Marcus Hutchins: Why Destroying Bitcoin Wouldn't Stop Corporate Ransomware
I don't know if it would stop it, but without cryptocurrencies, it would certainly be much less. Laundering USD is significantly harder than laundering Bitcoin.
What exactly do you think people "launder" Bitcoin to? Why would it be harder to launder dirty USD than Bitcoin?
The end goal is the same, clean money you can use for any purpose. With USD, you only need to nestle it into a clean business that doesn't get scrutinized. Add in a step between with Bitcoin and suddenly it becomes harder.
I think the main issue is that with USD you need a dirty entry point that could compromise you at the moment of transfer, rather than with Bitcoin where you can chose the exit point whenever you want, and the entry is less risky. But still, adding Bitcoin to mix further complicates and adds risk to the overall process.
> without cryptocurrencies, it would certainly be much less
Isn't the (estimated) USD black market without cryptocurrencies vastly bigger than the black market of Bitcoin already, has been since forever and seems to continue to be like this for the foreseeable future?
Of course you can do the same thing with USD by using cash. A package of cash mailed to a fake address (where your courier receives the package from the mailman) is as untraceable as anything you can do with crypto. It is however more effort and potential risk.
"Transferring USD to a hostile nation is significantly harder than transferring Bitcoin. Crypto's ratio of criminal to legitimate use-cases is tiny compared to USD, and continues to shrink."
The initial claim was "Laundering USD is significantly harder than laundering Bitcoin", not about transferring currency between two countries.
Your rebuttal, while pedantically correct, does not refute their larger point that Bitcoin greatly aids ransomware.
Furthermore, I'd argue it is easier for ransomware groups to transfer large values of illicitly-gained Bitcoin across borders without the possibility of interception by authorities. This is a key step in international money laundering.
It's actually a great filter: it makes sure that people are already financially committed and keeps away tourists that don't want to spend.
From my point of view I rag on crypto because I’ve yet to see it produce any real world value outside of scams, frauds, and illegal activity.
Traditional finance is slow and cautious on purpose. Having to deal with each country’s laws, regulations, and individual sovereignty is very much a real thing. A platform like venmo could do instantaneous cross border payments today if it were only a technical problem. But it’s not. It’s a human problem that arises from countries governing themselves with their own banking and finance laws.
Now, if your argument is that we should ditch countries sovereignty and ignore laws to make finance quicker, easier, and more private; then that’s argument I can understand. I don’t agree with that argument at all, but if that’s an opinion of someone I can see why an anarchistic point of view could resonate.
How many burritos did you get at 7/11 via BTC payments? I bought a car during COVID -- there weren't any places for me to pay for it with BTC. My mom didn't, and won't, use it for anything.
That like 5 dudes in San Fran bought or sold a house with it is really just exceptions proving the rule.
Are you taking the view that all laws are just? If not, then you must admit that crypto has some value where it helps to route around unjust laws (e.g. many people on this site consider the war on drugs unjust and ineffective).
IMO it's absolutely not a valid path forward to have citizens selectively choose to ignore/evade certain laws that they personally deem unjust
Crypto is a joke in search of a problem that has attracted a cult of personality ("obviously detractors are just the US government!")
In its entire lifespan the uses of crypto (by and large) I've seen went something like
- Curiosity for edge-case nerds
- Buying drugs on Silk Road
- HOLY SHIT I SHOULD PUT MY RETIREMENT IN THIS I'LL BE A BILLIONAIRE!
- Buying ugly monkey jpegs
This is ignoring all the absolutely monumental abuse of the entire sphere it generated and just trying to name the major "uses" over the last decade-plus
- getting fleeced, and watching the exchanges burn down or get indicted
x = ["languages", "alphabets", "keyboards", "electricity", "computers", "linux/windows", "internet", "crypto"]
I have the suspicion that we'll be blaming AI soon.
Besides, while crypto is definitely useful, the financial system seems to work fine too.
"U.S. banks and financial institutions processed roughly $1.2 billion in likely ransomware payments in 2021"
https://www.cnbc.com/2022/11/01/us-banks-process-roughly-1po...
You can't use USD bank transfers (you open yourself up to SEC and DoJ prosecution), you can't use gold (the logistics are near impossible), and you can't transfer assets (same story as above).
Crypto is unique in that it's both a virtual store of assets, and has infrastructure that can exist independent of western financial infrastructure
"In 2012, U.S. federal regulators hit HSBC Holdings with a $1.9 billion fine, along with $665 million in civil penalties, for significant lapses in its compliance and anti-money laundering (AML) systems. HSBC laundered over $881 million for Mexico's Sinaloa and Colombia's Norte del Valle drug cartels."
It provides no real benefit it and is a net negative to humanity imho
Wouldn't most Russians need money in Russia? What am I missing?
1. It is generally viewed as safer to keep large amounts of money outside of Russia. This is both because the Russian economy is bad, and because organized crime is a huge problem inside of Russia.
