News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by blackhawkC17 on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:06PM (#40311037)
I feel this factor plays a huge role in rich/upper middle class/upper-class people staying rich or growing richer.

Kids that grow up upper-class imitate their parent’s approach to work and life in general, giving them an upper-hand.

Many poor kids are very smart and capable but end up imitating bad examples early on, making them handicapped.

One of the best things a disadvantaged kid can get is a good role model. Doesn’t have to be rich…anyone with a stable middle-class life to imitate is enough, compared to questionable characters some imitate (gun-toting rappers for one).

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by NetBeck on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:16PM (#40311169)
>It is estimated that 70% of wealthy families will lose their wealth by the second generation and 90% will lose it by the third.[0]

[0] https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/generational-wealth%3A-why-d...

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by Rinzler89 on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:33PM (#40311366)
What's the actual real world evidence on that? Plenty of rich European families have been rich for hundreds of years, and I'm not talking about royalty. That kind of disproves the theory.

The ones who go broke fast are usually the ones who also got rich fast, trough luck instead of work or knowledge, like from lottery wins or speculations.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by s1artibartfast on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:41PM (#40311494)
There is a lot of real world socioeconomic data on it. studies usually look at the population in terms of 20 or 25% segments. That doesn't mean it is true for the 1% or 0.1%. That said, there are lots of examples of people entering and leaving the top 1% too, so outcome isn't perfectly deterministic.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by whimsicalism on Thursday May 09, 2024 @03:23PM (#40311997)
Actually, real world socioeconomic data on familial wealth holdings is incredibly hard to come by.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by s1artibartfast on Thursday May 09, 2024 @03:47PM (#40312239)
Wealth is hard to come by, but income is much more available.

Some countries have publicly available data on individual income filings. The US provides anonymized data, but scienentist have done a lot of fancy tricks to make the family connections clear.

Raj Chetty among others have done a lot of work on US social mobility[1]. They were able to trend parent/child incomes in the US going back to 1940, and have tons of great insights.

I dont remember all of the findings off the top of my head, but one was that relative social mobility (%s) for the US have been constant over time. Another was that economic mobility out of the bottom classes is dominated by poor immigrants. It is unclear if it is genetic, personality, or culture, but children of poor immigrants out perform native born poor by an enormous factor (2-3X better IIRC)

https://www.econtalk.org/raj-chetty-on-economic-mobility/

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by Rinzler89 on Thursday May 09, 2024 @04:24PM (#40312589)
>Wealth is hard to come by, but income is much more available.

Income is a completely different thing than wealth and those two are not always directly correlated. You can have a good income but not accumulate much wealth because all is bein eaten away by taxes and a high CoL, and you can also have a low income but still decent wealth from an inheritance for example.

And the original claim was that wealth gets lost between generations by the majority of people which I find dubious.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by s1artibartfast on Thursday May 09, 2024 @04:46PM (#40312800)
I think that as a practical matter, they are extremely correlated. Wealth sitting in cash loses half its value every 20 years. Physical assets require upkeep and property taxes.

In practice, if you aren't making income, you losing wealth.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by Rinzler89 on Thursday May 09, 2024 @05:03PM (#40312939)
>Wealth sitting in cash loses half its value every 20 years.

By wealth, people tend to mean assets, not petty cash sitting in checking accounts. If you're sitting on inherited assets you're accumulating more wealth by just sitting on your ass without doing anything.

Just see the post-2009 monetary polices: from housing to stocks, everything went up like crazy, especially during COvid. You didn't have to be financially literate, all you had to do was sit on your inherited assets and not touch them and the government's money printer did the work for you in the last 10+ years.

So forgive me but I still see no proof that 72% people loose their wealth between generations, when everything went up up up in the last decades, especially housing. Unless that wealth we're talking about was an old carpet and $600 bucks in a checking account.

>Physical assets require upkeep and property taxes.

N'ah bruh. Stocks or empty land in desirable areas requires no upkeep and wealth taxes in some EU countries range from laughable to zero, while income taxes in those same countries hover around 50%. Go ahead, tell me more how income is the same thing with wealth.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by s1artibartfast on Thursday May 09, 2024 @05:15PM (#40313042)
It seems like you didn't read the whole post. If anyone ever sells those assets, they are counted as income.

