News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by deamanto on Monday July 08, 2024 @08:15PM (#40911245)
I'd also like to highlight another bad practice by Ticketmaster.

When you purchase a ticket from them and resell it on their marketplace, once someone purchases it, they(Ticketmaster) hold your funds and only give you the money ~7-14 business days after the event is over. They say this is to verify the validity of the ticket.

On the buyer side, you purchase the ticket from the marketplace and it gets added to your account immediately. (I think) You get the barcode some time ~1 week before the actual event begins.

The confusion for me? Ticketmaster owned the ticket and all logic relating to the validity of it. The logic to validate this shouldn't be complex at all. They OWN the ticket. They KNOW it's legitimate because it never left their database. Yet they double dip and hold both buyer and seller funds. Events can be close to a year in the future but the seller won't see that until after that event ends.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by tesrx on Monday July 08, 2024 @08:46PM (#40911448)
Excellent point. I wonder if Ticketmaster profits by making interest off of holding those funds?
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by mixmastamyk on Monday July 08, 2024 @08:50PM (#40911476)
Wonder no more—yes.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by ipsum2 on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @01:59AM (#40912905)
Do you work at ticketmaster? Otherwise, how do you confirm this?
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by mixmastamyk on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @02:21AM (#40913018)
Every big corp holds money longer than necessary to maximize interest. It’s free money. We know TM. “Why wouldn’t TM do it” is what you should be asking proof for.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by tsukurimashou on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @03:46AM (#40913522)
exactly this
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by passwordoops on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @07:27AM (#40914808)
Rule of thumb when it comes to monopolies: always err on the side of rentierism. In fact, it should be incumbent on their defenders to prove (insert greedy activity) is not practiced by said corporation
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by seanhunter on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @10:22AM (#40916499)
Ticketkmaster earns interest on cash they hold[1]

This is cash that ticketmaster is holding

Therefore they will be earning interest on this.

[1] see interest incom on their latest 10-K https://investors.livenationentertainment.com/sec-filings/an...

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by fallingknife on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @03:34PM (#40920079)
1. ticket master holds the money for 14 days before paying the customer

2. there are a lot of customers

3. therefore ticket master holds lots of customer cash in transit (this is called the "float")

4. cash earns 5% interest so this year they will earn about 5% * avg float

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by bonestamp2 on Monday July 08, 2024 @09:02PM (#40911555)
There's another good point in here. Why do they hold the ticket until just before the event? I bought tickets to a concert for my wife's favorite band. Then, my wife's work scheduled an event for that same week and she had to leave town. So, what I really wanted was a refund so someone else could buy the tickets. They don't do that of course. So, then I wanted to sell the tickets for face value... but ticketmaster didn't "deliver" the tickets to my account until the day before the event!

I watched for a month leading up to the event as the ticket prices plummeted while the scalpers were desperate to get at least something for their tickets before my ticket was even delivered to me.

As soon as they take my money, they should update the database to show that the ticket is mine. If I want to sell it, I should be able to do that immediately too.

But, from what I've read, that instant resale ability only belongs to their "partners" who resell a lot of tickets, and you need access to their "TradeDesk" tool to do it: https://tradedesk.ticketmaster.com

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by Ocha on Monday July 08, 2024 @09:21PM (#40911652)
Just vote with your pocket and don’t buy tickets from them. I do that - yes I don’t get to go to major concerts but there are still so much more that is not on ticket master. I found a lot of new entertainment and was happy to pay $4 fee instead of whatever TM charges nowadays.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by Loughla on Monday July 08, 2024 @09:25PM (#40911665)
That's the secret.

If nobody used them, they would go away.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by mattmaroon on Monday July 08, 2024 @09:27PM (#40911683)
Our options shouldn’t be see no concerts from successful musicians or pay monopoly pricing. This is something government should solve.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by nulbyte on Monday July 08, 2024 @10:33PM (#40912006)
You're right, of course, those shouldn't be our options. But that's just how it is. If you aren't willing to stop playing, the game will never end.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by mattmaroon on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @02:17PM (#40919182)
Again, not true, that's a false dichotomy. Political pressure is an alternative. The justice department is already suing. Clearly it can be done.

