News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by growingkittens on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @08:46AM (#39288474)
Parents in the US are allowed to unilaterally destroy a child's life in many ways.

For instance, spanking. Discussions around spanking focus on parent's rights without defining what spanking is.

Some people think of spanking as a strong tap on the butt. Others chase their children down with a belt while screaming obscenities. Both of these people are accepted in society if they describe their actions as 'spanking'.

If someone advocates for spanking without defining what it is, the chances that they have unwittingly acted as an advocate for child abuse are really high.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by Aurornis on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:34AM (#39289023)
> Others chase their children down with a belt while screaming obscenities. Both of these people are accepted in society if they describe their actions as 'spanking'.

Hitting children with a belt is neither broadly accepted by society nor is it legally acceptable. Calling it “spanking” doesn’t give people a free pass from the law.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by growingkittens on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:39AM (#39289075)
I live in the American South, where it is absolutely accepted by society and the law.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by wizerdrobe on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:59AM (#39289351)
Depending on state, IANAL but in “the South” (Carolina)…

I had a less than stellar household, was punched several times in the head by a parent so I put them in a headlock to get them to calm down. Spent several months in juvenile detention because of my “assault.”

Later came to learn, after my useless public defender advised I plead guilty, that would have been legally considered self defense.

About a year later the same parent started slapping me in the face. I called the police this time but to my disappointment was informed slaps are legally acceptable but closed-fist strikes are not. So a punch or hammer fist would be child abuse and criminally punishable. For further clarification, belts, breadboards, the famous “switch,” are all legal so long as it’s not physically, permanently damaging.

As with most things human law, it’s up to interpretation and will vary by responding officer and such.

This was circa 2008 so we’re not talking “1950s America” here.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by okwhateverdude on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:54AM (#39290035)
Man, I sincerely hope you had a jenny-throws-rocks-at-the-house moment later. Parents being shitty to their kids is the worst.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by PopAlongKid on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:53AM (#39289269)
>Hitting children with a belt is neither broadly accepted by society nor is it legally acceptable.

Maybe true in the 21st century, but certainly not true earlier than that. And re: sibling comment, it wasn't only happening in the American South but other regions as well.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by tamaharbor on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:00AM (#39289359)
Spanking is still legal corporal punishment at schools in at least 18 US states.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by masfoobar on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:01AM (#39288649)
What do you consider to be the correct meaning to "Spanking" ?

edit: No being difficult or troll -- just curious.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by growingkittens on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:29AM (#39288961)
There is no correct meaning of the word spanking, just a spectrum of meanings.

Each instance has to be evaluated individually, because the spectrum of possible meanings is so wide.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by lttlrck on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:27AM (#39288939)
Yes. It is a very broad term for inflicting pain using your hand or an implement...

Be careful what you advocate!

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by JohnClark1337 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:16AM (#39288812)
"Gentle Parenting" is another instance. It could mean that you set boundaries but are more cautious about how you give punishments, attempting to fit the punishment to the bad deed. Or it could mean that you let the child do whatever they want and give them everything, teaching them that there are no negative consequences to their actions and that others are there to serve them.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by dang on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @01:55PM (#39292627)
"Eschew flamebait. Avoid generic tangents."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by growingkittens on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @03:59PM (#39294245)
Jackie Coogan suffered due to a lack of child protection laws - which still don't exist due to the strength of parent's rights in the US.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by dang on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @04:26PM (#39294525)
That would be the point of contact with the article, yes, but the thing about generic tangents is that they take off from a point and then head in a generic direction, one which is nearly always less interesting than the specifics of the article itself—and which if the topic is divisive at all, usually ends in a flamewar that is just a repetition of previous flamewars. On HN, we're trying to avoid this kind of thing and focus on curious conversation.

Btw I'm quite sure you didn't intend any of what I'm describing here. The point is that it happens unintentionally, and all too easily, so we all need to learn to consciously avoid it.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by h2odragon on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:25AM (#39288922)
When I was 17, my Dad told me he was "investing" the near million dollars that was my share of the sales of software I'd written.