The vast majority of wealth isn't empty houses, ever rented, and never sold.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by TheCoelacanth on Friday May 10, 2024 @03:52AM (#40316397)
Wealth sitting in cash is almost an oxymoron. It's not wealth if it's not producing more wealth.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by afpx on Friday May 10, 2024 @08:43AM (#40318282)
A good book to read is Piketty's "Capital in the 21st Century" in which he does a lot of analysis to support your intuition.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by afpx on Friday May 10, 2024 @09:02AM (#40318484)
That page you link says that the poor that escape poverty do so by mingling with well-off people. The poor that stay poor only mingle with other poor people. The best route to becoming rich is to look and act like the rich and hang out where they hang out.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by froh on Thursday May 09, 2024 @05:02PM (#40312935)
the top 1% is people we all know.

the interesting groups are the top .1% and .01%. there isn't that much fluctuation at that layer.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by s1artibartfast on Thursday May 09, 2024 @05:08PM (#40312984)
You said we don't know but claim to know. Which is it?
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by Rinzler89 on Thursday May 09, 2024 @05:19PM (#40313078)
It's complicated. Not all wealth is public. Only the wealth of the individuals who's wealth is tied to publicly traded companies: Musk, Bezos, Zuck, etc.

But we also have all those royal families from Europe and the Middle East, dictators like Putin, etc. whos' wealth are secret and very well hidden through crown estates, trusts, shell companies, all through Caribbean off-shores and often under different names. The best you have for those people is guestimations and some leaks from the Panam Papers to get an idea.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by froh on Friday May 10, 2024 @08:57AM (#40318419)
what I meant was the top 1% is one in a hundred, and you personally know some people that are at that income and wealth percentile, don't you?

however for the 1 in 10_000 you may or may not know people in that tier and for the 1 in 100_000 let alone 1 in 1_000_000 you are close to that tier or part of it to personally know them (in such a way that they know you).

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by Jerrrry on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:39PM (#40311461)
Comparing American generational accumulation to the olden European social quasi-caste system is a little disingenuous.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by Rinzler89 on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:48PM (#40311591)
Where did you see me compare it to Americans?

I'm from Europe so my knowledge revolves around local examples.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by dom2 on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:33PM (#40311371)
This isn't a real statistic, it's an advertisement for wealth management.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by detourdog on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:44PM (#40311539)
I usually see this statistic about family businesses. In the USA a family business passing through 3 generations is rare.

My personal observation is that the 4 generation has so many better options than the family business is holding them back with responsibility and the family unity has broken down through generational grudges.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by dexwiz on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:46PM (#40311572)
Are all decedents rich, or just a small fraction? Even if a family line has been continued for hundreds of years, there may be hundreds or even thousands of decedents of the original members who do not have access to the line of wealth. Also many families stay wealthy by only marrying members of other wealthy families. Marrying outside of the ruling class results in rapid dilution of power.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by whimsicalism on Thursday May 09, 2024 @03:24PM (#40312013)
We do not have anywhere near the quality of data about familial wealth holdings to say anything of the sort
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by naveen99 on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:32PM (#40311363)
That might have been truer when people were having 6+ children. With the modern average of 1.5, I doubt more than 10% lose their trust funds.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by anon291 on Thursday May 09, 2024 @09:16PM (#40314629)
That's losing their wealth, not becoming trapped in poverty. Wealth (as in hard cash) is fleeting. The behaviors that create wealth are not. I truly contend that, in America at least (what I'm familiar with), everyone can achieve a solid life. You might not be wealthy, but you will be able to support yourself and provide for a family. People losing their wealth does not mean they become destitute, nor should it. It just means they fall into a more 'normal' cohort.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by afpx on Friday May 10, 2024 @08:54AM (#40318386)
That study was done by the Williams Group. Although it is widely cited across many popular news sites, it is surprisingly impossible to find the original study. Also, there's also almost no information about the Williams Group out there. No, Wikipedia page, for instance. Their web site says they do: "Government Relations, Public Affairs, Lobbying"
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by rqtwteye on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:42PM (#40311518)
Totally agree. When I grew up, I was friends with the son of the richest family in town. I was once invited to dinner with them and was totally shocked they had real conversations. My family had a stable income and house but my interactions with my dad were basically him ranting about somebody else or me. I don't recall any productive conversation I ever had with him. Even now in my 50s I still struggle to have conversations and constantly have to watch not to talk like my dad. On the other hand I also took on a lot of good traits of my parents like financial responsibility.

