Does this reflect safer streets, or just fewer (esp. unsupervised) child pedestrians?
In 1969, 48 percent of children 5 to 14 years of age usually walked or bicycled to school (The National Center for Safe Routes to School, 2011).
In 2009, 13 percent of children 5 to 14 years of age usually walked or bicycled to school (National Center, 2011).
* In 1969, 41 percent of children in grades K–8 lived within one mile of school; 89 percent of these children usually walked or bicycled to school (U.S. Department of Transportation [USDOT], 1972).
* In 2009, 31 percent of children in grades K–8 lived within one mile of school; 35 percent of these children usually walked or bicycled to school (National Center, 2011).
https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2023/09/school-car...
They don't do anything, it just increases alert fatigue.
Probably both. The streets are probably "safer" because there are fewer pedestrians-car interactions. We now have walking trails and such separate from roads. And driving kids around in vehicles might be bad environmentally, but if we are talking about traffic deaths then it is a legitimate tool (ie busses rather than kids walking to school).
I suspect much of it is simply that kids no longer wander around on roads. They spend less time outside and when they do it isn't near roads. But the numbers between the 1970s and 2020s are so dramatic that one must conclude that roads are generally safer places for everyone today.
Your article is a perfect example of misjudging risk. Roughly 100 kids die in pedestrian accidents per year. Even if those SUVs are doubling the chance of an accident, those SUVs are only a portion of all vehicles on the road, say 10%. 100 kids goes up to 110. It's just noise when you account for all mortalities.
Media has been fueling fear bullshit for decades.
Furthermore according to some quick googling, SUVs are between 21% and 29% of the fleet in the United States right now, and pickup trucks which have all the same issues are about 17%. So it's not "say 10%", it's between 38% and 46%. Which certainly lines up with what I see day to day during my time on the road.
And this:
> Given that more intelligent people breed less, the avg parent isn't as smart as the avg person. And we know how smart the average person is.
This is just gross, just all the way around. I'm not a parent and in fact am child-free, but this is offensive even to me. I really hope you're not in a career that requires empathy.
So you can't state from your data that it has got safer: you need the child deaths/km or deaths/hr walking.
The graph in the article explains this. Kids just don't go outside anymore.
I learned to chop wood and use a chainsaw as a child, partially during Boy Scouts activities. OMG that is a risky thing for a kid. Never would I suggest that be taught to kids today.
Why not?! Understanding how to handle dangerous situations in a safe manner is a huge learning opportunity for a young person. If you have a chainsaw at home ( and lots of us do ) young people absolutely need to have a healthy appreciation for the danger of that machine.
A ten-year old being taught how to handle tools could likely be safer than a 25 year old who has never seen or used one before, but just bought one.
Not to mention that the US population in the 1970 census was 203M. In the 2020 census, 331M - a 63% increase from 1970!
So a 91% reduction in deaths while population increased 63%. I'm not a statistician but that seems pretty great.
I'm sure the children-per-capita rate changed during that time as well so maybe someone who knows that figure could do some more precise math.
But overall the "oh no my kids couldn't possible cross the street without being immediately killed!" hyperbole seems just that.
That's easily disprovable.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_United_Sta...
Should have said ~38% to ~24%.
You don't seriously think children stand more of a chance against cars of today with their ridiculously inflated size, power and weight do you?
The problem with statements like this is that they hide actual risk. The reality is that child road deaths are dramatically down, in line with all road deaths. Roads in the 1970s were basically warzones by today's standards. The fact that 3/8 of deaths occur there today is because we have come so far in decreasing all the other sources of early death.
US child pedestrian deaths 1975: 1632. US child pedestrian deaths 2019: 138.
https://seriousaccidents.com/blog/children-traffic-fatalitie...
I had a prof once joke that they worst thing anyone could do in the fight against heart disease would be to cure cancer: By taking cancer out of the picture, the percentage of deaths from heart disease would skyrocket. But exactly that has happened to children in recent years. Childhood cancer is no longer a death sentence, so too innumerable other conditions. And when kids do get sick they live long enough not to die as kids. So the smaller and smaller number of child road deaths each year ironically now represents a greater and greater percentage of total child deaths. The reality is that kids today are safer crossing the road than ever before.
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a756524ed915...
UK Child death/injury in 1979: 12,458. UK Child death/injury in 2013: 1,980.
And that is despite roads now being massive more crowded and full of larger vehicles. The total population has also increased by at least 50% since the 70s, making the reduction in net traffic deaths even more dramatic.