News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by VincentEvans on Monday February 26, 2024 @05:45PM (#39517693)
- 1B in donations at 5% APR conservatively invested will yield 50M every year.

- At yearly tuition rate of 59K the earned interest is enough to pay for 850 students without drawing down the invested principal.

- Albert Einstein college of medicine admits about 150 freshmen every year and medical school is 4 years long. So at any given time there are 600 students studying medicine at this school.

It seems to me that simply earned interest on this donation should be enough to allow students to attend this school free of tuition indefinitely.

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by laweijfmvo on Monday February 26, 2024 @06:10PM (#39517982)
Let's hope the tuition (and all other costs at the university) don't magically start going up now that they have all that money flowing around...
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by et-al on Monday February 26, 2024 @06:23PM (#39518106)
Cynically, I'm concerned administrative bloat will catch up in 5-10 years and they'll have no choice but to charge students again.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by hx8 on Monday February 26, 2024 @09:46PM (#39519552)
I give it closer to 20 years, but I agree.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by gonzo41 on Monday February 26, 2024 @06:54PM (#39518341)
This will happen. Count on it.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by earthwalker99 on Monday February 26, 2024 @06:24PM (#39518121)
Don't worry about that! It turns out capitalists are wonderful people so they deserve it!
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by mixdup on Monday February 26, 2024 @09:24PM (#39519375)
Well, given the numbers in the parent comment they should have a surplus of $14.7 million yearly, so they could just let the surplus go back into the endowment and that would help keep up with inflation
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by thret on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @01:27AM (#39520760)
Hopefully the donation was made with sufficient fine print to avoid this eventuality.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by happytiger on Monday February 26, 2024 @08:03PM (#39518787)
As long as they can reinvest the extra to keep up with inflation.

It’s a reminder of what can be done when billionaires give back and pass it through to society instead of passing it along to their heirs.

This kindness is going to change the world and provide doctors that will treat and help hundreds of thousands.

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by fisherjeff on Monday February 26, 2024 @06:22PM (#39518100)
Well they won’t touch the principal so long as tuition inflation stays below about 1.5%
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by anonym29 on Monday February 26, 2024 @05:48PM (#39517732)
It's enough not only for that, but to gradually expand the number of students they can afford to admit tuition-free into the future (strictly on interest), as well, should the desire to do so ever arise.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by delfinom on Monday February 26, 2024 @06:19PM (#39518065)
Given that the AMA cartel sets artificial quotas on med school admissions per school, it's not that simple lol
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by verteu on Monday February 26, 2024 @07:20PM (#39518523)
I don't think that's accurate. From my research, the bottleneck is residencies, whose funding is determined by Congress [1]. The AMA has supported laws to increase residencies, such as "H.R. 2389/S. 1302, the Resident Physician Shortage Reduction Act" [2].

The paper "Physician workforce in the United States of America: forecasting nationwide shortages" [3] mainly blames an aging population and too-slow growth in the number of "residents and fellows".

edit: Found a dissenting view here [4], its main reference seems to be [5].

[1] https://www.washingtonian.com/2020/04/13/were-short-on-healt... [2] https://www.ama-assn.org/system/files/2024-nac-action-kit-gm... [3] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7006215/ [4] https://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2013/11/its-doctors-w... [5] https://washingtonmonthly.com/2013/06/19/first-teach-no-harm...

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by bradleyjg on Monday February 26, 2024 @08:04PM (#39518792)
> whose funding is determined by Congress

There’s no law forbidding you, a state government, a local government, an insurance company, the AARP, or anyone else from funding a residency.

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by verteu on Monday February 26, 2024 @09:12PM (#39519290)
Good point - I don't see why they're subsidized by the federal gvt at all, rather than the resident, the hospital, the AMA, etc.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by whatshisface on Monday February 26, 2024 @09:35PM (#39519472)
Med students don't have a lot of money, and hospitals are actually there (from their perspective, at least) to make money. The AMA doesn't have a lot of extra money either.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by bradleyjg on Monday February 26, 2024 @09:37PM (#39519486)
They don’t have a lot of money yet. They have a very high amount of lifetime earning potential compared to their peers in other countries (yes, even after debt service and malpractice insurance.)
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by esoleyman on Monday February 26, 2024 @10:52PM (#39519956)
Are you seriously asking residents to subsidize their own training working 60-80 hours a week [1] and being paid maybe $20-25/hr for 3-7 years while the hospitals make money from their services?

If that were the case, then the only ones who would put up with such a system would be those who have rich families to back them up.

