Musk is perfectly willing to play by the rules and norms of the Chinese market. They opened up a factory there and everything, they are even selling lots of cars in the PRC while exporting some outside.
I’m not sure how BYD would fair in Norway/Sweden; where unions are granted blanket monopolies on economic control. Is it even much of a player there yet?
Pretty sure BWD is the top selling EV manufacturer in Sweden, I recall reading that before the Tesla union shenanigans happened.
No idea about Norway
https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/tesla-...
https://www.car.info/en-se/stats?from=2023-02&to=2024-01&vd=...
Tesla Model Y: 23.088 cars (18,2 percent) Volkswagen ID.4: 6614 cars (5,2 percent) Skoda Enyaq: 5740 cars (4,5 percent) Toyota bZ4X: 5395 cars (4,2 percent) Volvo XC40: 5025 cars (4,0 percent) Ford Mustang Mach-E: 3792 cars (3,0 percent) Toyota Yaris: 3582 cars (2,8 percent) Toyota RAV4: 3457 cars (2,7 percent) Volkswagen ID.3: 3141 cars (2,5 percent) Hyundai Kona: 2991 cars (2,4 percent) Audi Q4 e-tron: 2688 cars (2,1 percent) Nissan Ariya: 2606 cars (2,1 percent) Nissan Leaf: 2471 cars (1,9 percent) BMW iX1: 2415 cars (1,9 percent) Tesla Model 3: 2083 cars (1,6 percent) Toyota Corolla: 1911 cars (1,5 percent) Polestar 2: 1832 cars (1,4 percent) BMW i4: 1782 cars (1,4 percent) MG4: 1622 cars (1,3 percent) Audi Q8 e-tron: 1602 cars (1,3 percent)
Unions don't have blanket monopolies on economic control, that's absolute bullshit...
I see quite a few BYDs here in Sweden. My girlfriend even got one as a rental some 3-6 months ago.
The post workers union only decided on taking such action due to Tesla bringing scabs to break the strike of their own workers, that's such a huge no-no in the free market of labour in Sweden that workers from other sections of the economy decided to join on sympathy strikes.
I suggest you to educate yourself on how the labour market works here in Sweden, how government interference in it is extremely low, and with that decisions around labour come mostly through agreements between employees and employers; it's a core tenet of all labour relationship over here and Tesla actively worked to break it. If Tesla was actively acting to break a part of the social contract of your nation, would you bend over and say it's free speech?
Don't look at other countries with your local eyes, it's absurdly ignorant, your rules are not my rules, learn about our rules to be able to have an informed opinion.
https://sverigesradio.se/artikel/tesla-teknikern-jobbar-trot...
https://www.na.se/2023-11-16/tesla-ar-den-basta-arbetsgivare...
The number of striking Tesla mechanics is so low that IF Metall refuses to reveal how many are striking, and recently expelled some Tesla employees for not obeying their power play of striking.
https://da.se/2023/12/if-metall-flera-strejkbrytare-utesluts...
It's a powerplay by unions who have to resort to sympathy strikes using the government monopoly on giving out registration plates because Tesla workers are happy. Even those are failing as Tesla sales in Sweden have increased over 2022 in Nov and Dec 2023, in spite of blockades on Tesla car imports. Would be interesting to see the court battle over plates because Swedish law says plates must be provided for lawfully registered cars. The law usually trumps contracts, which should have exceptions in the cases of force majeure anyway.
BS. Unions almost never reveal the number of striking employees.
> and recently expelled some Tesla employees for not obeying their power play of striking.
It's not "power play", it's business as usual that Tesla wants to upend.
Why don't they?
> It's not "power play", it's business as usual that Tesla wants to upend
Tesla has been selling and servicing cars in Sweden from almost 10 years, it was business as usual till the union decided to strike.
To not paint a target on striking employees in case of small strikes.
> Tesla has been selling and servicing cars in Sweden from almost 10 years, it was business as usual till the union decided to strike.
The union has been trying to negotiate with Tesla during that period.
Sweden traditionally has very weak labor laws, there is not even a minimum wage. Instead, Sweden relies on strong unions, with more than 70% of employees in unions. There are unwritten rules on how businesses should behave, but Tesla just decided to ignore them.
