News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by bayindirh on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:18PM (#38755349)
How this is different from Meta's "reduction" of pro-Palestinian posts exposure and preventing it from spreading too far?

Does Meta's (or other similar actors') actions align with potential countries' geopolitical objectives?

Can we look both of them objectively and say both are bad (I think so), or is there us vs. them mentality?

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by alexsereno on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:40PM (#38755549)
Of course they do, however an important distinction here is that Meta is banned in China and TikTok is not banned here. Both are bad, but Chinese netizens aren’t exposed to one of the two.

China is quite good about filtering out which propaganda interests they want their citizens exposed to, and of course are more active in influencing operations globally as well.

We can argue if that model of propaganda and control is good or not, but regardless they are smart enough to know that they don’t want to open up their youth to US propaganda machines but are happy to have us open ourselves to their propaganda. It’s asymmetrical, and that causes a lot of consternation. It’s also risky.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by stavros on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:47PM (#38755590)
Meta is banned because China is a dictatorship, not because bans are good.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by Kadin on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:14PM (#38755839)
"Dictatorships are bad" is not the game-over argument that it once was, maybe 20 years ago.

The Chinese aren't just competing against the US for control of some islands and sea lanes here and there, they are putting their political system -- which is de facto a dictatorship selected periodically by a small ruling clique -- as an alternative model to democracy. One that can compete with and defeat democracy, in fact.

And to be blunt, it's not clear to me that they are losing. We in the US have put ourselves at a disadvantage w/r/t China over and over again, relying ostensibly on the magical power of democracy to always win the day. As far as I can tell, it's straight-up magical thinking.

If we do not take China seriously as a threat to democracy, not just internally to Asia but as an aspirational model of society and the basis for legitimate government, I think we risk losing.

Why we would allow a propaganda outlet of what is effectively an enemy state to operate in the US, and why we would allow technology transfers and other advantageous trade arrangements, is mind boggling to me. Sure, the 'marketplace of ideas' sounds great on paper, but not when the other people don't believe in the same things. That sort of treatment -- access to the US market, both economically and that of ideas -- should be reserved for polities that at least have signed-on to the basic concepts that the US is built on.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by stavros on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:18PM (#38755879)
I didn't say "dictatorships are bad". Also, there's quite some area between allowing a propaganda outlet and banning it completely.

Then again, by the same token, why should the EU allow Meta to operate on its territory?

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by mrkstu on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:25PM (#38755960)
You're already seeing the EU investigate X/Twitter for not modulating the messaging of their users according to their (the EU's) dictates.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by mvdtnz on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:20PM (#38756486)
> "Dictatorships are bad" is not the game-over argument that it once was, maybe 20 years ago.

Yes, it is. By god, something needs to be done about the absolute stupidity that is making its way through American universities. This is tragic.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by colechristensen on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:39PM (#38756619)
It is indeed not the game over argument any more, measured by the people. Both sides of the political spectrum in America have been ever more strongly advocating for authoritarian enforcement of their political goals and both sides have increasing admiration for foreign dictatorships and terrorists.

The extremes are closing in on the excluded middle which doesn’t have much of a voice at all as nonextremist views are attacked as supporting the other sides.

They are not always doing this in the same ways and in the same places, but there is a definite trend.

I’m not making excuses for one side by saying the other side is doing it, both threaten the republic and world peace.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by mensetmanusman on Sunday December 24, 2023 @05:37PM (#38757698)
People that don't understand math appreciate dictatorships because they can imagine themselves in power.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by malwarebytess on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:48PM (#38756697)
> One that can compete with and defeat democracy, in fact.

If it's better then why shouldn't it win? Frankly the lines are blurred. So called liberty is not so clearly championed by the west any longer, and on top of that robber barons and corporations are running rampant through our societies and governments. There's no apparent upside for ordinary people to a Western victory any longer, or at least it's not clear cut.

