News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by rahidz on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:00PM (#40711579)
Anyone else find it a bit "conflict of interest"-y that Wikipedia often limits creation of niche articles because they have to be 'notable' enough, meanwhile its creator is heavily involved in running for-profit Fandom that just so happens to solve that problem?
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by Retr0id on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:14PM (#40711727)
I see what you're saying, but in practice, not really?

It would be weird for wikipedia to host, for example, every minecraft crafting recipe.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by thih9 on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:40PM (#40711993)
Why would that be weird? Personally I would find it convenient.

There would be some issues, e.g. I wouldn't want to see Minecraft recipes when I'm searching for "obsidian". But these seem solvable; niche articles could be flagged and downranked, or they could live in a satellite wiki project, or something else.

I remember seeing niche articles like this and enjoying it.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by JoshTriplett on Monday June 17, 2024 @07:00PM (#40712175)
I am very much on the side of inclusion, but at some point, the number of users who have the ability to check the added information becomes sufficiently small that the articles become nearly impossible to maintain and fact-check. I can understand drawing a notability line somewhere.

If, for instance, Wikipedia allowed articles on every human being, whether well-known or not, they'd likely have a larger problem than they already do with people creating attack articles against other people over extremely local disputes/feuds. With more notable people, they can look for other sources to confirm or deny information about those people.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by gravescale on Monday June 17, 2024 @07:27PM (#40712399)
I'm also a pretty strong inclusionist at heart, but I can see also that if the living-person rules were relaxed, self-aggrandisement would proliferate like crazy. Even under the current, slightly deletionist, status-quo in a 10000 word article about some random academic (1), who is going to fact check all that spew and edit it down? The answer on that page is "no-one, for years"(2). And that's with lots of references, even if they are all his own papers and therefore not secondary sources.

Now what would the millions of articles about every TikTok influencer look like?

And then the same goes for products and companies. Every scam Kickstarter and onanistic startup would get a massive screed.

And then it all sits and rots forever once the academic retires, the influencer gets a real job, the Kickstarter vanishes and the startup folds, because no one else cares. But someone has to go around and fix the links and update templates and generally expend effort indefinitely.

On top of all that, while the article creator is still around, because the article is actually an advert, any attempt to edit it into a more encyclopaedic article is disproportionately likely to cause drama that burns up volunteer time and effort.

(1): One I saw recently https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Didier_Sornette

(2): Especially as many people actually good enough at collating and editing encyclopedic articles about subjects that aren't about their own media-based hobbies quickly decide Wikipedia isn't a very fun place to do that any more.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by lmm on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:46AM (#40714160)
> Especially as many people actually good enough at collating and editing encyclopedic articles about subjects that aren't about their own media-based hobbies quickly decide Wikipedia isn't a very fun place to do that any more.

That cuts both ways. IMO Wikipedia has lost a lot of contributors by banning fun and disallowing the topics that people found interesting.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by gravescale on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @01:16AM (#40714276)
My comment is more of a tangent along people/products but certainly I agree in that I don't see why the wider Wikimedia group of sites including things like Wikibooks needed to completely evict "fun" content, even if I personally don't think it should be in some language's Wikipedia itself.

Not least, you can crosslink between Wikimedia sites, so you could just link to [[fans:Digimon:Whatevermon]] and have the content "nearby" in digital terms without drawing it under the same notability and sourcing guidelines as an article on benzene, say.

Which as you say would keep the (often very, perhaps to a fault) keen contributor to the fandom in the Wikimedia tent and might encourage them to contribute to Wikipedia and related sites as well.

Then again, the auxiliary Wikimedia sites are pretty neglected by the parent foundation which has more important things on its mind much of the time, mostly fundraising and finding novel ways to spend that money.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by sbarre on Monday June 17, 2024 @07:28PM (#40712418)
> they could live in a satellite wiki project

You mean something like Wikia?