It was OK while Tesla was still a small scrappy startup, but they're not anymore.
Unions here never disclose how many employees are on strike, it's a way to protect the collective action.
> https://sverigesradio.se/artikel/tesla-teknikern-jobbar-trot... > En Tesla-anställd tekniker som Ekot pratat med är kritisk mot fackets kamp för kollektivavtal, och väljer att trots strejken fortsätta arbeta.
> ”Hade jag inte tyckt om mitt jobb, hade det varit så toxiskt som de beskriver, då hade jag bytt jobb”, säger han till Ekot.
That's one technician saying they are happy and disappointed with IF Metall, unless conditions are so egregious to force unanimous action there will always be employees who don't want to participate on a strike. It was the same in the case of Klarna, a lot of employees were not in support of a potential strike but there was enough support to announce it to force Klarna to come into a collective bargaining agreement.
> It's a powerplay by unions who have to resort to sympathy strikes using the government monopoly on giving out registration plates because Tesla workers are happy. Even those are failing as Tesla sales in Sweden have increased over 2022 in Nov and Dec 2023, in spite of blockades on Tesla car imports.
It's become a powerplay, exactly because of how the labour market works here, if a company succeeds in overturning a foundational principle of the labour market then employers have acquired a much more outsized power against employees. IF Metall wants Tesla to abide by what any other car manufacturer abides to in Sweden, in not doing so they are creating a market advantage over other companies who are following the rules of the labour market.
Had Tesla not brought scabs to break the strike nothing of this would be happening, do you understand that? The major issue is that, it's not Tesla not signing a CBA, it's Tesla trying to strong-arm their way through union busting tactics in a society where unions are a core tenet to balance employers-employees relationships. Without unionised power the labour market in Scandinavia/Nordics is not possible to be balanced, the government tries to not interfere.
I do not understand why you defend Tesla so often in Hacker News, I've noticed your username across the years always siding with Tesla, Tesla is in the wrong here and they are paying for it.
If Tesla doesn't like how the market works here they are free to leave at any moment...
I'm not aware enough of the details of how this works in general to say whether this is good or bad overall.
Their hybrid cars has serious problems, including catching fire on their own. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXrsmYQvK8E
It's not like Tesla didn't have issues, but not so serious and numerous ones.
The newer BYD vehicles are more comparable to Tesla (and other manufacturers), but there's a long, long way to go before they prove themselves more than a manufacturer of cheap cars.
Tesla has never been a manufacturer of cheap cars. More recently, it has become a manufacturer of good ones.
The fundamentally simpler nature of EVs means they're rolling software platforms, and the software matters a great deal. Tesla has gotten good at the software side of the equation, and are arguably ahead of pretty much everything else.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/stevetengler/2023/07/19/the-thr...
NZ mostly buys second hand vehicles from Japan, so new vehicle sales numbers are low.
I'm visiting Australia now and you see lots of Great Wall trucks
They claim to be the world's biggest manufacturer of "battery charging" (electric and hybrid I suppose) vehicles.
They look like high end vehicles and I've seen them around often... but never drove one so can't really comment on quality.
The example you gave is for a 15 year old car where only 100 were produced and Mercedes couldn't have been too upset since they signed a partnership with BYD that year. Around the same time Tesla was selling Lotus Roadsters. In the meantime obviously neither still needs to do that. BYD will sell outside of China whatever they are legally allowed to sell on top of the growing sales they have inside China.
> This should tell you everything you need to know about this company.
If you're too focused on how they did business 15 years ago you might miss that they're passing by you today. Does Musk tell you everything you need to know about Tesla? Millions are still buying. If you don't buy BYD it won't be because they were copying the megastars of the time decades ago.
I'm not a fan of Chinese business practices but a lot of big companies everywhere started by copying more established competing products.
This is like saying we should ignore Tesla because the only car they sold in 2009 was a rip-off Lotus.
Speaking as an American, I'd love to see what the presence of low-end (say, $10k range) autos would do to traffic laws and city planning.
No it's not like saying that. Lotus had a deal with Tesla.
Ford used to advertise Ford Granada that looks like a new Cadillac and costs less. [1]
[1] https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/AdwAAOSw~Chg93LK/s-l1600.jpg
Yet, it seems like they're beating a lot of other EV makers across the world, and are producing top-selling vehicles in a bunch of countries. So seems it's somewhat working outside of China? Or I misunderstand what you mean.
