“I’m not an economist but here is my …”
edit Joseph Stiglitz, Nobel Prize winning economist, has said that most of the inflation we saw was markups - ie firms raising their prices due to inadequate amount of competition.
Here is an 50 min long talk on the subject https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4BAsZIHp9HI&t=1217s
Its refreshing when the vast majority of online discourse about inflation is just shouting “We have inflation because business are so much more greedy than they have EVER been!!!!”
Here is an 50 min long talk on the subject https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4BAsZIHp9HI&t=1217s
Let me know where he's wrong.
His point is basically that the most recent inflation was caused by a supply shock and high uncertainty, not aggregate demand from fiscal policy, and that broad monetary tightening is a worse strategy for calming this kind of inflation than <insert set of> targeted policies. None of this is “evil corporation have monopoly.” The example he even uses for service side under-supply is a local mechanic, hardly what people think of as “big business monopoly”
He was wrong about not getting real wage growth, which did appear just months after this was posted, and is now back on track. But it’s not key to his argument, just an interesting thing I noticed.
I watched it months ago and I had the idea that he said that most of inflation was markups due to lack of competition. But I might be thinking of someone else, like Steve Keen.
Don't fall for the "appeal to authority" fallacy.
Often times they seem to have just read the papers that justify something they already believe in. Economics in particular is not a science and extremely dangerous one to have "opinions" about, since I feel like it's got a heavy ideological bent forced unto it due to political considerations.
There are economists like Steve Keen and Joseph Stiglitz who seem to make sense to me, and then there seems to be a lot of gobblygook. But I'm not an expert nor would I say I categorically know what I'm talking about in this area. I just try my best to listen.
> There are economists like Steve Keen and Joseph Stiglitz who seem to make sense to me, and then there seems to be a lot of gobblygook.
Seems at odds. Even further when you say:
> Often times they seem to have just read the papers that justify something they already believe in. Economics in particular is not a science and extremely dangerous one to have "opinions" about, since I feel like it's got a heavy ideological bent forced unto it due to political considerations.
> HN is particularly arrogant about some subjects, because it seems like having read a few papers, some people think they know more than experts in the field.
Apt. Just wish it would apply to you and not everyone else.
It is entirely possible I am also falling victim to the same trap, that's not something I would ever deny. But repeating what you heard from an economist in a mainstream publication just leads to mostly repeating falsehoods, since economists who get heard in the mainstream media seem to me to be often ideological.
It was the first time I followed an economist from 0 to 100 and it all made sense. Yet he's considered an outlier, but he is also considered to be one of the few people who correctly predicted the 2008 crash.
In a free market you can't have an inadequate amount of competition. If he is right, it means that regulations hampered competition.
M2 money supply, please read the part where the formula changed in 2020: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M2SL
> I know that most people say that M0 is only a small factor in price increase and other factors like credit given by banks, the speed at which money moves and spendin/saving behavior play a bigger role. But I doubt that.
Please don’t take offense, but I doubt that you understand what you’re talking about given the fact that you confused monetary base and money supply.