News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by logifail on Thursday September 12, 2024 @03:42PM (#41524695)
(Genuine Q): Why are people - or even just HN readers - really so interested in living longer?

Both my father and my father-in-law have dementia.

My father's dementia is fairly advanced (he doesn't know who I am and hasn't for a while, there are times where he doesn't know who my mother is) although he's still living at home.

My father-in-law's dementia is less advanced although he's much more frail as he was diagnosed with bladder cancer, had it removed, so has ended up with the whole tubes+bags "solution".

My OH and I were discussing this for the Nth time last week.

Apologies for being blunt, but our current perspective is this: try make your life count, and hope for it to end cleanly. Via Dignitas, if necessary.

There is no way I want to see out my final years in the way that my father or my father-in-law are doing now :(

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by switchbak on Thursday September 12, 2024 @03:53PM (#41524801)
The people in this space talk a lot about not just life span, but health span. I don't know anyone who wants to suffer for a long time, of course we'd want to live well.

I know for myself, I'd love to be around to watch my kids grow up. Even better if I can do that while being old-man jacked and physically capable enough to still enjoy life. I don't think this has to mean that you're putting off enjoying life in the current moment though.

It seems like a funny question to ask who's "interested in living longer"? Taken to an extreme that's a pretty depression question.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by a13n on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:30PM (#41525184)
Survival instinct is deeply hard wired into all animals, including humans. It's natural to want to continue living.

Anti-aging is picking up now because there's a growing belief that significantly extending the healthy human lifespan is within scientific/technological reach.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by logifail on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:37PM (#41525265)
> Survival instinct is deeply hard wired into all animals, including humans.

Survive and reproduce...

So if/when one has the reproduction bit out that of the way, the survival bit as such may not seem to be quite as vital.

You know your genes are going to survive, meaning you don't personally have to. Which is the whole point of evolution, right?

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by stickfigure on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:03PM (#41525552)
Evolution is not a motivational poster or a speech from your therapist. It's just the outcome of a physical and biological process. It just is.

I personally would prefer to survive longer. If you don't, that's your business.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by logifail on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:23PM (#41525736)
> I personally would prefer to survive longer. If you don't, that's your business.

Ideally I'd die in my sleep 75-80 +/- a few years having seen some grandkids. Doing daft stuff now to push that number further out just seems pointless.

The next generations will have enough problems to deal with without having one more cranky 90+ year-old constantly popping pills claiming he can live forever.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by shermantanktop on Thursday September 12, 2024 @06:51PM (#41526462)
And voting.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by a13n on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:03PM (#41525548)
I don't know that we have evidence that survival instinct goes away after reproduction. It's still valuable to our species to survive after reproduction in order to protect and nurture offspring, for example.

There's no evolutionary reason that survival instinct would turn off after a certain age.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by logifail on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:12PM (#41525634)
> There's no evolutionary reason that survival instinct would turn off after a certain age

Umm, without wishing to get too clinical or morbid, it's clear that once your offspring have reached adulthood there will always come a point beyond which you rely on them more than they rely on you, right?

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by inglor_cz on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:50PM (#41525411)
"Which is the whole point of evolution, right?"

Pretty much the entire point of civilization is not to be at the mercy of natural forces, including evolution.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by logifail on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:57PM (#41525484)
> Pretty much the entire point of civilization is not to be at the mercy of natural forces, including evolution

The parent to my comment did bring up "survival instinct" (!)

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by inglor_cz on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:03PM (#41525550)
Sex, hunger, sleep are all instincts, but civilization tries to make their satisfaction nicer, safer, cheaper, more reliable.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by onemoresoop on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:31PM (#41525805)
I'd trade length of lifespan for quality in a heartbeat. Getting old is not very pleasant. I'm already starting to feel the creaks and decline merely in my mid 40. I'd love to have more time now but do have to work and when/if I will be able to retire I will be too worn out and lacking the desire to do the things I'd do know with that time. I'd be content to live healthily till say 65-70. My mom who is at that age is saying that she used to say the same thing when she was young but she no longer things like that. I guess we all do have some survival instinct kicking in no matter what we rationalize prior.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by r00fus on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:41PM (#41525877)
Why does quality and lifespan have to be a dichotomy? In fact the more I think about it, living a quality lifestyle often leads to longer life (eating healthy, keeping fit, having meaningful friendships).

