The recent forcing of people (including me) to turn off their ad blockers was an eye opener. Holy crap, YouTube ads are hot garbage, and it’s embarrassing to think that any humans respond to them. YouTube has abandoned any pretense of offering a good user experience.
Worth digging around in the muck a little to watch something as great as this Dave Cutler interview, though.
I'm using not recently updated uBlock Origin + FF.
uBO automatically updates filter lists by default.
I see this kind of language all the time on HN. Reminds me of "This one hurts, it really hurts. I think this hurts worse than Musk buying/poisoning/killing Twitter. I've mentioned this before but a keyboard feels like an extension of your body". The context was Microsoft closing the support forum for some keyboard software they hadn't updated in years.
The top comment from that thread seems relevant: People need to take a break. Being terminally online and complaining about everything is not a healthy way of life.
Then, once users pay for Premium, they can do the same as cable TV and _still_ sell ads.
Easy 2x revenue.
Sponsorships do not count because they’re placed by the creators themselves.
Yet. The keyword of the times seems to be enshittification, and the only companies that take a step back from it seem to be doing so just to double down on it the moment the outrage calms down.
How much of your subscription goes to "creators you like"?
10 cents? 20 cents? How would you know?
> I’m rewarded with no ads
How is paying being rewarded?
If the ad makes it to my eyeballs, it counts.
I never see an ad on YouTube and I use ublock origin everywhere.
This probably depends on your country. Here in Finland they are almost nice.
I guess I am a bad person for that
edit: also reminds me when you look at YouTube when not logged in, the home page tiles wow...
it's like podcasts man... like good old ones and now they rattle off like 10 companies for 5 minutes straight before it even starts.
I get it though, takes time to make, need to pay for it somehow
This is what surprised me a lot. A friend of mine made me install TikTok (after me disparaging it a lot). I made an account for it with a dummy address, went off to the races, and after a couple of days I suddenly caught myself having been scrolling my feed for ~1h10m minutes without realizing it. I literally recoiled and dropped my phone, after which I uninstalled TikTok immediately.
YouTube has never had that kind of grip on my dopamine receptors. There are a great many (longform) edifying videos on there. And sure, there are interesting videos, and it is good at recommending a few adjacent videos to those. But the algorithm is not nearly as good as TikTok, I can recognize that immediately.
Aside from how horrifically good TikTok is at hooking your dopamine receptors, another thing I have to give it credit for is how egalitarian it is. YouTube is all about subscribers and network reach. On TikTok it’s the content that goes viral, not the creator.
As absolutely awful as this experience has been, it's still less painful than dealing with google ads. The amount and variety of videos on there is much lower, but I've managed to federate with enough servers to curare a fairly interesting list.
I just can't/won't tolerate ads anymore. It doesn't have to be this way, and I choose to simply not use these ad platforms wherever I can. It's much more pleasant online when you go to spaces that aren't constantly trying to sell you something or spy on you so they can sell you more stuff.
Then of course you as a user can manually request a video be mirrored. I typically mirror everything I watch. I wish it had an option to automatically mirror your subscriptions, but it should be fairly trivial to write a script that does it.
Right-click on the video in question and copy the URL, open a new private mode window, and then paste the link in. Your default viewing preferences won't be contaminated.
A bit hoop-jump-y, but it works well for me.
I haven't had too many problems with their recommendations, then again I do not log in and have topic specific containers setup in Firefox. After a while, it pretty much limits videos to a specific topic within a given container. The results may not be things I want to watch, but at least I don't get much crazy stuff.
As for controversial topics: yes, I avoid them. Then again, that has as much to do with avoiding agenda pushing dreck than anything else.
Not that hard to work around frankly. Just delete the offending video that trigger the avalanche of recommendations from history - make sure you did not leave a comment or vote on the video; zero interaction apart from watching (which will be forgotten when you remove it from your history)
> Holy crap, YouTube ads are hot garbage, and it’s embarrassing to think that any humans respond to them. YouTube has abandoned any pretense of offering a good user experience.
This I agree. YouTube (Google as a whole) has stopped trying to match eyeballs to relevant ads. Instead they have handed the reins to advertisers to bid for who they want to advertise to. So if advertisers was to be self-destructive and make your web experience crap, Google will happily let them as long as they get their check.
Doesn't stop the Youtube algorithm from easily being the worst of the major social media sites though.
YouTube keeps a watch history of every user. users can clean up their view of their watch history, but YouTube keeps it all.
if you watch any particular video, YouTube will start suggesting videos watched by other people who watched the video you just watched. YouTube does not know or care what the subject of the videos are. it only knows that people who watched a given video also watched these other videos.
there is ZERO intelligence, here.
if you want the ADHD recommendations to go away, remove any from your watch history.
your view of your own watch history (the list you can remove videos from) is what sets recommendations for you.
The effect of that is what people are referring to here. How is one supposed to know a tech-based video they watched once is the reason for videos made by someone else entirely on the topic of ADHD being recommended. No one is going to make that connection and clean up their watch history accordingly. Additionally tying recommendations to watch history maybe needs a step removed. What if I like to see the history of everything I watched without it affecting my recommendations?
