News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by markx2 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:07AM (#38629420)
"And my main point is that poverty and privilege are largely accidental. You don’t choose to be born into an income bracket, a country pile, a housing estate, a double barrelled name or a damp tenement bedsit. But ignorance is a choice. And choosing to use your privileges to patronise people whose lives are entirely beyond your experience and comprehension, is a choice."
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by lawn on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:33AM (#38629786)
> But ignorance is a choice.

No, it's not always a choice.

You might be born in a family and community that actively brainwashes their members and prevents you from coming into contact with conflicting information.

This can even be true in less severe circumstances, such as being bombarded with propaganda on social media, which essentially hacks your brain.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by sneed_chucker on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:46AM (#38630007)
Yeah, a very interesting piece of cognitive dissonance is when people are all "a person's behavior is a product of their environment, which they can't be held fully responsible for" until the person in question holds views or engages in behavior that we want to hold them personally accountable for.

I know neither the "product of environment" or "personal responsibility" view is absolute with anyone, but I've noticed that different people draw the line in widely different places.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by hasty_pudding on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:03PM (#38630314)
How is behavior NOT a product of ones environment?

One only has the information to make decisions about the world they have gathered from their environment.

No one is born knowing correct way to behave.

As an example do you think everyone in the Middle East is Muslim because they've made the decision to be? Or because that is what their environment has taught them is correct.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by roflyear on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:47AM (#38630032)
How is that what this author is doing? Did you read the article?
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by dylan604 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:39AM (#38629873)
I too disagree with that statement. Ignorance is just ignorance. What would make the GP's comment more accurate would be willful ignorance, but even that is stretching. To me, willful ignorance is just a sugar coating for a much more accurate/harsh description of what is actually happening.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by ncr100 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:40AM (#38629901)
I had a friend from a rough upbringing who called it, "poverty mindset".

Eg you have a success in your life? Prepare to be shunned and thought of with disdain by your community.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by klyrs on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:59AM (#38630231)
And what do we call it when somebody loses status, and are shunned and thought of with disdain by their community?
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by IMTDb on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:12PM (#38630462)
If it's because of their achievements ? Misplaced jealousy !
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by hnbad on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:05PM (#38630340)
The flip side of this is privilege mindset: you have success in your life? Your upper middle class upbringing, social safety net, financial security and financially successful peer group played no part in it, it's all because you worked hard (or smart) and now enjoy your just desserts, might as well kick down the ladder behind you so those lazy bums don't get a leg up.

Arguably this is more common among privileged folks (including those fleetingly getting a whiff of privilege, aka "temporarily embarrassed billionaires") than "poverty mindset" is among poor folks. And of course the accusation of "poverty mindset" usually isn't what you hear from the kinds like the author who actively take time and money out of their meagerly successful lives to help those worse off than them. It's instead something you're far more likely to hear from those who "made it out" (often "against all odds" without any consideration what the idea of "odds" means in this context) and incidentally don't believe they "owe" anything to those they "left behind".

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by roflyear on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:43AM (#38629952)
It's good to be humbled.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by xeckr on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:45AM (#38629991)
Envy is far from a virtue.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by roflyear on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:46AM (#38629999)
We can't choose how other people behave. We can choose how we react to their behavior.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by Kalium on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:55AM (#38630176)
You can choose to be humbled by the envy of others if you wish. I think you might want to contemplate that this would be a very unusual decision.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by roflyear on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:42AM (#38629944)
When you're a public figure, you hopefully do not have those issues. Any isolation or ignorance is a choice you're making. The author is very obviously not talking about people who are in a cult, or even the average person on Facebook.

They are talking about public figures lecturing poor people on how they should behave.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by toenail on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:27AM (#38629682)
> And choosing to use your privileges to patronise people whose lives are entirely beyond your experience and comprehension, is a choice

Not sure how that way of thinking is productive. Patronising people is bad in itself. Thinking that people you perceive as "privileged" can't comprehend you is a choice too and a form of ignorance.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by eropple on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:32AM (#38629772)
The author did not say can't. In the entire piece, the only person the author used the word can't in reference to was herself, when she was poor. Choice implies a don't and a won't.

