News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by bradley13 on Saturday October 14, 2023 @01:42PM (#37882526)
There are many international routes where the same train continues from Germany into Switzerland, and then possibly into other countries. Germany has gotten so unreliable that Switzerland is stopping this practice on some routes, because late German trains have a knock-on effect throughout the system.

So now, the German trains stop at the first Swiss station, when they finally arrive, and people gave to switch trains.

Germany is also years behind on their commitment to getting cargo on trains. Switzerland built a rail tunnel especially for trans-European traffic, but Germany is apparently incapable of getting cargo onto trains.

It ought to be mortally embarrassing for the supposed industrial powerhouse of Europe. But that's OK, they are building more autobahn.

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by sschueller on Saturday October 14, 2023 @02:13PM (#37882790)
They should be embarrassed because Switzerland assumed the Italian part would be the one not finished on time and even helped a bit financially on that side to make sure it gets done. No one ever thought the Germans were incapable of getting it done. They are still buying land! Meanwhile Switzerland dug the longest train tunnel in the world. Italy is completely done as well and cargo imports are now shifting to the south instead of through the north.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by throwaway5959 on Saturday October 14, 2023 @02:34PM (#37883000)
That sounds great for Italy.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by johnfabian on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:19PM (#37883392)
In general Italy builds transit infrastructure cheaply by European standards (which means massively cheaper than North American standards). Despite real concerns about corruption or ineffective bureaucracy they've managed to improve their rail infrastructure a lot these past few decades. Germany and the UK look very bad compared to them in this respect
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by zabzonk on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:25PM (#37883444)
> In general Italy builds transit infrastructure cheaply by European standards

And then: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ponte_Morandi

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by mc32 on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:06PM (#37883815)
Given that bridge was in its 5th decade, I don't see how that applies to what the Italians have done in the last couple of decades, unless you're arguing what they are building today will be tomorrows Morandi Bridges?
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by zabzonk on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:19PM (#37883913)
i have no idea what the italians have been doing. i would observe that in the uk most bridge failures were in the 19th century, when the properties of materials such as cast iron were not too well understood - same lack of understanding that the morandi bridge seems to have had much more recently.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by handsclean on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:37PM (#37884056)
Wikipedia lists 282 bridge failures between 2000 and present, 4 of which occurred in the UK, 7 in Italy, and 35 in the US.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by zabzonk on Saturday October 14, 2023 @06:18PM (#37884759)
no doubt my wikipedia skills are lacking, but kindly where are you getting the 4 in the uk from?
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by handsclean on Saturday October 14, 2023 @07:24PM (#37885211)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_bridge_failures#2000–p...

I’ll readily admit it’s not great data, but I think it’s a step better than drawing conclusions from a single event.

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by stratom on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:40PM (#37884077)
Germany deliberately starved public transport to death over last decades, instead spending money motor highways to pleasure lobbyists.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by KennyBlanken on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:21PM (#37883409)
It's amazing what you can do when your country came out of WW2 with 85% of the gold the Nazis plundered off the millions of Jews they massacred....and followed up on that by banking for nearly every dictator, warlord and arms dealer. All people with shockingly poor life expectancy.

Also amazing what you can do when you have incredibly strict immigration policies (though these days it's less strict than how they treated American POWs crossing from Germany into Switzerland. Those, they murdered) that allow only rich folks in...

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by Moldoteck on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:21PM (#37883926)
Germany has money too, they just don't use it efficiently. Look at Italy, France - train infra in both works much better. Anyway, believe in what you want to believe, truth is - big part of modern world can have swiss quality train infra, they just choose not to
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by _zoltan_ on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:25PM (#37883958)
I've moved from a very low income family from an east European country to Switzerland with 0 immigration fuss. So on that point you're definitely wrong
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by sschueller on Saturday October 14, 2023 @05:16PM (#37884341)
The financial sector only makes up 9% of the Swiss GDP. Additionally in 1996 there was a global investigation by several nations including Switzerland, several Jewish organizations and the US into "Nazi Gold" and in 1998 Swiss banks paid 1.25 Billion to Holocaust victims[2].

Switzerland has one of the highest percentage in Europe of foreigners living in its borders[1]. It is a staggering 24%. Next one down is Austria with 14.4%.

[1] https://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/business/migration-series_europ...

[2] https://www.swissinfo.ch/ger/politik/zwei-revisionen_rueckbl...

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by christkv on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:22PM (#37883415)
Start looking at public infrastructure works in Germany and you’ll a series of massive cost overruns and hugely delayed delivery times. Airport in Berlin is a classic.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by saiya-jin on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:36PM (#37883574)
It boggles my mind how such an efficiency powerhouse can be that bad.

I live in Switzerland and although I am not involved in trains, what Swiss do aint magic, just simple following the rules, and rules they do. Maybe even less efficient than Germans at the end.