You writing your congressperson is more likely (albeit, still not at all likely) to make a difference than you not going to your annual concert.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by shiroiushi on Monday July 08, 2024 @09:39PM (#40911744)
Expecting the US government to properly handle monopolies and anti-trust issues is a fool's errand. It's like saying the US government should solve the issue of gun proliferation in the US: it's simply not going to, in our lifetimes.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by mattmaroon on Monday July 08, 2024 @09:45PM (#40911770)
I don’t think that’s accurate. They’ve successfully handled plenty of anti trust issues in the past and very recently got on this one.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by sofixa on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @04:17AM (#40913676)
When was the last time they did it?
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by ricket on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @04:22AM (#40913702)
I googled "us government anti trust wins" and found a few articles that point out some recent ones, e.g. Adobe and Figma in December 2023, and an Apple lawsuit in March 2024.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by dml2135 on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @11:01AM (#40916915)
Biden's FTC and Justice Department are in the process of suing Apple, Facebook, and Google for antitrust violations. And Ticketmaster.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by skywhopper on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @08:33AM (#40915349)
On the contrary, the US government is probably a lot easier to influence than an entrenched monopoly.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by mattmaroon on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @02:35PM (#40919355)
It probably would require less money.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by Dylan16807 on Monday July 08, 2024 @10:38PM (#40912030)
That's why they've done so much to force performers to use them.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by spicybbq on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @10:09AM (#40916353)
While this is literally true, solutions in the form of "if everyone would just X" are not solutions at all.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by wrsh07 on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @12:01PM (#40917642)
That's not really possible, because they contractually require venues and performing artists to only perform at their venues

This kind of gross exclusionary contract should be illegal (it's kinda the same BS that Google does with Android OEMs - contractually force them to [1]), but for some reason antitrust avoided acting on the matter (including allowing acquisitions in the space) for quite some time

[1] > Predicating the availability of any of Google’s apps, including the Google Play Store, on OEMs not taking advantage of the open source nature of Android on devices that will not include Google apps seems much more problematic than Google insisting its apps be distributed in a bundle. The latter is Google’s prerogative; the former is dictating OEM actions just because Google can. https://stratechery.com/2018/the-european-commission-versus-...

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by NickC25 on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @02:09PM (#40919109)
That might have been true in decades past.

They now, having merged with LiveNation, have effective ownership of all major and semi-major venues around the country. They also aren't just doing concerts, they're doing sporting events and other live entertainment as well.

They aren't going anywhere. They are just too big, and too ingrained.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by NoahKAndrews on Monday July 08, 2024 @10:11PM (#40911905)
See Tickets seems to be on the rise recently, which I've been glad for
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by jenny2244 on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @01:33AM (#40912797)
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by trustno2 on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @01:15AM (#40912715)
They have an effective monopoly.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by sirsinsalot on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @06:15AM (#40914363)
Not just on tickets, but on venues, catering, security, logistics. It's pretty bad.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by account42 on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @06:42AM (#40914519)
... for a completely optional form of entertainment.

At the very least you have the choice not to go to any concerts until there are better options. You can also make that clear to your favorite bands.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by skywhopper on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @08:32AM (#40915339)
lol, people and bands have been complaining about it for 30 years and it’s only gotten worse. Yes, you could skip concerts for the rest of your life, I suppose, to make a point. But it’s not going to fix anything.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by account42 on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @09:02AM (#40915624)
Complaining yes, but how many people are actually putting their foot down? As for bands, they may actually be profiting from this scheme where ticketmaster ensures higher prices while taking the blame. If they really cared enough they could chose not to deal with Ticketmaster. Sure, that would limit their choices in venues which could mean lower potential for profit. Probably not going to be a real issue for the the more popular groups.

And yes, if there are no concerts with acceptable terms (and that's really a hypothetical if) then don't go to any for the rest of your life. You make it sound like this is some kind of required part of the human experience when it is just one of many possible ways to spend your time. Even if you are really into music, concerts are just one way to experience it - and when it comes to audio quality, a fairly crappy one.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by TylerE on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @10:46AM (#40916759)
The bands are absolutely profiting.

Ticketmaster is basically “customer punching bag ad a service”.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by mattmaroon on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @01:56PM (#40918982)
The bands at the top are absolutely not profiting, they’re losing money over it. Instead of a healthy ecosystem of promoters willing to pay them market rates, they’re dealing with a monopsony that depresses earnings. They HAVE to go through TicketMaster venues, because TM has locked up 85% of large ones, which means they have to accept whatever fee the promoter (LiveNation, same company) is willing to pay them. That’s part of why AEG sued them, they are a giant international promoter who is effectively boxed out of the American market by TMs stranglehold on venues and vertical integration.

Venue owners are profiting. LN/TM can pay them a lot for exclusive rights thanks to their monopoly-inflated profits.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by TylerE on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @08:50PM (#40922803)
The bands get more than a small cut of the various fees, and especially the upcharge things like Platinum tickets.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by mattmaroon on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @10:40PM (#40923266)
No they don’t, that’s not how the money works in concerts. The bands get paid a flat fee by the promoter. You can Google this if you don’t believe me but I know from working with concert promoters.