Both my wife and I have signed the papers to decline extended life in a vegetative state and have confirmed our desires with our kids.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by shermantanktop on Thursday September 12, 2024 @07:10PM (#41526606)
The aging process will have the final word, but it’s a process. Nobody is healthy one day and in vegetative state the next.

It’s a good idea to live a healthy life, but you are merely shifting the odds. Many a health nut has hit 60 and found themselves with new problems every year, and each one is a small thing, but it adds up.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by amanaplanacanal on Thursday September 12, 2024 @11:11PM (#41527758)
I'm 67, and I'm sure as hell not ready to go yet. Of course, anybody could go at any time, so live while you can!
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by elzbardico on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:08PM (#41524976)
Nobody expects to live longer and have dementia. People are betting that they will escape that and there's a good probability that they will do. Not to mention that if you are around your 30s or 40s it would be terrible to not care about your general health just to find out in the next 10 or 20 years that science found a cure to dementia but now your body is too much fucked to take advantage of that.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by logifail on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:24PM (#41525128)
> Nobody expects to live longer and have dementia

I think we can generalise that statement to "nobody expects to have dementia". Until you get it :/

There are people taking lots of vitamins, but with apologies to any vitamin-takers, that hypothesis seems to have been thoroughly debunked.

For healthy adults, taking multivitamins daily is not associated with a lower risk of death https://www.nih.gov/news-events/news-releases/healthy-adults...

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by klingoff on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:47PM (#41525375)
Cabbage also doesn't work, but what does that have to do with a theory that:

Metformin exerts a substantial neuroprotective effect, preserving brain structure and enhancing cognitive ability.

We obviously want additions or replacements to physical and mental exercise depending on how much we get.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by elzbardico on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:46PM (#41525364)
Living is risky, yeah, I know it. A lot of it is a fucking gamble, your profession, the place you decide to live, the people you enter relationships with.

Nothing is assured.

Yeah, maybe we will be all unemployable and miserable due to LLMs taking our jobs and failing to create others. Maybe we shouldn't have reproduced as our kids will never get to become adults due to a nuclear war or a fucking serious pandemic with a virus that will make SARS-COV-2 look like nothing.

Who knows?

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by barrucadu on Thursday September 12, 2024 @03:46PM (#41524730)
Obviously the idea is to live longer with good mental and physical health.

There's no point in living longer if your faculties are too degraded to enjoy it, you may as well just be dead.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by Jach on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:09PM (#41525603)
I guess it's not so obvious if GP is the top comment. It seems broader messaging around anti-aging needs to be even better (nothing against the paper). Sometimes I like the jargon of negligible senescence and longevity escape velocity, because I don't think it's possible to know the meaning of those phrases and also think the goal is eking out as much substandard life as possible, so if you can't have a two-way conversation at least you can put in a semantic roadblock that invites a curious reader to look up the meaning and then not have the GP's question.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by elzbardico on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:19PM (#41525078)
I find life awesome. I truly fucking enjoy it. I am not rich, I can't retire and probably will never be able to do so, but I also enjoy my work even if not all the time. I think the world is moving towards a terrible inflexion point, I think we are in a fucking crisis right now, and still, fuck that. I don't want to leave this boat.

Now that said, I completely accept that not everyone shares my point of view, and I also accept that probably I wouldn't understand their reasons for doing so.

Maybe you should stop worrying about it. Some people would eagerly take any opportunity to live a few more years, it makes no sense to you, but it makes to them. It is not like they are forcing you to also live more than what you want.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by Unbeliever69 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:38PM (#41525852)
I totally get where you're coming from. I voluntarily left the workforce and now we live off my wife's income as a public school teacher. She’s got about 15 years until retirement, and while we’re not rich, we’re definitely comfortable. Surprisingly, we’ve managed to do better financially on a single income than we did with two.

