News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by martythemaniak on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @08:30AM (#39523812)
This is good. Flight 1 had 63 corrective actions and it took 5 months to complete the report. This one took 3 months and had 17 corrective actions. They'll get to orbit this year for sure
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by jillesvangurp on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:41AM (#39525365)
With the Falcon 1 they also needed a several attempts before they started getting it right. The Falcon 9 went through a similar set of launches and also it took a while from successful launch to successful landing.

The ambition level is really high with Starship but if there's any company that can get it done it's spacex.

Basically what they are doing is a form of agile development where instead of speccing out the whole thing years in advance, they basically iterate and redesign what needs redesigning. Even if the project ultimately fails, there are multiple things coming out of the project that are at this point valuable. Like the merlin engines. Or their welding innovations. The notion of launching a steel contraption this size to orbit is ludicrous. Yet, they almost pulled it off last time. Worst case they have learned a lot to do a better falcon rocket. Best case, this thing actually starts working.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by inglor_cz on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:50AM (#39526302)
Even here on HN plenty of people seem to misunderstood the fundamentals of "hardware-rich development" and assume that it must be fantastically expensive and/or reckless.

It is not exactly cheap to do it like SpaceX does, but the savings in time and increases in robustness may very well offset the cost of all the prototypes that undergo a RUD.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by evilduck on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @03:16PM (#39529194)
Even SpaceX's methods of fail fast (and often explosively) is relatively cheap. SLS is doing it the hard and expensive way.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by bumby on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @04:47PM (#39530502)
The downside is that rapid iteration doesn't always give the same insight in terms of scientific understanding.

E.g.,

Design_A fails. We quickly pivot to Design_B, which works. However, we don't spend the time ultimately understanding why Design_A failed. This can be operationally great, but it can also risk conflating being lucky with being good. If you don't fundamentally understand why the thing failed the first time, it's much harder to understand if those failure modes are fully mitigated.

Personally, I think the ideal approach is to have SpaceX continue the rapid enginneering iterations, but give NASA (or some other entity) the resources to research the rest.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by hotstickyballs on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @05:00PM (#39530693)
You can understand why design A failed. Just don’t need design B to be blocked on that with agile because the last iteration was working.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by bumby on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @05:41PM (#39531173)
Sure, you can if you dedicate the resources to understanding the failure. What I saw personally is that is not always the case with SpaceX. In my experience, they changed a design and seemingly used that as an excuse to not further investigate the original design. (This was related to COPV failures. The general consensus seemed to be “we don’t need to understand why it failed because we’ve moved on to a different design.”)
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by panick21_ on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @06:25PM (#39531644)
That's just your assumption. SpaceX is actually doing all that. They invested early in good simulation tools and they are developing their own. They have great material science teams and engineering teams. They do invest a lot in actually understanding the fundamentals and they make good use of the data from things that failed.

Take for example the work on the failure of Amos 6. They went really deep into that one and its a pretty interesting result from a scientific perspective.

On the other hand, there is no point in doing endless science on why the pad blew up during the first orbital flight test. They solution was already in development anyway and its pretty clear that the solution would migrate the problem. It might introduce new problems but the old one wasn't happening again.

So there is a limited need to the exact detail of underground steam explosion or whatever exactly happened there.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by bumby on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @06:59PM (#39531984)
Nah. If you read my response to the comment above, you can see it’s based on actual experience. Maybe your conclusion is based on assumption?
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by Teever on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @05:42PM (#39531188)
What's stopping them from choosing to revise design A over chosing design B?
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by bumby on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @05:44PM (#39531212)
Nothing, other than it may just be easier to change the design to avoid the effort of a deeper investigation.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by adastra22 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:47PM (#39533739)
> However, we don't spend the time ultimately understanding why Design_A failed

Did you read TFA? It's about the release of an extensive report documenting why Design_A failed and what corrections are to be made regarding each specific failure.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by bumby on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @08:57AM (#39537949)
I'm speaking about personal experience on a different failure.

Also, from the HN Guidelines: "Please don't comment on whether someone read an article. "

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:08PM (#39533865)
You're dealing with incredibly smart people here. Now of course perfect knowledge is almost impossible. But each of the designs is probably specked out with at least pluses and minuses and theory is as to whether or not the design is viable, which ways it will perform well or fail.

This is just basic science: theory experiment result.

And with all the documentation and instrumentation on the flights, The theories can be experimentally validated or invalidated.

This isn't like some agile programmer shoving in a couple hundred lines of code over the course of a one week sprint.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by bumby on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @08:59AM (#39537984)
Would you have said the same about NASA pre-Challenger/pre-Columbia, or Boeing pre-CST-100? I don't think SpaceX is inherently unique in either the ability of their people or their innate human biases. They may have a different culture, and related to that, I'm pointing out what I've experienced as a potential downside of rapid iteration philosophy. I'm not even saying it's bad, just that we need to be cognizant of it's downsides.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by mlsu on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @03:24AM (#39535422)
Luck tends to average out over many trials.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by bumby on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @08:55AM (#39537927)
Not a particularly good strategy here for a couple reasons:

1) Risk on safety critical operations is not something people tend to want to roll the dice with.