After all if we're going to be ruled by elites, and be under a system which can compete with capitalist "democracy," might as well be ruled by elites who are ideologically aligned with the people's well-being.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by Natsu on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:55PM (#38756751)
Better for whom is the key question, I think. They're quite eager to do something about Taiwan which showed how much better China could be doing.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by aaomidi on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:15PM (#38756928)
Honestly not sure if comparing China and Taiwan gets that conclusion for everyone?
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by Natsu on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:06PM (#38766585)
Economically it's doing much better than even most of the USA, though there's a question of how long that might last.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by hsuduebc2 on Sunday December 24, 2023 @05:00PM (#38757333)
Better in what? This is really shallow relativization of someone mad at current system. It is not better in any values valued in "western civilization".
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by nradov on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:28PM (#38756558)
Back during the early Cold War, some Americans were concerned that the Soviet model would out compete democracy and free market capitalism. They might beat us without even fighting. Later we found out that it was all a facade. Their purported successes were all lies and failures. The entire society was rotten to the core and eventually the internal contradictions ripped it apart.

China is not to be taken lightly. They are a legitimate threat and strategic competitor. But they also face enormous problems due to unfavorable geography, lack of key natural resources, corruption, malinvestment, and demographic collapse. These problems are not getting better, and I won't be surprised if there's a violent civil war in 30 years (as has happened many times over millennia of Chinese history).

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by aaomidi on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:17PM (#38756939)
I mean, then why did we spend so much money and kill so many people destabilizing half the world?

If the model was so rotten to begin with, that is.

How many people did the west directly and indirectly kill in the 20th century?

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by callalex on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:35PM (#38757093)
For the same reason we still do: it’s incredibly profitable for the people who make weapons.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by janalsncm on Sunday December 24, 2023 @05:03PM (#38757370)
I believe your analysis conflates economic systems with political ones. The U.S. doesn’t have an entirely free market capitalism system (see: farm subsidies which fed into supermarket propaganda) and China doesn’t have an entirely planned economy.

As far as political systems go, the collapse of China seems to always be around the corner. But in reality, the U.S. seems to be much closer to civil war. No faction stormed the Capitol in Beijing when Xi was appointed. And even if our political system is not overthrown, it may die the death of 1000 cuts. How much can you honestly say Congress represents the People’s vs lobbyists (professional bribery) and PAC interests?

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by hsuduebc2 on Monday December 25, 2023 @02:07PM (#38765159)
Context is very important here. Xi was appointed not elected by people. He got almost three thousand votes and one against. There is no election so it can't create friction. Like in eastern European nations where there was one party system and elections were virtually non existent. Friction there is not generated by politicians but usually from poverty or similar systematic issue. As long as Chinese population would perceive themself as improving and even rich system is safe. Democracies works very differently.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by Duya-Taksis on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @12:32PM (#38773805)
"China is not to be taken lightly."

Yet that's exactly what you're doing.

"But they also face enormous problems due to unfavorable geography, lack of key natural resources, corruption, malinvestment, and demographic collapse."

None of these things are true. Stop consuming intellectual droppings from the likes of Peter Zeihan.

China has a monopoly on rare earths and more importantly, processing technologies, which are the key resources for a technological society. It's rapidly transitioning its grid and transportation systems to run on renewable power. Over the next decade it will do in hydrogen what it did in solar and wind. That will give it total self sufficiency in critical inputs like ammonia and synthetic fuels.

Corruption was an issue before Xi's anti-corruption drive. Corruption was wonderful when it served American interests, when the CIA was paying out the bribes. Now that the CIA networks have been torn up and the corrupt officials put behind bars and executed, the US cries that China is "increasingly authoritarian." Well, the louder the US cries, the more I know China is on the right path.

Malinvestment? That's rich coming from an OnlyFans economy like America. You people can't even make enough artillery shells to send to Ukraine. You're being outbuilt by an order of magnitude by Russia, a country you mock as having an economy the size of Texas. Your GDP is entirely hot air and all you make is noise.

