Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by mananaysiempre on Saturday September 07, 2024 @02:29PM
(#41475512)
There’s also the, umm, Flying Bum[1] descended from a discarded project of the US military. (It’s not quite clear what they wanted to do with it—radio relay for ground troops in difficult terrain? mobile command post?) Filling it with helium (expensive and very limited on Earth) feels kind of barbaric, though, knowing what lengths even physics labs go to in order to avoid wasting it.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by jodrellblank on Saturday September 07, 2024 @03:43PM
(#41475972)
> "it can use nonflammable helium instead of explosive hydrogen as a lifting gas."
Frustrating FUD that's held back Hydrogen lift airships for almost a century, because clickbait scaremongering sells newspapers. What about [1] and [2], Spectrum.IEEE reporting on Hydrogen fuel-cell electric aircraft, or [3] them reporting on a hydrogen fuel cell rescue truck, without mentioning explosions or the Hindenburg.
You know how many people died in the Hindenburg disaster?
36.
And how many survivors?
62.
Yes that's too many. FOURTY TWO THOUSAND people killed by cars EVERY YEAR in the USA[7] held back car development or sales? When was the last time an aeroplane crash killed that many people? It was August 9th - only a month ago - a crash in Brazil killed 66 people[4]. Before that? January 2023 a crash in Nepal killed 72 people. In fact, look how many plane crashes there are[5] - that doesn't leave newspapers scaremongering about airplane travel and regulators banning it. OK, it does, "Horrific Oregon plane crash shows moment aircraft flies into home and EXPLODES as residents evacuate area" a week ago in the Daily Mail[8].
Jet fuel is explosive, explosions are how engines work! A Boeing 737 carries ~20,000 litres or ~5300 gallons of jet fuel, and nobody writes articles about how planes are bad because jet fuel burns.
With today's technology, and all the improvements in airline safety generally - checklists, regulations, mandatory inspections and maintenance, why wouldn't Hydrogen lift airships be similarly safe to airplanes? Look at "List of airship accidents"[6] and ask yourself how many could be made unlikely with today's technology, weather forecasting, and careful design and maintenance procedures? The first 30 years are mostly:
And if you think the fire risk is not safely manageable, have a think about Hydrogen refuelling pumps at every gas station on every town and city street, used by ordinary people not paying much attention, refuelled and maintained by the lowest bidder, into old, maybe poorly maintained, cars and trucks.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by jodrellblank on Saturday September 07, 2024 @05:24PM
(#41476570)
Deaths per mile travelled for planes and cars designed and built before 1930, for a fair comparison. The Graf Zeppelin launched in 1928 did 1,000,000 miles with no crashes, deaths or injuries. How many other vehicles from the 1920s were that capable and safe?
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by tzs on Saturday September 07, 2024 @09:48PM
(#41477620)
I'm not sure deaths per mile is a good way to compare different modes of transport.
Suppose a company discovered warp drive and started offering trips to the Andromeda galaxy. Their warp starships can carry 100 passengers. Establishing the warp field is dangerous, and 99% of the time the result is an explosion that destroys the ship (and everyone aboard). If the warp field is successfully established actually traversing the warp field is safe enough that the chances of anything going wrong in transit are negligible.
Those warp starships that kill 99% of their passengers would have a fatality rate per passenger mile 5 orders of magnitude lower than that of commercial airlines, and 8 orders of magnitude lower than that of automobiles but I doubt many people think is is safer.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by waldrews on Sunday September 08, 2024 @12:16AM
(#41478174)
Well, maybe it's still better than the alternative of trying to get there by chemically propelled rocket, and having a 100% chance of dying of old age on the way.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by xp84 on Sunday September 08, 2024 @09:49PM
(#41484822)
I get your point technically, but I think the mildly fallacious part of your argument is that the warp example opens up the possibility of orders of magnitude farther travel in the first place, whereas most Earthbound modes of transport are not too far off from one another in their potential. Nobody’s driving a Corolla to the Andromeda Galaxy, or flying on a 737. Therefore no one ought to be comparing them on any distance-related metric, probably. Perhaps a pure “chances that a given person boarding the craft disembarks alive” metric would be better.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by jodrellblank on Tuesday September 10, 2024 @04:07AM
(#41498386)
More relevant is that if someone straps wings on their back, jumps off a building and dies, that’s 1 death/0miles or infinity deaths per mile.