2. Russia and Russians have large shortages of things that can easily be bought outside of Russia. Once bought, they are fairly easy to smuggle back into Russia. But first you need to have money outside of Russia.
3. Russians like vacations. Getting yourself out of the country is easier than getting your money out of the country.
These scams are all still incredibly profitable despite relying entirely on the regular financial system. There is no reason to think ransomware would stop in the absence of cryptocurrency given that extensive infrastructure has existed and currently exists to "cashout" proceeds of fraud. And in the ransomware case it's even easier because the victim is willingly making the payment, and the attacker can just not give the decryption key if the victim trys to stop the payment in any way.
And yes, this scales. If you ever looked at the promoted stories on Snapchat a few years ago, you may have seen a user with the name "The Billionaire Gucci Master" living a very opulent lifestyle. That was all paid for with business email compromise money.
> Besides, while crypto is definitely useful, the financial system seems to work fine too.
What percentage of those payments was someone who had never purchased crypto before buying it to make a ransomware payment in crypto?
In a lot of cases, it is an unexpected purchase of crypto.
Remember, large payments generally start and end in the financial system. The interesting bit is what is in the middle to make it hard for law enforcement to track down and stop crime.
Yeah, it's a bummer the perfect/no crime world we lived in pre-crypto got ruined by crypto. /sarcasm
I want to pick on this, because its both true and untrue, depending on how far back you look at this illegitimate business. Ransoms did not use crypto at first, but they are now the de facto payment. Antiquated ransom payment via gift cards, MoneyPak, Western Union, etc. are all still viable options for gangs.
The current scale and profitability is based on hitting companies for large amounts of money. And that very much depends on crypto.
Perhaps they were first figured out because of crypto, but now that the genie is out of the bottle they can't be regulated away. They'll continue to be possible even if the government of a victim nation cracks down on Bitcoin.
As long as:
1. Computers are complicated, it will be possible to trick users into running software that does things they don't want, and
2. Factoring numbers is harder than multiplying numbers, it will be possible to use asymmetric cryptography to encrypt those files, and
3. Money can be sent across international borders, because rich countries want to buy cheap stuff from poor countries, and
4. Jurisdiction ends at national borders, so Russian gangs won't get prosecuted for receiving money from American/European victims,
ransomware will continue.
Sure, Viagra spam stopped working when credit card companies cracked down because while someone will send $100 over a credit card in the privacy of their home, if you make it too difficult they're going to give up.
But the corporate ransomware model doesn't cease to work if instead of having your negotiation team turn the corporation's cash into Bitcoins they instead have to go to Western Union and turn it into rubles. We're talking about a $100M transaction, heck, you could charter a plane to Russia and it would be a rounding error in the end.
I'm personally waiting for the first public reports of criminal gangs using Chat GPT to automate spear phishing at scale.
I'm sure it is happening already, but the victims are keeping it quiet. The use case is too obvious. Identify key people in an organization from the website, Linked In, etc. Find them on social media. Find their less technical friends. Compromise the friends' accounts in various ways. Then send targeted phishing attacks to your real target. With every step of this automated by LLMs.
Do you seriously think that:
A. Any western union on the planet keeps $10m cash on hand or even 10% of that?
B. The US would even allow western union to participate?
Crypto is absolutely a requirement for this racket to work.
When you're requesting millions from a target the payment method becomes fungible; do you think MGM has a million bitcoin to give? No they go out and spend cash to get the bitcoin and then give it. If the attackers requested diamonds then instead you'd have to go out and buy diamonds and then give them.
Cutting off credit cards worked because the payment method was not fungible. If they didn't accept CC then they're not getting orders.
Payment networks are obviously not an option. Visa and her peers are not going to deliver the funds.
The only thing left is crypto. In fact it is the only use case where crypto is the preferable solution. I'll quote Stephen Diehl: "Any application that could be done on a blockchain could be better done on a centralized database. Except crime." [https://www.stephendiehl.com/blog/nothing-burger.html]
Also, the first paragraph of your first link (the Wikipedia page for "Ransomwware") literally ends with "... and difficult to trace digital currencies such as paysafecard or Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are used for the ransoms, making tracing and prosecuting the perpetrators difficult." Crypto and ransomware are absolutely intertwined in 2023, and have been for well over a decade.
Well not Steve Wynn personally but I mean how do you think the Somali pirates got paid? They literally airlifted them cash. USA does the same thing with Iran as well ...
When you get into the millions spending a dozen thousands on transaction fees is worth it if the transaction otherwise wouldn't occur. Removing BitCoin probably will reduce something like Petya which only wanted ~$300 but it absolutely will not stop MGM or hospitals from being attacked for millions.
> Payment networks are obviously not an option. Visa and her peers are not going to deliver the funds.
SWIFT will absolutely transfer the funds; social engineering to receive wires you're not supposed to is a lucrative crime (i.e. "CEO Wire Fraud"). VISA probably just won't because they'll find a transaction of that much with no collateral as a huge risk.
