Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom
by Retr0id on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:28PM
(#40711870)
I was going to say "it would be like documenting every chess opening move", but I looked it up and the article exists, so I guess I've just argued against myself: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_chess_openings
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom
by RheingoldRiver on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:35PM
(#40711941)
In disambiguation issues alone, it would be a nightmare if wikipedia hosted niche-topic content within the same namespacing as everything else. What would be good is not wikipedia being more lax, it's WMF providing the same service that Miraheze does; and here, I think, is where the conflict of interest really gets in the way
Every single one of those chess openings has multiple books written about it. The most popular openings have hundreds of books about them.
Not to mention courses, articles, blog posts, discussion and youtube videos
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom
by makeitdouble on Monday June 17, 2024 @07:54PM
(#40712603)
If we're going by volume written about, minecraft isn't lacking any. Try to find more about red stone or mining techniques.
The main difference would be history, the split between books and online resources, and how the older generation sees it.
Circling back to my original point, wherever we draw the line on notability and inclusion vs exclusion, there are going to be people on either side unhappy about the location of the line.
It's probably easier for all parties to let the Minecraft community draw their own line on their own wiki(s) (which is exactly what happens).
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom
by makeitdouble on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @11:42AM
(#40719136)
"No solution will make everybody happy" is kinda of a poor argument though, as it will always be true whatever happens. In the end it comes down to who the service is for, and the younger generation probably doesn't see it as theirs.
I get the feeling Wikipedia will slowly become culturally irrelevant and end up in the same place as the encyclopedias, as an established and mostly frozen dataset that we'll want to keep running but won't look at 99% of the time
Re:“Attention assault” on Fandom
by nextaccountic on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:41PM
(#40712002)
This is a list of notable chess moves though, not an exhaustive list of all possible chess moves