2) The nature of the industry makes each trial pretty expensive. Over decades, the shuttle only had something like 135 launches and the managers still didn't have a good handle on the actual risk.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by mlsu on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @01:54PM (#39542147)
> the shuttle

Sort of proving the point here, no? There is a reason SpaceX has gone to orbit more times than the Shuttle has. Soon they will have launched more Starship prototypes than the shuttle ever did. And they will be safer, because SpaceX understands why their rockets fail.

Obviously this strategy does not work with humans in the loop. It might have been impossible to do what SpaceX is doing now in the 80s given the advancements in computer control and simulation that have happened since then.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by bumby on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @03:35PM (#39543139)
>Sort of proving the point here, no?

I don't think so, for the same reason you identified: it only works when the risk isn't safety critical (ie when humans are in the loop). In other words, it's acceptable when risks are low. It's the same reason NASA is more risk-tolerant with non-human-rated missions. But keep in mind CCP is also meant to transport humans. The risk we'd want to bolster against is the human biases that lead us to get complacent. There are some instances that make me wonder about that with SpaceX, but I'm giving them the benefit to the doubt that they've learned from those.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by quartesixte on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @04:02AM (#39535652)
Some counter-points:

1) The failures themselves aren't all too complex (relatively speaking), and by the time the design made it to a flight vehicle it has been vetted for all immediately knowable risks. The rest you discover during flight. And even then the actual nature of the problems rarely (if at all) are esoteric or present breakthrough scientific discoveries.

2) Failure in rocket launches are catastrophic leaving behind very little evidence. There could be a limit to how much you can learn. But...

3) ...SpaceX is a business serving customers, and if a pivot means going away from a complex cloud of possible failures (known and discovered) to more robust, more deterministic, more reliable, you should do it.

4) At what level do you stop and go "this is fundamental enough"?

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by bumby on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @08:52AM (#39537890)
I think I disagree on many points here in this specific case.

>The failures themselves aren't all too complex

The COPV failure mechanisms may not be terribly complex (e.g., voids or delamination), but managing the processes to mitigate them isn't.

>by the time the design made it to a flight vehicle it has been vetted for all immediately knowable risks.

SpaceX has already shown some bad processes that disprove this statement. E.g., the strut failure was due to poor supplier quality control, which is a relatively mature process in the industry. I'd give them the benefit of the doubt and say they've gotten better as they've matured as a company.

Failure in rocket launches are catastrophic leaving behind very little evidence.

The difference, I think, is that you are constraining this to launch failures. I'm talking about knowledge and data about individual component failures, from which you can derive the overall reliability of the design.

if a pivot means going away from a complex cloud of possible failures (known and discovered) to more robust, more deterministic, more reliable, you should do it.

I don't disagree that more simple tends to be more reliable. However, the point was that iteration doesn't necessarily advance knowledge of failure. I think these two points are not mutually exclusive. A good business case doesn't mean it makes for good engineering or good science.

At what level do you stop and go "this is fundamental enough"?

It's a tough question. But if you can't characterize why a failure mode occurred reasonably well, that's probably not good enough. So if they say, "We know voids in the COPV manufacturing process contributed to the failure" they should probably make sure they have a good understanding of why they occurred. (And maybe they have at this point)

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by gibolt on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @04:54PM (#39530604)
The focus on making lots of prototypes reduces cost. They streamline the largest and most expensive manufacturing bottlenecks.

Each Starship has 30+ engines required per flight and tons of precision welding. All of it can now be made in a month. That means massive cost savings going forward, the faster each can be made

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by Geisterde on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:32PM (#39533634)
Hmmm, from a manufacturing prespective this is probably the safest way too, because you have already scaled production, you arent suddenly trying out all these new manufacturing processes when starship enters production. All your processes have been continuously validated already.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by jillesvangurp on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @02:17AM (#39534996)
Failing fast also reduces cost. It cuts down on the time wasted on things that aren't going to work. With traditional design it can take years to find out if something will work or not. And when they don't, it leads to lengthy and expensive redesigns. You avoid all of that by iterating rapidly and building on and perfecting what works and scrapping/replacing what doesn't work before you sink a lot of time and resources in these things
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by hoseja on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @08:23AM (#39537523)
We could have had dozens of James Webb Space Telescopes for the cost of, like, five.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by gibolt on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @03:40PM (#39543187)
Even better, since larger payloads can fit, the design can be far less complex due to weight and folding limitations.