As for demography, that's the last thin reed you have to hang all your ill wishes toward China on. Unfortunately for you, that's changing for the better. The Chinese government has shifted from an anti-natal/neutral policy to a pro-natal one and will introduce a raft of policies to boost birth rates. Before you even think that that never works, it does work. It worked in Hungary and it will work far better in China, where the Chinese government can pull many more levers than the Hungarian government can.

Incidentally, the biggest block to Chinese people marrying and having children is the high cost of housing. Guess what the deflating housing bubble is going to do for that.

"These problems are not getting better, and I won't be surprised if there's a violent civil war in 30 years"

I've just demonstrated that they either don't exist or they are getting much better. If you want to look for violent civil wars, look to the US. You won't have to wait 30 years.

"as has happened many times over millennia of Chinese history"

China has millennia of history. Let's see the US make it to 300 years.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by foverzar on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:06PM (#38756861)
> they are putting their political system -- which is de facto a dictatorship selected periodically by a small ruling clique -- as an alternative model to democracy.

Oh please. Just because you people in the west are stuck in the 20th century and have an unyielding urge to reformat other nations and instill a political system you're familiar with, doesn't mean anyone else cares for this kind of idiocy. Stop projecting.

You're just like USSR with its obsession with "global revolution" and counterproductive dichotomies. And just like it happened with USSR, everyone else is getting pretty pissed with all that zealous crap that doesn't amount to anything but guised political opportunism IRL.

It's not like your specific approach to governance looks any less shitty to other cultures. Grow up, embrace diversity, learn to play nice with others - yours is the last civilization that needs to take a long hard look at itself. Either naturally, or through some major political crisis, or, worst case scenario, everyone else will just gang up on you like Saudis, China, US, WEU and many others did on USSR, if god forbid all that global (outside NATO and its few aspirants) distaste for bullshit "holier than thou" attitude reaches a boiling point.

Srsly, grow up. Traveling and meeting new people is extremely helpful in that regard.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by aaomidi on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:14PM (#38756918)
What’s really funny is that the democracy Americans keep touting as some amazing system is currently stripping away rights from:

Queer folk

Women

Pro-Palestinian people

Maybe it’s time to question if your democracy is at a point to be exported to the rest of the world (?)

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by callalex on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:36PM (#38757100)
Can you name one non-democracy that isn’t doing exactly those same things?
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by aaomidi on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:44PM (#38757178)
I never said non democracies are good. I just said our democracy isn’t mature enough.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by peyton on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:54PM (#38757284)
I dunno, the whole point of a government based on natural rights theory is the government isn’t the giver of rights, so it can’t strip people of rights. If you’re thinking of privileges granted by a group of doctrinaires, that’s more like an ecclesiastical polity.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by callalex on Monday December 25, 2023 @01:52AM (#38760436)
Ok, then what was the point you were actually trying to make while listing minority groups with high specificity?

Let’s start from a point of common understanding: I agree that it is a bad thing to oppress minority groups.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by mikrotikker on Sunday December 24, 2023 @05:07PM (#38757411)
Which rights exactly?
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by aaomidi on Sunday December 24, 2023 @08:58PM (#38758917)
Are you serious? lol

Maybe let’s start with the basic one that’s abortion?

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by Levitz on Sunday December 24, 2023 @11:17PM (#38759707)
This is a map of countries in which abortion is legal:

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/a/a5/Ab...

This is a map of democratic countries:

https://cdn.statcdn.com/Infographic/images/normal/18737.jpeg

You might notice a resemblance. Want to do gay rights next?

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by defrost on Sunday December 24, 2023 @11:26PM (#38759779)
Your maps appear to support the premise put forward by aaomidi.

The USofA is labelled there as not very democratic, grouped as with "Flawed Democracies" and the premise put forward was that US Democracy was stripping rights (eg: abortion) and perhaps wasn't a great example of a good democracy.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by foverzar on Monday December 25, 2023 @06:30AM (#38761747)
> You might notice a resemblance.