To get deaths per mile down needs a long tail of safe mass use, and that comes after the rough early days of little use and lots of accidents. Cars got a lot less deathy after banning drunk driving, adding white lines on the roads, banning jaywalking - things outside Car technology - as well as seatbelts, airbags, crumple zones, better headlights, power assisted brakes, antilock brakes.
Zeppelins used Hydrogen and several deadly accidents were while emptying or refilling. Now there are better materials, equipment, OSHA rules, industries which deal with natural gas and gasoline and other dangerous gases and chemicals routinely which is outside Zeppelin technology but would help make them safer.
One Zeppelin crash was the gas release valves sealed shut to save money. We have better regulation around airline safety to catch that kind of “safety device isn’t functioning” and expect failovers at the design stage, also outside them being Zeppelins and just general bad practice.
One Zeppelin crash was a last minute extension to the design launched before it could be tested properly for political reasons, that’s an avoidable problem with regulatory bodies overseeing designs and builds - also general bass practice.
Aircraft got safer once the copilot started flying and the pilot advised. Because of social power imbalances, it’s much easier for the pilot to correct the assistant, than for yer assistant to correct the pilot. Maybe that could benefit Zeppelins?
Ocean travel got safer as ships learned to avoid the worst routes and weather, and with the Panama and Suez canals; by the time of the Titanic when lifeboat regulations were being discussed it was an argument that ships don’t crash enough anymore to benefit from lifeboats. Lots of Zeppelin problems with storms should be improved with todays weather prediction/reporting as well as storm-proof materials.
Zeppelins stopped before all those kinds of changes/developments. Left in the era of men standing in a field holding onto them by ropes, altitude by sonar echo and stopwatch, radio by dangling a wire to use as an antenna, controlling speed by telling a man sitting by each engine to turn them up or down, then saying “high deaths per mile they must be inherently unsafe” is more scaremongering dismissal than genuine interested carefully reasoned position.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by WalterBright on Saturday September 07, 2024 @08:23PM
(#41477332)
Helium is a much less effective lifting gas than hydrogen, meaning there goes your payload. Helium is a non-renewable resource, too.
The hydrogen gas could also fuel the engines.
I concur that the risk of hydrogen in a Zeppelin is overstated. We know why the Hindenburg burned, and that is easily fixed. (Static electricity discharge, and the skin coated with rocket fuel.)
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by ghaff on Saturday September 07, 2024 @11:47AM
(#41474543)
It depends on your situation. And, given Starlink, there's a lot of flexibility these days for people who can work remote.
ADDED: And if they can't work remote adding a few days on the sides probably isn't a great option either. Certainly it wasn't a good option when I was maximizing vacation days.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by porphyra on Saturday September 07, 2024 @02:19PM
(#41475431)
There's plenty of comfortable travel even if you are in a hurry... If you can pay for it. Modern first class is pretty good and beyond that you could always fly private (I have only ever flown economy, though).
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by ghaff on Saturday September 07, 2024 @02:51PM
(#41475641)
True. I usually don't but have flown business trans-Pacific. Taking an ocean liner when schedule permits is very comfortable but really is a different beast.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by jillesvangurp on Saturday September 07, 2024 @01:58PM
(#41475280)
I think it's more a case of things moving on. The Hindenburg crashed only shortly before cross atlantic passenger flight by much faster planes took off (around 1939). The Hindenburg was already a bit obsolete by the time the accident happened. And of course WW II then happened which made passenger travel by plane a bit impractical. Even so there was plenty of it happening.
Post WW II we had transatlantic flights taking over and creating the modern aviation industry. With iconic planes like the Lockheed Constellation (which first flew in 1943). Initially those would have been similarly luxurious. And this is also not that different from what a Concorde ticket would have cost later on. And of course Concorde flights were also discontinued after a crash. Not unlike the Hindenburg.