Rather than spend 10 years designing and building one telescope, they could spend 2-3 years and keep refining the hardware, with multiple types on the same platform

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by BryanLegend on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:56PM (#39533788)
Falcon 9 reached orbit on it's first attempt, so it didn't have failed experimental flights unless you count Falcon 1 as being it's experiments.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by jillesvangurp on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @02:13AM (#39534976)
You are right. It was essentially a bigger Falcon 1 and not a complete redesign. So, the risk was not as high. It was an incremental upgrade. Not a small one but still.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by jwells89 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:59AM (#39525611)
It’s so exciting to keep track of. Feels like everything I hoped to see happening in spaceflight back in the 90s and 00s is finally (maybe) becoming reality and absolutely shattering the stagnancy that had overcome the field, hopefully this time for good.

If this pace can continue unabated, maybe it’s not too unrealistic to hope that my grandkids’ generation in a few decades has astronaut as one of their most aspired careers much as was the case for the kids of the 70s, 80s, and 90s… except this time it’d be much more practically achievable since there’d be greatly increased demand for people with that skillset.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by whimsicalism on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @04:36PM (#39530330)
I am not sure if there is enough profitable space industry.

Last I checked asteroid mining was not super feasible, but maybe some like space based solar.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by jwells89 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @04:51PM (#39530555)
In my mind the potential for profitable industry beyond earth orbit depends almost entirely on how low we can manage to bring cost of kg to orbit.

It doesn’t have to be cheap enough to make e.g. asteroid mining profitable on its own (which is an awfully high bar), just high enough to make construction of large, permanently spacebourne ships feasible.

Ships like that ease the bootstrapping problem and make it more feasible to mine asteroids in-place instead of having to move them to an orbit that’s not expensive to reach. Their flexible, multipurpose nature also helps pay for them over time; they can for example drop crew and cargo off at the moon and Mars en route to the asteroid belt.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by Animats on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @05:45PM (#39531217)
The asteroid Psyche is expected to have a lot of gold content. NASA sent a probe last year, but it's a long trip and will take until 2029 to get there. Even then it just orbits.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by panick21_ on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @06:28PM (#39531672)
That's nonsense. Sure Psyche has a lot of valuable materials on it, but so do mountains on earth, doesn't mean its great way to make money.

There are things far closer to earth that are far easier to get to, and those things are also far smaller then Psyche and thus far easier to mine.

The most serious space mining company right now is targeting near earth asteroids for platinum group metals.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by Sabinus on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @08:11PM (#39532602)
The composition and purity of asteroids can be vastly different than on Earth.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by ethbr1 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @09:01PM (#39532990)
Most of the value in space resources would seem to be that their mass is already up Earth's gravity well, and less so preciousness.

If you need 1 kg of something in space, the cost is {extraction} + {getting it there}.

For anything raw or low tech, it'd seem way easier not to have to bulk lift it off Earth.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by timschmidt on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:23PM (#39533972)
Composition should actually be very similar if not identical. All were formed from the same accretion disk around the sun. Distribution of heavy elements within asteroids will be much different from the planets, however, due to the planets having had or still having molten cores.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by timschmidt on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:00PM (#39533817)
Heavy elements like gold and platinum sank to the center of the earth's core while the whole planet was molten and this is why they are rare near the crust. Asteroids have never been entirely molten, and as such have valuable heavy elements dispersed relatively evenly throughout. In other words, much higher concentrations of valuable elements are expected to be available much closer to the surface of asteroids than on Earth.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by panick21_ on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @02:40AM (#39535140)
I know but that doesnt change what I said.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:19PM (#39533946)
Reliable, viable Starship means the military can rapid deploy a force anywhere in the world in an hour or two.

That would mean huge savings to the military in naval fleet investment, overseas bases. The military would likely pay SpaceX ongoing contracts of tens of billion dollars per year for that exclusive nation-state capability.

The growing Starlink constellation will sustain huge business.

NASA would fund additional missions with the reduced launch costs.

Space tourism and fast global travel is worth another 10 billion dollars annually.

Then there's space telescopes and instrumentation.

Space industry is completely TBD. Here's a kooky idea: how much is antimatter harvested from the solar wind worth? Near earth asteroid capture and mining may be feasible. Moon mining may be on the table.

Militarization of space is an inevitability, and starship provides the payload to get equipment into space.

Starship might provide the launch ability to deal with space junk.

Anyway, you drop the cost of launch by 10x-100x, THINGS WILL BECOME POSSIBLE.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by stoneman24 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @09:53AM (#39524798)
I suspect if test flight 3 makes orbit then flight 5 will be delivering starlink satellites and then testing on the way back down.