Leaving the traditional workforce was an easy decision for me. COVID had me working from home, and my startup didn’t make it through the pandemic—raising capital was tough. Once I experienced working from home, I knew I couldn’t go back to the office or work for anyone else.

I feel the same way about retirement. While my wife supports us financially, I support her by managing the household. I take care of the pets, make her lunch, clean, help with her lessons and emails, and handle groceries and errands. I really enjoy this role. It frees me up to work on personal projects like novel-writing and developing a SaaS product I’m passionate about.

I get a lot of satisfaction from making my wife’s life easier, especially since being an elementary school teacher is no walk in the park. Thanks to my support, she’s been able to raise over $60k for a unique program at her school in just two years. She’s sharing her success stories at conferences worldwide, and seeing her thrive makes me happy too.

I’m not spending my time golfing or vacationing. I keep my mind sharp and enjoy the work I do. Yes, I worry about the future—like the fear of being so sick that I become a burden, and no, I don’t have enough saved up for that possibility.

I feel like my generation (X) is in a tricky spot, but for now, I’m content.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by rileymat2 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @03:51PM (#41524775)
I am not sure if it would map to dementia, but:

> The results highlighted a significant slowing of aging indicators, notably a roughly 6-year regression in brain aging.

And some people call Alzheimer's type 3 diabetes. So there could be something protective?

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by transitionnel on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:32PM (#41525207)
Diabetes causes rupturing of small blood vessels, which has been seen in eyes and feet. It would follow that the same is happening in the brain and an anti-diabetic medicine would directly improve brain longevity in affected individuals.

*I am not a doctor, but also I can correlate data without bias.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by pdimitar on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:13PM (#41525010)
Why are you conflating long lifespan with miserable last 10-20 years of the life?

I aspire to be like that French gym trainer who was in near-perfect health and an optimal presence of mind at 96 years old when he died suddenly (I think of heart attack).

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by tempestn on Thursday September 12, 2024 @03:49PM (#41524757)
As others said, obviously the goal is to live longer in good health. As for why, because.. I like living. Why would I not want to do it for longer?
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by fnordpiglet on Thursday September 12, 2024 @03:54PM (#41524810)
I care more about being healthier longer. And I’d like that to last as long as I can and not a lot longer necessarily. It’s because I love life because it’s life, and wouldn’t mind if it went on for a long time. I could learn so many things.

But, even if it’s 60 years I want them to be healthy. So I do the things I am supposed to to age more slowly because aging is causative to ill health. My things I do is eat reasonable amounts of healthy food and exercise regularly. I supplement a few things like magnesium and taurine, that I specifically do better taking than not.

But if they came out with a “never age until you die” pill I would take it immediately.

But I think you’re confusing long life with long health span. I don’t think anyone dreams of living a long full life is hellish degenerative ill health.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by riehwvfbk on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:16PM (#41525049)
So who will pay for your long healthy life? The default answer is: you will, by working longer. Any other answer has this problem: why is this magic source of funds not currently available to cover even our current shorter lifespans?

OK, so we've established that you have to continue working. Are you sure that you as a geriatric man on artificial life extension will be competitive with a younger guy who can go crazy and use the same tech to, say, never sleep - never mind that he'll die at 40? And even if we aren't talking extremes: you as a pill-supported walking corpse have to be ever vigilant of your own mortality. Someone younger can afford to take more risks.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by daedrdev on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:27PM (#41525771)
Your argument is easily applied to all medical advancements, do you think we should stop using antibiotics? Vaccines? Maybe you should let the individuals determine what's best for themselves instead to trying to prescribe your strange anti capitalism ideology for them.

Anyway medical research is focused on giving us on better quality of life as we age, which is what people objectively value, not whatever you think they are trying to do.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by logifail on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:43PM (#41525887)
> Anyway medical research is focused on giving us on better quality of life as we age

Polite correction: medical research is focussed on returns for those funding said research.

Treating Americans is definitely a cash-cow for Big Pharma, indeed if a potential new drug can't/won't make it past the FDA then it will likely be killed off regardless of what the rest of the world might want/need/approve.

Check out US healthcare spend per capita compared with everywhere else on the planet.

