As for comfort wearing this for extended periods of time, we'll have to see. I think that will be the key deciding factor. There was a lot of marketing speak in the original announcement suggesting that they did work quite hard on this issue and made some progress. A light enough device that can provide the experience of having a ginormous screen in front of your nose without inducing headaches, motion sickness, etc. could be a nice thing to have. If somebody delivers such a thing, people will be reluctant to turn them off possibly.
As for replacing existing things, there's a long history of people thinking about new products in terms of how the old one worked. The more interesting question to ask is what new content will emerge for this thing.
Is this great? It's a market, maybe, but it is it one we want to incentivize and grow?
Increasingly I feel like we, as an industry, lean too hard into providing lesser-resistance substitutes for mentally and socially healthier lifestyles, and that "we are not making the choice for them, the root problem has to be solved somewhere else" is a cop-out.
The massive amount of effort we spend on boyfriend/girlfriend replacement tech, meet-up-with-friends replacement tech, experience-interesting-places replacement tech is starting to worry me.
At least, it's hard to get for people who don't happen to already be at the top of some empire.
It can certainly be done at an unhealthy level but you can say that about a lot of things.
If it is bad, then you'd have to discourage things like reading books. And I guess, depending on what you think is wrong with it, maybe discourage other mainly solitary pursuits.
Why on earth not? Reading books is solitary. Programming is usually solitary. A lot of hobbies are solitary.
But you can watch a show on your own and then talk about it the next day with your friends.
I think it's very simple. If this thing works more or less as advertised, lots of people might buy it. I don't think it's a given Apple has another winner here but I wouldn't exclude the possibility. And I was kind of impressed with what they announced last year.
I also see the appeal for people who travel a lot for work. This is probably an amazing way to watch movies on a plane or in your hotel room at night.
I have a wife and two small kids, so I will not be buying this to watch movies at home.
I feel like this entire thread has a blind spot to the fact that this device is very much a luxury item. A 55-inch TV is ~$300. A high-end laptop is ~$1000. High-end noise-cancelling headphones are ~$250. You could buy all of those and still not reach half of the cost of this device.
The only people I can see buying the device are rich people looking for another toy, not as a serious competitor to other entertainment tech.
I'm surprised at how consistently people think that a technology that is so expensive and serving such a niche will end up having adoption asides from a few wealthy enthusiasts. iPhone 2 suggested retail price was $300 (~$425 in todays dollars) and provided "smart" replacement for your cell phone matching its features 1-to-1 while also providing more than what was available.
If someone imagines themselves buying this to watch movies "on the go" or at hotels or something, they're part of an extremely exclusive club.
Meta is selling hundreds of thousands of units a month, so I don't know if I'd say no one wants it either. It seems to be selling pretty well overall, but Meta way overinvested in some of the stuff and is having a hard time making enough money.
Just because one device is from Apple doesn't make media consumption any more virtuous or productive.
This was back when most phones were still carrier subsidized and required long term service contracts. Per Apple's press release, the $299 pricing required "a new two year contract with AT&T". Unsubsidized price was about double.
https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2008/06/09Apple-Introduces-th...
Even if you have a lot of space in your apartment, it's hard to justify much of a home theater setup, as you will be really limited by sound issues.
Nobody is buying the Pro version of the headset just for watching movies other than the early adopters, YouTubers etc we have today.
The idea is that when a normal version launches for $999 it will be a far more compelling proposition.
It seems like you need to live alone and be rich enough to afford it such that you likely already have a great home theater anyway and still be interested in the Vision Pro. Or you actually don't want a TV at all for some reason but still want a home theater experience.
That seems like a quite small market?
Most people who rent also move at least every few years, so having that large of a thing to move is a bit annoying. Not even mentioning people who travel for work and obviously cannot bring such a system with them.
It isn’t just all about the money when it comes to device purchases.
Seems quite a few folks are opting to randomly binge-stream on their laptop as vegging out on the TV is a thing of the past for them, so no need to have their living space dominated by these types of electronics.
The appeal of the laptop/tablet/phone veg is the speed at which you can plop and start watching. Futzing with VR headset is kinda not that.