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by thih9 on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:23AM (#40716438)
Perhaps - but still managed by the foundation and not run as a for profit project.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by Waterluvian on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:50PM (#40712083)
It's not really about what you would find convenient. It's about what Wikimedia wants to spend its limited resources on. It has decided it wants to spend its resources on something it believes to be a reasonable subset of general knowledge and information. Where to draw that line is highly subjective, but they have to try to find a good balance.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by lmm on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:48AM (#40714166)
Wikimedia spends the vast majority of its resources on stuff that has a lot less to do with traditional-Wikipedia than a Fandom competitor would.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by audiodude on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:31AM (#40714673)
The Wikimedia Foundation has not decided this, the community of editors has, through years of debate and eventual consensus.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by itishappy on Monday June 17, 2024 @07:29PM (#40712422)
Game wiki's often have custom UIs that are designed to make browsing game data a better experience. I'll be using Factorio as an example:

https://wiki.factorio.com/

Items can be referenced using their in-game names because there's no risk of conflict and custom templates can be created and tailored per game. Guess which one of these contains more info:

    {{:Infobox:Tank}}
https://wiki.factorio.com/Tank

    {{Infobox video game
    | title = Factorio
    | image = Factorio cover.png
    | developer = Wube Software
    | publisher = Wube Software
    | platforms = {{cslist|[[Linux]]|[[macOS]]|[[Microsoft Windows|Windows]]|[[Nintendo Switch|Switch]]}}
    | released = {{ubl|'''Linux''', '''macOS''', '''Windows'''|14 August 2020|'''Switch'''|28 October 2022}}
    | genre = [[Construction and management simulation]], [[real-time strategy]]
    | modes = [[Single-player]], [[multiplayer]]
    | director = {{Unbulleted list|Michal Kovařík|Tomáš Kozelek|Albert Bertolín}}
    | producer = 
    | designer = Michal Kovařík
    | artist = {{Unbulleted list|Albert Bertolin|Václav Benč}}
    | composer = Daniel James Taylor<br>Petr Wajsar <small>(Space Age expansion)</small>
    }}
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factorio

Keeping the information up-to-date is a big task for a fast-moving game. Imagine editing the card every time the dev changes the hp of the tank. The Factorio blog describes the benefits of this better than I can:

> Together with scripts, templates allow us to partially automate updating the wiki to the newest version, and alongside access to the game's source code, it is possible for me to update the wiki to a new version within a few minutes

The blog post has a lot of other interesting stuff in there as well:

https://factorio.com/blog/post/fff-233

A whole lot of work goes into making game wikis pleasant. I'm sure you could duplicate this all on Wikipedia as well, but that's a lot of additional work and communities already struggle to keep their Fandom wiki's up-to-date. The old Factorio wiki does not even have an article for the tank which has been in the game for years:

https://factorio.fandom.com/wiki/Combat

Out of date info is wrong info.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by Dylan16807 on Monday June 17, 2024 @11:03PM (#40713687)
> Items can be referenced using their in-game names because there's no risk of conflict

Did you purposefully pick one of the items that has an in-game naming conflict and a disambiguation line?

Being focused to a single game means there's only a few conflicts, but it's not zero.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by itishappy on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:02PM (#40723005)
Good point! Not my intent, lol.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by TZubiri on Monday June 17, 2024 @08:21PM (#40712752)
Every project needs a scope.

An encyclopedia excluding exhaustive videogame information is reasonable.

If you don't, you end up with 20 articles for real life fish species, and 20000 articles for fish species in videogames.

Especially since we are talking about an online encyclopedia, Wikipedia is cognizant of its biases and tries to counter them.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by red-iron-pine on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @03:58PM (#40721610)
wikipedia is for everyone; fandom is for fans, aka fanatics
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by binary132 on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:23PM (#40711825)
why?
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by Retr0id on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:28PM (#40711870)
I was going to say "it would be like documenting every chess opening move", but I looked it up and the article exists, so I guess I've just argued against myself: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_chess_openings
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by RheingoldRiver on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:35PM (#40711941)
In disambiguation issues alone, it would be a nightmare if wikipedia hosted niche-topic content within the same namespacing as everything else. What would be good is not wikipedia being more lax, it's WMF providing the same service that Miraheze does; and here, I think, is where the conflict of interest really gets in the way
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by slyall on Monday June 17, 2024 @07:31PM (#40712437)
Every single one of those chess openings has multiple books written about it. The most popular openings have hundreds of books about them.

