News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @06:39AM (#39116141)
Fire the board and put an actual engineer in the CEO seat until the company gets fixed. The wrong culture of people are in charge and until this is addressed substantively there won’t be change.

Radical action is required or the company could be destroyed.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by maeln on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:52AM (#39116667)
For me this argument always made 0 sense. Dennis Muilenburg was a engineer through and through, and he did pretty much all his career at Boeing. But this is during his time as CEO that all the previous issues with the 737 Max arose, which led to him being fired. You want an engineer CEO, you got one and it didn't help anything.

Because that's not what a CEO does in any case. At this level of management, especially in those huge company, you are so far removed from the craft that it is really irrelevant if you have any experience in it.

I think, it is way more important to look at the actual owner of Boeing and its general environment. Boeing is now mostly owned by big institutional investment firm [0], and they are the one who choose the CEO.

Boeing is also one of the most insanely protected company in the U.S. Whatever Boeing does, the U.S government will always be here to make sure Boeing stays dominant and make life very difficult for any competitor.

The situation with the 737 Max was actually a good example where the FAA and the U.S Govt was again very lenient with Boeing, and just gave them a slap on the wrist. So if you were the owner of such company, why not abuse this amount of protection ? Why not push for the maximum profitability at the cost of quality ?

If Boeing received more than just a slap in the wrist for the previous 737 Max fuck-up, they would be way more inclined to reevaluate their whole quality process and make sure no incident every happen.

[0] https://www.investopedia.com/articles/insights/052116/top-3-...

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:08AM (#39116827)
The point is that Quality flows from the top down. If the people on top of the organization don't take it seriously, then it's hard for the actual working engineers to get the support they need to do their jobs. Having an engineer as the CEO at least makes it likely that that person understands what is needed and makes it happen.

It's not a guarantee, but I'd trust an engineering organization with an engineer at the helm a lot more than someone with a sales background.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by beAbU on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:30AM (#39117073)
The point of the previous poster stands. They /had/ an engineer CEO and that did not mean shit.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:49AM (#39117309)
Maybe. This whole program and its failures mostly goes back to choices made by McNerney.

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/01/23/opinion/boeing-737max-ala...

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by fuzzfactor on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:05AM (#39118156)
You could say that obviously most engineering types are not good enough to run an engineering company.

But that wouldn't be true, in reality almost nobody is good enough to run an engineering company.

Having an engineer type sure improves your odds compared to general business practitioners, though.

It may be like unobtainium but if you had your choice of engineers at an aircraft company you can't do better than one whose mathematical ability puts general business leaders to shame, and who started out building planes at an early age and hasn't forgotten how for their entire career. In fact only gotten better by focusing so strongly on the finances that directly contribute to the most reliable aircraft that can be produced. Even then some will still crash. As we have seen, it's lots better without the temptation to be distracted by the general business trends that come and go, which encourage little manipulations of large resources in ways that any negative outcomes, unforseen or not, will be pushed far enough into the future for decision-makers to have fully cashed out before that time.

The worst you could do is have somebody who has never participated in aircraft design, assembly, and maintenance allowed into the chain of command anywhere between the entry-level engineers and the top decision makers.

It should go without saying that natural leadership ability has got to be there for it to be sensible for someone to move up the chain of command, but also it needs to be fully rewarding for highly skilled engineers to prosper progressively without having to be very near the ladder that has to be climbed leading to executive duties.

As each decade goes by and people overall settle more and more for having non-leaders in leadership positions, you can't expect things to ever be the same in any way unless this pervasive defect can be reversed.

It didn't get this way overnight and it can't be fixed overnight.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by unethical_ban on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:49AM (#39117945)
To reframe the point the parent made: Boeing is a special case due to the fact that those above the CEO are uniquely institutional (large investment) and the company enjoys a level of "socialized failure protection" from the US government that few other companies get.

At least other companies that get cushy treatment from the US government often have more competition, like GM.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by lupire on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:49AM (#39117955)
The CEO laid off half the Quality org. That's direct involvement.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by stanrivers on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:54AM (#39118003)
I think this accountability is a good point… if someone told me absent any other information that a company had the issues Boeing has been having, then I would assume they get shut down or forced into a restructured management with hugely increased regulatory oversight.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @03:18PM (#39122121)
> Because that's not what a CEO does in any case. At this level of management, especially in those huge company, you are so far removed from the craft that it is really irrelevant if you have any experience in it.

An engineer CEO is going to value different things than a non-engineer CEO.

If your anecdote says anything it's more about where is the pressure coming from that caused an engineer CEO to behave like a non-engineer?

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by maeln on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @03:39PM (#39122349)
> An engineer CEO is going to value different things than a non-engineer CEO.

And why exactly ?

