News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by HumblyTossed on Monday January 29, 2024 @12:38PM (#39179301)
Air Force pays goooood[0].

But seriously:

>> but then we're thinking: 'How do we lift the plane? How do we salvage it?'"

Don't. Just leave it. Be happy it was found, but just be respectful and leave it.

[0] Yes, I RTFA.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by s_dev on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:13PM (#39179901)
>Don't. Just leave it. Be happy it was found, but just be respectful and leave it.

I don't see anything inherently disrespectful about rasing the plane from the seabed. I recall people telling James Cameron that he should leave the Titanic alone but he made a great movie and brought the ship back in to the public imagination and didn't disrespect the fact many souls were lost tragically. The ship was deemed not economically viable to salvage but this plane is much much smaller and it may be worth putting in a museum.

I'm presuming you are offended on behalf of other people but if not can you elaborate why you find the idea so offensive or disrespectful?

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by aeturnum on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:26PM (#39180153)
> I recall people telling James Cameron that he should leave the Titanic alone

I think HumblyTossed is suggesting this group do exactly what Cameron did: investigate and document but not remove. If this is Earhart's plane, it's probably also her grave. We generally frown on disturbing the resting places of the dead for commercial purposes.

What "worth" do you see in placing it in a museum?

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by cortesoft on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:10PM (#39180925)
> If this is Earhart's plane, it's probably also her grave.

Only because no one knew where she was to bury her properly.

I assume you don't say that we shouldn't recover bodies from ANY plane crash; most people would expect bodies to be moved from a plane crash to be buried properly.

Why is this one different? The length of time it took to find the crash, I assume. So how long before we can't move the body because it is a grave? 3 months? A year? 10 years?

I don't think I would consider this a grave, and recovering the body and burying it properly is not grave robbing.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by aeturnum on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:44PM (#39181407)
That's super fair - I think recovery and reburial is probably a respectful option. My impression is that our decisions about what to do with human remains often relies on finding a living member of the family to speak about preferences. To go back to the titanic example - I don't know of any families who agitated to have the remains in the ship reburied. One of the ways this situation is different is that there would be no ambiguity about remain identification.

> I don't think I would consider this a grave

If by not a "grave" you mean not an "intentional burial site" I agree. But it would be a final resting place and, to the question I was answering ("why would people object") that's a thing that people care about being handled with the proper care and consideration.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by cortesoft on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:20PM (#39181923)
Yeah, this one is always a tricky topic for me because I have literally zero emotional response to human remains and really don't care at all what is done with my remains or the remains of my loved ones. Once a person is dead, the body is just random matter to me.

Trying to guess how other people would feel about things is a complete academic exercise in this case for me.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by bogantech on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:49PM (#39182356)
There are no bodies to recover. The crabs ate them long ago
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by jncfhnb on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:34PM (#39180291)
We don’t frown on that at all, nor do we apply any sacred virtue to graves comprised of accidental wrecks.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by executive on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:32PM (#39180255)
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by malermeister on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:47PM (#39180519)
While I agree with you, there's sarcophagi in museums all over the world.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by markstos on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:56PM (#39180692)
And on the tour these days, you are more likely to year "Yeah, maybe we shouldn't have moved it".
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by lmm on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:59PM (#39183305)
> What "worth" do you see in placing it in a museum?

The same value as anything else in a museum? It's historically important, and also really cool, the kind of thing that inspires kids and even adults.

(I saw Halifax W1048 at an impressionable age and am very glad I did)

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by HumblyTossed on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:23PM (#39180086)
Because there's little to be gained save morbid curiosity. She did amazing things alive, celebrate that. Putting a wreck in a museum will emphasize her death.

Enjoy disagreeing...

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:28PM (#39180192)
That’s such an odd opinion. Her death is already emphasized whenever the disappearance is mentioned because it’s super interesting. Being concerned that someone who died doing something interesting will have their death emphasized is just super weird imo. Everyone in history is dead.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by HumblyTossed on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:42PM (#39180438)
Her disappearance is emphasized. Her death is not. There is a difference.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:51PM (#39180615)
But like, who cares? It kinda just doesn’t seem like a big deal to me. I really don’t get it.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by TylerE on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:26PM (#39180148)
The big problem with Titanic is how deep it is. Very, even by ocean standards.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by tomjakubowski on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:33PM (#39180286)
Titanic (12,500ft) is pretty close to average ocean depth (12,080ft).
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by TylerE on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:50PM (#39180593)
The Pacific is several thousand feet deeper on average than the Atlantic, though. Especially the parts of the Atlantic near the US mainland are quite shallow, with the continental shelf extending outwards well offshore. I guess it would have been more accurate to say that for a ship in the major Atlantic shipping lanes, Titanic is quite deep.