Not to mention courses, articles, blog posts, discussion and youtube videos

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by makeitdouble on Monday June 17, 2024 @07:54PM (#40712603)
If we're going by volume written about, minecraft isn't lacking any. Try to find more about red stone or mining techniques.

The main difference would be history, the split between books and online resources, and how the older generation sees it.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by Retr0id on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @08:45AM (#40717176)
Circling back to my original point, wherever we draw the line on notability and inclusion vs exclusion, there are going to be people on either side unhappy about the location of the line.

It's probably easier for all parties to let the Minecraft community draw their own line on their own wiki(s) (which is exactly what happens).

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by makeitdouble on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @11:42AM (#40719136)
"No solution will make everybody happy" is kinda of a poor argument though, as it will always be true whatever happens. In the end it comes down to who the service is for, and the younger generation probably doesn't see it as theirs.

I get the feeling Wikipedia will slowly become culturally irrelevant and end up in the same place as the encyclopedias, as an established and mostly frozen dataset that we'll want to keep running but won't look at 99% of the time

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by nextaccountic on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:41PM (#40712002)
This is a list of notable chess moves though, not an exhaustive list of all possible chess moves
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by ang_cire on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:26PM (#40711852)
The same reason I would not fault a print encyclopedia publisher for not including video game strategy guides?
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by mcny on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:34PM (#40711925)
This is an ongoing debate between inclusionists and deletionists and it is far from settled even though the deletionists would have you believe the war is over.

See also https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Inclusionism https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Deletionism

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by ang_cire on Thursday June 27, 2024 @01:49AM (#40807665)
I mean, no matter where you fall philosophically, Wikipedia does take resources to host, including storage costs, and they're always strapped for cash.

If they could be assured of never needing to reduce pages to not run out of money, I would have no logical objection to having a page for everything, but as someone who's donated quite a bit to them, they are most assuredly not in that position.

If the day comes that their hosting costs match or exceed their available funds, I'd much rather know that what is there is all the most important information, and not a glut of random pages that no one ever looks at.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by sdenton4 on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:35PM (#40711937)
Limited page count?
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by ang_cire on Thursday June 20, 2024 @06:10AM (#40736913)
Essentially, yes. Space and scope/mission creep.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by TZubiri on Monday June 17, 2024 @08:18PM (#40712734)
Worth noting that "the creator" of wikipedia doesn't run wikipedia.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by pocketarc on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:10PM (#40711685)
I don’t even really understand why things have to be notable for Wikipedia. If people wanted to maintain all of the Runescape articles in Wikipedia (as mentioned by nouser76)… why not? Why not have Wikipedia literally be the central place for all information for all these different things?
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by stevage on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:19PM (#40711783)
There are many places on Wikipedia that explain exactly why.

The short answer is, because it costs time and effort, and a little bit of money, to maintain all those articles, and they cause more problems than they are worth.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by Gormo on Monday June 17, 2024 @10:30PM (#40713524)
What does it mean to "maintain" an article as something distinct from posting and updating it?
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by stevage on Monday June 17, 2024 @11:06PM (#40713710)
Amongst other things, looking out for vandalism and misinformation. Also managing categories, infoboxes etc as they get updated. There's quite a lot. Just look at the history of any article.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by rightbyte on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:27PM (#40719614)
It would be quite bloated if Wikipedia had 1000 Runescape articles about different minutia I guess.

But I'd like if Wikipedia had 'subwikis' with that kind of stuff.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by soulofmischief on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:15PM (#40711743)
The most lazy approach possible to solve the issue that low-traffic and low-interest data becomes increasingly low-confidence as either no one is monitoring for changes, or due to information wars between parties with conflicting interest.

I've personally been approached to build tech to monitor and revert changes matching keywords using residential proxy systems as a service for low-stakes clients (and declined).