I was thinking "come on, how similar can they be, the CLK has a really distinctive design", but nope, identical. Wow.
Such a ridiculous take on a technology forum.
It’s a waste of human energy to reinvent the wheel. Not to mention the example given earlier is irrelevant since it’s no longer in production anyway.
I swear the stupidest takes on this forum called “hacker news”. Hackers who usually reuse the same exploit “tech and design”, lol…
Where are you getting 1% from? That's off by a drastic amount.
"EV sales climb and are on track to be 9% of US new car purchases in 2023"
"U.S. sales of hybrid, plug-in hybrid and battery-electric vehicles reached 17.7% of new light-duty vehicle sales in the third quarter"
https://www.utilitydive.com/news/electric-vehicles-EVs-new-c...
https://apnews.com/article/automakers-electric-vehicles-us-c...
Tesla's building their cheap car too, but it will not launch until 2025 earliest.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesla_next-generation_vehicle
And Teslas built overseas are fine, it's Fremont's quality control that sucks. Which is likely exactly why Tesla is planning to built the Model 2s in Mexico, Germany and China, but not the US.
https://www1.hkexnews.hk/listedco/listconews/sehk/2024/0101/...
https://arstechnica.com/cars/2024/01/tesla-sold-1-8-million-...
Well, as it stands right now, BYD looks to be the more popular option in countries like Sweden just because Musk refuses to do what every other single company does in the country. Even Amazon found a way to work in a way that the common person is protected, why can't Tesla?
No it's not, where are you getting your data from? Not to mention jumping to conclusions.
I guess I'll do the same? Why have curious conversation when you can assume the worst?
> Tesla sales this Q have been suppressed by people awaiting model refreshes
You're just saying "Tesla had less sales because of bad $X" with fancier words. The importance is not why Tesla fucked up (that's up to them to figure out), but that they're now being surpassed even though they had a huge headstart.
If you are world #2 in your field of work do you consider yourself a failure and that you fucked up? That's a sad existence.
Personally, I wouldn't, I don't care what "position" I'm at, as long as I have enough. But I'm fairly sure that Musk would take that as a failure, especially if you've been #1 for a bunch of quarters and suddenly you aren't.
(Musk has repeated many times that he wants Tesla to be the biggest automaker [by volume] https://dallasexpress.com/business-markets/teslas-goal-large...)
https://sustainablebrands.com/read/behavior-change/tesla-ope...
Their actual pledge: https://www.tesla.com/legal/additional-resources#patent-pled...
States you can use Tesla patents if you agree to let Tesla use your patents, rip-off your products, make counterfeits, and steal your trade secrets.
That is worse than standard patent reciprocity agreements and I think most companies would prefer paying for regular patent licensing over such ludicrous IP overreach. Tesla and Elon Musk somehow proposed something even less open than regular patents and had the gall to lie about being openness advocates.
Not seeing that in your link, can you quote the relevant parts or cite better sources?
“asserted, helped others assert or had a financial stake in any assertion of
(i) any patent or other intellectual property right [highlighted for emphasis] against Tesla
(ii) any patent right against a third party for its use of technologies relating to electric vehicles or related equipment”
Condition 1 states you can not assert any intellectual property right against Tesla. Intellectual property rights include patents, copyrights (protects against rip-off products), trademarks (protects against counterfeits), and trade secrets (protects against insider stealing).
This is explicit and deliberate as condition 2 states only patent rights are protected for others.
Tesla then goes on to reiterate that it explicitly and deliberately protects its own copyright and trademark:
“challenged, helped others challenge, or had a financial stake in any challenge to any Tesla patent; or marketed or sold any knock-off product (e.g., a product created by imitating or copying the design or appearance of a Tesla product or which suggests an association with or endorsement by Tesla)“
They literally need that additional “I’m about to screw you” clarification clause to make double-sure that if you try to fight the terms in the future as unconscionable they can point to how they made double explicitly sure that you realize the rights Tesla is extending you are explicitly a tiny fraction of what Tesla is demanding from you.
