News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by sillysaurusx on Friday May 10, 2024 @02:26PM (#40322245)
The water seems like the hard part. Are there any tricks for cheap, safe hydration for a family?

I guess we could just start building walls of unopened water bottles in our basement…

(In my teens I saw a family friend had a bag full of food supplies. I asked someone if that was a prep bag, and they said yes. I thought they were a bit weird. Now I’ve come full circle browsing Amazon for cheap doomsday food.)

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by sa46 on Friday May 10, 2024 @03:13PM (#40322813)
I used to be a logistics officer for an Infantry battalion.

Most of the comments down thread underestimate water consumption. Depending on the climate, you'll want the following daily quantities [1]:

- 2-3 gallons for drinking

- 1.5 gallons for hygiene (can skip for a while)

- 0.5 gallons for food prep

The planning factor for military operations was 8 gallons per person per day. Water is heavy—8 pounds per gallon—and acquiring, storing, and moving it is a large effort.

[1] https://cascom.army.mil/g_staff/g3/TTD/Products/QM-How-to-Ha...

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by fl0ki on Friday May 10, 2024 @03:44PM (#40323088)
> 8 pounds per gallon

It never occurred to me that people needed this spelled out, but I guess it's simpler in most of the world where 1L = 1kg.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by ghostly_s on Friday May 10, 2024 @03:58PM (#40323225)
I don't think you can blame inch-pounds for this one- even though we rationally know it is heavier than most materials we don't "think of" water as heavy because modern society gives us the luxury of seldom having to handle more than a thirty minute or so supply of it at once.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by DemocracyFTW2 on Friday May 10, 2024 @04:43PM (#40323608)
then again, anyone with a garden or balcony that has to be watered with a watering can can [sic] attest to how heavy a little bit of water is. If you have a small 100m² garden and it rains a modest 1mm (per m² that is) that's 1L/m² equivalent to 1kg/m² or 100kg total mass of water. When it has rained 1mm people call it "three drops of rain" and they will have to water their plants anyway. That's already 10 cans @ 10L each to lug around.

The other kind of people who know about the weight of waters are people with campers / trailers and people with fish tanks in their apartments. The maximum allowable size for a fish tank in the middle of the room is not that much.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by fl0ki on Friday May 10, 2024 @04:20PM (#40323399)
I wasn't actually commenting on the "heavy" part but the "8 pounds per gallon" part. I can do these conversions on demand but, besides never being the native way I think personally, there are simply more numeric conversions you have to do when you use this system whether or not it's native to you.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by almostnormal on Saturday May 11, 2024 @03:17AM (#40326558)
>> 8 pounds per gallon

> It never occurred to me that people needed this spelled out, but I guess it's simpler in most of the world where 1L = 1kg.

It's easy in gallons and pounds, too, if the correct gallon is used: 10 pounds per imperial gallon of water, by definition.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by samatman on Saturday May 11, 2024 @11:02AM (#40328522)
It's just as simple, frankly. A gallon is four quarts, each of which is two pounds of water. A quart is two pints: and a pint's a pound, the world round (Yes, most of us are aware of the irony of that couplet).

These are all things which are generally known to Americans. But HN has an international audience, for whom "gallon" is presumably somewhat vague.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by close04 on Friday May 10, 2024 @03:36PM (#40323018)
> 8 gallons per person per day. Water is heavy—8 pounds per gallon

The average person needs far less than 65lbs (30kg) of water per day, which is a third of the average male weight in the US.

By medical standards humans need more like 8lbs (under 4l) per day for men and 6lbs (under 3l) for women. Less if your rationing and not exerting yourself.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by hooch on Friday May 10, 2024 @07:11PM (#40324621)
OP’s factoring includes washing, food prep, all that other stuff.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by dilyevsky on Friday May 10, 2024 @09:24PM (#40325317)
1.5 a day for washing is hilariously wasteful. Use some wet wipes for crying out loud!
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by throwaway11460 on Friday May 10, 2024 @09:43PM (#40325395)
How do you wash your clothes and dishes with wet wipes?

Also you need to clean your home - you don't want to get sick in a catastrophe scenario.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by instagib on Saturday May 11, 2024 @10:55AM (#40328468)
1.28gal for toilet flushing the most efficient toilets. 1.6gal for normal and it can be worse for older ones.

I was on a hike that recommended 1 gallon to complete it for 5 miles round trip.

I’m sure there is a method to the madness of 8 gallons per person that isn’t easy to see. There is a lot of rounding up with the military also.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by ianburrell on Friday May 10, 2024 @07:32PM (#40324739)
The normal amount in disaster preparedness is 1gal per person per day. The problem with the larger amounts is that people see they need huge amounts and don't do anything. Better to get started storing 5-7 gal for each person.