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by fragmede on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @03:47PM (#39122434)
this hypothetical engineer-CEO is going to put a lot more stock in what the engineers are saying, so even if it'll cost a lot of money, reducing profits, the engineer-ceo is going to say we're not not launch until the engineers say it is good to go. The MBA CEO is going to say the engineers are stupid, they don't know the whole picture, they're going to bankrupt the company, and we're going to launch anyway.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @05:48PM (#39123679)
you're being hyperbolic, but the underlying idea is correct.

The thing is, most everyone understood what I meant, this other person is just trying to play ignorant.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by maeln on Thursday January 25, 2024 @03:26AM (#39127430)
No, I am just putting into question this seemingly undeniable claim that someone who happen to have been an engineer in their career would somehow end up being a more engineer focused CEO. This naively would make sense, but does it actually have any factual weight ? There is so many counter argument to this. Becoming a CEO, from an engineering start, usually involve spending a lot of your career in higher management. At this point, why would you be more sensible to the engineer issues, than the higher management/board/owner ? Climbing the ladder also require at some point to satisfy the requirement of non-engineer, shifting you own goal if what you aim is to be at the top of the ladder. Having an engineer past doesn't guarantee at all that you will listen to engineer more once you have climb the ladder.

People just want to continue to create this weird tension between engineer and business people, both trying to act as if they are much better than the other at handling a company, when in actuality, it is the collaboration of both which is successful, and some of the best company manage to harness exactly this.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Friday January 26, 2024 @05:14AM (#39140890)
> People just want to continue to create this weird tension between engineer and business people

because there _is_ tension between business and technical people.

a business person can walk into a room and through charm and sheer force of will get what they want. No amount of charm will ever find and fix that bug.

It's a fundamentally different approach to the world, hence why they clash so often and why an engineer turned CEO is going to act vastly different than business person turned CEO.

and just as clearly, what a CEO values matters or they wouldn't be paid so much because they could be replaced by anyone otherwise.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by meepmorp on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @03:53PM (#39122497)
Jack Welch had a PhD in chemical engineering.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by jillesvangurp on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:20AM (#39116956)
Two planes crashed. That's four years ago and that was root caused to a single issue which has since been addressed. Before that the 737 had a great safety record. In fact it still does. Not perfect but pretty amazing considering it's the most widely use plane ever produced. After that there have been a few incidents, including the non fatal one with the door. But nothing out of the ordinary.

Here's a list of all the incidents with the 737 over the years.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_accidents_and_incident...

If anything, this decade is looking pretty good so far.

I'm not saying there's nothing going on at Boeing in terms of management and quality control. But hadn't it been for the issues a few years ago, this would barely register in the news as anything else than the minor incident this was. But because that was in the news, now any Boeing related news is causing world + dog to panic. And that apparently includes FAA leadership and management at major airlines. They are apparently more worried about how it reflects on them than about the actual facts.

I think the grounding of the aircraft has much more to do with politics and appearances than with actual safety. It was premature and probably overkill. People insisting on expensive audits and other draconian measures have basically persuaded the FAA to do what they otherwise wouldn't dream of doing: ground loads of planes over an issue that can probably be excluded with a simple, straightforward inspection. There hasn't been a lot of detail about what exactly went wrong. Nobody waited for that to be revealed even. But I bet it's something straight forward like a missing bolt or something similarly easy to check and verify.

If you are an airline and you own anything even mildly resembling a 737 and you haven't at this point checked if the bloody doors are fine, you should not be operating planes at all. At least, claiming ignorance after all the attention in the news is not a thing. You shouldn't be waiting for the FAA to tell you to do this as it's both obvious and you are responsible for your fleet.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by snapcaster on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:40AM (#39117197)
On one hand I agree with you that people are likely overreacting, but i disagree that anyone is acting irrationally. Boeing has lost _all_ credibility amongst the public and we're not all aviation experts so we don't know that a 4-bolt-gap is fine or whatever their current issue is.

>But hadn't it been for the issues a few years ago

By "issues" you mean hundreds of people being killed by a known manufacturing/training issue? Where does your faith in these people come from?

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by jillesvangurp on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:22AM (#39117647)
> Where does your faith in these people come from?

The unchanged safety record. Yes, it's tragic when planes crash. Thankfully it's not happening a lot. And as I've argued, it actually seems safer than ever.

People seem to insist there are all sorts of issues with Boeing. Except that doesn't seem to be translating into a major increase in accidents or incidents. So, the attention and paranoia seems a bit over the top. People who know nothing whatsoever about any of this calling for CEOs and boards to be fired and the FAA to do this or that.

You know what's not happening? A lot of pilots, mechanics, airlines, etc. reporting doors with the same issue. Just not a thing. And all of them are aware and looking. That's 100% guaranteed. Nobody needs to be told to start looking. These doors are probably safer than they've ever been because world+dog has been looking at them for the last few weeks.