My sister always had a better relationship with her kids and they have way better social skills than me or my sisters.

Examples or mentors can have a huge influence on people, especially when they are young. Some are good, some are bad.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by giantg2 on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:11PM (#40311105)
I generally agree. However, some kids of rich people turn out spoiled or lazy.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by lotsofpulp on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:35PM (#40311411)
This is simplified in the aphorism “you are the company you keep”.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by anovikov on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:24PM (#40311276)
I'd say having a "stable middle-class" parent is the worst starting point to become rich. It's a sure way to become a similarly boring middle-middle class person - that is, a strictly conformist, risk-averse, boot-licking serf.

Kid of a rich person will probably become rich because they inherit cash. Kid of a poor person may become rich because they are ready to take risk and usually have good social skills. That, or they may die trying or end up in prison... But there's no good pathway to become rich if you come from a boring middle-middle-class. Too little money for elite uni or other ways to "hack" it, too little money for risk taking ("starting a startup because you always have something to fall back on"), and inherited attitude against risk-taking. Dead end. You just take up a mediocre white collar job and count years till retirement.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by ch4s3 on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:37PM (#40311440)
This isn't supported by data, of people in the middle income quintile 23.3% of their children end up in the top quintile while only 9.3% of people from the bottom quintile make it to the top[1]. The fourth and fifth(top) quintiles of income lead to the highest rates of children entering the top quintile.

[1] https://www.cato.org/commentary/upward-mobility-alive-well-a...

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by darby_eight on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:12PM (#40311115)
This implies one's being upper class is a reflection of having better habits than the poor, which is incorrect. They just have more money. Rich people could not survive poverty.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by s1artibartfast on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:24PM (#40311282)
I largely disagree due to social mobility.

If you look at the differences between people who escape poverty and those that don't, you will find major differences in Habits and capability.

If you look at people who drop in social class and those that dont, you will also find differences.

If starting wealth was all that mattered, and human behavior had zero impact, you would see no mobility. I guess one could chalk mobility up to random luck, but this flies in a the face off massive amounts of data correlating performance with outcome.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by Red_Leaves_Flyy on Thursday May 09, 2024 @08:57PM (#40314511)
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by giantg2 on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:20PM (#40311224)
Some of the richest people I've ever met have middle class or upper-middle class appearances. They do make good decisions, have good jobs, etc. We see some evidence in studies that wealthly grandparents are strong indicators of wealthly adult grandchildren. We also know that poor habits deplete wealth quickly (like with lotto winners). It seems reasonable at least some wealthy people have good habits and that at least some of the children adopt those habits and manage to at least protect the existing wealth.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by djeastm on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:25PM (#40311286)
>We see some evidence in studies that wealthly grandparents are strong indicators of wealthly adult grandchildren.

Seems just slightly obvious, though I'm sure the studies are more nuanced than this

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by giantg2 on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:34PM (#40311384)
Yeah, the ones I've seen have looked at things like even what type of assest the wealth is in (liquid, securities, land, etc). The type of wealth can be a factor in how well the wealth is remained.
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by darby_eight on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:41PM (#40311491)
Liking the aesthetics of fitting in with the proles does not mean they could survive
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by giantg2 on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:43PM (#40311528)
Nothing in my comment was about survival in poverty. However, their ability to live within their means seems indicative that they have the discipline that they might be able do it. In fact, most people can survive in poverty - what other choice do they have?
Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by feoren on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:44PM (#40311549)
Both can be true, if growing up with more money is a causal factor in having "better" habits (in terms of wealth generation/retention). I also agree that many rich people could not survive poverty. Both are adapted to their situations.

