> According to the Insurance Research Council (irc), an industry data group, 29% of claims nationally (and over 50% in several states) involve people insured at the state minimums [in the tens of thousands of dollars]. Few policies go beyond a few hundred thousand dollars of liability. The cost of a serious crash “is never going to be covered by that”, says Dale Porfilio, of the irc. By contrast, in Germany drivers are required to have €7.5m ($8.2m) of bodily-injury coverage, and in Britain liability is unlimited.
I don't have a car, but I acknowledge that most Americans live in places where not having a car would make their lives much harder. Still, it seems reasonable for me to raise insurance requirements on enormous SUVs. They're 50-100% more dangerous to pedestrians, so this would reflect a higher actual cost inflicted on other people. If you don't want to pay that cost, and you still need the transportation of a personal car, buy the smaller and less dangerous vehicle.
Further research supports these findings, showing that trucks and SUVs with hood heights greater than 40 inches are about 45% more likely to cause fatalities in pedestrian crashes than shorter vehicles with sloped hoods. The study, also by the IIHS, used data from nearly 18,000 crashes and noted that tall, squared-up hoods, characteristic of many best-selling SUVs and trucks, contribute significantly to the risk. The number of pedestrian deaths has significantly increased, with pedestrian fatalities jumping 13% to 7,342 in 2021, marking the highest number since 1981. This rise in pedestrian deaths has outpaced the increase in overall U.S. traffic deaths, highlighting a growing crisis in road safety related to larger vehicles[1].
These findings underscore the need for vehicle design changes to improve pedestrian safety, particularly as the proportion of SUVs on U.S. roads continues to rise. Despite advancements in vehicle safety that have reduced overall motor vehicle crash fatalities, the increased lethality of SUVs to pedestrians poses a significant challenge that requires attention from both manufacturers and regulatory bodies.
[0] https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/new-study-suggests-todays-s...
[1] https://www.reuters.com/world/us/tall-trucks-suvs-are-45-dea...
(ChatGPT 4)
And they present very little risk to pedestrians as a result. You're sitting LOWER than the pedestrians. You can see a bottle-cap on the road. You don't feel superior to anyone at all.
It’s funny, I’m often tempted to fact check data or lookup jargon, etc. and comment to save someone else the trouble. I once did this on the seriouseats subreddit with copy paste from a relatively reliable source and met with an insane heated argument over what amounted to semantics and a flurry of downvotes. I wonder if attribution to ChatGPT increases civility towards the commenter or if HN is just generally more civilized.
At this point it shouldn't be required by law or it should be subsidized for those for whom it represents an undue burden.
Doubly so if they have "badass offroad cosplay" mods like welded bumpers and lightbars. Yes okay maybe you need that out in the dunes, but if you're playing at that level you should be trailering the warmachine to the dunes and towing it behind something with better visibility. If that tank touches pavement, it should pay the insurance risk commensurate with its armor.
A poor person won't be purchasing a newer vehicle but that has no bearing on the make and model they end up driving.
An SUV with the floor rusted out and leaking oil and no A/C is going to be cheaper to purchase than a used corolla with under 50k miles on it and everything generally working decently.
20-30 y/o SUV's exist, 0 year old corolla's exist. It turns out the size of the vehicle isn't nearly the largest determinant of price for vehicles.
And you can get what has happened multiple times - when gas prices rise substantially, low-mpg vehicles get dumped on the used market, so you have poor people and kids driving massive boats (the hotrodding scene from the 70s is a direct result of this).
Finally, "accidents" that cause injury or death are treated way too lightly by the justice system. If you kill someone in any other way and get convicted, you're doing hard time in prison. If you kill someone with your car, you might not even get jail time if it was deemed an accident.
1: https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/insurance/minimum-car-ins...
However, the first dollars of insurance are often the most expensive; so the price to customers going from $50k to $500k may be not as much as even the first $50k was.
IIRC, a VERY low percentage of people who kill a pedestrian are ever even charged (like 3%) with anything. In the vast majority of cases, there is negligence involved and everyone is just like "ok, you killed someone though your own negligences, but turns out there are no consequences for that"???
