I think you've confused "productivity" with "bulk". Do you evaluate engineers by how many lines of source code they write in a day?
Imagine if your brain refuses to do worthless uncreative work, that is ADHD, it is great for coming up with ideas but sucks for doing the work you often have to do.
What studies like this seem to allude to is that it warrants a more nuanced take. If you're engaging in creative work, maybe these kinds of drugs aren't the best way to boost productivity.
Just look at the results
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5285601/table/T...
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5285601/figure/...
https://ntp.niehs.nih.gov/sites/default/files/ntp/about_ntp/...
"This review finds, with moderate confidence, that higher fluoride exposure (e.g., represented by populations whose total fluoride exposure approximates or exceeds the World Health Organization Guidelines for Drinking-water Quality of 1.5 mg/L of fluoride) is consistently associated with lower IQ in children."
https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/features/fluoride-children...
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25446012/
You don't seriously think that drinking fluoride is OK? It's been studied to death and it's obvious at this point that long term fluoride exposure causes developmental neurotoxicity. Multiple countries have sponsored these studies and they show negative correlations to IQ and an increase in fluoride. They've demonstrated this in rats with sodium fluoride as well.
Finally, there is probably a level at which it actually does become toxic. Like with many other minerals, too little is actually harmful, there is a right dosage and too much is again showing toxicity.
Why do the papers against do not mention this, do not mention any theorical model to explain their findings, do not correct for socio-demographics factors when we know that intelligence is generally very poorly related to any other variables except those ones which disproportionately explain it?
In groups of 100? What's the percentage of people that routinely consume toxic levels of fluoride from dental supplements (that study ran four months)? People don't generally eat toothpaste or drink mouthwash but I'm sure it happens. I just wouldn't assume that it would happen often enough to give you poison data.
" Like with many other minerals, too little is actually harmful, there is a right dosage and too much is again showing toxicity."
This is where I'm at on tap water...I assert that LOW-DOSAGE exposure over extended periods of time is bad and I assert that in the US there are area's that have incredibly high-doses of fluoride in tap water (at least 6 parts per million). Which is bad all around. Water is controlled at the jurisdiction level and there's NO guarantee that you're getting below the recommended dose of fluoride. I'm of the opinion that it's completely nuts to put this stuff in the drinking water and the Indian, Harvard, and recent NIH papers appear to back this up.
"Why do the papers against do not mention this, do not mention any theorical model to explain their findings, do not correct for socio-demographics factors when we know that intelligence is generally very poorly related to any other variables except those ones which disproportionately explain it?"
I agree with this...In the first study I could not tell if they controlled for socio-economic status. They identified villages with varying levels of fluoride and called it a day. The Harvard study did though. And the American study I linked to seemed to control for this as well...And they all came back with results that were similar...Repeated low-doses of fluoride have detrimental effects to development health.
Form the harvard study: "We carried out a pilot study of 51 first-grade children in southern Sichuan, China, using the fluoride concentration in morning urine after an exposure-free night; fluoride in well-water source; and dental fluorosis status as indices of past fluoride exposure. We administered a battery of age-appropriate, relatively culture-independent tests that reflect different functional domains: the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML), Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised (WISC-IV) digit span and block design; finger tapping and grooved pegboard. Confounder-adjusted associations between exposure indicators and test scores were assessed using multiple regression models. "
>Reviewer comment (DocB1_Monograph, page 2): It would be helpful if the Abstract was clear in the Discussion that the conclusion about effects on IQ in children was derived from high human exposures (higher than US exposures) without getting into more hazard conclusions or assessments.
They repeatedly say that the current research is no where near comprehensive and results are weak.
I’ve watched several peers go down the path of trying to use stimulants for motivation starting in college and again later in my career. There’s no denying that it works at first. They are stimulants, after all, and they stimulate people especially well when they first start taking them.
