News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by imiric on Monday July 08, 2024 @03:01AM (#40903194)
This is an overly wordy article, that I think misses the mark.

The internet _as the Western world knows it today_ will not be the same in a few decades. But then again, it's hardly the same today as it was 30 years ago either.

A few things affect this:

- Advertising. It's everywhere and corrupts every form of media. Content is made to appease advertisers, and web services are built to extract data from users. The internet experience is getting gradually worse.

- Politics. For some reason, it's only dawning on governments now that providing uncensored and unfettered connections to their political adversaries can be used for information warfare. The idea that connecting the world will make it a better place and undo the millennia of tribalism is a romanticized platitude of the 1990s.

- Artificial intelligence. The situation will only be exacerbated by letting AI loose on the internet. Whatever humans can do online, AI can do much, much better—or worse, depending on your perspective.

The outcome of these things will be that countries will have a more restricted and censored version of the current internet. We'll follow China's example, and have a European internet, US internet, etc.

The internet will survive. It will just be very different.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by InDubioProRubio on Monday July 08, 2024 @03:50AM (#40903415)
I think what we will also see - are pocket universes. As in- to circumvent censorship, people will download and run an ai, that mimicrys the free internet for them.
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by Galatians4_16 on Monday July 08, 2024 @03:37AM (#40903355)
> The idea that connecting the world will make it a better place and undo the millennia of tribalism is a romanticized platitude of the 1990s.

This only applies in media that allows censorship, and controls visibility. If it doesn't, the bigots are easy to identify and weed themselves out. If it foes, the bigots can form bubbles, and foster tribalism.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by chpatrick on Monday July 08, 2024 @04:12AM (#40903519)
I think you'll find bigotry is actually quite popular worldwide.
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by account42 on Monday July 08, 2024 @09:45AM (#40905394)
Good observation. Next step is realizing which "side" is the one holding extremist views.
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by EricE on Monday July 08, 2024 @11:04AM (#40906066)
Why the side opposite of you, of course!
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by conradolandia on Monday July 08, 2024 @10:45AM (#40905907)
What in the cryptofascism are you talking about?
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by InDubioProRubio on Monday July 08, 2024 @03:48AM (#40903407)
Information wants to be free - the ideology - downvoted into disappearance and death.. the irony..
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by dyauspitr on Monday July 08, 2024 @04:57AM (#40903762)
This is probably an even worse “platitude”. Most people go with the flow so if you’re immersed in a lot of bigotry, you will probably end up being a bigot eventually. Then it just spreads, especially if you couple the bigotry with humor. Bigotry is tribalism and seems naturally engrained so it’s something you have to actively resist.
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by account42 on Monday July 08, 2024 @09:47AM (#40905413)
> This is probably an even worse “platitude”. Most people go with the flow so if you’re immersed in a lot of wokism, you will probably end up being woke eventually. Then it just spreads, especially if you couple the wokism with humor. Wokism is tribalism and seems naturally engrained so it’s something you have to actively resist.

Funny how well a simple word replacement can work.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by itishappy on Monday July 08, 2024 @10:15AM (#40905643)
> This is probably an even worse “platitude”. Most people go with the flow so if you’re immersed in a lot of NASCAR, you will probably end up being A NASCAR FAN eventually. Then it just spreads, especially if you couple the NASCAR with humor. NASCAR is tribalism and seems naturally engrained so it’s something you have to actively resist.

> This is probably an even worse “platitude”. Most people go with the flow so if you’re immersed in a lot of FITNESS, you will probably end up being FIT eventually. Then it just spreads, especially if you couple the FITNESS with humor. FITNESS is tribalism and seems naturally engrained so it’s something you have to actively resist.

> This is probably an even worse “platitude”. Most people go with the flow so if you’re immersed in a lot of CRYPTO, you will probably end up being A CRYPTO-BRO eventually. Then it just spreads, especially if you couple the CRYPTO with humor. CRYPTO is tribalism and seems naturally engrained so it’s something you have to actively resist.