I really dont see any difference with Germany on the ground, yet when I look at Germany's politicians and their actions, at least the public part leaves a lot to be desired. Rather then the question becomes how come this country is actually economically so successful? Certainly not due to perfect environment for private businessess.

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by blibble on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:37PM (#37883583)
> It boggles my mind how such an efficiency powerhouse can be that bad.

it's almost as if that it isn't true that it's an efficiency powerhouse

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by candiodari on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:50PM (#37883689)
The German "secret" was first "interim" jobs (effectively day laborers, with government support for not paying social services) and then cheap energy. You don't get to say it, though. Everything came from same old, same old. The secret was easy to exploit people plus cheap energy.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by whoisstan on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:08PM (#37883824)
The article doesn't explain "nation built on efficiency", its a theme that continues to persist despite any significant examples.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by globular-toast on Saturday October 14, 2023 @05:18PM (#37884361)
I've been saying it for years. Germany's real strength is in marketing. Look at German cars. The myth about them being reliable still persists despite ample evidence to contrary.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by winter_blue on Saturday October 14, 2023 @06:02PM (#37884668)
Hm, that myth isn't that alive anymore. What I've heard is that German brands (except for Porsche) were terrible in terms of reliability. Italian cars are far worse though (probably the worst?). And that most European and American brands, in general, have a bad reputation among reliable car enthusiasts; with Japanese and S.K. brands being the kings of reliability.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by bratwurst3000 on Monday October 16, 2023 @04:47AM (#37897205)
That’s basically the point. German industry is bad, but not as bad a their neighbors. Expect Switzerland.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by sschueller on Saturday October 14, 2023 @05:00PM (#37884236)
Germany has privatized a lot of infrastructure and what happens is as expected. The only way to make money is to cut corners, unlike a state which gets that "value" back in its economy growing due to go infrastructure, private industry can't make profit that way.

The profit in infrastructure is economic growth and optimizations of people's mobility. This can only be done by a state. A state can still mess it up but it is the only entity that can do it.

Good luck getting a "Taktfahrplan" working if you have to rely on private rail companies optimizing for every last dollar and having the locomotives catch fire blocking lines for hours. When the Fung Wah Bus breaks down for the 10th time on the way to NY it doesn't block all traffic but with rail you don't have the luxury to drive around it.

The extensive damage in the Swiss Gotthard Base Tunnel was caused by a bad wheel from a foreign rail company that cut costs to a point of running rail cars with wheels that have way too many km on them.

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by injeolmi_love on Saturday October 14, 2023 @09:50PM (#37886089)
Japan has had a privatized rail system with none of these issues.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by mcpackieh on Sunday October 15, 2023 @01:10AM (#37887047)
Conventional wisdom says that people throw trash on the ground at a rate inversely proportional to the number of public trash cans. Japan has very few public trash cans (a response to the sarin gas attacks in the 90s) yet their streets remain clean.

Does the example of Japan prove the conventional wisdom wrong?

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by pauldenton on Monday October 16, 2023 @11:26AM (#37901165)
It shows culture is more important than conventional wisdom
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by stratom on Saturday October 14, 2023 @05:07PM (#37884287)
Germany is simply investing to little. Last year Switzerland invested more than 3 times the amount per person (413€) in rail infrastructure compared to Germany(124€). And the years before Germans spent even less. They increased the budget already by 40% from 2021 to 2022.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by Archelaos on Saturday October 14, 2023 @06:10PM (#37884713)
> ... such an efficiency powerhouse ...

I think this is just a cliché. There are a lot of examples in the public, the semi-public and the private sector were Germany is or became very inefficient or missed opportunities (long-distance trains, mobile phone prices and coverage, Berlin public administration, Berlin airport, Stuttgart train station, but also Deutsche Bank, Siemens, Bayer, BASF, not to speak of Quelle and Holzmann in the past).

However, one should not forget the special circumstances due to German reunification in the last 30+ years. In terms of GDP and population proportion it would be equivalent if the USA opened its border to Mexico today and gives all Mexicans US citizenship immediately. Than Mexico joins the USA 11 month later. After 10 years the USA gives up the US-Dollar for a Pan-American currency. For the 3 decades after the Mexico-USA unification the old USA transfers aprox. 2,000,000,000,000 to old Mexico. -- Perhaps this thought experiment makes it clear that it would have been more than a miracle if the high degree of efficiency that was associated with the old West-Germany could have been seamlessly continued into a reunified Germany. But allow the Germans another 34 years ...

Regarding long distance travelling (people as well as freight), Germany is also in a quite unique situation. It is in the center of major European long distance routes from every direction. In comparision even the traffic network topography of Austria and Switzerland is a lot simpler. In Austria it is North-South over the Brenner to Italy and NW-SE from Central Europe to South-East Europe. Switzerland is primarily NE-SW (Basel-Geneva) and a single major North-South train route (Zürich/Luzern-Lugano).