The problem is that the motivation from stimulants is famously prone to tolerance and rebound effects. It’s also very prone to habit-forming associations. I’ve noticed several people try to use prescription stimulants in an “as needed” fashion when they need to get a lot of work done quickly and they don’t really want to do it. It doesn’t take long before it’s obvious to their friends and coworkers when they’re having an off day or an on day, even though they might deny any rebound effect. It gets scary when they do this so long that they forget how to self-motivate without taking stimulants because they’ve built such a strong mental association between “I have a lot of work to do” being a trigger for “I should take another pill today” or even “I’ll save this work until tomorrow when I can take a pill”. It gets even scarier when tolerance sets in (to the motivating/stimulating effect, not so much the intended attention-enhancing effect) and they’re now flirting with escalating doses, double doses, combinations with ‘nootropics’ to boost effects or ‘reduce tolerance’ and other slippery slopes.
The short-term productivity boost shouldn’t be denied, but I think it’s also short-sighted to hold these drugs up as a free lunch productivity boost. Let’s be honest: A little experimenting here and there isn’t going to show tolerance, extensive rebound, psychological associations, or other effects, but that’s also what gets people in trouble when they start to think it’s a free lunch. There’s a reason the traditional ADHD treatment approach involves taking the same dose every day rather than encouraging the patient to build psychological associations between taking the drug to alter their mood state.
The strange part about this conversation is that if I wrote all of the above text about drinking 2 energy drinks at the start of a work day, few people would argue with it. The tolerance, rebound, and dependence effects of caffeine seem to be well known in pop culture. For some reason people with a little exposure to prescription stimulants seem to think that the normal rules don’t apply to them, at least at first.
A lot of people who have minimal or sporadic experience with stimulants seem to think they’re no-strings-attached productivity boosts, but there’s no free lunch. The brain will adapt over time.
So I switched to decaf. I'll still enjoy regular coffee now and then as a special treat.
A very US-centric view I think, i never knew a single person in my University who took these 'enhancing' drugs, we just got wasted from alcohol and smoked weed. And I went through rather stressful University where 2/3 of people who started were thrown out of school in first 2 years in one or the other filtering hardcore courses with slightly psychotic professors (still not getting why by far the hardest course from 5 years for studying freakin' Software engineering had to be 'Theoretical electrotechnics' with some hardcore math way beyond our actual math courses, of course never used any of that, not even on rest of studies).
Anyway, any substance you abuse will eventually kick back quite hard, if it didn't yet give it some time (or take a bit harder look in the mirror next time). Same for bad habits.
Stimulants may be used by individuals with true deficiencies in an effort to get to baseline. Many people who start using stimulants in their 20's and 30's report being able to express healthy, practical behaviors that they couldn't summon themselves to express before: cleaning the house, making it to meetings on time, paying attention in conversations. I think this type of fearmongering towards stimulants possibly throws the baby out with the bathwater for individuals that may experience some benefit.
I used to be completely mentally exhausted after a single meeting, modafinil fixes that for me. It makes me smarter in the sense of "crystallized" intelligence as a consequence of accumulating more knowledge, experience, mental models etc.
There's also the problem of getting used to the drug. When I first started taking it, there were various side effects (including perceived worsened short term memory), which subsided with time.
A bunch of strong serotonergics produce such effects. Normally SSRI are screened for it, but that's mostly for acute version...
Dose scheduling is underresearched part of the whole ordeal. Sometimes a pause is necessary to prevent the damage or recerse the tolerance.
After being on it for ~5 years it lost its magic and efficacy, so I ended up introducing lifestyle changes in the form of a 5-color-a-day smoothie, exercise & sleep. Lifestyle changes were helpful, but not quite enough.
When I recently started back up, I noticed that Provigil was a bit too stimulating for me. And I've found a good balance in doing a 1/4 to 1/2 a pill. About 50-100mg dose + caffiene (coffee/tea/energy drink) instead of the typical 200mg.
And that's been quite a nice boost.
Adderall on the other hand is a massive dump of dopamine and focus, so the focus is there, but it's easy to become a stimulated zombie.
Your ‘friend’ was probably into overdose territory and the Modafinil antagonized the d-amphetamine while also inducing a wakefulness effect.
I really hope your friend realizes how bad this was.
Amphetamine is primarily absorbed through the plasma membranes and not DAT since it’s lipid soluble.
Dopamine does not and thus relies on DAT. By inhibiting DAT (as both amphetamine and Modafinil do), you increase extracellular dopamine.