Very deep.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by drdeca on Monday July 08, 2024 @11:59AM (#40906516)
If you remove the last sentence of each of these, I think they seem somewhat true.

Personal interest plays a role of course. To varying degrees?

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by itishappy on Monday July 08, 2024 @12:32PM (#40906837)
I'd be more surprised if they didn't! I'd argue that's just how culture works. The counter-examples are probably a lot more interesting.
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by p5a0u9l on Monday July 08, 2024 @09:59AM (#40905506)
Assuming you’re serious and not just trolling - what even is wokism, aside from a name thrown at people you disagree with? Bigotry is a known, studied phenomenon. Are you saying there is not a natural tendency to prefer one’s own kind and mistrust foreigners? Are you saying that groupthink respects no particular ideology?
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by shrimp_emoji on Monday July 08, 2024 @01:18PM (#40907279)
Wokism is a rejection of common sense, exchanged with an embrace of exotic rationalization flowers bred in the left-leaning echo chamber hothouses of academia and Tumblr.

You can reduce anything to "a name thrown at people you disagree with", and anything can be "a known, studied phenomenon". Especially if researchers can safely study it when academia is captured by an ideology that's hostile to certain viewpoints. ;D

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by itishappy on Monday July 08, 2024 @05:39PM (#40910010)
Weird, I can't seem to find that definition anywhere. The general council of Governor DeSantis defined it in court as the following:

> the belief there are systemic injustices in American society and the need to address them

I have a feeling you're describing a personally held belief rather than a societally accepted definition, which would explain why yours seems to single out specific groups and views you (assumedly) disagree with.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by TSP00N3 on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @01:00AM (#40912660)
I think urban dictionary did a pretty good job on this one:

“Woke

When this term became popularized, initially the meaning of this term was when an individual become more aware of the social injustice. Or basically, any current affairs related like biased, discrimination, or double-standards.

However, as time passed by, people started using this term recklessly, assigning this term to themselves or someone they know to boost their confidence and reassure them that they have the moral high grounds and are fighting for the better world. And sometimes even using it as a way to protect themselves from other people's opinion, by considering the 'outsider' as non-woke. While people that are in line with their belief as woke. Meaning that those 'outsiders' have been brainwash by the society and couldn't see the truth. Thus, filtering everything that the 'outsider' gives regardless whether it is rationale or not.

And as of now, the original meaning is slowly fading and instead, is used more often to term someone as hypocritical and think they are the 'enlightened' despite the fact that they are extremely close-minded and are unable to accept other people's criticism or different perspective. Especially considering the existence of echo chamber(media) that helped them to find other like-minded individuals, thus, further solidifying their 'progressive' opinion.”

Link: https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Woke

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by dyauspitr on Monday July 08, 2024 @11:29AM (#40906275)
Exactly. It just makes my point.
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by breuleux on Monday July 08, 2024 @12:11PM (#40906645)
Fully open and uncensored platforms do not force bigots into bubbles, but they do not prevent them from creating them willingly. If it serves the bigots' interests to form bubbles in order to foster tribalism, then they will.

Basically, if there exists a strategy for an ideology to spread under censorship, it is hard to believe that removing restrictions would make it any less effective. Bigots won't out themselves and discredit themselves on an open platform just because they can, they are not idiots.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by torginus on Monday July 08, 2024 @04:55AM (#40903751)
Honestly I welcome the 'death' of the internet with open arms. Irrespective of the enshittification flavor of the day, the end result is the same - face to face human relationships will be back in vogue again, and the internet will go back to a complimentary role at best.

I would also like people to let go of the idea that the internet is Serious Business. People who live their lives on Twitter, discussing political matters of grave importance, people getting 'canceled' over inane shit is just ridiculous.

