News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sea Kit by flir on Saturday March 09, 2024 @04:38AM (#39650568)
It's (e). They're getting intelligence from NATO countries.

I thought that was publically acknowledged? Could be wrong.

Re:Sea Kit by fock on Saturday March 09, 2024 @07:15AM (#39651178)
Well, in some countries the chancellor acknowledging that is publicly ostracised for "disturbing the opinion". Which is very fun, because apparently that's not something people want to have put into the remaining mainstream media. All that in countries which a) claim not to be at war (and crucially not doing an inch of the economic adjustments), b) are the good democracies and c) are trying to play this down to things like "satellite" and internet comms. Noone is putting this out: https://en.defence-ua.com/events/what_awacs_see_as_they_tran... . If you would go into a debate and say: "hey, we are fighting this war already and without our direct involvement Ukraine would be gone from the map" - I guess that would be called fakenews.
Re:Sea Kit by zarzavat on Saturday March 09, 2024 @05:04AM (#39650662)
What confuses me is, how is this even a talking point? Under what theory is EU supposed to sit back and watch a bordering country get invaded and not pass that country intelligence?

Are we supposed to believe that if the EU invaded Belarus, that Russia wouldn’t pass any intelligence to the Belarusian government?

Re:Sea Kit by Dalewyn on Saturday March 09, 2024 @05:59AM (#39650889)
>Under what theory is EU supposed to sit back and watch a bordering country get invaded and not pass that country intelligence?

Has EU, or more aptly the comprising countries thereof, declared war?

The only thing I hate more than warmongering are proxy wars.

I'm all for Ukraine winning, because if they lose then Putin and Russia are vindicated in warmongering as a proper form of diplomacy, but I'm sick and tired of proxy wars.

As an aside: Yes, as an American I stand with the Republicans in denying further aid to Ukraine if we're going to continue doing the same thing. If we're going to lend more aid, either we punt the money figures up a few orders of magnitudes or we send in American boots to settle it ourselves. No more halfassed "aid" that only prolongs the war indefinitely and enlarges the suffering of civilians.

Re:Sea Kit by resoluteteeth on Saturday March 09, 2024 @06:18AM (#39650987)
The definition of "proxy war" is "a war instigated by a major power which does not itself become involved".

Regardless of the scale or nature of the aid, since Russia is directly involved, the Ukraine war can only be a "proxy war" if you believe it was instigated by the EU/NATO/the US, which is essentially assuming the Russian talking point that it was somehow forced to invade Ukraine because it felt threatened.

I disagree with that position and if you do to please do not describe it as a "proxy war" even if you think that other countries providing a limited amount of aid rather than getting actively involved will cause the war to be prolonged.

Re:Sea Kit by carlosjobim on Saturday March 09, 2024 @08:14AM (#39651407)
Who made that definition? There can be proxy wars in some regions between nations that are at the same time involved in open wars against each other in other regions. This happened a lot in WWII.
Re:Sea Kit by ImPostingOnHN on Saturday March 09, 2024 @11:35AM (#39652773)
That looks like the Oxford Dictionary's definition. That checks out, the poster is correct.

It makes sense, helping an ally who is attacked doesn't sound like a proxy war to me.

Re:Sea Kit by allendoerfer on Saturday March 09, 2024 @06:14AM (#39650972)
> I am against help, because we do not help enough.

And he is using a website made for the smarter kids. This election is going to be golden.

Re:Sea Kit by vasco on Saturday March 09, 2024 @07:08AM (#39651156)
> And he is using a website made for the smarter kids

Being in a group that accepts people that say "this group is smart" annoys me to no end as the lowest form of circle jerk. Specially when it's not even true.

There's no IQ test to access this site, there's no merit on the part of the users, the merit is on the part of the moderation, since the user pool is the same as any public website written in english.

Re:Sea Kit by victorbjorklund on Saturday March 09, 2024 @06:11AM (#39650958)
Has China, Iran, Belarus, etc decleared war? All of them help Russia. Are those doing proxy wars?
Re:Sea Kit by toberoni on Saturday March 09, 2024 @06:55AM (#39651112)
This is not a proxy war, neither EU or US are interested in Russian territory. They made it clear that no Western weapons are to be used outside Ukraine. This is defensive support for a sovereign state, not a scheme to topple Putin (who is the sole aggressor in this conflict without any formal declaration of war).

Furthermore, I’m having a hard time understanding your reasoning regarding US aid.

Currently, Russia is paying an enormous price while the US risks no lifes and gets to send its old weapons to Ukraine. This might not be a winning strategy for Ukraine, but it sure sounds better than an open war between 2 major nuclear powers which puts billions of lifes at risk or draconian Russian occupation of large parts of Ukraine.