Next, DAT does not “transport amphetamine around the brain”. It only transports it from the post synaptic cleft into the cell.
Also Modafinil is a much weaker DAT inhibitor than amphetamine itself as far as we know.
Lastly, drugs don’t “antagonize” other drugs. That word is a specific term used for the action on the receptor level.
The dopaminergic effects of Modafinil aren’t well known and are thought to be mild. It’s simply misinformation to claim that modafinil was somehow blocking the effects of amphetamine on the dopamine receptors.
I’ve asked my doctor for a prescription so that I could use it to go on stimulant breaks, but since I already have a prescription for Vyvanse and Adderall he was concerned I’d get drug audited. The last time I tried to find a good online Indian source it seems it’s very hard to find anything legit.
People either love it or find that it does nothing for them, so don’t get your hopes up too high. However, for patients who respond it seems to be a great improvement. Be warned that it can take a long time for the positive effects to appear. Unlike stimulants that work well on the first day and decline over the subsequent months/years, it seems to do very little or have uncomfortable side effects on the first few days and then reveal the positives after a month.
And FYI, there’s a weird copayment reimbursement program from the manufacturer that makes it affordable for many. Dumb game to have to play, but it’s there.
They thought they had discovered a free source of motivation in a pill.
Of course, most people’s initial assumption was that they received fake pills. Not a bad assumption after ordering online with crypto from an overseas website, but most of the stories went the same way: It didn’t matter the source, it just wasn’t “working” for them any more.
I’m always surprised that people understand how tolerance works for energy drinks, coffee, and other caffeine sources. But then they get exposed to prescription drugs and assume it’s going to feel like that forever.
The second part of this problem is the misunderstanding about dosing. The prescription pill doses are set for continuous dosing of patients who need to take it every single day.
A Narcolepsy patient taking 400mg of Modafinil every day forever is going to get into a steady-state tolerance that, ideally, brings their function back to a normal adult. A non-Narcoleptic person who takes 200mg or 400mg of Modafinil without having a baseline tolerance is going to be zipping around with extra stimulation. However, tolerance will set in eventually as well, leaving them with some stimulation, but nothing like those early doses when they had no tolerance. Again, this is a well known effect for other drugs like opioids or caffeine or benzos, but for some reason people forget the laws of tolerance apply to prescription stimulants too.
I believe it's at least partially caused by incorrect expectations. When people start taking modafinil, the effects are quite strong and stimulant-like, sometimes even with mild euphoria. But then these effects disappear and people are like - what's happening, I can't feel it anymore? Tolerance or fake pills?
I fell into this trap originally as well and was comparing production batches etc. But the actual reason is that with a pro-longed use, Modafinil doesn't "feel" like anything. There's no altered state of mind, there isn't even a mild kick you get from a coffee. Modafinil isn't a stimulant which would kind of push you to do things. It doesn't "give" you anything, it only "takes away" the fatigue, and this is far more difficult to notice. On a relaxing day off, it doesn't feel any different if I take modafinil or not.
In fairness, tolerance management and mitigation is a component of prescription drug design and composition, unlike the others. It of course can't overcome pharmacology, but there are mechanisms with varying efficacies.
Isn't the point of doing that to get better results?
I mean, imagine if without drugs I can do a hard slog through the books for 6 hours before giving up; and with drugs I can spend 12 hours anxiously bouncing between tasks and feeling very busy; but I actually learn more by doing the former than the latter - nobody taking study drugs is hoping to spend twice as long for worse results.
Many people using this kind of drugs normally lasted maybe 1 hour or so before giving up (without the drugs). And it often took a long ramp-up to even get to that 1 hour of focus.
> and with drugs I can spend 12 hours anxiously bouncing between tasks and feeling very busy
I guess this is maybe the case when your body isn't yet accustomed to the drug. I don't have any such issue after I got used to the drug (in my case modafinil).
Say unaided, you can get to 85% proficiency in 6 hours and that's about all you can sustain.
With smart drugs, you only get to 75% proficiency in 6 hours but can keep going and will hit 95% in 9 hours.
Think of it like a pick up truck with two gas tanks. It is less efficient than a small car but because of the larger tank it has more range.