These days, there's a business and first class section servicing the rich with similar pricing. This never really went away.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by SoftTalker on Saturday September 07, 2024 @03:26PM
(#41475859)
Concorde just became a poor value for everyone involved. It was noisy, it sucked fuel, it required three crew on the flight deck to operate it, demand was dropping because for their money, people were preferring the more oppulent, spacious, and comfortable first class of a modern wide-body than the cigar-tube regional jet experience of sitting in the Concorde, even if it was faster.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by ianburrell on Saturday September 07, 2024 @02:17PM
(#41475416)
Another factor is that Germany was the expert in airships. The Zeppelin company scrapped their airships, made fixed-wing aircraft during the war, and was nearly destroyed at end of war.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by krisoft on Saturday September 07, 2024 @02:06PM
(#41475345)
> one crash killed public interest
It was not really one crash, but a series of crashes.
R38 broke up in the air over the UK. Roma crashed and burned in Virginia. Dixmude exploded mid-air over Sicily. R101 crashed and burnt in France. R100 was declared a failure and broken up. USS Akron crashed, and so did the USS Shenandoah.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by Animats on Saturday September 07, 2024 @04:09PM
(#41476149)
Yes. That generation of airships was terrible at maneuvering. An airship has huge sail area, isn't very strong, and is not high powered. Crosswinds are a big problem.
The modern Zeppelin NT handles better. Remember Airship Ventures, which used to have an airship touring over Silicon Valley? They had one. Unfortunately, they launched the service in 2008, during the recession. Then the price of helium doubled. So that operation shut down. The NT was fly by wire with steerable fans, which gave it enough maneuverability that it could be landed without a big ground crew. Here's the Airship Ventures craft landing at Moffett Field.[1]
DARPA funded Lockheed-Martin's Skunk Works to build a more maneuverable airship. The result was the P-791.[2] This could be taxied out of a hangar, flown, landed, and taxied back in, all under its own power. All the propellers are on two-axis gimbals, and the flight control systems is constantly adjusting them to keep it level. It has hovercraft-type air bags as landing gear, so it can suck itself onto the ground when needed under windy conditions. All the propellers are on two-axis gimbals. Worked fine, but no military need at the time.
I'm surprised that no billionaire has an airship yacht yet. You need an airship-sized hangar anywhere you want to go, though, so there are not many destinations possible.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by krisoft on Sunday September 08, 2024 @07:45PM
(#41484250)
> I'm surprised that no billionaire has an airship yacht yet.
When people ask me what would I do if i won the lottery i tell them that I would build a liveaboard airship. Would need to win multiple lotteries probably, and also the liveaboardness would need to be very minimalistic but still it would be awesome just even the journey to get there.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by WalterBright on Saturday September 07, 2024 @01:44PM
(#41475183)
What killed public interest was not necessarily the crash, but the happenstance that it was filmed and shown over and over and over, along with the famous live radio broadcast of it. Heck, my dad even saved 1937 newspaper clippings of the fireball.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by Tarsul on Saturday September 07, 2024 @01:46PM
(#41475195)
Yes. I mean one just has to look at the last picture of the article with the Hindenburg burning. Not even the best propagandist could save this disaster.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by tomatotomato37 on Saturday September 07, 2024 @01:55PM
(#41475259)
Germany's war preparations starting to divert resources away from civilian enterprises during the time probably didn't help either. Those zeppelins were massive investments in terms of material and industry after all
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by yieldcrv on Saturday September 07, 2024 @02:16PM
(#41475410)
I was thinking that too
A lot of trends were cut short by the world wars
A lot of things I like from the 1890s and 1900 early aughts just stopped being made or were never explored fully, and then I remembered “oh yeah, everybody died” and its like the first time in hundreds of years that something so broadly affected so many socioeconomic classes in so many places at once
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by ghaff on Saturday September 07, 2024 @01:49PM
(#41475220)
Yeah. It's hard to justify premium and much more time-consuming transatlantic travel even when I can afford it. I've done it for various reasons. But generally I'd prefer to spend my money and and time on other things.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by graycat on Saturday September 07, 2024 @01:57PM
(#41475268)
> US$400, .... $7,811
Ah, peanuts! Chump change!