But, y'know? When those self-same people go on about how You Can Just Cook when--and this is a keyhole view, a single strand of a very nasty knot, don't you dare well-actually on the vertex and not the shape--poverty is directly tied to mental health problems and the attendant executive dysfunctions that frequently come with? It's reasonable to assume either ignorance or malice (or even, though the author does not, the incapability of can't).

And adjusting one's pince-nez to hmm-hmm-hmm about perhaps it's actually the poors who are ignorant is, to put a point on it, gross.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by sterlind on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:53AM (#38630134)
Especially considering what the author's been through with vindictive council busybodies making her live even that much more difficult out of sheer spite - like when they cut off her bennies before her first check even came in because they'd read about her deal in the paper - I think she held back rather more than I could in such a situation.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by BobaFloutist on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:31AM (#38629758)
She didn't say they "can't", she said that they "don't."

"Beyond your experience and comprehension" doesn't preclude the acquiring of more experience, it just suggests they don't currently have it.

She's pointing specifically at the people that are patronizing, and explaining why specifically their words are patronizing, not saying that nobody with any wealth could ever understand her - if they couldn't, what on earth would be the point of her blog?

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:56AM (#38630189)
Man, so many comments here playing the word dissection game, it's tiresome. The author is responding to a singular person here, a person who basically did say "Let them eat spuds", and based on that statement really does seem to be unable to empathize with people who aren't the children of Barons. Whether or not all people in such privileged positions are capable is irrelevant. Ms. Rees-Mogg has shown she is incapable, by her own words.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by UncleMeat on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:45AM (#38629988)
Well, a world where wealthy political leaders understand the state that the poor are in and still make statements about how they should just buy raw potatoes is an even clearer example of heartlessness.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by _a_a_a_ on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:41AM (#38629924)
> Thinking that people you perceive as "privileged" can't comprehend you is a choice too and a form of ignorance.

In my experience they can't, and I do have experience in this.

In one example, a few years ago I worked with some extremely rich people. I mean, exceedingly rich. Once kept negotiating on everything, even if it was to only save a few pounds. I asked for a little cash advance (£180) to allow me to do some work for them (I was very skint then). The guy said he would give it to me - provided I committed to working for them for six months.

Well, nice try but I had my pride so it was a No anyway.

It was not done in any way nastily, to him it was a game and he didn't mean to hurt me, but he literally had no idea of how things could be to other people. He had never in his life had to live off loss-leader baked beans and bread. I've a fair number of rich people and they can't understand the struggle it can be for others. This is first hand experience and multiple data points.

Edit: the ££ involved corrected

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by jc2jc on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:48PM (#38631177)
Do the wealthy not read books or newspapers? Watch film? Listen to music? It's unfathomable to me how anyone can grow up without gaining some understanding of poverty. I know it can happen, but I personally think it's more likely they pretend to not understand because it is inconvenient.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by chefandy on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:23PM (#38630661)
Adjacent point based on your comment: I want to emphasize that this is not a difference in understanding between the rich in the traditional sense and the poor in the traditional sense, at least in the US. I know people with significant multi-generational family assets that don't call themselves rich. This crowd is largely (obviously not exclusively) white, US-born, and from the upper end of the middle class going up. Based on my interactions, very few seem to have experienced significant portions of their life without basic food, housing and medicinal security.

A whole lot of people within all striations of the middle class assume that they kind of "get it" through osmosis because they're not rich and they were probably friends with poorer people growing up. But barring stereotypes, we always assume other people's lives, problems, decisions, challenges, and affordances are more similar to our own that others. People from the upper end of the middle class are often blind to the difficult realities of growing up lower-middle-class in meaningful ways that create similar cultural discrepancies.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by roflyear on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:39AM (#38629895)
> Thinking that people you perceive as "privileged" can't comprehend you is a choice too and a form of ignorance.

You've kinda proven their point with this statement, no?