When I was 34, he passed, and I had to wrap up his estate. Discovered that I was on the paperwork for several corporations I had never heard of; that there was no money left, and some of the details of how he spent it all. We apparently contributed to Nashville getting their hockey team, among other fun diversions having nothing to do with the business we had been in.

Still aint got over the bitterness.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by IncreasePosts on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:59AM (#39290979)
Wait, so you've owned a slice of the Nashville Predators since the late 90s? I thought sports teams have been a great investment over the past 20 years?
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by h2odragon on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:37PM (#39291506)
no, he got scammed by those folks for some amount. They did a Cayman Islands "carry trade" deal and i have no idea what happened there.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by kevinventullo on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:16AM (#39289549)
Out of curiosity, what was the nature of the software you had sold as a teenager?
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by h2odragon on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:36PM (#39291493)
Bid estimating package for building earthen structures
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by geraldhh on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:13AM (#39289503)
otoh most 17 year old's would probably not do any better.

is the morale here that nobody should have "invested" it anywhere?

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by majormajor on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:12PM (#39291147)
The moral, if you want one, is that if you're going to "protect" your kid "for their own good" instead of letting them have a say in it than you damn well better not fuck up.

A 17 year old who screws up can learn some lessons. A 17 year old who was screwed by their father? Less so.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by thinkingtoilet on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:16AM (#39290354)
You can put it in a trust and hire someone to manage it, but that has it's own complications. Other than that, an index fund. Dead simple.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by tinco on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:19AM (#39289582)
Not sure if they wouldn't. The sort of companies 17yr's hear about and are excited about in the past 20 years have all done extremely well. Perhaps that's a quirk of the past 20 years, but I wouldn't dismiss 17yr olds investment strategies out of hand.

They would do a lot better than what sounds like shady angel investments and sports team sponsorships.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by kiba on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:21AM (#39289606)
Have we not forgot about the fraud and scams of the last twenty years? There's also the huge issue of hindsight bias.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by kiba on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:17AM (#39289554)
Stick it into an index fund.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by huytersd on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:01AM (#39290131)
Nonsense. If my son did that it would go straight into a low risk index fund or bond.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by AlexandrB on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:38AM (#39290687)
To be fair, 20 years ago low cost index funds were much less common and knowledge of them was also not as widespread. But bond is always a good option.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by Bluestrike2 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @02:00PM (#39292727)
Considering the fact that the commenter's father lost or wasted all of it, he'd have probably been better had it sat in a checking account for the intervening years. Or under a mattress in wadded up dollar bills. Even if you're completely clueless about investing and you just walk into your bank and ask to talk to someone about what to do with it, you'd still come out ahead even if they push you towards mutual funds with excessive fees. Pretty much anything would have been better.

I'm not a parent, but I have trouble imagining how I'd ever feel comfortable directly managing my (hypothetical) kid's earnings like that. It just seems like, no matter what you do, you're creating a dynamic that could undermine or outright destroy your relationship. Especially if some of those investments go poorly.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by h2odragon on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @02:09PM (#39292825)
I was raised to believe that the entire reason I existed was to take care of my parents. Pops really didn't have a division between "his property" and "my property."

One of the last things he did was sell me the land I'd built my house on. With a personal loan from one of his banker buddies with a 25% APR.

I really shoulda known better as a teenager.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by zackmorris on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:26AM (#39289659)
You just nailed why "nobody wants to work anymore".

I grew up in the 80s and Gen X people like me mostly remember asking our Boomer parents for money and they would maybe give us $20 or tell us to get a job. Meanwhile many of them (not mine) were making bank. We grew up with the understanding that there would simply be no money for us other than what we earned ourselves. The minimum wage would never increase, working people's taxes would never decrease, rich people's taxes would never increase, social security would be gone by the time we retire, etc etc etc. It never made sense to me how the hippie generation that learned so much about consciousness and the human condition managed to unlearn all of that and revert to a greed-is-good gilded age philosophy of trickle-down economics.

