News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by berserk1010 on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:07PM (#39181750)
A couple of things to note:

1.) Why did it take Evergrande 3 years to liquidate? In western countries, liquidation happens in a few months. One should note that Evergrande did not get that big by itself; obviously it had the support of CCP elites to secure huge bank loans. Therefore, when it went bankrupt, the delay was to allow these elites to pull money/liquidable assets out of Evergrande. Thus after 3 years, Evergrande probably has pretty bad mark-to-fantasy assets left. This bodes very ill for creditors. Foreign creditors account only for $25B of the $300B liabilities for Evergrande. https://apnews.com/article/china-evergrande-property-liquida...

2.) This event implies that most of the Chinese real estate developers are bankrupt/insolvent. excluding for Li Ka Shing's portfolio most likely.

3.) Evergrande's assets are mostly comprised of lands in China. This means, most of the lands will get returned to local governments, which will increase land inventory massively. This will accelerate the real estate price decline in all parts of China, on top of the 30-40% drop we're seeing in Tier 1 cities, on top of the 50-60% drop we're seeing in non-Tier 1 cities.

4.) What does this mean for China's 3 pillars of economic engine (real estate, consumer spending, export)? real estate comprises of 25-30% of Chinese economy, so the economy will be forced to mark to reality these assets, and will take a huge hit. Consumer spending is tied to real estate engine, since most of the citizens' wealth is in real estate. Thus we are seeing consumer spending decline and downgrade substitution patterns. Case in point: recent $1 McDonald burger deal was causing shortages in China. Haidilao has been focused on a cheaper version of their hot pot, which costs $10. $1 bread shops are spreading across China.

5.) If real estate and consumer spending is crashing, then China can only rely on export, and thus the trend of dumping abroad will continue. Especially cars and solar. Europe is in the middle of looking into applying tariffs to Chinese EVs. US is already set with heavy tariffs on Chinese EVs. Note that Chinese export to US and Europe has dropped 10% and 20% y/y.

EDIT: also coincidently, Chinese authorities just banned short selling https://www.reuters.com/world/china/china-securities-regulat.... This is following the Chinese stock market decline of 11% this year. and 3 year cumulative decline.

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:22PM (#39181953)
> This bodes very ill for creditors. Foreign creditors account only for $25B of the $300B liabilities for Evergrande.

I'm sorry - but any foreigner who lent Evergrande money thinking this wasn't a huge risk is a moron.

> This will accelerate the real estate price decline in all parts of China, on top of the 30-40% drop we're seeing in Tier 1 cities, on top of the 50-60% drop we're seeing in non-Tier 1 cities.

According to "official" sources - property prices aren't even down 5%. Where are you seeing that they're down 30-40% in Tier 1 cities?

It would take the median couple >7 years saving 100% of post-tax income to afford a downpayment on the median 100 m^2 condo. If you assume even 3% interest - thereafter - the monthly payment would be >80% of their COMBINED post-tax income.

China's property prices have astounded me since 2000 - and yet they continued to rocket higher for a solid two decades.

People are NUTS in the US at Price to Income levels of 4:1 - when this is some of the lowest Price to Income for housing in the world. We consider places like Vancouver and London and Sydney ludicrous bubbles - and yet they are usually below 10:1. China was at 11:1 in 2000 and climbed to 17:1 by 2020: https://lipperalpha.refinitiv.com/2020/06/chart-of-the-week-... Places like Shanghai have ratios of 38:1 and higher.

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by brianwawok on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:46PM (#39182314)
Your math just says the median person doesn’t buy a condo. If only the top 10% can afford them, that’s still a huge pool of people.

Pretty sure median US income can’t afford a condo in NYC.

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:52PM (#39182404)
At the end of the day - prices need to be supported by incomes (buyers or renters) or magic beans.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by lmm on Monday January 29, 2024 @08:30PM (#39185285)
Sure. But the median Chinese income tells you very little about the distribution of Chinese incomes.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by HWR_14 on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:53PM (#39182424)
The foreigners probably loaned money to Evergrande a long time ago, before the issues started appearing.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:55PM (#39182450)
The issues were apparent since 2000.

The vast majority of Evergrande's outstanding foreign debt is from >2012.

BlackRock, HSBC, and UBS poured in about $3B of the $25B in 2021 alone...

