News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by mycologos on Thursday February 29, 2024 @08:09AM (#39548803)
The Economist had an interesting recent article suggesting that, at least in America, part of the problem is that car insurance is way too cheap, so owning a car and driving like a moron is too easy: https://www.economist.com/united-states/2024/01/18/why-car-i....

> According to the Insurance Research Council (irc), an industry data group, 29% of claims nationally (and over 50% in several states) involve people insured at the state minimums [in the tens of thousands of dollars]. Few policies go beyond a few hundred thousand dollars of liability. The cost of a serious crash “is never going to be covered by that”, says Dale Porfilio, of the irc. By contrast, in Germany drivers are required to have €7.5m ($8.2m) of bodily-injury coverage, and in Britain liability is unlimited.

I don't have a car, but I acknowledge that most Americans live in places where not having a car would make their lives much harder. Still, it seems reasonable for me to raise insurance requirements on enormous SUVs. They're 50-100% more dangerous to pedestrians, so this would reflect a higher actual cost inflicted on other people. If you don't want to pay that cost, and you still need the transportation of a personal car, buy the smaller and less dangerous vehicle.

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by o_1 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @08:36AM (#39549104)
SUVs are not the problem. it's literally what the article said, mininums are too low. Most SUVs are family's traveling. You should look up the statistics for uninsured motorists in Florida, it's staggering. People simply will not follow the law, it's an enforcement problem. The sheer miles of roadways to police is extremely vast, it's very difficult to remove dangerous uninsured drivers. Hence why most people by big SUVs to protect themselves from collisions.
Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by cognaitiv on Thursday February 29, 2024 @08:59AM (#39549351)
Research indicates that SUVs are indeed more dangerous to pedestrians compared to other vehicle types in the United States. A study by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) highlighted that late-model SUVs are more likely to cause fatalities to pedestrians than cars. This is attributed to the higher front profile of SUVs, which tends to result in more severe injuries upon impact. The study found that at speeds greater than 19 mph, SUVs caused more serious injuries and were more likely to result in pedestrian fatalities compared to cars. Specifically, at speeds of 20-39 mph, 30% of crashes with SUVs resulted in pedestrian fatalities, compared to 23% for cars. At speeds of 40 mph and above, all crashes with SUVs resulted in pedestrian fatalities, compared to 54% with cars. This indicates a significant increase in the risk posed by SUVs at higher speeds[0].

Further research supports these findings, showing that trucks and SUVs with hood heights greater than 40 inches are about 45% more likely to cause fatalities in pedestrian crashes than shorter vehicles with sloped hoods. The study, also by the IIHS, used data from nearly 18,000 crashes and noted that tall, squared-up hoods, characteristic of many best-selling SUVs and trucks, contribute significantly to the risk. The number of pedestrian deaths has significantly increased, with pedestrian fatalities jumping 13% to 7,342 in 2021, marking the highest number since 1981. This rise in pedestrian deaths has outpaced the increase in overall U.S. traffic deaths, highlighting a growing crisis in road safety related to larger vehicles[1].

These findings underscore the need for vehicle design changes to improve pedestrian safety, particularly as the proportion of SUVs on U.S. roads continues to rise. Despite advancements in vehicle safety that have reduced overall motor vehicle crash fatalities, the increased lethality of SUVs to pedestrians poses a significant challenge that requires attention from both manufacturers and regulatory bodies.

[0] https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/new-study-suggests-todays-s...

[1] https://www.reuters.com/world/us/tall-trucks-suvs-are-45-dea...

(ChatGPT 4)

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by CalRobert on Thursday February 29, 2024 @09:11AM (#39549480)
Good summary. Something ChatGPT missed is that SUV's are taller, and that tends to increase speed, because _perceived_ speed is lower the farther you are from the ground
Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by myself248 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:31AM (#39551558)
'swhy Mitatas are so much freakin' fun.

And they present very little risk to pedestrians as a result. You're sitting LOWER than the pedestrians. You can see a bottle-cap on the road. You don't feel superior to anyone at all.

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by CalRobert on Thursday February 29, 2024 @03:12PM (#39554419)
Miatas are great! Also one of the few examples of a model that got _smaller_ in a later model year instead of continuing to bloat. https://www.carsized.com/en/cars/compare/mazda-mx-5-2000-roa...
Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by cognaitiv on Thursday February 29, 2024 @09:24AM (#39549646)
Interesting point!

It’s funny, I’m often tempted to fact check data or lookup jargon, etc. and comment to save someone else the trouble. I once did this on the seriouseats subreddit with copy paste from a relatively reliable source and met with an insane heated argument over what amounted to semantics and a flurry of downvotes. I wonder if attribution to ChatGPT increases civility towards the commenter or if HN is just generally more civilized.

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:00AM (#39551113)
increasing insurance increases the harm to the poor.

At this point it shouldn't be required by law or it should be subsidized for those for whom it represents an undue burden.

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by myself248 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:29AM (#39551524)
The poor are more likely to be driving Civics than Escalades anyway. Increasing insurance on the larger, heavier, taller, more dangerous vehicles is exactly the right thing.