If I remember correctly, a starship can deliver 440+ starlink satellites compared to around 60 for falcon 9.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by Casteil on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:20AM (#39525095)
Starlink V2 sats are bigger, so they definitely won't be sending 400+ up at a time with Starship - probably more like 100-200.. but I don't think they've had any official updates/figures on this in a while.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by bryanlarsen on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:51AM (#39526314)
They just confirmed that 24 V2 minis are 17.5 tons. So ~200 v2 minis would be 150 tons. But v2's are probably bigger than v2 mini's...
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by ianburrell on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @01:20PM (#39527497)
The V2 are 1.25 ton according to Wikipedia. Which means 150 tons would be 100-120.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by dotnet00 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:03AM (#39524910)
Probably why they're hoping to get permission for 9 launches this year. Even if they throw away the entire stack, it probably costs less than the equivalent number of F9 launches.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by mjevans on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @04:25PM (#39530198)
I strongly suspect they'll achieve at least partial re-usability if not full by 9 launches. If not SpaceX will at least have a very clear understanding of the engineering problem by that point. I'm most worried about the final landing which I would not want to be anywhere close to until they've had a solid string of successes without any issues.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by dotnet00 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @05:53PM (#39531304)
I'm not sold on them achieving partial reusability in practice in 9 launches (assuming that the 9 launches happen mainly this year as they have requested). I think they'll have achieved it in theory (ie demonstrated a hover landing of the booster over water), but they've only just started to build out the second tower that'll be needed to actually test reusability without risking the entire launch infrastructure.

Between the construction pauses during testing/launch, and things they can't really speed up like concrete hardening times, I don't think they'll be able to both have 9 flights AND operationalize the second tower this year.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by mjevans on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @06:00PM (#39531385)
Yes, we solidly agree on the risks associated with an as yet, as far as I know offhand, completely new landing system... Two really strong metal toothpicks.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by brandonagr2 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:10AM (#39525004)
Current falcon 9 launches can lift 22-24 starlink v2 mini satellites
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by Geisterde on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:36PM (#39533671)
Well Elon did say the "lack of load" that played a part in the last ships crash wont be a problem.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by rbanffy on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @08:39AM (#39523932)
I love that Superheavy/Starship can be profitable even if they are expendable.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by baq on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @09:37AM (#39524620)
There are customers from three letter agencies who could find a use for this payload capacity, for sure.

OTOH imagine if a reusable launch of this costs approximately the same as an expendable Atlas 5 in it's most performant configuration and reliability is proven - NASA could launch a Pluto probe like New Horizons, except it'd be able actually make orbit over there.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by somenameforme on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:20AM (#39525100)
Atlas 5 is already completely obsoleted by the Falcon Heavy which costs about half as much, for a reusable launch, and carries about 3x as much.

But for Starship, most people don't seem to realize what a potential game changer this is. The goal for Starship is to get costs down to about 15x less than Falcon Heavy. When you can start sending stuff to space for a few dollars per pound, we're not talking about just probes, but rather opening the door to the complete commercialization and exploitation of space.

Such an exponential jump (downward) in prices would also largely end the only-for-the-super-rich phase of space we're currently in. You could be doing a flyby around the Moon for what you might spend on a holiday to Asia, in the very foreseeable future. That's what makes Starship so tantalizing. If it succeeds - this is a revolutionary step forward for space. Of course, there's no guarantee that it will succeed, but it increasingly looks like it will!

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by misiti3780 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:50AM (#39525485)
Also, wont it theoretically speed up and decrease international shipping + travel. We should be able to go from the US to Japan in an hour or two in the future.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by Sanzig on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:04AM (#39525683)
I am pretty skeptical of Starship ever getting used for suborbital transportation, other than maybe for ultra-elite VIP transport or something like a rapid deployment system for military special forces. It seems highly unlikely they will ever get the price down to where it can compete with commercial airliners, and Concorde's commercial failure showed us that people will happily choose cheap subsonic flight over fast supersonic flight. You can get almost anywhere on Earth in 36 hours' notice with conventional jet travel relatively cheaply on 1-2 weeks of US median income for a return ticket - that sweet spot of speed and cost is hard to beat.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by njarboe on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:29AM (#39526008)
I think there is a pretty large market for a trip to space and an hour flight from LA to New Zealand, New York-Sydney, London-Shanghai, etc. for $10-20k. What an amazing combination that would be.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by rbanffy on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:40AM (#39526158)
Add a couple hours for the trip between town and pad, security and so on. Still it's 3-4 hours.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by lupusreal on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @12:26PM (#39526745)
I don't think there are many cities that have suitable launch sites near them. It's unlikely they'll ever get approval to launch over populated areas, or even from most populated coastal locations.

Also, the issue of getting boosters to all of these destinations seems like a problem. Planes don't split in two and have half return to the launch site but Starships do. So you could land the upper stage in Tokyo, but then what? How do you get a booster there for the return journey?

Personally I doubt they'll even use these to bring people to orbit anytime soon. I think they're purpose built for launching massive LEO constellations.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by skissane on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @04:18PM (#39530119)
> Also, the issue of getting boosters to all of these destinations seems like a problem. Planes don't split in two and have half return to the launch site but Starships do. So you could land the upper stage in Tokyo, but then what? How do you get a booster there for the return journey?

IIRC, the suborbital point-to-point transport use case doesn’t use the booster (SuperHeavy), just Starship.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by sebzim4500 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @02:09PM (#39528243)
You'd probably have to launch from international waters, after taking a boat/helicopter.