(Source: friend in Big Pharma)

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by gamepsys on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:02PM (#41524895)
Life is great, who wouldn't want more of it?

I'm old enough to see some the advances in medical care different family members were able to receive when they became very ill over the decades. I'm young enough to be optimistic that when it's my turn the treatments available will be even more significant.

There's a certain quality of life I wouldn't want to spend a prolonged time in. I understand your point about not wanting to be in bad health. Most of the activities I do that will likely prolong my life (diet, exercise, manage stress, build social bonds, supplements, pharmacology, screenings) will also increase my likelihood of prolonging the amount of time I have in good health.

Why am I interested in living longer? I think it's better than the alternative.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by darby_nine on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:05PM (#41524935)
> I think it's better than the alternative.

I mean, why? Longer lives are not necessarily any happier. In fact, old age seems pretty physically miserable.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by elzbardico on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:11PM (#41524998)
This is personal and depends on your perspectives. Obviously the people who want to live longer don't share the same point of view as you. And it is ok, as long as you are not forced to adopt their point of view and vice-versa.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by gamepsys on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:10PM (#41524990)
There's miseries in all stages of life. I've known people that still enjoyed life into their 80s and even 90s. I'm not very afraid of being physical uncomfortable, and I enjoy being here enough to want to fight for more time.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by mullingitover on Thursday September 12, 2024 @03:56PM (#41524827)
The bigger problem with extending lifespans beyond what evolution has optimized for is that you end up competing against your offspring for resources, and you give pathogens a non-moving genetic target to attack (which defeats the whole point of sexual reproduction).
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by inglor_cz on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:00PM (#41525520)
"you end up competing against your offspring for resources"

This was relevant in the pre-agriculture era. We already live in densities several orders of magnitude higher than evolution optimized us for.

I am more concerned about the somewhat artificial societal resources, such as top jobs. We might get a very ossified elite. We almost saw a presidential election with two ancient guys competing. With longevity widespread, this may become a pattern.

"you give pathogens a non-moving genetic target to attack"

True, but we generally try to manage new infectious diseases by scientific means, not by "0.6 per cent of population is resistant to this, let the rest croak". See: AIDS, Covid.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by mullingitover on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:38PM (#41525858)
> This was relevant in the pre-agriculture era. We already live in densities several orders of magnitude higher than evolution optimized us for.

I mean, keep in mind that we're living in a snapshot of time that's very much not stable or sustainable. It's like we're all embers born in a massive forest fire that started a few days ago. Everything seems normal and stable for us in this situation because our frame of reference is effectively a few seconds. However, this forest fire will eventually consume all the available fuel and things will return to baseline, no matter how hard we fantasize that we're going to somehow spread the forest fire to other planets.

Any temporary victories we've made over evolution are just that. We've already seen how absolutely vicious pathogens can be toward monoculture biomasses. Just ask the Gros Michel banana.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by inglor_cz on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:55PM (#41526001)
Yeah, of course tomorrow a global plague may eradicate us all, or "all except Sentinelese people".

Nevertheless, looking at our prehistory, the worst bottleneck of the human race was probably some 900 thousand years ago, way, way before we had anything resembling civilization.

https://www.nhm.ac.uk/discover/news/2023/august/human-ancest...

So, at least for me, the question of whether we are more resilient as civilization vs. as primitive people in their pristine state, is very much open. Too many people seem to be sure that going with the natural flow is long-term better. But it feels a bit like the Noble Savage myth reiterated for current sensibilities.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by lottin on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:13PM (#41525639)
What makes you think that our current life expectancy is optimal?
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by jjk166 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:53PM (#41525990)
Not if your offspring also live longer.

You have kids at 1X, Grandkids at 2X, die at 3X, doesn't matter if X=25 or X=30 or X=100, the population dynamics are the same.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by riehwvfbk on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:01PM (#41524877)
The people who want to extend their lives are the ones whose lives tend to be pretty good. The CEO plotting world domination kind of archetype. The rest of us are expected to be expendable biorobots who serve them. Unfortunately, this won't play out the way their fantasies tell them. The rich and powerful will be trapped by the need to always maintain their fragile lives. This in turn will slow down progress and open up the gates to a younger and more daring group to come to power.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by datavirtue on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:37PM (#41525264)
This is true. Shifting a populations life expectancy up to suspend biological aging would be a panic moment for most governments that are tied to huge benefit systems based on age. Good luck changing the retirement age, again.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by non- on Thursday September 12, 2024 @03:51PM (#41524778)
The exciting thing about these findings is not that the monkey's live longer, it's that their brains aged slower.