Those terms are so unfair it is ridiculous and it is insulting that Tesla dares to claim it, in any way, represents a good faith patent and openness pledge. I can find a more honest promise from a used car salesperson.
Deliveries have more factors involved, and really only useful if full production capacity isn’t being fully sold out (which I believe still is).
It's just a matter of when, not if, from where I'm sitting.
Like what? Source(s)?
This is false reporting, only 10 to 30 of the 130 mechanics "walked off the job". The rest like their stock options and performance based pay hikes instead of the union table rates for all.
> About 130 mechanics at 10 Tesla garages across Sweden walked off the job on Oct. 27 over the company’s refusal to sign a collective bargaining agreement
This is false reporting, only 10 to 30 of the 130 mechanics "walked off the job". The rest like their stock options and performance based pay hikes instead of the union table rates for all. A lot of other news outlets picked up this false narrative.
The number of striking Tesla mechanics is so low that IF Metall refuses to reveal how many are striking, and recently expelled some Tesla employees for not obeying their power play of striking.
https://sverigesradio.se/artikel/tesla-teknikern-jobbar-trot...
https://www.na.se/2023-11-16/tesla-ar-den-basta-arbetsgivare...
A lot of other news outlets picked up this false narrative from AP and reporting that 130 employees are striking.
The number of striking Tesla mechanics is so low that IF Metall refuses to reveal how many are striking, and recently expelled some Tesla employees for not obeying their power play of striking.
Recently the NYT finally said only a few dozen are striking. Sad to see previously trustworthy news outlets like AP resorting to abject fake news to smear Tesla and spread a narrative. And it's spread and repeated on places like HN with no critical thinking or research.
The point being… you asked for sources, I pointed out some I heard about, and you jump at me with some argument I’m not even interested in. I don’t care who’s right and who’s wrong.
The bottom line is Musk started a fight and people walked out.
Added a link that gives you some additional context.
Tesla sold 55% more cars in Nov 2023 compared to Nov 2022, and 9% more in December, so how is that Tesla's downfall?
https://carup.se/trots-strejken-tesla-far-ut-fler-bilar-i-sv...
https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/tesla-...
Edit: Ran into the posting limit but the below is certainly false about Sweden, BYD is not selling the most cars there.
> BYD are selling the most cars, and is the fastest growing in terms of sales in the country
- "BYD overtakes Tesla - sells the most electric cars" - https://www.mestmotor.se/automotorsport/artiklar/nyheter/202...
- "BYD beat Tesla - grew fastest in Sweden in 2023" - https://carup.se/byd-slog-tesla-okade-snabbast-i-sverige-202...
Source? BYD aren't selling the most cars in Sweden.
> BYD beat Tesla - grew fastest in Sweden in 2023
Tesla sold 20K cars and BYD sold 3K in Sweden in 2023. How is that beating Tesla? They went from 1.1K cars to 3K, so had better percentage growth than Tesla
> Det är i det sista kvartalet 2023 som BYD kan stoltsera med bättre siffror än Tesla. BYD rapporterar att de sålt 526 409 elbilar från och med oktober och fram till årets slut.
> Teslas försäljning å sin sida slog rekord och blev den högsta för ett givet kvartal i tillverkarens historia. Resultatet blev 484 507 bilar. 41 902 färre än BYD.
---
> It is in the last quarter of 2023 that BYD can boast better figures than Tesla. BYD reports that it sold 526,409 electric cars from October through the end of the year.
> Tesla's sales, on the other hand, broke records and became the highest for a given quarter in the manufacturer's history. The result was 484,507 cars. 41,902 fewer than BYD.
Tesla outsold BYD in Sweden 6 times over.
Any stat out of China I take with a heavy grain of salt.
Is there a browser mod to hide comments like this? Bonus points if it hides the snide demoralization-style comments that have started infesting HN too ("Oh you are a software engineer? Let me tell you why you are ignorant without knowing anything about you")
And besides, BYD did that by selling a lot of very cheap vehicles. I don't think that really fits the business objectives for Tesla.
I'm guessing that Musk's unwillingness to work with the rules and norms in the markets Tesla is trying to enter, will be Tesla's downfall. Hopefully Tesla could somehow get rid of Musk as it seems like he is constantly holding Tesla back quite a bit. (edit: some context: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...)