Obviously, I can't know if students from the bottom percentile also engaged in that, but all the students I knew that took drugs to perform better, were motivated students that wanted to maximize their grades. And they studied things that required lots of reading and memorization (law, medicine, and similar).
My take was that the kids that used those drugs, were the ones that wanted an extra push on the last 10% - to put it that way.
Even on them, a person will need to consciously make healthy choices. These drugs do not magically help you think smart. That still has to come from you.
If anything, I feel ever so slightly “dumber” on them. They dull my creative thinking and in return, I gain a bit of motivation. It does nothing to my willpower. So I still need to want xyz thing bad, but it makes it makes the act of doing that thing much more fulfilling. Even if it’s something I consider a waste of my time, but something I must do - the experience is more fulfilling. I reckon it’s the extra dopamine at play.
Regardless, xyz is still my decision and I can very much pick an unhealthy thing. Drugs don’t aid your prioritization skills. They don’t improve your communication. Those are skills that have to be learned. Maybe not, if you won an organized parent lottery. Then at least you will know what good looks like, and can learn to emulate that.
I never considered motivation and willpower to be separate, but I think your breakdown makes a lot of sense.
I'm also not a big fan on emphasizing the "cognitively healthy" part of the equation. My understanding is that stimulants do exactly the same thing in a person whether they're "cognitively healthy" or not; they're not the sort of drugs that target a deficiency or clear up some specific problem. The only difference is that some people have more of a need in this area than others.
This reminds me of an old article I read about how psychedelics don't actually "increase connectivity in the brain" like users thought, as though that had anything to do with why people use psychedelics.
That's why some folks say they take psychedelics; they want to justify their drug use for 'fun' as something more beneficial. I wish people were more honest with themselves and others.
In fact a lot of people who have taken (and really cherish) psychedelics would not describe them as fun, and sometimes they're very actively un-fun/terrifying/unenjoyable, and yet can still be beneficial.
What exactly is going on at the level of "brain connectivity" is pretty much unrelated to all of that^
The article just scanned people's brains while they were on drugs and saw that the electrical activity was more erratic and scattered than normal, not more active and connected, and concluded that people were using psychedelics based on a myth.
Lying about efficacy will do nothing but only bolster what was never a legitimate rationale to begin with. This is a country that failed to learn lessons from prohibition, that managed to kept the Mann Act on the books even though the legislative intent - that of the fear over 'miscegenation' was hardly a secret, a country where congress never bothered to even get rid of the chapter in the US Code that contained the Chinese Exclusion Act and therefore leaving the ugly legacy plain to see for all. Why lie about your cause when the truth that undergirds the reality is far uglier and far more disconcerting to begin with? And of course, for once, Oscar Wilde was wrong and the truth may not be pure but certainly simple: prohibitionist policies began in racism and are sustained by moral panics while protected by the state agencies that now benefit financially from its existence. All this has a paper trail, both online and in print, in the federal register, in the US Code, in congressional records and archives. If that's not enough to justify resistance, your real reasoning will still be more persuasive than having to make up something to justify a position against a line of thinking that has goalposts with wheels built in from the start.
Marijuana legalization used the same strategy: medical first, then complete. The technique works. The other technique of "Oh yeah, I want it for fun so you should let me do it" has been tried for eons and got nowhere. You can come up with all the theory, but one technique worked and the other didn't, so I'm not interested in the theory.
Fake science it's going to be. The people who hate it don't have the ability to tell that it's fake.
And come on, healthcare requires you to lie. The head of the NIAID famously lied about mask efficacy in order to get what he wanted and people backed him for it. I don't see myself as any different.
The amount of half-braindead pot smokers earnestly talking about their medical need to get stoned is so irritating. Legalization happened despite them, not because of them.
When a drug is stigmatized in the United States, it is essentially impossible to get it legalized without showing there is a medical use for it. That's just how it is. If your goal is to get a drug legalized, it does not matter whether that's how it should be, or whether this is all rooted in systemic discrimination, or whether pharmaceutical companies push stuff that's just as bad under their veil of legitimacy. Citizens who are anti-drug are under the impression right now that ~100% of illicit drugs are extremely dangerous and a major threat to their community, and they are not going to sit around and listen to a history lesson philosophizing about how all their fears are a propagandized illusion.
