> Providing consumers with information on where to find reputable companies selling repair parts would be a much more palatable alternative to selling them yourself.
That does not really make sense. They are a repair company and the only company selling specialized parts is, of course, the manufacturer.
> also stands in the way of advocating for consumers.
That is much too bleak. They made a deal happen in the first place, which is large progress even if it did not quite work out, and compromises are a fact of life.
The whole thing comes across as self-promotion for their tools/parts business. Add in their dabbling in lobbying for regulations to force manufacturers to make devices that you can buy ifixit (and other) kits for… and it starts to feel as disingenuous as Epic’s “pro-consumer” interest in outlawing the razors/blades business model that game consoles use.
While working on small screws like torque or pentalobe, you either have crappy drivers or Wera. iFixit is the provider of "good but not Wera" class tools which most DIYers and even professionals can use without any problems.
Wera is "The Purveyor of Top Notch Tools", so that even companies like Apple and BMW use/supply their tools in their factories and repair centers, however they're out of reach for many people.
Allen wrenches are easier to screw up than you might think, but you can usually find some with a cut end rather than a sheared end if you look. Get into Torx, and you still have choices in the sizes used for construction screws. Get beyond that and you've got very little.
iFixit fills that void. You're ordering anyway, and it's nice to have some options that are quality without being super expensive professional grade. Like, I'll use a pentalobe screwdriver a couple times in my life. I need it to work, but it doesn't have to be Wera levels of good or ergonomic. Interchangeable bits are totally ok for my use case; I don't need dedicated drivers in every size.
Availability of parts and tools is critical to being able to repair anything and iFixit's entire business is based on repair.
Strategies restricting parts and tools as a moat protecting repair and secondary (used) markets should rightfully be illegal. Lobbying for this, especially when your business is repair and repair supplies, is self-preservation, and not lobbying against forces trying to put your business out of business is... irresponsible.
That means cooperating with and occasionally coercing OEMs into playing ball.
Good grief, I hope you phrased that poorly and don't actually mean what you seem to mean.
But isn't that why they exist? I have always seen the teardowns and repairability scores as advertising. If they didn't sell repair tools then what would they make money on?
How else would the skills and information needed be obtained and maintained?
Doing these things is not cheap! Just tooling can surprise one thinking about this activity.
In fact, the more for profit repair centers there are, the better.
Back when things came with some expectation about service, one could find shops all over the place able to do services.
I learned a lot about how to repair and setup CRT Televisions from one back in the 70's when...
I WAS A 6TH GRADER IN PRIMARY SCHOOL!
No joke. The shop was right across the street. Before high school I was reflowing circuits and boards, testing and replacing tubes, other components and could do a basic bring up on a new CRT.
Skills I used in high school for date money.
It is crazy how far away from that we have come.
Also, I like repairability laws here too even if some people don't.
Sure, but you're allowed to not be happy about it and to criticize the supplier.
Withholding any moral judgement, I do think these current incentives contribute to a direction we don’t want society to go. Feels like we should fix the incentives here to encourage reuse.
Support right to repair!
I'm sensing some contradiction in that.
Pricing and packaging parts in a way that ensures its cheaper to buy a different phone is the opposite of a free market. Breaking your screen or wearing out your battery shouldn't mean you have to replace both, but it does if you own a Samsung and want genuine Samsung parts.
Did this approach get disclosed when consumers bought the phones, or only when something happened?
Is there some regulation forcing them to act in this manner?
Doesn't this mean exactly what the person you're replying to said?
It's mutually beneficial: iFixit handles a service business that Valve would rather not be in, and customers get a more repairable product. It's also a source of revenue for iFixit that is probably more reliable than depending on advertising or selling tools.
A similar deal with Samsung or another phone maker would be amazing.
Samsung will make more money from you if they can sell you cloud services and other ecosystem stuff, just like Apple does with their platform.
Just look at how much revenue Apple’s services business brings in as a proportion of their business, at a much better margin than hardware sales.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/382260/segments-share-re...
Services are rapidly growing as a proportion of Apple’s electronics business and I suspect that Samsung is similar if they’re playing their cards right.
There’s going to be a point where Samsung really doesn’t care if you have an old phone or not, as long as you are using Samsung services for your digital life.
Exactly. I usually use ifixit's guides but often by the parts on amazon or ebay because generic parts are generic parts, but if ifixit could certify that their parts are OEM certified, I'd definitely consider paying the extra that they charge to buy from them.
This is too shallow. Yes, it's possible that this can go wrong. Doesn't mean it will. If they're showing you on video how easy or hard it is to repair something, that doesn't leave a lot of room for the sort of thing you're hinting at.
Providing consumers with information on where to find reputable companies selling repair parts would be a much more palatable alternative to selling them yourself.
> “I don’t know why Samsung insists on charging so much for service parts,” Wiens says, visibly frustrated. “The prices that we see are out of line with what we know components actually cost to manufacture.” Wiens starts to elaborate but stops himself. He clarifies that he would love to discuss this more, but his contract with Samsung prevents him from doing so.
In this case, the for-profit business relationship with Samsung also stands in the way of advocating for consumers.