Why would Ticketmaster/live nation pay them at all? They don’t have to, the bands don’t have any other places to play and they make most of their income from live shows.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by TylerE on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @11:53PM (#40923537)
Platinum Tickets are priced by the artists who get the bulk of the revenue.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by JansjoFromIkea on Wednesday July 10, 2024 @08:44AM (#40926264)
Just to back this up, Robert Smith references Platinum Tickets here https://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-64975160

Choice quote: "It is a greedy scam and all artists have the choice not to participate. If no artists participated, it would cease to exist."

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by mattmaroon on Wednesday July 10, 2024 @09:32AM (#40926716)
It doesn’t say it goes to the artists. It says artists can choose not to participate. It says most of the fees go to the venue, which is true, that’s how they get exclusivity.

Perhaps they give artists a little to encourage participation in some ancillary revenue, I don’t know. I’ve mostly worked non-TM venues. But I’m sure the promoter gets most of that too and it’s not a lot of the overall ticket sales.

I can tell you for sure, everyone but the venues feels they would get more without the monopsony. There is not a functioning market for concert promotion once you get to the 10,000+ seat level, and TM is actually even buying up the ones below that too.

Your only end run around it is the festival circuit since a lot of them are out in a field rather than a venue, but guess who is buying those up now also…

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by mattmaroon on Wednesday July 10, 2024 @09:36AM (#40926752)
Also note how they say ticket master passes on fees to the promoter. That’s a clever way of phrasing because it makes it look like they’re not greedy, but the promoter is almost always LiveNation, which is the same company.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by mattmaroon on Wednesday July 10, 2024 @09:34AM (#40926730)
I am fairly sure that’s not true, and also that platinum tickets are a small percent of tickets.

Do you have a source for that statement? The article about it linked below does not back up either assertion. I’m pretty sure they’re dynamically priced by a TM algo, and I’d bet little of it goes to the artists.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by Spivak on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @09:38AM (#40916007)
It's possible you can put your foot down, lots of venues will sell you paper tickets at the box office. It's inconvenient but they also don't charge TM fees sooo. It's what I do since they open the box office during any of their events. Just get tickets for the next few shows right there.

> Even if you are really into music, concerts are just one way to experience it - and when it comes to audio quality, a fairly crappy one.

This fundamentally misunderstands why people go to see live music and honestly maybe what people enjoy about music entirely.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by quantified on Thursday July 11, 2024 @10:45PM (#40942382)
The extra fees are shared with venues and bands. Keeps them on TM's side.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by dml2135 on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @10:59AM (#40916894)
On large venues for big name artists.

Granted, I live in NYC, which probably has one of the most vibrant local music scenes in the country. But it's not like nowhere else has local bands that play at small venues.

It feels like a lot of the people that complain about ticketmaster's monopoly have never branched out from Billboard chart artists.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by to11mtm on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @09:30PM (#40922937)
It's weird?

Even the most 'hole in the wall' places around here have deals with LN/TM, short of a bar-band or niche-local joint.

One of the more 'fun' ways that LN/TM did shenanigans at the past I observed: Metal shows at smaller places in the Detroit area like Harpo's (famous place but known for the sketch area) or Token Lounge (literally a bar with a dance floor and stage, pretty fun tho) you'd have one of the local small/startup bands selling tickets, often -below- cost at the box office.

Why? If they sold enough tickets, they got to play as an opener. Yes some scammers would try to fake this, but I never saw anyone actually get 'taken'. And yes I'd buy them if I didn't already have them to help the locals out.

That said, the concerts at those smaller venues, despite being TM/LN, were in the 20-30 dollar range after fees. Not 'top billboard' type stuff per se but Children of Bodom, Lacuna Coil, and other 'popular but niche' bands in the 2005-2007 timeframe.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by quantified on Thursday July 11, 2024 @10:44PM (#40942379)
There are a lot of musicians that aren't on the charts that play in Ticketmaster-controlled venues.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by bonestamp2 on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @12:24PM (#40917932)
I did that for several years. I don't really consider it voting though because nobody is counting the votes -- they still sell out of tickets with higher profits each year.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by EGreg on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @08:36AM (#40915374)
I’ve never dealt much with TicketMaster, despite them being a monopoly. So my questions here may just be out of naiveté:

1) Why would TicketMaster pay event organizers ahead of time, if the event might be shit and attendees may demand their money back? Rather than having to deal with a lot of chargebacks and making it their own problem with the banks, they might prefer to make sure the event goes off without a hitch and refund people while they still can. Rather than subsidizing the refunds they make the event organizer have to get (and pay for) financing instead, backed by their payout. They might also offer such financing.

2) I get that they hold event organizers hostage by making contracts with the venues for years, that might be an antitrust issue but it’s separate from 1.

3) Why would TicketMaster make scalping easy? Middlemen would just buy up all the tickets and then pump and dump the price, much like early crypto investors in a meme token or altcoin do. So they don’t “deliver” the ticket to you until just before the event, exactly for that reason.