Even if you got them to listen, they would just say "Why risk it?" The only way to start changing minds is to point out there are upsides to drug legalization beyond just "freedom is good." That's why all of the arguments for legalization focus on health/therapeautic benefits, either directly from the drugs themselves or in the ability to treat those who need help with addiction.
Yes the trip can be lots of fun, but really, "fun" is widely available once you cross the line and take drugs. MDMA is fun. Amphetamines can be fun. There is no scarcity of "fun" here and I have no issue admitting I've taken those to the possible detriment of my health and for fun.
The difference is that if I had to skip the "trip" part of psychedelics and retain the rest, I'd still do it.
I don't recall seeing anyone make that argument, but I do tend to avoid woo and pop sci. What is reasonably clear is that psychedelics increase neuroplasticity even in vitro, which is hypothesised as being one of the plausible mechanisms of action for psychedelics as a treatment for mental disorder - they potentially create a window of opportunity for habitual patterns of maladaptive cognition and behaviour to be unlearned.
Some people are very attached to the idea that the qualitative experience of the "trip" is integral to the therapeutic effects of psychedelics, but that is by no means a universal belief; many groups are working on non-psychedelic drugs that exploit this mechanism.
I think it's entirely reasonable to be wary of people justifying their recreational drug use with outsized claims of therapeutic benefits, but in the case of psychedelics there is definitely something of clinical interest happening. I'm quite circumspect about the clinical use of psychedelics, but I think it's highly likely that we are going to see a generation of novel and useful psychiatric drugs emerge based on what we have learned from psychedelics research.
I don’t know a lot about stimulants in general, but I know for caffeine in particular this is not true. As an anecdote, I have a friend that caffeine puts to sleep, she just can’t take it. I’ve come to find out (partly from knowing her) that part of why the FDA doesn’t regulate caffeine, is that it has a very wide range of varying effects on different people.
Contrast with, say, SSRIs, which might have some effect in a healthy person but you're looking at a different range of effects compared to someone taking it for depression/anxiety/OCD/whatever.
At some point during debugging you might throw your hands up and wonder who created this tangled web of complexity but adderall delays that moment for awhile.
There's a nonzero chance that it was your predecessor on a 2am Adderall binge ;)
I also feel "dumber" while on ritalin, but at the end of the day the job gets done. Also a lot of frustrating stuff, the kind of stuff that would easily derail me, just becomes easy to overcome.
Progress is just happens, but you can also be motivated to do dumb/useless work, for stimulants dosage is key.
https://www.reynoldsclinic.com/why-french-kids-dont-have-adh....
> There’s also the differences in how children are brought up in America and in France. For example, French parents have set strict limits from the time they are born. The children are raised with limits such as not being allowed to snack whenever they want. They have four strict meal times and they know those are the times they are allowed to eat, not before. While they love their children just as much as others do, they do believe in forced strict limitations to help the children grow up in guidelines and feel safe and secure.
Really?
I have also had a number of friends with "ADHD" for whom the solution was "cut sugar, sleep enough, go into a room with no electronics (or a user account with nothing else installed), do some cardio".
I am not denying the existence of ADHD, but as a society, we look for shortcuts to problems that have real solutions and are therefore more likely to just pop a pill. See the sister comment, it addresses this too.
And furthermore - yes, cutting screen time in children dramatically increases their ability to focus later in life.
The reason parents are holding sugar back from kids is they think they're hyper due to a "sugar rush", which is completely placebo i.e. they're just acting like that because they heard you're supposed to.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01497...
I am not trying to move goalposts with the next statement, but I always assumed sugar has a similar effect to caffeine, in that you get a temporary boost that you pay for later. Study pointing to this quoted/linked below.
For me personally, energy drinks very much do seem to improve alertness, at the cost of crashing later. This is especially evident if drinking them two days in a row, where on the third day you absolutely have no energy left. And that's not even mentioning the absurd blood pressure spikes.