Somewhere recently saw a review of the Titanic, lots of pictures (taken BEFORE leaving England!) with the mention that the 1st class fare was $100,000. And that the ship cost $1.5 million to build.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by organsnyder on Saturday September 07, 2024 @03:18PM
(#41475809)
Assuming those numbers are accurate, that $100k surely bought a lot of amenities (not just food and beverage, but also dedicated staff people) that weren't free.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by trhway on Saturday September 07, 2024 @03:20PM
(#41475823)
They didn't have to do multi-hundred-million dollars certification (and i think their safety record wasn't good). The lower speed also lowers the costs of making it. They are really less a plane and more like a ship, only floating in the air, and the ships are significantly cheaper.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by jcranmer on Saturday September 07, 2024 @07:44PM
(#41477149)
One number is being adjusted for inflation, the other number is not. Per Wikipedia, the highest first class fare was £1000 in currency at the time, and the ship itself cost about £1.5 million in currency at the time.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by bobthepanda on Saturday September 07, 2024 @02:20PM
(#41475435)
Eh, the current furniture trend is all about precisely cut woods. The Hindenburg furniture looks like something you would see in a diner or fast food restaurants.
It’s worth noting that everything, including the furniture, was designed to be lightweight and not flammable, so it isn’t necessarily representative of what was in vogue then either.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by SoftTalker on Saturday September 07, 2024 @03:16PM
(#41475796)
Especially post-COVID but even before then, the vast majority of their sales were coming from drive-thru. The people who came inside were retirees who would order from the dollar menu and get a free cup of coffee and sit there for an hour.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by Isamu on Saturday September 07, 2024 @05:11PM
(#41476489)
Literally Modernist. There’s some details that might be Art Deco inspired but overall just clean lines, metal tube furniture, uncluttered. It fits with the need to keep weight down.
The Modern architect Le Corbusier took inspiration from the clean lines and shapes of aircraft and such, you can read about it in Vers Une Architecture.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by kjkjadksj on Sunday September 08, 2024 @01:47PM
(#41481850)
I think part of it is the lagging effect of copycat manufacturing that keeps it up even longer. You can get a copycat 1950 eames chair at any big box store today. However it seems like those copycats only really emerged the last 10-20 years. So we are now in this period where you might see a 70 year old fiberglass chair someplace and think it to be a very modern design. It probably won’t last forever I expect, but it makes you wonder what would even qualify today to be the next eames chair. I’m not sure how many contemporary, truly seminal designers there are today akin to an eames. Many more players in the space today from around the world keeps the notoriety distributed.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by SoftTalker on Saturday September 07, 2024 @03:32PM
(#41475895)
People smoked constantly in those days. Asking them to stop for a three day voyage would be untenable. It was probaby considered quite an imposition just to ask them to go to a special room.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by spaceman_2020 on Saturday September 07, 2024 @03:43PM
(#41475970)
Why did we stop building crazy stuff like this?
Everything seems to now be an exercise in somehow optimizing profits
Even our billionaires are boring now
Where are the wild eyed people dreaming up impossible megastructures and geoengineering projects? I can’t imagine anyone even attempting to build the Panama canal today
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by neuralRiot on Saturday September 07, 2024 @04:06PM
(#41476133)
>Everything seems to now be an exercise in somehow optimizing profits
It has always been, but now the idea is to maximize it as fast as possible and “tomorrow is not my problem”, same as school grades discussed in another post, the goal is to pass the metrics, the final result doesn’t really matter.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by leobg on Sunday September 08, 2024 @07:06AM
(#41479677)
You may be right. And it’s odd. Everyone is talking about AI and the future and all of that. But really, we live as if there is no tomorrow. Nobody would start a construction project anymore that would pay off a generation later. Compare that to medieval building projects. I imagine we lack a stable foundation to stand on. If you have no idea what the world will look like 50 years from now (and what people will value them), it’s useless to make any long term investments. Your customers are the people of today, along with their ideas about the future - but not the people of the future themselves.
