Duya-Taksis
China's population is more than 4x America's. If a billion people vanished from China, it would still be more populous than America. America is the one with the demographic problem, not China. China has at least 20 years of urbanization left, with people moving from unproductive agrarian work into the cities.
Furthermore, the government has plenty of policy space to implement pro-natal programs. Before you even think it - no, they work. Coordinated, consistent pro-natal policy can and does routinely lift birth rates.
China is rocketing up the value chain on every single metric. It just installed more industrial robots this year than the rest of the world combined. Investment , both state and private, is pouring into renewable energy, EVs, semiconductors, advanced manufacturing, biotech, aerospace, etc.
China's government, for whatever problems it has, is simply the most effective on competent ever devised. It outclasses every other government on Earth, it isn't even close.
You and your fellow Americans need to open your eyes and understand your diminished and ever-diminishing place in the world.
Exactly. Godspeed to China and I hope it stomps the US into the dirt.
"Asking for some kind of balance or symmetry here is like saying it's unfair that fighter jets drop bombs on the enemy and not their own side. Yes, that's the whole point. We win, they lose."
Except it's the other way around. China wins and you lose. Again and again and again.
Yet that's exactly what you're doing.
"But they also face enormous problems due to unfavorable geography, lack of key natural resources, corruption, malinvestment, and demographic collapse."
None of these things are true. Stop consuming intellectual droppings from the likes of Peter Zeihan.
China has a monopoly on rare earths and more importantly, processing technologies, which are the key resources for a technological society. It's rapidly transitioning its grid and transportation systems to run on renewable power. Over the next decade it will do in hydrogen what it did in solar and wind. That will give it total self sufficiency in critical inputs like ammonia and synthetic fuels.
Corruption was an issue before Xi's anti-corruption drive. Corruption was wonderful when it served American interests, when the CIA was paying out the bribes. Now that the CIA networks have been torn up and the corrupt officials put behind bars and executed, the US cries that China is "increasingly authoritarian." Well, the louder the US cries, the more I know China is on the right path.
Malinvestment? That's rich coming from an OnlyFans economy like America. You people can't even make enough artillery shells to send to Ukraine. You're being outbuilt by an order of magnitude by Russia, a country you mock as having an economy the size of Texas. Your GDP is entirely hot air and all you make is noise.
As for demography, that's the last thin reed you have to hang all your ill wishes toward China on. Unfortunately for you, that's changing for the better. The Chinese government has shifted from an anti-natal/neutral policy to a pro-natal one and will introduce a raft of policies to boost birth rates. Before you even think that that never works, it does work. It worked in Hungary and it will work far better in China, where the Chinese government can pull many more levers than the Hungarian government can.
Incidentally, the biggest block to Chinese people marrying and having children is the high cost of housing. Guess what the deflating housing bubble is going to do for that.
"These problems are not getting better, and I won't be surprised if there's a violent civil war in 30 years"
I've just demonstrated that they either don't exist or they are getting much better. If you want to look for violent civil wars, look to the US. You won't have to wait 30 years.
"as has happened many times over millennia of Chinese history"
China has millennia of history. Let's see the US make it to 300 years.