This article is about an airline finding loose bolts. That's a serious issue of course. Exactly the kind of thing an inspector should notice on countless inspections that happen to planes throughout their life. There are of course many bolts in airplanes and torquing them correctly kind of is a big deal to the point where companies are keeping detailed records about who torqued them, when, and how strongly.

Airlines are doing exactly what they are supposed to be doing: inspecting their airplanes on the off chance there might be something wrong. I expect most pilots would also care to look at the door panel in question when they do their routine inspection of the plane before taking off. I know I would; and I'm not even a pilot. Maybe not in depth and just a cursory glance. But they'd be aware and on the lookout for trouble. After all, it's their job to make sure the plane is safe before taking off. This mentality is ingrained in the aviation industry. Which is why safety records are so good. It's rare for something this bad to go unnoticed.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by hughesjj on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @04:59PM (#39123132)
> The unchanged safety record.

What do you specifically mean by this?

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:08AM (#39117496)
I thought Mr. Travis’s write up was excellent about what some of the issues are, and why they are different in this series (max program variants).

https://spectrum.ieee.org/how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-lo...

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by spydum on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:11AM (#39116353)
People busting on the past and current CEOs, and for sure they deserve it.. however in my experience, many of these decisions happen at the board level. The Boeing board of directors need to be replaced, and held accountable for allowing quality measure to drop (for whatever the cause: outsourcing or pure cost cutting/staff skills). But instead, as is so common in corporate politics, we pick a figure head like the CEO to be sacrificed, while the root problems don't get solved.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by stingraycharles on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:29AM (#39116478)
The parent you’re replying to started his statement with “fire the board”. So I think they are agreeing with you.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:11AM (#39116849)
Don’t forget the CEO overseeing this program was his own chairman of the board at the time all this got started.

https://www.cnn.com/2019/10/12/business/boeing-ceo-chairman-...

I emphatically agree with you about it being a board first, CEO also situation, but when the CEO is also in charge of the board it’s difficult to see how effective second guessing of a CEO’s decision can reliably happen.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by cedws on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:09AM (#39116835)
This is how capitalism works, right? Public companies are under a constant squeeze. Profit, profit, profit. Growth, growth, growth. If the CEO doesn't deliver they get removed and the board simply installs a new one. The growth machine must never stop, even at the expense of employees and customers.

Experienced, knowledgeable employees costing too much? Get rid of them. Q2 profits fell short of expectations? Hike the prices. Supplier too expensive? Find another one.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by mhb on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:53AM (#39117346)
Exactly. Let's get the Antonov, Ilyushin, and Tupolevs into the US skies!
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by croes on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:19AM (#39116406)
>we pick a figure head like the CEO to be sacrificed

Isn't that the reason why they earn so much money because they "take" the risks?

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by Sebb767 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:33AM (#39116511)
The point being made here is that sacrificing the CEO does not solve the problems in the company and is completely unrelated to their pay.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by bsuvc on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:47AM (#39116624)
It does solve the problem.

Leaders need be held accountable, not to fix the past, but so that other leaders will make better decisions in the future.

In this case, it is a lesson that if you destroy your engineering culture and sacrifice quality, you will lose your job.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by sseveran on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:53AM (#39116674)
They had an engineer as CEO. That one did not work out.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennis_Muilenburg

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by passwordoops on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @06:44AM (#39116174)
And criminal negligence charges. There needs to be a solid message sent to the quarterly-bonus profiteers
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by ChatGTP on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @06:53AM (#39116232)
Boeing is in bed with the DOD, this is never going to happen.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by passwordoops on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:01AM (#39116293)
Not necessarily. The moment these issues hit critical systems you'll see a change. DoD officials have already sounded the alarm on monopoly in general:

https://www.defenseone.com/business/2021/02/hicks-warns-agai...

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by willcipriano on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:09AM (#39116346)
The DoD has lost trillions of dollars of equipment.

They will rattle sabers until their grandson gets a no show job.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by lovich on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:24AM (#39117005)
Billions I might believe over their history. Trillions id need to see some evidence of. Especially if “lost” is including combat losses
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by willcipriano on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:26AM (#39117022)
https://breakingdefense.com/2023/11/with-trillions-at-play-p...

Billions were lost just in the humvees that were gifted to the Taliban recently.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by nebula8804 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:46PM (#39121109)
There has got to be some way to fix this problem. How is it that as a society we have collectively built up so much bureaucracy and bloat that causes this?
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by lovich on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @06:43PM (#39124212)
It literally wasn’t worth it to return? I might have a biased view of this site but I thought we were mostly engineers who understood how complicated a “simple” change could be. Logistics for physical goods is hard enough for coordinating moving items from a factory to a front which is order -> chaos. Moving from a war front back to storage is going from chaos -> order and significantly harder.

Either way, still not trillions to my original point

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by j16sdiz on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:08AM (#39116339)
Can't see why not.