Same problem in education. We have no idea what kids will need 20 years from now. So we just let them do what they like. Not because we cared more than the teachers of the past. But because they had a plan and a mission and a reason why to pull kids through training that sometimes was tough for them, whereas we don’t.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by trhway on Saturday September 07, 2024 @04:33PM
(#41476299)
Yep, optimization. I did at some point napkin on cargo Zeppelin 3-4 days vs 747 in half a day Shanghai to SFO. Zeppelin would burn almost the same fuel, and ultimately 747 would provide higher ROI due to more flight over the same time period.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by derbOac on Saturday September 07, 2024 @06:04PM
(#41476738)
The Hindenburg, and apparently those linked planes ended after catastrophic accidents. Not saying they couldn't have been revived but safety has a way of constraining what you might do.
Reading the main article reminded me of the Concorde. Similar luxury vibes and similar end.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by ghaff on Sunday September 08, 2024 @11:19AM
(#41480913)
My dad once was once upgraded from his usual first class to a Concorde. His reaction was basically "meh." As I recall, he landed at a less convenient time and really preferred his usual seating which wasn't as comfortable as today.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by SoftTalker on Saturday September 07, 2024 @03:14PM
(#41475784)
They're just too slow for most people. Like trains. There's a certain charm to spending three days to get to LA on a train, eating in the dining car and watching the scenery go by, but for most people they'd rather get on an airliner and be there in 4 hours.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by fragmede on Saturday September 07, 2024 @03:19PM
(#41475816)
Like cruise ships? An airplane can also get you places way faster, but cruise ships are a some $50 billion industry, with some 30 million passengers each year. How much of that industry would an airship need to slice off to be profitable?
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by spaceman_2020 on Saturday September 07, 2024 @03:44PM
(#41475985)
So an airship that runs over a picturesque coastline route would do the trick. Don’t have to fly over the Atlantic. Just fly around the caribbean islands
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by NikkiA on Saturday September 07, 2024 @04:52PM
(#41476423)
While they were both still in service, there was a famous long-serving cruise package of QE2 from Southampton to NYC, then Concorde back (and another package of the opposite directions)
But yes, mostly these days cruises are a circular trip.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by ghaff on Saturday September 07, 2024 @08:05PM
(#41477245)
Queen Mary 2 today.
Yes. It's nice. There's a lot of entertainment. Good food. But you need to be in a circumstance where you don't really care about the time (or the money although it's in the ballpark of business class air for two people).
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by dr_dshiv on Saturday September 07, 2024 @03:19PM
(#41475815)
There is no way today to have the experience of looking down at the earth, silently, from a few thousand feet.
I think an LA to Las Vegas route could be viable. You aren’t limited by volume— only weight. You could have huge vaulted ceilings and massive windows. Hell, bungee jumping while we’re at it.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by jodrellblank on Saturday September 07, 2024 @03:49PM
(#41476010)
I wish the billionaires would drop a few dollars into making enormous airships come back, just because they are amazing and not for profit.
Even for profit, they can lift more than anything else - build houses or appartments in a factory and float them accross the country to their destination. Then they can be bigger than road/bridge/tunnel limits. Because they are buoyant they don't need much energy for the effort of lifting (improves on airplane, helicopter, hovercraft, mag-lev).
If not that, then just for tourism / novelty / showing off. Along the lines of the beautiful (but not very economical) buildings of old - train stations, libraries, opera houses - to show off doing something grand and impressive.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by WalterBright on Saturday September 07, 2024 @08:27PM
(#41477348)
> just because they are amazing and not for profit
Why all this angst about somebody making a profit? Why does it have to lose money in order to be acceptable? If it's amazing, who cares if a profit is made?
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by jodrellblank on Sunday September 08, 2024 @08:32AM
(#41480017)
> "If it's amazing, who cares if a profit is made?"
That's what I said. Restated: billionaires already do things which are expected to be profitable; apparently Zeppelins are not in that case and I can't argue that I think they would be profitable and should be in that case, so that case doesn't need commenting on. The case where they do things as money losers, I would like it if that case included Zeppelins.
(angst about somebody making a profit) and (it has to lose money in order to be acceptable) are not things I said.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by metadat on Saturday September 07, 2024 @10:08PM
(#41477705)
> The latest gas cells were made by a new method pioneered by Goodyear using multiple layers of gelatinized latex rather than the previous goldbeater’s skins.