And, I'm sorry - if you didn't see a risk doing that in 2021 - you're gonna lose all your money sooner or later.

In BlackRock's case - it was primarily for 401k-ers for exposure to Chinese bonds. I think the US should've made it illegal - and probably will soon - to offer a product like that.

Why anyone in the US would want exposure to Chinese bonds that don't even have good yields for "diversity" is incredible. Up next - Russian and Venezuelan 100-year bonds at 0% interest!

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by seanmcdirmid on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:30PM (#39182943)
2012 was the year that Andrew Left publicized why he was shorting Evergrande stock, which he got banned for in 2016. I would say 2010 was when Evergrande started popping up in the news as possibly insolvent, 2000 is too early.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by djbusby on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:00PM (#39182522)
If only someone had warned us!
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by thriftwy on Monday January 29, 2024 @06:19PM (#39184128)
What's wrong with Russian bonds? That land is unlikely to be going away, may contain even more mineral wealth and is climate change resistant.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by dgellow on Monday January 29, 2024 @07:59PM (#39185011)
Aren’t bonds linked to governments, not land? Russia the country can default.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by hollerith on Monday January 29, 2024 @09:49PM (#39185840)
The Kremlin has been saying that if the $300 billion worth of Russian Central Bank assets that were frozen in response to the invasion of Ukraine are confiscated (e.g., to give them to Ukraine), the Kremlin is going to respond by confiscating assets in Russia held by Westerners.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by petre on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @02:16AM (#39187257)
Westeners who were dumb enough to move their assets into Russia in order to evade taxes. Like Depardieu, who recently got UAE citizenship.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by thriftwy on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @03:29AM (#39187672)
But that's not a problem with Russia - that's the West not honoring their IOU. Also not problem for everybody else.

The West is a minority of the Earth now, including financially.

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by photonbeam on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @12:30AM (#39186681)
Not if climate change triggers a new ice age :)

Though I guess that bond prices would be meaningless for most at that point

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by ffgjgf1 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @02:51AM (#39187423)
What does that have to with bonds the government might refuse to pay out (or western governments might ban you from receiving payments even if they don’t)?
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by MrPatan on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:05PM (#39182592)
> any foreigner who lent Evergrande money thinking this wasn't a huge risk is a moron.

Or they are very smart while investing your money. Check your country's pension fund, see who manages it and what they invest in. Or better yet, don't.

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by berserk1010 on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:48PM (#39182331)
cursory searches on western media reviews shows 20%, 25%, 30%.

https://medium.com/alpha-beta-blog/even-beijing-home-prices-...

https://fortune.com/2023/08/17/china-home-sales-worse-than-o...

https://sccei.fsi.stanford.edu/china-briefs/tier-3-cities-ho...

My sources are from real estate agents in China.

Not sure why anyone would actually trust official numbers from China. China still claimed 5% gdp growth last year. pretty laughable.

Also, you can just watch what multinationals are doing. They have retail numbers from their Chinese stores. And it's pretty clear Japanese and Taiwanese and South Korean and American and European multinationals are all withdrawing.

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:09PM (#39182642)
A Medium post isn't a source.

Your fortune article says PRICES are only down 2.4% (roughly the "official" stats).

Your other article is about T3 cities.

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by berserk1010 on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:13PM (#39182698)
It's all in the articles

"Existing homes near Alibaba Group Holding Ltd.’s headquarters in Hangzhou have dropped about 25% from late 2021 highs, according to local agents."

"Even as of March, before a fresh slowdown, more than half of tier-2 and tier-3 cities saw existing-home prices fall more than 15% from peaks,"

"residential housing prices in tier 3 cities dropped by nearly 20%."

EDIT: Again, to get the real numbers, you need to have access to Chinese real estate agents. And these folks aren't going to be posting articles for everyone to read. Or if they post a video in anger, it will get taken down.

