I'm not as afraid of completely losing our cultural memory exactly because "piracy" can't be ultimately defeated: As long as people can consume their DRM-protected content, there will be always a way to remove the DRM and offer it through alternate means. I understand the risk of civil disobedience, however it seems that there has never been a time without the risk-takers that effectively protect our cultural heritage.
Despite the immense power of the immoral US Copyright law, it's not all-powerful as places like sci-hub prove.
I can download a movie for free, or I can spring $20-30 for the DVD, then sit through forced FBI warnings, then previews, etc. when I really just wanted to watch a damn movie.
They shifted the burden to the consumer (time wasted) and in a world with piracy, good luck with that model.
When I was in my early 20s in the 2000s, I could go to a theater and just know what the deal was for 90% of the movies that were playing at a 20-plex automatically just from TV ads and a few late-night-show actor interviews. Today I know zero (other than recognizing which one is some Marvel thing). If you dropped me off at the movies I wouldn’t know what to watch without googling them all.
1. Word of Mouth 2. Internet reviews 3. IMDB 4. it's up on l33. ;)
To those that want to do this the legal way, purchase it, throw it in a box, then pirate a version of the movie that doesn't treat you like a clown.
Netflix has a bunch of stuff in 4k. Do they not count for some reason?
They are racing to become the very thing that got them the traction they had in the beginning. People are fucking tired of paying more for less, while being told how fucking great it all is.
Why does this desire make them less sympathetic?
The irritating thing about this is that one may be unable to find some movie or song which they’ve already seen or heard. Even in a case where it is officially available, gating some record of culture behind a fee is just holding said culture hostage to ransom it back.
More charitably, it’s someone attempting a business model which is thwarted by how inexpensive it is for individuals to copy and share digital media. I instead lack sympathy for the people with an obviously bad business strategy and prefer to recognize this culture-renting as farcical.
(That question I asked wasn’t rhetorical; I am genuinely interested in the answer but I also wanted to explain a different perspective.)
Particularly when it comes to arts - games (disclaimer: I work in games), music (disclaimer I make music), art, theatre, there is usually another person I the other side of it who has made decisions to get that to you in the first place. Saying "my way or the highway" doesn't show Amazon that you're not willing to engage with the Kindle DRM and will buy it if they provide CC licensed prints, it shows them you're willing to dodge paying $10 instead.
> it’s someone attempting a business model which is thwarted by how inexpensive it is for individuals to copy and share digital media. I instead lack sympathy for the people with an obviously bad business strategy and prefer to recognize this culture-renting as farcical.
An over idealistic belief of free market being the only way that a product can exist, and throwing jingoism and shade at at anything you disagree with furthers the idea that you're not open to compromise.
Compromising is the basis of any transaction - I want the item for free and you want to be recognised for it, so we come to an agreement.
They assume what they want of my actions. They may instead choose to think that I don't like using their service; perhaps I don't like the licensing terms that a copyright owner might choose to not offer their stuff on Amazon anymore leaving me SOL on my purchase. I buy games on Steam because their service doesn't suck for consumers. Valve recognizes that Steam's revenue comes from people choosing to use the platform to purchase games and they act like it.
> music (disclaimer I make music)
How do you feel about the settlement between Tom Petty and Sam Smith[0]? Do you think your music is infringing copyright because you independently made a song that happens to contain a copy of a part of another song's melody? Does the other song writer deserve their 12.5% cut of your music "as is usual for writers of sampled or interpolated work" even if they clarify that they don't think your interpolation was intentional? I personally wouldn't think so; seems to me that it's just a cartel doing its thing. Even if said interpolation was unintentional, you, the song writer, made the mistake of not knowing that the melody in your song had already been popularized.
0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stay_with_Me_(Sam_Smith_song)#...
> I want the item for free
No, this is just a common assumption that people make. I bought the item already, lost it, and recognize that making another copy is practically free. I no longer have my copy of Pokemon Red that I had as a kid and I'm not apologizing to Nintendo or Game Freak just because I found a ROM online to use instead. Let's take a more recent personal example: Monster Sanctuary[1]. I have purchased this game no less than 3 times (Steam, Playstation, Switch) because it was more convenient and reliable than pirating it in every instance.