Anyway, this isn't an "argument" - I don't have one other than "that seems inconsistent with my experience." Though your own link seems to be pretty inconsistent as well*
* "Caffeine consistently improved marksman reaction time but did not improve marksmanship accuracy. However, there is some evidence that caffeine attenuates performance decrements in marksman accuracy caused by stress and fatigue if optimal dosing strategies are employed. Dosing strategies timed according to hours of wakefulness and time before testing could prevent performance deterioration. Doses of 100-200 mg every 2 hours may effectively improve accuracy during extended duty; however, further research is needed."
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31045484/
* "The literature on CHO effects on cognition suggests that CHOs can improve cognitive functioning, particularly under circumstances where participants are asked to perform cognitively demanding rather than easy tasks (Mantantzis et al., 2017, Scholey et al., 2009, Sünram-Lea et al., 2002). In a similar manner, studies have found the protective effects of CHOs on mood to be more robust when participants perform demanding physical and cognitive tasks. In fact, whereas participants in control groups experience higher levels of tiredness after performing a cognitively demanding task, consumption of CHOs seems to protect subjective ratings of energy against a potential drop-off after high cognitive exertion (Benton and Owens, 1993, Owens et al., 1997). Additionally, exogenous energy supply in the form of CHOs has been shown to increase vigor and reduce fatigue under conditions of increased physical stress (Ali et al., 2017, Lieberman et al., 2002, Markus, 2007, Welsh et al., 2002) and cognitive demands (Owens et al., 1997, Smit et al., 2004). Therefore, it has been hypothesized that, similar to cognition, mood improvement following CHO administration is stronger when participants have to perform demanding cognitive or physical tasks (for a review, see Benton, 2002)."
I think it’s ridiculous to make a blanket statement about how kids are raised in America vs France with zero evidence to back it up. There are plenty of strict parents in the US, and I’m sure there are plenty of lax parents in France. Plus, as the article states:
> The American psychiatrists believe that ADHD is a disorder based on biological issues.
So the way a kid is raised has nothing to do with whether or not they have ADHD.
According to the article, the real reason “Why French Kids Don’t Have ADHD” is because the doctors avoid that diagnosis:
> Basically the French community has decided to focus more on fixing the underlying causes of the problem behavior instead of giving it a wide range diagnosis.
Looking for underlying causes and fixing problem behavior sounds great, I just feel like the article is confuses having ADHD and being diagnosed with ADHD.
Despite my problems with the article, I actually do think that ADHD in children is over diagnosed in the US. And even if the disorder itself isn’t over diagnosed, I think ADHD medication are over prescribed to children. Those medications have can have negative side effects, like reducing appetite and therefore growth, but that’s not even my main problem with it. As other posters have described really well, ADHD medication can reduce creativity and problem solving skills. If a kid is medicated too young they might obey the rules a little too much and develop into a less creative, interesting, and dynamic person as a result.
Taking a neurological imbalance and turning it into a morality thing is abuse. Even if unintentional. This is real. Parents look for simple answers like "give em the strap" but how is that less reductive than "give em the pill"?
> Numbers in America show that at least 9% of the children that are school-age are diagnosed with the disorder
That percentage seriously makes me think that we might be overdiagnosing based on personality type instead of just diagnosing based on underlying disorders. Either that or US schools are very different than French schools.
In addition, when able to focus, the quality of work still suffers from several factors such as sleep deprivation and the fact that you forgot to eat or even drink for the last several hours.
I've never seen code written in one of these stimulant fueled all-nighters that didn't create more work than it took to write.
The only exception I've found is for doing housework and other mindless, repetitive tasks.
[0] https://twitter.com/carolinecapital/status/13790363463003054...
imo, that's kind of a dangerous assertion. I'm an adult in his thirties. I take Adderall because I have a genuine loss in executive function at times. A small dose of Adderall (read: less than 2mg) puts me back on track where I can deeply focus, understand, and interpret things. There's certainly people I've seen abuse the drug, but I don't think it's safe to say that the results of Adderall are quantity over quality and frankly the abuse of the drug often doesn't occur in a vacuum. It happens in people that aren't very substance aware in the first place.
A much better test would have been to give all the study participants some new material requiring multiple hours of study to memorize & learn, then give them a test. The knapsack problem is fine to test some measure of "intelligence", but a bad choice to simulate academics.