Even looking for Titanic was a cover story in the first place. They were actually looking for a sunken Russian sub that was sorta in the area. It was only when they had a bit of left over time at the end of the mission that they ACTUALLY found Titanic, almost accidentally.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by not-my-account on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:03PM (#39179733)
If we raise it, it will almost certainly end up in a museum where many many people will see it and connect with Earhart and her story. Earhart would near deification, I’d guess. Plus the inspiration of many young boys and girls to adventure. I don’t quite see where the lack of respect would come from. Or, if it is disrespectful to raise the crash, that disrespect would be repaid many times over with honour in a museum, no?
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by digging on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:11PM (#39179862)
> Earhart would near deification, I’d guess.

Let's not get hyperbolic. She's already well known. Agreed though that displaying her plane in a museum would seem respectful to me.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by VBprogrammer on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:05PM (#39180837)
I can't imagine what would be recovered of a crash of a light aluminium aircraft after a century at the bottom of the ocean would bear much resemblance to an aircraft.

I think it's a great thing to locate and document the discovery but I don't see much to be gained from raising it.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by GolfPopper on Monday January 29, 2024 @07:37PM (#39184841)
Plus, it would be a violation of the Benthic Treaty with the Deep Ones.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by jncfhnb on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:36PM (#39180324)
Frankly I think her story is a bit less inspiring without the mystery
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by whartung on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:17PM (#39181023)
Indeed. Just leave it.

Document it, photograph it, leave it.

There's no reason to lift it, to "restore it", etc.

It's a wreck. Leave it alone.

Go find a "modern" Electra, and make that as "close to Earharts" plane for your display. But there's no reason to drag this thing up.

If this plane were shot down, it would be considered a war grave and left untouched. No reason to not treat this the same.

Rejoice if she has, indeed, been found. Peace for the families, finally.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by paulddraper on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:21PM (#39180043)
> just be respectful

IDK if littering wrecks is more respectful than putting them in a museum.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by whycome on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:14PM (#39179918)
Good use case for Apple Vision Pro, etc. Capture the plane in situ and then have it available to view as an AR model (at home, or in a 'museum' space). Let users 'walk' or 'swim' around the wreck.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by TylerE on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:29PM (#39180214)
No so sure. Titanic is essentially unique, her two sisters not lasting much longer, the last going to the scrappers in 1935.

There were quite a few model 10 Electras built. Over a dozen survive, with several still flying. The Earhart museum already has a 10E, even.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by Cthulhu_ on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:19PM (#39179999)
It looks like there's something similar for the Titanic already, so, not a weird suggestion to make.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by jdawg777 on Monday January 29, 2024 @12:58PM (#39179644)
Salvaging the plane could give interesting clues about what led to the crash.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by poulsbohemian on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:31PM (#39181238)
Every time Earhart is mentioned here, someone pops up with authoritative info that she and Noonan were not well prepared / equipment was faulty / more Hollywood salesmanship than navigation skills / that island was always going to be a stretch on gas... point being that while in the collective memory they are heroes, my lay understanding is that scholarship on the subject has already determined there were major problems with their flight plan
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by filleduchaos on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:16PM (#39181870)
It's been several decades in saltwater at unbelievable pressure - I somehow doubt that.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by HumblyTossed on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:24PM (#39180108)
That's just morbid curiosity...
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by quatrefoil on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:48PM (#39180545)
I find it odd to see geeks, on a site essentially devoted to idle curiosity, speaking out against idle curiosity.

There is value in showing respect for the dead, mostly for the benefit of those near death and the grieving families, but the arguments made here seem weird to me. Do we seal homes and turn them into tombs when a person dies inside? Do we leave car wrecks on the side of the road?

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by alpaca128 on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:35PM (#39181292)
Curiosity is great but that doesn't mean it should always take priority. Would it be nice to know how that plane crashed? Sure, but we also figured out how the Titanic sank without lifting it out of the water.

> Do we leave car wrecks on the side of the road?

No, but we also don't need 80 years to find car wrecks on the side of the road, and there are various reasons to remove them. This comparison is ridiculous.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by lp0_on_fire on Monday January 29, 2024 @04:40PM (#39183074)
I think the "risks" of disturbing a grave site are greater than any "rewards" for doing it.

A home in which someone died can be used again by another person after proper cleaning and what not. Wrecks on the side of the road are usually removed because they are a danger to other motorists.