The problem is that this makes it harder to bring people out of poverty, because you're trying to pull them into a situation they're less adapted for. I actually am in favor of simply giving the poor (/everyone) money (e.g. basic income), but even I acknowledge that poverty-formed habits are going to be a barrier in that strategy's effectiveness.

We're not trying to pull rich people into poverty, so the fact that they wouldn't fare well there is moot.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by s1artibartfast on Thursday May 09, 2024 @03:23PM (#40311998)
What would cause them to not survive poverty? would they all commit suicide or spontaneously combust?

Avoiding death is a pretty strong force for adaptation to new circumstances.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by feoren on Thursday May 09, 2024 @05:56PM (#40313351)
Alcoholism, drug addiction, dying on the street on a cold night, lack of proper healthcare, and yes, suicide. I didn't think it'd be controversial to suggest that poverty can kill. And you're taking a strict definition of "survive" -- plenty of people talk about "not being able to survive" some situation if they think it would be extremely difficult and take a permanent toll on them, even if they might not literally die.

Honestly it's a completely moot point anyway, as I said: nobody is trying to pull rich people into poverty, so it doesn't matter how they'd fare.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by s1artibartfast on Thursday May 09, 2024 @06:14PM (#40313472)
I just think it odd that you predict their "survival" rate will be lower than those born poor.

I think it goes without saying that it would be a rough transition if you swapped two people. I expect the long term outcome would be better for a rich person swapped into poverty, than if the poor person who stayed.

I think this because they statistically and experientially I think they have more of the skills necessary to escape poverty: education, trades, social coding, ect.

You see this often with immigrants to the US, and is especially pronounced in the works of Raj Chetty and Ran Abramitzky.

When you take someone successful in one country and have them start over poor in another. The immigrants do better over the course of their lives, and the children of poor immigrants do FAR better than the children of native born poor.

https://www.amazon.com/Streets-Gold-Americas-Immigrant-Succe...

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by NoMoreNicksLeft on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:38PM (#40311447)
I grew up in poverty, on food stamps. I do somewhat well for myself. My wife had a similar childhood.

We have poor financial habits that occasionally hint (I won't go so far as to say that they "threaten") at upending our lifestyle. Just having "more money" doesn't protect. Our habits would, if not kept in check, squander nearly anything. We are, in many ways, our own worst enemies. I've struggled to recognize this my entire adult life.

I think when someone starts speaking as you just have, it has as much to do with social posturing as anything. You have to say that, to show everyone else how special and empathetic you are. You understand the plight of the poor, that it isn't fair and they're "just like anyone else". That if some windfall dropped into their laps, they too would be rich forever, because that's how wealth works. And when you do this, you see everyone clapping and murmuring to each other about how enlightened you are, and you get off on that.

There are better habits. The wealthy tend to have more of them (many more), and the poor never develop those at all. Mostly, I think, because if they have these habits for any length of time, it quickly becomes incorrect to refer to them as poor. These habits can't protect against all misfortunes, but they protect against some and they mitigate the rest. And when you teach people that these things aren't true, you're doing them a disservice. You're robbing them of the one thing that might change their lives. It's both bizarre and cruel.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by s1artibartfast on Thursday May 09, 2024 @05:40PM (#40313222)
>It's both bizarre and cruel.

Yep, it seems like so many people are happy to tell children that their efforts and choices don't matter because everything is luck, and moreover, if they do try, they are a fool.

Cruel and tragic, especially when it comes from people who claim to be helping.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by caeril on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:51PM (#40311633)
Wealth is correlated with conscientiousness.

Conscientiousness is partially heritable.

The bankruptcy rate for former NFL/NBA/Music superstars and lottery winners is significantly higher than that of trust fund babies.

Make of that what you want.

Re:Familial Transmission of Personality Is Higher Than Shown... by anovikov on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:19PM (#40311214)
This. I've seen enough people of all walks of life to say: the key difference between rich and poor is just that: having money. There's nothing wrong with that. Money is morally neutral just as the class is.