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:17PM (#39182742)
A small section of a New Tier 1 city is not indicative of an entire T1 city.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by seanmcdirmid on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:39PM (#39183055)
Is HZ really considered a T1 city now? It is more like a rich T2 city.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday January 29, 2024 @05:14PM (#39183483)
According to Wikipedia it is a "New Tier 1" city. T1 is still just Shanghai, Beijing and Shenzhen/Guangzhou.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by seanmcdirmid on Monday January 29, 2024 @09:16PM (#39185621)
I guess by money it could be, so could other cities in jiangsu and zhejiang that are China’s richest provinces.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by pphysch on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:32PM (#39182969)
That user is a new single-purpose account with a clear interest in shaping narratives around a certain country, so I would take their claims with a big grain of salt.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by berserk1010 on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:37PM (#39183035)
What can I say, all I know about/care about is Chinese economy. I do provide a lot of valuable facts/links to the site
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by lucubratory on Monday January 29, 2024 @06:23PM (#39184160)
You provided a link to a Medium post.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by berserk1010 on Monday January 29, 2024 @06:37PM (#39184288)
Author is a data scientist pretty fluent in Chinese matters. You take what you can get out of censored dictatorship like China.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by wesapien on Monday January 29, 2024 @09:03PM (#39185535)
Nice stats but people want housing condition to improve not degenerate to other countries lows. Should we thank our western overlords for sparing us from those conditions? No.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by deadfoxygrandpa on Monday January 29, 2024 @10:42PM (#39186153)
i live in shenzhen and i would love it if prices dropped 30-40%. i'd buy an apartment immediately lol. i've been checking real estate prices every once and a while for about 5 years now ready to buy if something shows up at a good price in an area i want to live in

the reality so far is that prices have pretty much stayed flat for the past 4-5 years. there hasnt been any significant fall anywhere within like 1 hour of me in shenzhen

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by berserk1010 on Monday January 29, 2024 @11:04PM (#39186283)
I guess you weren't looking hard enough.

Pre-owned housing prices in Shenzhen fell by nearly half from their peak in 2020 after holding up over the past two years of plunging new-home values amid slumping demand and a liquidity crunch for developers.

https://www.caixinglobal.com/2023-08-25/shenzhen-existing-ho...

Meanwhile, according to Leyoujia store transaction data, second-hand housing prices in Shenzhen in the fourth quarter of 2023 were around 65,000 yuan per square meter, down 12% from 2022, and 22% lower than the all-time high in the first quarter of 2021. The transaction prices in some areas and real estate have already returned to 2018, and the drop compared to the highest point was as high as 30% to 40%.

https://news.futunn.com/en/post/36099590?level=1&data_ticket...

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by r00fus on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:53PM (#39182423)
> 1.) Why did it take Evergrande 3 years to liquidate?

Because this isn't "the West". China/CCP is specifically unwinding this slowly to avoid cross-market contagion.

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by ffgjgf1 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @02:54AM (#39187449)
And looting all the remaining assets in the process. Not to mention trying to extract as much as possible from mortgage holders who bought uncompleted houses and have to continue paying even though they’ll never get anything in return.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by datadrivenangel on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:14PM (#39181836)
It will be very interesting to see how the CCP navigates this coming recession.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by berserk1010 on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:22PM (#39181947)
I would call it a Great Depression https://www.forbes.com/sites/miltonezrati/2024/01/22/chinas-.... And the depression probably started in 2021 or 2022.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by bigbillheck on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:03PM (#39182553)
> And the depression probably started in 2021 or 2022.

GDP is generally a bogus metric but it's an odd kind of depression that has a 5% growth in it.

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by onlyrealcuzzo on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:07PM (#39182613)
You can easily get 5% growth and worse living standards.

Expand your balance sheet to pay everyone to dig a hole.

GDP goes up.

As long as you ignore debt, GDP doesn't really mean anything.

Look at China's debt.

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by MrPatan on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:08PM (#39182619)
Is that 5% growth? Or is that a piece of paper with a number "5" in it? There is a difference.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by ffgjgf1 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @02:58AM (#39187471)
> odd kind of depression

Not so much if you compare it to the original “Great Depression” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_Depression

Of course assuming that 5% even means anything. Look up the Soviet official growth figures from the late 70s and 80s

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by enaaem on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @05:29AM (#39188458)
Li Keqiang, China’s former premier, doesn’t even look at gdp. It’s for ‘reference only’.

https://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE6B527D/

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by chasd00 on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:57PM (#39182469)
my guess is the CCP will declare it a mild economic correction and anyone saying otherwise will be jailed.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by NicoJuicy on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:15PM (#39181856)
Some insights I didn't knew/consider, especially 2 and 3.

Can I ask the source of how you gained those insights?