It should go back to trash talk and funny memes, and cat pictures and sharing baking recipes.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by account42 on Monday July 08, 2024 @09:51AM (#40905439)
The "Internet" didn't kill direct human interactions, the engagement economy did. This economy will continue to exist and continue to outcompete direct contacts as long as it remains profitable, with or without the Internet.
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by big-green-man on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @05:16AM (#40914006)
It's not profitable though. Or, at least, not sustainable, it's short term profitable during the rise of it. How is it actually profitable to distract people from doing productive things in order to get them to waste all their time? Ultimately the music stops.
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by benfortuna on Monday July 08, 2024 @08:21AM (#40904766)
The Internet (and especially the Web) is not so much the content, but how it is linked. Without a doubt the way we link (quality) content and hide the drivel should|will|MUST evolve. And that evolution may produce something unrecognizable from the Internet of today.
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by account42 on Monday July 08, 2024 @09:41AM (#40905359)
> Politics. For some reason, it's only dawning on governments now that providing uncensored and unfettered connections to their political adversaries can be used for information warfare. The idea that connecting the world will make it a better place and undo the millennia of tribalism is a romanticized platitude of the 1990s.

Or another point of view: Those who call for internet censorship and country-level firewalls are NOT looking for the world to get better and instead are just afraid of losing their control over the population. Which is why you first see those measures being employed in openly totalitarian systems before now being slowly adoped in supposedly free societies whose rulers like to claim to represent the population they rule over.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by JohnFen on Monday July 08, 2024 @10:10AM (#40905585)
> The internet will survive. It will just be very different.

The internet will continue to exist, certainly. However, it does become a more hostile and unpleasant place over time. Because of that, it's much less useful to me than it used to be and that trend doesn't appear to be changing.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by nooormal on Monday July 08, 2024 @11:42AM (#40906387)
More hostile as in... you open some random webpage, you get 3 popup windows with porn ads playing at full volume? And when you close them, infinitely more open, like a hydra, until it locks up and you have to reboot.

Or you drop into a public game of CS, and a dozen teens start screaming at you over low bitrate compressed audio streams, to logoff and kill yourself because you sound like an n-word.

This was my internet experience in 1999. I think the derangement has been a constant over time.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by JohnFen on Monday July 08, 2024 @12:12PM (#40906652)
It's true that the internet was already well down that road in 1999, but it has become much worse since then. I'm really comparing it to internet earlier than that. It was about 2000 when I started considering the internet as effectively dead in terms of being able to provide the value I used to get from it.

But "more hostile" includes not only advertising and tone, but spying, overtly hostile actors such as crackers and other criminals and so forth.

> Or you drop into a public game of CS, and a dozen teens start screaming at you

I don't count this as part of the general degradation of the internet, though. That's more about the online gaming community. Things were that way before the internet was the most common method of online gaming.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by nooormal on Monday July 08, 2024 @02:55PM (#40908233)
Interesting. My frame of reference for the internet started in 1998, after "eternal september" and the earlier culture. Which makes me curious about baseline expectations.

I agree many aspects are growing... overtly bad. I think LLMs are well on their way to rendering the mainstream internet, search, and social media effectively worthless. The signal to noise ratio is unfixable.

I still get value from my habits, which haven't changed for decades: niche forums, personal websites, blogs, podcasts, youtube. I would be satisfied as long as those remained more or less intact, the rest can go. Requires a lot of curation though.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by Karrot_Kream on Monday July 08, 2024 @03:56PM (#40908933)
Wait do folks not remember the "I get to tell my wife 'sudo make me a sandwich'" jokes on Freenode into the early 2000s? "Pool is closed due to AIDS" from Habbo Hotel?
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by hellojesus on Monday July 08, 2024 @12:48PM (#40906994)
> Or you drop into a public game of CS, and a dozen teens start screaming at you over low bitrate compressed audio streams, to logoff and kill yourself because you sound like an n-word.

I do have a strange nostalgia about those days. It was a culture that didn't exist in meatspace, and there was something fun about that.