The "personal home theater!" angle has been tried, and failed, so many times now. It doesn't seem like the Vision Pro changes anything to suddenly make it a motivating feature on its own. Which I think is the more telling thing about Netflix's response here. They've been pushing VR movie watching since day 1. And yet now they aren't doing so for the AVP. That seems less likely to be a snub of Apple and more likely to be an admission of "this just isn't something people do or want currently"
I have a Quest 3, and I would much rather watch movies on a laptop or iPad than it. The screen quality is not great. You can see the pixels due to the low-ish resolution. The contrast ratio is not great.
The screen quality is generally good enough for VR games and other VR-specific experiences, however.
Netflix's engineering staff is expensive and I imagine they learned some interesting lessons from experiments like Bandersnatch. No need to make bets for the sake of innovation, let things play out first. I'm sure there is some signaling involved for the sake of investors showing they're prudent here.
All I'm saying is - to your point - the market may be shifting to where personal consumption devices like this make sense. It's not replacing a TV so much as a laptop.
For some early adopters the experience may be far superior, and if so, a next generation device that cuts the cost and size in half may be the thing that launches things forward. Like the iPhone 3G.
Or it could be sort of a wash and go the way of the 3d TV craze from 15 years ago.
If I was into media enough to spend $3,500 to have a great experience, it would be a bummer if I couldn't watch a movie with someone else occasionally.
Or if you're both into the big screen VR experience, you can both wear headsets. Watching movies in a shared virtual movie theater is already a thing and works great. Even better is that you can be in your home and your romantic partner can be in their home (or traveling) and you can still watch together.
For the low low price of 7000$, vs 1000$ for a TV.
Obviously for the Vision we'll wait for prices to come down.
There's one use case that I do think I would actually use once it's good enough though. It's using glasses as replacement for computer monitors when doing work. But I'd prefer the Nreal/Xreal Air form factor and price point.
My inner VR enthusiast thinks the Apple Vision is cool but my inner realist wonders if anyone is really going to use anything beyond smart glasses.
My personal prediction - smart glasses as a smartphone replacement, AR/VR headsets as a poweruser workstation machine replacement.
The market segments map out nicely with your prediction as well - almost everyone has a smartphone of some kind (just like i expect almost everyone to have some sort of smart glasses in the future), while a relative minority (even though it is a large one) has poweruser workstation machines (just like with AR/VR headsets in my prediction).
That is, until at least the tech gets insane enough to allow packing full functionality of an AR/VR headset into the form factor of glasses, with an insane battery life to boot. I don’t see that happening in any foreseeable future though, sadly, barring some transformational and unexpected battery chemistry breakthroughs.
I still struggle with seeing smart glasses as a viable smartphone replacement unless paired with some sort of peripheral to perform input privately. Doing everything by voice or expressive gestures around others isn't going to work for people.
I agree, for now we have no good or even barely established UX/HCI paradigms for hypothetical standalone AR glasses.
Not that we even have those types of paradigms established for currently existing AR/VR devices, but we are getting there slowly. With each year since I first tried the original HTC Vive, every new device and update slowly but surely made the interactions better, simpler, and feel more “worked out”.
What gives me hope is seeing how the touch-only UIs have changed since the original iPhone release. At first, everyone was scoffing big time at touch-only interfaces ever becoming functional, viable, and widely used. The first third party apps on the App Store were also extremely disjointed and had almost nothing in common between each other in terms of UI/UX. Felt like everything was just spliced together and stamped with “we think this should work.” Not casting shade at devs of those apps, everyone was in that position back then, as there were no established UI/UX for touch-only interface smartphones.
In 2024? While there are still continuing changes, things slowed down overall as the general cohesive UI/UX principles for touch-only smartphones have been established. And they indeed became functional, viable, and widely used devices.
Btw, pretty much every AR/VR headset I am aware of these days already supports bluetooth controllers and keyboards. For some keyboard models, you can even have them visible and physically tracked in your VR space (I tried it with Quest 2 and apple’s wireless keyboard, worked like a charm).
Keyboards in VR are really bad, and the AVP also doesn't have any ideas there (looking at keys one by one and pinching is extremely "peck and hunt").