My stance here is that if you're going to make it required by law, someone needs to subsidize it and I believe it should be the insurance companies.
The low minimums you're complaining about exist specifically because the law is trying to split the difference between requiring insurance and not causing too much harm to those that can't afford it, or can barely afford it.
Here's how insurance works.
I purchase insurance. Someone hits me. My insurance company pays to repair the vehicle and the medical coverage needed (per my insurance policy). They then sue the other party to recoup the money. If it's another insurance company they're typically guaranteed 2 things.
1. The company can afford to pay out
2. The company doesn't want to go to court so gentleman's agreements are made between the insurance company to minimize overhead costs.
If the other party is uninsured they're typically forced to eat the cost because the chances of getting money out of someone who can't afford insurance isn't worth the overhead of even trying.
This is why it's a business risk that the insurance companies have mitigated by getting it required by law.
How did they mitigate it if as said the punishment for not having insurance is not too severe and many people are driving without an insurance? (again as per said above, I have no independent confirmation of this)
Yes, you are reading my message correctly. It was not clear to me.
Now that I am reading your answer I am realising that you did not mean “completely mitigate”, just increase the chances of someone having insurance. That was the core of my misunderstanding.
Thank you for the clarification.
and I'm skeptical that you're a moral human being. Apparently poor people with families don't need larger vehicles the way middle class people with families do.
Your idea is stupid and untenable, let it go.
Hm, surely we don't need to go that far. This is an internet discussion, we're supposed to be nice to each other!
> Apparently poor people with families don't need larger vehicles the way middle class people with families do.
Maybe I don't understand what claim you're making: is it 1) vans/SUVs must not become any more expensive (via higher insurance requirements), or else poor people will be priced out of owning a car entirely, or 2) owning a van/SUV is almost a human right, and raising the barrier to it is immoral?
I've tried looking at listings and I don't see evidence of the claim that somehow poor people are forced to buy SUVs because they're cheaper. There appear to be many big and small cars at every price range.
For 2), huge cars have only been widespread for a decade or two. The idea that they're somehow necessary for a meaningful human life is hard for me to grok.
You're on a crusade against larger vehicles and you think that crusade is more important than avoiding more harm to poor people, to the point that you said they have no need of larger vehicles (with a straight face) so it's ok to place a tax on them that will mean the poor will be forced to forego something as simple as a minivan for their family due to the extra taxes on them.
that's an immoral stance, one that you can only have gotten to because poor people is an abstract idea to you, you don't attribute any humanity to that abstract idea.
What makes it even worse is that you're so far gone you thought my issue with your statement was because I think owning a van or SUV is a human right rather than your entirely cavalier dismissal of the poor as being people.
rethink your strategy, the harm from your current strategy means it will never be implemented.
Also, minivans and vans have been around since the 1930's. Get your facts right.
Yep. This is enormously unpopular among suburbanites but America does too much to subsidize dangerous SUVs. Insurance should be by pound
If you don't have any assets, why would you need liability insurance?
The requirement to have liability insurance in order to license a car was introduced when I was young, before that, you didn't need it. I remember being in traffic court around the time they introduced it, the judge refused to enforce tickets for driving without insurance because, paraphrasing from something said decades ago, "I don't work for the insurance companies". This was in a poor area. The other alternative was, after getting a ticket for driving without insurance, to purchase one week's insurance, show proof of that to the court, after which the ticket would be dismissed.
I'm not poor anymore but I still think forcing poor people to buy liability insurance is bullshit. They don't have anything to insure. If they accidentally bump into your car and cause $100 of damage, they're bankrupt. Rich people are the ones with assets to insure, rich people should pay for the insurance.
But in some places (for instance where I live, Lausanne Switzerland) it's becoming easier to escape this car culture. I don't have kids, but some colleagues do. One of them does not own a car and her 2 children (6 and 9 years old) do everything by bike : going to school, to the activities (they climb!), etc. They surely look much more agile and risky than other colleague's children. It's quite crazy to see these two kids on their bikes, and how much liberating it is for them to move by theirselves. Unlike most kids who just commute in their parents's car.
