But the thing is, historically most governments kept those factors well regulated so that the government had a coarse control over that ratio. (A noisy but effective control.) But at the 2000's crisis, the US decided to loose their regulations so that there the ratio is completely defined by the market.
What that means is that no, it's not obvious that the dollar inflation is coming from the inflated money supply. But that's a problem by itself.
https://tradingeconomics.com/united-states/inflation-cpi (click max)
Except for housing, food, healthcare, education, transportation, and energy. But yeah besides the eye watering increases in the prices of the things that make up the overwhelming majority of the typical household’s spending prices have barely increased. In fact you can get a bigger TV for less money!
CPI includes all of those in the proportion in which they are paid for by consumers (rather than through taxation.)
Shelter, 32.8%
Food, 13.3%
Tuition, other school fees, and childcare, 2.2%
Medical care, 6.9%
Transport, 6.0%
Energy: 7.6%
https://finance.yahoo.com/news/foolish-why-inflation-rate-wo...Well, what you seem to be describing is M2, aka actual money available for spending. Which is a rather large factor in the general price level.
Think about it this way: How can M2 increase without M0 also increasing? Then we can look at those mechanisms and determine if they are to "blame" for the recent price increases. I think they are not.
It is quite simple. There are no reserve requirements anymore.
For every $1 in notes and coins, there are about $30 in bank deposits that exist as a number on a spreadsheet somewhere. So instead of actually printing more, when the central bank "prints money" it means they edit the number in their spreadsheet, increasing their own bank balance. Then they spend that balance buying things like government bonds and treasury bills (which also exist only on spreadsheets)
Banks lending is an increase in the money supply.
When you own a house and there is a cafe in that house which pays rent even though it is closed, because it gets the money from some governmental covid assistance program, then you do not have to pay the money back and can spend it consumer goods and drive prices up.
Wealthy people borrow against their equity all of the time to avoid taxes while funding their lavish lifestyles.
This after-tax money needs to have been pre-tax money at some point, so therefore, they do pay taxes at some point. Just not income tax presumably, but something akin to capital gains tax (e.g., sell off some of their assets/equity to pay interest). It's a lower tax rate, but in absolute terms, it's still a large numbner.
This doesn't reflect consumer behavior. Just consider a simple example ignoring future income. Say I have 520k. I buy a 500k house. Scenario 1. I buy it with cash and I have 20k left. Scenario 2. I buy it with a mortgage (20% down), and how have 420k left.
It's easy to see why those in scenario 2 would continue to fund lifestyle choices like eating out.
The reality that they need to pay back that debt gets moved to the future. The future also provides additional income. So the need to pay it back gets delayed, meaning money available now is freed up for lifestyle choices.
I think is reasonable to think that low interest rates pulls consumer spending from the future into the present, when compared to higher interest on lending.
High inflation also spurs consumer spending because the return on savings is less.
back to housing, My experience is that personal spending is waaay down after buying a house, because I now need to service 1.2M of debt every year, which is about 80k.
The point is, that creation of debt does not immediately net cancel out to a no-op in terms of consideration for monetary inflation.
This is all in response to the comment several steps up "Banks lending is an increase in the money supply" and the commenter who presumably disagreed with that by saying that one will not spend that money in the economy because they have to pay it back.
If the person that lent you the 400k don't have them at their disposal then the total amount of money at the disposal of someone in the economy didn't change after your transaction.
You are right because banks can create money.
Aren’t almost all fancy restaurant visits paid with money lent from the bank (credit cards)?
Given the amount of people with insurmountable credit card debt and nothing to show for it except Instagram pictures, I'd say you're not entirely correct.
And when the loan is paid off, it correspondingly decreases.
Joseph Stiglitz, Nobel Prize winning economist, has said that most of the inflation we saw was markups - ie firms raising their prices due to inadequate amount of competition.
Here is an 50 min long talk on the subject https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4BAsZIHp9HI&t=1217s
The idea that the expansion of money supply led to the price increases seems to be mostly a media narrative. Many people believe it however.
Edit: it actually does correlate with deficit spending, but only because the last two major deficit spending increases were 2008-2010 and Covid. So it's pretty hard to say deficit spending in particular was causal (as opposed to, say, near-zero interest rates combined with industry consolidation).
What, then, caused the 40:1 inflation?
> if you believe people being much more knowledgable about those things
My father was head of the business department at a college and taught finance. He had an encyclopedic knowledge of how money worked. He had a degree in economics from MIT and an MBA from Harvard and a PhD in history from KSU.
We had a lot of discussions about this.
But since he has passed on, you might be interested in "Monetary History of the United States" by Milton Friedman.
