The line of thinking is that if Israel is subject to international courts/laws regarding genocide for its action, then China will be too. China's participation in judging Israel opens itself to the same judgement.
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Territorial_disputes_in_the_So...
I don't see folks buying that, sorry. In international realpolitik you play the cards you have and if your rival opens themselves up for criticism you play it.
Rhetoric trumps logic in this one.
It's flawed thinking because PRC can't be legally attacked the same way.
Plurality of UN sentiments has already, repeatedly sided with PRC on Uyghur/XJ as internal counter terrorism measure, and not genocide. Crimes against humanity maybe, but all the US/west driven efforts to get it recognized as genocide has failed.
Same PRC actions in SCS. PRC not party to the optional arbituation system in UNCLOS. And there's no legal mechanism under UNCLOS to determine sovereignty. The PCA ruling is not actually international law, recognized by UNCLOS or UN. PRC doesn't have to worry about UNCLOS/ITLOS ruling against it in SCS because they legally can't.
Sure there might be rhetorical damage, but not potential legal damage under UN the same way Israel, party to genocide convention, would legally be, if ICJ decides they are doing/did a genocide. Legal damage in this case, being actual diplomatic damage, i.e. mandetory sanctions against countries who are genociding, which pro-Israel countries will of course ignore, suffering reputational damage in turn, or domestic damage if it's within their domestic laws to obey ICJ ruling on genocide and they choose to ignore.
However, situations like this, in which rhetoric and de jure policy conflict with de facto reality, open one up to others taking the fiction at face value. And what do you do then? Can't deny it without causing other problems. So now this may be regarded as an international matter because Gaza "isn't part of Israel".
China officially recognizes the state of Palestine.
The Isreali supreme court itself has determined that Gaza is not Isreali territory.
An Israeli court can say what it wants, but can't have it both ways.
The supreme court has jurisdiction over actions taken by the Isreali government, regardless of where those actions take place.
Additionally china's military currently has big corruption problems (e.g. the missle fuel water controversy). I doubt china really wants to put their reputation on the line until they sort that out, especially given what happened to russia in ukraine.
I'm also unsure if this move would be seen well domestically. They have enough problems right now, and focusing resources on this doesn't sound like it would be met with high praise.
They would simply be stepping into the role on the world stage the US and other Western countries have fulfilled for the last few decades. Israel probably wouldn't be foolish enough to attack them, and their allies definitely wouldn't aid them.
And in the unlikely event Israel does attack their humanitarian convoy, it would only give China an opportunity to do some live-fire practice and score extra points on the world stage as the innocent defender.
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/interactive/2023/china-...
This made me chuckle :-) "Let's dip our toes into solving international conflicts with an easy one, like the Israeli / Palestine conflict!"
This would NEVER happen.
"At least two-thirds of the world’s top 50 container ports are owned by the Chinese or supported by Chinese investments, up from roughly 20% a decade ago."[1]
[1] https://www.freightwaves.com/news/experts-warn-of-chinas-inf...
However, they have nothing to lose and everything to gain by brokering some kind of peace using their supply chain supremacy.
Meanwhile US looks more and more like a paper tiger because they can't stop Yemen from blockading Israeli shipments and also refusing to do the one thing that would resolve the shipping issues: force Israel to the table for a ceasefire.
Chinese warships will never be allowed anywhere near the Mediterranean in the first place - if there is one thing that even the split US Congress will agree on, it is that China already has too much influence and that they need to be stopped.
Additionally, China's army hasn't seen actual combat in a loooong time. It's likely that their army is in just as bad of a shape as Russia's is, and getting that demonstrated on the world stage before they have a chance to snack a piece or the whole of Taiwan would be pretty foolish.
There have been Chinese navy visits to the Mediterranean. You can sail in on international water. (Edit: Nope, it's to narrow)
"Chinese naval ships visit Morocco"
http://eng.chinamil.com.cn/CHINA_209163/Exchanges/News_20918...
You cannot get into the Mediterranean without passing through territorial waters.
Grabbing for straws: "Chinese naval escort taskforce visits Tunisia"
http://eng.chinamil.com.cn/CHINA_209163/TopStories_209189/79...
The United States has not ratified UNCLOS, and regularly claims the right of Transit Passage. In fact, this fact is one of the reasons why Iran claims that the United States cannot enter into Iranian TTW while making a Strait of Hormuz transit - because the US has not ratified UNCLOS, their claim is that the US cannot claim transit passage. For the United States (or any Western Nation) to make the claim that China cannot claim Transit Passage would lend weight to Iran's argument, which you can imagine, they would not want to do.
I do not want to make any assumptions around your specific views on this matter - you may hold the opinion that China could not claim transit passage, however I wanted to interject some perspective that:
1. That may not be universally agreed upon 2. Specifically, the United States and it's allies may not make that argument because it would put them in a negative position for other international disputes.
PRC actions in SCS is not legally against UNCLOS. Reality is, everything PRC does currently in SCS is legally grey area until UNCLOS/ITLOS/UN actually rule against it in official capacity. PCA ruling is essentially a term paper on official looking letterhead drafted by anti PRC lawfare, pretending to be international law. It's one (strong) legal interpretation, but it's not settled case under UNCLOS - UN (which UNCLOS law operates under) does not recognize or comment on PCA ruling.
Sorry but this is goofy fan-fiction. No, China does not have the ability to forcibly land in Gaza without huge losses, and then being completely trapped there with no hope of resupply. That's an incredibly long supply line.
Their only chance would be to make a bet that attacking them would be politically unacceptable.
Does Israel have the stones for direct airstrike on Chinese fleet? It’s gonna get messy. It’s a big game of chicken, I am not sure who I would bet on.
Israel could (and probably would) prevent the fleet from delivering the aid even without help from the US.
In support of your "If China decides to send humanitarian relief to Gaza, China can do it, and Israel can't stop them," you link to a description of a ship designed for an invasion of an island 85 miles off China's coast, an invasion which China (correctly IMO) calculates would probably end in failure (or else it would've invaded by now).
Israel can't challenge China militarily in, e.g., the Pacific, but it is a wealthy competent state that takes security seriously.
Gaza has a sizable coastline, and China has a large number of amphibious assault ships available. They can defend themselves against Israel air attacks. If China decides to send humanitarian relief to Gaza, China can do it, and Israel can't stop them.[3] China would look like the good guys. Which their leadership knows.
[1] https://www.foreignaffairs.com/china/chinas-game-gaza
[2] https://edition.cnn.com/middleeast/live-news/israel-hamas-wa...
[3] https://www.newsweek.com/china-amphibious-assault-ship-type-...