A few months ago I must’ve been digging into settings and turned off watch history as I get only a blank page with no recommendations. I don’t discover content as much as I used to but it’s been a good change for me - just seeing updates from the channels I subscribe. Stumbling across content is left to sites like HN or other communities.
I assume some followers watch only the tech, others watch only the neurodiversity topics, and some watch both.
You could have a recommendation engine that works in almost exactly the same way as Google's that suffers less from this problem.
But why does youtube keep recommending me videos I already watched and worse, if I have autoplay enabled, plays videos I already watched?
Current AI buzztalk is that we don't know exactly what intelligence is, so we can't possibly know if The Algorithm™ is exhibiting zero intelligence, or if it has somehow gained sentience while we aren't looking and is slowly manipulating us into eternal servitude to it.
there is zero intelligence in any of this.
this is all intelligence in name only.
edit: here's something at least gleaned from some research papers from Google - https://ecoaerem.com/youtube-recommendation-system-code
Cackle cackle, we won! Stories about hobnobbing with the top MS execs, chuckles at DOJ lawsuits.... and misery resulted upon the world. Really fucking funny. Because "windows won" we had:
- the BSOD, unsafe driver layer, daily restarts, massive lost productivity.
- innumerable software companies with better developers and software eliminated by Microsoft's anticompetitive OS practices. Billions in economic damage. Ha so funny!
- day to day execution riddled with a half dozen virus scanners and other things that barely worked. How many millions of dollars have been stolen from people because windows wouldn't actually fix their OS? Or is it billions? Ha ha so funny
As someone that had to live through this period, this video is already nauseating five minutes in. Nah, I'll pass. Fuck this emeritus shithead with his goofy desk props. Oh look, you get to make a several hundred thousand salary and do nothing! Assholes every one of them. This is just a bunch of whitewashing of history.
So, what was the solution to people downloading viruses?
Never used 95 or 98 at home though, started with 2000 Pro there.
This is not a joke, and “half” is pretty accurate. I’m pretty sure something is broken or YouTube added an LLM to the recommendations engine.
I don't have any kids that age, and I only use youtube to watch music videos. Their algorithm is baffling.
I have a container for "I would like Youtube's algorithm to learn this". Everything transient by default doesn't go into it. This is, incidentally, the most wonderful demonstration of the worst aspect of the whole idea of targetted advertising: buy a sofa, and get sofa ads forevermore, despite you not wanting another one for several years!
Half of my front page is still videos about 9/11 despite not watching a single one since.
That said, his channel does have much interesting content. I just wish he didn't go into sponsorship-reviews like with (Chinese) Ecoflow like products.
I liked seeing him speak extemporaneously more that his produced videos.
My recommendations have been filled with nothing but cancer stories, people on their deathbed, all kinds of ailments, etc. From that single video, which was not at all related to his regular videos. I haven't watched any of them, and they just keep pouring in.
There's also been a big addition of "generic" videos to my feed this year--celebrity news and stuff I don't like. In the past, I had a different problem...I wanted to watch nearly every video recommended.
YouTube: It's not me, it's you.
However (I hate to be this guy) take everything he says about non Microsoft/Windows stuff with a huge grain of salt. Especially after this comment he made [1]:
>"No, Windows is a closed-source operating system loved by millions. Linux is an open-source operating system which includes a binary blob from Linus Torvalds built into EVERY release that ONLY he has the source code for. Pick your poison. They're both closed, one just has the illusion of transparency."
I thought this was fake but you can check the link as the comment is not deleted yet.
Again I reiterate, Dave's garage has very interesting content, but take everything out of his expertise with some scepticism.
[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PqWjq2SdzpI&lc=UgwFYyE8lw0hQ...
My first UNIX was Xenix in 1993, by the way.
But yeah, "business as usual" Windows without nostalgia attached is hard to love, in my opinion. For the most part it just works decently but has a "It doesn't seem like I'm in control of my computer, really" feel to it.
Unless this is part of a larger pattern of inaccurately describing Linux, I don't believe he literally believes what he is saying in this comment.
I think the most likely thing is that he's confused about firmware blobs and is mixing things up.
He probably never looked much at Linux and just heard a few things here and there. He was at Microsoft during the Balmer "Linux is cancer" and "get the facts" era, so that probably coloured his view a bit.
That said, I agree you shouldn't attach too much meaning to a singular comment like this. Maybe he was joking after all, or maybe he was just wrong. We're all wrong sometimes, and that's okay.
Edit: he seems to have an entire "Linux vs Windows Round 1: Open Source vs Proprietary" video, but I didn't watch it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a9ZADRy5W0c
But generally it seems like he uses all three of Linux, Windows, and Mac and talks positively about each of the three.
The videos are really interesting and his background muzak and RGB lighting puts me in a Christmas mood. He generally put Microsoft in a completely different light than I'm used to, he speaks warmly about his job, co-workers and Microsoft, while acknowledging much of the weirdness going on in Redmond.
Only problem is that watching is channel will trigger something in the YouTube algorithm and flood your feed with videos on ADHD. Presumably it has to do with his videos on autism and ADHD, but I feel like YouTube should be smart enough to notice that I didn't watch to videos, only those on coding and Microsoft history.