Re:Sea Kit by Dalewyn on Saturday March 09, 2024 @07:33AM (#39651248)
>neither EU or US are interested in Russian territory.

But the west is interested in depleting and weakening Russia, which we can accomplish by prolonging this war as long as we can by supplying just enough aid to keep Ukraine from losing but not so much that Ukraine would win.

>Furthermore, I’m having a hard time understanding your reasoning regarding US aid.

You know what is worse than war? An unnecessarily protracted war. The longer a war goes on, the exponentially worse the civilians caught in the crossfire suffer.

I want Ukraine to win for reasons already stated, but I also do not want to see this war go on any longer than it has to. The west is more than opulent enough to supply enough equipment to end this war sooner, and if we go as far as to send in our own boots we can end this war overnight.

But we don't. Instead we provide just enough aid to keep Ukraine afloat. It's now over 2 years since Russia began its invasion.

As an aside, the military industrial complex is making a killing (pun intended) selling new gear to replace the ones donated to Ukraine.

What the fuck.

So no, no more aid unless enough is provided to end this war in Ukraine's favor as soon as fucking possible. I do not agree to aid that is any less and would keep prolonging this war at great cost to civilians.

Re:Sea Kit by toberoni on Saturday March 09, 2024 @08:14AM (#39651406)
I'm not so sure that your theory is a fact. There are a lot of plausible explanations for the course of this war. I follow this conflict closely and personally I think the West never had a coherent strategy and there would have been better ways to decimate the Russians.

I still don't see how letting Russia conquer half of Ukraine minimizes civilian cost. Russia has a long history of deadly deportations and it has already established systematic torture in occupied Ukranian territory. A landlocked Ukraine will be very hard to stabilize. And will Russia stop or will it continue in Moldova, Georgia or Kazakhstan?

There's also the question if the link between Western aid and warmongering holds up. All aggression comes from Russia and it alone is responsible for this destruction. As long as the victims, the Ukraine people, ask for help to defend themselves the West should deliver. The current aid is not enough but it surely is better than fighting Russia alone.

Re:Sea Kit by onlypassingthru on Saturday March 09, 2024 @07:05PM (#39655635)
The US is not trying to prolong the war; quite the opposite, actually.

The US has consistently advocated for a different strategy than what Zelensky is doing. If anything, it is Zelensky who is still trying to figure out how to fight this war.

[0]https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/08/us/politics/ukraine-war-u...

[1]https://www.nytimes.com/2023/08/22/us/politics/ukraine-count...

[2]https://www.nytimes.com/2023/09/22/us/politics/zelensky-bide...

[3]https://www.nytimes.com/2023/12/11/us/politics/us-ukraine-wa...

[4]https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/07/us/politics/ukraine-us-mi...

Re:Sea Kit by zarzavat on Saturday March 09, 2024 @09:17AM (#39651690)
A proxy war is when you have two countries who are not otherwise affected by a particular war, sponsoring opposing sides for geopolitical advantage.

Syria was a proxy war. Ukraine is not. Invading a neighboring country is a direct threat to the EU’s security, as evidenced by the large number of Ukrainian refugees that the EU now has to support. Had Putin succeeded in installing a figurehead regime in Kyiv, what is to say he wouldn’t have started marching on Moldova as well? Europe has seen this before.

Declaring war is a bit passé nowadays anyway.

Re:Sea Kit by GJim on Monday March 11, 2024 @05:18AM (#39666061)
> I stand with the Republicans in denying further aid to Ukraine

Meanwhile, the UK has opened to Ukrainian refugees (3 families in our street have accommodated refugees) and has pledged unconditional support.

We learnt our lesson that appeasing dictators, like Putin, does not work.

You should be ashamed of yourself.

Re:Sea Kit by paganel on Saturday March 09, 2024 @05:31AM (#39650766)
Because, firstly, EU is not a country, I'm a EU citizen and I certainly do not approve of this policy but there's no way for me (or for other people who think the same as me) to vote out the people that make those decisions (I'm also not a French citizen, maybe that way I could have had an effect on Macron holding power or not).

It's a double-edged sword for the EU leaders in the middle to long-term, because once a great part of the European population will start realising that they have been in effect disenfranchised then said population will have no qualms in following new political leaders that will leave "democracy" at the side, and thus leaving the concept of the EU for dead.

Re:Sea Kit by dainiusse on Saturday March 09, 2024 @05:41AM (#39650814)
If you're an Eu citizen - you should care that russia is stopped in Ukraine as they said multiple times - their goal is up to Lisbon.
Re:Sea Kit by pastacacioepepe on Saturday March 09, 2024 @05:55AM (#39650873)
Eu citizen here, the only thing I care about is that we don't get pulled in some pointless war. I couldn't care less about protecting the ownership of some land, especially when the price to do so is to throw away hundreds of thousands of lives.