Doubly so if they have "badass offroad cosplay" mods like welded bumpers and lightbars. Yes okay maybe you need that out in the dunes, but if you're playing at that level you should be trailering the warmachine to the dunes and towing it behind something with better visibility. If that tank touches pavement, it should pay the insurance risk commensurate with its armor.

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Thursday February 29, 2024 @02:09PM (#39553643)
a poor person will purchase a rundown $2k escalade before they purchase a $20k+ new civic.

A poor person won't be purchasing a newer vehicle but that has no bearing on the make and model they end up driving.

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by mycologos on Thursday February 29, 2024 @05:29PM (#39556094)
There's an implicit claim here that it's easier to buy a cheap big used vehicle than a cheap small used one. That doesn't seem true, as even now at the height of SUV popularity, most new cars are not SUVs. A significant majority of used cars should therefore be small cars, no?
Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Thursday February 29, 2024 @08:31PM (#39557465)
you're not thinking this through, vehicles cost differing amounts of money based on many things, including how well they're doing mechanically.

An SUV with the floor rusted out and leaking oil and no A/C is going to be cheaper to purchase than a used corolla with under 50k miles on it and everything generally working decently.

20-30 y/o SUV's exist, 0 year old corolla's exist. It turns out the size of the vehicle isn't nearly the largest determinant of price for vehicles.

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by epistasis on Thursday February 29, 2024 @12:03PM (#39552065)
The poor aren't buying oversized vehicles, because those vehicles are the more expensive option already.
Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by bombcar on Thursday February 29, 2024 @12:13PM (#39552172)
Depends on what your definition of poor is, because if you go to street view in poorer areas of LA you do not miss out on seeing the SUVs.
Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Thursday February 29, 2024 @01:01PM (#39552741)
it turns out SUV's can be purchased used as well.
Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by bombcar on Thursday February 29, 2024 @01:19PM (#39552958)
A big part of the problem is that the used market is controlled by new car buyers (from the past) - if nobody is buying new compact/cheap cars (for whatever reason) then they're not available for used buyers.

And you can get what has happened multiple times - when gas prices rise substantially, low-mpg vehicles get dumped on the used market, so you have poor people and kids driving massive boats (the hotrodding scene from the 70s is a direct result of this).

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Thursday February 29, 2024 @01:37PM (#39553174)
vehicles can be repaired and sold and many people make good money doing exactly that.
Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by e40 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:29AM (#39551521)
And will increase the number of drivers without insurance. It's already an issue now, but it will go way up if insurance is even more expensive.
Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by ryandrake on Thursday February 29, 2024 @12:09PM (#39552132)
Like most of this thread, this is an enforcement problem. Insurance is way too cheap, and people just ignore it way too easily. Also, the minimum required coverage (in most states) is way way way too low. In most states it's as low as $25k bodily injury per person, $50k per accident[1]! A single broken arm can cost more than that in the USA. How on earth are we allowing people to drive a 3 ton death machine around carrying only $25k of insurance??? If someone carrying the minimum insurance plows into a car full of people, there is no way $50k is going to be enough to make everyone whole.

Finally, "accidents" that cause injury or death are treated way too lightly by the justice system. If you kill someone in any other way and get convicted, you're doing hard time in prison. If you kill someone with your car, you might not even get jail time if it was deemed an accident.

1: https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/insurance/minimum-car-ins...

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by bombcar on Thursday February 29, 2024 @12:15PM (#39552196)
How many other ways does the average person have available to accidentally kill someone? If vehicles are about it, then you may see light sentences for vehicles simply because it's accidental, not because is vehicular.

However, the first dollars of insurance are often the most expensive; so the price to customers going from $50k to $500k may be not as much as even the first $50k was.

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by ryandrake on Thursday February 29, 2024 @12:38PM (#39552469)
Some say "accidentally" but I say "negligently." Society is way to light on people who injure others while using their cars. How does the saying go? If you want to kill someone and reduce the chances you are punished, just accidentally kill them with your car!
Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by e40 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @05:45PM (#39556241)
Just to reinforce this, Freakonomics did a "The Perfect Crime" podcast which talks about this very issue: https://freakonomics.com/podcast/the-perfect-crime-2/

IIRC, a VERY low percentage of people who kill a pedestrian are ever even charged (like 3%) with anything. In the vast majority of cases, there is negligence involved and everyone is just like "ok, you killed someone though your own negligences, but turns out there are no consequences for that"???

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Thursday February 29, 2024 @01:10PM (#39552857)
uninsured/underinsured motorists is a business risk for insurance companies, one they mitigated by convincing our government to make it required but they did so at the expense of placing an undue burden on the poor.

My stance here is that if you're going to make it required by law, someone needs to subsidize it and I believe it should be the insurance companies.

The low minimums you're complaining about exist specifically because the law is trying to split the difference between requiring insurance and not causing too much harm to those that can't afford it, or can barely afford it.

Here's how insurance works.