Only if you really-really squint and look only at americas, while ignoring most of Eurasia and huge chunk of Africa where most of the world's population happens to live.

I hardly see much of a global correlation here.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by mikrotikker on Monday December 25, 2023 @10:46PM (#38768748)
Try another? The abortion issue is clearly used by either side to drive division, they don't want to fix it. So it's less a stripping and more of a peasants stuck in the middle kind of thing.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by superduty on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:00PM (#38755698)
This.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by ramblenode on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:59PM (#38756293)
> Of course they do, however an important distinction here is that Meta is banned in China

Meta isn't banned in China. They just haven't developed a product that complies with Chinese law (in large part because US lawmakers warned them not to do this---so more like an export ban than an import ban).

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by eganist on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:10PM (#38756395)
> They just haven't developed a product that complies with Chinese law

Strictly speaking then, Meta is banned in China for not complying with Chinese law.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by ZoomerCretin on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:21PM (#38756966)
A ban implies there is some order that explicitly targets Meta. It's like saying Europe has a ban on American chicken imports, when the reality is that they have no problem with it so long as their laws and regulations are followed.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Sunday December 24, 2023 @05:22PM (#38757552)
Which Chinese law?
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by miguelazo on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:18PM (#38756475)
> TikTok is not banned here

False. It has already been banned in multiple jurisdictions, companies, and many government agencies.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by justinclift on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:47PM (#38757211)
So "slightly banned" then. ;)
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by cma on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:04PM (#38755732)
TikTok is not available in China, there is a different version under a different name with different content rules.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by jokethrowaway on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:02PM (#38756326)
It's worse than that, the content we get in the west is drastically different to the one they get in China.

It's not about exposing the west to chinese propaganda (sure, they'll promote the CCP view of any global topic, but that's often the same as our governments) it's about brainwashing western kids so they grow up to be useless and not a threat.

Would you rather your youths learnt how to cook or do stupid 10s dances? Guess which content gets displayed in China vs the West.

Not to mention the instances of mental illness spreading through tik tok via emulation (eg DID)

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by notjoemama on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:26PM (#38755419)
Maybe, but isn’t part of the problem contextual? Multiple US corporations have manipulated their content based on sensitivities that are promoted from specifically the CCP and not based on moral outlook of their population. It seems to me that’s a clear indicator of over bearing authoritarian control. Baring any value statements about political systems, isn’t there a political problem with a foreign entity controlling the content of another; particularly when an adversarial relationship exists?
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:29PM (#38755451)
> isn’t there a political problem with a foreign entity controlling the content of another

We restrict foreign ownership of media properties to 25 percent (without review) [1]. Expanding that rule to social media would make sense.

Beijing requires TikTok run itself differently within China, after all [2]. That’s the difference in care that matters. (Facebook’s lack of care in Myanmar comes to mind as analogous [3].)

[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2013/11/14...

[2] https://www.cnn.com/2023/03/24/tech/tiktok-douyin-bytedance-...

[3] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebo...

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by Kadin on Sunday December 24, 2023 @05:36PM (#38757692)
Expanding the foreign ownership rule to include social media platform companies (and, frankly, any strategically-important technology company in general) seems like a no-brainer.

Other countries should logically do the same. If Burma/Myanmar doesn't like what Facebook is doing there, they have demonstrated the capability to shut it down on multiple occasions. Setting aside that their government is a basically-illegitimate military junta, if I was them, I sure as fuck wouldn't let a US tech company operate within my country without a significant local presence that I could exert influence on.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by bugglebeetle on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:33PM (#38755475)
> Baring any value statements about political systems, isn’t there a political problem with a foreign entity controlling the content of another

No, in fact, many international newspapers, particularly those in Europe, report more honestly on the US than outlets like the New York Times or Washington Post. El Pais has far more integrity than either of those and it’s owned by a Spanish media conglomerate.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:36PM (#38755504)
> many international newspapers, particularly those in Europe, report more honestly on the US than outlets like the New York Times or Washington Post

Yes and no. They report with different biases. It’s interesting to read. But they sometimes make comically elementary errors regarding our politics.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by bugglebeetle on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:46PM (#38755583)
> But they sometimes make comically elementary errors regarding our politics.