1: https://monster-sanctuary.com/
> throwing jingoism and shade at at anything you disagree with furthers the idea that you're not open to compromise
Like how every time anyone speaks out against the copyright cartel it's immediately framed to be because they want something for nothing by someone who disagrees. Pot, meet Kettle.
I will stand by that statement. This copyright shit is a farce. 10-year terms would be fine but Disney didn't want to lose Mickey Mouse. Tom Petty doesn't need to go after Sam Smith for supposedly copying the melody of a song that was written 34 years ago. You personally shouldn't lose revenue on your own songs just because you accidentally copied the melody of a song you heard when you were 6.
------------------------
Where do you offer your music for sale?
You have a point, but this lacks the context that caused people to stop being shafted more and more and MOAR, making it more pollyanna, than useful, imo.
YMMV.
What if all the shops that sold chocolate near you bar one decided to shut down? This chocolate shop (ChocStix) keeps selling, but says you need to keep eating it in the store or in an authorised location to ensure you don't share or give away the chocolate.
You can at this stage give up chocolate all together, or find an alternative. The manufacturer isn't at fault here. However if they've signed an exclusive deal to only sell chocolate to ChocFlix in your area, it's not unreasonable to buy your chocolate from a dodgey looking dude selling it out the back of a van.
The big issue is exclusive rights over media on broad scales here, not some niche demand for a specific use case.
I'm in the States, so it's less of an issue of region/market lock-out and more an issue of no one being able to own their own media any more.
Just checked my local library system and there are 7 available copies of Heavenly Creatures, I could get it and watch it in a few days via inter library loan. But I'm in the States.
95% of the films I watch via the library I would venture. But it depends on your system.
Of course, none of that has anything to do whatsoever with the point. As we transition as a society away from physical goods and towards digital goods, we are placing ourselves at risk of companies erasing those digital goods. For now we have backups (like DVDs) and workarounds (like VPNs). Reasonably soon that won't be the case. It is possible that the favorite content of toddlers today (e.g. on Disney+) might just be totally inaccessible to them one day.
Also (IANAL) but if you acquire the disc, back it up and then keep or destroy the original, it’s even fully legally sound.
The library bought one copy of the dvd/BR and shares it with as many users as they can. How is that fundamentally different than downloading an “illegal” copy on file sharing? In either case, someone acquired the source material (afaik, “pirated” content is bought with actual money most of the time) and then shared without further revenue for the publishers.
Isn’t that fundamentally the same except for saying that libraries can do it but not scene groups?
Libraries are just a more convoluted and restrictive way of doing the same thing imho. While not everyone everywhere has access to a library system (let alone a well funded one), virtually anyone can download off the internet.
Note: None of this is a commentary on what’s “right” just discussing the legal ramifications. I don’t personally care what anybody does or have energy to convince anyone of anything.
When did we decide that? It's never been easier for an ordinary person to write, record, and broadcast...
Despite subscribing to the Showtime channel on Amazon Prime, I cannot watch Homeland. I can watch it on Netflix though and the audio and quality is absolute shit. And I don’t want to give Netflix 20 quid a month for that.
Why homeland? Was on a Damien Lewis binge. Love that guy’s work.
Guessing Band of Brothers, Billions, what else?
E: Should have refreshed before replying.
I really wanted to watch it again considering severance s2 has been in limbo for ages.
I still used torrents for content that I had access to because it was significantly more convenient to have an mp4 file. I prefer to use my player of choice. Also stupid restrictions on quality per device. You can’t get more than 720p on Netflix unless you use edge. That kind of restriction is so boneheaded stupid.
The economics of it all is so insane anyways. How much money is a company getting if I watch their film once on Netflix vs how much are they getting if I buy it on physical media. The difference is difficult for me to justify . Also I don’t want to have a bunch of physical media taking up space.
Do I rip them and sell the discs? Throw them away? Donate them? What is the morality of that?
Anyways instead of trying to square the ethics of capitalism with the content I like, I’ll just do it on my own terms. Things do go down the memory hole though even in piracy. Less obscure stuff vanishes entirely.
My trick is to just google it and click the videos tab, filter by video length. Surprisingly often you find it.
It made me realize that we are very much at risk of losing our cultural memory. For this particular movie I could use a VPN I suppose, but I imagine that some movies/music/books will someday not be available in any region in any form.
1. https://www.justwatch.com/ca/movie/heavenly-creatures
2. https://www.entoin.com/entertainment/heavenly-creatures-on-n...