The closest to a magic AR solution I can think of is tracking so obscenely great that you can project a touch keyboard on a screenless slab without annoyance. Maybe.
Unless you approximate smartphone typing speeds, silently, it's not going to be a smartphone replacement for any masses.
In fact, this might be a great use for Zeiss's holocam tech [0]: high resolution, low definition, grayscale "window" that waveguides some of the light passing through, down to one of the edges, where an image sensor picks it up and decides it.
It's not that far fetched if you move most of the hardware to a fanny pack or similar. You can probably get pretty close with current smart glasses (or Bigscreen Beyond) and a (next gen) Steam Deck.
The AVP is vastly overpriced and overspecced for basic media consumption.
For that price you can get 3 of your friends a nice 1080p short throw projector and studio monitors which will outlive the vision pro and won't cause neck/head pain after an hour.
Still my wife watches her stuff on a phone.
People actually don't care about quality more often than not.
But the quest 3 should be cheap enough already for this and good enough and still is not the mass market
I'd be surprised if anyone thought the Quest 3 didn't render sharp text. I find everything very readable.
We'll have to see how people handle 1.5lbs of headgear for long periods. Maybe it'll be fine, but the Quest is already heavy enough.
I'm a bit like you. I don't watch TV by myself, and the idea of plugging into a VR device to do so seems weird.
But I carry my AirPods everywhere and mostly listen to music solo. It's not unreasonable to think that the same happens with TV/movies.
I still get Dolby Atmos and Dolby Vision on both devices and with iPad being much closer than TV screen size is alright.
People that watch movies on their phones and smaller ipads are wild. I tried watching movies on Quest 2 - too bulky.
(Particularly for kids, of course, which isn't a market that works well with the $4k price of the current Vision Pro. But a hypothetical cheaper future generation...)
I'll admit that some of my perspective here comes from being extremely not a TV-watcher, so "the social joy of watching a show" mostly fails to motivate me. :D
It's also the lets-play-a-2-player-game-on-the-couch console!
For me a killer app needs to make use of the AR capabilities of the headset to justify the cost.
I suspect there will be a larger portion of people who have both a Vision Pro and a television, and use the Vision Pro for some portion of their viewing.
The "replaces TV" is likely a mental connection between the cost of a higher end TV and the cost of a higher end AR headset being in a similar range where media consumption is a major feature of both. One could maybe justify the price of a 85" OLED or justify the price of a Vision Pro, but not both.
But a lot of people watch a lot of TV solo.
And headsets are actually extremely comfortable for binge-watching because you can lie back in your reclining chair or lie totally flat on your bed or long couch. You just drag the virtual screen up to your ceiling. You can also loosen the headband in these cases.
There's no reason to sit upright for viewing unless you want to.
But I was specifically responding to the article which opens with this quote by Om Malik:
>With that caveat, I think both, the big (TV) and biggest (movie theater) screens are going to go the way of the DVD. We could replace those with a singular, more personal screen — that will sit on our face. Yes, virtual reality headsets are essentially the television and theaters of the future.
And the rest of the article lays out a mostly supporting case with the missing apps argument.
The scary thing is that noone is better equipped to achieve this dystopian goal than Apple, already entering the space with a fully protected walled garden...
If I'd be Netflix (or even Disney), I wouldn't rush to support such a future...
And that’s after you buy a VP for you, your partner and your 2.2 children… only $14,000!
There's a very clear cultural divide here. You missed a very important point in TFA:
> If you live in Asia, like you live in Taiwan, people don’t have big homes, they don’t have 85-inch screen televisions. Plus, you have six, seven, eight people living in the same house, they don’t get screen time to watch things so they watch everything on their phone.
(Emphasis mine.)
Basically, the point is that watching TV in VR will probably be very popular in Asian markets.
Just using it for consumption is also very unimaginative.
I look forward to seeing developers explore the potential of spacial interactions that are different than just strapping a 2d display on your head.
It might not be as good as sharing real popcorn, but it can be a surprisingly convincing imitation.
[1] https://store.steampowered.com/app/457550/Bigscreen_Beta/
We played a few flat (not VR) games, on a super large screen in a cozy virtual room, with directional audio that is always on. With your attention being taken on what is happening within the game, it's -almost- as convincing as sitting together and playing the same game.