>Also, the issue of getting boosters to all of these destinations seems like a problem

You launch them, presumably.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by Gare on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @06:14PM (#39531519)
Or just ship them... with a ship.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by snypher on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:10PM (#39558445)
You're not truly wealthy until you have boosters staged at your vacation homes.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by dotnet00 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @01:39PM (#39527777)
Yeah the short term approach for crewed Starship seems likely to involve transporting crew to a Starship once it is already in orbit and vice versa for return.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by njarboe on Thursday February 29, 2024 @10:51AM (#39550968)
Off shore platforms. Most large cities are on or near an ocean or large lake.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:27PM (#39533993)
Think of this market:

The NFL wants to expand to Europe, Asia, South America badly. Problem is the logistics of Mach-1 air travel won't allow that. Same for the NBA, NHL, and MLB. A true world super league of futbol.

We're talking 10s of billions of dollars in new annual revenue for these sports leagues ... if they could transport a whole team anywhere in the world in 4-5 hours.

It costs a couple hundred thousand per flight for a team? Um, the Super Bowl brought in 600 million in ad revenue and probably another 50-200 million in ticket costs.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by Sanzig on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @12:37AM (#39534420)
A transcontinental flight ranges from low five figures for a long range business jet to upper five/lower six figures for a widebody jetliner. Those are machines purpose built for the job of moving people transcontinental distances. They benefit from decades of heritage building tens of thousands of units leading to extremely aggressive cost optimization. I just can't see Starship getting the cost per flight down into the hundreds of thousands of dollars range. Not to mention the boring (but important) constraint of trying to insure a team of valuable athletes flying around in a rocket with way less of a safety record than conventional air travel.

That said, having a sports team arrive in town by literally descending from the heavens on a burning rocket sounds badass. Unfortunately I can't really see it happening, but I'd be happy to be proven wrong.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by pests on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @03:14PM (#39542930)
I agree it would t work.

The Miami Dolphins charter a private 747 with 143 business class seats, 36 economy seats, 26 upper deck business and 10 first class.

Not only do all 55 players need to travel but so do all the people accountable for electronics, medical, gear, coaches and staff, etc.

It's a lot to transport and a lot of risk on one vehicle.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by deprecative on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:18AM (#39525853)
Watch Elon call it something like Airship and have it be fit for tens to hundreds of people per launch with no need for a pilot (though one may be present). It'd take twenty years to get to market, sure, but hey that's progress.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by rbanffy on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:51AM (#39526315)
Getting it to airline-level safety will take at least that much, unless they start flying multiple times a day without any anomalies whatsoever.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by AlgorithmicTime on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:44AM (#39526217)
Half the point of special forces is to be covert, which is made hard when your transportation is a giant rocket streaking through the suborbital zone.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by Sanzig on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:58AM (#39526392)
But imagine the PsyOps impact of the enemy looking up and seeing the US raining down literal ODSTs on them ;)

Realistically, they'd be dropping into an allied base in-theatre with a pad able to support a Starship landing, and then taking conventional means the rest of the way. Of course, I suspect that when it comes to "drop operators from space" vs. "train extra operators who can be forward deployed," the latter is probably going to be way more cost efficient. Would make for a cool movie though.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by rbanffy on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @12:10PM (#39526545)
Imagine how much of a sitting duck is a rocket glowing infrared on a ballistic trajectory to the landing site.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by zardo on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @05:24PM (#39530982)
Like an aircraft carrier, good at projecting power below a certain threshold of conflict and capability where they turn into a liability.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by PBnFlash on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @05:09PM (#39530819)
Worth noting that flying to the equator can provide a pretty significant increase of payload mass. Just a quick layover to orbit.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by TMWNN on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @05:36PM (#39531131)
>Concorde's commercial failure

I thought Concorde failed commercially because it couldn't get approval to fly over the US elsewhere over land because of sonic booms. I know reentering spacecraft cause sonic booms but thought that they occur high enough to not cause the same problems on the ground.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by pfdietz on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @07:39PM (#39532365)
It failed because trading slightly shorter flight time for much higher cost was not worthwhile. Instead, airliners have been optimized for cost reduction and efficiency at high subsonic speeds.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by TMWNN on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @08:36PM (#39532799)
I am aware that airlines today fly slower than 50 years ago, to improve fuel efficiency. That said, all orders except the British and French flag carriers' were canceled because of the overland bans, correspondingly greatly increasing the per-unit cost of those that were sold. I think the NYC-to-London/Paris routes were (slightly) profitable; were there no overland bans, are there really no other routes that Concorde could also have flown?
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by lmm on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @06:12PM (#39531506)
> I thought Concorde failed commercially because it couldn't get approval to fly over the US elsewhere over land because of sonic booms.