Of course, I am aware this works only because there's a really good bike infrastructure. And people drive pretty well too, I guess.
But I would bet that every service you might reasonably need is within a few kilometers of your home, and every conceivable service is likely within 100km. Many people do not live in such environments. I'm in a town of 16k people, but the nearest allergist 200+km away, the nearest railroad 400km away. (One of my team is away today because he has to take his kid to the allergist, an all-day trip by car.) And it was -30c this morning. Car "culture" isn't a fashion choice but a necessity for anyone not living in a warm suburban village.
Yes, pickups do outnumber cars here. Most don't really need them daily, but offroad ability is an actual thing in winter in areas where the roads are not plowed ever 20 minutes, and in summer when forest fires evacuation is a real thing.
That is correct. Kindergarten, doctors, train station and my work are all within 7 kilometers. My wife's work is 60 km away, but reachable via train in 40 min. My parents live 400 km away, but are also reachable via train in 3h.
I am not advocating this lifestyle at all. I don't even think it is a lifestyle - as mentioned above, we didn't consciously decide to not own a car, it's just something that slowly developed.
As my wife cannot drive, living in an area like you are describing would be a prison sentence for her, so we avoid that. This has also has its downsides: a house in a remote black forest village with a bus every 2 hours would cost 1/3 of what a house costs in our area.
People around here say exactly the same thing about cities. Not being able to go hunting/hiking/camping/fishing. Not being able to ride a dirtbike/snowmobile. Getting a ticket if you cut down a tree in your back yard without government permission. Having to pay for parking. Having to adjust your work schedule around the mass transit schedule. People looking in through your windows. Being woken up by cop cars at all hours. They describe city life as "prison".
Being isolated in an area that depends on a car for any movement but not being able to drive actually is isolating like a a prison, however.
I think this is just the decline of the birth rate. I think about my neighborhood. My kid should be spoiled for kids to play with, but couple only has one kid and the ages are spread from infant to nearly an adult, so it works out in the whole neighborhood theres only a handful of kids she can play with. I see bus stops with just 2 kids there. When I was a lid there were nearly a dozen at just my stop.
I really think because there are less kids, it's just less safe for them because people don't honestly think they'll turn the corner and there well be half a dozen kids playing basketball in the street or something.
Lol. Maybe it is "safer" now because gangs of teenagers no longer roam the streets. I think today that many older people are happy not to see teens hanging in public. The old always fear the young.
My kids are 6 and 4 though.
Hilversum is the nicest place I've ever lived for biking and walking, but it's still not as good as Houten, parts of Utrecht, etc.
I grew up in a village and I felt like I owned it, a few roads of course but they had to careful, not us.
I believe that sort of mentality helps a lot in feeling connected with a place and not just a foreign object who has to take armored vehicles (e.g. Cars) to move from point to point.
Step 1 is to reduce speed limit to 45kph (25mph) anywhere a pedestrian could interact with the road which is what Vision Zero recommends.
Edit: and that's car accidents, not pedestrian accidents which is also a fraction of that 4k.
Thanks to the safety of their cage, cars can roam in freedom without having to worry about needlessly interferences.
I have been lately despising every kind of caged playground, where children might find fun in a sandbox.
The pressure from parents on other parents has made it so we dont trust children to handle risks that are pretty manageable.
I suspect that overall deaths are down, even if simply because overall total percentage of travel that is on freeway (controlled-access) is up.
I was shocked coming to Germany and seeing cyclists not constantly being attacked by the general public. In the UK it's seen as totally illegitimate.
https://walkbiketoschool.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/Fina...
""" ▪ In 1969, 48 percent of students in grades K through eight (ages 5 through 14) walked or bicycled to school.1 ▪ In 2009, only 13 percent of students in grades K through eight walked or bicycled to school. """
The problem with statements like this is that they hide actual risk. The reality is that child road deaths are dramatically down, in line with all road deaths. Roads in the 1970s were basically warzones by today's standards. The fact that 3/8 of deaths occur there today is because we have come so far in decreasing all the other sources of early death.