> Also, the first paragraph of your first link (the Wikipedia page for "Ransomwware") literally ends with "... and difficult to trace digital currencies such as paysafecard or Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are used for the ransoms, making tracing and prosecuting the perpetrators difficult.
I'd rather trace a difficult to track currency with a public ledger (BitCoin) than an impossible to track currency without a public ledger (USD).
> Well not Steve Wynn personally but I mean how do you think the Somali pirates got paid? They literally airlifted them cash. Again, cash is not an option for the scale of the operation that modern ransomware represents. According to a United Nations-backed report, Somali pirates made between $339 million and $413 million in ransom profits between 2005 and 2012. The highest ransom on record was $13.5 million, paid in April 2011. It should be noted that in 2011, Bitcoin's price rose to $32 on June 8, but then plummeted to $0.01 within a few days. The price of Bitcoin peaked at $30 in June 2011, but then dropped to $5. Bitcoin finished the year at $4.70. Not exactly a viable alternative at that time. Now compare those 8 years to any recent year's ransomware take. "Total ransomware revenue fell to at least $456.8 million in 2022, down nearly 40% from the $765.6 million extracted from victims in 2021."
But ok, back to the present: are you suggesting that a US company would/should/could just charter a flight into Russia? That everyone, including the US and Russian government, knows has millions of dollars of cash sitting on-board? And you think this wouldn't hit any snags? If you have an above board way to solve this then there are a number of cartels would love to hire you. Hell, not even the ransomware gangs would be comfortable with this arrangement, as bigger crime syndicates with better connections to the Russian state would be all but guaranteed to intercept the flight. And good luck getting the US government's blessing to send cash into a place like North Korea, who is very active in the ransomware space.
> SWIFT will absolutely transfer the funds; social engineering to receive wires you're not supposed to is a lucrative crime (i.e. "CEO Wire Fraud"). Does SWIFT accept applications from known ransomware gangs? What about accepting applications from fly-by-night operations located in former Soviet states with no institutional history? Don't be ridiculous.
And how does stealing funds being sent to someone else help you when you are trying to get funds sent directly to you? Are you suggesting that MGM would collude with the ransomware gangs to send funds via SWIFT to a 3rd party, such that the gang would be expected to intercept them thus satisfying the ransom? Or are you suggesting that SWIFT would knowingly transfer money intended for cybercriminals to some 3rd party, with the expectation that the gang would intercept the funds? This is just getting silly.
> VISA probably just won't because they'll find a transaction of that much with no collateral as a huge risk. Visa won't because they aren't going to risk their business with functioning governments to collect some transaction fees to do work for known criminals doing public crime.
> I'd rather trace a difficult to track currency with a public ledger (BitCoin) than an impossible to track currency without a public ledger (USD). Not sure what the point of this statement is, except that it seems to buttress the text you didn't copy, namely "Crypto and ransomware are absolutely intertwined in 2023, and have been for well over a decade", which is about as non-controversial as they come. As an aside though, plenty of organizations actually have a lot of success tracking that "impossible to track currency without a public ledger (USD)". In fact, here is some information about tracking the cash given to Somali pirates: https://www.cnn.com/2013/11/02/world/africa/horn-of-africa-p...
Cheers.
Parachute:
> >TME: Can you tell us about how you would arrange for ransom deliveries?
> We developed a special mechanism that allowed us to drop the ransom out of an aircraft by parachute. The pirates would collect the money after it fell into the water, take it to the ship, count it and then leave. At that point another team that we had already pre-positioned would board the ship, cross load supplies, help the crew get it underway again and escort it to the nearest safe port.
* https://maritime-executive.com/editorials/q-a-with-rob-phayr...
Once that's done you'd probably go to the 'standard' techniques that (e.g.) drug lords would use with cash. Assuming it wasn't spent on hookers and blow:
* https://www.cnn.com/2013/11/02/world/africa/horn-of-africa-p...
This is not even remotely true. Crypto is definitely the best licit way to move value around the world, so sure, it also is the best way to move illicit value around the world. But look at any Illicit Financial Flows report [1] and you will see that crypto is still marginal.
They might... do they accept bitcoin at their casinos or online gambling sites?
A million dollars worth of bitcoin? Probably, and even if they didn't it would be trivial for them to get.
AFAIK Caesars customers were never exploited after the fact. On Twitter I'm hearing MGM Sports Betting app customers are getting drained right now.
But if you follow the trail, Scattered Spider had the hard ransomware work done by ALPHAV, also known as Black Cat, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BlackCat_(cyber_gang). And THEIR developers and money launderers are linked to DarkSide, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DarkSide_(hacker_group). Which is based in Russia.
So basically a bunch of young Western men participated in the social engineering. But the real computer knowhow and methods of getting paid trace right back to Russian criminals who are willing to work with them.
Rumor was that Caesars was hit by the same group, and paid the ransom.
As a reminder, these attacks are overwhelmingly carried out by Russian gangs, and are only possible because of crypto. See https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/ransomware-problem-bitc... for more.