fisheries, Peter Boyle, Paul Rodhouse. Chapter 16].
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by hagbard_c on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:21AM (#41658093)
They only live for 3 years or so, just eat them when they're close to kicking the bucket.

This short lifetime combined with their intelligence does raise the question how far an octopus could get if it were able to reach our age. Would they continue learning and adapting, leading to a race of superintelligent molluscs or would they plateau in their first year and just coast along?

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by HelloMcFly on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:18AM (#41658707)
Typically octopuses produce offspring only near the end of their life, so eating them at any point is destructive for their reproduction and species health.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by hagbard_c on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:20AM (#41658718)
Eat them after they reproduced then, they only do that once in their life.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by HelloMcFly on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:59AM (#41659175)
They typically die after reproducing. Mothers use their remaining energy to help their offspring survive, fathers sometimes do but not all - if you could somehow capture only post-mating male octopuses from species that don't sacrifice themselves for their offspring then sure, but that seems like an unrealistic expectation.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by timschmidt on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:49PM (#41665494)
So is growing billions of genetic clones of that one perfect fruit, but you know...
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by mellavora on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:46AM (#41659017)
except the mother has to care for her eggs until they hatch. So I guess we'd be fine only eating the males...
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by UncleOxidant on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:57PM (#41661263)
I suspect that would not be good eat'n. Female ocotopuses that have laid their eggs start to fall apart - you can see the skin peeling off of them. The females stay with the eggs until about when they're ready to hatch and then they just sort of go to pieces. The males, I suspect, suffer a similar fate after they've mated.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by ceejayoz on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:30AM (#41658173)
Anyone who likes the sound of that should check out Adrian Tchaikovksy's Children of Time trilogy, particularly the second one.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by doctorhandshake on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:09AM (#41658591)
Same here
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by tessierashpool9 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:43AM (#41658979)
just because something is intelligent is no reason not to eat it imho
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by colechristensen on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:57AM (#41659152)
This is an honest question, I'm not making a joke.

Why shouldn't we eat _you_ then?

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by ahartmetz on Thursday September 26, 2024 @11:13AM (#41659319)
The main reason for humans not eating one another is in-species nepotism, I believe. It's not very principled, but probably closest to the truth.

There is also don't mess with the effectively most powerful species on the planet whose members have collectively decided that (for somewhat principled reasons) none of them should be eaten.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by aeonik on Thursday September 26, 2024 @11:53AM (#41659892)
Disease is actually the main reason.

Any parasite, bacteria, virus, and especially prions spread much much more easily the closer the food is to your own biology.

Cannibalistic tribes have had issues with this in even the recent past.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by merry_flame on Saturday September 28, 2024 @11:07AM (#41680716)
Good point. This needs an update though now we know more about zoonotic spillover. Pigs, monkeys, bats, etc. should be off the list asap.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by tessierashpool9 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @11:06AM (#41659252)
while i do keep in shape and i'd certainly make for a juicy steak or filet, i doubt this culinary experience is worth ten years to life in prison.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by colechristensen on Thursday September 26, 2024 @11:09AM (#41659281)
Ok, one step up then, why should it be illegal?
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by tessierashpool9 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @11:18AM (#41659385)
i find your questions a little funny as i had this sort of conversation already dozens of times and i know where this is coming from and where it's going. i mean i've been a vegetarian myself for more than a decade (am not anymore) and i took pleasure in leading people who initiated discussions around it ad absurdum.

in germany there was a case of cannibalism many years ago where a guy known by the name Armin Meiwes slaughtered and ate another guy called Bernd-Jürgen Armando Brandes. never got the panic around it given that the whole deal was consensual. other than that you know yourself that society comes up with rules to ensure its stability and survival. eating each other wouldn't fly well from that perspective.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by colechristensen on Thursday September 26, 2024 @12:48PM (#41660587)
You could restate the golden rule as "treat others sufficiently like myself the way I'd like to be treated", not so long ago this wasn't applied to other humans who didn't look the same, but now it just seems reasonable to expand who the golden rule applies to beyond just species into... beings within a certain threshold of human intelligence. It is somewhat of a fundamental of morality, beings which are sufficiently intelligence deserve the same rights as I want for myself.

If you remove intelligence (or something quite similar) as the criteria, what do you have instead?

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by tessierashpool9 on Friday September 27, 2024 @03:30AM (#41667351)
so, you can eat mentally handicapped / retarded humans then?

<check-mate/>

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by csomar on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:04PM (#41660742)
It is not. It's illegal to kill the OP though.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by mock-possum on Thursday September 26, 2024 @12:21PM (#41660253)
prion disease shudders
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by csomar on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:02PM (#41660723)
Cannibalism is rare even among animals. That's probably why people don't eat other people. Otherwise, saying we can't eat animals because they are smart is dangerous. Some humans are not smart...
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by qup on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:25PM (#41662924)
Things will eat me, if I let them.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by energy123 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @12:59PM (#41660691)
Eating a carcass isn't a problem, throwing it into boiling water while it's still alive or clubbing it to death is the objectionable thing.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by 39896880 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @07:48PM (#41664802)
Let me ask a similar question as another user asked: what attribute do animals lack that, if a human also lacked, would justify eating a human?
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by kaxllca on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:27AM (#41658140)
A female octopus will try to eat the male octopus, so the intelligence is not at empathy or morality levels.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by ceejayoz on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:31AM (#41658195)
Empathy/morality isn't necessarily a requirement for intelligence, nor are the definitions of either easy to nail down.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by mellavora on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:54AM (#41659103)
It is hard to extend morality between species. The idea of parents sacrificing themselves for their children seems to resonate as highly moral, and is also a common pattern in biology.