Charging a single person in boeing is not the same as bringing down the whole company

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @06:57AM (#39116264)
I don't think you need an engineer as CEO for that. Might on the margins help but other things such as ability to change processes or reporting lines might matter more.

If you want cultural change you need a CEO that wants that and knows how to get there - which is not an engineering problem.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:14AM (#39116377)
Friend, as a software engineer who’s become a CEO I can’t disagree with you more.

The traditional culture of CEOs in the western world isn’t healthy: it’s top down focus and focus on pushing down responsibility and departmental compartmentalization tends to create a lot of the problems the very same management theory fancies itself to solve.

Having an actual “buck stops with me” CEO who has experience in the trenches and not managing other people to get the results that would reassure the market and has been shown to work very well in company after company.

First principles and the culture of questioning need to be nurtured by competent leaders, and not MBA lead presentations and check in meetings for progress. Sleeping in the factory until this situation is fixed is what needs to happen and it is not this board and management team.

Also, this is a board issue first, a CEO issue second.

Of course: I’m biased.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:16AM (#39116388)
That is not really related to my point unless you want to say that engineer CEOs are intrinsically better/not susceptible to bad culture etc.

I have worked with great, bad, and middling CEOs and I would not say that it comes down to their degree background where they place in the spectrum of quality. Not having experience in managing other people but only some sort of trench experience will likely fail at a place of the size and complexity.

A lot what you describe is more like poor management.

And, yes, there is a big role for the board to play.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by brigadier132 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:24AM (#39116448)
> unless you want to say that engineer CEOs are intrinsically better/not susceptible to bad culture etc

Yes, that's what we are all saying.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:54AM (#39116685)
With evidence. Of the top performing companies in 2018:

> 32 have an MBA, up from 29 last year. 34 have an engineering degree, up from 32 last year.

It has shifted further in this direction since, especially with 2020.

https://hbr.org/2018/11/the-best-performing-ceos-in-the-worl...

Edit: the point has been made. Please do some of your own research rather than constantly sea lioning.

https://www.quora.com/What-is-it-called-when-someone-keeps-a...

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:03AM (#39116773)
How many have law degrees? The majority of CEOs in the top 100 were not engineers it seems. And performance is stock performance/TSR, if I understand correctly.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:26AM (#39116460)
Then show the evidence. This feels like a testable hypothesis.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by brigadier132 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:43AM (#39116587)
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:57AM (#39116712)
That just compares MBAs and engineers (not sure what happens if someone has both), not the many other non-engineer educations CEOs can have (law, mathematics, physics, ...). MBA is quite US centric.

Also, performance measures play a role.

I found this, for example, which says there is no relationship: https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2011/06/18/does-ceo-educatio...

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by st-keller on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:07AM (#39116334)
„Cultural change is not an engineering problem“ - cannot count how often i heared this. But if you want to have an „engineering culture“ - let an engineer handle it! But why would anyone whish to hange to said „engineering culture“ if no engineer is around?
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:15AM (#39116380)
Why would it need to be an "engineering culture" as opposed to, for example, a "quality culture"? And even if you want to former, why does it need an engineer to create that culture? Does a good movie director also need to be a good writer or actor?
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by ehvatum on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:07AM (#39116825)
Because building planes is an engineering task.

Let’s use your argument: Would you hire a lawyer to captain a ship? Why not? It’s not like the captain actually steers the ship or oils the engine.

You see? It’s not that hard to think a tiny tiny little bit.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:12AM (#39116854)
The CEO is building a plane? The head of a shipping company builds ships or captains a ship?
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:27AM (#39117035)
No it’s the executives role to set the culture and nurture the concerns of quality that are lacking in this organization. And quality is a product engineering attribute and a product of manufacturing concerns being powerful enough within an organization to be addressed, so I was making the suggestion that perhaps an engineer should be in the seat until the problem is remedied.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:34AM (#39117121)
Lots of other disciplines care about quality.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:52AM (#39117331)
Lots of other disciplines are irrelevant when you’re talking about actual aircraft manufacturing and not the soft concept of quality.

Edit: aircraft engineering organizations require an executive that understands the airline market and how to build airplanes. This company in particular needs a fixer to address quality problems and reassure the market that substantive changes to the quality of manufacturing will be made.

An expert in toy manufacturing who ran Mattel shouldn’t be overseeing jet aircraft production and this idea that they can do so effectively is a big part of the reason companies continually fall down on manufacturing quality and flame out like GE, HP, and now Boeing are doing. Sorry. This idea that a CEO without a background in aerospace can just fly in and fix everything because of transferrable skills sounds good but it’s just simply not true and in fact is the exact and very specific management theory and corporate ideology that is the root cause of the problems at the core issues this company is experiencing*.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:09AM (#39117500)
There is nothing soft about quality in producing pharmaceuticals, for example.

I'd say there are number of industries and backgrounds a "quality in production" CEO could come from.