Or, if you're more cynical, because the US' own supersonic airliner failed and they wouldn't let those Euros show them up.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by philwelch on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:04PM (#39533838)
The American SST was cancelled because of the sonic boom problem.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by lmm on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @12:53AM (#39534535)
It was cancelled because Boeing were late and over budget; by the time they started work on a prototype, Concorde was already being shown at airshows, and the US Senate voted to stop throwing more money at them. Sonic booms were at most one contributing factor among many to that senate vote.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by philwelch on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @01:36AM (#39534772)
Concorde was also late and over budget. And until Congress defunded the 2707, it had more pending orders from more airlines than Concorde did. Sonic booms weren’t the only reason for the cancellation but they were probably the single biggest reason.

Also, Concorde wasn’t even the first supersonic airliner—that was the Tupolev Tu-144.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by markonen on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @08:19AM (#39537468)
Not sure why you're getting downvoted, this was definitely a key factor that made Concorde into a niche product.

It's not that customers preferred slower and cheaper flights over Concorde—they didn't, Concorde had very healthy average occupancy rates and operating the flights was very profitable for BA and Air France (they got the planes for free, of course).

It's that you can't fly a 1960s plane forever and you also can't amortize the design and development cost of new models with the only addressable market being first class customers travelling between the East Coast and a couple of European capitals (and this was directly caused by the overland flight restrictions).

Flying Concorde is one of my fondest memories :/

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by pests on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @03:45PM (#39543220)
Not just a boom or booms, a continuous boom along its travel.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @09:00PM (#39532977)
sub-orbital military applications would be risky as they'd look like an ICBM launch to other nuclear powers. Commercial rockets depend on advance public disclosure of launch dates to stave off WW3 from itchy trigger fingers.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by dghlsakjg on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @06:16PM (#39531547)
Maybe.

The fundamental physics involved in suborbital flights mean that you are likely experiencing sustained acceleration of 3+ Gs minimum. That is a lot, something near the max g force of a roller coaster but lasting for minutes. Combine that with the launch/landing zones needing to be many miles from anything, and it isn't really ready for primetime. Just for reference 1.3 Gs is the max sustained load you will feel in a regular airliner, very rarely 1.5 Gs for terrain avoidance.

For cargo, maybe medical stuff like moving organ donations around, but largely I can't imagine a ton of use cases where getting something to an antipode in 3 or 4 hours is that much more valuable than getting it there in 19 hours.

Then again, maybe I lack imagination.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by philwelch on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:06PM (#39533850)
So not only do I get there hours sooner, but the ride itself is more fun?
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by ghufran_syed on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @03:16AM (#39535359)
If you’re a military unit about to get wiped out by an enemy force due to running out of ammo, I imagine getting 100 tons of ammo in 1 hour vs in 19 hours would be a big difference?
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by dghlsakjg on Monday March 04, 2024 @12:43PM (#39593378)
The scenario where you have access to a space launch system, and an LZ at the front, and abundant supplies on the opposite side of the earth, but your logistics have failed to keep supplies in theater doesn't exist.

Forces that run out of ammo don't have access to cutting edge ICBMs is a rule that I would bet money on.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by Covzire on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @02:17PM (#39528362)
Mini-factories in space could become a thing, supposedly a lot of industrial processes are only difficult because of friction and gravity.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by colechristensen on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @02:50PM (#39528837)
Asteroid mining I think is one of the most interesting initial space industries. Something silly like a single asteroid having metals with current valuations of a million times the global GDP. Obviously you can't sell for that much but asteroid mining could make a lot of commodities become insanely cheap, and that would enable some pretty amazing things here at home, and in space.

Like what if steel were cheaper than plastic? If there was enough of it around to build a bridge between New York and London? If you could build a ship the size of Manhattan and then a city on top of it to roam the oceans? If you could build entire cities in orbit or city-ships that slowly wandered the solar system.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by mjevans on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @04:30PM (#39530260)
Yes, send up the robot miners. Plow the results onto the moon a safe but close distance to a base. Manufacture parts in lower G and far easier vacuum (it's super useful for MANY industrial things). Possibly even use solar collector ovens to melt/cook.

Returning bulk products to earth might not be viable in the short term, but this could really bootstrap what we do off planet and I'm hopeful it might eventually make space elevators viable which would open a lot of options.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by floxy on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @04:47PM (#39530503)
The biggest coup d'état was training an entire generation of children to be virtual mining operators.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by dog_boxer72 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @08:33PM (#39532767)
Banning child labor was a mistake, clearly they yearn for the mines.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by TMWNN on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @05:42PM (#39531190)
>Asteroid mining I think is one of the most interesting initial space industries.

I hope to see in my lifetime a large asteroid brought to Earth orbit, for both mining and as a very large space station.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by Geisterde on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @05:12AM (#39536082)
A large space station is an interesting idea, or a long range station!
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by adolph on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @06:54PM (#39531931)
> Asteroid mining

Think of all the science you could do with asteroids! Peer into the early history of the solar system . . . see what precursors to life existed before Earth was habitable. . . and all people think about is how fast they can strip-mine our extraterrestrial heritage. . . All that belongs in a museum!