How much did Goodyear help Nazi causes (even inadvertently)? A company is like a machine automata in many ways.
p.s. The amount of metal on the Hindenburg was truly insane. With today's technologies 3x, probably even more, paying passengers could be accommodated aboard such a contraption. Plastic is the worst, laziest scourge ever (97%+ of supermarket packaging) and occasionally incredible.
Re:Hindenburg's Interior: Photos Show What Luxury Air Travel...
by knowald on Sunday September 08, 2024 @06:08AM
(#41479434)
Here in my city in Germany called Friedrichshafen there is the "Zeppelin Museum", as it's is the birthplace of the Zeppelins, and there is a walkable Partial reconstruction of the LZ 129 Hindenburg interior.
You can have a walk around that from home, on Google Arts & Culture:
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hybrid_Air_Vehicles_Airlander_...
Frustrating FUD that's held back Hydrogen lift airships for almost a century, because clickbait scaremongering sells newspapers. What about [1] and [2], Spectrum.IEEE reporting on Hydrogen fuel-cell electric aircraft, or [3] them reporting on a hydrogen fuel cell rescue truck, without mentioning explosions or the Hindenburg.
You know how many people died in the Hindenburg disaster?
36.
And how many survivors?
62.
Yes that's too many. FOURTY TWO THOUSAND people killed by cars EVERY YEAR in the USA[7] held back car development or sales? When was the last time an aeroplane crash killed that many people? It was August 9th - only a month ago - a crash in Brazil killed 66 people[4]. Before that? January 2023 a crash in Nepal killed 72 people. In fact, look how many plane crashes there are[5] - that doesn't leave newspapers scaremongering about airplane travel and regulators banning it. OK, it does, "Horrific Oregon plane crash shows moment aircraft flies into home and EXPLODES as residents evacuate area" a week ago in the Daily Mail[8].
Jet fuel is explosive, explosions are how engines work! A Boeing 737 carries ~20,000 litres or ~5300 gallons of jet fuel, and nobody writes articles about how planes are bad because jet fuel burns.
With today's technology, and all the improvements in airline safety generally - checklists, regulations, mandatory inspections and maintenance, why wouldn't Hydrogen lift airships be similarly safe to airplanes? Look at "List of airship accidents"[6] and ask yourself how many could be made unlikely with today's technology, weather forecasting, and careful design and maintenance procedures? The first 30 years are mostly:
And if you think the fire risk is not safely manageable, have a think about Hydrogen refuelling pumps at every gas station on every town and city street, used by ordinary people not paying much attention, refuelled and maintained by the lowest bidder, into old, maybe poorly maintained, cars and trucks.[1] https://spectrum.ieee.org/hydrogen-powered-planes-fuel-cells
[2] https://spectrum.ieee.org/stealthy-startup-promises-cheap-ca...
[3] https://spectrum.ieee.org/hydrogen-truck-emergency-rescue
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voepass_Linhas_A%C3%A9reas_Fli...
[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_accidents_and_incident...
[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_airship_accidents
[7] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in...
[8] I'm not linking to the Daily Mail. If you're desperate to read it, you'll have to find it.
Suppose a company discovered warp drive and started offering trips to the Andromeda galaxy. Their warp starships can carry 100 passengers. Establishing the warp field is dangerous, and 99% of the time the result is an explosion that destroys the ship (and everyone aboard). If the warp field is successfully established actually traversing the warp field is safe enough that the chances of anything going wrong in transit are negligible.
Those warp starships that kill 99% of their passengers would have a fatality rate per passenger mile 5 orders of magnitude lower than that of commercial airlines, and 8 orders of magnitude lower than that of automobiles but I doubt many people think is is safer.
To get deaths per mile down needs a long tail of safe mass use, and that comes after the rough early days of little use and lots of accidents. Cars got a lot less deathy after banning drunk driving, adding white lines on the roads, banning jaywalking - things outside Car technology - as well as seatbelts, airbags, crumple zones, better headlights, power assisted brakes, antilock brakes.
Zeppelins used Hydrogen and several deadly accidents were while emptying or refilling. Now there are better materials, equipment, OSHA rules, industries which deal with natural gas and gasoline and other dangerous gases and chemicals routinely which is outside Zeppelin technology but would help make them safer.