I firmly encourage those who care about the land to go fight themselves to protect it! Those arable fields willl thank you for your life.

There is also no reason to believe Russia will go any further than Ukraine, to think they want to get to Lisbon even is completely delusional, considering they'd have to face NATO and countries with nuclear weapons.

I hope this war ends quickly, that will only happen when NATO stops posturing and accepts that eastern UA is lost for good.

The only ones who profit from the war going on are arms producers and crooked politicians.

Now, let's see how long before this comment gets flagged.

Re:Sea Kit by nkrisc on Saturday March 09, 2024 @06:27AM (#39651027)
The only message that this position would send is that wars of conquest are acceptable and the EU will sit idly by while war rages around them.

You’re basically describing the start of WWII.

Re:Sea Kit by pastacacioepepe on Saturday March 09, 2024 @06:40AM (#39651075)
> The only message that this position would send is that wars of conquest are acceptable

If the only thing that makes a war bad in your eyes is the goal of conquest, than that seems rather hypocritical in my eyes. Whether land is taken or not, what really makes a country independent is who governs it. Who cares about land, it's just soil and it's not worth human lives.

At least the citizens of eastern UA had referenda to decide if they wanted to be with Russia. I don't think we granted Iraqis or Afghans the same privilege.

> You’re basically describing the start of WWII.

This is such an absurd statement I won't waste my time debating it.

Re:Sea Kit by lenkite on Saturday March 09, 2024 @09:00AM (#39651593)
The US has already effectively conquered parts of Syria and is busy looting oil from the oil fields. The world stands idly by. Israel is busy reducing Gaza to rubble. The world stands idly by.
Re:Sea Kit by zarzavat on Saturday March 09, 2024 @12:07PM (#39653032)
It’s reasonable to act to prevent one’s neighbour from being conquered, without having an obligation to be world police.

Europe has a strong memory of what happens when you don’t act to protect your neighbours from aggressors: those aggressors soon come for you too.

Re:Sea Kit by croes on Saturday March 09, 2024 @06:26AM (#39651019)
Before the attack on Ukraine people said the same about Russia attacking Ukraine. There is no reason why Russia would do that, and look where we are now.

As the farmer said, "I'm not greedy, all I want is the land next to mine.

Re:Sea Kit by mopsi on Saturday March 09, 2024 @07:03AM (#39651136)
> There is also no reason to believe Russia will go any further than Ukraine

It's exactly the opposite: Russia has no reason to stop. Arms industry is ramping up, domestic population has been beaten into submission and can't even organize a single major protest, and governments in the west are under complacent illusion that Putin will stop any moment now. Why stop at Ukraine? You say NATO and nuclear weapons. Are you going to press the button if you are afraid of sending long-range conventional missiles? Of course not.

Long shots like flirting with MAGA to delay tens of billions worth of military aid have also paid off spectacularly.

Russia is punching way above their weight because of foolish illusions about their intentions.

This is very reminiscent of the Phony War phase of WWII. Poland had been invaded, but international support for Poland was much weaker than it could've been, because UK, France and others were irrationally afraid of Germany. They had 110 divisions in the west against German 23, but did not put them into action. After the war, multiple German generals (Alfred Jodl, for example, chief of operations at German high command) said that had allied forces attacked them from the west, Germany would've held on for only 2 weeks at best. Hesitation gave the initiative to Germans and we all know how that went.

Re:Sea Kit by arp242 on Saturday March 09, 2024 @07:13AM (#39651173)
It's about the people living on the land, not the land itself.
Re:Sea Kit by azmodeus on Saturday March 09, 2024 @06:58AM (#39651118)
If it was about your own home would you frame it the same way of „some land“? If it was your own family shelled or your own country would you argue the same way?
Re:Sea Kit by nkrisc on Saturday March 09, 2024 @06:45AM (#39651090)
> At least the citizens of eastern UA had referenda to decide if they wanted to be with Russia.

Ah, there it is. Explains all now. The idea of a referendum under hostile military occupation is completely absurd.