The way to allow for extras is to store water for a longer length of time. If recommended value is two weeks, and it is in my area, then a month is a good buffer.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by dilyevsky on Friday May 10, 2024 @09:22PM (#40325307)
8 ga of water per person per day is completely insane in disaster scenario. 2-3ga for drinking a day? Medical professionals recommend less than 1 for a normal person.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by mcmcmc on Saturday May 11, 2024 @12:30AM (#40325962)
Keep in mind military operations generally aren't supposed to be disaster scenarios. And someone marching 10+ miles a day in full kit, possibly through heavy terrain or while under fire, is probably going to sweat a lot more than a normal person.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by ornornor on Saturday May 11, 2024 @06:24AM (#40327251)
I’d you’re not doing anything. But if you’re doing physical effort then you’ll need to drink a lot more that 2–3L a day.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by briffle on Friday May 10, 2024 @02:36PM (#40322359)
Walmart sells 5 gallon water totes for $15. that is essentially 5 days for one person. We have a few on hand (family of 4 plus dog) and every six months or so, I empty them, clean them, and re-fill them. Also, there are gravity filters that work great if you have things like creeks near you.. Berkey Filters are pretty good for filtering out contaminants, as well as 2-bag gravity filters that are really popular with backpackers because you can fill the dirty bag up, hang from a tree, and do other things while the clean bag fills.. (not an endorsement, but their pictures show nicely how they work) https://www.platy.com/filtration/gravityworks-water-filter-s...
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by dole on Friday May 10, 2024 @04:16PM (#40323378)
I'll second Berkey Filters. While a full Berkey setup may seem expensive, the filters themselves and not the housing is the important part.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by steve_adams_86 on Friday May 10, 2024 @04:49PM (#40323653)
You can also use the filters with alternative housings that are far cheaper if aesthetics aren’t a concern. I’ve seen people use food safe 5 gallon buckets for example. It’s much cheaper and works just as well in emergency situations. You do need to be careful about light penetration of the translucent bucket wall.

Another cool thing is that you can make (in a pinch, I wouldn’t recommend this over berkey filters) filters from the same type of bulkheads berkey uses attached to home-made ceramic filters. They work remarkably well in emergencies and are trivial to make if you’ve got clay and a hot fire. There’s definitely trial and error involved for getting perfect seals, and some advanced DIYers I’ve seen used glazing to create a more easily sealed rim which can have a plastic tube jammed into it for a friction fit, which then attaches to the inner part of the bulkhead.

Totally unnecessary if civilization is working but awesome if things go sideways and you’re out of filters. There might be better methods too, I haven’t looked into it for years.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by mmh0000 on Friday May 10, 2024 @04:09PM (#40323311)
I've got one of these in my garage. It provides a lot of piece of mind knowing water is solved for. I not a "prepper" by any means, but, realistically I need water every day or I will die. Spending a few hundred to ensure I don't die from dehydration during a natural disaster seems worth it.

https://www.surewatertanks.com/collections/products/products...

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by bbarnett on Friday May 10, 2024 @03:43PM (#40323078)
If there is no AC, and you are exerting yourself a lot (no car or transportation is down, more work to prepare food, even having to take a dump outside), 5 gallons is barely enough for one person to drink per day. You'll be sweating a lot more in those conditions.

Another example is food in winter months. During a disaster, even with winter gear, your houee may not be heated. If it is -20C inside, your body will need more calories.

If you're having to go outside to cook, to expel waste, and maybe even to go find snow to melt for water, you're going to need 3x your caloric intake.

You have to plan for worst case usage per day, not best.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by danw1979 on Friday May 10, 2024 @03:57PM (#40323205)
If you drink ~19 litres (5 US gallons?) of water every day you will not survive long. That’s about an order of magnitude more than is recommended under normal non-strenuous conditions.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by groby_b on Friday May 10, 2024 @04:01PM (#40323246)
> 5 gallons is barely enough for one person to drink per day.

OK, no. If you're running a marathon, in hot weather, you're at maybe a liter per hour. Unless you plan to run 20h marathons and the sun never sets, 5 gallon is well beyond drinking needs.

And unless you're able to exert yourself at that level at all, this isn't the "worst case", this is pure fantasy.

And if you're preparing for -20C in your house, I recommend investing in insulation, not more calories stored away. (I also question 3x, the figures I've seen point to 2x, with exertion somewhat counteracting cold)

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by vbezhenar on Friday May 10, 2024 @04:29PM (#40323477)
I drink may be two liters of water per day. Unless Google lies to me, 5 gallons is almost 20 liters which would be enough for 3 weeks for me with rationing.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by ramses0 on Friday May 10, 2024 @04:33PM (#40323508)
The genius move I heard of was to throw a few 5-gal jugs of water up in your attic (!!!). It's relatively shelf-stable, standardized size, and "in case of emergency" you can even use it as a gravity-flowed spout to fill smaller containers below.