I would describe the political coverage of both of the US papers I mentioned in much the same terms.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:47PM (#38755593)
> would describe the political coverage of both of the US papers I mentioned in much the same terms

I wouldn’t. Most plainly, because they’re read (and responded to) by policymakers.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by bugglebeetle on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:04PM (#38755741)
That’s more indicative of their relationship to power (largely subservient) than anything to do with the accuracy of their reporting or integrity.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:18PM (#38755887)
> more indicative of their relationship to power (largely subservient)

What are you basing this on? From the people I know in federal and state government, this is totally backwards.

> than anything to do with the accuracy of their reporting or integrity

Sure, whatever. The point is is there signal in the noise. And for those publications, there is. In part because they create the signal.

That said, they’re written for decision makers and the civically and commercially engaged. For casual readers, a less-frequent and more-entertaining format is probably a better fit.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by dekhn on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:40PM (#38756113)
I'd love to see some head-to-head comparisons of articles in El Pais that you think are more honest than the New York Times (and I fully accept that the NY Times is the "mouthpiece of the establishment".
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by toyg on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:02PM (#38756327)
Pick pretty much anything in the run up to the Iraq invasion. From what I remember, it was a nadir of US journalism. Generally speaking, any time there is military US intervention somewhere, American publications toe the line in embarrassing ways.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by dekhn on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:46PM (#38756678)
Do you have links to actual articles about current events?

If you read the Times, you'll notice that for the first week the mostly print the establishment view (america war good) but then after that, they start publishing the more critical articles.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by bugglebeetle on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:33PM (#38757060)
Later countering the propaganda they uncritically (some might argue, intentionally) spread in the first place does not argue in their favor.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by dekhn on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:49PM (#38757226)
I'm still waiting to see some links to head-to-head articles posted contemporaneously so I can compare.

Experts who read the NY Times know how to read through the intentional narrative/propaganda (which is mainly meant to capture the hearts and minds of the young and naive) to understand the underlying reality.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by bugglebeetle on Sunday December 24, 2023 @05:02PM (#38757351)
> Experts who read the NY Times know how to read through the intentional narrative/propaganda

The parent already cited the Iraq War coverage, in which they incited the country to violence with known lies, leading to hundreds of thousands of innocent civilian deaths. If this isn’t enough to swear you off their coverage, I honestly don’t know what else would.

But to your point, the NY Times has millions of readers and this is a very small subsection of their audience. Which do you think is a more important function of journalism: lying to the masses in a way that is understood to be propaganda by your so-called “experts” or telling the majority of people the truth in the first place?

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by notjoemama on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:38PM (#38755520)
Good point, so when it’s a non-adversarial country then different reporting has the potential to be more honest reporting.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by mvdtnz on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:18PM (#38756470)
Both are bad but there is a qualitative difference between the badness of USA's global objectives and China's global objectives, and the means by which they work towards these objectives. The equivalence people draw between western powers and China is really puzzling to me. And no, I'm not American and I am no fan of American foreign policy.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by ZoomerCretin on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:31PM (#38757049)
The United States has a history going back a full century of directly and indirectly forcing extremely violent changes in government when foreign governments are insufficiently deferential to American political/economic interests. Kissinger's state department alone aided and abetted multiple genocides and the deaths of over a million civilians.

Not only has the PRC never done this, they take the public stance that they have absolutely no interest in this, and publicly espouse the principle of non-interference in the internal affairs of other countries. The only obvious Chinese global objective is a world where they exist as a non-ideological economic partner willing to profit from trade without strings attached, like America's enforced austerity and privatization "reforms".