Re:Sea Kit by paganel on Saturday March 09, 2024 @05:46AM (#39650834)
> their goal is up to Lisbon

That was in fact Mitterand's goal in late 1989 - early 1990, the other way round, that is, until the Americans (well, the honorable James Baker) freaked out and nothing came out of it. I still think from time to time what could have been if "from Lisbon to Vladivostok" had become real, just as Mitterand had wanted it. [1]

[1] https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/155777507.pdf

Re:Sea Kit by fvdessen on Saturday March 09, 2024 @06:37AM (#39651063)
It could never have been as Eastern European countries would do anything not to be in a union with Russia
Re:Sea Kit by paganel on Saturday March 09, 2024 @07:33AM (#39651245)
My country, Romania, had in fact signed a pact with the USSR after 1989, so not all Eastern European countries would have been against it.
Re:Sea Kit by hef19898 on Saturday March 09, 2024 @06:02AM (#39650906)
Last time I checked, Lisbon was in fact in the EU... Vladivosstok not so much.
Re:Sea Kit by arp242 on Saturday March 09, 2024 @07:35AM (#39651254)
> there's no way for me (or for other people who think the same as me) to vote out the people that make those decisions

You can vote for your country's elections. You can also vote for the EU parliament.

And ever EU nation supports Ukraine, with the exception of Hungary. In this case the policy of the EU is very much aligned with the policy of ... pretty much the entire EU.

Re:Sea Kit by paganel on Saturday March 09, 2024 @07:44AM (#39651283)
My country, Romania, has no effective say in this matter at the EU level. As for the European Parliament and its democratic legitimacy, the lesser said the better. We also used to have “elected” representatives under Ceausescu’s Romania, with the same effective results.
Re:Sea Kit by XorNot on Saturday March 09, 2024 @08:44AM (#39651528)
Your country is going to be invaded and reoccupied by Russia if Putin gets his way in Ukraine and Trump delays article 5 just long enough for it to be "not worth it".

Because why should we waste hundreds of thousands of lives on protecting "just some land".

Re:Sea Kit by paganel on Saturday March 09, 2024 @08:54AM (#39651570)
Let us care for ourselves, we did just fine before (we actually fought the Soviets/Russians on their home turf before, unlike the majority of the Western countries), and use those troops you mention for the defense of your own realms, we don’t need them here.
Re:Sea Kit by catlifeonmars on Saturday March 09, 2024 @10:25AM (#39652188)
If I was your neighboring countries, I would absolutely not let you “care for yourselves”. That puts my border at risk. Nothing is in a vacuum.
Re:Sea Kit by justsomehnguy on Saturday March 09, 2024 @09:55PM (#39656377)
> That puts my border at risk. Nothing is in a vacuum.

Ah, yes, when it is a Western border at risk it is totally fine, it's not fine if that is a Russian border.

Hypocrisy.

Re:Sea Kit by jnsaff2 on Sunday March 10, 2024 @03:47AM (#39657452)
The russian border was last challenged by hitler and before that by napoleon. Anything after that is just been being pissy about everything.

> Beginning with the reign of Ivan the Terrible in the sixteenth century, Russia managed to expand at an average rate of 50 square miles per day for hundreds of years, eventually covering one-sixth of the earth’s landmass.

https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/ukraine/2016-04-18/r...

Re:Sea Kit by catlifeonmars on Sunday March 10, 2024 @10:14AM (#39659259)
I was speaking in general terms. It’s bad strategy to ignore what happens 1-2 borders away. I don’t think that’s controversial?
Re:Sea Kit by croes on Saturday March 09, 2024 @06:22AM (#39651001)
It funny that those people claiming to be disenfranchised have no problem with leaders who won't give them any rights at all.
Re:Sea Kit by paganel on Saturday March 09, 2024 @01:27PM (#39653703)
It makes it more honest, for one thing.

And second, it may sound as a paradox, but those authoritarian leaders are more connected with the masses and their needs (and vice-versa) compared to a pseudo-democratic and very opaque assembly composed of some hundreds of members (what are now called “parliaments”) of which no-one knows all that much, for that matter.

So a switch to an authoritarian leader would in effect, and comparatively speaking, mean a return of effective power to the masses, because it is on those masses that the legitimacy of said leader depends. Today’s parliamentarian regimes have long lost their legitimacy (notice senile 90+ years old ladies being parliament members in the most “democratic” country on Earth), it’s all a Glasperlenspiel [1] at this point, following prior moves blindly while the reason behind those moves has long been lost.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Glass_Bead_Game

Re:Sea Kit by ArnoVW on Saturday March 09, 2024 @08:58AM (#39651582)
That. Plus the fact that everyone (Russia included) gave Ukraine security guarantees when in the 90s we convinced them to give their nuclear missiles to the country that had occupied them just before.

At the time everyone was very nervous about proliferation of nuclear weapons and it seemed a sensible promise. But when push comes to shove it seems more complicated.

Re:Sea Kit by _dain_ on Saturday March 09, 2024 @04:49AM (#39650604)
Yeah it's not a secret that this is happening. UK/France/Germany are helping with targeting.