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by lolinder on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:20PM (#40711790)
> The most lazy approach possible to solve the issue that low-traffic and low-interest data becomes increasingly low-confidence

Can you suggest some alternate approaches that you think would actually work? How would you approach removing the notability requirement without immediately opening the floodgates to hundreds of thousands of additional sketchy articles about niche topics that don't have enough interest to be vetted by more than one person per year?

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by soulofmischief on Thursday June 20, 2024 @01:08PM (#40740912)
I've been advocating this for years, but I think a lot of problems on the internet could be solved with a universal, decentralized, anonymous reputation system. A user or entity maintain a private cryptographic key. Each service is given a different sub-key which anonymizes the entity for each service, if they choose. A myriad of voting systems could be employed depending on the needs of each service, via other site users, site admins or both.

These differing voting systems (stars, points, etc) could be normalized through some standardized process into a final reputation score. Other services could then either consider the aggregate score, or only focus on ratings from particular other services, which could be grouped into service types for convenience. Ratings are cryptographically backed and could be fuzzed to increase anonymity. Scores would also be weighted by the relative reputation of other entities. Participating services would also themselves need to maintain a high reputation for their scoring to have much weight in the aggregate.

Services could use these scores to wall of certain site features to entities without sufficient reputation, or even wholesale deny read/write access. Obviously there are particulars to work out to prevent brigading, etc. but there is a balance to strike such that farmed accounts could still quickly be punished the moment they begin spamming/astroturfing. Perhaps a flag/vouch system similar to HN could be employed. Voting rings could also be detected, though with limits given that each vote comes from an anonymized sub-key.

This system would even protect against a future where the majority of content on the web will likely be aided or entirely produced by LLMs or AI. I welcome such synthetic content, but only if it matches or surpasses the general quality of human posts on the internet (which is much worse than one might think). On top of this, users could themselves use these scores as a way to filter out content which is signed with a reputation score below some threshold.

I imagine some kind of hierarchical web, where some services are harder to gain write access to than others, allowing users to gain reputation in low-stakes environments with some level of decentralized moderation, but without compromising the integrity of higher-stakes information.

Each piece of information on the internet should be signed with some sort of introspectable reputation score, and this kind of system would make it possible without compromising privacy and security of users in any political environment.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by johannes1234321 on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:39PM (#40711978)
I would argue that quite some "fandom" content gathers more views than many "notable" pages on Wikipedia.

That said, I think there is a distinction between fact and made up.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by i80and on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:29PM (#40711879)
It's been frustrating watching articles for stuff I cared about in the 2000's get deleted because the mere passage or time has rendered the topics non-notable
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by bpeebles on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:38PM (#40711965)
It's not always clear but notability is not temporary[0] under English Wikipedia's guidelines. Standards of what makes something notable have shifted over the years and sometimes the different is hard to tease out.

0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Notability#Notabilit...

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by i80and on Monday June 17, 2024 @07:00PM (#40712171)
I understand this to be the case, but in practice the distinction is mostly immaterial. Topics are notable for a decade, then not notable the next.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by stevage on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:18PM (#40711770)
No, that's a real stretch. Jimmy Wales is barely involved in Wikipedia, and certainly has no say in editorial policy like that.

The notability policy predates the creation of Wikicities significantly.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by Fatnino on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @01:02AM (#40714207)
Then why does his face show up at the top of every page asking for money at the end of every year?
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by stevage on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:35AM (#40714699)
I think you're probably smart enough to answer that one.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by vintermann on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @06:43AM (#40716141)
It's not simply about there being a notability policy. Wikipedia was famous for having a conflict between "deletionists" and "inclusionists" who had disagreements on what these policies should be and how they should be interpreted. Deletionists are generally considered to have won because Wales and the circle around him sided with them.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by thih9 on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:20PM (#40711794)
I am a user of both Wikipedia and Fandom, Vampire Survivors Wiki[1] in particular. I would very much prefer to read niche articles on Wikipedia.

I can understand strict rules about reliable sources, independent point of view, or fighting SEO/spam. Still, satellite wikis could exist. Or Portals could serve as some workaround to the notability rule. Or something else.