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by ajross on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:03PM (#38756838)
> How this is different from Meta's "reduction" of pro-Palestinian posts exposure and preventing it from spreading too far?

Presumably because Palestine is one salient issue, being moderated at a time of extreme engagement, while the linked article asserts a pattern of such moderation across the site.

It's the difference between "This subreddit doesn't allow political discussion" and "conservative topics are banned on Reddit".

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by avalys on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:55PM (#38755647)
Speaking as an American, yes, it is most definitely "us vs. them".

China is a geopolitical enemy ruled by a communist dictatorship that wants to diminish America's power, standing, and influence in the world to advance their own. American power and the mere threat of bringing it to bear on our adversaries is what enabled the past three decades of peace, prosperity and progress throughout the world, and China is actively working to undermine and diminish it in favor of their own.

Asking for some kind of balance or symmetry here is like saying it's unfair that fighter jets drop bombs on the enemy and not their own side. Yes, that's the whole point. We win, they lose.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by toyg on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:08PM (#38756388)
Ah yes - peace in Iraq, Syria, Afghanistan, Libya, Serbia, Rwanda... Much peace, such prosperity.

I wouldn't choose China over the US any day of the week, but over the last 3 decades they've objectively been more pacifist and prosperous than most US client states. Please tone down the jingo.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by xenospn on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:50PM (#38757244)
I’m not so sure that China is “pacifist and prosperous” compared to the US. What I am sure of is that you just have not heard of many cases where they haven’t been, because it’s China.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by janalsncm on Sunday December 24, 2023 @05:10PM (#38757440)
There’s no question that the average person in any random country has more to worry about from the United States than China. Whether the U.S. or China is a nicer country to live in is a different question.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by Duya-Taksis on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @12:35PM (#38773841)
"China is a geopolitical enemy ruled by a communist dictatorship that wants to diminish America's power, standing, and influence in the world to advance their own. American power and the mere threat of bringing it to bear on our adversaries is what enabled the past three decades of peace, prosperity and progress throughout the world, and China is actively working to undermine and diminish it in favor of their own."

Exactly. Godspeed to China and I hope it stomps the US into the dirt.

"Asking for some kind of balance or symmetry here is like saying it's unfair that fighter jets drop bombs on the enemy and not their own side. Yes, that's the whole point. We win, they lose."

Except it's the other way around. China wins and you lose. Again and again and again.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by avalys on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @07:56AM (#38781504)
“A boot stomping on a human face, forever.”
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by goalieca on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:26PM (#38755423)
Meta is run by billionaires acting in their own self interest and it’s obvious when often in conflict with the USA government. TikTok parent company is accountable to the government of China.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by foverzar on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:19PM (#38756953)
This is a naive reductionism.

Also, the fact that Meta employs lots of spooks is commonly perceived as "Meta is accountable to the US government", which is no less reductionist.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by goalieca on Sunday December 24, 2023 @08:25PM (#38758714)
It’s not naive at all. Corporate dynamics are widely different in China. In China there is no strong separation between corporations and government.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by foverzar on Saturday January 06, 2024 @02:46PM (#38894685)
Corporate dynamics is different across any culture.

> In China there is no strong separation between corporations and government.

Is there even a country where that's actually a thing? It's definitely the opposite of "strong separation" in the US, just look at the lobbying institution.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by slowhadoken on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:04PM (#38755736)
They’re both bad but foreign propaganda is worse.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by kortilla on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:02PM (#38755713)
Whataboutism

Let’s talk about the article maybe?

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by foverzar on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:27PM (#38757016)
> Whataboutism

Comparisons and distinctions are the most natural way to perceive, learn and reason about stuff.