Interesting to note: they have higher debt levels than the US ( GDP wise). If GDP would go down, that would mean a vicious circle and they wouldn't be able to "fund" their way out with low risk.

Which seems to indicate a lot of advantages to fiddle with the GDP growth numbers and explains limiting access to economic statistics: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-08-16/china-is-...

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by berserk1010 on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:23PM (#39181966)
You would have to know mandarin (to read through government economic reports), and have access to Douyin videos. And these videos get taken down by the authorities fairly quickly
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by yorwba on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:52PM (#39182414)
There's probably a dozen people reading this thread who know enough Mandarin to handle a few short Douyin videos if you could provide us with links.

Though as a platform it lends itself well to amplifying extreme claims backed by speculation that play into people's fears, so unless the accounts in question have a history of well-sourced factual reporting, I'd be rather skeptical.

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by berserk1010 on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:02PM (#39182539)
I'll paste one sample, it's safer

1、恒大,龙头房企,负债规模约2.6万亿,2021年9月正式宣告暴雷。

2、中梁,浙江房企,负债规模约2000亿,2022年4月公告美元债寻求展期,宣告暴雷。

3、俊发,云南房企,负债规模约1200亿,2022年4月2.19亿信托贷款未兑付,宣告暴雷。

4、融创,龙头房企,负债规模约1万亿,2022年3月美元债展期,宣告暴雷。

5、世茂,龙头房企,负债规模约4000亿,2022年3月公告60亿信托展期,宣告暴雷。

6、龙光,粤系房企,负债规模约2000亿,2022年3月公告美元债违约,宣告暴雷

7、祥生,浙江房企,负债规模约1500亿,2022年3月,1200万美元利息违约,宣告暴雷。

8、大发,上海房企,负债规模约300亿,2022年3月2228万元美元债利息无法偿还,宣告暴雷。

9、禹洲,闽系房企,负债规模约900亿,2022年3月美元债利息2125万美元违约,宣告暴雷。

10、正荣,闽系房企,负债规模约2000亿,2022年2月公告美元债违约,宣告暴雷。

11、富力,粤系房企,负债规模约3000亿,2021年12月7亿美元债展期,宣告暴雷。

12、华夏幸福,产城地产龙头,负债规模约2600亿,2021年2月首次承认52亿债务逾期,宣告暴雷。

13、佳兆业,粤系房企,负债规模约2300亿,2021年11月3亿理财产品未兑付,宣告暴雷。

14、阳光城,闽系房企,负债规模约3500亿,2021年公司理财未兑付,宣告暴雷。

15、奥园,粤系房企,负债规模约2500亿,2021年11月,6590万元信托贷款违约,宣告暴雷。

16、新力,江西房企,负债规模约1000亿,2021年10月2.5亿美元债违约,宣告暴雷。

17、花样年,粤系房企,负债规模约600亿,2021年10月2亿美元债违约,宣告暴雷。

18、当代置业,负债规模约800亿,2021年10月3亿美元债违约,宣告暴雷。

19、中庚地产,闽系房企,负债规模300亿,2021年10月9.3亿债务违约,宣告暴雷。

20、光耀地产,粤系房企,负债规模100亿,2021年9月宣告破产。

21、蓝光,川渝房企,负债规模约2000亿,2021年5月中期票据违约,宣告暴雷,目前逾期未偿还债务已达300亿。

22、阳光100,老牌房企,负债规模约400亿,2021年8月债券违约,宣告暴雷。

23、德润创展,深圳房企,负债20亿,2021年8月宣告破产。

24、广州粤泰,粤系房企,负债规模80亿,2021年8月宣告破产。

25、宝能地产,深圳房企,负债规模2000亿,2021年8月理财产品逾期,宣告暴雷。

26、实地,粤系房企,负债规模约200亿,2021年7月商票拒付,宣告暴雷。

27、三盛宏业,上海房企,负债规模约500亿,2019年10月员工理财未兑付,宣告暴雷,公司老板失踪,被法院悬赏1000万。

28、福晟,闽系房企,负债规模约700亿,2019年12月3亿基金违约兑付,宣告暴雷。

29、泰禾,闽系房企,负债规模约2000亿,2020年7月债券违约,宣告暴雷,目前逾期未偿还债务已达430亿。

30、卓达地产,北方房企,负债规模300亿,2018年开始,卓达24次被列入被执行人,此外还有7起股权冻结,涉及金额约9.14亿。

这30家房企的负债总规模是7.48万亿

also, https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.redd.it%2F%...