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by VBprogrammer on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:38PM (#38630977)
She's obliquely referencing Jacob Reese Mogg's sister who grew up in a Grade II listed home in Somerset, overlooking the medip hills. Her life experience is only slightly more relevant to the poverty crisis than the Salman of Saudi Arabia. There is no fucking perceived.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by m3kw9 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:58AM (#38630210)
Everything you do is luck starting with the day you were born, you decide to eat an egg? Yeah it’s because you are t allergic or have money, you have money? Your parents had money. You have money? Because you had a job. You have a job? Maybe because you had a functioning brain, good hand/feet. It’s all luck in that sense. You decide to just wait for luck to come after reading this? It was also luck you read this comment
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by MichaelZuo on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:28AM (#38629717)
> But ignorance is a choice.

Is that true for this case?

Understanding the actual on-the-ground situation for all types of people and situations in the 10 largest countries will probably take up most of a normal human lifespan. And that's assuming they spend several hours a week, 50 weeks a year, learning.

Understanding India and China alone to that level would probably take up 30-40 years.

It seems literally impossible for the vast vast majority of people to have enough time for that ignorance to have been a meaningful choice.

i.e. This is likely the baseline default for nearly everyone, who are not especially interested in the UK or who are not super-geniuses.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by eropple on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:30AM (#38629739)
When you consider the actual context of the essay and that the person to whom the author is speaking directly is the sister of an MP and herself a MEP, this kind of well-actually does ring hollow.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by toyg on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:41AM (#38629921)
The wife of a generationally-wealthy MP, both the products of extremely wealthy families who did not have to work for their money (which is why they are both in politics - because they're pretty useless everywhere else).
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by bdsa on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:52AM (#38630116)
Sister
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by andrewflnr on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:18PM (#38630557)
When you make an argument in general terms, you can't call no-fair when someone takes it at face value and counter-argues in equally general terms. That's not cheating, it's just assuming good faith.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by mftrhu on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:48PM (#38631174)
When people point out that one's counter-argument, by virtue of ignoring the context the original argument is steeped in, is not actually countering any argument, they aren't saying that the counter-argument is "cheating" - they are adding context.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by andrewflnr on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:01PM (#38632475)
You can call it "adding context" if you concede that said context implies the original argument was badly phrased, in that the most direct reading is not what the writer really meant.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by mftrhu on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:44PM (#38633176)
Or I could just call it "adding context". I could also expect readers to not have to be spoon-fed, and to avoid launching themselves into "counter-arguments" before they have understood what they are arguing against.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by andrewflnr on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:08PM (#38634879)
An argument that doesn't contain adequate context to be understood is a bad argument. You can't expect people outside your exact bubble to have enough context to figure out things you're literally not saying.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by hnbad on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:13PM (#38630486)
I'd say "ignorance is a choice" misrepresents this as a problem of individuals rather than structures. Miss Mogg isn't the problem. The world would not be much better if she took the time and energy to try to learn about the author's life experience and attempt to empathize with it - which is no easy feat given they are worlds apart and each other's life experiences are likely mutually incomprehensible because they lack any frame of reference.

The ignorance is inevitable. The system that produces and enables this ignorance and that allows this ignorance to result in harm (by creating ignorant laws that create ignorant legal structures that ignorantly harm people the people who created the laws didn't understand) is the problem. You can guillotine the entire House of Lords but that wouldn't change anything other than the names and the number of dead aristocrats.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by PuffinBlue on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:13PM (#38630472)
The next sentence is:

> Choosing to use the powers vested in you by the constituencies you serve, to deprive those same constituents of light, heating, food and home security is a wilful and deliberate act. And it has to stop.

It’s abundantly clear that the whole passage was speaking to Rees-Mogg, calling her out for her Marie Antoinette ‘let them eat potatoes’.

This passage isn’t a generalism, is a specific response to the words of a former politician, a former Conservative MP and MEP for East Midlands.

To reduce the articles substance to a specially selected out of context quote such as OP highlighted seems disingenuous.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by avereveard on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:18AM (#38629568)
"born lottery" it such a weird, fatalist take. the parents definitely decided to bring a life into the world trough action or inaction.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by ajsnigrutin on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:23AM (#38629635)
Parents sure, but you had nothing to do with your parents bringing you here.