---

Highlights:

• Metformin prevents brain atrophy, elevating cognitive function in aged male primates

• Metformin slows the pace of aging across diverse male primate tissues

• Metformin counterparts neuronal aging, delivering geroprotection via Nrf2 in male primates

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by iwontberude on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:07PM (#41525578)
• Metformin-associated lactic acidosis has an estimated death rate of up to 50%.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by giardini on Friday September 13, 2024 @01:14PM (#41533137)
So... don't overdose?
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by iwontberude on Saturday September 14, 2024 @10:57PM (#41544849)
It can build up over time and requires regular blood work.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by yieldcrv on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:13PM (#41525009)
I don’t want to live longer with dementia

I want the entire system to have longer maintenance and repair: skin smooth, head of hair, muscles not atrophied, bones not brittle, oxygenated blood circulating and keeping a brain well functioning without its own independent deterioration, risk of cancer mitigated, but also easily repairable if its occurring

I look at the London borough checklist of what people died from in the 1600s, and it makes me optimistic that the things people currently die of will be solved

I just don't want to be felled by those things. Its nice that solving for them includes a high probability of centenarian lifespans, I’m fine crossing that bridge when we get there.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by ceejayoz on Thursday September 12, 2024 @03:46PM (#41524732)
I mean, we want to live longer and not get dementia.

I wanna know what happens. I want to download my brain into a computer and see what humanity does over the next couple million years.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by highwaylights on Thursday September 12, 2024 @03:51PM (#41524777)
Even if that were possible, and theoretically we could take the entirety of a person's brain and emulate every synapse into digital storage, along with enough compute to run everything (which is a massive hurdle to overcome), would it really still be you?

I kind of think about it a bit like the transporter deck from Star Trek. Are those people really travelling somewhere else or are they getting cloned and then done like Hugh Jackman at the end of The Prestige?

How would anyone even know? A computer simulated you would seem like you to everyone else, but you'd already be gone.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by ceejayoz on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:18PM (#41525068)
> How would anyone even know?

If no one can ever know, I'm not sure I care. Transport me to cool places all you like.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by incongruity on Thursday September 12, 2024 @03:57PM (#41524842)
Worse, still, unless the current me blinks out of existence, "old me" will still be around - unless we can replace neurons in-place with computational analogs, the original me is destined to die, almost no matter what, even if a copy/download is made. From the download's perspective, it continues, but the original, if not ended then and there, still faces a grim end and will know it.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by ceejayoz on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:17PM (#41525061)
If painless (or I don't remember it), I'm 100% fine with a fairly speedy destructive upload process.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by highwaylights on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:20PM (#41525709)
You won't remember it as you'll cease to exist at all is the point.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by ceejayoz on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:45PM (#41525903)
My consciousness gets interrupted on a nightly basis. One more will be fine.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by incongruity on Monday September 16, 2024 @09:07AM (#41555689)
Yep. Part of me is terrified every time I go to sleep -- but the sleepiness wins.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by nikkwong on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:42PM (#41525328)
The correct answer is that there is no "you". Continuity in consciousness is an illusion that can be deconstructed through deep enough meditation, or more accessibly through psychedelics. It certainly feels like there is as "you" at the center, but what you call "you" is sort of a narrative that your brain is stitching together at each moment, and it can be subject to distortion, revision, reinvention.

You are not the same "you" from moment to moment--you are just reassembled by your brain every second in a way that feels conscious. So I would say there is a false dichotomy in the center here. If "you" are already an illusion, digital emulation just manipulates that illusion in different ways. Whether or not "you" survive in a literal sense is not the right question, there was not a fixed "you" to keep or lose in the first place

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by cbsks on Thursday September 12, 2024 @06:24PM (#41526287)
I’m in the middle of a sci-fi book that explores this. The answer is that you won’t be the same person. Your mind will meld with the computer’s AI and you will go insane and try to exterminate the human race. I wouldn’t risk it.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by logifail on Thursday September 12, 2024 @03:56PM (#41524829)
> we want to live longer and not get dementia

...but why? Dying is natural. Dying is normal. It's what's supposed to happen.