With ChatGPT it’s now easier than ever to impersonate thousands of people at scale, with credit cards and everything. But I will admit, showing up to an event at least once confirms there is a human behind the account. But a first-timer buyer? Shouldn’t be able to resell, no.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by mhuffman on Wednesday July 10, 2024 @08:08PM (#40932686)
#1 and #3 are related. They make scalping easy so they get all of their money immediately and can pay event organizers ahead of time. I personally think scalping should be straight-up illegal but business schools loove it and consider it an excellent example of helping with liquidity in a system and finding the true "willingness to pay" price of something.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by EGreg on Wednesday July 10, 2024 @09:42PM (#40933088)
willingness to get ripped off LOL

I built a blockchain-based solution.

It features a price discovery mechanism: you auction off M tickets to M people, the price goes up every time after M people buy and the oldest buyer is booted when the others buy, but can buy back in again. Buyers can set a “reserve price” to automatically bid up to that price.

No scalping, because tickets aren’t transferrable.

Similarly, you can disallow transfering of bearer token X but let the user sell it back to the central market maker and someone else buys it. Enforcing commissions on sales.

Blockchain makes all this work, decentralized.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by amarant on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @08:38AM (#40915393)
Tbf, this does sound like a fairly efficient anti-scalper strategy, so I guess there's at least some upside to this mess.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by bonestamp2 on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @11:08AM (#40916998)
I guess it depends on your definition of scalper. It prevents mom and pop from reselling their unwanted tickets. If they stopped there and prevented all reselling I'd be fine with that even though I'd lose out on some money in this one case.

But then they literally built a whole platform (link in my last comment) for actual scalpers to resell tickets in bulk. So, they're not trying to prevent scalping, they're just ensuring that only their "partners" can scalp.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by mike503 on Saturday July 13, 2024 @03:06AM (#40952363)
This began a lot more on third party sites like stubhub due to Covid and the massive amount of cancellations; before most places paid out after the sale, and if the buyer wound up having an issue (due to the seller mistake, selling it multiple times, whatever) they would charge the seller and usually assess a penalty.

But when everything in the world was being cancelled I assume they didn't have all the money just sitting around to reverse and it was a ton of thrash to deal with. As someone who had bought tons of tickets and sold some, it was a mess. I had a ton of credit card refunds back, the third party sites had to reverse payments, etc.

Waiting until after the event is just less overhead. Guarantees the transaction happened without a hitch.

There are some POS and broker sites that still pay on transfer, but none of the "primary" secondary market does.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by cypherpunks01 on Monday July 08, 2024 @09:40PM (#40911748)
It's simply 0% financing for their business. No more complex than that.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by patates on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @04:46AM (#40913829)
Maybe to stop people selling the ticket and still going to the event with a pre-printed one? Solving that would also be easy if they have a central verification system (just invalidate the ticket and issue a new one) but not if it is all p2p.

(disclaimer: I'm a complete outsider, last time I bought anything from Ticketmaster was a really long time ago).

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by Phemist on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @06:49AM (#40914566)
They would need to solve that anyway in case 2 or more friends attempt to get in on the same ticket.

Not at all difficult - simply share screen a third device and display the rotating QR-code through e.g. zoom on individual phones. For additional trickery, try to split the group into joining multiple ticket scanning lines and timing the scan of the ticket to be as close as possible to eachother.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by krger on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @09:11AM (#40915719)
>When you purchase a ticket from them and resell it on their marketplace, once someone purchases it, they(Ticketmaster) hold your funds and only give you the money ~7-14 business days after the event is over. They say this is to verify the validity of the ticket.

I imagine it's more about discouraging scalping, regardless of what they may say about it.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by garaetjjte on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @11:08AM (#40916994)
Possibly it's fraud prevention, in case payment for the original ticket was fraudulent and chargeback occurs after the ticket is resold on marketplace?
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by LorenPechtel on Thursday July 11, 2024 @05:38PM (#40940830)
That does sound like a very reasonable thing to do. Otherwise you have a threat vector of steal card, buy ticket, sell ticket, pocket the cash, card owner disputes, now Ticketmaster has paid a stolen identity who took the money and ran.

Anything that can be used to monetize stolen cards will tend to be used for the purpose even if it's inefficient.

Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by elcomet on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @11:09AM (#40917005)
Because you could just print the ticket, then sell it, and still enter the show with it ?
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by mmmlinux on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @11:12AM (#40917050)
This is literally what the rolling codes prevent.
Re:Reverse Engineering Ticketmaster's Rotating Barcodes by babypuncher on Wednesday July 10, 2024 @01:02PM (#40928952)
I really, really, really hope Ticketmaster gets broken up. Their shittiness seemingly knows no bounds.