Wikipedia is by nerds and largely for nerds, I'm sure allowing nerdy topics there would help everyone in the long run.

[1]: https://vampire-survivors.fandom.com/wiki/Vampire_Survivors_...

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by JustLeafy on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:11AM (#40714000)
Hey there, the other admin of the Vampire Survivors Wiki here. What do you think of moving this wiki to wiki.gg?
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by thih9 on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:51AM (#40714787)
To clarify, I’m not an admin or editor, just a reader. In any case, as a reader, wiki.gg looks good to me and better than fandom.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by garrettgarcia on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:18PM (#40711773)
Where's the conflict of interest in having two different products for two different purposes?
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by YawningAngel on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:08PM (#40711659)
I have had this exact thought and am deeply irritated by it
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by Vt71fcAqt7 on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:22PM (#40711811)
It goes hand in hand with Wikipedia's stricter source requirements. You would need to source all the information from books and news articles (from a select choice of reliable sites decided by wikipedia editors). Essentially Wikipedia's definition of notable is 3 reliable sources writing about the topic. So it's really more about reliability (or, what Wikipedia admins consider reliable) than notability.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by makeitdouble on Monday June 17, 2024 @08:04PM (#40712664)
Partly unrelated, but I wonder how Wikipedia's source requirements will move in the future as:

- more "reputable" news sources AI generate their articles

- traditional publications are facing existential threats as their revenue source is drying out ("Google Zero"), and we can't expect their number to grow in the future

- more experts and analysts are gatekeeping their work under subscription paywalls and alternative services. Paid mailing lists for instance won't be a valid and verifiable source

It feels like at some point Wikipedia could be basically frozen if they can't adapt to the new landscape, but from the outside it doesn't look like an organization that can sensibly move on and change core parts in a pragmatic way.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by celemap on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:41PM (#40711997)
You realise Wikipedia is not for Monster Hunter character builds right? A video game Wiki is different than Wikipedia.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by add-sub-mul-div on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:39PM (#40711983)
No. Before the internet the encyclopedia didn't have over 10,000 articles about The Simpsons and it's reasonable that that would be outside the scope of Wikipedia as well. Just because someone profits from a situation doesn't make it improper.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by Affric on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:33PM (#40711919)
Not at all. Once you start permitting large amounts of fiction in Wikipedia then what’s to stop any sort of fiction being included? Why not just have articles full of lies? Fundamentally fiction is lies. Just because a large group of people enjoy indulging the lies doesn’t mean it should be included in an encyclopaedia. I say this as a lover of fiction and video games.

Notability criterion is important.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by eurleif on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:37PM (#40711957)
There's plenty of fiction on Wikipedia already; fictionality is orthogonal to notability; and it's possible to describe what occurs within a work of fiction without asserting that it occurs in the real world.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by Affric on Monday June 17, 2024 @07:18PM (#40712320)
I don’t think that fictionality is orthogonal to notability. I do think that something that occurs in fiction is inherently less notable than the equivalent event occurring in real life no matter how popular the work of fiction.

I agree on the second point but fundamentally extensively in depth information about the inner workings of a fictional piece are best acquired from the work itself. Not gleaned from an encyclopaedia.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by bawolff on Monday June 17, 2024 @09:58PM (#40713351)
> meanwhile its creator is heavily involved in running for-profit Fandom that just so happens to solve that problem?

My understanding is that the series of events was - stuff kept getting rejected from wikipedia, so jimmy and some other people made wikicities (now fandom). I dont think its coincidence that jimmy saw a business oportunity, but wikipedia rejecting stuff came first, and jimmy does not control wikipedia processes.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by vintermann on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @06:46AM (#40716165)
> jimmy does not control wikipedia processes

He and the employees of his organization obviously had an outsized influence on it.

Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by bawolff on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @12:20AM (#40724775)
In the very early days maybe, but his influence waned a lot faster than you would expect.
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom by account42 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @08:00AM (#40727426)
I'm all for criticizing Jimmy for his involvement in Fandom but I also don't think Wikipedia needs to be given even more power as the de-facto source of truth for everything. Instead we should work towards having more independent websites.