In the case of Earhart's plane the air frame and navigation systems are 75ish years out of date so it's not like there is a pressing need to solve a potential safety issue. IMO there is nothing of value to be gained besides "solving the mystery" and perhaps gathering a few personal artifacts that could be displayed in a museum or returned to the families.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by quatrefoil on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @01:28AM (#39186999)
And nothing of practical consequence is learned from exploring the tombs in Egypt. We might be able to decipher some tidbits about everyday life thousands of years ago, but one would be hard-pressed to explain what tangible benefits it offers, beyond "well, it's a part of our heritage / it's cool to know". Just like many other human activities, it's glorified idle curiosity.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by genocidicbunny on Monday January 29, 2024 @06:57PM (#39184470)
> Do we leave car wrecks on the side of the road?

If they get lost for 80+ years, yeah, we do. There's a state park not far from me that has a trail that uses an old highway's right of way for a bit. The highway is long long gone, but if you look down from the trail into the gully nearby, you can still make out a few rusting hulks of cars from the 1920's and 1930's that went off the road and were just left there.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by deadbabe on Monday January 29, 2024 @12:49PM (#39179478)
It can be raised respectfully.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by yardstick on Monday January 29, 2024 @12:55PM (#39179590)
Probably can. Should it though?

Like the Titanic, maybe we just let it rest in peace? Send a sub down to confirm what it is. Then maybe update a few of the monuments to her to indicate her final resting place has been found…

My only concern would be looters. If it is quite feasible to access “easily” then yeah maybe we should recover it just to protect against looters and pillagers.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by Kon-Peki on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:07PM (#39179805)
It appears that there would be significant questions about ownership and whether maritime salvage laws apply [1]. Remember that Earhart was a faculty member at Purdue University, the aircraft was owned by the university, and it was filled with student experiments. They're going to claim that it still belongs to them. You're going to spend millions to recover it and then immediately get hit with a lawsuit demanding you turn it over to them. By an entity that will have no problem collecting enough donations to fund the best lawyers for as long as it takes.

[1] https://www.perthilj.com/blog/2019/2/19/aircraft-salvage-in-...

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by reaperman on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:47PM (#39181463)
Seems like a situation where it would be best to get all parties with any claim that wouldn’t be summarily dismissed to agree on details of what should happen with the salvage before committing to recovering it.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by MeImCounting on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:40PM (#39180392)
Aside from the practicality of the two, the Earheart wreck seems much more like something our society would want to honor. An explorer and adventurer who's legacy and life pushed equality forward for women across the west vs a failed engineering project which was mostly a status symbol for rich people.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by not-my-account on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:04PM (#39179753)
The titanic is massssive, making raising it a much more difficult challenge compared to raising a single aircraft.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by notbeuller on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:45PM (#39181429)
There was a rather silly 1976 thriller “Raise the Titanic!” predating it’s actual discovery by about 10 years. They made a movie from it too in 1980. Based on a premise that there was something valuable the government wanted on board)
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by RegBarclay on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:59PM (#39181631)
Then Arthur Clarke wrote "The Ghost from the Grand Banks" in 1990 (after Ballard discovered it was in pieces) with a slightly more plausible approach to raising the bow. The wreck has deteriorated now to the point where raising it would probably destroy more than what would be recovered.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by paulddraper on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:22PM (#39180057)
If it were a feasible to raise the Titanic as a small aircraft, it would have been done.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by stronglikedan on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:16PM (#39179946)
> Should it though?

Yes, it's a plane not a person. We can learn from it, and Earhart won't care.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by yardstick on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @12:32AM (#39186693)
What could we learn from taking it out of the water vs leaving it in its grave?

There will be no FAA safety notices (or whatever they are called) based on the findings.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by deadbabe on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:10PM (#39179844)
Yes absolutely, there’s no reason for the plane to rest at the bottom of an ocean forever. The bottom of the ocean is the opposite of rest, it’s hell.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by Beldin on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:46PM (#39181442)
To you, there's no reason. To others, there is. That by itself shows the need for discussion (where either side ought to listen to the other).

With respect to the argument of putting the plane rests in a museum: I do not see how that would be better than being able to visit the actual place where the crash occurred, with the plane still somewhere below the waves.

Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by deadbabe on Monday January 29, 2024 @03:08PM (#39181769)
The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by yardstick on Tuesday January 30, 2024 @01:51PM (#39194045)
What are the needs of the many here? And are they really needs, or just nice to haves?
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by dclowd9901 on Monday January 29, 2024 @02:27PM (#39181155)
Looters are exactly why we should raise it. Protect it from unscrupulous people.
Re:An Air Force officer who spent $11M searching Earhart's p... by cozzyd on Monday January 29, 2024 @01:34PM (#39180288)
Yeah, but then amateur submariners can't offer expensive tours in their homebuilt craft.