I came from a blue collar background and my family could not help subsidize my training and I could not afford to live, make rent, or afford food if I had to pay for my training as well.

There are so many other things that you are completely glossing over including annual income between generalists vs specialists, pediatricians vs non-pediatricians, reimbursement inequality from Medicare (has not kept up with inflation and is ~40% below inflation), Medicaid pays at best 10-15% on the dollar, and so on.

American physicians also work almost teice as many hours as their European counterparts which would increase their incomes.

[1] it’s considerably more because if you report it then the program can be in danger and lose its credentialing

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by tastyfreeze on Monday February 26, 2024 @11:26PM (#39520135)
> subsidize their own training working 60-80 hours a week [1] and being paid maybe $20-25/hr for 3-7 years while the hospitals make money from their services

That sounds like an apprenticeship. Many other industries do exactly that. Why should doctors be different?

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by LunaSea on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @01:53AM (#39520907)
Because you don't work 60 to 80 hours a week during an apprenticeship.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by verteu on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @08:02AM (#39523552)
But why must medical residency require 60 to 80 hours per week of work? AFAICT, it's because residencies are competitive, because there aren't enough of them, because nobody wants to pay for them. (But you can't make them unpaid, because, by circular logic, they require 60 to 80 hours per week.)

As an outsider, the whole system seems completely bizarre to me.

> [AMA president] Dr. Richard Corlin has called for re-evaluation of the training process, declaring "We need to take a look again at the issue of why the resident is there."

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by bradleyjg on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @08:17AM (#39523699)
It’s at the intersection of the medical cartel and the credential cartel. A giant pile of suck.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by LunaSea on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @08:04AM (#39523569)
They don't but it's the current situation nonetheless because medical students are at the mercy of their resident doctors.

If you don't do it, they will sack you, fail you or you won't find a job there.

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by ElFitz on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @12:49AM (#39520576)
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by bradleyjg on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @07:44AM (#39523365)
US doctors are among the richest people in the entire world, have an involuntary unemployment rate that rounds to zero, can live wherever they like without serious impact on pay and yet somehow are also the most oppressed and put upon if you ask them. Go figure it out.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by esoleyman on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @07:58AM (#39523504)
It’s inappropriate to link once dissatisfaction with one’s income.

There are multiple reasons why US doctors are unhappy about their profession. I’m not sure where you get being oppressed as being the titular complaint.

I was an engineer before going to medical school and have an outside perspective as well.

I have complaints with medicine as to how it has changed over the last 10 years and not for the best. I have the right to complain to make things better for my patients and my work-life balance. That doesn’t mean that I am oppressed.

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by bradleyjg on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @08:03AM (#39523561)
You have the right to complain and I have the right to point out that your industry, along with the housing and education industries, has stolen the entire productivity gains of a generation of Americans. I’m not concerned with your work life balance.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by Amezarak on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:12AM (#39525022)
Health care cost disease in the US has little to do with doctor salaries or demand for doctors. Unfortunately, as that would be a relatively easy problem to solve. The data I've seen indicates physician salaries adjusted for inflation are relatively flat or have even declined since the 1970s.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by esoleyman on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:22AM (#39525127)
Your complaint should be directed towards the hospitals, for-profit insurance companies, and others who profit massively on the backs of patients.

My "industry" is only myself as I am beholden to my patients. I work and am paid by each patient who I treat and receive reimbursement by 50% of them at best.

If you don’t care about my work-life balance and lump me in with the rest of the healthcare system, then there’s nothing much to discuss.

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by HDThoreaun on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:00AM (#39525629)
Doctors also massively profit off the back of patients. They make far more and live a far more lavish lifestyle than doctors in other countries. I have multiple doctors in my family, they all work less than 30 hours a week and make more than 300k. And theyre not even in the lucrative specialties. Most are family physicians which Im sure you know is the worst paid doctor.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by esoleyman on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @05:23PM (#39544245)
Doctors are paid by the patients that they treat. As an emergency physician, I treat 20-25 patients per shift on average and I am paid by approximately half of them due to not having insurance or money to pay for my services. I am paid roughly $120 per patient. Is that excessive in your opinion?

I would say that doctors in other countries are not paid accordingly and are UNDER-paid. See the UK NHS strikes as an example.

You should be complaining about is the excessive charges and reimbursement that hospitals receive for the care that they give. It gives me pause that despite having multiple physicians in your family that you do not understand the difficulty of their practice or work environment.

Most white collars jobs including doctors, engineers, and administrators make multiples of our European counterparts. I would say that Europe underpays its workers.