Lots of things, government deficit spending being only one of them. What % of causality can be assigned to deficit spending vs. other causes is something I will leave to the experts.
> My father
Knowledge of finance and history is great, but it's not a substitute for actually being an economist.
As for the "degree in economics", lots of people out there have an undergrad economics degree, including me. That doesn't make me an economist any more than my other undergrad degree (math) makes me a mathematician.
One thing that I'm sure you already know about history is that causality is not a constant thing over time. Something can cause inflation in the 1990s, and a completely different process can cause inflation in the 2020s.
I think we all agree that government deficit spending can cause inflation, and is one possible cause to be investigated among others. Is it the sole cause of all inflation in the last 40 years? Is that causality even possible to determine from the data? I suggest that nobody can be both intellectually honest and confident in answering those questions.
Unless you're willing to stake your own expertise against Joseph Stiglitz and Robert Reich, then I respectfully suggest you should back off from your confidence in what you personally believe is happening in the economy.
And yes, I would say the same to Stiglitz if he had a habit of complaining about the D compiler design in economics forums.
> I think we all agree that government deficit spending can cause inflation
If it is borrowed money that is then paid back, it does not cause inflation. If it is borrowed money that is financed by borrowing more money, it does (not "can") cause inflation.
> Is it the sole cause of all inflation in the last 40 years?
Nothing else explains the increase in the quantity of money relative to the value of goods & services in it.
> Unless you're willing to stake your own expertise against Joseph Stiglitz and Robert Reich
Appeal to Authority is a logical fallacy. Remember all the appeals to authority with Fauci, who was upset that people would not accept his pronouncements as the truth, especially after he was found to be lying? Reich is either a fool or a liar. I don't know anything about Stiglitz. I've read enough of Krugman to know he's a fool.
> I would say the same to Stiglitz if he had a habit of complaining about the D compiler design in economics forums.
It's a poor analogy because I have a lifetime of personal experience with economics, I've run successful businesses, I manage investments for several people, and I've read economics texts by Nobel prize winning economists.
Some would call it "common sense."
I'd contend that costs going up is _a_ cause of price increases.
The reason a soda costs more from a movie theater than a supermarket is not because a soda costs more to make in the movie theater, for instance.
but if that was true, why did it happen only during the pandemic and not before?
At any point in time, if a business felt like their customer could've paid more, the business should be increasing that price. So the recent price rises cannot be explained with this train of argument.
Unless, of course, the pandemic somehow made it so that people could pay more.
When consumers start reducing demand, or substituting other products things will change - I’ve already started changing my behaviour - but it takes a little while, you buy a $7 jar of mustard, $12 bag of granola, or a $30 hotel margarita - and you’re f** that never doing that again, but it feels like it takes a while for that to work its way through the system.
M2 money supply, please read the part where the formula changed in 2020: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2SL
> I know that most people say that M0 is only a small factor in price increase and other factors like credit given by banks, the speed at which money moves and spendin/saving behavior play a bigger role. But I doubt that.
Please don’t take offense, but I doubt that you understand what you’re talking about given the fact that you confused monetary base and money supply.
“I’m not an economist but here is my …”
edit Joseph Stiglitz, Nobel Prize winning economist, has said that most of the inflation we saw was markups - ie firms raising their prices due to inadequate amount of competition.
Here is an 50 min long talk on the subject https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4BAsZIHp9HI&t=1217s
Its refreshing when the vast majority of online discourse about inflation is just shouting “We have inflation because business are so much more greedy than they have EVER been!!!!”
Here is an 50 min long talk on the subject https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4BAsZIHp9HI&t=1217s
Let me know where he's wrong.
His point is basically that the most recent inflation was caused by a supply shock and high uncertainty, not aggregate demand from fiscal policy, and that broad monetary tightening is a worse strategy for calming this kind of inflation than <insert set of> targeted policies. None of this is “evil corporation have monopoly.” The example he even uses for service side under-supply is a local mechanic, hardly what people think of as “big business monopoly”
He was wrong about not getting real wage growth, which did appear just months after this was posted, and is now back on track. But it’s not key to his argument, just an interesting thing I noticed.
I watched it months ago and I had the idea that he said that most of inflation was markups due to lack of competition. But I might be thinking of someone else, like Steve Keen.
Don't fall for the "appeal to authority" fallacy.
Often times they seem to have just read the papers that justify something they already believe in. Economics in particular is not a science and extremely dangerous one to have "opinions" about, since I feel like it's got a heavy ideological bent forced unto it due to political considerations.