So I've come to equate deciding for others with sin. Because the ultimate sin is to look out for oneself and deny the agency of another under whatever mental construct floats your boat. That's what stuff like the golden rule and 10 commandments are about.

We're seeing this today with center-right populist politics where its proponents call grown adults snowflakes for calling out exploitation. And even the center-left silently supports neoliberal colonialism if it supports its narrative. This is why I could never vote for a republican that thinks he/she knows better than me while undercutting me, or a democrat who claims to act in my interests while gentrifying my community to raise my rent for example.

The elders currently in charge of government think they have some wisdom that comes with age, but they can't hear us when we tell them that there are no adults in the room. Because the world is literally burning while they obsess themselves with materialistic pursuits that will materially diminish the quality of life for us and future generations.

Meanwhile Millenials and Gen Z seem to be rejecting this patriarchy. And Gen X largely wants no part of withholding resources from others "for their own good". I see two possible futures around 2030: a head-in-the-sand focus on the comfort of the family like in the early 2000s and 1990 where actual world peace is put out of sight and mind, or a silent revolution where the old guard retires and young people pay those inherited resources forward to automate the drudgery that consumes our waking lives so that we can move into the New Age.

The odds say that the former future is most likely based on history, but I suspect that the incalculable rage that young people feel towards the rich and powerful may alchemize into a level of healing love that the world hasn't seen yet. In other words if you have children, they will self-actualize in the ways which you were denied, and that wind-in-our-sails shift from conservatism towards investment in the future will play out across the population at large and deliver rapid spiritual evolution and innovation like we saw during the pandemic. So we should probably maintain vigilance in the face of one last sabotage as the powers that be attempt to cement minority rule by the elites before they pass.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by glitchc on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:56AM (#39290063)
The fly in the ointment is that Millenials are turning out to be just as materialistic as the Boomers.

2017: https://www.ipsos.com/en-uk/millennials-are-most-derided-gen...

2022: https://www.investopedia.com/articles/personal-finance/02191...

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by Lerc on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:17PM (#39291209)
The first link is about perception not reality. People consider Millennials to be materialistic. It doesn't say they are.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by glitchc on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:58PM (#39291808)
From TFA:

> Millennials are the most materialistic generation: A new analysis of the European Social Survey shows that across Europe, those aged 21-37 are more likely to agree with a range of materialistic statements. This is especially true in the UK, where 24% say it is important to be rich, compared with 13% of Generation X and 10% of Baby Boomers.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by neuronerdgirl on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @05:12PM (#39295000)
You can't point to that in a vacuum. For boomers and Xs, it was literally less important to be rich, because you could still do quite well for yourself. Since about 2008 if you're not rich you are much more likely to be existentially struggling. So yea millennials think it's important to be rich because those are the only people who can afford houses.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by glitchc on Friday February 09, 2024 @05:32PM (#39321303)
"It's harder to be rich so more people want to be rich."

We call this changing the goalposts. It's also logically incorrect as "rich" is a relative measure, not an absolute one.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by at_a_remove on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:27AM (#39290520)
We're getting a little far afield here, but I find all of those "You Big Silly, Social Security Isn't Going Bankrupt" articles, which eventually make the correction that we just won't be getting our expected benefits out of the fund quite a bit like those technically correct "we won't ever run out of oil" stances. It's true, the last few barrels of oil will probably reside in a museum somewhere, priced like a Gaughin, but for all practical purposes ...

For all practical purposes, the Boomers have this locust-y feel about them. Not malevolent so much as blindly hungry, leaving little behind. Their consumption and barren futures aren't a concern for them, they'll be dead, and we will, like Coogan, have been robbed on a generational scale. We will hear Lillian Coogan's words in many variations: "No promises were ever made to give Jackie anything."