Again, I am a highly paid worker just like the rest of you. If I don’t work and treat patients then I am not paid anything whatsoever.

I would be further much ahead financially if I had stuck to being an engineer 18 years ago and not have put off earning an income for 7 years and going into massive debt. This was a risk because I come from a blue collar, lower middle class background without a safety net.

What is the point of your diatribe?

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by HDThoreaun on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:49AM (#39551841)
Yes $120 per patient is excessive. Yes the rest of the medical industry is even more of an excessive rip off. I dont think being a doctor is easy, I just think doctors are taking advantage of the government limited supply of their profession to negotiate salaries that are much higher than they would be if we had enough doctors. Doctor salaries are 9% of medical costs in the US, you cant just brush that off as insignificant.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by esoleyman on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @07:59AM (#39523511)
You may be right about the work hours. I possibly mis-remembered an article from several years ago when they compared income and work hours.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by Emma_Goldman on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @02:54AM (#39521325)
I agree you should be paid properly. But I don't understand why, if the US has a privatised healthcare system, hospitals are not paying to train their own labour?
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by esoleyman on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @07:52AM (#39523438)
They do to a degree but most of the money comes from the government to subsidize costs. I’m not privy to the amount or percentage but they do cry about it when the residency union (CIR) asks for inflation adjusted salary increases.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by bradleyjg on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @07:55AM (#39523475)
US hospitals are almost all nominally non-profit. In practice, they are partnerships run for the economic benefit of controlling employees but the scam the tax code by pretending otherwise.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by verteu on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @08:13AM (#39523654)
So hospitals won't pay to train their workforce because... they can save money by forcing Congress pay for it?

> hospitals are actually there (from their perspective, at least) to make money

Aren't most hospitals non-profit?

(Disclaimer: These are genuine questions; I have very little knowledge of the medical system.)

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by HDThoreaun on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:57AM (#39525579)
> So hospitals won't pay to train their workforce because... they can save money by forcing Congress pay for it?

They wont train their workforce because they would lose money doing it and can always hire people already trained. It's a tragedy of the commons which is why congress had to step in to subsidize.

> Aren't most hospitals non-profit?

Technically yes, but most are part of massive systems that are run by MBAs like traditional corporations.

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by me-vs-cat on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @07:49PM (#39532446)
>> hospitals are actually there (from their perspective, at least) to make money

> Aren't most hospitals non-profit?

"Non-profit" is not referring to how the company operates. "Non-profit" refers to the owners extracting profit. Of course there are extra pieces, such as regulated transparency, but "non-profit" as a category are not wholly the donation-supported organizations that first come to mind.

In other words, if you are the owner of a successful non-profit, you'll have to simply pay yourself a market rate (TM) salary for such a successful executive as yourself. Instead of buying lavish Christmas presents like all those executives at greedy "profit" companies, your family members will only be able to get lucrative positions at your non-profit.

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by bombcar on Monday February 26, 2024 @05:55PM (#39517807)
Or another way to look at it, you only need $50m a year to be the "equivalent" of a billion dollar endowment, and $50m a year is the budget of a smallish county.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by ksherlock on Monday February 26, 2024 @10:42PM (#39519917)
There would seem to be about 10 countries with a budget of $50 million or less and most of those are islands you've never heard of with a population under 2,000.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_governmen...

In the US, $50 million would be closer to the budget of a small city (~50,000 people.)

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by bombcar on Monday February 26, 2024 @10:46PM (#39519934)
Which is why I said “small county”. A county in the US is a division made up of the land around some cities.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by nshelly on Monday February 26, 2024 @09:57PM (#39519632)
Yes, great win all round, and also can help save on administrative costs. Poetically it was Einstein who said:

Compound interest is the eighth wonder of the world. He who understands it, earns it … he who doesn't … pays it.

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by sergiotapia on Monday February 26, 2024 @10:04PM (#39519673)
Beautiful, I hope admin bloat doesn't eat the whole enchilada.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by farseer on Monday February 26, 2024 @10:46PM (#39519935)
There is no risk free 5% yearly return. The current interest rates may be temporary and there is inflation that erodes the 50M and the Principal amount.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by mgiampapa on Monday February 26, 2024 @10:57PM (#39519990)
On a large scale a 5% average return is very conservative. No interest rates won't stay where they are, but no one would invest an endowment just by putting it a HYSA.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @01:49AM (#39520888)
> On a large scale a 5% average return is very conservative

Any return above GDP growth is not conservative. On average, real world GDP has grown at 3 to 5% per year since 1964 [1]. (We use real GDP because university costs will increase with inflation.)