There are economists like Steve Keen and Joseph Stiglitz who seem to make sense to me, and then there seems to be a lot of gobblygook. But I'm not an expert nor would I say I categorically know what I'm talking about in this area. I just try my best to listen.
> There are economists like Steve Keen and Joseph Stiglitz who seem to make sense to me, and then there seems to be a lot of gobblygook.
Seems at odds. Even further when you say:
> Often times they seem to have just read the papers that justify something they already believe in. Economics in particular is not a science and extremely dangerous one to have "opinions" about, since I feel like it's got a heavy ideological bent forced unto it due to political considerations.
> HN is particularly arrogant about some subjects, because it seems like having read a few papers, some people think they know more than experts in the field.
Apt. Just wish it would apply to you and not everyone else.
It is entirely possible I am also falling victim to the same trap, that's not something I would ever deny. But repeating what you heard from an economist in a mainstream publication just leads to mostly repeating falsehoods, since economists who get heard in the mainstream media seem to me to be often ideological.
It was the first time I followed an economist from 0 to 100 and it all made sense. Yet he's considered an outlier, but he is also considered to be one of the few people who correctly predicted the 2008 crash.
In a free market you can't have an inadequate amount of competition. If he is right, it means that regulations hampered competition.
He doesn’t agree with you. He has a great podcast called Debunking Economics.
Why do you think that? Suppose that Treasury minted $100,000,000,000,000,000 in coins and locked them up in Fort Knox and never spent them. By what mechanism would that increase in the money supply drive up prices?
And it’s not just mere spending either, but how it’s spent matters. One of the reasons the government has been able to issue trillions of new dollars a year for the past decade and a half with relatively little inflation is that most of that money was captured by a relatively small number of ultra high net worth persons who mostly hoard it and don’t appreciably change their expenditures except of course on finance assets, which observably have inflated like crazy.
However, in 2020 when government started spending new money into the hands if average citizens then inflation started to skyrocket.
I don’t understand why this is hard for people when it’s been so clearly observable. It’s a cautionary tale against letting ideology override evidence I suppose.
There are no Scrooge McDuck cash vaults.
Did I not make that clear? I said that they "don’t appreciably change their expenditures except of course on finance (sic) assets, which observably have inflated like crazy."
I dislike the lazy and misleading usage of "investing" for a simple asset swap of cash for already issued financial assets, even though that's what most people mean by the term. That is a savings reallocation. Investing is when you actually allocate new capital, so for example buying into an IPO, a public offering, angel investing, buying equipment, and so on.
> Rich people do not hoard cash. They invest it, all of it. Even money deposited in a bank account gets invested, as the bank loans it out.
Banks don't loan deposits, but rather loan origination creates deposits. You're a very smart guy, take some time to learn how the banking system actually works.
> There are no Scrooge McDuck cash vaults.
The Federal Reserve Bank of New York has entered the chat.[1]
> Did I not make that clear?
You wrote: "ultra high net worth persons who mostly hoard it"
> Banks don't loan deposits, but rather loan origination creates deposits. You're a very smart guy, take some time to learn how the banking system actually works.
The banks cannot loan money out unless they have reserves on deposit. Yes I know about fractional reserve banking, but those reserves come from deposits. That's why banks give out free checking. They can loan a multiple out of the cash on deposit. It's also why they have minimum deposit levels.
Take some time yourself :-)
"No individuals or private sector entities are permitted to store gold in the vault." -- from your cite
I thought it was clear that the sentence after modified that.
Although you need to ask yourself, when those UHNWIs spend a billion dollars cash on stocks and bonds, where does that cash go? It doesn't just disappear into the ether, it becomes the seller's deposit, and now the seller is holding the cash. So yeah, at the end of the day (literally, payments settle at the end of the day), somebody is holding that cash, and that somebody is the ultra rich and banking institutions, trusts, and various other entities that they own, with public pension funds taking up some of the slack. It's much clearer if you stop think of it as "investing" and start think of it as what it is, an asset swap. Namely swapping cash for equity or debt.
> The banks cannot loan money out unless they have reserves on deposit. Yes I know about fractional reserve banking, but those reserves come from deposits. That's why banks give out free checking. They can loan a multiple out of the cash on deposit. It's also why they have minimum deposit levels.
Nope. Reserves come from the Federal Reserve, they're a different thing. That's right, the money in your deposit account and the money banks use for interbank payments are different "data types" that happen to share the same unit of account.