/s

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by throwaway2037 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:37PM (#39533677)
I hear this touted a lot, but I never hear any specific examples. Do you know any?
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by wigiv on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @12:32AM (#39534374)
There are quite a few specific examples, all on a spectrum of technical and economic feasibility, of course.

Here’s a great place to start: https://www.factoriesinspace.com/

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by hoseja on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @08:28AM (#39537589)
Imagine vacuum foundries. AFAIU lot of metallurgy gets very complicated by the ubiquity of everything rusting all the time, exponentially moreso if it becomes hot.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by pfdietz on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @03:48PM (#39529697)
> ending stuff to space for a few dollars per pound

That's about what it costs to fly freight across an ocean.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by thereisnospork on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @04:21PM (#39530151)
That begs an interesting comparison in fuel usage (kJ or $ basis): supplying dV for one pound to orbit vs. the energy required to perform the work needed to overcome ~8,000 miles of marginal drag from +1lb of cargo on a ship.

Fuel usage being the limiter of terminal economics once launch systems are commodified to the degree ships are.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by pfdietz on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @07:33PM (#39532324)
It's important to note that most of the propellant is not fuel, it's liquid oxygen. And LOX is the second cheapest industrial liquid (after water).

As for the fuel itself, natural gas is much cheaper than jet fuel per unit of combustion energy.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by euroderf on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @03:51PM (#39529743)
For that price I'd send up a partially-eaten block of cheese, just because I can.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by newzisforsukas on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @04:15PM (#39530085)
> When you can start sending stuff to space for a few dollars per pound, we're not talking about just probes, but rather opening the door to the complete commercialization and exploitation of space.

It almost sounds too good to be true or something.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by jibe on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @04:49PM (#39530527)
It’s not uncommon to see much bigger improvements in cost than what SpaceX is targeting. E.g., solar. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/solar-pv-prices
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by somenameforme on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @09:33AM (#39538447)
Most of what SpaceX has already achieved has sounded similarly, but costs were so astronomical to begin with that it didn't make any immediate difference to most people. So for instance the Space Shuttle was only retired in 2011. After all was said and done it ended up costing $1.6 billion per launch - about $30,000 per pound of payload. The Falcon Heavy costs about $0.1 billion (in reusable mode) and brought the costs down to less than $700/lb.

That's a greater than 40x reduction in costs, which sounds too good to be true - but the problem is that even at $700/lb, that's still far too expensive to do anything remotely interesting. But take that down again and suddenly everything changes and we, more or less instantly, enter into an entirely new stage in human development and history. It'll be akin to the automobile. Henry Ford didn't make the first automobile, but he did make the first commercially affordable one. And, in the blink of an eye, society permanently changed because of it.

---

As a fun aside, when doing a web search to grab the numbers above somehow this [1] ended up in the search results. It's from 2012 and somebody pondering SpaceX's wild claims of being able to get costs below $1,100 per kg ($1,500 inflation adjusted).

[1] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3992936

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by TMWNN on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @10:16AM (#39539000)
>So for instance the Space Shuttle was only retired in 2011. After all was said and done it ended up costing $1.6 billion per launch - about $30,000 per pound of payload. The Falcon Heavy costs about $0.1 billion (in reusable mode) and brought the costs down to less than $700/lb.

Is that an apples-to-apples comparison? Each shuttle launch cost $1.5 billion when including development cost (that is, $200 billion in total spending on the STS program / 135 launches); as your link discusses, the incremental cost per launch was "merely" $450-500 million. The $0.1 billion figure per Falcon Heavy launch is only the incremental cost since we don't know how much Falcon Heavy cost to develop (And how to account for the Falcon 9 development costs that Heavy is heavily based on?). Obviously Falcon 9/Heavy has every potential for launching far more times than the shuttle, further reducing the development cost allocated to each launch (or at least, until Starship gets going I guess). But we ought to be as accurate as possible in comparing Falcon and STS.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by somenameforme on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @11:48AM (#39540526)
It's all about what the customer pays. In the case of the Space Shuttle the customer also completely paid for the development of the launch system, so it doesn't really make sense to exclude that. It's also fair to include it because it's also included for SpaceX. When we say a Falcon Heavy got launch costs down to below $700/lb, that also includes a enough of a profit margin built in to completely fund their past operations and development, as well as future ones.

SpaceX's 'real' (in the sense you're speaking of) per launch costs are going to be substantially lower than even $700/lb. In the case of Boeing/Lockeed/etc, they didn't have to pay for any of this - as it was all completely taxpayer funded. That should have enabled them to offer prices that would be unbeatable by any company paying for their own operations.

---

To put this another way, imagine Boeing et al operated like SpaceX, or frankly most any "normal" company does. They would need to set their launch prices in a fashion such that they'd be able to recoup their tens of billions of dollars in development costs on the Space Shuttle, and then also add a profit margin on top. It's likely their charged cost per launch would have been even higher than $1.6 billion!