> I wanna know what happens

I've reproduced three times so I've ticked that particular biological box.

My OH is away this week. Our eldest cooked lunch on Tuesday when a meeting I was in ran over by an hour. I stumbled into the kitchen an hour later than planned to find the three of them eating what he'd prepared from what he'd found in the fridge and he'd made enough for me, too. They're pretty well set.

> I want to download my brain into a computer and see what humanity does over the next couple million years

I'm absolutely, completely OK with not doing that :)

I'm confident the next generation will figure it out, just like ours did, and the one before us, and so on...

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by lucb1e on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:06PM (#41524953)
It's also natural and normal to die in infancy, but we've solved that and I don't hear many complaints

Edit: looked it up, 49% is the estimated rate for hunter-gatherer societies and 48% until ~200 years ago (depending on the country, may also be ~60% or as "low" as ~40%). In 1950 it was still more than a quarter; only within living memory has it truly become abnormal to die soon after birth. https://ourworldindata.org/child-mortality

This argument of what's "natural" holds so little water to me, I don't understand in what state of belief anyone even brings this up. Is this a religious thing? Why say "it's natural to die and therefore we should always continue to do so"? Arguments of overpopulation, psychological issues (and unknown unknowns), and other real problems, I can certainly understand, but "it's natural"? Please explain

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by ceejayoz on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:16PM (#41525058)
> It's what's supposed to happen.

I wear glasses, clothes, and my kids were born three months early. I, and they, were supposed to die.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by dangus on Thursday September 12, 2024 @03:50PM (#41524769)
People want more healthy years.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by logifail on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:05PM (#41524926)
> People want more healthy years

...but that doesn't really answer why, does it? To "do more stuff"? To "see more things"? To "earn more money"? To "learn more"? Why?

A friend wasn't enjoying her job a year or two ago and said she felt seriously underpaid for the stuff she was being asked to handle. I asked her if she would feel any happier if they doubled or tripled her salary. After thinking about it she realised the amount of money wouldn't fix the problem, the issue was with the work environment, not the monetary package tagged on to her employment.

Life is finite.

So at least for all of us who don't have some desperately unkind medical issue that specifically shortens it, maybe we need to take a deep breath and learn to deal with that.

"Carpe diem", and all that.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by jjk166 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @06:03PM (#41526094)
> To "do more stuff"? To "see more things"? To "earn more money"? To "learn more"? Why?

Yes, to all of it.

Life will still be finite with a longer life, but more is more. If offered the opportunity to have your lifespan shortened for no gain would you take it? Obviously not, and likewise if you have the opportunity to increase your lifespan for no cost, it's exactly the same decision.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by dangus on Friday September 13, 2024 @11:43AM (#41532260)
Learning to deal with mortality and wanting more healthy years are not mutually exclusive.

I can’t really think of any downside to having more healthy years. Yeah, do more stuff, see more things, learn more.

Why? Because it’s enjoyable.

And why do I need a reason?

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by willcipriano on Thursday September 12, 2024 @03:56PM (#41524834)
Are you the sort of person who feels life is awesome?

Knowing the name of a assisted suicide company off the top of your head seems to suggest not.

If you were, why would you want that to end?

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by rscho on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:34PM (#41525226)
IMO, americans are very afraid of death, for some reason. Much more so than europeans or Asians, in my experience. So there's a culture of lasting as long as possible, including through very debilitating treatment. It was my biggest surprise from a healthcare culture standpoint, when I went to practice in the USA.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by imarg on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:06PM (#41525571)
I think this comment generalizes too much. I do not think Europeans are all the same on this (and probably Asians too).

As an example I have the impression that what you wrote is true for Dutch people (I don't know if it's true but I've heard/read they are more on the side of making elderly people comfortable in their last moments rather than trying to treat them with expensive procedures).