Edit: I even agree with need to understand the market and manufacturing, but it could come from being an engineer, a physicist, a mathematician etc.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by fuzzfactor on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:38PM (#39121000)
For these type of job hops many fundamental quality principles carry forward, but each is a whole new ball game when you got into it. Also for instance with pharmaceuticals as well as fuels you still use the exact same models of the latest spectrometers and chromatographs, so specialized expertise here carries over ideally but that is just the instrument, not the particular science being conducted.

What it comes down to is that someone with decades of experience in pharma can be useful in the fuel lab and vice versa, but it still takes years to get up to speed before the wisest decisions can be made since either way this type of thing is not soft about quality. That much it shares with aircraft reliability.

It takes a certain type of leadership to prevail in a situation like Boeing (and many others) did during World War II, and this has been so sorely lost by now that there is very little remaining linkage back to the real thing.

And while I'm here don't ask me how I know the airline companies' fuel is tested as reliably as their fuselages, and by a bureau with management hierarchy having a degree of dedication that's noticeably more modern than what was once expected in the past.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by jpalawaga on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:34AM (#39118532)
what did ballmer do at microsoft before he was CEO? What did microsoft look like after he became CEO?

Same questions, but with Satya. There's a reason Apple strongly prefers to hire from within. Actually, you could ask the same questions about jobs and cook.

You need to live and breathe the company. Further, the executive's background WILL play a role in the company's direction.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by hughesjj on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @05:02PM (#39123167)
I don't think the pedigree matters as much as for the leadership of a company to really know their product and market. I don't think that ex Boeing engineer turned ex Boeing CEO really knew their product given how absurd the procedures sounded to pilots around mcas and now with this de-icing issue.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by jsharf on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:30AM (#39116481)
I assume it’s easier to find an engineer who went to engineering school to learn how to build airplanes that are safe than it is to find an MBA who went to business school to learn how to build planes that are safe. (It’s not about the knowledge but about the root desire)

Similarly, I assume it’s harder to find an engineer who went into the field purely for money.

I do think on average engineers will prioritize safety (since they likely understand failure modes and production and long tail statistics better. We literally have to take engineering ethics classes), at the cost of doing a worse job at running the business. But when the business requires this level of safety, that IS doing a good job.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:36AM (#39116526)
You need to be able to steer a large and complex organisation - being an engineer has nothing to do with that. And, yes, incentives matter, but those can be set.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:28AM (#39117046)
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:35AM (#39117134)
No. This just says some engineers can (like some MBAs). There is no intrinsic link between being an engineer and being a great CEO. Most engineers are not executives.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:03AM (#39117453)
This argument relies on false equivalence and isn’t even rational.

Except top executives are engineering degree holders. They are, and that’s a fact. The majority of top performing companies are headed by engineering degree holding CEOs.

But you keep making the same wrong points and trying to play devils advocate on positions that you don’t back up.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:19AM (#39117613)
You are wrong. A plurality is, but not majority (https://hbr.org/2018/11/the-best-performing-ceos-in-the-worl...).

If you want to claim an intrinsic link between being an engineer and being a top performing CEO, you need to show something different anyway. For example, that the proportion of engineers that are great CEOs is higher than the proportion of MBAs or lawyers or chemist or ... that are great CEOs. Maybe that is true, but I haven't seen it. Edit: we could also look at a narrower problem, for example: is the performance of engineer CEOs in "engineering companies" better on average than that of non-engineer CEOs in that sector?

I am not saying engineers cannot be good CEOs, just that the link between being an engineer and a good CEO is (probably) not intrinsic.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:56AM (#39118844)
I never claimed an intrinsic link.

I’ve already established higher performance in the many replies I have given to your many comments.

Have a great day!

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:26AM (#39119228)
You earlier claimed there is an intrinsic link:

"If you have a great executive ticking all the boxes - splendid. But there is no intrinsic link between being an engineer and being a good CEO (same holds for other disciplines, btw.). You could have engineers that qualify, lawyers, MBAs, mathematicians, physicists, ...

reply

happytiger 2 hours ago | root | parent | next [–]

There is. You’re flat out incorrect."

You never established higher performance.

Have a great day

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by vegetablepotpie on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:41AM (#39116566)
Not who you’re responding to, but I agree with the notion that if you want an engineering culture, you need an engineer at the top.

Engineering is one of the few fields that understands value. Most other functions, within a corporation, are more process oriented and have a more transactional world view as a consequence of dealing with costs for most of their activities.

In other words, if you want to slash budgets, lay off staff, and deliver value to shareholders, your faithful MBA is your go to. If you want to build cultures that create products that strive to satisfy arrays of non-functional requires, like efficiency, reliability, and safety, engineering managers have spent their careers building these departments.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:47AM (#39116623)
You are describing a manager yourself, so not sure we disagree disagree that much.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by cduzz on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:35AM (#39116523)
Aren't these all "yes, and" examples?