Banks can and do originate loans in any amount they deem fit when they have a creditworthy borrower. When Mr Banker is deciding whether or not to extend your business a 10 million dollar line of credit, he doesn't call Fred down in the Vault Department to check if there is enough in the money bin or reserve account to originate the loan. He simply sends it off to underwriting, sees if they think your business is creditworthy, and if so originates the loan, which creates a loan liability and a deposit asset on the business's ledger and a loan asset and deposit liability on the bank's ledger. Reserves are not at all involved in the loan origination process. Then before close of business the bank acquires any necessary reserves on the interbank market or from the discount window. And those reserves will always, in aggregate, be available, because the 0th law of the Federal Reserve is "thou shalt maintain the integrity of the interbank payment system."[1]
The fact that reserves have no direct effect on loan origination is precisely why banks are now required to meet capital requirements in addition to reserve "requirements."
> Take some time yourself :-)
I have. Like I said, you're objectively wrong about this. If you're ok with that state of affairs then fine, but since this site is about knowledge and I have great respect for you I thought I'd share.
> "No individuals or private sector entities are permitted to store gold in the vault." -- from your cite
That was mostly humorous. But yeah, money bins are for the elite. Sovereign wealth funds and such.
Incidentally this is true for reserves as well. Individuals are not permitted to open a reserve account at a Federal Reserve Bank. The only way we can actually obtain and hold reserves is via physical Federal Reserve Notes. Obviously that's got a lot of considerable drawbacks, although I'd bet dollars to donuts that the ultra wealthy probably keep somewhere between a hundred thousand and a million bucks in paper money reasonably close at hand for reasons analogous to why normal people have a change jar.
> Reserves come from the Federal Reserve
Sigh. Remember that Silicon Valley Bank that went bust recently because it didn't have enough on deposit to cover customer redemptions?
> I'd bet dollars to donuts that the ultra wealthy probably keep somewhere between a hundred thousand and a million bucks in paper money reasonably close at hand
You'd lose that bet. There's simply no reason to do that other than if you're doing illegal money laundering.
> Banks can and do originate loans in any amount they deem fit when they have a creditworthy borrower.
No, they have to meet the reserve ratio. Otherwise, they wouldn't offer free checking.
To highlight your ignorance let’s avoid distractions and focus on this one point: if the filthy rich don’t have most of the cash, who does? Who has 31 trillion dollars in cash, and isn’t filthy rich?
Remember that cash always exists. If Mr Filthy spends a billion to buy stock from Mr Rich, now Mr Rich holds that billion in cash. That cash billion is always going to be in play.
What chain of accounting operations do you imagine take place that allow the UHNWI sector to divest itself of cash nearly entirely and who is going to hold that cash once they have?
> You'd lose that bet. There's simply no reason to do that other than if you're doing illegal money laundering.
In my personal experience, which is to say the VHNWIs I’ve known (owns property outright in Tokyo, Hamptons, NYC central park overlook, bentley, that kind of guy) it’s been for drugs. An awful lot of blow mainly. I’ve never to my knowledge met an UHNWI so sure I’m extrapolating, but I’m pretty sure the kind of oil sheikh who flies around his arabian stallions and camel herd with him on his private 747 has a mil or two cash handy for whatever.
It's 2 trillion, not 31. https://www.uscurrency.gov/life-cycle/data/circulation
As to who has it, it's in circulation. It's being used to buy goods and services, and then the merchant does nightly drops to the bank, who credits it to the merchant's account, then hands out the cash for withdrawals and loans.
I would presume that much of the cash in circulation is in the untracked illegal economy, as the cash isn't traceable. Drug dealers hoard millions in cash because no bank will take it.
> If Mr Filthy spends a billion to buy stock from Mr Rich, now Mr Rich holds that billion in cash.
Using emotionally laden words doesn't make your case more compelling. Be that as it may, nobody buys stock anymore with cash. I've been buying stock my entire adult life, never with cash.
> it’s been for drugs
I.e. the black market, which I already allowed runs on cash.
> I’m pretty sure the kind of oil sheikh who flies around his arabian stallions and camel herd with him on his private 747 has a mil or two cash handy for whatever.
Speculation. But indeed, some rich people may have large quantities of cash on hand for use in the black market. After all, an illegal arms dealer isn't going to take your credit card. But that's not hoarding cash, either.
To save you some trouble using the rough figure of 115 million “banked” households if you want to claim it’s spread around that would require the median household to have approximately $174,000 in demand deposits, so it’s certainly not there.
Again, you said the ultra rich don’t hold that $20 trillion. Then who does?
Frankly I think you’re just extrapolating incorrectly from your flawed understanding of the banking system and your own presumably HNWI savings allocations. I agree it can be a bit tough to understand there are folks out there for whom a million in notes and coins is a lesser percentage of their net worth than the change in your change jar is of yours.