But how it plays out, from humans where the male can provide more by continuing to live and "hunt/protect/teach"-- but at the risk that the "hunt/protect" might end his life, to spiders where (some species) the male gives his body to provide nutrition for the child,

well, who am I to say which is more moral?

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by webkike on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:32AM (#41658200)
Okay, but maybe they deserve it? Hard for me to tell since I’m not an octopus
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by drooby on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:39AM (#41658264)
The males die shortly after mating.. it's hypothesized that the males may even offer their body as nutrition...as a way to maximize their offspring's success.

So this adds another layer of wtf.

Doesn't really help moralize human behavior though.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by IG_Semmelweiss on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:13AM (#41658643)
Naybe a way for sustainable farming?

Breed octopuses, take the dead males who succesfully bred, and offer their meat with zero harm to the animal.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by ChrisMarshallNY on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:10AM (#41658605)
The Oatmeal talks about the male Angler fish: https://theoatmeal.com/comics/angler
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by lenerdenator on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:47AM (#41658365)
To be fair, it's not at the empathy or morality levels of humans that a lot of people consider "smart", either.

As for the female octopus trying to eat the male octopus, did I ever tell ya the one about my ex wife? Huh? Huh? crickets

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by kadgh on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:04AM (#41658527)
Excellent point, but a truly intelligent octopus species would set up a parliament and make laws that the male octopus must provide 10 fish per week to the female after mating instead of cannibalism.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by bmelton on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:15AM (#41658672)
Or perhaps the octopus regard us as under-evolved for having done similar
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by ChrisMarshallNY on Thursday September 26, 2024 @10:03AM (#41658521)
I was reading a fairly forgettable SF series, where one of the alien species is this giant centipede, that switches between “cooperative,” mode, and “competitive” mode.

When “cooperative,” they are your best buddy.

When “competitive,” you are fresh meat.

And you can’t tell when they switch.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by roughly on Thursday September 26, 2024 @11:25AM (#41659471)
Oh man, wait till you hear what humans do to each other.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by micromacrofoot on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:38AM (#41658260)
are you sure? maybe they feel really bad about it after
[dead]
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by ceejayoz on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:44AM (#41658330)
> via things like divorce rape

Touch grass.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by andai on Thursday September 26, 2024 @09:54AM (#41658428)
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by rimeice on Thursday September 26, 2024 @12:39PM (#41660490)
I know enough people who have made this exact same choice (myself included) for this to have its own name. Octoparian?
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by vasco on Thursday September 26, 2024 @01:53PM (#41661218)
You should try Polvo à Lagareiro or Pulpo a la Gallega, life is too short to not eat good food.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by marliechiller on Thursday September 26, 2024 @02:00PM (#41661294)
You should try eating young children, life is too short to not eat good food. That's what that sounds like to someone that opts not to eat something on the basis of its intelligence
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by vasco on Thursday September 26, 2024 @03:07PM (#41662004)
If my parents and everyone around me for thousands of years ate young children and they all told me it was legal and tasty and good for you, I probably would. But since it's not it'd seem you're making a false equivalency from the top of your horse.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by Intralexical on Sunday September 29, 2024 @05:57AM (#41686211)
Wasn't this kinda the plot of The Giver? Not eating, but killing.

It took them some work to undo the indoctrination. Middle-school me wasn't sure if that was right. But empathy is actually an involuntary instinct in most humans, and I think Lowry was right in that most people will find such things "evil" when faced with the its reality.

Of course in real life there are places and situations where it is normalized to harm children. E.G. Currently unfolding with Sean Combs. But anybody outside those situations rightfully considers that disgusting and aberrant on finding out, and those inside it find ways to bury and rationalize their discomfort and end up traumatized for it instead of actually thinking it's good.

Either way, analogy is not false equivalency. And neither are OP's moral decisions an indictment of your culinary preference, nor does your culinary preference have any bearing on OP's morally motivated decisions.

Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by jjk166 on Thursday September 26, 2024 @02:34PM (#41661643)
There are a lot of second order benefits to eating irish children, I think most would consider such a proposal modest.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by drawkward on Thursday September 26, 2024 @02:17PM (#41661458)
well, except for the switch to cannibalism.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by inkcapmushroom on Thursday September 26, 2024 @04:21PM (#41662869)
They already said they used to love eating octopus. You reply they should try eating octopus because it's tasty. They already tried it before and decided to give it up for reasons beyond how it tastes.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by vasco on Thursday September 26, 2024 @06:25PM (#41664180)
Yeah but in case they didn't try the best dishes they might not know the extent of what they are missing.
Re:Octopuses seen hunting together with fish, punching those... by Intralexical on Sunday September 29, 2024 @05:39AM (#41686124)
I had a bit of tentacle float up in some seafood soup once. Felt like seeing a small severed finger, wrecked my appetite for that meal immediately.