Who do you want, a good director, a good actor, or a director who's a good director and a good actor? Which do you want, a quality culture, an engineering culture, or a quality and engineering culture? Of course one is "in charge" but pretty clearly "engineering" and "quality" aren't even in the room....

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:42AM (#39116568)
Let me put it this way: someone who is a great engineer but has no skill in running and steering a large organisation will fail. Someone who knows how to do the latter might succeed by "using" talented engineers within the organisation.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:31AM (#39117083)
Or someone who is an engineer with experience running large organizations? Why engineer means automatically no experiencing running large organizations in your mind is baffling.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:39AM (#39117184)
If you have a great executive ticking all the boxes - splendid.

But there is no intrinsic link between being an engineer and being a good CEO (same holds for other disciplines, btw.). You could have engineers that qualify, lawyers, MBAs, mathematicians, physicists, ...

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:04AM (#39117457)
There is. You’re flat out incorrect.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:29AM (#39117701)
Citation, please. And, no, having a plurality of top performing CEOs being engineers is not showing an intrinsic link between being an engineer and top performing CEO.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:02AM (#39118931)
Find your own citations. You have received a reply of substance to your multitude of questions and requests for evidence many times. This is the reason I said you were sea lioning.

> Sealioning is a type of trolling or harassment that consists of pursuing people with relentless requests for evidence, often tangential or previously addressed, while maintaining a pretense of civility and sincerity, and feigning ignorance of the subject matter.

This is what you keep doing and it’s rather exhausting.

I wish you well. I hope you have a great day.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:30AM (#39119288)
I am sorry, but you have not provided any evidence for (changing) your claims.

Have a great day.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:49PM (#39121145)
K.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by photonthug on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:34AM (#39116514)
It's an engineering process.. so yes to get quality culture you might want a engineering quality expert, which is to say probably an engineer.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:38AM (#39116541)
You want engineering quality experts, but not clear at all that needs to be at CEO level. If you have someone with that skill and great experience running large and complex organisations - great take them. If not, take someone who knows how to get organisations to change and do stuff.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by photonthug on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:55AM (#39116691)
Not clear at all that the best CEO is an MBA either. Putting an MBA in charge of engineering processes is like arguing anyone can do it, so if that's the position then why the resistance towards it being an engineer? If you want a culture expert, how about a history prof or an anthropologist? "Experience running large organizations" usually just equates to failing upwards.. run the last few orgs you admin into the ground and hide the debris with outsourcing, mergers, acquisitions, anything that hides your responsibility long enough to dodge accountability, move on to the next before it gets pinned on you. Do that 10 or 15 times, and that's a great career for most of the leadership/culture "experts" in the CEO world. I don't get the apologism or tendency to lionize these people
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:10AM (#39116845)
Why is it always MBA vs engineer? I never advocated for that.

As you point out lots of other choices.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:34AM (#39117128)
https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2018/10/22/more-top-...

There is plenty of evidence that engineers in the CEO seat are effective drivers of companies and shareholder value. This is false equivalence reasoning presented over and over in this thread and I dare say this opinion is quite antiquated and precisely the thinking that has put Boeing on its current destructive course.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/insead/2014/05/29/why-engineers...

https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2018/10/22/more-top-...

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:42AM (#39117220)
If you have a great engineer and executive take them. But if not, the choice is by no means clear then.

The CEO being an engineer is not sufficient for success.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:04AM (#39117466)
I never took this position.

Your core arguments are ever changing throughout this thread, and on every reply.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:25AM (#39117666)
Not really. My arguments have been pretty consistent that being an engineer and being a good CEO are not really linked. Some engineers are good CEO, so are some MBAs, physcians, ...
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:03AM (#39118945)
I literally just gave you the evidence that they are linked in the sample of the top 100 performing companies.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:35AM (#39119338)
And I responded multiple times that that just shows that engineers can be good CEOs, nothing more.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:51PM (#39121170)
K. Cool.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @07:43AM (#39116589)
Quality is an engineering attribute: a byproduct of a culture that by definition survives in a company despite profit drive by putting minimum standards and support for people who keep them before or in balance with the bottom line concerns. Quality isn’t a culture, it’s literally a product engineering concerns that get prioritized.

The old school management theory is that engineering leaders are accountable to shipping quality products on time and within budget. That’s it.

But a CEO's historical understanding of engineering operations has been pretty opaque: ships on time, or doesn't. Of course this is lacking everything meaningful about software.

So the same visionary management theory has come up with a concept of DORA metrics. This provides the competency with quality management metrics that allow for decision-making around whether engineering is delivering or not and a whole new level of understanding and abstraction.

But understand that most of the companies that are getting themselves in deep shit right now are doing so because they have removed power from their engineering organizations to the point where, and the service of relentless extraction of shareholder value, they have destroyed their companies and crippled their products. It is happened to quite a few companies and manufacturers in the United States, from GE to Boeing, and from IBM to GM.