Maybe your parents left you a few millions in a trust or even a billions worth family business... or your parents left you outside, in the streets, without school, making you beg others for food to survive.

You had literally zero choice of what family you're getting born into.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by lucideer on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:20AM (#38629599)
this idea that life decisions like choosing to have kids are always made solely by individuals in a vacuum without any societal nor contextual influence is just such a perfect example of the privilege the gp is describing
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by 2devnull on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:25AM (#38629658)
Nobody really makes any choices if you think about people biologically. I like to think people have some freedom and therefore some responsibility. Not too much. But some.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by lucideer on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:55AM (#38630166)
Exactly. Nuance.

Every person bears responsibility for every decision they partake in, just as we also need to acknowledge that some have significantly more agency in such engagements than others.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by gosub100 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:28AM (#38629712)
Do women not have agency over their bodies? If not, why aren't you doing something about it?
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by avgcorrection on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:27AM (#38629692)
Obviously it’s a lottery to the BABY.

This is straightforward Rawls-liberalism.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:19PM (#38630587)
> Obviously it’s a lottery to the BABY.

You say that like the same baby might conceivably have been born into more than one potential family. But the opposite is true: examine any baby and you'll find that there's only one possible set of parents they can have, barring identical twins.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by avgcorrection on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:20PM (#38630615)
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by thaumasiotes on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @08:51PM (#38636838)
Are you saying that the family it is born into is a lottery to the baby, or that you wish we would pretend that it is?
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by avgcorrection on Thursday December 14, 2023 @10:09AM (#38642150)
I’m saying that you are being deliberately obtuse. Or something worse.
[dead]
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by UncleMeat on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:50AM (#38630079)
She was feeding herself and a child on seven pounds a week. My food budget for two people is like 20x that.

What she wants is at least for the wealthy to not say heartless shit like "just buy raw potatoes instead of frozen french fries."

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by bobthepanda on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:41AM (#38629928)
Probably run a functioning economy so that people can earn money at a rate faster than inflation? There’s more than one way to get fed.

The UK economy has been one of the worst performers in developed economies since COVID.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by gosub100 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:47AM (#38630027)
It seems like those "free" social benefits have a cost after all. You want to redistribute other people's wealth, don't be surprised when those people dont want to be a part of your economy. Isn't the tax rate in the UK around 50%? So every other pay period, I work for the government?
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by bobthepanda on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:29PM (#38630791)
Right, because the benefits have gotten significantly better since COVID, not a prime minister totally tanking the economy by promising unfundable tax cuts and getting fired in 43 days, or the general bureaucratic mess that has been Brexit implementation.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by michaelmrose on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:33PM (#38630864)
In the US median household income is around 75k and average cost of out of pocket medical costs and insurance for a family is about 18k or about 1/4 of your income alongside the lower tax of at least 22%

The UK has tax brackets like everyone else and the same family would pay about 27% income tax and about 8% of their income in vat.

It looks like everyone but the very well off is worse off in the US.

Keep in mind that that family doesn't have the threat bankruptcy from an uncovered emergency room bill as well.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by bobthepanda on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @01:01PM (#38631403)
Housing to income is worse in the UK, particularly in London.

London has a house price to median income ratio of 13. The same figure is 10 in San Francisco.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by drcongo on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:52AM (#38630122)
a) No, it's not 50%. and b) that's not how tax works. And c) to one of your other comments, the UK is not a socialist country, far from it.
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by philk10 on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:55AM (#38630164)
You going to do the Thatcher quote next ""The problem with Socialism is you eventually run out of other peoples' money." ?
Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by corobo on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:41AM (#38629920)
"Countless benefits" that you can't get for various reasons or other. Take away the kid and she'd likely have had nothing. Been there lmao.

Help is merely the illusion of help in the UK. Why? So people like you can point to it and say "look you're fine" and get on with their day without giving it any thought.

Re:You Don't Batch Cook When You're Suicidal by lucideer on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @11:59AM (#38630242)
> a socialist country

I've seen some odd takes on HN but this is a level of anti intellectualism worthy of twitter.