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by TMWNN on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @03:33PM (#39543122)
> It's all about what the customer pays. In the case of the Space Shuttle the customer also completely paid for the development of the launch system, so it doesn't really make sense to exclude that.

Good point. I agree that from the customer's perspective, the flyaway cost is what matters. That said, wouldn't that also mean that for Starlink launches, the development cost would still have to be amortized across them when they are not for other launches? That doesn't feel right to me; surely the flyaway/incremental cost is still what matters.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by venusenvy47 on Thursday February 29, 2024 @08:10AM (#39548816)
That link compares a cargo Dragon mission to ISS against a Shuttle launch. Did a Shuttle mission have more overhead because of the people on board? I'm not clear if the Shuttle cost is just the launch, or the whole manned mission with all the astronaut preparation.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by somenameforme on Friday March 01, 2024 @03:05AM (#39559654)
That was just the cost of launching cargo. I found a report from NASA on the exact costs here. [1]

---

Space Shuttle - $54,500/kg to orbit, $93,400/kg to the ISS

Falcon 9 - $2,720/kg to orbit, $23,300/kg to the ISS

---

The Falcon Heavy is about $1500/kg to orbit. Note the units as we're swapping between kg and pounds in this thread pretty regularly.

[1] - https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20200001093

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by TMWNN on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @05:33PM (#39531087)
>Atlas 5 is already completely obsoleted by the Falcon Heavy which costs about half as much, for a reusable launch, and carries about 3x as much.

Which is why the rocket has been discontinued.

This is also why Boeing Starliner is dead man walking. Starliner is only certified for Atlas 5, and there are enough spare boosters for the launches NASA contracted with Boeing for, no more. The consensus is that Boeing will fulfill the contract then that'll be the end of Starliner, which is great for Boeing in the sense that it'll finally close that money-leaking wound, but not great for NASA because the whole point of Starliner + Crew Dragon was to have two separate US-owned ways to send people into space.[1] Even if Starship passes every test going forward ahead of schedule and gets man-rated, NASA would prefer to not have one company provide both methods, but I don't know what would be a better alternative. Sierra finally gets that big contract to man-rate Dream Chaser? Blue Origin?

[1] Setting aside how everyone at the time believed that Starliner would be the first one into orbit

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by dotnet00 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @06:03PM (#39531422)
There is still the possibility of either New Glenn or Vulkan being crew rated to carry Starliner. With Vulkan the concern was mainly that no one was willing to foot the bill, but with the rumored acquisition of ULA by Blue Origin, there's a chance they might want Starliner as their own crew vehicle. The main limitation being that Boeing has already shutdown Starliner production, only making the 2 needed for the ISS contract. So even if anyone else wanted them, they'd have to put in a bunch of money to restart production. Putting all those costs together it might just become better to do something else, e.g. crew rate Dreamliner.

That said, right now it's kind of up in the air, since as it stands, Dragon's second crew contract and Starliner's existing contract are likely to cover all remaining ISS launches. So what's needed afterwards depends on the commercial space stations NASA is pushing for.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by adolph on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @06:47PM (#39531856)
> Starliner is only certified for Atlas 5

I'm not certain what is meant by "certified" because it still hasn't made a human flight test yet.

Notwithstanding the retirement of Atlas and Delta, Starliner was intended to be compatible with multiple launch vehicles, including the ULA Atlas V and Delta IV, and the SpaceX Falcon 9

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_Starliner

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by tedmcory77 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @06:49PM (#39531881)
"for a few dollars per pound" - Thank you. I hadn't realized their goals were that ambitious.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by sebzim4500 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:11AM (#39525021)
Expending the second stage would almost certainly be cheaper per kg than Falcon 9, but I doubt this is still true if you have to expend the booster.

Keep in mind we would have to compare it to the ~20M marginal cost of a F9 launch, not the $70M sticker price that a customer would pay.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by bryanlarsen on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:44AM (#39525414)
It might actually be cheaper even if the booster is expended.

Falcon9 is estimated to cost about $30M/launch. $20M to build the upper stage, and $10M to launch. Starship is estimated to cost about $100M to build both the booster and the second stage. Add $10M to launch.

So 17t/$30M vs 150t/$110M.

Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by looofooo0 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @02:34PM (#39528596)
110m crazy, a380 was 4x
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by bryanlarsen on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @02:50PM (#39528840)
$110M is insane. Anything under $1B seems unfathomable. $25M for a 2MN full flow staged combustion engine seems cheap. SpaceX plans on building them for $250K a piece. They're not there yet, but current estimates of $1M a piece are just as insane.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by imtringued on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @02:23AM (#39535022)
It will be half the cost of SLS.
Re:SpaceX discloses cause of Starship anomalies as it clears... by iwontberude on Thursday February 29, 2024 @02:10PM (#39553654)
Considering the reusable Falcon 9 costs more than twice as much as launching a Soyuz despite the reusable components. It's a bit of a boondoggle, but I am so glad we have national capacity for launching payloads.