One Zeppelin crash was the gas release valves sealed shut to save money. We have better regulation around airline safety to catch that kind of “safety device isn’t functioning” and expect failovers at the design stage, also outside them being Zeppelins and just general bad practice.
One Zeppelin crash was a last minute extension to the design launched before it could be tested properly for political reasons, that’s an avoidable problem with regulatory bodies overseeing designs and builds - also general bass practice.
Aircraft got safer once the copilot started flying and the pilot advised. Because of social power imbalances, it’s much easier for the pilot to correct the assistant, than for yer assistant to correct the pilot. Maybe that could benefit Zeppelins?
Ocean travel got safer as ships learned to avoid the worst routes and weather, and with the Panama and Suez canals; by the time of the Titanic when lifeboat regulations were being discussed it was an argument that ships don’t crash enough anymore to benefit from lifeboats. Lots of Zeppelin problems with storms should be improved with todays weather prediction/reporting as well as storm-proof materials.
Zeppelins stopped before all those kinds of changes/developments. Left in the era of men standing in a field holding onto them by ropes, altitude by sonar echo and stopwatch, radio by dangling a wire to use as an antenna, controlling speed by telling a man sitting by each engine to turn them up or down, then saying “high deaths per mile they must be inherently unsafe” is more scaremongering dismissal than genuine interested carefully reasoned position.
The hydrogen gas could also fuel the engines.
I concur that the risk of hydrogen in a Zeppelin is overstated. We know why the Hindenburg burned, and that is easily fixed. (Static electricity discharge, and the skin coated with rocket fuel.)
I've done Atlantic crossings by ship. You just need the time and schedule around availability. (And pay the premium of course.)
ten days on either side is not
ADDED: And if they can't work remote adding a few days on the sides probably isn't a great option either. Certainly it wasn't a good option when I was maximizing vacation days.
I feel like seeing such an affliction happen to so many of the richest people at once is what killed interest in the zeppelin
I always felt that was too reductive, one crash killed public interest? No more like it killed that tiny market’s interest
I think it could be done better, safer, and cheaper now
Post WW II we had transatlantic flights taking over and creating the modern aviation industry. With iconic planes like the Lockheed Constellation (which first flew in 1943). Initially those would have been similarly luxurious. And this is also not that different from what a Concorde ticket would have cost later on. And of course Concorde flights were also discontinued after a crash. Not unlike the Hindenburg.
These days, there's a business and first class section servicing the rich with similar pricing. This never really went away.
The crash just sealed its fate.
After the war, planes were better and faster.
It would give anyone pause thinking of flying in it.
It was not really one crash, but a series of crashes.
R38 broke up in the air over the UK. Roma crashed and burned in Virginia. Dixmude exploded mid-air over Sicily. R101 crashed and burnt in France. R100 was declared a failure and broken up. USS Akron crashed, and so did the USS Shenandoah.
The modern Zeppelin NT handles better. Remember Airship Ventures, which used to have an airship touring over Silicon Valley? They had one. Unfortunately, they launched the service in 2008, during the recession. Then the price of helium doubled. So that operation shut down. The NT was fly by wire with steerable fans, which gave it enough maneuverability that it could be landed without a big ground crew. Here's the Airship Ventures craft landing at Moffett Field.[1]
DARPA funded Lockheed-Martin's Skunk Works to build a more maneuverable airship. The result was the P-791.[2] This could be taxied out of a hangar, flown, landed, and taxied back in, all under its own power. All the propellers are on two-axis gimbals, and the flight control systems is constantly adjusting them to keep it level. It has hovercraft-type air bags as landing gear, so it can suck itself onto the ground when needed under windy conditions. All the propellers are on two-axis gimbals. Worked fine, but no military need at the time.
I'm surprised that no billionaire has an airship yacht yet. You need an airship-sized hangar anywhere you want to go, though, so there are not many destinations possible.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6b5zO1ZzTws
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lockheed_Martin_P-791
When people ask me what would I do if i won the lottery i tell them that I would build a liveaboard airship. Would need to win multiple lotteries probably, and also the liveaboardness would need to be very minimalistic but still it would be awesome just even the journey to get there.
I'm not so sure. What killed most Zeppelins was bad weather.