600 students would have paid $35.4mm in tuition a year at $59,000 per year. That's a 3.54% drawdown per annum, right in line with real GDP growth. A 4 to 5% real return target is doable, but not conservative and certainly not a figure with a lot of margin for error.

[1] https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/WLD/world/gdp-growth-r...

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by Emma_Goldman on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @02:44AM (#39521266)
Growth is a useless indicator. The whole point of Piketty's argument is that the return on capital tendentially outstrips the rate of growth, and that large investors have access to especially high return assets. The OP is right that a 5% average annual return is conservative.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @03:09AM (#39521428)
> Growth is a useless indicator. The whole point of Piketty's argument is that the return on capital tendentially outstrips the rate of growth

I'll sidestep that Piketty measures wealth and calls it capital. Because that observation says nothing about how risk is distributed across those returns.

> large investors have access to especially high return assets

$1bn doesn't make for a "large investor" in institutional terms.

> OP is right that a 5% average annual return is conservative

No, they are not.

There are objective measures for this. I've worked closely with endowments the world over. A manager pitching a 5% target return on a fund with a 3.5% annual drawdown as conservative would be fired. A banker pitching the same would be subject to professional sanctions.

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by Emma_Goldman on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @03:20AM (#39521494)
> Cute

Sorry, this is childish and you don't substantively respond to the core point. I am not going to waste my time.

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @03:29AM (#39521564)
Fair enough. Edited.

> you don't substantively respond to the core point

Yes, I do. Even if capital returns well in excess of growth on average, that doesn't change that the returns on assets in that excess regime are riskier than those below it. (This actually being formally provable by way of seniority.) Excess returns are never achived conservatively, let alone very conservatively.

Piketty's work has been seriously challenged. It makes good points. But it also contains bad ones, including a couple really sloppy and unsubstantiated assertions. His conflation of wealth and capital being germane to your argument.

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by scotty79 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @07:42AM (#39523343)
> Any return above GDP growth is not conservative.

That would be true if additional GDP was distributed equally. But the rich capture majority of it in their investment vessels. So for a person with capital I think double of GDP is still conservative as long as inequality grows.

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by VincentEvans on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @03:37PM (#39529534)
“As of October 2023, Harvard's endowment has an 8.2% 10-year return. In fiscal year 2023, endowment returns averaged 7.7%, with smaller endowments posting larger returns. Institutions with over $5 billion in assets have historically had higher 10-year average returns of 9.1%.”

https://www.highereddive.com/news/college-endowment-returns-...

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by HDThoreaun on Thursday February 29, 2024 @11:55AM (#39551943)
10 years isnt very long. Whos to say we'll have another 40 year bull market like we just did?
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by VincentEvans on Thursday February 29, 2024 @12:55PM (#39552653)
Trailing 10 year performance is a standard reporting metric used to facilitate risk-and-return decisions in an uncertain world.

Here it serves to simply add weight to an argument that expecting a 5% annual return for invested endowment funds is reasonable and supported by historical evidence.

If things do not go as well going forward - all it means that principal will erode over time.

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by VincentEvans on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @03:36PM (#39529528)
I didn’t say risk-free, I said “conservative”.

But let’s turn to examples:

“As of October 2023, Harvard's endowment has an 8.2% 10-year return. In fiscal year 2023, endowment returns averaged 7.7%, with smaller endowments posting larger returns. Institutions with over $5 billion in assets have historically had higher 10-year average returns of 9.1%.”

https://www.highereddive.com/news/college-endowment-returns-...

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by amirhirsch on Monday February 26, 2024 @11:41PM (#39520220)
Michael Saylor can sell enough Bitcoin to make MIT tuition-free. We should pressure him.
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by lowkey on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @12:07AM (#39520387)
MIT's existing endowment is nearly $30 Billion.

Why single out a particular private individual or his publicly traded company when you could simply pressure the institution itself to make tuition free?

Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by stephen_g on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @01:04AM (#39520656)
Sure, but surely you'd have to dispose that much bitcoin over a really, really long time to not seriously move the price down... People might be disappointed at the amount of real money actually flowing around the cryptocurrency markets...
Re:New York medical school eliminates tuition after $1B gift by IG_Semmelweiss on Monday February 26, 2024 @11:45PM (#39520249)
opportunity missed.

She should have made the gift contingent on keeping tuition costs indexed at 2023 level plus a tiny fraction of inflation say 0.5%

Then the real challenge would be very interesting - what they could cut every year to keep the program going.