The current profit comes from revenue not reputation culture thinks that you can build some level of abstraction to engineering management, and then layer on traditional management theory in order to extract value from a chain of command.

The truth is that engineering lead organizations deliver a great deal, more value to shareholders in the long-term, as they are more focused on building the platforms that create competitive long-term foundations. Companies like Netflix, Google, Apple, and other “tech companies” occupy the top value of the stock market in equities positions around the world, because of the fact that they are able to use software to amplify the value of their innovations at profound levels. But America’s Legacy companies continue to operate as if this lesson is not true they continue to prioritize optimization over platform.

The old system continues to persist with the idea that there must be a professional manager at the top of the organization, rather than someone who is focused on creating value with platforms, and the culture tends to produce these situations of crisis in exploitation, because they do not understand how important it is to create a culture of platform value creation.

So of course, I make the comment that we should have an “engineering experience CEO,” or even an actual engineer in the CEO seat, and predictably it ends up being criticized for the fact that we could have a professional manager in that seat, and don’t actually need an engineer to be a CEO. That’s fine, and I can understand the point you’re raising.

But, it’s been my experience that CEOs that have been in involved in platform, engineering and large scale systems management do a much better job of preserving the culture that creates lasting and durable platform value for companies like Boeing, and this is the value which has been destroyed and the culture which must be resurrected before the company crashes.

So, rather than bringing another abstraction specialist, who will find another metric values system to manage things, which isn’t working, I was suggesting that we should bring in an actual engineer to sleep on the factory floor and make sure that this culture stops before someone dies and the share price drops to unrecoverable levels (where it’s going!).

To expound I’ll say this.

The current culture at Boeing is very much a culture where the engineers don’t speak up. Many of the most passionate people who worked there have been fired or let go because they spoke up so, I think it’s time for a change before one of the most storied and important companies in American history becomes yet another casualty of the MBA-lead, value extracting management theory.

So in sun, it really doesn’t matter if the CEO is an engineer, but it matters that the CEO is not working with abstractions, and therefore I was making the suggestion that the CEO should be an engineer, or at least come from engineering as a background, so that we do not continue the pattern of incompetent management that has gotten this company to the brink of failure.

Forgive my typos, I had to dictate this as I’m traveling.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:14AM (#39116874)
I think you describe a much more particular issue with perhaps average(?) US executive eduction and practice where perhaps MBAs are overemphasised.

I disagree that quality is specific to engineering. Lots of other fields understand quality, too.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:35AM (#39117138)
Manufacturing quality. These are manufacturing problems.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by clouddrover on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:14AM (#39116877)
> I don't think you need an engineer as CEO for that.

You need a CEO who actually understands the business. If your business is building planes and your CEO has never built a plane, then your business will inevitably have problems because the CEO fundamentally doesn't understand the business.

It won't happen immediately but a slow rot will set in. The CEO won't pay attention to the details because he never understood the details in the first place.

Optus recently had a major network outage. Part of the reason why that happened is they picked a CEO with no telecommunications background. She fundamentally didn't understand the business she was in:

https://edition.cnn.com/2023/11/07/tech/australia-optus-netw...

She's since quit as Optus CEO in an "I don't want to fix my own mess" move. She doesn't seem to have paid that much attention to Optus anyway:

https://www.afr.com/rear-window/optus-a-part-time-gig-for-ce...

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:22AM (#39116970)
So what exactly would the CEO have to have done to "build planes"? Some wiring? Screwing in things? Ordered parts? Quality tested a component? Why not the need to also piloting a plane to understand how it works? What specific part imbues the required understanding?

What if CEO build other things than planes?

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by arcbyte on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:35AM (#39117765)
You need two types of experience: deep and abstract.

You need the deep experience of having worked inside the beaurocracy of a huge effort on some tiny piece of the project.

You need the abstract experience of having built a smaller, less complicated version of an entire plane yourself. Think RC model plane here. And yes you should be at least an RC pilot.

With both of those experiences you will be able to extrapolate very closely everything you need to know to be succesful in establishing an engineering culture.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by clouddrover on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:25AM (#39117010)
To actually have done something and contributed to designing and producing aircraft. To actually have an aeronautical engineering background. That's the business Boeing is in.

Putting inexpert people in positions of authority is guaranteed to damage a business, as Boeing is now finding out.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:29AM (#39117054)
In the anstract, do you think civilian control of the military is wrong then, too?

Should experts always be in control everywhere or are there limits?

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by Filligree on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:06AM (#39118989)
The military likely would be more effective with generals in charge, yes.

There are downsides to that, which is why we don't do it. You can judge for yourself if those same downsides apply to Boeing.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @11:53AM (#39119577)
I think that goes to the heart of it: I am not sure generals would necessarily be better at achieving the political objectives of what the military is for.