> there are folks out there for whom a million in notes and coins is a lesser percentage of their net worth than the change in your change jar is of yours.
You argued before that they were hoarding most of their wealth. Now it's a tiny percentage.
Bezos (and other billionaires) were in the paper recently for funding their cash needs by borrowing. Why would they borrow if they had a cash hoard? It doesn't make any sense.
No, it doesn't. Banks don't loan out deposits; banks originating loans create deposits. It's basic double entry bookkeeping. Your deposit asset is the bank's liability.
Here is a basic, simplified, but essentially correct model:
1) Credit worthy borrower Alice approaches a bank to borrow $1,000,000 to buy some real asset worth $1,000,000 from Bob. Maybe a house, maybe a business, whatever, doesn't really matter.
2) Bank performs underwriting and determines that Alice is in deed credit worthy. Now bank performs the following four operations simultaneously (This is where we simplify, we're assuming Alice and Bob use the same bank to avoid bringing interbank payments in, and other possible complications like an escrow party, but all those extra steps sum out to equivalent to the simple model).
3) Create a deposit in Bob's account for $1,000,000.
4) Create a corresponding liability on bank's account for $1,000,000, corresponding to Bob's deposit.
5) Create a liability on Alice's account with the bank for $1,000,000.
6) Create a corresponding asset on the bank's account for $1,000,000. This is the asset that banks sell when they sell a loan.
At this point the bank has created $1,000,000 that Bob is going to spend as he pleases, but the bank's total net worth is unchanged, since the bank's new liability is equaled by its new asset. And the bank then expects to earn a return on that asset based on the terms of whatever the loan agreement are.
Now at this point you're going to object about fractional reserve requirements. As it happens they actually never constrained loan origination because the Fed had to supply the exact amount of reserves after the fact, in aggregate, that the banking system required for the loans it originated, because if it didn't the interbank payment system would seize up. However that's quite complicated to demonstrate and I'm not up for it[1].
But fortunately we can ignore that, because there are no reserve requirements anymore[2]:
As announced on March 15, 2020, the Board reduced reserve requirement ratios to zero percent effective March 26, 2020. This action eliminated reserve requirements for all depository institutions.
> You argued before that they were hoarding most of their wealth. Now it's a tiny percentage.Tiny percentage of notes and coins. Not M1 cash. And you still haven't answered, who is holding that $20 trillion in M1 cash? If the ultra high net worth individuals are all divesting themselves of all their M1 cash, someone has to be their counterparty. Who?
[1] It is worth understanding though if you're interested. The shocking thing is that reserves and deposits (and coins too, but they're a tiny percentage of outstanding cash money) are entirely different "data types"! They just both happen to be denominated in the same unit of account. Naturally that's not a coincidence but a property of how the modern banking system has been constructed. Reserves mainly come into play for interbank payments and federal government spending. Incidentally coins are also a different type from paper money. That's not particularly relevant to the topic at hand, but the existence of that rabbit hole serves to show just how interesting and complex the money system actually is.
[2] https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/reservereq.htm
Sorry, but that's what they do. You don't agree, so there's nothing further to talk about.
> Bob transfers the real asset to Alice.
I.e. the bank loaned out Bob's deposit to Alice. The rest is just accounting machinations. Yes, I understand double entry bookkeeping. I got an A on that course (!) and I've been doing the the accounting for my business ever since.
Agreed. One cannot educate the obstinate, and you are obstinately clinging to your ignorance here.
Here[1] for example is another explanation and you can easily find more from sources as authoritative as the central banks themselves, who I think we can both agree have a better grasp on the operational mechanics of banking than either of us. I won’t bother to provide those additional links for obvious reasons.
Nevertheless perhaps one day you’ll stop believing the fairy tale version of banking you learned as a boy, and when you do you can refer back.
[1] https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/022416/why-b...
The house my brother lives in was sold in 2011 for less than what the owners paid for it in 2006.
Now, its up 2.5x from what he paid.
Honestly, how can you be this dense. The difference in the past years wasn't QE or "money printing", it was that the government performed fiscal stimulus, which tends to put money into the hands of people more than letting their bank account be backed by government bonds.
The Economics Explained yotuber made a video about how hyperinflation is already there using a similar graph and where is it exactly?
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/BOGMBASE
The amount of products and service we produce probably did not.
Most people think that M0 is only a small factor in price increase and other factors like credit given by banks, the speed at which money moves and spending/saving behavior play a bigger role. But I doubt that. To me, it seems those are all indirect, delayed outcomes of the money supply. So we don't see the prices increase linearly and instantly with the increase of the monetary base. But we see it eventually.