News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ICJ Orders Israel to Prevent Genocide Without Cease-Fire by biorach on Friday January 26, 2024 @02:18PM (#39146826)
This seems far fetched given China's traditional insistence that countries' internal affairs should not be subject to external overview, it's undeclared stance that subject populations should be suppressed by whatever means necessary and the still marginal effect of the conflict on its trade.
Re:ICJ Orders Israel to Prevent Genocide Without Cease-Fire by loceng on Friday January 26, 2024 @02:44PM (#39147174)
Good cop, bad cop theatre of what I call the establishment division.
Re:ICJ Orders Israel to Prevent Genocide Without Cease-Fire by shkkmo on Friday January 26, 2024 @02:29PM (#39146973)
I don't see how military operations outside of a country's legal territory is considered an "internal affair"
Re:ICJ Orders Israel to Prevent Genocide Without Cease-Fire by kelseyfrog on Friday January 26, 2024 @02:42PM (#39147151)
I believe parent was referring to the Uyghur genocide[1] not the Territorial disputes in the South China Sea[2].

The line of thinking is that if Israel is subject to international courts/laws regarding genocide for its action, then China will be too. China's participation in judging Israel opens itself to the same judgement.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uyghur_genocide

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Territorial_disputes_in_the_So...

Re:ICJ Orders Israel to Prevent Genocide Without Cease-Fire by The_Colonel on Friday January 26, 2024 @03:45PM (#39148037)
That line of thinking doesn't make sense since Xinjiang is part of China while Gaza isn't part of Israel. One is a domestic question, the other isn't (going by the international recognition).
Re:ICJ Orders Israel to Prevent Genocide Without Cease-Fire by kelseyfrog on Friday January 26, 2024 @04:01PM (#39148281)
China: But this is a Domestic issue!

I don't see folks buying that, sorry. In international realpolitik you play the cards you have and if your rival opens themselves up for criticism you play it.

Rhetoric trumps logic in this one.

Re:ICJ Orders Israel to Prevent Genocide Without Cease-Fire by maxglute on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:53PM (#39149936)
>opens itself to the same judgement

It's flawed thinking because PRC can't be legally attacked the same way.

Plurality of UN sentiments has already, repeatedly sided with PRC on Uyghur/XJ as internal counter terrorism measure, and not genocide. Crimes against humanity maybe, but all the US/west driven efforts to get it recognized as genocide has failed.

Same PRC actions in SCS. PRC not party to the optional arbituation system in UNCLOS. And there's no legal mechanism under UNCLOS to determine sovereignty. The PCA ruling is not actually international law, recognized by UNCLOS or UN. PRC doesn't have to worry about UNCLOS/ITLOS ruling against it in SCS because they legally can't.

Sure there might be rhetorical damage, but not potential legal damage under UN the same way Israel, party to genocide convention, would legally be, if ICJ decides they are doing/did a genocide. Legal damage in this case, being actual diplomatic damage, i.e. mandetory sanctions against countries who are genociding, which pro-Israel countries will of course ignore, suffering reputational damage in turn, or domestic damage if it's within their domestic laws to obey ICJ ruling on genocide and they choose to ignore.

Re:ICJ Orders Israel to Prevent Genocide Without Cease-Fire by falserum on Friday January 26, 2024 @02:33PM (#39147028)
Gaza is kind of/maybe/sometimes/by some considered part ofisrael.
Re:ICJ Orders Israel to Prevent Genocide Without Cease-Fire by wharvle on Friday January 26, 2024 @02:55PM (#39147340)
The notion that Gaza's more than some variety of closely-held protectorate is either aspirational or a convenient fiction, depending on who's stating it. They aren't even close to having a level of control over their own territory and affairs to be considered a sovereign state. Hell, the West Bank also can't credibly be called a sovereign state, taking into account only facts on the ground and observed behavior, and not what officials say. In some respects US tribal nations have more actual sovereignty, in ways that matter, even though they definitely aren't sovereign states, from an international relations perspective, and functionally nobody treats their tribal territory as meaningfully distinct from that of the US as a whole, in these contexts.

However, situations like this, in which rhetoric and de jure policy conflict with de facto reality, open one up to others taking the fiction at face value. And what do you do then? Can't deny it without causing other problems. So now this may be regarded as an international matter because Gaza "isn't part of Israel".

Re:ICJ Orders Israel to Prevent Genocide Without Cease-Fire by lostdog on Friday January 26, 2024 @03:27PM (#39147790)
Gaza is more tightly held than Taiwan.
Re:ICJ Orders Israel to Prevent Genocide Without Cease-Fire by wharvle on Friday January 26, 2024 @03:49PM (#39148087)
Heh—that, for fuckin' sure. The fiction there runs the opposite direction, where China pretends (and encourages others to pretend) that Taiwan's less independent than it is, meanwhile just about everyone acts like Taiwan's in fact very much distinct and independent from China, even if they say otherwise.
Re:ICJ Orders Israel to Prevent Genocide Without Cease-Fire by shkkmo on Friday January 26, 2024 @02:46PM (#39147205)
No, it isn't.

China officially recognizes the state of Palestine.

The Isreali supreme court itself has determined that Gaza is not Isreali territory.

Re:ICJ Orders Israel to Prevent Genocide Without Cease-Fire by Sporktacular on Friday January 26, 2024 @03:51PM (#39148129)
Then it has no legitimate say over the affairs of Gaza.

An Israeli court can say what it wants, but can't have it both ways.

Re:ICJ Orders Israel to Prevent Genocide Without Cease-Fire by shkkmo on Friday January 26, 2024 @04:43PM (#39148918)
That's nonsense.

The supreme court has jurisdiction over actions taken by the Isreali government, regardless of where those actions take place.

Re:ICJ Orders Israel to Prevent Genocide Without Cease-Fire by Sporktacular on Friday January 26, 2024 @07:11PM (#39150736)
It adjudicates the actions taken by all Israelis. Its jurisdiction should stop at the border it recognises. But it continues however to award land outside Israeli territory to Israeli citizens by ruling on the status of settlements. That is extra-territoriality.