News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Are Things Expensive? by nerdponx on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @01:31AM (#38692531)
In this case it also correlates with corporate profits.

Edit: it actually does correlate with deficit spending, but only because the last two major deficit spending increases were 2008-2010 and Covid. So it's pretty hard to say deficit spending in particular was causal (as opposed to, say, near-zero interest rates combined with industry consolidation).

Re:Why Are Things Expensive? by WalterBright on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @02:39AM (#38692918)
Any other explanation for inflation has to explain where the extra money comes from. A price increase doesn't create more money.
Re:Why Are Things Expensive? by nerdponx on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @02:42AM (#38692934)
What extra money? You're talking about CPI inflation, not money supply.
Re:Why Are Things Expensive? by WalterBright on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @03:10AM (#38693094)
Prices have doubled in the last 20 years. Where did the extra money to pay those prices come from?
Re:Why Are Things Expensive? by hef19898 on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @05:08AM (#38693839)
Zero interest rates after the 2008 crisis would be my bet, the post-Covid infalation was driven by a significant degree by energy prices and corporate profits. And free money, that only changes as a reaction to said inflation. Just we managed to avoid a 2008-like economic melt down post Covid still puzzles me.
Re:Why Are Things Expensive? by nerdponx on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @11:55AM (#38698045)
My unprofessional opinion is that financial markets absolutely loved Trump, and there was enough economic activity to stave off critical revenue problems in the early days. Then after a few months people started spending as much money as before, they just shifted what they spent it on.
Re:Why Are Things Expensive? by WalterBright on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @01:59PM (#38699926)
Think of all the inflation since 1914. What is it, 40 to 1? Somehow it was all corporate profits?
Re:Why Are Things Expensive? by hef19898 on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @02:13PM (#38700104)
Of course not, claiming that would be rediciulous. The last one, post Covid, seems to be driven partially by corporate profits if you believe people being much more knowledgable about those things than me.
Re:Why Are Things Expensive? by WalterBright on Tuesday December 19, 2023 @03:43PM (#38701249)
> claiming that would be rediciulous.

What, then, caused the 40:1 inflation?

> if you believe people being much more knowledgable about those things

My father was head of the business department at a college and taught finance. He had an encyclopedic knowledge of how money worked. He had a degree in economics from MIT and an MBA from Harvard and a PhD in history from KSU.

We had a lot of discussions about this.

But since he has passed on, you might be interested in "Monetary History of the United States" by Milton Friedman.

Re:Why Are Things Expensive? by nerdponx on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @11:45AM (#38710622)
> What, then, caused the 40:1 inflation?

Lots of things, government deficit spending being only one of them. What % of causality can be assigned to deficit spending vs. other causes is something I will leave to the experts.

> My father

Knowledge of finance and history is great, but it's not a substitute for actually being an economist.

As for the "degree in economics", lots of people out there have an undergrad economics degree, including me. That doesn't make me an economist any more than my other undergrad degree (math) makes me a mathematician.

One thing that I'm sure you already know about history is that causality is not a constant thing over time. Something can cause inflation in the 1990s, and a completely different process can cause inflation in the 2020s.

I think we all agree that government deficit spending can cause inflation, and is one possible cause to be investigated among others. Is it the sole cause of all inflation in the last 40 years? Is that causality even possible to determine from the data? I suggest that nobody can be both intellectually honest and confident in answering those questions.

Unless you're willing to stake your own expertise against Joseph Stiglitz and Robert Reich, then I respectfully suggest you should back off from your confidence in what you personally believe is happening in the economy.

And yes, I would say the same to Stiglitz if he had a habit of complaining about the D compiler design in economics forums.

Re:Why Are Things Expensive? by WalterBright on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @04:20PM (#38713793)
Yes, a degree in economics does make one an economist. So does teaching college level finance courses.

> I think we all agree that government deficit spending can cause inflation

If it is borrowed money that is then paid back, it does not cause inflation. If it is borrowed money that is financed by borrowing more money, it does (not "can") cause inflation.

> Is it the sole cause of all inflation in the last 40 years?

Nothing else explains the increase in the quantity of money relative to the value of goods & services in it.

> Unless you're willing to stake your own expertise against Joseph Stiglitz and Robert Reich

Appeal to Authority is a logical fallacy. Remember all the appeals to authority with Fauci, who was upset that people would not accept his pronouncements as the truth, especially after he was found to be lying? Reich is either a fool or a liar. I don't know anything about Stiglitz. I've read enough of Krugman to know he's a fool.

> I would say the same to Stiglitz if he had a habit of complaining about the D compiler design in economics forums.

It's a poor analogy because I have a lifetime of personal experience with economics, I've run successful businesses, I manage investments for several people, and I've read economics texts by Nobel prize winning economists.

Re:Why Are Things Expensive? by nerdponx on Wednesday December 20, 2023 @05:39PM (#38714595)
I don't know what to say. You're saying appeal to authority is a fallacy, and then invoking your own authority.