In the same way, I couldn't say if Boing would need something more closer to a priest or a technocrat.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by clouddrover on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @04:06PM (#39122636)
Civilians don't run the military. The military experts run the military. That's a good thing.

And the military doesn't run the government. That's also a good thing.

The only way your analogy works is if you think it's a good idea to appoint generals and admirals who have no military experience. I hope you don't.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @05:06PM (#39123208)
In most Western countries the most senior person in command is a civilian, not a general or admiral (and there are civilians in various other positions, too).
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by clouddrover on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @05:18PM (#39123353)
Answer what has been put to you: Do you think people with no military experience should be generals and admirals?
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Thursday January 25, 2024 @01:02AM (#39126658)
I don't see that as the right analogy, because the highest command authority already is with a civilian.

Anyway, why not under certain circumstances? Already now there are differences between countries what is run by the military and what isn't.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by clouddrover on Thursday January 25, 2024 @04:41AM (#39127790)
> Anyway, why not under certain circumstances?

Because someone with no military experience is inexpert. They don't know what they're doing.

In the military a lack of expertise is very likely to result in people dying unnecessarily.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by RandomLensman on Thursday January 25, 2024 @05:29AM (#39128088)
So when currently in country A something is done by the military and in country B by civilians, only country A has it right?

The US army corps of engineers being in charge of levees isn't the only way, for example. A lot of generals don't fight wars. And those who do, are under civilian supervision.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by nvm0n2 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @05:10PM (#39123263)
Civilians control but don't manage the military. They control it, in the sense of setting the goals, but they don't generally manage things after that.

The equivalent here would be the customers.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by dotnet00 on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:40AM (#39117196)
Putting in an engineer at the top alone won't fix endemic culture issues. You'd have to do a more in-depth rethinking of all the processes and purge all the penny pinching cruft. But that isn't palatable to shareholders so it won't happen.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by happytiger on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:50AM (#39117313)
Maybe by replacing the board?

The CEO was his own chairman from 2016-2019, so there’s that too…

Getting back to basics around following procedure and having a single process sure would have helped in this situation. Just read what the leaker actually wrote. It’s a comical parody of a company that’s off track and not empowering engineering to set boundaries on procedure.

So if you don’t address the executives in charge and bring in someone who will change the situation, which this board and CEO have utterly failed to do and in fact have made worse since 2019, who is going to change that?

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by FredPret on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:07AM (#39118186)
I’m not so sure that it won’t be palatable. It’s not like their strategy is making money - Boeing has lost a ton of money for years now.

https://valustox.com/BA

If you told shareholders you’ll fix the crisis shown in the plummeting profit graphs above, I’m sure they’d vote for it.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by bigbillheck on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @08:54AM (#39117355)
If you check the historical record you'll find that Boeing has had a long history of making defective planes.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by tarsinge on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @09:37AM (#39117797)
In the current economy who cares if the company is destroyed? Shareholders with insider knowledge will already have reduced their exposure. See what PE firms are doing, only thing that matters is ROI. I don’t see how it will change until we go back to pre-Reagan times, I.e. companies purpose are not just to make money for shareholders.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by jimnotgym on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @10:30AM (#39118484)
Why? Because engineers have naturally better morality when faced with performance related pay than MBAs? Because engineers are morally superior?

There are several engineers on the board of Boeing already. The non engineers had long careers at Boeing or other aerospace companies.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by delfinom on Wednesday January 24, 2024 @01:06PM (#39120574)
There was an actual engineer as CEO.

They threw him under the bus for the 737 Max because 3 years in on the job and he was starting to ruffle the feathers of McDonnell Douglas.

Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by zipper234 on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @11:08PM (#39212627)
The culture has to be changed. CEO pay is completely out of whack, giving early retirement to higher paid engineers so Boeing can hire people at lower wages, moving parts of the manufacturing to areas that do not have Labor Unions, putting the screws on manufactures so they cannot make a decent profit. Is this corporate America. We need an airplane manufacturer in the US, but I say fire the Board and the CEO. Maybe those who want to protect Boeing should talk to families who lost relatives on the 2 fatal crashes. Shame on Boeing leadership. It all started with the merger of Boeing and McDonnell Douglas. Management was not willing to go back to the drawing board and now look at the cost.
Re:Alaska CEO: We found many loose bolts on our Max planes by zipper234 on Wednesday January 31, 2024 @11:16PM (#39212666)
Fire the CEO and the Board. This all started with the merger of Boeing and McDonnell Douglas. Profit above all else. Just like Jack Welch of GE. It is pathetic. Take all the money and squeeze the bottom. Retire experienced engineers and hire new ones with less experience and lower pay. Move manufacturing so you will not have Labor Unions to worry about. Squeeze companies suppling parts so they do not have a fair profit. It is pathetic. We all must demand change. I am flying overseas but not on a Boeing plane. And my heart goes out to families who lost loved ones in the 2 fatal crashes.