While here in Greece we do try to prolong the life of even the most hopeless situations (that might be changing). It's not rare to have our elderly parents/grandparents bedridden at home for years.

Of course I might be generalizing also.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by rscho on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:11PM (#41525626)
Yeah. It's just my experience. Not claiming anything beyond my personal perception. In my country, we also tend to put quality of life first.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by 4star3star on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:09PM (#41525601)
Partly, I think that the culture is more affected by the lack of history than most people realize. If you've lived in Europe, and I'm sure elsewhere, you understand your mortality implicitly from the centuries-old buildings and streets. At least that's what I got out of it.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by numpad0 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:04PM (#41525562)
Doubt it, besides there aren't a lot of reasons for us all to not just casually choose death had it been for humans' innate fear of death, which I think is kind of good thing.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by dgfitz on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:37PM (#41525262)
Wow. Hope you went back to wherever you came from.

What a fucked up thing to say.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by rscho on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:01PM (#41525522)
Yes, I went back to a country with socialized medicine where patients as well as doctors are still relatively courteous to each other. It was a huge relief to leave the US, professionally speaking. BTW, I don't really get why you're so riled up.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by stickfigure on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:05PM (#41525570)
If my doctor said "don't be afraid of death", I would get a new doctor.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by rscho on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:17PM (#41525682)
It's natural to be afraid. I'm afraid too, at times. But people are only willing to suffer so much. In this regard, US people offer an interesting contrast: they tend to view as normal not to suffer at all in routine care (minor surgery, for example), but are willing to accept an incredibly bad quality of life in desperate situations. In Europe for example, it tends towards the opposite. Again, I'm just one guy. YMMV.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by stickfigure on Thursday September 12, 2024 @08:59PM (#41527184)
I'm not paying my doctor to be a therapist or a rabbi. I am paying for the best medical care I can get - and if I want to prolong my life (in whatever condition), that's my choice.

When I hear "don't be afraid of death", that's not medical advice. Medical advice is "there's nothing I can do for you", which is fine, but I'm going to shop for a second opinion. Maybe a third.

For the record, I'm not afraid of death, I just want to postpone it for as long as possible. If medical technology allowed, I'd be very happy with "indefinitely".

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by rscho on Friday September 13, 2024 @03:27AM (#41528848)
> I'm not paying my doctor to be a therapist or a rabbi. I am paying for the best medical care I can get - and if I want to prolong my life (in whatever condition), that's my choice.

Not saying anything else.

> When I hear "don't be afraid of death"

Didn't say that either!?

You're assuming opinions, here. Also, 'healthy' life prolongation was not my point. There's a personal threshold for everyone where people just prefer dying. It can be lower or higher, and my observation is that it's heavily influenced by local culture.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:40PM (#41525294)
What he is saying is true, doctors and everyone else involved try to squeeze as much money as possible from dying people.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by rscho on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:08PM (#41525594)
I don't really have a comparative opinion about that. What I mean is that I've seen countless examples of US patients and docs willing to go to extremes of treatment that would be considered unreasonable elsewhere. But I was just a bloke in one big university hospital, so YMMV I guess. Still, the culture gap was pretty surprising.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by asimovfan on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:48PM (#41525385)
What's fucked up about it? I didn't get it?
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by dgfitz on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:05PM (#41525567)
That American humans are more scared of dying than other humans. Almost seems… well…
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by homebrewer on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:11PM (#41525629)
Read "Being Mortal" and you might come around to a very different viewpoint.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by dgfitz on Thursday September 12, 2024 @07:55PM (#41526885)
Read “X” and you might come around to a different viewpoint, where X is a book title and the opinion is that of the author.