I've taken to trying to have a minimal set of 4 one liter steel water bottles hung in the closet (grab + go) all the time. So convenient to be able to "just grab some water" on the way out the door, and is the start of a solid emergency prep station.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by scheme271 on Friday May 10, 2024 @04:56PM (#40323713)
If it's kept in plastic containers, it's probably only good for a year or so before enough stuff leaches into the water that it'll last off and funky. The time period decreases significantly if your attic gets hot (like a lot of them do).
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by Terr_ on Friday May 10, 2024 @08:36PM (#40325089)
In that kind of emergency, I'd probably be satisfied with safe-but-distasteful as opposed to unavailable.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by halgir on Friday May 10, 2024 @05:06PM (#40323792)
I want my regular drinking water to be as free of microplastics as possible, but is contamination from plastic containers dangerous enough to be of any concern during an emergency situation?
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by blincoln on Friday May 10, 2024 @04:49PM (#40323657)
If one is going to do that, I'd strongly recommend putting them in some kind of basin that can hold the water if it escapes from the jugs, or sturdier containers, or both.

At least in the US, water jugs are generally very flimsy. An attic is likely to have wide temperature variations throughout the year, and leaky water jugs up there could cause some expensive damage.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by nytesky on Friday May 10, 2024 @05:59PM (#40324180)
Yeah we had plastic jugs in our cool basement leak all over the concrete floor — I can’t imagine the disaster that would be to have plastic jugs in my 140F attic with resultant leaking down from the ceiling
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by travisb on Friday May 10, 2024 @04:30PM (#40323485)
The cheapest way is to find some cheap, food-safe container(s). Put it into your basement and change out the water every 3-6 months.

55 gallon rain barrels can often be found subsidized and therefore cheap.

Keep a bunch of camping iodine drops around and you are set.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by pennomi on Friday May 10, 2024 @02:36PM (#40322365)
Backpacking water filters aren’t all that expensive and work fine with most water sources. Wouldn’t produce enough to shower in but certainly enough that you could survive in a disaster.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by ThrowawayR2 on Friday May 10, 2024 @04:00PM (#40323244)
I wouldn't think backpacking water filters would help much in for getting water from rivers / ponds in an urban/suburban environment? They'd take care of particulate matter and microbes but I doubt they'd do much for chemical contaminants.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by Johnny555 on Friday May 10, 2024 @04:48PM (#40323642)
Also, most filters can filter bacteria and cysts, but can't filter out viruses. Many say viruses are not an issue in the backcountry (but I still use purifying tablets), but if you're taking water from a suburban stream during a disaster, I'd definitely want to make sure I'm not ingesting whatever viruses the guy upstream deposited when he used the stream as a toilet.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by heavenlyblue on Saturday May 11, 2024 @09:11AM (#40327829)
Viruses do not survive in the open air well because they don't have a hybernation mechanism as opposed to bacteria
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by Marsymars on Friday May 10, 2024 @02:51PM (#40322543)
I've got an assortment of backpacking/camping water filters, but don't live especially near a water source, so my days would revolve around walks to the nearest creek. (2 km away) A cargo bike would help a lot there.

If the municipal water is still functional but non-potable, a LifeStraw Max gets you effectively unlimited water on-demand for most sources of contamination.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by jandrese on Friday May 10, 2024 @03:14PM (#40322821)
You could collect rainwater, but realistically water outages are usually not "the taps are dry", but rather "the water treatment plant failed so we can't guarantee the water is safe to drink."
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by Marsymars on Friday May 10, 2024 @07:36PM (#40324758)
I do collect rainwater! (In the summer months, at least.) Have a system cobbled together based on bluebarrelsystems.com

Though disaster preparedness and water efficiency are a bit at odds. For the former I'd want to keep all my barrels mostly full, but for the latter I want to keep them empty enough that rainfall events aren't overflowing them and wasting water.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by Terr_ on Friday May 10, 2024 @08:32PM (#40325064)
That seems to be pretty optimistic with respect to geography.

Consider: "The pumps aren't working and there's nothing left up inside the local water-tower."

Then you'd have to travel to get any appreciable amount of water before even starting to filter it.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by cesarb on Saturday May 11, 2024 @07:15AM (#40327432)
> You could collect rainwater, but realistically water outages are usually not "the taps are dry", but rather "the water treatment plant failed so we can't guarantee the water is safe to drink."

This happened literally last month in the region where I live, and yes "the taps are dry" is exactly what happened.