I can already say that this is my favourite way of playing couch co-op remotely. Haven't tried movies, yet I wouldn't expect the experience to be any different.
The phrase I kept hearing from film studio/director types was that they didn't know how to tell a story with VR that could only be told with VR (profitably). Note that didn't stop them from trying and there wasn't a shortage of ideas. The point was that they hadn't figured out what would actually resonate with audiences (and make more money than doing what they already knew).
But things are different now. Back then, the problem was that VR in your home was a dead-end. What seemed promising was using it for theme park rides and people at Universal/Disney were super excited about it. So the "story" they were trying to design was something that was mass marketable with IP tie-ins, short enough not to tire the average American and maximize throughput while also minimizing floor space in the places they'd install. That's a very different kind of experience than a film or video game.
I think with cheaper/lighter hardware the profit model could be different and the kind of content you consume with it would become different. I don't think people have figured it out yet, but with hardware changes there's a different kind of story that can work and it just needs the right storyteller to figure it out.
All that said, the problem all these tech bro led companies forget is that content is king in this space and you can't just make some cool gizmo and expect people to buy it when no one knows how to create for it. For all their flaws, Magic Leap was actually smarter about that than their competition.
This was my exact same complaint within my group creating VR content around the same time. Gaming is a no-brainer. It was the live action that was the blocker. Directors want to control the narrative with various techniques like blocking, depth of field, framing, etc. Within VR, all of that control is lost. Within VR means that it is possible the viewer isn't even looking in the right direction as the director intended. Putting the camera in motion is weird for the viewer since the viewer did not initiate it (unless it was something obvious like being in a car/roller coaster/etc).
But a lot of filmmakers don't want to make video games, and finding new answers to that question is something that VR struggles with today.
Part of me flippantly says that most directors are making nothing but a demo of a video game since it's all CG anyways.
Another part of me says this is also where the generative AI characters will not be something a traditional director will even be interested in. Part of being a director is working with actors and getting them to deliver the performance they want. There are different types of directors, and the type that are an "actor's" director will not be interested in it at all. Those that are more technical and just want tech to tell a cool story might be interested since it takes that weird human interaction out of the equation.
There's live theater too. Could be an interesting way to experience front-row tickets for a play. But what could AVP provide that a live play couldn't? Maybe putting the viewer in the middle of the stage, but it would be a pain to keep rotating to witness the action.
That's also ignoring the artistic issues with convincing actors/directors to design and conduct performances for audiences in a completely new way, which is the problem I was alluding to earlier.
> Maybe putting the viewer in the middle of the stage, but it would be a pain to keep rotating to witness the action.
This has been done before (I've even been to a few local productions where this is the norm) but you have to keep in mind the production is designed for the venue its performed in and where the audience is located.
I think there's a kind of theater production where you could use VR as a tool to a lot of success but I think the work has to be written for it, a production team that's down with it, a cast that can be trained to do it, and pricing model that makes it profitable.
It's a very hard problem domain that isn't technical. It's artistic, social, and economic.
---
I think ballet would be a much better fit than theater, for what its worth.
I see that kind of thing having a window of opportunity between when it is possible and when everybody has an XR headset and there is nothing special about it. The slower XR is to catch on, the wider the window.
You're not far off, the industry buzzword is "LBE" for "location based experiences." There was a startup that was killed by COVID/mismanagement called the Void that was building some great LBE stuff with tie-ins to Disney IP (Star Wars, Marvel, etc) and had locations in their parks.
There is definitely a market for it, and even "cheap" LBE like escape rooms have kind of proven that there's a market for entertainment that works like a ride.
But: the iPhone did replace the rotatry phone! /s
Going out to eat at restaurants used to be a social activity, now people just sit together but stare at their phones.
I may be an outlier but in our house the only time we watch shows or movies is a social context--usually Friday or Saturday nights as a family. I'm struggling to see how the headset could replace what is in my experience a mostly social activity.
Will it ever be comfortable enough for the binge watcher to watch it all day? I have my doubts.
I think it will be a coexistence and replacement of flat screens will be a very long time away.