Edit: you know what, there are in fact entire cultures that think when they die they get to fuck 40 virgin girls. Perhaps I’m wrong.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by dang on Friday September 13, 2024 @06:30PM (#41535800)
Please don't respond to a bad comment by breaking the site guidelines yourself. That only makes things worse.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by dang on Friday September 13, 2024 @06:30PM (#41535797)
Please avoid nationalistic generalizations on HN. It leads to nationalistic flamewars, which we definitely want to avoid here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by eqvinox on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:36PM (#41525245)
"decelerates aging clock" implies slowing down processes of decreasing health, not just living longer in a frail state at the end. In particular if you click the link, the first thing it says is:

• Metformin prevents brain atrophy, elevating cognitive function in aged male primates • Metformin slows the pace of aging across diverse male primate tissues • Metformin counterparts neuronal aging, delivering geroprotection via Nrf2 in male primates

It doesn't even say you'd live longer. If I could get something that doesn't extend my life at all, just keeps my brain fresher into my old age, I would jump on that as well.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by inglor_cz on Thursday September 12, 2024 @04:49PM (#41525398)
People are interested in slowing aging, which means living longer in good health.

The ultimate goal would be negligible senescence.

Dementia and other chronic diseases that plague our end days now are consequences of aging. They don't just come randomly, they are a result of the aging process, which is nothing but slow deterioration, possibly a programmed one.

Of course people want to get rid of that.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by desireco42 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:10PM (#41525616)
I think you are looking at this the wrong way. I turned 50 recently. I have ADHD and I was fairly immature for a long time.

I finally understand so much about life, I genuinely am helping a lot of people and to be honest, want to continue living and enjoying life.

There are so many books to read, experiences to have.

Yet I can feel that my body is no longer how it used to be.

If there was something that could bring back to clock, 5-10 extra years. Totally worth it.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by StanislavPetrov on Thursday September 12, 2024 @05:26PM (#41525762)
I certainly wouldn't want to live forever one way or the other, but most people who talk about living longer mean slowing or halting the aging process, not simply surviving more years as a decaying husk.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by jjk166 on Thursday September 12, 2024 @06:10PM (#41526173)
Your Father and Father-in-laws conditions are due to the process of aging, not the number of years they have lived. It is the process of aging which anti-aging advocates want to delay or eliminate. Living longer doesn't mean tacking on years at the end, continuing the aging process for longer; it means adding years to the middle before aging begins, as well as lessening the effects of aging when that time eventually comes.
Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by monkeyfun on Thursday September 12, 2024 @06:42PM (#41526397)
To flip your question around, why are you living right now?

I developed a severe intestinal disorder in my 20s. Some people can get it or ones like it in their teens, others their 30s, 40s, 50s, etc. and many won't ever develop such issues, although they're reasonably common to a less severe extreme than my case.

Knowing this, and that I could explain my disorder for years being debilitating and putting me in agonizing pain and suffering, why would you want to live any longer when it could happen to you too?

Not everyone is going to develop such cognitive disorders as you discuss, and often they're a result of complex genetic and lifestyle factors, as well as likely having to do with aspects of aging like reduced function of organs. So it's quite possible these diseases and disorders aren't inevitable simply as a consequence of living long enough, or could be treated and reversed as medical science advances.

If I sound bitter by the way, I am slightly, but do mean for this to still be conveyed productively.

To hear someone asking "why are people interested in living longer?" makes me genuinely want to know why you're interested in living longer. You could die right now and free up resources for the rest of us, or donate resources to younger people than you who are in need, or simply give it to me since I'm neither senile nor old (not even 30) nor have a family history of such disorders as you mentioned, nor would I put it to poor use.

I suspect you want to live. The simple fact is, it's that same desire to live and to continue enjoying life to the fullest that makes those of us with foresight interested in prolonging our healthy lives.

Re:Metformin decelerates aging clock in male monkeys by washadjeffmad on Sunday September 15, 2024 @10:38PM (#41552239)
The greatest challenge of chronic pain isn't necessarily the pain, but how it warps and taints parts of you beyond your control.

People who haven't experienced their failure are completely unaware of the incredible mechanisms of our evolution that keep us from suicide. They're also unaware of what choosing to live means in the face of the eventual erosion of those failsafes by pain.

It's like hurtling down the interstate at 70mph in heavy traffic and having the power steering go out. There's no sense of freedom and accomplishment in having to fight just to keep to your lane, only terror from all the parts of you that know how easily you'd crash if you stopped trying for even a few seconds. It's exhausting in every sense.