The motivation that drives people to attack attempts of building a frame of reference is always suspicious.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by peepeepoopoo54 on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:29PM (#38756568)
> Whataboutism

You invented a word to defend the hypocrisy of our government that could just as easily have come from George Orwell's description of Newspeak in 1984. Doubleplusungood. Dwell on that for a moment.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by abricot on Sunday December 24, 2023 @03:44PM (#38756655)
kortilla didn't invent it. It was coined in the 1970s.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by peepeepoopoo54 on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:32PM (#38757055)
It wasn't popularized until the last few years.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by kortilla on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:32PM (#38766322)
By me?
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:19PM (#38755357)
EDIT: Nvm, misread the Appendix. They’re dampening pro-Israel, pro-Ukraine and anti-Trump content.

> Can we look both of them objectively and say both are bad (I think so), or is there us vs. them mentality?

Yes. That doesn’t preclude classifying how they are bad, both commonly and uniquely.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by Adverblessly on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:33PM (#38755478)
I think you misread it, the linked study shows that HamasIsIsis is also a suppressed tag. They are suppressing pro-Israel content and promoting pro-Palestine content.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:41PM (#38755552)
You’re right. Thank you.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by bayindirh on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:24PM (#38755391)
It was a honest question. I have no TikTok account, and not opening Facebook app more than a year now. I just share some photography I do on Instagram, but it doesn't cross post to Facebook either.

So, I just wanted to ask and learn.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:25PM (#38755407)
I also have neither. I’m just citing the paper. Reading it might be a good start.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by bayindirh on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:27PM (#38755434)
It's sitting on my printer's output tray, however I have more pressing matters now. I'll go through it tomorrow.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:30PM (#38755457)
> however I have more pressing matters now

This is rude. You’re implicitly valuing everyone else’s time less than yours. (Not bad. Just rude.)

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by bayindirh on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:39PM (#38755542)
Nope. I didn't say I did not open/skimmed it. I looked into it, got a couple of questions and asked it, and you answered it, and I thanked you in a long form.

If I didn't value your time or anyone else's, I can write short/snarky answers and/or leave you hanging.

Lastly, insinuating that someone didn't read the article is also rude, and against the guidelines, too.

> Please don't comment on whether someone read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that".

Have a nice day, and a nice year.

[dead]
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by notjoemama on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:31PM (#38755461)
Following your value statements, somehow we’re just supposed to ignore the CCP policy of US accelerationism? Like I said in another comment (here I will point out the paper says this) the difference is a political party in China manipulating content behind the scenes and Instagram manipulating content based on their publicly available content policy. Additionally the former is specifically geared towards CCP interests, not based on citizens outlook or morality, whereas Instagram attempts to cater to what they believe is the moral perspective of their users.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:32PM (#38755467)
> the difference is a political party in China manipulating content behind the scene

It’s also meaningful that it’s China. They’re an adversary. This would be very different if we were talking about France or India.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by notjoemama on Sunday December 24, 2023 @01:42PM (#38755562)
And to underscore that, the CCP has openly said and planned to be the dominate financial, political, and military force on the globe. Their intention and actions are exactly to reduce not just US influence but all other influence. Neither France nor India take that stand point. A country hell bent on global domination has never worked anyway.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by woooooo on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:39PM (#38756106)
Do you have a quote from anybody you're basing that on?
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by superduty on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:00PM (#38755690)
It’s not.

This nonsense was created as fodder for incompetent and dishonest politicians.

You’ll now hear the least competent ones exclaim things like “a rutgers study says China bad, China spy, China control of social media not same as US government control of social media ugg ugg fire fire”.

Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by Zetobal on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:09PM (#38755781)
Pretty much acts like an enemy state since the 60s but maybe we are all hallucinating for decades.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by woooooo on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:35PM (#38756064)
That's a pretty strong statement covering a long period of time with radically different Chinese governments.
Re:Study: TikTok Global Platform Anomalies Align with CCP Ge... by Hnrobert42 on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:52PM (#38757264)
See also, whataboutism.