Just compare this map of the Swiss railway system (ignore the red lines, which are more or less only used for local transport):

https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personenverkehr_in_der_Schweiz...

with that of Germany:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rail_transport_in_Germany#/med...

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by s1artibartfast on Saturday October 14, 2023 @09:56PM (#37886123)
>However, one should not forget the special circumstances due to German reunification in the last 30+ years.

This is extremely misleading. Eastern Germany had a better educational system than the west and higher female labor participation. A better example might be like if the USA opened it's boarder to Cuba, and was flooded by doctors and engineers.

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by Archelaos on Sunday October 15, 2023 @05:31PM (#37893565)
Of course there are a lot of aspects, were the two situations are different. But I did clearly state that the parallels are "in terms of GDP and population proportion", which are two major general numbers typically used to sort countries into categories. Cuba has aprox. 12 times less people than Mexico and its GDP is aprox. 7 times less (but twice as much per capita). So you would need between 7 and 12 Cubas to join the USA to make the comparison working.

My only point was to find an analogy that illustrates the approximate order of magnitude.

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by t8sr on Sunday October 15, 2023 @05:20AM (#37888258)
Your characterization of the Swiss situation is inaccurate - it’s much more complex than you say for three reasons:

1) There are actually many more corridors, of which Basel-Geneva is not really an important one. St Gallen - Zurich - Bern - Geneva and Basel-Lugano are the main ones, but there are two routes between Bern and Geneva, there are trains connecting Zurich to the South East and trains connecting Bern to Visp and Sion. On top of that you have non-SBB companies like ZB.

2) The topography of the country is complex with lakes and mountains everywhere.

3) The scale is off: Germany is massive and you’re showing a map that includes the Berlin S-bahn, while only showing major connections for Switzerland, even though that mapped is 4 times more zoomed in.

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by Archelaos on Sunday October 15, 2023 @06:07PM (#37893837)
Ad 1) I was perhaps not clear enough that I was talking about the main transit routes. I agree that especially the situation in northern Switzerland could be described as being more complicated and the route from Innsbruck to Zurich should have been included. The area between Basel, Bern and Zürich is indeed the place where traffic from different origins and destinations intermingles.

Ad 2) True.

Ad 3) Perhaps a better map to support my point is this one about the core Trans-European freight train network: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans-European_Transport_Netwo... Of course this map is limited, as it does not cover passenger transport and does not show transport volume. However, the fundamental topological problem of the network in Germany should be quite apparent as there are a lot of options were traffic is changing directions and a congestion in a specific place may easily spread to other hubs. -- It is perhaps no coincidence that Europe's two largest marshalling yards are in Germany: Maschen Rangierbahnhof[1] near Hamburg and Mannheim Rangierbahnhof[2].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maschen_Marshalling_Yard

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mannheim_Rangierbahnhof

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by mensetmanusman on Saturday October 14, 2023 @11:02PM (#37886491)
They have institutional inertia. But now they have internal demographics worse than Japan, and the immigrant workforce can’t be trained fast enough.

Ie their skilled labor force is shrinking and these are the knock on effects of having too small of families.

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by bratwurst3000 on Monday October 16, 2023 @04:44AM (#37897179)
Cheap labor and poor contracts compared to for example France
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by kingofpandora on Sunday October 15, 2023 @01:16AM (#37887074)
Private in Germany is no better. The incompetence is everywhere. Actually it's not incompetence, it's something else, but whatever it is, it's pervasive.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by mro_name on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:24PM (#37883951)
in fact we germans bet on Italy being the one to blame for failure and did - nothing!
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by lnsru on Saturday October 14, 2023 @01:50PM (#37882594)
They are not building more autobahn!!! Autobahn is not green enough. The infrastructure is falling apart.

A tunnel in Munich takes from idea to building at least 40 years. 8 miles of regional train extension takes 3 decades (building start date not known yet). Funny thing is that most of the track is already available. That’s the new real Germany. Not the one we knew from the movies.

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by daveliepmann on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:42PM (#37883641)
>They are not building more autobahn!!!

Doch, Alter. The German federal government and at least 3 top parties are completely captured by the auto industry, so we're tearing down neighborhoods to extend urban freeways in Berlin: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bundesautobahn_100

And the FDP scored the transport ministry in the traffic-light coalition, so of course there announced a plan to extend a bunch of highways: https://www.cleanenergywire.org/news/plans-fast-track-expans...

