In a conversation with Phaedrus, Socrates worries that writing could impair human memory, as people depend on written words instead of recalling information. [0]
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phaedrus_(dialogue)#Discussion...
The question is will we one day have tools so powerful, that the human is vestigial, and tool (without human) is just as powerful and cheaper than tool (+ human)?
AI might replace it.
Writing "replaced" some forms of intellectual effort.
And it's yet to be seen how AI will play out.
I find that it is true that new mediums and new technologies for language have a numbing effect on certain senses and an amplification of others.
Writing is beneficial in one regard but does have an impact on memory. Epic poems of great length were memorized in their entirety, a skill that would be a lot easier to develop in a world without writing.
Not without a solid result establishing so. But good luck with this, you'd probably need to compare our world with internet and a similar enough world but without it, which does not exist.
In any case, internet can't be reduced to "tiktok et al"
In already developed countries the Flynn effect seems to be reversing, ie IQ is leveling off or even dropping.
It's basically impossible to improve an adult's g-factor, for example. For children, things like nutrition and hygiene (e.g. no parasites) play a big role. But the kinds of things a human learns or tools they use doesn't significantly affect G-factor.
Many other mass produced products we buy today are clearly lower quality than ones crafted by artisans 50 years ago, and yet they do what we need them to do at a fraction of the cost.
I think that's a sweeping generalization. For example, it's much better to have a bunch of food that's mostly garbage than to have a famine where all food is super high quality. There were points in history where this choice was made (obviously unconsciously because the choice is too obvious to even think about). Other examples abound.
Technology often makes things much cheaper while reducing quality. Sometimes that's bad, sometimes it's great.
Like any idea about squishy human brains and its products it remains to be seen and can’t be as easily proven as for example research in Physics.
I would say current research has a probability of 50% of being correct at best.
https://blogs.ubc.ca/etec540sept13/2013/09/29/socrates-writi...
This coupled with an broad interest in just about anything means I can often help people far outside my specific field, usually rather swiftly as well.
Qanon was purely a creation of the internet. Now go take a look at how many people believe one, many or all of the various Qanon alternative facts.
They don't prove that it makes people dumber. You have to quantify and qualify people and to define "dumb".
Maybe people are not actually dumber because of the internet, but the internet is very good at spreading ideas, including incredibly dumb ones, especially (because of how human beings work) those likely to cause feeling of outrage.
Maybe people are not dumber, just too defenseless against the scale of bullshit they are faced with because of the internet. Maybe internet is an incredibly good tool, but strongly requires good learning / training of critical thinking and there's not enough of this yet.
It's hard to argue that nowadays people believe more crazy stuff than before the internet was invented. (It's very easy, of course, to claim this, as many like to do.)
Taking into account that such blunt statements always hide a lot of nuances, this seems to capture the reality.
Every tool has this trade-off, and the existence of skills that will be lost is not evidence that the tool will do more harm than good. I don't think anyone here would argue that Socrates was correct that writing would be the end of memory and wisdom.
> To [Thamus] came Theuth and showed his inventions ... when they came to letters, "This,* said Theuth, "will make the Egyptians wiser and give them better memories; it is a specific both for the memory and for the wit."
> Thamus replied: "O most ingenious Theuth, the parent or inventor of an art is not always the best judge of the utility or inutility of his own inventions to the users of them. And in this instance, you who are the father of letters, from a paternal love of your own children have been led to attribute to them a quality which they cannot have; for this discovery of yours will create forgetfulness in the learners' souls, because they will not use their memories; they will trust to the external written characters and not remember of themselves. The specific which you have discovered is an aid not to memory, but to reminiscence, and you give your disciples not truth, but only the semblance of truth; they will be hearers of many things and will have learned nothing; they will appear to be omniscient and will generally know nothing; they will be tiresome company, having the show of wisdom without the reality."
None of this really happened. I mostly use editor tools to automate away tedium that doesn't matter; I type "log.Inf<TAB>" and it adds "src/internal/log" as an import at the top of the file and types the o and open parenthesis for me. I have not forgotten how to do that myself, but it saves me a couple seconds. Calculators didn't really make people dumber, though I have to say that a lot of arithmetic I learned in elementary school did make me dumber ("touch math" was the killer for me; slows me down every time I do arithmetic in my head; I need some brainwashing program that deletes that from my brain). Spell check didn't make people worse at spelling; spelling things wrong still has a penalty (C-w to kill the last word and spell it correctly), so the incentive is to still to lurn how to spel wrds rite. Zoom meetings didn't ruin the corporate world; I personally found them very helpful for memorizing people's names with a high degree of certainty. You see it under their face for 40 minutes at a time, and you learn it fast. In real life, probably takes me a few weeks for people I only see once a week. So, honestly a benefit for me.
The current state of AI seems very similar to these technologies. I did a copilot free trial (and didn't renew it). With the free trial I think there were a couple things it was good at. One time I wanted a CPU profile for my app, so I just asked the AI to type it in. Open a file, check for an error, start profiling to the file, stop profiling, close the file. Would have taken me a minute or two to type in, but Copilot typed it in instantly. I also did something like "do the same as the function above, but for a YAML file instead of a JSON file". Again, super trivial to type in that code, it's really only one line, but the AI can handle that just fine in an instant. I don't really think it's more than slightly smarter IntelliSense, but without any access to the compiler toolchain, so it can sometimes just hallucinate stuff that doesn't exist.
I've found this to be kind of an interesting way to proofread documents and design APIs. Give ChatGPT a document you're working on, and then ask questions about it. If it gets the wrong answer, then your doc is no good! Similarly, ask it how to write some code using your new API (without showing it the API). Whatever it writes should be the surface area of your API. This avenue is pretty interesting to me, and it's not replacing humans, it's just a smarter rubber duckie.
Overall, I think we're in a little bit of a hype phase with AI. I look at it kind of like a dog that has read every book, if such a thing were possible. Pretty smart, but not quite human yet. As a result, it's not going to do well in the areas where people really want to apply it; customer service, insurance claims, loan underwriting, etc. But it is pretty good for asking questions like "does my document make sense" or "please find some boilerplate to cut-n-paste here, I am going to delete this before checking in anyway". Also not too bad at slightly modifying copyrighted images ;)
And as we zoom out and think more farther into the future, I see it getting much worse. If AI is really doing all the "hard stuff", then the general human incentive to learn and do them at all quickly treads to 0. This isn't going to be everyone, I think some people will absolutely become "10x developers" or the equivalent for other domains. But all this will result in is more inequity, in my naïve view. The universe has a fundamental property that things move from higher energy states into lower ones. From a human POV, I think you could apply a similar idea, if the need to be smart quickly recedes, then in general we may degrade unaugmented human collective intelligence over time.
I don't know, maybe we'll figure something out to make it much easier to learn and ingest new concepts, but it seems more and more to me that the high obstacles for human brains learning things (with poor memory) is too big a bottleneck to overcome any time soon.