US child pedestrian deaths 1975: 1632. US child pedestrian deaths 2019: 138.
https://seriousaccidents.com/blog/children-traffic-fatalitie...
I had a prof once joke that they worst thing anyone could do in the fight against heart disease would be to cure cancer: By taking cancer out of the picture, the percentage of deaths from heart disease would skyrocket. But exactly that has happened to children in recent years. Childhood cancer is no longer a death sentence, so too innumerable other conditions. And when kids do get sick they live long enough not to die as kids. So the smaller and smaller number of child road deaths each year ironically now represents a greater and greater percentage of total child deaths. The reality is that kids today are safer crossing the road than ever before.
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a756524ed915...
UK Child death/injury in 1979: 12,458. UK Child death/injury in 2013: 1,980.
And that is despite roads now being massive more crowded and full of larger vehicles. The total population has also increased by at least 50% since the 70s, making the reduction in net traffic deaths even more dramatic.
Does this reflect safer streets, or just fewer (esp. unsupervised) child pedestrians?
In 1969, 48 percent of children 5 to 14 years of age usually walked or bicycled to school (The National Center for Safe Routes to School, 2011).
In 2009, 13 percent of children 5 to 14 years of age usually walked or bicycled to school (National Center, 2011).
* In 1969, 41 percent of children in grades K–8 lived within one mile of school; 89 percent of these children usually walked or bicycled to school (U.S. Department of Transportation [USDOT], 1972).
* In 2009, 31 percent of children in grades K–8 lived within one mile of school; 35 percent of these children usually walked or bicycled to school (National Center, 2011).
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/09/school-car...
They don't do anything, it just increases alert fatigue.
Probably both. The streets are probably "safer" because there are fewer pedestrians-car interactions. We now have walking trails and such separate from roads. And driving kids around in vehicles might be bad environmentally, but if we are talking about traffic deaths then it is a legitimate tool (ie busses rather than kids walking to school).
I suspect much of it is simply that kids no longer wander around on roads. They spend less time outside and when they do it isn't near roads. But the numbers between the 1970s and 2020s are so dramatic that one must conclude that roads are generally safer places for everyone today.
Your article is a perfect example of misjudging risk. Roughly 100 kids die in pedestrian accidents per year. Even if those SUVs are doubling the chance of an accident, those SUVs are only a portion of all vehicles on the road, say 10%. 100 kids goes up to 110. It's just noise when you account for all mortalities.
Media has been fueling fear bullshit for decades.
Furthermore according to some quick googling, SUVs are between 21% and 29% of the fleet in the United States right now, and pickup trucks which have all the same issues are about 17%. So it's not "say 10%", it's between 38% and 46%. Which certainly lines up with what I see day to day during my time on the road.
And this:
> Given that more intelligent people breed less, the avg parent isn't as smart as the avg person. And we know how smart the average person is.
This is just gross, just all the way around. I'm not a parent and in fact am child-free, but this is offensive even to me. I really hope you're not in a career that requires empathy.
So you can't state from your data that it has got safer: you need the child deaths/km or deaths/hr walking.
The graph in the article explains this. Kids just don't go outside anymore.
I learned to chop wood and use a chainsaw as a child, partially during Boy Scouts activities. OMG that is a risky thing for a kid. Never would I suggest that be taught to kids today.
Why not?! Understanding how to handle dangerous situations in a safe manner is a huge learning opportunity for a young person. If you have a chainsaw at home ( and lots of us do ) young people absolutely need to have a healthy appreciation for the danger of that machine.
A ten-year old being taught how to handle tools could likely be safer than a 25 year old who has never seen or used one before, but just bought one.
Not to mention that the US population in the 1970 census was 203M. In the 2020 census, 331M - a 63% increase from 1970!
So a 91% reduction in deaths while population increased 63%. I'm not a statistician but that seems pretty great.
I'm sure the children-per-capita rate changed during that time as well so maybe someone who knows that figure could do some more precise math.
But overall the "oh no my kids couldn't possible cross the street without being immediately killed!" hyperbole seems just that.
That's easily disprovable.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_United_Sta...