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by nineplay on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:24AM (#39290483)
> Gen X people like me mostly remember asking our Boomer parents

Millennials are the children of Boomers, not Gen X.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by flir on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:53AM (#39290885)
Born '72 to a mother born '47.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by TehShrike on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:31AM (#39288995)
Children should be allowed to own property.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by aetherson on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:00AM (#39289352)
They should. However, we should understand that for all the failings of parents as managers of a child's money, a five year old child is also not going to make good financial decisions, and there does need to be someone who can make prudent, and indeed numerate, decisions on the child's behalf.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by firebat45 on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:19AM (#39290406)
Children may not be able to make good decisions with their money, but many adults aren't either, especially when it is someone else's money (ie, their kids).

A child should retain full control of their own money up to a certain value. Above that, they should be assigned a fiduciary to take care of the rest.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by aetherson on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:46AM (#39290794)
"Assigned a fiduciary" does a lot of work there. Who assigns the fiduciary? How do we find a good one? Why does this fiduciary do this job? God knows that financial professionals are not exactly immune to misconduct.

I think we should maybe admit that this is just kind of a difficult space, where there's in some rare cases a lot of money on the line and there's not necessarily anyone who's perfectly suited to handle it.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by marcinzm on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:09PM (#39291089)
How does this prevent these issues? Do you think a 5 year old child would not sign over all their property to their dear parents and/or manager if asked? It just increases the number of people who would try to swindle the kid since literally anyone interacting with the kid could do it.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by pizzafeelsright on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:35AM (#39289796)
No. Children are property.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by razakel on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @11:06AM (#39290202)
To quote Lady Hale, that is a startling proposition.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by TehShrike on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @04:20PM (#39294463)
Both can be true!
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by PopAlongKid on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:37AM (#39289057)
I mistook Jackie Coogan for another child star of the same era, Jackie Cooper.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by croisillon on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:30PM (#39291394)
oh wow wikipedia, "Cooper supported Republican presidential candidates and appeared at rallies for Herbert Hoover in 1932", the guy was born in 1922!
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by Gorath on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:04PM (#39297487)
He was nominated for an academy award at age nine, this hardly seems far fetched. Have you forgotten this is a thread about child stars? Or are you just being intentionally misleading
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by croisillon on Thursday February 08, 2024 @10:07AM (#39302757)
i believe you neither support republicans nor democrats at 10, i don't see what's misleading
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by tamaharbor on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:57AM (#39289315)
Me too. Among many other things… Coogan played Uncle Fester in the Addams Family television series, Cooper played Jackie in the Our Gang / Little Rascals comedy series.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by lupusreal on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:41AM (#39289106)
Children are never good at acting anyway, I wish writers wouldn't write stories that require child actors.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by kevinmchugh on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:06AM (#39289435)
I find that children rarely have much range, but they can be cast inline with their natural inclinations or personality. There's a number of tv shows where the kid actors get worse over time, as they're asked to do more kinds of storytelling (stranger things is a good example).
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by ceejayoz on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @09:49AM (#39289214)
Watch the audition for the kid in ET and tell me kids can't ever be good actors. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tA5giyG8E7g

No kids in TV/film would leave a very odd gap in the stories we can tell.

Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by lupusreal on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:06PM (#39291055)
For each their own I guess, I hated ET even when I was a kid.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by ceejayoz on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @12:16PM (#39291197)
You don't have to like the movie, but it's hard to argue the kid in that video can't act.
Re:Jackie Coogan and the Fall of Hollywood's Child Stars by at_a_remove on Wednesday February 07, 2024 @10:19AM (#39289570)
This isn't true. It's rare, but there are some terrific child actors. Watch the original IT to note just how good Seth Green and Emily Perkins are. Dakota Fanning and her sister. Haley Joel Osment felt very natural in The Sixth Sense. Brooke Shields in Alice, Sweet Alice was more in control of her performance than most adults.

Anyway, kids in movies and television shows aren't going away. We have to make sure they are well-treated.