I purchase insurance. Someone hits me. My insurance company pays to repair the vehicle and the medical coverage needed (per my insurance policy). They then sue the other party to recoup the money. If it's another insurance company they're typically guaranteed 2 things.

1. The company can afford to pay out

2. The company doesn't want to go to court so gentleman's agreements are made between the insurance company to minimize overhead costs.

If the other party is uninsured they're typically forced to eat the cost because the chances of getting money out of someone who can't afford insurance isn't worth the overhead of even trying.

This is why it's a business risk that the insurance companies have mitigated by getting it required by law.

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by krisoft on Thursday February 29, 2024 @04:16PM (#39555217)
> This is why it's a business risk that the insurance companies have mitigated by getting it required by law.

How did they mitigate it if as said the punishment for not having insurance is not too severe and many people are driving without an insurance? (again as per said above, I have no independent confirmation of this)

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Thursday February 29, 2024 @04:57PM (#39555726)
are you telling me it's not clear to you how requiring insurance by law guarantees more people carry insurance which guarantees more accidents have an entity worth suing for compensation?
Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by krisoft on Saturday March 02, 2024 @04:15AM (#39571233)
> are you telling me it's not clear to you

Yes, you are reading my message correctly. It was not clear to me.

Now that I am reading your answer I am realising that you did not mean “completely mitigate”, just increase the chances of someone having insurance. That was the core of my misunderstanding.

Thank you for the clarification.

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by stetrain on Thursday February 29, 2024 @12:24PM (#39552304)
Building a society where you need to pay for a car, license, fuel, and insurance to just to function increases harm to the poor.
Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by mycologos on Thursday February 29, 2024 @05:28PM (#39556080)
That's why I'm suggesting that we target very large vehicles first. I am skeptical that poor people absolutely need very large vehicles, which are more expensive to run anyway.
Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Thursday February 29, 2024 @08:38PM (#39557509)
> I am skeptical that poor people absolutely need very large vehicles

and I'm skeptical that you're a moral human being. Apparently poor people with families don't need larger vehicles the way middle class people with families do.

Your idea is stupid and untenable, let it go.

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by mycologos on Friday March 01, 2024 @12:42PM (#39564358)
> and I'm skeptical that you're a moral human being

Hm, surely we don't need to go that far. This is an internet discussion, we're supposed to be nice to each other!

> Apparently poor people with families don't need larger vehicles the way middle class people with families do.

Maybe I don't understand what claim you're making: is it 1) vans/SUVs must not become any more expensive (via higher insurance requirements), or else poor people will be priced out of owning a car entirely, or 2) owning a van/SUV is almost a human right, and raising the barrier to it is immoral?

I've tried looking at listings and I don't see evidence of the claim that somehow poor people are forced to buy SUVs because they're cheaper. There appear to be many big and small cars at every price range.

For 2), huge cars have only been widespread for a decade or two. The idea that they're somehow necessary for a meaningful human life is hard for me to grok.

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Monday March 04, 2024 @12:45AM (#39587365)
One of my biggest criticisms of HN in general is that dang, et al, have created a safe space for heinous opinions where pushing back on them too hard will get YOU moderated.

You're on a crusade against larger vehicles and you think that crusade is more important than avoiding more harm to poor people, to the point that you said they have no need of larger vehicles (with a straight face) so it's ok to place a tax on them that will mean the poor will be forced to forego something as simple as a minivan for their family due to the extra taxes on them.

that's an immoral stance, one that you can only have gotten to because poor people is an abstract idea to you, you don't attribute any humanity to that abstract idea.

What makes it even worse is that you're so far gone you thought my issue with your statement was because I think owning a van or SUV is a human right rather than your entirely cavalier dismissal of the poor as being people.

rethink your strategy, the harm from your current strategy means it will never be implemented.

Also, minivans and vans have been around since the 1930's. Get your facts right.

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by jobs_throwaway on Thursday February 29, 2024 @12:32PM (#39552401)
>raise insurance requirements on enormous SUVs

Yep. This is enormously unpopular among suburbanites but America does too much to subsidize dangerous SUVs. Insurance should be by pound

Re:Why Children Need Risk, Fear, and Excitement in Play by rufus_foreman on Thursday February 29, 2024 @07:38PM (#39557133)
>> part of the problem is that car insurance is way too cheap

If you don't have any assets, why would you need liability insurance?

The requirement to have liability insurance in order to license a car was introduced when I was young, before that, you didn't need it. I remember being in traffic court around the time they introduced it, the judge refused to enforce tickets for driving without insurance because, paraphrasing from something said decades ago, "I don't work for the insurance companies". This was in a poor area. The other alternative was, after getting a ticket for driving without insurance, to purchase one week's insurance, show proof of that to the court, after which the ticket would be dismissed.

I'm not poor anymore but I still think forcing poor people to buy liability insurance is bullshit. They don't have anything to insure. If they accidentally bump into your car and cause $100 of damage, they're bankrupt. Rich people are the ones with assets to insure, rich people should pay for the insurance.