The water treatment plant staff detected high levels of toluene in the river which feeds the plant, so as a preventive measure, they shut down the whole thing. It took several days until they managed to get the toluene levels in the river low enough that adding activated charcoal to the water intake could get rid of the rest. In the meantime, there was no water being pumped into the system, and once your building's water tank ran dry (the size varies depending on the building), there was no water anymore (unless you hired a water truck to bring water from a nearby city).

And that's not even the first time this kind of thing happened around here. A couple of years ago, another water treatment plant in the same region (fed by a different river) had trouble due to high levels of geosmin in the river, and they also had to shut down for a while. The result was the same, taps running dry once the building water tanks get empty.

Not to mention that pumping water needs lots of electric power. Not only at the water treatment plant, but several other places in the system need to move water against gravity, or increase its pressure.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by rolph on Friday May 10, 2024 @02:57PM (#40322614)
distillation allows separation of water from not water.

mud or damp vegetation can be a water source.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by ninininino on Friday May 10, 2024 @03:33PM (#40322990)
I would probably want a Gravi-stil as relying on filter mediums has a built-in expiration date (or # of gallons).
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by Marsymars on Friday May 10, 2024 @04:53PM (#40323685)
Sure, but even with my regular water usage, the LifeStraw Max filters would last me over a year, and it works via water pressure. There isn't really any disaster scenario where I'm remaining in my home and need to purify water via burning wood.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by rolph on Friday May 10, 2024 @02:54PM (#40322584)
storing large quantities of water is not trivial maintenence.

its better to be able to sanitize required quantities on demand.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by encoderer on Friday May 10, 2024 @02:35PM (#40322349)
Have the local water delivery company drop off 5 jugs a year
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by tithe on Friday May 10, 2024 @02:36PM (#40322364)
One option is to do what quick-service restaurants (e.g., Subway) do for chips, cookies, drinks, etc.: keep a hefty supply of product on hand, but consume it first-in-first-out (FIFO, like a queue): add new supplies to the "back" when you consume from the "front".
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by swader999 on Friday May 10, 2024 @03:09PM (#40322768)
A bag of pool shock and how to use it safely to treat water is fairly easy and cheap.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by ceejayoz on Friday May 10, 2024 @02:31PM (#40322312)
> Are there any tricks for cheap, safe hydration for a family?

Live near a lake, stream, etc. and enough firewood to boil water.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by harry_ord on Friday May 10, 2024 @02:31PM (#40322317)
High water tinned foods will help a lot.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by ajross on Friday May 10, 2024 @03:18PM (#40322858)
> The water seems like the hard part. Are there any tricks for cheap, safe hydration for a family?

You already have the equipment for that. Your existing hot water heater stores enough drinking water for a month at least, probably more if you ration carefully.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by mgkimsal on Friday May 10, 2024 @03:25PM (#40322916)
we got the smaller 42 gallon one, and.. with two people and a pet... it might last a couple weeks tops, I'd think, if we rationed (~2-3 gallons per day?)
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by ajross on Friday May 10, 2024 @03:34PM (#40323003)
I don't think I've ever drunk two gallons in a day in my whole life. Sedentary survival needs in reasonable climates are maybe a third of that.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by Filligree on Friday May 10, 2024 @09:06PM (#40325233)
Go hiking in 35 degree weather on Mallorca, you'll easily exceed that.

But that's not really disaster-relevant, no.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by cynicalsecurity on Friday May 10, 2024 @02:39PM (#40322390)
Dig a well.
Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by salad-tycoon on Friday May 10, 2024 @04:23PM (#40323425)
You have to have the right kind of ground to drill with this. I think lots of gravel and rocks won’t work well. Never used it myself but was considering it in the past.

https://www.drillawell.com/complete-kit

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by tlavoie on Friday May 10, 2024 @05:00PM (#40323747)
I've got a 1000 litre / 250-ish US gallon rainwater collection tank. While I wouldn't want to start there for drinking water, it would do for quite a while if I boil it.

We do get power failures, so it's mostly been for some garden watering, and being able to flush our toilets during an outage. We're on a well, and the pump needs 220v. I suppose I could get a better generator too, ours only does 120v.

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by namibj on Saturday May 11, 2024 @12:52PM (#40329237)
You can just use a transformer to re-create the 240 for your pump if the power/load is otherwise fine

Especially as an autotransformer it's pretty cheap (should be about 50$).

Re:Coronal mass ejection impact imminent, Two more earth-dir... by tlavoie on Saturday May 11, 2024 @01:40PM (#40329527)
That's true! It hasn't been a huge issue, we tend to mitigate basically by filling some pots with water when a storm is coming. (Usual outages happen in high winds, we have overhead lines and many trees.)