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by Sakos on Saturday October 14, 2023 @05:13PM (#37884320)
This country is so fucked up. We're screwed.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by lnsru on Sunday October 15, 2023 @02:29AM (#37887430)
I wish A8 towards Italy would re-build and would look like current highways in Poland. The whole country and neighborhood go there during vacation season.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by tetris11 on Saturday October 14, 2023 @01:58PM (#37882665)
They're getting there, they're building a more direct route between Karlsruhe and Basel. At the moment though, these ICE and cargo trains are passing through some tiny villages with barely more than two tracks.

I really wish cargo trains could just pass underground via tunnelling tech. They are obscenely loud, and given the mountain-valley nature of the villages in the Rheinland, their sound travels very far in the night, and often echoes around.

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by canadianfella on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:13PM (#37883325)
ICE?
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by eCa on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:24PM (#37883432)
German high-speed trains (InterCity Express).
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by flarg on Saturday October 14, 2023 @08:28PM (#37885624)
Aka I Cannot Even arrive
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by theyinwhy on Sunday October 15, 2023 @04:09AM (#37887904)
ETA? I Cannot Estimate.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by fsh on Saturday October 14, 2023 @01:48PM (#37882580)
The Swiss trip planner now completely ignores DB trains for trips within Switzerland. They don't want to disappoint their customers.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by nic547 on Saturday October 14, 2023 @02:07PM (#37882741)
Doesn't seem so, just checked Chur -> Zürich HB, for Sunday "SBB Mobile" offers a ICE starting from Chur at 12:35. Basel SBB -> Zürich also offers ICE connections. AFAIK there are less ICE trains running in Switzerland due to the issues, but the remaing ones still seem to appear in the trip planner.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by fsh on Saturday October 14, 2023 @02:49PM (#37883117)
You're right, it seems like this is exclusive to the EuroCity between Munich and Zürich which is a cooperation of DB, SBB, and ÖBB.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by idiliv on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:38PM (#37883591)
I happen to take this train on a regular basis, and it is reliably delayed :-).

Conveniently, my connecting train is also usually sufficiently delayed so that I do not miss it.

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by layer8 on Saturday October 14, 2023 @02:53PM (#37883159)
This is actually an intrinsic difficulty of the German rail network, due its highly interconnected structure, and the fact that it connects to other countries in all directions. The schedules are much more complex to handle than, say, in France where you mostly have a spokes-and-hub topology centered on Paris.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by Beldin on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:36PM (#37883579)
The Netherlands does cargo on rail just fine and has the busiest network in EU.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by lispm on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:44PM (#37883648)
Netherlands has just two neighbour countries and 1/10 of the network. Most of its rail cargo goes into and through Germany.
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by layer8 on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:55PM (#37883730)
This is the Dutch rail network: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/6/6f/Ra...

And this is the German rail network: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/08/Bahnstre...

Germany has almost 14 times as many rail stations as the Netherlands, and over ten times as many rail kilometres.

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by Moldoteck on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:23PM (#37883942)
So why not just copy NL infra 14 times across Germany? If every subpart of Germany has same quality as NL, general quality will still improve
Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by layer8 on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:39PM (#37884068)
Because those 14 parts would be highly interconnected with each other. You couldn’t actually treat them as 14 separate parts.

This is a bit similar to how a 14-core processor doesn’t give you 14 times the performance of a single core if the cores have to communicate with each other.

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by t8sr on Sunday October 15, 2023 @05:23AM (#37888277)
And yet every time there’s a delay in one of those connections, it’s DB that’s at fault, and somehow never the rail companies it interconnects with.

If what you say is true and Germany is uniquely more interconnected than other European countries (which I don’t buy, btw), then you still have cause and effect backwards: the interconnection makes the impact of delays worse, it doesn’t cause them. The delay ultimately happens in a single place and then has knock-on effects, but the place it starts is usually inside Germany.

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by Beldin on Saturday October 14, 2023 @03:41PM (#37883628)
> German trains stop at the first Swiss station, when they finally arrive, and people gave to switch trains.

It's not just German trains. The Swiss are rather strict about train punctuality (more than 2 min is not accepted if memory serves), and if an international train would cause delays, the Swiss put on their own train on regular schedule and halt the tardy train at the border.

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by Monory on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @07:52AM (#37913542)
You are almost correct, according to SBB [0], train is considered to be on-time if the delay is less than 3 minutes.

[0]: https://company.sbb.ch/en/the-company/responsibility-society...

Re:Germany's terrible trains are no joke for a nation built ... by stratom on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:24PM (#37883953)
> Switzerland built a rail tunnel especially for trans-European traffic, but Germany is apparently incapable of getting cargo onto trains.

And the same is happening with the Brenner tunnel in Austria again. Italy and Austria are about to start constructing the last remaining sections, to be finished in around 2034. While Germany has not build anything, and is still discussing where they are going to build the tracks and expect the construction not to be finished before 2040, likely even later.

Edit: more detailed dates