Should have said ~38% to ~24%.
You don't seriously think children stand more of a chance against cars of today with their ridiculously inflated size, power and weight do you?
I realize it's not possible for everybody, but there are areas where this is still possible. Even in the suburbs.
My current "town" - Reston, VA - is like this. I can walk to all three schools (~1 mile), two lakes (~2 miles), a shopping center (~1 mile), community center (~1 mile), ball fields (~0.5 miles), and miles of wooded trails without crossing a single street at grade (we have pedestrian tunnels). And you can buy a decent TH for ~$600k (that's "affordable" for DC metro).
It always amazes me that people willingly choose newer/bigger homes with crap infrastructure for families to live locally over older/smaller homes where the QOL is, by my measure, so much higher.
there is a lot of bad urbanism about new suburbs, but the parks are a bright spot.
From what I've seen, there may be parks, but they rarely seem to be walkable, and if they are, they're just a swing set (and not a full field with room for older kids to run). Lots of disjointed sidewalks, where the developer put sidewalks in/around the cluster of homes, but failed to link it anywhere useful.
The latter two often are quite walkable and even advertise it as a feature. It depends on what is selling.
As house prices level off, expect to see developers throw more money at things like walkability and parks, as they hate to ever have to reduce prices in a development or an area, and would rather "throw more on".
Reston is a gem. It's not perfect by any means, but it was intentionally designed to be something other than unmitigated suburban sprawl. And it helps a lot. There's still a big reliance on cars to get around, but the wide availability of trails is fantastic.
That's not affordable, not even for DC metro. Houses in Greenbelt (one of the nation's original walkable planned communities) can be had for less than $400k. $600k is "large colonial" money, or "walk to UMD's campus" money. Even those numbers are not necessarily comfortable swings for the median worker.
The average home sale for all of DC Metro, for all home types, is right around $600k. And average new homes in Fairfax County is around $1 million.
That's why I had "affordable" in quotes - it's not cheap, no debate there, but it's reasonable for the area given the demographics (and you can spend less, but get a less desirable home design or location). Lots of teachers and SAHM/Fs in my neighborhood, which you're less likely to find in Ashburn or McLean.
AFAIK it's never been $600k. NOVA prices have always been inflated and overweight the average (for super-fun reasons I won't get into but that you can probably guess), not a norm that MD prices fail to reach. This mortgage calculator (https://themortgagereports.com/mortgage-calculator) pegs a $600k home at ~$3700/m, which is going to be about 45% of the post-tax income (assuming a take-home of about $100k from that $135k), or ~1/3 of pre-tax. Depending on who you ask, that's just on the edge of affordability; it leaves no wiggle room, particularly if you've seen or will see transportation or food or other costs rise (so it makes sense that the actual median is lower).
It's perhaps advantageous for some to project the idea that a $600k median is reasonable, because they derive certain privileges from both the rising figures and the delta with what people in the area can actually afford comfortably, but I guess my point is that it's not actually reasonable. It puts a strain on household budgets and redirects funds that should be going to things like infrastructure, disproportionately affecting the less well-off. (It's also a bit of a feedback loop, as higher housing values can be borrowed against, and the debt used to bid up the prices of other goods.)
Now, I'm in a city (in the Bay Area) and I was walking from a residential area into the city (2-3 miles one way). Still, you would not expect lawful crossing of a street to be so dangerous.
I grew up in 80's the time where almost everybody played in parks and fields. But I can't give that to my own son of 7.
He has to cross 3 streets to reach a playground 200m from here,the worst of the crossings a street with 50km/h limitsand 1 car every 10 seconds. Not much, except just enough people drive like idiots, 90km/h or more on a road not even 500m long.
We've been teaching him good pedestrian behaviour since he could walk. We've done a few tests where he walked to the baker, thinking he was unsupervised. He probably can do it most of the time. Except, 1 distraction while an idiot drives by will kill him.
So I bring him to the playground and let him play as unsupervised as possible for an adult on the side of a playground. Of course, he knows I am there.
I start working with him with more dangerous tools like a soldering iron. He can deal well enough with these risks. But not the streets.