My understanding is that the people that were breached were breached outside 23andMe, and their credentials were simply used to log into 23andMe. Not attachking you or anything but haven't you opted in to sharing potentially sensitive information to people you don't know, basically making this information as secure as these people's accounts are? Or, for that matter, as secure as these people are?
Perhaps they could highlight that a bit more (I wouldn't think of that probably if I used this feature). But that's just as much "just" a mistake as "just using a feature".
One thing reading Hacker News has made clear is that people have wildly differing opinions of what "sensitive" and "risky" mean.
I have a personal domain with a catch all configured. So back then I would just give a name like adobe.com@<personal-domain>.
When they leaked my password I contacted their support and they flatly told me that's not them who lost the password, even though evidently the mail itself was tailored specifically for Adobe.
It is likely the support was told to follow a script when a concerned client contacts them and there is no way they are going to tell you anything else regardless of the specifics of your case or how absurd their arguments are.
A small search surfaces a lot of gene banks which store human and non-human DNA. Use your favorite search engine for this.
Generally submissions are done with patients' consent, but I'm not very sure that some of the blood samples are directed to national private databases for countries' own use and research.
The reasons doesn't have to be nefarious. Knowing your population's genetic weaknesses is a good way to defend it, and having access to a wide pool allows a deeper understanding of genetic conditions and how genetic therapies are working.
Also, earlier comments than mine already cited how law enforcement in US is already using this as evidence.
I'm an ordinary person. I don't have access to more information than you do.
> Which governments are you referring to?
Any that has an intelligence service. (And probably most others too.)
> And how are they doing this?
They get the data from breaches like this or otherwise purchased from services like this.
> And how do you know of this?
I’d suspect less that they know and more that they have a reasonable suspicion. I personally have that suspicion because 1) it’s feasible and 2) governments would be interested in the data.
https://www.masslive.com/news/2024/01/how-to-get-a-free-gene...
https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/dna-from-genealogy-site-used-t....
Also, the government keeps all DNA from people arrested (not convicted) for anything
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/your-dna-police-database-...
one of these is not like the other
It's easy to throw out cynical opinions. It's also easy to come along later and say "I _knew_ this would happen"
If one outcome is 99% likely and the other 1%, the intelligent thing is choosing the 99% likelihood, but that still means that sometimes the person making the bad choice was right.
That doesn't make them intelligent, it makes them lucky.
At least part of the issue is not informing people of the risk they're taking by using the feature. That doesn't make for good business, though
"After further review, we have identified your DNA Relatives profile as one that was impacted in this incident. Specifically, there was unauthorized access to one or more 23andMe accounts that were connected to you through DNA Relatives. As a result, the DNA Relatives profile information you provided in this feature was exposed to the threat actor."
So there's nothing I could have done with password security that would have prevented this; my only mistake was using a feature of their site.