However, when covid hit and my wife and I started playing games, I quickly learned my wife severely disapproves of typing "kys" to others in games, and now I try to only say positive things. It is a better experience, but then again I'm now a parent and hoping to spare my children from interacting with college me.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by Lammy on Monday July 08, 2024 @01:41PM (#40907485)
keep yourself safe :)
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by shrimp_emoji on Monday July 08, 2024 @12:51PM (#40907030)
It's what the Internet is for -- a place where things don't matter and where you could go to blow off steam. The Dionysian night to real life's Apollonian day.

Needing to be polite in every aspect of our lives because of this stupid demand to collapse down to the lowest common denominator of humor or mental fortitude is ruining the Internet and making the world and media less fun. It's also Orwellian. There's people who want to dox you and make sure you get fired or never get hired for being mean in a CoD lobby. That's psychotic. Those people are mentally ill, and we've let them run the show and tell us what to do. And of course, it's symbiotic with corporations and advertisers who want things as anodyne and rated E as possible since that makes the most $$$ (if only we can collectively accept more mediocre art and experiences as we forget what better ones we had).

I'm glad the pendulum seems to be swinging back as people are figuring out that having had less for fun for the last 10 years accomplished absolutely nothing worth caring about.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by big-green-man on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @05:07AM (#40913959)
Yeah, I think the internet is going to get back to it's roots: a place to publish documents and send emails. Those documents might be videos, but ultimately it looks to me like all the social this and that have been a big, decades long slow motion flop. It's a great replacement for telephones and TV and libraries, everything else that's come out of it seems to be, from inception, perpetually propped up by investors hoping it works out eventually. I think the time is coming now where people are beginning to see that the vision is not materializing.
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by woooooo on Monday July 08, 2024 @12:50PM (#40907021)
> romanticized platitude of the 90s.

I'm staying in romantic land, it beats the heck out of the government moderating which information I see for my own good.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by imiric on Monday July 08, 2024 @03:53PM (#40908902)
Ignoring the problems of global interconnectedness doesn't make them go away. Information can be weaponized and used against you in ways that are difficult to detect and prevent. We know that propaganda, like advertising, is highly effective, and the internet is the best medium we've invented yet for broadcasting it. At what point do you prioritize issues of national security that threaten your society and way of life, over your perceived freedom to consume funny memes and dancing videos? It's increasingly clear that an unrestricted internet carries existential risks, but most people also wouldn't want to live under totalitarianism either. So there's a delicate line that "democratic" governments need to walk to ensure their subsistence, and it's on us to voice how far we're willing to sacrifice some of the "freedoms" we're used to.

Needless to say, it's going to be a bumpy ride until we figure this out.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by woooooo on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @10:30AM (#40916576)
It's fascinating to have a conversation like this in the context of AIPAC and the Gaza war.
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by Nasrudith on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @05:12PM (#40921186)
Sorry, National Security as an excuse is still utterly broken from its abuse in the early 2000s. We aren't buying this "bomb the village in order to save it" bullshit doublethink.
Re:The internet is already over (2022) by imiric on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @05:39PM (#40921494)
It's not an excuse. It would be ignorant to not acknowledge the existence of information warfare, and its very real effects. The irony is that the tools the US built and gave away for the world to use are being used against it, and will likely cause its downfall. Do you think the current sociopolitical climate is unrelated? The Cambridge Analytica leak confirmed that small independent agencies can effectively disrupt democratic processes and topple governments. What do you think state actors can do?

FWIW, I don't have a dog in this fight, and I'm speaking as a neutral observer. I don't like the idea of giving more control to governments either. But it's clear that something has to be done to defend countries from this type of attack. Traditional military might can't defend you from an invisible enemy.

Re:The internet is already over (2022) by squigz on Monday July 08, 2024 @01:46PM (#40907526)
> The idea that connecting the world will make it a better place and undo the millennia of tribalism is a romanticized platitude of the 1990s.

shrug Certainly a better place than a disconnected world.