A lot of trends were cut short by the world wars
A lot of things I like from the 1890s and 1900 early aughts just stopped being made or were never explored fully, and then I remembered “oh yeah, everybody died” and its like the first time in hundreds of years that something so broadly affected so many socioeconomic classes in so many places at once
happened again in the late 1930s
Ah, peanuts! Chump change!
Somewhere recently saw a review of the Titanic, lots of pictures (taken BEFORE leaving England!) with the mention that the 1st class fare was $100,000. And that the ship cost $1.5 million to build.
That's a ridiculous cost structure. What was going on?
A quick check suggests the passenger manifest has, OK, 8 first-class passengers.
It sounds like the ship is expected to turn a profit by the time it makes its second voyage. Really?
Love all the weight-saving construction of everything.
They don’t look dated, or quaint, or from another era. The Bauhaus really did win.
It’s worth noting that everything, including the furniture, was designed to be lightweight and not flammable, so it isn’t necessarily representative of what was in vogue then either.
The fact that such design been made accessible and democratized isn't a disqualifier. If anything it makes it even more "of our time."
Diners have been dying for a long time and fast food chains are busy ripping out their dining rooms for more drive thru lanes in 2024.
The Modern architect Le Corbusier took inspiration from the clean lines and shapes of aircraft and such, you can read about it in Vers Une Architecture.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dornier_Do_X
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_377_Stratocruiser
Everything seems to now be an exercise in somehow optimizing profits
Even our billionaires are boring now
Where are the wild eyed people dreaming up impossible megastructures and geoengineering projects? I can’t imagine anyone even attempting to build the Panama canal today
It has always been, but now the idea is to maximize it as fast as possible and “tomorrow is not my problem”, same as school grades discussed in another post, the goal is to pass the metrics, the final result doesn’t really matter.
Same problem in education. We have no idea what kids will need 20 years from now. So we just let them do what they like. Not because we cared more than the teachers of the past. But because they had a plan and a mission and a reason why to pull kids through training that sometimes was tough for them, whereas we don’t.
Reading the main article reminded me of the Concorde. Similar luxury vibes and similar end.
Not Elon Musk. He's anything but boring.
But yes, mostly these days cruises are a circular trip.
Some info: https://www.heritageconcorde.com/concorde--the-qe2
Yes. It's nice. There's a lot of entertainment. Good food. But you need to be in a circumstance where you don't really care about the time (or the money although it's in the ballpark of business class air for two people).
I think an LA to Las Vegas route could be viable. You aren’t limited by volume— only weight. You could have huge vaulted ceilings and massive windows. Hell, bungee jumping while we’re at it.
Here’s a vision deck for an aerostatic future: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1r6CPFJ1AX1ZULacguTf6...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_airship_accidents
Even for profit, they can lift more than anything else - build houses or appartments in a factory and float them accross the country to their destination. Then they can be bigger than road/bridge/tunnel limits. Because they are buoyant they don't need much energy for the effort of lifting (improves on airplane, helicopter, hovercraft, mag-lev).
If not that, then just for tourism / novelty / showing off. Along the lines of the beautiful (but not very economical) buildings of old - train stations, libraries, opera houses - to show off doing something grand and impressive.
Why all this angst about somebody making a profit? Why does it have to lose money in order to be acceptable? If it's amazing, who cares if a profit is made?
That's what I said. Restated: billionaires already do things which are expected to be profitable; apparently Zeppelins are not in that case and I can't argue that I think they would be profitable and should be in that case, so that case doesn't need commenting on. The case where they do things as money losers, I would like it if that case included Zeppelins.
(angst about somebody making a profit) and (it has to lose money in order to be acceptable) are not things I said.
How much did Goodyear help Nazi causes (even inadvertently)? A company is like a machine automata in many ways.
p.s. The amount of metal on the Hindenburg was truly insane. With today's technologies 3x, probably even more, paying passengers could be accommodated aboard such a contraption. Plastic is the worst, laziest scourge ever (97%+ of supermarket packaging) and occasionally incredible.
p.p.s. the SuperGuppy (still flying, since 1965) is pretty remarkable: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aero_Spacelines_Super_Guppy
You can have a walk around that from home, on Google Arts & Culture:
https://artsandculture.google.com/story/explore-the-zeppelin...