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by yorwba on Monday January 29, 2024 @05:10PM (#39183428)
Thanks, I much prefer text over video anyway, and now even people who can't read Chinese can join in on the fun, though Google Translate struggles a bit with the 暴雷 slang https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%E6%9A%B4%E9%9B%B7#Verb
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by cdf on Monday January 29, 2024 @09:42PM (#39185787)
I'm an overseas Chinese and can read Chinese but not keeping up with modern slang and 暴雷 means to me what you see in the translation... a thunderbolt?
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by resolutebat on Monday January 29, 2024 @11:05PM (#39186285)
暴⫽雷 (verb-object)

to default on a large scale; to fail to repay the loan or deposit of many creditors or clients

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by hmm37 on Monday January 29, 2024 @08:55PM (#39185485)
How did you conclude points 2 and 3 from this data?
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by NoboruWataya on Monday January 29, 2024 @07:10PM (#39184585)
> Why did it take Evergrande 3 years to liquidate? In western countries, liquidation happens in a few months.

No they don't, not for entities of any significant scale or complexity. Lehman Brothers was still in liquidation as of 2022: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bankruptcy_of_Lehman_Brothers

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by berserk1010 on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @01:31AM (#39187015)
I mean 3 years to start liquidation. Lehman brother's liquidation started on 9/19/2008, a few days after it filed for bankruptcy on 9/15/2008. https://www.sipc.org/news-and-media/news-releases/20220928
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by hmm37 on Monday January 29, 2024 @08:42PM (#39185382)
Do you have any education in finance, securities, law, economics, etc.?

E.g. Your Edit stating that China banned short selling. They didn't ban short selling. They banned borrowing of shares that are "restricted" to short sell.

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by giva on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @09:44AM (#39190625)
I'm quoting wikipedia here:

> There are a number of ways of achieving a short position. The most fundamental method is "physical" selling short or short-selling, which involves borrowing assets (often securities such as shares or bonds) and selling them. The investor will later purchase the same number of the same type of securities in order to return them to the lender. If the price has fallen in the meantime, the investor will have made a profit equal to the difference.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Short_(finance)

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by doughnutstracks on Monday January 29, 2024 @09:43PM (#39185794)
Are you Chinese? I examined your posting history and noticed a pronounced bias against China.
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by berserk1010 on Monday January 29, 2024 @11:18PM (#39186357)
Depends, are you one of those overseas Chinese police that threatens Chinese citizens abroad with their families' life in China unless they cooperate and stay silent on social media?

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-65305415

https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/two-arrested-operating-illega...

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by doughnutstracks on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @01:30AM (#39187010)
No I'm not. I'm just asking if you have first-hand experience with the Chinese regime or if your aversion comes from somewhere else.

You indiscriminately share links from the internet, including sinophobic YouTube videos, to reinforce your arguments. However, when presented with a counterargument supported by similar sources such as the IMF or other news outlets, you dismiss it as CCP lies.

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by pertymcpert on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @01:54AM (#39187127)
All of what they said isn't very controversial. Which part did you disagree with so vehemently that you decided to stalk their profile?
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by doughnutstracks on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @07:34AM (#39189364)
Over the last few years on HN, I've observed an increase in posts expressing a negative bias towards China. These posts consistently echo similar concerns with every distressing news about Evergrande or China. Occasionally, these accounts intentionally flout guidelines by using their profile for ideological battles [1].

Admittedly, I could have framed the question more politely about the origins of his aversion.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35254063

Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by bllguo on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @03:14PM (#39195120)
if you're actually interested in reality, that it's not controversial to a western crowd predisposed to sinophobic sentiment is precisely what should be setting alarms off
Re:Evergrande, once China's biggest property developer, orde... by powerapple on Sunday February 04, 2024 @01:52PM (#39253137)
I have to disagree with Haidilao comment, which I have visited several times in different cities, it is packed with people, when people queuing outside, and I don't see the price is cheaper than previous year.

Maybe when prices have dropped if they are converted into dollars. I am not sure should we use dollars to measure everything to should I use Yuan for China.